What do you think?
Rate this book
Swiss Guard Romance #1
Love in the Eternal City
Rome—once the heart of an empire, now the heart of the Catholic Church—has witnessed many love stories. When the Eternal City draws together a Swiss Guard and an American expat, a modern-day romance blooms in the shadow of Saint Peter’s Basilica.
Haunted by a broken engagement and betrayed by her best friend, Elena Gattino travels to Rome for a new job and the hope of a new life. Fueled by pasta and bolstered by prayer, she becomes brave enough to forge new friendships with the Rechsteiner siblings as she explores Rome and finds her footing at work.
Benedikt Rechsteiner is comfortable serving in the Swiss Guard, even if he recognizes his life lacks a special something…or someone. Simmering family tensions and uncertainty about his future have left Beni wary of relationships, but his unexpected feelings for Elena challenge him to face his fears.
Soon, Beni and Elena’s friendship turns into more, thanks to the matchmaking meddling of a Vatican spymaster, a Swiss Guard comrade-in-arms, and Beni’s overenthusiastic yet lovable sister. But then Elena’s past follows her to Rome, putting her in danger that even Beni may not be able to save her from. And if Beni wants to be with Elena, he’ll need to discern where his own future lies—and reconcile with his father after years of bitterness. Can the two forge a relationship strong enough to withstand the suffering that comes their way? Or will the tensions of their own lives pull them apart?
Haunted by a broken engagement and betrayed by her best friend, Elena Gattino travels to Rome for a new job and the hope of a new life. Fueled by pasta and bolstered by prayer, she becomes brave enough to forge new friendships with the Rechsteiner siblings as she explores Rome and finds her footing at work.
Benedikt Rechsteiner is comfortable serving in the Swiss Guard, even if he recognizes his life lacks a special something…or someone. Simmering family tensions and uncertainty about his future have left Beni wary of relationships, but his unexpected feelings for Elena challenge him to face his fears.
Soon, Beni and Elena’s friendship turns into more, thanks to the matchmaking meddling of a Vatican spymaster, a Swiss Guard comrade-in-arms, and Beni’s overenthusiastic yet lovable sister. But then Elena’s past follows her to Rome, putting her in danger that even Beni may not be able to save her from. And if Beni wants to be with Elena, he’ll need to discern where his own future lies—and reconcile with his father after years of bitterness. Can the two forge a relationship strong enough to withstand the suffering that comes their way? Or will the tensions of their own lives pull them apart?
302 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 15, 2024
9 people are currently reading
240 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 44 reviews
August 14, 2025
Love in the Eternal City by Rebecca W. Martin
4.5 Stars
Blog Post: https://bookloveramanda.blogspot.com/...
This was a beautiful read. A book club read with my sweet friend Tammy, @protagonistpub on YouTube! While I am not Catholic, I really appreciated how the Catholic Faith was very beautifully portrayed and the characters endured real life struggles and this book is not short of emotional depth. You can see how much the characters love the Lord and how important their faith is to them.
We follow Elena, an American who is struggling with a lot of personal issues after her engagement ends. She leaves her home in the states and travels to Rome where she works closely with the Vatican. This feels like a fresh, new beginning for Elena. Here, she meets Benedikt (Beni) who is a member of the Swiss Guard and she becomes friends with Beni's sister, Reni. We see how Beni and Elena's friendship turns into more and its a very sweet romance. Beni is such a great guy and he truly cares for Elena, I loved that. He loves her for who she is, and will protect her at all costs when her past shows up in Rome and puts her in a bit of danger.
Overall, I am so glad to have read this book - physically and slowly. Sitting with this book a few chapters at a time each day was the best. There was some humor, light hearted romance, sweet words, true love, faith elements and the city truly comes to life on page. Romances have become frustrating to me as of late and this has ALL the depth I needed!
I also love that this is one of my friend's Tammy's favorite books and it was her birthday month! Perfectly fitting for me to finish the week of her birthday!
p.s. I love that Elena is described as plus size, as someone who is also plus size, much of her emotions were relatable.
"Forever toward eternity."
4.5 Stars
Blog Post: https://bookloveramanda.blogspot.com/...
This was a beautiful read. A book club read with my sweet friend Tammy, @protagonistpub on YouTube! While I am not Catholic, I really appreciated how the Catholic Faith was very beautifully portrayed and the characters endured real life struggles and this book is not short of emotional depth. You can see how much the characters love the Lord and how important their faith is to them.
We follow Elena, an American who is struggling with a lot of personal issues after her engagement ends. She leaves her home in the states and travels to Rome where she works closely with the Vatican. This feels like a fresh, new beginning for Elena. Here, she meets Benedikt (Beni) who is a member of the Swiss Guard and she becomes friends with Beni's sister, Reni. We see how Beni and Elena's friendship turns into more and its a very sweet romance. Beni is such a great guy and he truly cares for Elena, I loved that. He loves her for who she is, and will protect her at all costs when her past shows up in Rome and puts her in a bit of danger.
Overall, I am so glad to have read this book - physically and slowly. Sitting with this book a few chapters at a time each day was the best. There was some humor, light hearted romance, sweet words, true love, faith elements and the city truly comes to life on page. Romances have become frustrating to me as of late and this has ALL the depth I needed!
I also love that this is one of my friend's Tammy's favorite books and it was her birthday month! Perfectly fitting for me to finish the week of her birthday!
p.s. I love that Elena is described as plus size, as someone who is also plus size, much of her emotions were relatable.
"Forever toward eternity."
