(Rounded from 3.5)
Waggoner maintains the grimy, unhinged quality of the film while adding more depth to some of the characters, additional scenes, and even some additional lore. He jumps from character to character, letting us experience the terror from both sides, usually following victims before (and while) they meet their end, but also letting us spend time with Art as he does his brutalizing. The novel moves quickly, as much as the movie, but he still manages to give us some emotional depth for many characters who don’t get more than a scene or two, which definitely deepens the experience. There is not a lot of time spent on world-building, it is really just setting up scenes and expecting us to fall into a familiar world, but it never feels rushed. And, as I said, we do get more lore and world-building than in the actual film, yet nothing that could be a hard and fast explanation, simply peeling back the curtain a bit more.
The set pieces were done well, and Art’s glee at his butchery was always well-communicated. The writing in general was direct and clear, without any pretense but with just a little bit of dark wit sludging around beneath the surface, which made it very readable, I flew through the book. For as graphic and disturbing as the film can be at times, nothing here in the novelization feels that way. I actually expected the splatter to be turned up a little higher than it is, to be honest. Don’t get me wrong, it isn’t tame, but there is no sense of exploitation or gore just for the sake of it, and I have definitely read splatter novels that twisted my guts up a little more. Yet all the visuals of the film are included, nothing and no one is spared, yet somehow Waggoner invites the reader into the spectacle in such a way that it doesn’t feel as violating… That might be a pro or con for you, depending on what you are hoping for from the experience.
Even after all those words about how much I enjoyed it, I was still a little disappointed. Waggoner does give us more than the film, but there are still things that he was in a unique position to answer that he left untouched. Being inside Art’s head gave us a chance to explore this world as the character sees it, and this isn’t exploited nearly as much as I think it could be. For instance, it more or less seems accepted (though still, as of the release of Terrifier 3, not entirely explicit) that Art was a mortal human in Terrifier 1, and he does actually die, and his resurrection at the beginning of 2 is what makes him more than human. Yet he doesn’t reflect on this at all, and we get no insight on why he is attracted to the specific victims he chooses. We can assume there is this connection with Sienna and therefore with anyone connected to her, but how does he know? How does he end up at the right places at the right times? Does he recognize these compulsions as something new or different than what compelled him in Terrifier 1, or is it all more of the same, to him? All we really get of Art’s interiority is that he is amused at others’ pain, and that isn’t particularly insightful. I was really hoping for something a little more, it feels like there is a lot of interesting and exciting ground that was left totally unexplored. Of course this disappointment is the result of my expectation, not the fault of Waggoner, and who knows how much creative license he has in terms of canon (which Leone was kind of making up as he went, at least until he got to 3). Yet Waggoner did give us all sorts of lore details we didn’t get in the films, so it feels like he could have gotten us deeper into whatever hellish sewer pits comprise Art’s mind, and that would have made the story more terrifying as a result.
If you enjoy the films than you will enjoy this novel. If you don’t enjoy the films then this may fall short. It still feels like an incomplete mythology (because it is), and while the characters are given more depth here than in the film they still don’t have a whole lot to do. Even though I felt it could have given a little more, I was impressed with what Waggoner did with the material, and I had fun the whole time reading it. If that is what you’re expecting and hoping for then you won’t be disappointed.