Wasn't what I expected. That's not normally a good reason to give a middle-of-the-road review of a book (in my opinion)... except in the few selections I read, the scholarship seemed similarly middle-of-the-road. I know we all need these occasional "setting the stage for a new movement in the field" volumes... but going over the 16 kinds of letters found in Oxyrhynchus just so you can determine a "genre" bores me...
... although the references to pirates and lesbians were fantastic. ;)
Maybe I need to finish the book entirely before driving down the hammer. Anticipated point taken.