August 19, 2024
Contemporary Catholic romances are my thing, and I'm always elated to read more of them, especially well-written ones. Catholics doing normal Catholic stuff paired with all of the history and intrigue associated with the Swiss Guard is a winning combination, and Love in the Eternal City, Rebecca Martin's debut novel, is a story I'm happy to recommend!
This first in a series of Swiss Guard romances, it has an outstanding setting that serves as a character in its own right. I felt like a Roman tourist with a private guide.
The story combines a realistic treatment of modern personal, familial, and relationship issues with espionage and suspense. There's a little something for everyone.
This first in a series of Swiss Guard romances, it has an outstanding setting that serves as a character in its own right. I felt like a Roman tourist with a private guide.
The story combines a realistic treatment of modern personal, familial, and relationship issues with espionage and suspense. There's a little something for everyone.
August 9, 2024
When I learned about this book's existence, I thought "oh cool, I like romcoms and I've only ever read like one Catholic one, maybe I'll check it out."
Then I read it.
I melted a million times, cried, laughed, and lay awake for half an hour after finally putting my phone down at midnight (and I have a baby who doesn't sleep through the night, so that's saying something), smiling uncontrollably over how much I adore this book. I'm pretty sure haven't fallen in love with a book so hard since The Lord of the Rings.
First and foremost, I was not expecting the mental health arc, and it was OH so good. Perfectly realistic, relatable in parts, and even helped me see some people in my life in a new way.
Then the characters' faith, so beautifully represented and an incredible witness to the richness and depth of the Catholic Faith. It was seamlessly woven into the story, never preachy, and truly inspiring. The redemption and healing arcs were so moving!
All the characters, adorable and perfectly lovable. The Monsignor? The POPE??? (Side note, one chapter is entitled "If You Give the Pope a Pinecone", which I feel is important.)
The humour—I highlighted a bunch of lines on my Kindle, which I NEVER do:
'Beni has to pry my fingers off his waist. Mid-travel, I went from hands-off to hands very much on. I probably gave him an accidental Heimlich maneuver.'
“You are an empty-headed buffoon,” Oscar says in the tone of someone reciting a shopping list. “You have the brain of a sea slug and less common sense than a rabbit. Your reputation is doomed to be lower than dirt, and the best future you can hope for is as a garbage collector for a scientific base at the South Pole. There, I’ve forestalled your self-flagellation.”
“Oh, your son provides some excellent amenities,” I blurt out. “Have you seen his muscles?”
'“Andiamo! Get to the hospital, he’s losing consciousness,” Monsignor Mercadante yells and slams the door shut.' (spoiler alert, he is not losing consciousness)
In conclusion, if you want the best book you will ever read, go get this one without delay. It's light enough to enjoy when you're tired, but with plenty of depth. I'm getting a print copy as soon as it releases, and I'm gonna reread it so many times it's not even funny. (The book is, though.)
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher; all opinions are my own.
Then I read it.
I melted a million times, cried, laughed, and lay awake for half an hour after finally putting my phone down at midnight (and I have a baby who doesn't sleep through the night, so that's saying something), smiling uncontrollably over how much I adore this book. I'm pretty sure haven't fallen in love with a book so hard since The Lord of the Rings.
First and foremost, I was not expecting the mental health arc, and it was OH so good. Perfectly realistic, relatable in parts, and even helped me see some people in my life in a new way.
Then the characters' faith, so beautifully represented and an incredible witness to the richness and depth of the Catholic Faith. It was seamlessly woven into the story, never preachy, and truly inspiring. The redemption and healing arcs were so moving!
All the characters, adorable and perfectly lovable. The Monsignor? The POPE??? (Side note, one chapter is entitled "If You Give the Pope a Pinecone", which I feel is important.)
The humour—I highlighted a bunch of lines on my Kindle, which I NEVER do:
'Beni has to pry my fingers off his waist. Mid-travel, I went from hands-off to hands very much on. I probably gave him an accidental Heimlich maneuver.'
“You are an empty-headed buffoon,” Oscar says in the tone of someone reciting a shopping list. “You have the brain of a sea slug and less common sense than a rabbit. Your reputation is doomed to be lower than dirt, and the best future you can hope for is as a garbage collector for a scientific base at the South Pole. There, I’ve forestalled your self-flagellation.”
“Oh, your son provides some excellent amenities,” I blurt out. “Have you seen his muscles?”
'“Andiamo! Get to the hospital, he’s losing consciousness,” Monsignor Mercadante yells and slams the door shut.' (spoiler alert, he is not losing consciousness)
In conclusion, if you want the best book you will ever read, go get this one without delay. It's light enough to enjoy when you're tired, but with plenty of depth. I'm getting a print copy as soon as it releases, and I'm gonna reread it so many times it's not even funny. (The book is, though.)
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher; all opinions are my own.
July 12, 2024
Let me say, first and foremost, that I am not usually a romcom reader. I’m not sure why, but that genre just hasn’t grabbed me in the past. But this book! This book absolutely, 100% grabbed me. This book deserves all the exclamation points, all the praise, and all the emphasis on the genuine delight of this story and characters! “Love in the Eternal City” is a new favorite; it will be a comfort read for me, one I’ll return to time and again. The setting — Rome sweet home — is perfect, and the author describes everything in a way that so clearly echoes lived experience and excellent research. Throughout the novel, and in various locales around the Eternal City, there’s a steady, realistic sense of place. On a related note, the bits and pieces of information about the Swiss Guards, Church history, and the like were both interesting and organic to the flow of the plot. This is a story that feels truly, authentically Catholic, and not just because of the setting. The main characters, Beni and Elena, are authentic, multifaceted, and strong in their faith; their friendship and love story is the kind of literary example I’d like to see more often. They’re written as real people with real baggage, but with the moral backbone to pursue virtue and the good nature to see the lighter side of life along the way. I also appreciated and related to plot points involving past mistakes/trials, mental health struggles, and the necessity of trust in God’s plan no matter what. The story has well-crafted themes, but at the same time, it doesn’t try to say everything about everything (which is a very good thing). Instead, the author tells the story in a way that’s always engaging, heartfelt, and meaningful — and the result is a wonderful novel that will certainly be loved by newcomers to the genre (like myself) as well as long-time romcom fans. I can’t wait to see what’s next for this series!
