What do you think?
Rate this book
The Heart Taker
Teen gossip columnist Jack Berlin thought he was exposing high school drama—until a string of murders leads to a deadly new girl who just might steal his heart… literally.
Teen gossip columnist Jack Berlin ruthlessly exposes the social evils of his prep school’s popular crowd. But when four boys in a neighboring town turn up dead—their hearts removed—Jack goes hunting and finds a dark connection between the murders and Delilah, a beautiful new girl at school. Determined to uncover the truth, he rallies the help of his secret crush, Deb, and a group of geeky crusaders known as the Guardians to prove his suspicions. As the school falls to Delilah’s whims, Jack unearths her horrifying secret and discovers that Delilah isn't the only threat they're facing. And unless he and his friends can unravel the rest of the mystery, Jack will lose everything—including his heart.
Teen gossip columnist Jack Berlin ruthlessly exposes the social evils of his prep school’s popular crowd. But when four boys in a neighboring town turn up dead—their hearts removed—Jack goes hunting and finds a dark connection between the murders and Delilah, a beautiful new girl at school. Determined to uncover the truth, he rallies the help of his secret crush, Deb, and a group of geeky crusaders known as the Guardians to prove his suspicions. As the school falls to Delilah’s whims, Jack unearths her horrifying secret and discovers that Delilah isn't the only threat they're facing. And unless he and his friends can unravel the rest of the mystery, Jack will lose everything—including his heart.
276 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 1, 2024
About the author
A.M. Wiley
5 books53 followersA. M. Wiley is a self-proclaimed movie buff, rollerblader, and nostalgia junkie. He spends his time digging through the crypts of local used bookstores or reminiscing to his wife and three sons about the “good ol’ days.”
Want more? Follow A. M. on social media. If you’d like to sign up for his author newsletter and receive a free short story, email him at andrewwiley.author@gmail.com.
Want more? Follow A. M. on social media. If you’d like to sign up for his author newsletter and receive a free short story, email him at andrewwiley.author@gmail.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 44 reviews
January 22, 2026
I really liked The Heart Taker and thought the premise was genuinely interesting and different. The story instantly hooked me in, and once it settled in, I found myself pretty invested in where things were heading. There’s a strong atmosphere throughout the book, and the author clearly put a lot of thought into the world and themes.
Some parts did feel a little long, and I occasionally wished things moved faster, but it never fully lost me. The writing is solid, and even when the pacing slowed, the ideas and emotion behind the story kept me reading. I didn’t love every character equally, but a few of them stood out and carried the story well.
Jack was hilarious and I loved him. He was a lot of fun to have as my main character.
Overall, this was a strong read that just fell a hair short of being a five-star book for me. I’d definitely recommend it to readers who enjoy stories with a unique hook and a darker tone.
Some parts did feel a little long, and I occasionally wished things moved faster, but it never fully lost me. The writing is solid, and even when the pacing slowed, the ideas and emotion behind the story kept me reading. I didn’t love every character equally, but a few of them stood out and carried the story well.
Jack was hilarious and I loved him. He was a lot of fun to have as my main character.
Overall, this was a strong read that just fell a hair short of being a five-star book for me. I’d definitely recommend it to readers who enjoy stories with a unique hook and a darker tone.
January 31, 2026
I went into this one completely blind other than checking out the synopsis and wow this was good.
Again I love unlikely detective and poor Jack is just that, along with his school friends and his secret crush as they trying to solve why young guys are turning up dead and even more weird their heard removed.
I already knew we were going to get into some weird ritual stuff just from the missing hearts but I was not prepared to like the characters so much, they were well written and really sucked you into the story and I loved Jack, he was a idiot at time but still, loved him .
This is one of those weirdly nostalgic emotional horror reads that latches onto you as you dig into it and honestly this was my first run with this author and made me a solid fan, I will be back for more of this.
This was the kind of light emotional horror I needed to pick up between darker reads, absolutely a good choice.
Again I love unlikely detective and poor Jack is just that, along with his school friends and his secret crush as they trying to solve why young guys are turning up dead and even more weird their heard removed.
I already knew we were going to get into some weird ritual stuff just from the missing hearts but I was not prepared to like the characters so much, they were well written and really sucked you into the story and I loved Jack, he was a idiot at time but still, loved him .
This is one of those weirdly nostalgic emotional horror reads that latches onto you as you dig into it and honestly this was my first run with this author and made me a solid fan, I will be back for more of this.
This was the kind of light emotional horror I needed to pick up between darker reads, absolutely a good choice.
October 10, 2025
The Faculty meets Monster Squad
This is an excellent book for all of your spooky TBR's. There were some TRULY HORRIFIC scenes in here that lets the reader know that NO ONE is safe. The monster is super creepy. It's really hard for me to go into any detail without spoilers, but this certainly met expectations when you look at this KILLER cover.
This definitely had some of that "Stranger Things" feel, but with a bit more of a slasher twist. It kind of made me think of, what if The Goonies faced off against Michael Myers.
This was a fantastic read, especially right before Halloween, and now it just seems like Mr. Wiley just can't miss. I think that it's safe to say that he is now an instant-buy when it comes to any of his novels, and I can't wait to dive into his other books.
This is an excellent book for all of your spooky TBR's. There were some TRULY HORRIFIC scenes in here that lets the reader know that NO ONE is safe. The monster is super creepy. It's really hard for me to go into any detail without spoilers, but this certainly met expectations when you look at this KILLER cover.
This definitely had some of that "Stranger Things" feel, but with a bit more of a slasher twist. It kind of made me think of, what if The Goonies faced off against Michael Myers.
This was a fantastic read, especially right before Halloween, and now it just seems like Mr. Wiley just can't miss. I think that it's safe to say that he is now an instant-buy when it comes to any of his novels, and I can't wait to dive into his other books.
May 19, 2025
3.5 stars
July 9, 2025
I swear AM Wiley has not paid me off, but this is the third book I have read of his since connecting on social media, and I just can’t get enough. His writing style is so effortlessly readable, it can only be described as refreshing. This time around, he delves into the teenage horror realm, quite a departure from his Weird Space books. The Heart Taker follows a couple of HS newspaper journalists and their friends who desire to learn about a massacre in a neighboring town and the odd goings on in their own back yard. It is very straightforward, and Wiley’s rocket-speed narrative may irk readers who need more thoroughly fleshed out characters, but I read through this in one sitting and dug the HELL out of it. For risk of a bit of a spoiler, I was reminded of two, very distinct movies while reading The Heart Taker…Jennifer’s Body and The Faculty. Take from that what you will!
February 15, 2026
Pulse-pounding, intriguing, and fast-paced, this thrilling supernatural YA horror will captivate fans of C. Pike, R.L. Stine, and Buffy the Vampire Slayer.
May 20, 2025
Thank you to @weird_space_book for providing me with an ebook of this in return for an honest review.
