A hard one to review. I’m not sure if this was written to make herself relevant again? With Kristin Harila finishing all the 8,000 meter peaks in 92 days and her open, vulnerable honestly about losing her climbing partner and Sherpa shortly after, did Melissa think “if I write about my bratty, manipulative 20s, and that I’ve grown up I’ll look like I have a heart”
If you want an emotional book about truly finding a breaking point in climbing that delves into real mental illness, read Cory Richard’s Color of Everything. Comparatively, this fell so flat. I’m not sure Melissa has the emotional depth to go into mental health work. Girl you have PTSD. There was so much potential to get into the gritty. Your partner dies, you save Ueli, Avalanche death, earthquake and you wonder why you don’t feel comfortable up there? I went once and got severe altitude sickness and stopped climbing for 3 years.
She skims over how she was a naughty mean girl, but she still is! Page 89 she says *I have no idea what her name was, but it wasn’t Trixie. Ok, rude. Why didn’t you address that some of the male names had been changed, or you didn’t know them. (Before the last page) You yourself were part of the problem. Still. Handing out ridiculous names like Trixie.
I’m sorry but Melissa going on and on about wanting to prove she can do it alone and then using every man she could is so hypocritical. Her narcissistic tendencies aren’t something to be applauded.
I’m sorry your mom was mean, mine was too.
I think Ed Viestures uses the little footnotes, as footnotes should be used, to describe something you may not know in mtn Climbing… not as cutsie thought bubbles.
Listen, most of us are emotionally immature sh*ts in our 20s, but add fame, trauma and PTSD and you get Melissa. I used to follow her. Thought of her as an inspiration, but this poor attempt of excuses for being a lying, cheating, manipulative narcissist to settled house wife is just .. ick.
I’ve read a lot of climbers books and, honestly, they just own that they are mountain “gods” as she names them. She should have too. Or get deep, like Cory.
Sad thing is, my therapist heard Melissa on a podcast and thought it might pertain to some of my climbing issues. But this book is a far cry from how I’ve dealt with my life and climbing.
I’ve lost respect.
Stick to the podcast.
Don’t recommend.