*I voluntarily read and reviewed a copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.*
*I voluntarily read and reviewed a copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.*
August 30, 2024
I'm calling this a review, but it's really a love letter to this amazing Catholic romance. Every so often, I read a book that feels like it was written just for me, and LOVE IN THE ETERNAL CITY is one of those. From beginning to end, I love everything about this book.
The main characters, Elena and Beni, are wonderfully believable protagonists who are devoted to their faith and yet have realistic flaws and problems to work through. They were easy to root for and so sympathetic.
The supporting characters are so well-developed, and they support not just the plot but the characters as people. There is a warm sense of community that permeates the world of the story. I especially love the Pope character, who is young, spry, and a bit mischievous in the name of serving the Lord and his people.
The pieces of the story involving the activities of the Swiss Guard were interesting and often suspenseful. Multiple times during Beni's chapters, I gasped out loud - a true sign that a book is going to be a favorite.
I also loved the setting. I've never been to Rome or Vatican City, so I was excited by the armchair traveling I was able to do through the experiences of the characters.
There are so few Catholic romances out there. To have one that is not only true to the faith but so beautifully plotted and well-written is such a gift.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Chrism Press. I was not required to provide a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
The main characters, Elena and Beni, are wonderfully believable protagonists who are devoted to their faith and yet have realistic flaws and problems to work through. They were easy to root for and so sympathetic.
The supporting characters are so well-developed, and they support not just the plot but the characters as people. There is a warm sense of community that permeates the world of the story. I especially love the Pope character, who is young, spry, and a bit mischievous in the name of serving the Lord and his people.
The pieces of the story involving the activities of the Swiss Guard were interesting and often suspenseful. Multiple times during Beni's chapters, I gasped out loud - a true sign that a book is going to be a favorite.
I also loved the setting. I've never been to Rome or Vatican City, so I was excited by the armchair traveling I was able to do through the experiences of the characters.
There are so few Catholic romances out there. To have one that is not only true to the faith but so beautifully plotted and well-written is such a gift.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Chrism Press. I was not required to provide a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
January 5, 2026
I read a couple chapters on and off over the last couple months and really enjoyed it, but then came New Years Eve (a day reserved for tenderly reminiscing on the year) and once I got a cappuccino in my hand the rest of the pages just flew.
Hallmark movie + the Catholic faith = this book. It’s the best kind of cheesy and it really is a beautiful love story (Yes, an American girl leaves her small Midwest town for the big city and yes, that big city is Rome and yes, she falls for a Swiss guard, what about it?), it’s also lighthearted but grounded in real life struggles. The two main characters/lovebirds take turns narrating each chapter, which I would call whiplash in a good way (plus I’m nosy and I want to hear both of their points of view). Dare I say, a reading renaissance is on the horizon in 2026, and this book may have sparked it ✨
Hallmark movie + the Catholic faith = this book. It’s the best kind of cheesy and it really is a beautiful love story (Yes, an American girl leaves her small Midwest town for the big city and yes, that big city is Rome and yes, she falls for a Swiss guard, what about it?), it’s also lighthearted but grounded in real life struggles. The two main characters/lovebirds take turns narrating each chapter, which I would call whiplash in a good way (plus I’m nosy and I want to hear both of their points of view). Dare I say, a reading renaissance is on the horizon in 2026, and this book may have sparked it ✨
August 28, 2024
Love in the Eternal City was a fun ride through the streets and sites of the Vatican, many of which I hadn't even heard of. For example, who knew there was a Death Star in Vatican City? The romance of this story was a wonderful blend of rom-com and romantic suspense, all based in Catholicism which I absolutely loved. Faith in Christ was woven throughout the novel, showing both its importance and also the frustrations and doubts even the most devout person can experience. It certainly dug deeper emotionally than the typical rom-com with the thread of cyberstalking and mental health. Rebecca W. Martin portrayed the signs of depression realistically and with compassion, showing how often the person experiencing depression doesn't even realize that's what they're experiencing. Overall, a great read and I'm looking forward to the sequel.
September 5, 2024
After seeing quotes from Love in the Eternal City circulating on social media, I knew I had to pick up this book, and Rebecca’s debut novel did not disappoint.
Love in the Eternal City is a captivating tale, written from a Catholic perspective, that is set against the stunning backdrop of Rome. Though I’ve never been to Europe, let alone Rome, the vivid descriptions in this book have sparked a deep desire to explore the ancient beauty of the city for myself.
The story follows Elena, an American who has been jilted and is struggling with personal issues. Seeking a fresh start, she arrives in Rome, where she meets Benedikt, a handsome Swiss Guard with a beautiful heart and a complex family dynamic. The romance that blossoms between them is both heartwarming and intricately woven into the charm and history of Rome.
Rebecca’s ability to bring the Eternal City to life through her writing, combined with the emotional depth of Elena and Benedikt’s journey, makes this a must-read. If you’re looking for a love story that will transport you to the streets of Rome and is filled with faith and some real emotion, look no further. This book is the perfect escape and inspirational read for anyone.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book, but the views and opinions are my own.