This felt very much like a modern day Christopher Pike and also gave strong 'Jennifer's Body' vibes. I thought it was well written, had some good action scenes (although too many people survive) and It was very refreshing to read something where we're aware of who our vilkain is from the outset but was also nice to have the mystery of who was the puppet master as it were and why (I did sus them out very early on however), the author unfortunately decided to give them a feature which made them stick out like a sore thumb and was quite a bug bear of mine throughout. Something A.M Wiley did do that I really liked was start every chapter with a pop culture movie quote applicable to that chapter (for the most part) which I thought was a great framing device.
This felt very much like a modern day Christopher Pike and also gave strong 'Jennifer's Body' vibes. I thought it was well written, had some good action scenes (although too many people survive) and It was very refreshing to read something where we're aware of who our vilkain is from the outset but was also nice to have the mystery of who was the puppet master as it were and why (I did sus them out very early on however), the author unfortunately decided to give them a feature which made them stick out like a sore thumb and was quite a bug bear of mine throughout. Something A.M Wiley did do that I really liked was start every chapter with a pop culture movie quote applicable to that chapter (for the most part) which I thought was a great framing device.
August 7, 2025
This book was provided to me by the author in exchange for an honest review.
So here’s the honest truth: The Heart Taker is your classic teenage dream creature feature—with just enough blood, longing, and awkward heartbreak to keep the pages turning and the pulse unsettled. If you grew up on Buffy, Supernatural, or the better bits of Stranger Things, this one’s got your name stitched into its bones.
Jack Berlin is your typical high school misfit: thoughtful, uncertain, and halfway in love before the first chapter ends. He’s surrounded by a familiar constellation—mean girls, school crushes, outsider besties, and that undeniable teenage cocktail of anxiety, curiosity, and yearning to be seen. Add to the mix that he's a jaded high school journalist that pens a gossip column, and you've got the setup for some interesting dynamics. But when a string of student deaths rattles the school, and a mysterious new girl named Delilah drifts in like smoke, the story swerves into darker territory.
Delilah isn’t what she seems—of course she isn’t—and that’s the point. She’s beautiful, strange, and a little too still. The kind of presence that makes people speak softer or louder, depending on what they fear.
But the real delight here isn’t just the mystery or the slow-burn romance—it’s the ragtag team of gamer-geek outsiders who use their fantasy wisdom to help take on the very real threat growing in the shadows. They’re weird in all the right ways. The book doesn’t mock their nerdery—it honors it. These kids know the value of a well-placed plan, and the power of naming the monster.
Nina, the queen bee antagonist, brings her own venom to the mix—less magical than Delilah, but no less dangerous. The social hierarchy feels lived-in and recognizable, and the emotional stakes are just as sharp as the supernatural ones.
What sets this apart isn’t just the plot (though it’s twisty and well-paced) but the emotional texture. The book understands what it feels like to be young and overwhelmed—to feel like the world is happening to you, and you’re barely holding on. Jack doesn’t always make the right choices, but he tries. And that’s what makes his story compelling. There’s no prophecy guiding his steps. Just fear, love, instinct, and a few loyal friends with character sheets.
The Heart Taker is messy and sincere in the way real adolescence is. There’s heartache, guilt, bad decisions, and a few gut-punch moments where someone says exactly what you didn’t want to hear.
It’s not perfect. But it is honest, and that’s more rare than you'd think. This one goes out to the quiet kids with dice in their backpacks, and anyone who ever felt that there was something off about the hot new girl in town.
So here’s the honest truth: The Heart Taker is your classic teenage dream creature feature—with just enough blood, longing, and awkward heartbreak to keep the pages turning and the pulse unsettled. If you grew up on Buffy, Supernatural, or the better bits of Stranger Things, this one’s got your name stitched into its bones.
Jack Berlin is your typical high school misfit: thoughtful, uncertain, and halfway in love before the first chapter ends. He’s surrounded by a familiar constellation—mean girls, school crushes, outsider besties, and that undeniable teenage cocktail of anxiety, curiosity, and yearning to be seen. Add to the mix that he's a jaded high school journalist that pens a gossip column, and you've got the setup for some interesting dynamics. But when a string of student deaths rattles the school, and a mysterious new girl named Delilah drifts in like smoke, the story swerves into darker territory.
Delilah isn’t what she seems—of course she isn’t—and that’s the point. She’s beautiful, strange, and a little too still. The kind of presence that makes people speak softer or louder, depending on what they fear.
But the real delight here isn’t just the mystery or the slow-burn romance—it’s the ragtag team of gamer-geek outsiders who use their fantasy wisdom to help take on the very real threat growing in the shadows. They’re weird in all the right ways. The book doesn’t mock their nerdery—it honors it. These kids know the value of a well-placed plan, and the power of naming the monster.
Nina, the queen bee antagonist, brings her own venom to the mix—less magical than Delilah, but no less dangerous. The social hierarchy feels lived-in and recognizable, and the emotional stakes are just as sharp as the supernatural ones.
What sets this apart isn’t just the plot (though it’s twisty and well-paced) but the emotional texture. The book understands what it feels like to be young and overwhelmed—to feel like the world is happening to you, and you’re barely holding on. Jack doesn’t always make the right choices, but he tries. And that’s what makes his story compelling. There’s no prophecy guiding his steps. Just fear, love, instinct, and a few loyal friends with character sheets.
The Heart Taker is messy and sincere in the way real adolescence is. There’s heartache, guilt, bad decisions, and a few gut-punch moments where someone says exactly what you didn’t want to hear.
It’s not perfect. But it is honest, and that’s more rare than you'd think. This one goes out to the quiet kids with dice in their backpacks, and anyone who ever felt that there was something off about the hot new girl in town.
June 22, 2025
I was honored to be contacted by author A.M Wiley to give this book a read, and while it didn’t tick all the boxes for me, I will say that there was never a dull moment. It was a perfect amalgamation of genres that all just worked together somehow. Mystery, horror, supernatural thriller, and a little hint of sci-fi and romance in there too. All that with an amazing ending that leaves you wanting to know what will be in store next for Jack, Deb and the rest of the gang.
May 18, 2025
This book surprised me in the best way. The Heart Taker mixes high school gossip, creepy murders, and a main character who’s kind of a lovable smartass. Jack Berlin is a gossip columnist (yes, that’s a thing in this prep school), and he’s used to stirring up drama—until real danger shows up in the form of a new girl and a string of gruesome killings nearby.
At first, I thought it would just be a quirky high school mystery, but the tone gets darker fast, and I couldn’t put it down. The writing is sharp, funny, and somehow still chilling. It walks that line between satire and horror without feeling like it’s trying too hard.
The ending stuck with me too—not gonna spoil anything, but it definitely leaves an impact. If you like your stories clever, creepy, and a little bit weird (in a good way), this is one to check out.
At first, I thought it would just be a quirky high school mystery, but the tone gets darker fast, and I couldn’t put it down. The writing is sharp, funny, and somehow still chilling. It walks that line between satire and horror without feeling like it’s trying too hard.
