First, my thanks to Netgalley and Mad Cave Studios for the eARC copy. This has not affected my review at all, which are my own thoughts.
In Soul taker we meet Amarantha, an immortal creature that lives off the energy force of others. She can pass for human, looking like an old woman and trying to live under her own rules without attracting attention to herself, for she thinks that enemies from her past may still be haunting her down, though she swears she killed them all in the past, when she became the last one of her kind.
I have mixed feelings about Soul taker. Which is something I feel I'm saying about everything that I'm reviewing lately😂 Unfortunately, it is true. With Soul Taker it was because of how the story was told, being a little unbelievable even for a fantasy tale and the characters, their portrayal and development through this first volume, that, if I'm correct, compiles issues 1 to 6, so it is quite the glimpse of the story we get.
So, we start seeing Amara's calm life in the present, with her best friend and a quite boring (compare to her previous) life at the retirement community she lives at. Quite the dream for someone like her that has spent most of her immortal life been hunted and losing loved ones. And, now, that has ended, she's made friends and even found a new possible romantic partner: said best friend. Who is a woman. I want to mention that, because something I can give Soul Taker is originality in its protagonist: a looking-older woman who is attracted to other women, which is something that is not seem much is thy type of more fantastical comics that deal with immortality and/or supernatural forces. So that's a point in favor of this comic. (And if anyone knows of more stories, in whatever format, with more protagonist like Amara, send them my way😉)
Anyway, that's he context Amara live in. Until two things occur: her old enemies, who call themselves the Venatori and are a combination of knight templars bring to the modern world, find her out and send one of them to finally kill her for good and end her kind; and, a pharmacist company gets interested in her, offering to work together to replicate her immortality, which she refuses, 'cause it would alter her peaceful life.
With all that, I think the problem was the structure of the telling events, and the characters themselves. Some times, some thing would be mentioned that pointed to Amarantha's past, and a flashback would get inserted, either a bit before or a bit after that thing got relevant to us, so it could get explained, or we could get a grasp of who some other characters related to Amara where. In my opinion, a couple flashbacks felt force to explain a future character's presence, which I feel could have been done later in the story, when the character have got already revealed in the present and we have been wandering for a few pages what type of relationship these two share; I like to keep the tension going for as long as possible, without overdoing it. And I mention this, because it was what was done with another character, and I think that was well-done; someone that appears to Amarantha as a ghost of her past, and we wonder, until it is finally revealed who she is and what kind of relationship they shared and if your theories are right or wrong.
Maybe other people like it the other way around, to be given the flashbacks first so they know who the characters are when they finally appear, which is completely find. But I like mystery in fantastic tales like the one Soul Taker presents to us, I like making theories and been given bread crumbs little by little until we have all the puzzle pieces and can see the whole picture at the end.
I think this ties with my lack of attachment to Amarantha, so of course I would not care much about her past and whatever characters she has met. Really, by the end of the comic I was only hoping that her friend-turned-romantic-partner would survive the imminent slaughter; the rest of the cast, not so much. Even the Venatori didn't feel that defined; they look and act like the typical villainous group that is hunting down a group of magical creatures/people who they've deemed the monster of the story because...yes? Though Amara makes a point of not consuming too much life force from one person so not to kill them. And the pharmacist that is also following her didn't feel like too much of a threat, even thought I feel like it should have, because they want a youth serum (make through experimenting on Amarantha) for their CEO, who's dying, but the urgency was never felt.
It all felt flat for me. Like, sure, things are happening, Amarantha is reacting to them, and she only makes a decision at the end, when she's cornered. That's probably why I only liked the end too well, because we finally see Amarantha make an active choice for her life, instead of letting her enemies reach and having to defend herself in the battle.
Finally, I want to talk about the art, which I think is something worth mentioning when reading a comic. And that's it, really, common "comic art", not so much detailed, well-colored I'll admit, blending warms with colds to give the sensation of Amarantha hiding something and not being quite human as the people surrounding her, for example. But, it wasn't something I haven't seen before, though it was definitely better than others. I'm going to give a point in the art segment to the issue covers and the extra art at the end of the file: those were gorgeous and kept me staring at them for a while. My congratulations for the artist(s).
To sum up: the premise sounded good, but the deliverance of it wasn't too much different to other things I've read within the genre. At first, it kind or reminded me of The Old Guard: immortal people trying to life under their own rules, except, unlike the Old Guard, Amarantha isn't too up for helping others, but at least she doesn't go around murdering masses, so that's something. And the stories differ, obviously. But, I think, that if you like the Old Guard, the exploration of immortality and an original protagonist to all these mysteries, I think you can like Soul Taker.
And the end definitely calls for a continuation, because that cliffhanger was criminal!