Love in the Eternal City is a captivating tale, written from a Catholic perspective, that is set against the stunning backdrop of Rome. Though I’ve never been to Europe, let alone Rome, the vivid descriptions in this book have sparked a deep desire to explore the ancient beauty of the city for myself.
The story follows Elena, an American who has been jilted and is struggling with personal issues. Seeking a fresh start, she arrives in Rome, where she meets Benedikt, a handsome Swiss Guard with a beautiful heart and a complex family dynamic. The romance that blossoms between them is both heartwarming and intricately woven into the charm and history of Rome.
Rebecca’s ability to bring the Eternal City to life through her writing, combined with the emotional depth of Elena and Benedikt’s journey, makes this a must-read. If you’re looking for a love story that will transport you to the streets of Rome and is filled with faith and some real emotion, look no further. This book is the perfect escape and inspirational read for anyone.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book, but the views and opinions are my own.
August 29, 2024
Wow! a book about adults actually intentionally dating! A miracle!
The author’s website describes this book as “virtuous fluff” and honestly that’s the perfect description. It’s fluffy. It’s a romance. Almost everything is perfect with clearly defined problems to face, and then we get a great happy ending. (that’s what we want and need sometimes) but it’s also so wonderfully wholesome and cute! And this is a kissing book! It’s not a prudish, restrictive, “we can’t touch each other” story. It’s just life! Plus some adventures (I gasped out loud once - SO exciting!) so it’s not just romance romance romance, but also life stuff like jobs, and also spies, hand to hand combat, secret missions, and intrigue!
All of the side characters are absolute gems (the Pope makes a few cameos! And I think he’s from Texas?!?)
Special shout out to the card game euchre. (hey Midwest friends!)
Also there is a playlist that goes with the book. How cute is that?! And it’s GOOD.
It has everything from the Beatles to JJ Heller to Gloria Gaynor, and the “Both sides now” duet with Josh Groban and Sara Bareilles I never knew I needed.
I got a complimentary copy of this book from the publishers. All opinions are my own.
The author’s website describes this book as “virtuous fluff” and honestly that’s the perfect description. It’s fluffy. It’s a romance. Almost everything is perfect with clearly defined problems to face, and then we get a great happy ending. (that’s what we want and need sometimes) but it’s also so wonderfully wholesome and cute! And this is a kissing book! It’s not a prudish, restrictive, “we can’t touch each other” story. It’s just life! Plus some adventures (I gasped out loud once - SO exciting!) so it’s not just romance romance romance, but also life stuff like jobs, and also spies, hand to hand combat, secret missions, and intrigue!
All of the side characters are absolute gems (the Pope makes a few cameos! And I think he’s from Texas?!?)
Special shout out to the card game euchre. (hey Midwest friends!)
Also there is a playlist that goes with the book. How cute is that?! And it’s GOOD.
It has everything from the Beatles to JJ Heller to Gloria Gaynor, and the “Both sides now” duet with Josh Groban and Sara Bareilles I never knew I needed.
I got a complimentary copy of this book from the publishers. All opinions are my own.
January 31, 2025
(Full disclosure: I was gifted this book) It took me a while to write a review because I wanted to do it the ‘right’ way. There is no right way. When the author gave me this book, I thanked her but told her I wasn’t sure if I was going to read it. I am not the biggest fan of rom-coms. I did, after a few weeks, decide to give it a go and I am SO GLAD I did. This book is not just a cozy, cutesy read, but deals with some complex issues such as past abuse, body image, and mental health. It is done in such a fantastic way. I also realized something I think I am going to value in future books I read, the romance in this book reminds me of my relationship with my husband. The aspects that made me swoon were not in a way that made me fall for Beni, but in a way that reminded me of the wonderful things my husband does for me. I am happily, and patiently, waiting for the next installment in this world Rebeca has created.
September 29, 2024
I liked the concept of this book, and I loved all the Rome references and it was such a nice change of pace to read a romance written by a Catholic, but... Ugh. I didn't love it. The main characters were lame (dramatic emotions much?), I much preferred the supporting characters, and I didn't enjoy the writing. It wasn't smooth. I'd like to read this author's 5th book, she has potential. This one was just a hard read for me.
September 3, 2024
I would give this one a 2.5/5 stars.
I was really intrigued and excited about a Catholic romance. That aspect I loved about it, the faith so intertwined.
However, this book was too cheesy for me. It was too much at times.
I was really intrigued and excited about a Catholic romance. That aspect I loved about it, the faith so intertwined.
However, this book was too cheesy for me. It was too much at times.
September 1, 2025
And this, ladies and gentlemen, is how you write a relatable contemporary romance with plentiful, organic, and authentic expressions of faith. While the narrative is told from a Catholic perspective, I think many Protestants will also find this a truly rich and satisfying read.
January 26, 2025
Just the rom-com Saturday read I needed. A joyful and raw and did I say delightful? read with romance and real struggle and some Rome. Go read it for yourself.
August 16, 2025
4.5 ⭐️loved it!
August 31, 2024
I don’t know if I have adequate words to describe how and why I loved this book so much.
There are so many things about it! So, I’ll start;
The setting: personally, it's my favorite: Rome. God’s providence allowed me to live 9 blissful years in the Eternal City. And the way she describes it is so vivid, that I felt transported there. So real, I could almost taste the gelato and the pasta! Love Italian food! And I didn't need pictures to imagine perfectly well each scene and the beautiful places they visited.