The ending stuck with me too—not gonna spoil anything, but it definitely leaves an impact. If you like your stories clever, creepy, and a little bit weird (in a good way), this is one to check out.
February 6, 2026
"Pal's Run was supposed to be a shortcut from Ballenger to Laurel, but it seemed to take longer than before. The expanse of surrounding cornfields made Jack feel as though he was in a blacked-out, apocalyptic landscape, the lone survivor on the lost plains of a dead country. Obviously, he would eventually come across Deb being held captive by mutated zombies and rescue her-the last man and woman alive. But adventure and danger felt far too real at this moment for him to get lost in another fantasy."
3.5
Disclaimer: I was offered a free copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review. This has in no way impacted my feelings and the below thoughts are mine alone.
Horror like this, that celebrates weirdness rather than mocks it, is always going to carve out a special place in my heart. The Heart Taker is horror, yes, but it's horror-lite, there are some damn gnarly scenes in here, however, and there's plenty of gore and enough entertaining kills to keep even the most veteran horror fans entertained. A.M. Wiley has proven that you absolutely can have fun with the horror genre, and write to entertain your audience, while also having a lot to say and in the process, soaking the pages in blood. Stitched into every single page is love and adoration of the horror genre, this almost feels like a love-letter to horror, and actually, to small towns, too, because the author captures the spirit of small town living so beautifully.
There's such a compulsively readable quality to The Heart Taker - it's one of those books that you'll be unable to refrain from picking up and just blasting through, it's witty and funny and perhaps even borders on being satirical at times, but, it never seems overdone. At first, it's easy not to like Jack, he's a moody, snarky teenager, after all, but A.M. Wiley has found the delicate balance between teenage angst and beautiful, heartfelt moments. This is nostalgic horror through and through, reading The Heart Taker felt so much like getting to re-experience those campy teen thrillers/creature features that kept us all up late, burrowed under the blankets with a flashlight. It's a throwback to the golden age of horror, the bodies pile towards the sky, and there's bloodshed galore.
You'd be forgiven for thinking that, by now, a quirky group of teenage misfits banding together to fight off evil wasn't original, but, what starts out as a fun high-school mystery quickly turns into a completely different beast. What makes this book so refreshing, so wonderfully unique, is that it's clear that the author understands what it is to be unapologetically yourself. There's an authenticity here that you simply just cannot overlook, The Heart Taker is messy and unhinged and devastatingly feral in that highly specific way that your teenage years were. This one is for the nerds, the dorks and the outcasts and the weirdos, it's a bloody horrific story, but it's a damn great time.
"Jim prayed with his face in the dust. He begged to live, the moment so surreal he clutched his face in hopes he would wake from this nightmare. Jim looked up to where Ben hung on the fence, and his heart stopped. He was gone. Where is he? Where are the others? Jim was now alone in the field. He waited for a sign that his other friends might still be alive. The night only answered back with crickets and the distant rush of the highway."
3.5
Disclaimer: I was offered a free copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review. This has in no way impacted my feelings and the below thoughts are mine alone.
Horror like this, that celebrates weirdness rather than mocks it, is always going to carve out a special place in my heart. The Heart Taker is horror, yes, but it's horror-lite, there are some damn gnarly scenes in here, however, and there's plenty of gore and enough entertaining kills to keep even the most veteran horror fans entertained. A.M. Wiley has proven that you absolutely can have fun with the horror genre, and write to entertain your audience, while also having a lot to say and in the process, soaking the pages in blood. Stitched into every single page is love and adoration of the horror genre, this almost feels like a love-letter to horror, and actually, to small towns, too, because the author captures the spirit of small town living so beautifully.
There's such a compulsively readable quality to The Heart Taker - it's one of those books that you'll be unable to refrain from picking up and just blasting through, it's witty and funny and perhaps even borders on being satirical at times, but, it never seems overdone. At first, it's easy not to like Jack, he's a moody, snarky teenager, after all, but A.M. Wiley has found the delicate balance between teenage angst and beautiful, heartfelt moments. This is nostalgic horror through and through, reading The Heart Taker felt so much like getting to re-experience those campy teen thrillers/creature features that kept us all up late, burrowed under the blankets with a flashlight. It's a throwback to the golden age of horror, the bodies pile towards the sky, and there's bloodshed galore.
"Hunter's eyes were rimmed with red, and either he was wearing eyeliner or he hadn't slept in days. His greasy blond hair was spiked like a mohawk, but it didn't look intentional. Jack looked for a lobotomy scar. "Hunter, look, it's your cousin-Debra." The sister moved out of the way, fully revealing Hunter's menacingly large frame. Jack looked him over. Okay, so he went crazy and fought Delilah off? Scared her away or something? Hunter's eyes were clear as glass. Either the color had drained out of them, or it hadn't been there to begin with."
You'd be forgiven for thinking that, by now, a quirky group of teenage misfits banding together to fight off evil wasn't original, but, what starts out as a fun high-school mystery quickly turns into a completely different beast. What makes this book so refreshing, so wonderfully unique, is that it's clear that the author understands what it is to be unapologetically yourself. There's an authenticity here that you simply just cannot overlook, The Heart Taker is messy and unhinged and devastatingly feral in that highly specific way that your teenage years were. This one is for the nerds, the dorks and the outcasts and the weirdos, it's a bloody horrific story, but it's a damn great time.
"Jim prayed with his face in the dust. He begged to live, the moment so surreal he clutched his face in hopes he would wake from this nightmare. Jim looked up to where Ben hung on the fence, and his heart stopped. He was gone. Where is he? Where are the others? Jim was now alone in the field. He waited for a sign that his other friends might still be alive. The night only answered back with crickets and the distant rush of the highway."
October 31, 2024
What a solid fun ride! In this thrilling novel, teen gossip columnist Jack Berlin takes center stage as he dives into the dark underbelly of his prep school’s elite. Jack’s biting exposés have made him a social pariah, but when four boys in a neighboring town turn up dead, their hearts removed, he sets his sights on a far grimmer mystery. His investigation leads him to Delilah, the enigmatic new girl who quickly gains control over the school. Enlisting the help of his secret crush, Deb, and a band of nerdy crusaders known as the Guardians, Jack uncovers a chilling connection between Delilah and the murders. As the school falls under Delilah's spell, Jack and his friends realize there’s even more to the sinister plot than they imagined, and time is running out to stop it.
This book offers something for everyone—whether you’re into horror, sci-fi, fantasy, or even a touch of rom-com. It’s a page-turner packed with twists that keep you guessing, and just when you think you have it all figured out, the story surprises you. Though the protagonists are high school students, the themes and suspense will appeal to adult readers as well. Parts of this book brought me back to my high school days that made this book so much fun.
The character development is top-notch, making every figure in Jack's world feel real and relatable. Deb stands out as the brave and spirited girl we all wish we could have been in high school, adding depth and heart to the story.
Fast-paced and full of surprises, this book is not just a horror-thriller; it’s a layered tale about friendship, courage, and the darkness lurking just beneath the surface. An electrifying read that’s impossible to put down.
