Read for work's Mock Printz Committee. Kinda struggling with the rating right now because I liked it about the same as "Shut Up, This is Serious" and I'm not sure which one I would rate as better yet?? But I rated the other book a 5 so I guess this one is going to also be a 5, but now I'm thinking this is a 4.5??? I liked the subject matter of this one a lot but this had more cons than Shut Up did...so we'll see about the final ratings.
Story: Ariel is a seventeen-year-old girl who feels like she is too big, too queer, too dangerous, too much, etc. for everyone else. She struggles with intrusive thoughts and OCD, which are depicted in the form of a hungry crocodile/reptile and written in creepy font. Her older sister Mandy has gone off to college and her best friend Leah left the state for the summer, so Ariel is alone working her typical summer job at Wildwood, the summer carnival in town. At Wildwood this year she makes new friends - Ruth, a Black girl from Chicago here for the summer, and Rex, a trans boy who lives in town. Ariel experiences a breakdown and almost jumps off the edge of a bridge, but Ruth and Rex get there in time. The three friends grow closer, and Mandy explains to Ariel that she may have OCD. Ariel’s parents don’t believe in therapy (“prayer cures everything”) and are wrapped up in themselves/have a difficult relationship with her, so home life is difficult. Ruth and Rex work on exposure therapy with Ariel in helping her to face her fears and intrusive thoughts and ride the bus, watch the darts booth, and operate the Loco Loco ride that she’s terrified of. The book ends with Ariel still starting to work through fighting back against her intrusive thoughts but being able to do some things that seemed impossible and seeing her friends kiss, seeing them safe.
Voice: Ariel’s voice is pretty established from the get-go. Her thoughts are honest and brutal, raw and unfiltered, filled with fear and so many questions and blood and murder. Love that she covers a wide range of topics - gender, sex, religion, mental health, relationships (family, friends, lovers), and body image. She speaks on being a lesbian and on not being sure about her gender identity and trying to understand that in relation to how society views gender, how others perceive her, and how she views herself and her big body. Cursing is present. Appreciate how her intrusive thoughts are in a bold, creepy font while other people’s speech is in italics so we can differentiate who is speaking.
Style: I need to say that I really, really wished there was a trigger warning section at the beginning of this book. If a teen randomly picked this book up off the shelf, it could hit someone badly in a way they were not prepared for. That said, this book’s beginning sucked me in. It starts off this way: “I have to. Every time I leave the kitchen whether I’m going in or out of the house. It’s a rule written in blood. This morning, like every morning, I stare down at the collection of kitchen knives in the drawer by the stove. There are ten of them, one for each finger, short and long, serrated and not, silver silver silver I know them all well. This is the rule: in order to stop myself from driving one of them into my father’s chest I must open the drawers - the silent kind that don’t slam - and tap each blade with one finger, six times for each knife: tap tap tap tap tap tap.” There is no shying away from the ugliness of our inner intrusive thoughts.
Setting: Takes place in Ariel’s town, her job at Wildwood, the movie theater, Ruth’s car, places around town, and her house. I like that we weren’t all over the place and that a lot of the places were staples/repeated frequently.
Accuracy: I appreciated the breadth of types of intrusive thoughts covered in multiple ways - sexual intrusive thoughts, violent intrusive thoughts, religious intrusive thoughts, obsession with being perfect or safe. There were definitions of OCD and intrusive thoughts stated thoughtfully in places throughout the book, as well as some resources listed at the end. The book also emphasized that thinking you can treat OCD by yourself may not be the best way - that the brain deserves treatment, and that you wouldn’t just wrap a broken bone or a broken neck and think it’s fine. I think it's really rare to see such a strong depiction of OCD in such a blunt, unapologetic, realistic, and yet kind way in YA fic currently.