The characters: Elena Gattino, an American girl with a broken heart, struggling with anxiety and depression that travels to Rome in need of a fresh start. Benedikt (Beni), a handsome Swiss Guard that has always lived trying to meet his father’s professional expectations but feels he has failed miserably. They both were lovable and relatable characters, especially because of their flaws. Anxiety and depression are not easy themes to approach and I think the author managed it tastefully and realistically. Having experienced this, I felt so connected to her. Elena also struggled with self-esteem and feeling good in her own skin because of having some extra weight. I love how she handles it and I love how Beni is attracted to her and loves her as she is! Beni’s struggles are also relatable: the pressure of being what your parents expect of you while trying to discover who you really area and what you really want. I loved how he falls for Elena, and the patience and gentleness he has with her knowing her background, and his protectiveness was swooning. The romance was truly sweet and clean! Also, the lives of Swiss Guards have always intrigued me, so this was a wonderful insight into a type of men I truly admire. The side characters are endearing as well, I loved Ri (Beni’s stepsister and Elena’s new bff) and her enthusiasm, Oscar (Beni’s comrade and bff) with his funny banter, the Vatican matchmaker’s (you’ll know who they are), and even the fictional Pope was so down to earth and humorous.
The plot: is totally captivating and enjoyable. It has a mix of drama and lightheartedness, and what made it even more engaging was the spy, political -with a touch of mafia- and international intrigue. I literally couldn’t put the book down. The danger Elena’s ex-fiancé posed also made it more mysterious.
Inspirational message: I loved how the characters lived their faith so naturally. I’m catholic and I just love Christian fiction in general, but I haven’t found that many catholic authors for fiction, historical or contemporary, so this was an amazing discovery. I also think this story can perfectly be appreciated by any Christian, or any person with another faith, or without one.
I can’t believe this story is the author’s debut novel, it is that well written.
Highly recommended. I’m so happy to learn this will continue as a series, I can’t wait for the next book to come out! Hopefully, Ri and Oscar’s story!
I received a complimentary copy from the Publisher but wasn’t required to post a positive review. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
There are so many things about it! So, I’ll start;
The setting: personally, it's my favorite: Rome. God’s providence allowed me to live 9 blissful years in the Eternal City. And the way she describes it is so vivid, that I felt transported there. So real, I could almost taste the gelato and the pasta! Love Italian food! And I didn't need pictures to imagine perfectly well each scene and the beautiful places they visited.
The characters: Elena Gattino, an American girl with a broken heart, struggling with anxiety and depression that travels to Rome in need of a fresh start. Benedikt (Beni), a handsome Swiss Guard that has always lived trying to meet his father’s professional expectations but feels he has failed miserably. They both were lovable and relatable characters, especially because of their flaws. Anxiety and depression are not easy themes to approach and I think the author managed it tastefully and realistically. Having experienced this, I felt so connected to her. Elena also struggled with self-esteem and feeling good in her own skin because of having some extra weight. I love how she handles it and I love how Beni is attracted to her and loves her as she is! Beni’s struggles are also relatable: the pressure of being what your parents expect of you while trying to discover who you really area and what you really want. I loved how he falls for Elena, and the patience and gentleness he has with her knowing her background, and his protectiveness was swooning. The romance was truly sweet and clean! Also, the lives of Swiss Guards have always intrigued me, so this was a wonderful insight into a type of men I truly admire. The side characters are endearing as well, I loved Ri (Beni’s stepsister and Elena’s new bff) and her enthusiasm, Oscar (Beni’s comrade and bff) with his funny banter, the Vatican matchmaker’s (you’ll know who they are), and even the fictional Pope was so down to earth and humorous.
The plot: is totally captivating and enjoyable. It has a mix of drama and lightheartedness, and what made it even more engaging was the spy, political -with a touch of mafia- and international intrigue. I literally couldn’t put the book down. The danger Elena’s ex-fiancé posed also made it more mysterious.
Inspirational message: I loved how the characters lived their faith so naturally. I’m catholic and I just love Christian fiction in general, but I haven’t found that many catholic authors for fiction, historical or contemporary, so this was an amazing discovery. I also think this story can perfectly be appreciated by any Christian, or any person with another faith, or without one.
I can’t believe this story is the author’s debut novel, it is that well written.
Highly recommended. I’m so happy to learn this will continue as a series, I can’t wait for the next book to come out! Hopefully, Ri and Oscar’s story!
I received a complimentary copy from the Publisher but wasn’t required to post a positive review. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
October 19, 2024
4 stars
This book came very highly recommended to me from a writer friend, so I decided to give it a try despite being disappointed by Catholic contemporary fiction in the past. I'm super glad to report that I have very little to complain about.
First off, super well-written. The flow of the words and the narration of the story were easy to read, and relatable, too. I liked how Martin included the self-doubt aspect and interior prayer in a way that didn't feel uber preachy. We're human, so I think she showed those two things and paired them fairly naturally. It was also nice to feel like we could transport to Rome or reminisce about the Midwest with Elena as we read her story. And Benedikt is basically a dreamboat - serious in matters of the faith and the heart.
This wasn't quite the story I was expecting, but I don't think I can hold that against the book. But since it was a different story than I was imagining the plot twists and turns made the story feel very long. And sometimes I couldn't quite suspend my disbelief (that seems to be a problem for me, lately), so I felt like some of the directions the plot went down were unrealistic. However, I plan to reread in the future and give the whole thing another chance rather than let those things downgrade the book itself.
I did, however, feel like the romance occurred very quickly. I know that happens for some people - things just click - but it kind of felt like the story too obviously put the two together. I don't know if I'm being fair with that observation, but I would have liked a bit more pre-relationship moments and fewer during-relationship drama. I can see how the during-relationship drama is realistic, but I wanted more building up to a relationship to make it feel like the two had a little more to stand on than instant, mutual attraction.