P.S.
Big thank you to the author A.M. Wiley for the wonderful novel. You keep giving us fantastic stories that are out of this world and can tear your heart out….literally! Can’t wait for Weird Space 2!!!
This book offers something for everyone—whether you’re into horror, sci-fi, fantasy, or even a touch of rom-com. It’s a page-turner packed with twists that keep you guessing, and just when you think you have it all figured out, the story surprises you. Though the protagonists are high school students, the themes and suspense will appeal to adult readers as well. Parts of this book brought me back to my high school days that made this book so much fun.
The character development is top-notch, making every figure in Jack's world feel real and relatable. Deb stands out as the brave and spirited girl we all wish we could have been in high school, adding depth and heart to the story.
Fast-paced and full of surprises, this book is not just a horror-thriller; it’s a layered tale about friendship, courage, and the darkness lurking just beneath the surface. An electrifying read that’s impossible to put down.
P.S.
Big thank you to the author A.M. Wiley for the wonderful novel. You keep giving us fantastic stories that are out of this world and can tear your heart out….literally! Can’t wait for Weird Space 2!!!
July 10, 2024
I loved this book! There's something for everyone here - horror, thrills, sci-fi, fantasy, rom-com. I could not put this down and was totally surprised by the ending. Although the protagonists are high school students I think it will be well loved by adults too
All the characters are so well developed and relatable, particularly deb, the brave and spunky girl we all wish we could have been in high school.
All the characters are so well developed and relatable, particularly deb, the brave and spunky girl we all wish we could have been in high school.
June 20, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💀 (4.5/5)
(Thank you to the author for the gifted copy in exchange for an honest review.)
From the first chapter, The Heart Taker pulls you into a small town dripping with unease — the kind of place where the people are quiet, the woods are loud, and something is definitely watching you 👀🌲
This book gave me serious old-school horror vibes — a little IT, a little folk horror, and a whole lot of “oh no, absolutely not” energy 🕯️😵💫. It starts slow and eerie, and before you realize what’s happening, you’re knee-deep in rituals, red flags, and things that go bump where they absolutely should not be bumping.
The atmosphere is impeccable — tense without being overdone, creepy without relying on cheap scares. The writing keeps a tight grip on dread while weaving in moments of real emotional weight. And the twists? They sneak up on you like a shadow behind your shower curtain 🫣🚿
There’s a demonic element at the heart of it all (no pun intended… okay, maybe a little 🫀), and while it isn’t overly graphic, it’s still deeply unsettling. The tension creeps in slowly and lingers like a bad feeling you can’t shake.
What stood out most to me was how unpredictable the plot was. Every time I thought I had a grip on what was going on, the floor gave out from under me — and I loved it. That said, I do wish we’d gotten just a little more background on the demon’s history. There’s mention that she’s been “used for years,” but I was left wondering: has she been summoned repeatedly, or has she just always been there? I craved a bit more clarity on her presence and the mechanics of her influence.
But honestly? That’s a small thing in the scope of a very satisfying horror novel. The pacing, the atmosphere, the reveals — all incredibly well done. This book isn’t trying to drown you in blood; it’s trying to slowly wrap its claws around your ankle while you think you’re safe 🐾🛏️
Highly recommend if you enjoy:
• 🏚️ Small-town horror
• 👹 Supernatural slow-burns
• 🧠 Twisted secrets and generational rot
• 🩸 A bit of dread with your emotional damage
It’s creepy, clever, and refreshingly different — the kind of horror that sticks with you, like a whisper in the dark you can’t quite place
(Thank you to the author for the gifted copy in exchange for an honest review.)
From the first chapter, The Heart Taker pulls you into a small town dripping with unease — the kind of place where the people are quiet, the woods are loud, and something is definitely watching you 👀🌲
This book gave me serious old-school horror vibes — a little IT, a little folk horror, and a whole lot of “oh no, absolutely not” energy 🕯️😵💫. It starts slow and eerie, and before you realize what’s happening, you’re knee-deep in rituals, red flags, and things that go bump where they absolutely should not be bumping.
The atmosphere is impeccable — tense without being overdone, creepy without relying on cheap scares. The writing keeps a tight grip on dread while weaving in moments of real emotional weight. And the twists? They sneak up on you like a shadow behind your shower curtain 🫣🚿
There’s a demonic element at the heart of it all (no pun intended… okay, maybe a little 🫀), and while it isn’t overly graphic, it’s still deeply unsettling. The tension creeps in slowly and lingers like a bad feeling you can’t shake.
What stood out most to me was how unpredictable the plot was. Every time I thought I had a grip on what was going on, the floor gave out from under me — and I loved it. That said, I do wish we’d gotten just a little more background on the demon’s history. There’s mention that she’s been “used for years,” but I was left wondering: has she been summoned repeatedly, or has she just always been there? I craved a bit more clarity on her presence and the mechanics of her influence.
But honestly? That’s a small thing in the scope of a very satisfying horror novel. The pacing, the atmosphere, the reveals — all incredibly well done. This book isn’t trying to drown you in blood; it’s trying to slowly wrap its claws around your ankle while you think you’re safe 🐾🛏️
Highly recommend if you enjoy:
• 🏚️ Small-town horror
• 👹 Supernatural slow-burns
• 🧠 Twisted secrets and generational rot
• 🩸 A bit of dread with your emotional damage
It’s creepy, clever, and refreshingly different — the kind of horror that sticks with you, like a whisper in the dark you can’t quite place
March 22, 2026
📖 Aaron Reads | tt: @theaarontodd , ig: @aarontoddreads
Title: Heart Taker
Author: A.M. Wiley
Do I Recommend?: Yes! If you’re looking for a fast-paced, dramatic YA horror with a Stranger Things–style vibe.
Kindle Unlimited: Yes
Format: Ebook
Pages: 253
⭐ Star Rating: 3.75 / 5
🔪 AT Intensity Rating: 3 / 5
Quick Descriptors
• Retro losers club YA horror 🕹️👾🧛🏼♂️
• Social commentary on gender bias
• Teen group vs evil vixen
• Fast-paced with high drama
• Campy / heightened tone
One-Sentence Take
A fun, surprisingly dark, fast-paced, Stranger Things style YA horror that fully leans into the chaos and is hard to put down.
Review
This is such a campy, over-the-top ride in the best way. A.M. Wiley is my go-to for this style of horror, especially when I want the retro/nostalgia vibe! 🕹️👾
The biggest strength for me was how entertaining it is. There’s always something happening, and the story moves quickly without dragging. The final stretch especially feels unhinged in a way that makes it really hard to put down.
I also appreciated that the characters felt human, with a surprisingly strong emotional undercurrent. You can clearly see the coming-of-age elements, especially in Jack’s arc, and that’s one of my favorite parts of stories like this. Watching the characters evolve as everything spirals and rooting for them is always satisfying.
