I was a little nervous jumping into a series for the first time at Book 23, but Chiaverini makes the reader feel like she’s been with the characters from the beginning. There were only a couple of things I wondered about while reading, and my answers were quickly found just by reading the previous books’ summaries.
Sylvia grew up at Elm Creek Manor, but a disagreement with her sister forced her to flee her home and her dream of running the manor and thoroughbred farm that her father had started. When she returns home due to her sister’s death, she has to find a way to bring the manor out of debt. She brings in a younger couple, Matt and Sarah, and allows their new ideas to bring the farm out of debt, including opening an orchard.
The novel begins in 2004, with the opening of the orchard approaching. Sylvia, in her 80s, is a bit old school. She isn’t used to some of the new ideas that Matt and Sarah have, but she tries to go along with the hope that their ideas will bring in enough money to replace the leaking roof. Sarah and Sylvia are also planning their upcoming Quilt camps for the many quilters who converge on Elm Creek Manor for a week of quilting.
As Summer Sullivan is working on the historical quilt display at the local Union Hall, her visit to pick up the World’s Fair quilt forces Sylvia to flashback to 1933 when she and her sister worked together to create a Quilt of Progress for the 1933 World’s Fair in Chicago. As the story unfolds, long-buried feelings of resentment and hurt are brought to the forefront of Sylvia’s mind along with regret and nostalgia.
This dual-timeline story takes readers back to the Great Depression on a thoroughbred farm in Pennsylvania. Two families live together at Elm Creek Manor to help each other, and two teen girls are trying to make a quilt with dreams of winning the contest to save their family farm. The two storylines mimic each other as Sylvia, now the matriarch of the farm, is hoping an orchard will help them earn enough money to keep the manor open.
“The muslin center rectangle of each block was inscribed with a name, the names and penmanship unique to each block. The ink had faded away long ago and, in some places, had deteriorated the muslin fabric, but the black embroidery over each signature remained.”
I only knew Jennifer Chiaverini for her stand-alone historical fiction, but her Elm Creek Quilt series is wildly popular among quilters and readers alike. As the daughter and sister of quilters (I didn’t get the quilting gene), I was taken back to my own childhood of sitting underneath the quilt frame at our country church and pushing the needles up to the women sitting around the quilt. I even have inherited a quilt similar to one mentioned in the book, with embroidered signatures of all the women and their families who worked on the quilt.
Setting is important to Chiaverini, whether she is describing the orchard with the smell of apples about to be picked, or at Elm Creek Manor while Sylvia and her sister are poring over ideas for their quilt design, or walking into Sears’ Hall at the World’s Fair and seeing all of the winning quilts hanging up for viewing. I could imagine each of these scenes in my mind, including the various quilt designs that Sylvia and Claudia viewed.
This book is based on the real 1993 Chicago World’s Fair, where Sears, Roebuck & Co. sponsored a National Quilt Contest for the fair, offering a $1,000 grand prize and an additional $200 for quilts depicting the theme of the Century of Progress. In 1933, $1,000 was a lot of money, especially for a struggling farm, and Sylvia and Claudia dreamed of winning the grand prize money. Eventually, this particular quilt drove a wedge in their relationship and was the last time the two of them would ever work together on anything.
“If only she and Claudia had not squandered so many opportunities to be kind to each other, to be tolerant and forgiving, to admit their mistakes and reconcile—”
Aside from the sister story and history of the World’s Fair, I found myself nostalgic for simpler times of quilting and the joy of a family taking an adventure of a lifetime by riding the train to Chicago and spending a few days at the Chicago World’s Fair. I remembered days of excitement when the Sears catalog would arrive in the mail, especially the Christmas edition, and how exciting it would be to order something from the catalog, only to arrive soon in our mailbox. Sears was the original Amazon and way ahead of its time.
If you grew up with a mom or grandma who quilted or loves the story of a family coming together to save a farm, then this might just be the story for you. Even though I enjoyed the World’s Fair timeline more, I still connected to the more present-day story of a group of people finding ways to change and adapt to the times and keep their business relevant. Several of Chiaverini’s stand-alone novels were already on my list, and I look forward to reading more from her.