Anyway, those are my thoughts for now. I'll likely have more to add when I reread. Until then, I would recommend giving this one a chance. It blows the other Catholic contemporary book I read out of the water.
This book came very highly recommended to me from a writer friend, so I decided to give it a try despite being disappointed by Catholic contemporary fiction in the past. I'm super glad to report that I have very little to complain about.
First off, super well-written. The flow of the words and the narration of the story were easy to read, and relatable, too. I liked how Martin included the self-doubt aspect and interior prayer in a way that didn't feel uber preachy. We're human, so I think she showed those two things and paired them fairly naturally. It was also nice to feel like we could transport to Rome or reminisce about the Midwest with Elena as we read her story. And Benedikt is basically a dreamboat - serious in matters of the faith and the heart.
This wasn't quite the story I was expecting, but I don't think I can hold that against the book. But since it was a different story than I was imagining the plot twists and turns made the story feel very long. And sometimes I couldn't quite suspend my disbelief (that seems to be a problem for me, lately), so I felt like some of the directions the plot went down were unrealistic. However, I plan to reread in the future and give the whole thing another chance rather than let those things downgrade the book itself.
I did, however, feel like the romance occurred very quickly. I know that happens for some people - things just click - but it kind of felt like the story too obviously put the two together. I don't know if I'm being fair with that observation, but I would have liked a bit more pre-relationship moments and fewer during-relationship drama. I can see how the during-relationship drama is realistic, but I wanted more building up to a relationship to make it feel like the two had a little more to stand on than instant, mutual attraction.
Anyway, those are my thoughts for now. I'll likely have more to add when I reread. Until then, I would recommend giving this one a chance. It blows the other Catholic contemporary book I read out of the water.
August 18, 2024
Humor, heart, and faith meet in this delightful romance set in contemporary Rome. When Elena, a young American woman, arrives in the Eternal City, dating is the last thing on her mind. She has a new job, new friends, and is determined to make a fresh start after a disastrous former relationship wrecked both her career and her mental health. But then she encounters Benedikt, a Swiss Guard serving at the Vatican, and his bubbly younger sister Rianna. As Elena’s friendship with the siblings grows, she finds herself—despite her broken past—falling for Benedikt’s strong and caring personality. Benedikt is falling for her, too, but he has his own set of struggles: uncertainty about his future and estrangement from his wealthy, demanding father.
As the two begin to navigate a new relationship, they must grow in trust and faith—both in God and in each other—in order to find healing. Fortunately, they have a host of loving friends to support them, including Rianna, Benedikt’s fellow guards, a monsignor who also happens to be the Vatican spymaster, and even the Holy Father himself.
As a reader, I almost never pick up contemporary romance, but I found this book highly enjoyable. It strikes a lovely balance between rom-com humor and the more serious themes of spiritual discernment and mental/emotional struggles. The author’s descriptions of life in Rome are written with great love and attention to detail. Also, the behind-the-scenes look at the Swiss Guards and their daily work is fascinating. I learned a lot about them that I never knew!
In short, this book is a wonderful clean Catholic romance with a lot of laughs, a strong faith element, and even a dash of action and intrigue. It was a light, easy read that left me smiling and satisfied. Highly recommended!
As the two begin to navigate a new relationship, they must grow in trust and faith—both in God and in each other—in order to find healing. Fortunately, they have a host of loving friends to support them, including Rianna, Benedikt’s fellow guards, a monsignor who also happens to be the Vatican spymaster, and even the Holy Father himself.
As a reader, I almost never pick up contemporary romance, but I found this book highly enjoyable. It strikes a lovely balance between rom-com humor and the more serious themes of spiritual discernment and mental/emotional struggles. The author’s descriptions of life in Rome are written with great love and attention to detail. Also, the behind-the-scenes look at the Swiss Guards and their daily work is fascinating. I learned a lot about them that I never knew!
In short, this book is a wonderful clean Catholic romance with a lot of laughs, a strong faith element, and even a dash of action and intrigue. It was a light, easy read that left me smiling and satisfied. Highly recommended!
August 20, 2024
I went into this book not knowing exactly what to expect since it's from a debut author and I haven't read a lot of Catholic romance books, but the cover grabbed my eye and the synopsis intrigued me. I was not disappointed! If you didn't know this was the authors first book you wouldn't be able to tell it from reading it. It was so well done! The setting of Rome made me feel like I was there, visiting the actual places in real life. I loved getting to "visit" Italy for the first time.
The characters were so well written. The romance between Elena and Beni was just scrumptious. I appreciated the fact that Elena isn't your typical skinny heroine. Instead she struggles with some extra weight gain, and the feelings of trying to accept yourself that come along with that issue. I admired how Beni still found her attractive, and how he wasn't perfect either.
I wasn't expecting the mental health angle of the book, but it was very well done and fit in perfectly. The author perfectly captured the struggles that we all go through at times, while still offering hope that it doesn't have to overcome us.
There was also some intrigue and suspense in the book, with regards to Beni's job as a Swiss Guard and Elena's difficult relationship with her ex, Chris. It kept me turning the pages to see how it would all turn out. I loved this story, the characters and setting so much! I'm excited that its the first in a series, though it can easily be a stand alone story as well. I look forward to reading more from this author in the future.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher; all opinions are my own.
The characters were so well written. The romance between Elena and Beni was just scrumptious. I appreciated the fact that Elena isn't your typical skinny heroine. Instead she struggles with some extra weight gain, and the feelings of trying to accept yourself that come along with that issue. I admired how Beni still found her attractive, and how he wasn't perfect either.