That said, there were moments where the tone didn’t fully balance the darker elements. The family dynamics, especially between Jack and his mom, felt like they had more depth to explore. Since that relationship shapes Jack’s perspective in such a big way, I wanted a little more grounding there to match the weight of those themes. I think it would have made his arc with Deb even more impactful.
The overall vibe and writing style will either work for you or not depending on your taste. I personally enjoy it and tend to seek it out. It feels nostalgic in a way that reminds me of Goosebumps, Fear Street, and Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark. It’s a great palate cleanser if you want something fun but still a little dark!
Overall, this is a bingeable, high-energy YA horror that leans into its chaos and delivers a really entertaining ride. I can’t wait to start book 2 in the series!
Title: Heart Taker
Author: A.M. Wiley
Do I Recommend?: Yes! If you’re looking for a fast-paced, dramatic YA horror with a Stranger Things–style vibe.
Kindle Unlimited: Yes
Format: Ebook
Pages: 253
⭐ Star Rating: 3.75 / 5
🔪 AT Intensity Rating: 3 / 5
Quick Descriptors
• Retro losers club YA horror 🕹️👾🧛🏼♂️
• Social commentary on gender bias
• Teen group vs evil vixen
• Fast-paced with high drama
• Campy / heightened tone
One-Sentence Take
A fun, surprisingly dark, fast-paced, Stranger Things style YA horror that fully leans into the chaos and is hard to put down.
Review
This is such a campy, over-the-top ride in the best way. A.M. Wiley is my go-to for this style of horror, especially when I want the retro/nostalgia vibe! 🕹️👾
The biggest strength for me was how entertaining it is. There’s always something happening, and the story moves quickly without dragging. The final stretch especially feels unhinged in a way that makes it really hard to put down.
I also appreciated that the characters felt human, with a surprisingly strong emotional undercurrent. You can clearly see the coming-of-age elements, especially in Jack’s arc, and that’s one of my favorite parts of stories like this. Watching the characters evolve as everything spirals and rooting for them is always satisfying.
That said, there were moments where the tone didn’t fully balance the darker elements. The family dynamics, especially between Jack and his mom, felt like they had more depth to explore. Since that relationship shapes Jack’s perspective in such a big way, I wanted a little more grounding there to match the weight of those themes. I think it would have made his arc with Deb even more impactful.
The overall vibe and writing style will either work for you or not depending on your taste. I personally enjoy it and tend to seek it out. It feels nostalgic in a way that reminds me of Goosebumps, Fear Street, and Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark. It’s a great palate cleanser if you want something fun but still a little dark!
Overall, this is a bingeable, high-energy YA horror that leans into its chaos and delivers a really entertaining ride. I can’t wait to start book 2 in the series!
August 20, 2025
Appreciate the author for sending me a copy! I’m always open to reading new things I’ve never heard about, and honestly a great way to expand on my very limited genre. Which is 80% horror and 20% thriller.
Although yes, this book can be categorized and horror/thriller, this is very YA (and quite graphic for young audiences perhaps) and I typically do not read YA now that I’m older. Occasionally I find them quite entertaining, and this is one of them.
Jack is a high school student who is determined to use his journalistic talents to bring down the rich and rid the world of evil. By evil, we’re talking regular mortal evil stuff, like power hoarding, rich people, and special treatment. But little does he know, a chance of a lifetime is at his doorstep. A chance to eradicate a type of evil that’s not of this world.
Overview wise, this was a quick and entertaining read. Lots of action, everything progressed quickly and humor was scattered here and there. Really enjoyed the different characters and their interactions. There were some small issues I had with the plot here and there, but I was also able to suspend some of beliefs and logic because it serves no one to be super nitpicky. For example, these kids had a LOT of freedom, which isn’t necessarily impossible but couple that with a few scenes it does make me wonder. Or maybe my upbringing was just different so someone can tell me if I’m totally wrong.
This could definitely be a movie, kind of like those RL Stine movies on Netflix.
Although yes, this book can be categorized and horror/thriller, this is very YA (and quite graphic for young audiences perhaps) and I typically do not read YA now that I’m older. Occasionally I find them quite entertaining, and this is one of them.
Jack is a high school student who is determined to use his journalistic talents to bring down the rich and rid the world of evil. By evil, we’re talking regular mortal evil stuff, like power hoarding, rich people, and special treatment. But little does he know, a chance of a lifetime is at his doorstep. A chance to eradicate a type of evil that’s not of this world.
Overview wise, this was a quick and entertaining read. Lots of action, everything progressed quickly and humor was scattered here and there. Really enjoyed the different characters and their interactions. There were some small issues I had with the plot here and there, but I was also able to suspend some of beliefs and logic because it serves no one to be super nitpicky. For example, these kids had a LOT of freedom, which isn’t necessarily impossible but couple that with a few scenes it does make me wonder. Or maybe my upbringing was just different so someone can tell me if I’m totally wrong.
This could definitely be a movie, kind of like those RL Stine movies on Netflix.
September 14, 2025
4.5 stars
I enjoyed this so much! The Heart Taker was such a cosy read. It had so much of what my geeky little heart loves.
It's very reminiscent of stranger things, Sabrina, and super 8. If you love them, then this is definitely a book for you.
I really loved that at the beginning of each chapter, A.M. Wiley added an on point quote from some of the best pop culture movies such as Indiana Jones, Jaws, Aliens, Star Wars, and Mean Girls. It really added a brilliant touch that fit the whole vibe of the book.
And just as I was getting cocky thinking, I know who's who, the plot cleverly seaways, and I was guessing to the very end.
My only niggle is that I couldn't relate to some of the characters like Nina and her band of stuck up mean girls. I'd like to have known more about them and why they are such bellends. Having said that! It's been left open for a book 2!! Ahhh! 😍😍
Also, this tiny niggle could have something to do with me reading this off my phone. I've very much a paperback and blanket kinda gal, and reading off my phone just doesn't quite cut it for me personally. I'll be having a re-read once I've bought it on paperback, and I'm so excited because this cover art is epic ✨️
4 and half stars for The Heart Taker ❤️🖤
Thank you to the author for gifting me an e-copy in return for an honest review
I enjoyed this so much! The Heart Taker was such a cosy read. It had so much of what my geeky little heart loves.
It's very reminiscent of stranger things, Sabrina, and super 8. If you love them, then this is definitely a book for you.
I really loved that at the beginning of each chapter, A.M. Wiley added an on point quote from some of the best pop culture movies such as Indiana Jones, Jaws, Aliens, Star Wars, and Mean Girls. It really added a brilliant touch that fit the whole vibe of the book.
And just as I was getting cocky thinking, I know who's who, the plot cleverly seaways, and I was guessing to the very end.