Characters: Ariel is a relatable protagonist and one I immediately rooted for/felt sympathy for due to her intense struggles with her thoughts and how that negatively affected how she lived her life (being terrified of driving or taking the bus, not being able to do certain things at work, missing conversations with friends because she’s stuck in her rituals). Also appreciated the consistency in character of Ariel standing up to boys picking on her or her friends. Ruth’s brashness and ability to be herself unapologetically and to pull that out of the people around her made her such a fun character. Rex’s character was one of comforting and support and glue, while being quick to help Ariel in ways that actually supported her well - bringing food, calling her sister, finding places for her to rest, suggesting she face her fears with friends, etc. Ruth’s character as a Black female and Rex’s trans journey and tension with his parents regarding hormone replacement therapy provided interesting exploration of topics of race and gender. The scene that hit me the hardest was when Ariel was about to jump from the bridge but Rex and Ruth got there just in time, and just seeing their conversation play out, the realness of it all, the language, Ruth shrieking for Rex to deal with it because she couldn’t, and the way they cared for Ariel in the aftermath…I love that Rex brings Ariel food and talks to her about his brother and how he had a maniac episode and was killed by the police, and the way that Ruth opens up about her favorite cousin committing suicide and her whole family thinking she was so cold because she couldn’t get herself to go to the funeral. The scenes where Ariel, Ruth, and Rex drive off somewhere or go to the movies or talk until sunrise together sharing their thoughts are so precious, and so…vulnerable. Where they share their fears, their thoughts about their loved ones dying and their struggles and their relationships with their parents, all of it embodied the teen years where you really rely on your friends for support. Mandy wasn’t that interesting to me as a character, though I suppose we only see her from Ariel’s view - perfect older sister in every way who is determined to find a way to help her sister with her psychological struggles. Ariel’s parents are distant and struggling with their own things (her mom wants to be young and like all other women in society, while she realizes at the end of the book that her father is hurting too and keeps her at arm’s length), which adds depth to the book but doesn’t really get resolved in any way. In contrast, I love that Ariel has other supportive adult figures in her life who notice when she’s struggling, like Megga (boss) and Cipinko (weights teacher at school), and who talk to her about it.
Theme: The author says in the acknowledgments that the heart of the story is “Why do we think there is something wrong with us?” She spends a lot of time examining how a person can’t be put in one box and that society often defines what is “right” or “good” in a very specific way, but that we shouldn’t feel limited to being one thing. She also discusses how being a woman in society often seems like a cage and how it appears sometimes that everyone else was given the right code/set of thoughts while those who struggle aren’t, and that doesn’t mean that the struggling person is wrong.
Illustrations: LOL love the crocodiles on the spine of the book - cute actual illustration but also ties to the sinister part of Ariel seeing her hungry, dangerous OCD thoughts. The cover is pretty, with an eye-catching font and a nice depiction of Ariel to give me something to imagine her as, since there’s very little physical description about her besides being tall/big/unladylike.
Design (including format, organization, etc.): I have weirdly mixed opinions about this novel-in-verse format. Usually it’s powerful and hits me like a truck, and I feel like the format did lend itself to some very powerful moments, especially when Ariel was about to jump, or when she is wrestling through her intrusive thoughts or counting rituals. At other times, though, the sections felt a little disjointed and abrupt. The last third of the book seemed like it was dragging on a bit and I was just flipping pages to read quickly to find out how the rest of the story progressed. It took longer than I thought to get to the end of the book, which ended how I expected, but could have been fleshed out better with different scenarios to showcase the growth in battling her thoughts? I would have also appreciated more of Ariel being able to summarize or share her thoughts in how she felt as she worked through fighting her intrusive thoughts and reshaping her thinking.
“I am watching myself from somewhere high above / or maybe far below, watching myself / get dumped on the concrete, hot in the sun / watching myself look up at Rex and Ruth / who stand looking down at me, one of them crying / one of them blank-faced, but neither of them / running away. ‘Were you going to jump?’ I don’t know. Cut the shit, Ariel! Were you going to jump? I don’t know! No. I can’t do this shit, Ruth shrieks. Rex, talk to her! How did you find me? Megga told us to follow you. Were you going to jump? I don’t know / I don’t know / I don’t know” (190-191)
“Ruth shows up at sunrise with donuts. You could have texted me sooner. We didn’t want to wake you up. I was awake. We talk in whispers and leave crumbs. What are you most afraid of? Missing the signs, she says. Again and again. Losing everyone. Getting to the edge a second too late. Him: Never leaving this town. Getting stuck in invisibility. Answer your own question, Ariel. Hurting the people I love and not being able to stop.” (411-412)