I wasn't expecting the mental health angle of the book, but it was very well done and fit in perfectly. The author perfectly captured the struggles that we all go through at times, while still offering hope that it doesn't have to overcome us.
There was also some intrigue and suspense in the book, with regards to Beni's job as a Swiss Guard and Elena's difficult relationship with her ex, Chris. It kept me turning the pages to see how it would all turn out. I loved this story, the characters and setting so much! I'm excited that its the first in a series, though it can easily be a stand alone story as well. I look forward to reading more from this author in the future.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher; all opinions are my own.
September 15, 2024
While romantic comedy is not the first genre that comes to mind, nor to hand, when I am in search of a good novel, Love in the Eternal City provided me a very enjoyable foray into such ranks of novels.
Amid the ranks of rom com, this novel certainly stands out. I am confident that Rebecca Martin presents something better than any popular you will find in mainstream media, offering glimpses of real love rather than modern substitutes. Aside from cringing a bit at the sugar sweet romance, I was thrilled to read a novel that sanctifies human love rather than depreciating it into something merely emotional or physical. It was a refreshingly clean romance!
There is something very hopeful and joyous about Martin’s novel placement in our modern day. I was delighted by the masterful storytelling that made it possible to read a love story which was rather fairy-tale like, despite its setting in the 21st Century. We still need moments to feel like royalty today!
Even better than the skillful weaving of fairytale into the modern was the weaving of Catholic faith and tradition into a lively novel. Readers get to visit the holy places of Rome not only as a reading tourist but with a lively sense of God’s presence in the grand sights. Rather than facing the problems of life and love alone, there is a fortifying presence of the divine throughout.
Altogether, Love in the Eternal City was fun, witty, and good for the soul.
Disclaimer: I was provided with a complimentary copy of this novel so that I might provide an honest review. All opinions and views expressed are solely my own.
Amid the ranks of rom com, this novel certainly stands out. I am confident that Rebecca Martin presents something better than any popular you will find in mainstream media, offering glimpses of real love rather than modern substitutes. Aside from cringing a bit at the sugar sweet romance, I was thrilled to read a novel that sanctifies human love rather than depreciating it into something merely emotional or physical. It was a refreshingly clean romance!
There is something very hopeful and joyous about Martin’s novel placement in our modern day. I was delighted by the masterful storytelling that made it possible to read a love story which was rather fairy-tale like, despite its setting in the 21st Century. We still need moments to feel like royalty today!
Even better than the skillful weaving of fairytale into the modern was the weaving of Catholic faith and tradition into a lively novel. Readers get to visit the holy places of Rome not only as a reading tourist but with a lively sense of God’s presence in the grand sights. Rather than facing the problems of life and love alone, there is a fortifying presence of the divine throughout.
Altogether, Love in the Eternal City was fun, witty, and good for the soul.
Disclaimer: I was provided with a complimentary copy of this novel so that I might provide an honest review. All opinions and views expressed are solely my own.
August 19, 2024
3.5 stars, rounded up to 4.
Confession: I picked this book up for two reasons.
1: That. Cover. LOVE. :) I adore that this style is pretty in/cutting edge right now, and I hope to see it take over more Christian fiction in the near future.
2: Roseanna M. White and her husband are two of the folks behind Chrism Press, so I knew I could go in with high expectations regarding the writing style and quality of story.
Both of these reasons did not disappoint. :) Martin's debut novel is impressive--especially given it's a debut--with both the aforementioned reasons paired with spot-on humor and intrigue. I was very curious to see how everything would pan out, pretty much from page 1, and was pleasantly surprised.
I learned a lot about the Swiss Guards and life in and around Vatican City, especially from a Catholic perspective. Being born and raised Protestant myself, there was certainly a dichotomy there on a few levels--quite the Venn diagram! But I did appreciate seeing and learning from how the MCs incorporated their faith into their everyday lives. Frankly, I feel we Protestants could stand to learn a few things, and I do love to see how liturgy is making a comeback on "our side of the aisle."
This is a clean, fun read that makes me want to visit Rome and eat pasta and gelato!
I received a copy of the book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
Confession: I picked this book up for two reasons.
1: That. Cover. LOVE. :) I adore that this style is pretty in/cutting edge right now, and I hope to see it take over more Christian fiction in the near future.
2: Roseanna M. White and her husband are two of the folks behind Chrism Press, so I knew I could go in with high expectations regarding the writing style and quality of story.
Both of these reasons did not disappoint. :) Martin's debut novel is impressive--especially given it's a debut--with both the aforementioned reasons paired with spot-on humor and intrigue. I was very curious to see how everything would pan out, pretty much from page 1, and was pleasantly surprised.
I learned a lot about the Swiss Guards and life in and around Vatican City, especially from a Catholic perspective. Being born and raised Protestant myself, there was certainly a dichotomy there on a few levels--quite the Venn diagram! But I did appreciate seeing and learning from how the MCs incorporated their faith into their everyday lives. Frankly, I feel we Protestants could stand to learn a few things, and I do love to see how liturgy is making a comeback on "our side of the aisle."
This is a clean, fun read that makes me want to visit Rome and eat pasta and gelato!
I received a copy of the book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
August 31, 2024
What a satisfying read! This book takes the reader on a wonderful journey through the streets of Rome and the Vatican as the characters learn to face life, love, setbacks, forgiveness, and finding the path God has for each of them. The way forward is not easy but realistic so all readers can relate and even learn from the characters. The rich and detailed description transports the reader to Rome, complete with a longing for gelato.