My only niggle is that I couldn't relate to some of the characters like Nina and her band of stuck up mean girls. I'd like to have known more about them and why they are such bellends. Having said that! It's been left open for a book 2!! Ahhh! 😍😍
Also, this tiny niggle could have something to do with me reading this off my phone. I've very much a paperback and blanket kinda gal, and reading off my phone just doesn't quite cut it for me personally. I'll be having a re-read once I've bought it on paperback, and I'm so excited because this cover art is epic ✨️
4 and half stars for The Heart Taker ❤️🖤
Thank you to the author for gifting me an e-copy in return for an honest review
October 12, 2025
I find A.M. Wiley's writing to be engaging, uplifting and written with purpose. This is the second novel I have read by the author. A story about family, found family, true love, faith, seeking to do good, and valuing others as much as you value yourself. It is a story about good overcoming evil, light shining and banishing the darkness. I really enjoyed how the author talked about true romantic love verses hormonal lust. The author also did a great job is showing the power and goodness of female beauty versus hotness. The characters felt like real people with backstories that enhanced their portrayal. However, the backstories were barebones and left me wanting more. I was overjoyed to see faith brought out in the main character. But the main character's faith was barebones and it was not explored at all. I thought the book would have been greatly enhanced by the main characters faith becoming his guiding light and leading him through his strong character development in the story. As it was it was a coming of age story with a good moral message. Also, I felt the geek friends were left as archetypes and underused. This is a highly enjoyable horror tale free, of gratuitous gore, sexuality, blasphemy and vulgar language.
November 5, 2025
I was provided a copy of this book for free as part of Macabre Mortis book club's October Indie Tron! Thank you so much to Steph for organising, and thank you A. M. Wiley for providing your book!
Spooky season prevails all throughout Autumn and Winter for me; how could it not? Darker and colder nights, Samhain is upon us, and I keep with the Victorian tradition of reading ghost stories over Winter.
I started my Halloween reading early in October with The Heart Taker by A. M. Wiley this year. A thrilling and gory horror set in a high school, following would-be investigative journalist Jack as he explores the recent grisly murders that took place at a neighbouring high school, all sharing one odd, grisly aspect. The victims' hearts were removed.
Jack reads as what you'd get if you dropped Holden Caulfield in the middle of Jennifer's Body, and it makes for an entertaining read. Truthfully, I didn't like him much at first. He's not terrible, just a typical teenage edgelord type. He's intelligent - but very aware of it, and uses this to his advantage, stirring up drama in the school paper with his controversial opinion pieces. Much to the chagrin of his paper's editor, Debra, who wants him to work on an investigative piece covering the mysterious deaths of the other high school's students.
Then we meet Delilah. A new transfer who everyone is intrigued by. The demon-in-disguise begins working against Jack, claiming victims and gaining followers as she goes, aside from The Guardians, a nerdy group that runs another paper focusing on the supernatural. Working together, Jack, Debra, and the Guardians manage to discover the truth behind who Delilah is and behind a much deeper mystery in the town.
Jack definitely grew on me and had some great character growth throughout the book. I went into this expecting the book to end up in my "good for her" category of books. But while Delilah was likeable and conniving, the way the plot developed had you rooting for Jack and his group to come out on top.
It's well-paced, suspenseful and a genuinely good spooky read for the season. About 3/4 of the way through, I started to suspect who was really behind all the goings on, and was extremely vindicated to find out I was right. There are quite a few fun little references to other classic horror stories in the book too, such as Jack living on Elm Street. The misdirection with the Headmistress was a nice touch too, until close to the end I couldn't decide if she really was in on the scheme or was a red herring all along.
My only slight criticism would be that Delilah started out as a great villain, but ended up a little lacking in dimension when you find out she's a demon merely sent after certain victims by the cult that seems to be a dark undercurrent in the town. I would have liked to see her have more motive and agency as a villain, with more backstory, but it was enjoyable nonetheless.
Themes and Tropes:
Suspense
Supernatural horror
More to the town than it seems
Mystery
Gory
Strong FMCs
Surprise! It's a cult all along
Content warnings:
Gore
Murder
Grisly deaths - hearts removed
Grief
Sexism (Jack's early façade)
Violence
Like my reviews? Read more at: WraithfulReads.com.
Spooky season prevails all throughout Autumn and Winter for me; how could it not? Darker and colder nights, Samhain is upon us, and I keep with the Victorian tradition of reading ghost stories over Winter.
I started my Halloween reading early in October with The Heart Taker by A. M. Wiley this year. A thrilling and gory horror set in a high school, following would-be investigative journalist Jack as he explores the recent grisly murders that took place at a neighbouring high school, all sharing one odd, grisly aspect. The victims' hearts were removed.
Jack reads as what you'd get if you dropped Holden Caulfield in the middle of Jennifer's Body, and it makes for an entertaining read. Truthfully, I didn't like him much at first. He's not terrible, just a typical teenage edgelord type. He's intelligent - but very aware of it, and uses this to his advantage, stirring up drama in the school paper with his controversial opinion pieces. Much to the chagrin of his paper's editor, Debra, who wants him to work on an investigative piece covering the mysterious deaths of the other high school's students.
Then we meet Delilah. A new transfer who everyone is intrigued by. The demon-in-disguise begins working against Jack, claiming victims and gaining followers as she goes, aside from The Guardians, a nerdy group that runs another paper focusing on the supernatural. Working together, Jack, Debra, and the Guardians manage to discover the truth behind who Delilah is and behind a much deeper mystery in the town.
Jack definitely grew on me and had some great character growth throughout the book. I went into this expecting the book to end up in my "good for her" category of books. But while Delilah was likeable and conniving, the way the plot developed had you rooting for Jack and his group to come out on top.
It's well-paced, suspenseful and a genuinely good spooky read for the season. About 3/4 of the way through, I started to suspect who was really behind all the goings on, and was extremely vindicated to find out I was right. There are quite a few fun little references to other classic horror stories in the book too, such as Jack living on Elm Street. The misdirection with the Headmistress was a nice touch too, until close to the end I couldn't decide if she really was in on the scheme or was a red herring all along.
My only slight criticism would be that Delilah started out as a great villain, but ended up a little lacking in dimension when you find out she's a demon merely sent after certain victims by the cult that seems to be a dark undercurrent in the town. I would have liked to see her have more motive and agency as a villain, with more backstory, but it was enjoyable nonetheless.
Themes and Tropes:
Suspense
Supernatural horror
More to the town than it seems
Mystery
Gory
Strong FMCs
Surprise! It's a cult all along
Content warnings:
Gore
Murder
Grisly deaths - hearts removed
Grief
Sexism (Jack's early façade)
Violence
Like my reviews? Read more at: WraithfulReads.com.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 26, 2025
Let me be up front from the off by stating that I was unaware that this was a YA novel when I started, so my initial feelings on the books were clouded by that lack of knowledge. When I actually went to look and saw that it was YA, I was then able to better settle into the story.
The Heart Taker has everything you would want from the genre, such as high school drama, teenage angst, and a bubbling romance going on just below the surface. You don’t particularly expect there to be major character development, but the main man, Jack, was very well put together, thanks in large part to his family life, which became an integral part of the story.
As you might imagine for a YA novel, the violence and horror is muted somewhat, but there are still some very good elements that will keep readers of the intended age group on their toes. There is a good whodunnit going on through the story, too, and while I was able to, for the most part, figure it all out, younger readers will have a great time following all the breadcrumbs.
All told, this was a fast-paced, fun read that slots very nicely into the YA genre. I would definitely recommend giving The Heart Taker by A.M. Wiley a read if you are looking to dip your toe into horror via the YA reading pool.
4 stars out of 5
The Heart Taker has everything you would want from the genre, such as high school drama, teenage angst, and a bubbling romance going on just below the surface. You don’t particularly expect there to be major character development, but the main man, Jack, was very well put together, thanks in large part to his family life, which became an integral part of the story.
As you might imagine for a YA novel, the violence and horror is muted somewhat, but there are still some very good elements that will keep readers of the intended age group on their toes. There is a good whodunnit going on through the story, too, and while I was able to, for the most part, figure it all out, younger readers will have a great time following all the breadcrumbs.
All told, this was a fast-paced, fun read that slots very nicely into the YA genre. I would definitely recommend giving The Heart Taker by A.M. Wiley a read if you are looking to dip your toe into horror via the YA reading pool.
4 stars out of 5
November 13, 2025
This story was thrilling, gory but surprisingly funny, especially with the geeky crusaders known as the Guardian. As an avid gamer myself, the Guardian were the most relatable characters, each with their own knowledge of how to defeat the succubus.
Jack, a high school teen gossip columnist, a little self-centered and sexist was trying to expose the high school social gap and evilness, especially among female students. Yeah...boy has some mommy issues 😅. But when the murders of 4 high school students from a neighboring school caught his attention, he got more than dramas and gossip. He became a target of a succubus that was summoned to take his heart, literally.
Overall the story was very enjoyable. Jack, although a little unlikeable with his meh-attitude at the beginning of the story, really had the best character development. And remember The Guardian? They were awkwardly adorable, effortlessly funny and took their games seriously like their life depends on it. I love them all... except one person. 🫣 Yes....
Highly recommend!!
Jack, a high school teen gossip columnist, a little self-centered and sexist was trying to expose the high school social gap and evilness, especially among female students. Yeah...boy has some mommy issues 😅. But when the murders of 4 high school students from a neighboring school caught his attention, he got more than dramas and gossip. He became a target of a succubus that was summoned to take his heart, literally.
Overall the story was very enjoyable. Jack, although a little unlikeable with his meh-attitude at the beginning of the story, really had the best character development. And remember The Guardian? They were awkwardly adorable, effortlessly funny and took their games seriously like their life depends on it. I love them all... except one person. 🫣 Yes....
Highly recommend!!
December 2, 2025
In The Heart Taker we follow Jack, a teen reporter who investigates the murders committed in the nearby town. I was not an instant fan of Jack who came across as self assured but aloof. I had to remind myself that he's in fact still a kid to muster up some empathy. As the story went on though, I found myself empathizing with the poor dude. His family situation is not great, he has a crush on his fellow reporter Deb but doesn't know how to tell her, and on top of that there's a new girl at school and there's just something not quite right about her. Other than the fact that she pretty much took over Jack's job at the school newspaper from her first day.
This is a fast paced story with some dark and gory scenes as well as a group of nerds who became Jack's sidekicks in the investigation. I loved the mystery, the weird cult vibes, gory scenes, evil teen girl villains and the creepy vibes. The whole atmosphere reminded me a bit of Riverdale, although it's been a while since I watched that.
I received the book from the author. Opinions are my own.
This is a fast paced story with some dark and gory scenes as well as a group of nerds who became Jack's sidekicks in the investigation. I loved the mystery, the weird cult vibes, gory scenes, evil teen girl villains and the creepy vibes. The whole atmosphere reminded me a bit of Riverdale, although it's been a while since I watched that.
I received the book from the author. Opinions are my own.
December 9, 2025
When the popular kids start turning up dead… and someone is literally stealing their hearts?! Yeah. I was immediately obsessed. 😳🩸🖤
I LOVED this book so much and I’m not over it yet.
The group of kids? Elite.
The vibes? Pure nostalgia.
The energy? Stranger Things coded ALL day.
Teen gossip columnist by day… murder investigator by night?? Yes please. Jack thought he was just exposing prep school drama, not chasing a deadly new girl who literally steals hearts. Add in secret crushes, geeky sidekicks, small-town murders, and a terrifying mystery? I was locked IN.
This one had everything:
✅ Small town secrets
✅ Found family energy
✅ Creepy girl with a horrifying secret
✅ High school drama meets straight-up horror
✅ And twists I did NOT see coming
And now I’m sitting here like… I can’t wait for the second book because I NEED MORE.
If you love nostalgic horror with teens banding together to stop something evil… run, don’t walk.
Would you survive this kind of small-town chaos or be the first one taken out? 👀🩸
I LOVED this book so much and I’m not over it yet.
The group of kids? Elite.
The vibes? Pure nostalgia.
The energy? Stranger Things coded ALL day.
Teen gossip columnist by day… murder investigator by night?? Yes please. Jack thought he was just exposing prep school drama, not chasing a deadly new girl who literally steals hearts. Add in secret crushes, geeky sidekicks, small-town murders, and a terrifying mystery? I was locked IN.
This one had everything:
✅ Small town secrets
✅ Found family energy
✅ Creepy girl with a horrifying secret
✅ High school drama meets straight-up horror
✅ And twists I did NOT see coming
And now I’m sitting here like… I can’t wait for the second book because I NEED MORE.
If you love nostalgic horror with teens banding together to stop something evil… run, don’t walk.
Would you survive this kind of small-town chaos or be the first one taken out? 👀🩸
March 27, 2026
🚨slight spoiler at the end🚨
I really enjoyed this one! 🙌🏻 high school drama with a beautiful demon who will literally steal your heart? Yes please 😈 It started with a good prologue that drew me right in and I was totally hooked the whole way through. I enjoyed the story overall but the characters really done it for me, I thought they were all great. When we first meet our main character Jack I wasn't sure if I was going to like him but I was rooting for him the whole way through! The members of The Guardians were my favorite, they reminded me a little of The Lone Gunmen from The XFiles, and I love those nerdy guys! There was a few twists along the way that I wasn't expecting, I thought I had it worked out who was behind it all and I was completely wrong 😆 I really enjoyed the ending and have my fingers crossed there's a second book coming because I need to know what Miss Nina is up to!
I really enjoyed this one! 🙌🏻 high school drama with a beautiful demon who will literally steal your heart? Yes please 😈 It started with a good prologue that drew me right in and I was totally hooked the whole way through. I enjoyed the story overall but the characters really done it for me, I thought they were all great. When we first meet our main character Jack I wasn't sure if I was going to like him but I was rooting for him the whole way through! The members of The Guardians were my favorite, they reminded me a little of The Lone Gunmen from The XFiles, and I love those nerdy guys! There was a few twists along the way that I wasn't expecting, I thought I had it worked out who was behind it all and I was completely wrong 😆 I really enjoyed the ending and have my fingers crossed there's a second book coming because I need to know what Miss Nina is up to!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 4, 2026
“Teen gossip columnist Jack Berlin thought he was exposing high school drama—until a string of murders leads to a deadly new girl who just might steal his heart… literally.”