This book has a great balance of romance with real life issues being tackled. Elena needs to deal with mental health issues, brought on by a previous relationship that has threatened so much for her. Beni has so many questions about where his life should be heading and where God belongs in it all. Enter the sigh worthy romance that develops between these two. Rebecca Martin has crafted a wonderful story that inspires, teaches, and leaves the reader smiling after the last page.
This book is written with a Catholic perspective and characters who are actively participating in their faith. It is nice to see faith worked seamlessly worked into everyday life within the pages of this book. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
This book has a great balance of romance with real life issues being tackled. Elena needs to deal with mental health issues, brought on by a previous relationship that has threatened so much for her. Beni has so many questions about where his life should be heading and where God belongs in it all. Enter the sigh worthy romance that develops between these two. Rebecca Martin has crafted a wonderful story that inspires, teaches, and leaves the reader smiling after the last page.
This book is written with a Catholic perspective and characters who are actively participating in their faith. It is nice to see faith worked seamlessly worked into everyday life within the pages of this book. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
July 15, 2024
This story blew me away! I'd never read anything by the author and had to google what Swiss guards were, but it sounded cute and I loved the cover so figured I'd give it a go. (I know, I'm fickle. But hey, in this case, it paid off!)
Not only was the romance beautiful and grace-filled, but the descriptions of Rome, the Vatican and all the history there made me seriously consider adding Rome to my bucket list. It was full of history and depth and moments that just made me stop and think. Alongside the romance and history, it delves into burnout and mental health and the effect they have on relationships, which are so timely and relatable. Beautifully done. The relationship between the main guy and his sister was totally adorable too. I love a good big brother/little sister relationship!
I didn't realise when I was reading it that this was the first book of a series (it could totally be a standalone) but am now very much looking forward to the rest!
Many thanks to the author and publisher for an early copy of this book.
Not only was the romance beautiful and grace-filled, but the descriptions of Rome, the Vatican and all the history there made me seriously consider adding Rome to my bucket list. It was full of history and depth and moments that just made me stop and think. Alongside the romance and history, it delves into burnout and mental health and the effect they have on relationships, which are so timely and relatable. Beautifully done. The relationship between the main guy and his sister was totally adorable too. I love a good big brother/little sister relationship!
I didn't realise when I was reading it that this was the first book of a series (it could totally be a standalone) but am now very much looking forward to the rest!
Many thanks to the author and publisher for an early copy of this book.
September 5, 2024
This was a surprising and yet refreshing book to read. There were several surprising moments in the book that were such a blessing to read. The characters of the book are complex and endearing. What I loved best was the in-depth details of the beautiful Rome. The author did an excellent job describing the scenery, the history and the sanctity of the city. Elena came to the city healing, yet still broken. Benedikt has been living a life as a Swiss Guard who believes in duty and loyalty. When he and Elena meet, Rebecca draws the reader into an instant connection between the two. I think the relationship that was built between Elena and Benedikt seemed so real. I felt what they felt individually and collectively. I cannot wait to read the next installment in the series.
Read
June 11, 2025Had high hopes since I met Andreas Widmer in person and he’s a real life Swiss guard who had a vaguely similar story, and he really impressed me with his intelligence and Catholic passion. Unfortunately, this book for me tried to deal with too many weighty issues-mental illnesses, violence, infidelity, stalking… while I appreciate trying to make it a realistic story, it was honestly often jarring going from idealized Roman love scenes to such dark content, almost felt like trivializing it. Swiss guards are interesting and I appreciate making a heroine with modern struggles, so not bad but didn’t live up to my expectations either.
September 14, 2024
Such a wonderful story. I loved that God played an integral part in the story and that the depth with which we got to know the characters. We were able to see both healing and growth on the part of both Benedikt and Elena. I related to Elena in so many ways. I also absolutely adored the setting. Being anywhere in Italy is a dream book setting for me. Being in Rome was a blast because I was able to learn more about the Swiss Guard and the Vatican that I hadn't known before. Definitely adding a copy of this book to my shelves.
September 15, 2024
I must admit that I've never been to Rome but reading Rebecca Martin's descriptions it was very easy to be transported the eternal city! Both characters are incredibly real and vulnerable. Life is difficult but it is the faith with God that shows how he can guide you to the everlasting love we all seek. I hope anyone who wants to enjoy a lovely stop in Rome and enjoy the sweet romantic journey with Elena and Beni will read this!
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
September 17, 2024
I don't read a lot of contemporary romances, but I was drawn to this one because it was set in Rome and involved the Swiss Guards. I enjoyed the setting, learning about the Eternal City, discovering what life is like for the Swiss Guards, and the closed-door romance. I had a hard time connecting with the female protagonist, but gave credit to her love interest for sticking with her through all her struggles and angst. One quick note, I loved the cover! I probably looked at it a dozen times before I noticed the Swiss Guard peeking out of the doorway!
October 21, 2024
A Catholic romance beach read? Yes, please! I jumped at the chance to read this one.
As expected, it's a cheesy romance, but with characters who value their relationship with God. It had a bit of a slow start for me, but evolved into a page turner in the last half. Overall, it was fun and refreshing.
As expected, it's a cheesy romance, but with characters who value their relationship with God. It had a bit of a slow start for me, but evolved into a page turner in the last half. Overall, it was fun and refreshing.
April 13, 2025
I loved the Catholic themes in this book. It’s like a Catholic hallmark movie. I liked The beautiful descriptions of the city and life of a Swiss guard. 💂♀️
I want to give it a higher rating, yet I thought some of the parts were disconnected. The last few chapters of the book were fast paced and good reading.
I want to give it a higher rating, yet I thought some of the parts were disconnected. The last few chapters of the book were fast paced and good reading.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 44 reviews