While not my usual cup of tea, I found myself instantly taken in when reading The Heart Taker. AM Wiley seamlessly and effortlessly blends genres such as horror, sci-fi, and even high school style rom com to the point where they just flow perfectly. The amount of world building and character development that went into this book makes it so that when each twist and turn in the story takes place, you’re profoundly invested in what happens with each character. The book takes its time setting up the story yet is still a face paced story that keeps you on the edge of your seat. After being in a little bit of a reading rut for quite some time, The Heart Taker was definately a breath of fresh air. Thank you to the author for allowing me a review copy!
While not my usual cup of tea, I found myself instantly taken in when reading The Heart Taker. AM Wiley seamlessly and effortlessly blends genres such as horror, sci-fi, and even high school style rom com to the point where they just flow perfectly. The amount of world building and character development that went into this book makes it so that when each twist and turn in the story takes place, you’re profoundly invested in what happens with each character. The book takes its time setting up the story yet is still a face paced story that keeps you on the edge of your seat. After being in a little bit of a reading rut for quite some time, The Heart Taker was definately a breath of fresh air. Thank you to the author for allowing me a review copy!
October 31, 2025
I thought that this book sounded really interesting, and I was excited to read it. I haven’t read something like this before and I was not disappointed.
The story was really fun and I thought that it was very well written. I think that A.M. Wiley did an excellent job of creating a chilling and unsettling atmosphere while also mixing together different genres. I actually thought that the ending was pretty unpredictable and I did not see it coming.
I liked this book and it did a great job of telling a cohesive and interesting story, while also managing to be fast-paced and without dull moments. The ending was open-ended and I’m interested to see if the story will continue.
@Paperbackdanny on Instagram
The story was really fun and I thought that it was very well written. I think that A.M. Wiley did an excellent job of creating a chilling and unsettling atmosphere while also mixing together different genres. I actually thought that the ending was pretty unpredictable and I did not see it coming.
I liked this book and it did a great job of telling a cohesive and interesting story, while also managing to be fast-paced and without dull moments. The ending was open-ended and I’m interested to see if the story will continue.
@Paperbackdanny on Instagram
October 13, 2025
4/5 Stars
Format: Paperback
Spoilers: No
As a big fan of Wiley's Weird Space books, I was really excited to give The Heart Taker a try, and I'm glad I did. Wiley has a talent for writing really fun books with the right amount of nostalgia.
The Heart Taker is a YA horror novel that reminded me a lot of the RL Stine Fear Street series. While geared towards YA, as a former Goosebumps and Fear Street reader I really enjoyed my time with this one. It's an incredibly fun story with that great YA horror absurdity that makes it so fun. As with the Weird Space books, we get 80's/90's nostalgia, a fun teenage friend story, and a murder mystery with chills and thrills all along the way.
If you loved Weird Space, if you loved Fear Street back in the day, or you're just looking for a fun, fast paced entertaining horror book, you have to check the Heart Taker out.
Format: Paperback
Spoilers: No
As a big fan of Wiley's Weird Space books, I was really excited to give The Heart Taker a try, and I'm glad I did. Wiley has a talent for writing really fun books with the right amount of nostalgia.
The Heart Taker is a YA horror novel that reminded me a lot of the RL Stine Fear Street series. While geared towards YA, as a former Goosebumps and Fear Street reader I really enjoyed my time with this one. It's an incredibly fun story with that great YA horror absurdity that makes it so fun. As with the Weird Space books, we get 80's/90's nostalgia, a fun teenage friend story, and a murder mystery with chills and thrills all along the way.
If you loved Weird Space, if you loved Fear Street back in the day, or you're just looking for a fun, fast paced entertaining horror book, you have to check the Heart Taker out.
March 9, 2026
I thoroughly enjoyed this book! From the very beginning the story pulled me in. found it genuinely hard to put the book down because I kept wanting to know what would happen next.
The mystery surrounding the murders created an atmosphere that kept the tension building throughout the story. I was invested in figuring out what was really happening and how all the pieces would connect. I also enjoyed following Jack and the character growth that took place throughout the story.
Overall, this was a very engaging read. If you enjoy suspenseful stories that hook you right away and keep you guessing, this book is definitely worth picking up.
The mystery surrounding the murders created an atmosphere that kept the tension building throughout the story. I was invested in figuring out what was really happening and how all the pieces would connect. I also enjoyed following Jack and the character growth that took place throughout the story.
Overall, this was a very engaging read. If you enjoy suspenseful stories that hook you right away and keep you guessing, this book is definitely worth picking up.
April 7, 2026
Excellent Story
So, I accidentally read Fang Glory before reading this one. Luckily, it didn’t impact the story or level of enjoyment I had while reading. We get to learn about the backstory of the core of the Night Stalker team and their first encounter with Delilah. There was a perfect amount of action, suspense, and horror and the book was a lot of fun to read. I’m really looking forward to the continuing adventures of Jack, Deb, and the rest of the crew. Now…I may need to re-read Fang Glory and see if I can pick up references to The Heart Taker that I missed. Nice job, A.M. Wiley.
So, I accidentally read Fang Glory before reading this one. Luckily, it didn’t impact the story or level of enjoyment I had while reading. We get to learn about the backstory of the core of the Night Stalker team and their first encounter with Delilah. There was a perfect amount of action, suspense, and horror and the book was a lot of fun to read. I’m really looking forward to the continuing adventures of Jack, Deb, and the rest of the crew. Now…I may need to re-read Fang Glory and see if I can pick up references to The Heart Taker that I missed. Nice job, A.M. Wiley.
August 11, 2025
A horror story with a little mix of fantasy and sci-fi. A.M. Wiley writes a fun, fast paced, coming of age story about Jack, a high school gossip columnist investigating the murders of four teenage guys at a neighboring high school.
Although this leans more towards YA, I feel like this is something everyone can enjoy. It has the suspense, mystery, the bloodshed, and twists. The characters are likable and relatable, and it has a great ending.
Coming to mind while reading this was the great 90s movie, The Faculty, and Buffy, and a little bit of Strangers Things. So if you like those, you’ll enjoy this book too!
Thank you so much to the author for gifting me a copy to read, no strings attached.
Although this leans more towards YA, I feel like this is something everyone can enjoy. It has the suspense, mystery, the bloodshed, and twists. The characters are likable and relatable, and it has a great ending.
Coming to mind while reading this was the great 90s movie, The Faculty, and Buffy, and a little bit of Strangers Things. So if you like those, you’ll enjoy this book too!
Thank you so much to the author for gifting me a copy to read, no strings attached.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 44 reviews