There are a lot of glowing reviews, and there are a lot of angry reviews, both look to have been put up in an effort to counteract each other. As a former superfan of Allison’s since season 2 of SYTYCD (I was crushed when she was voted off and could hardly contain my excitement every time I saw her perform, often moved to tears), a parent, and person touched by grief as a result of suicide, I wanted to offer a review as a human observer rather than a blind fan with unconditional support or hater resorting to cheap shots.
I would guess, 2 years in, Allison doesn’t know how early in her healing journey she really is and will look back on this book with regrets. I think it’s incredibly sad that this is something that she, her children, and Steven’s family (to mention only those closest and most affected) have to contend with forever because, as even Allison indicates, you can’t take words back.
The first half is Allison’s story, the second half is her reaction to Steven’s suicide and sharing of his story. She always brought it back to her and the kids, so she could argue that it’s still her story, but it’s just not true. She has written this book as a testament to how good and strong she is and needs us all to believe it.
There are constant contradictions and verifiable lies through the book such that you have to wonder where the truth lies, if there is any at all. She mentions more than once “both things can be true” about seemingly contradictory feelings, and I agree, but this is not what I refer to. A few examples, both small/useless and big:
1. Allison and dance convention workers take obvious steps to access a roof that she admits is off limits, when the elevator gets stuck she says she’s “such a rule follower that (she) was in a total panic” not wanting to use the emergency phone.
2. Allison claims to have refused an autopsy due to knowing Steven drank and used drugs so heavily toward the end, but his autopsy results were reported publicly and also came back clean.
3. Allison indicates that they often dug deep in their conversations with each other (“so profound was our back-and-forth”), and spoke about direction for their lives as a family all the time, but later mentioned she had “zero interest.. in deep introspective journeys.”
4. Allison’s therapist has indicated maybe she is a people pleaser, but Allison has offered countless examples demonstrating she is not, including a monumental one of rejecting the Mormon faith as a teenager which rippled out in big ways. Professionally, maybe she could be seen to be a people pleaser if we can trust that she was being truthful about not admitting to injuries, meeting expectations when hiding single parenthood, or having to come up with technical knowledge on the fly (on DWTS), and maybe it is also an unavoidable adaptation of motherhood, but I didn’t see much in this book to support this idea.
5. Maybe the worst, most heartless one is that she indicates that she understands that people who die by suicide understand it to be their only option at that moment, but time and again states clearly that in this “most shameful act” he “chose to leave.” This is a glaring red flag of someone who has memorized the appropriate talking points, but doesn’t really understand in the slightest.
(I’ve seen many people point the Xmas tree decorating comment, but this claim is mistaken or blown out of proportion. She has indicated they decorate multiple trees each year and it was the family heirloom tree that hadn’t been decorated, the tree in their social media was generic)
There were moments of discussing some hard moments with her kids that were beautiful: holding space for them through the hard moments, validating their emotions, and supporting whatever they needed to feel on the journey through it all, stressing that it’s her job to equip them with the tools to handle the hard stuff (assuming these moments were truthful). There were also moments where I saw blinders, maybe activated unknowingly in a triggering moment, thwarting this aim: eschewing comments from friends or family members lovingly pointing out echoes of Steven in the kids. Instead of helping them through the hard feelings of accepting those great things even though they still feel anger and sadness, allowing both things to be true, she aims to remove these connections to Steven instead of taking the opportunity to let them integrate the love despite the difficulty.
Speaking of the kids, I worry about them all reading this for different reasons. I wonder if these events or quotes used were ok’d by the kids to use in the book (and CAN they, especially the littlests, know what they’re consenting to?). These are vulnerable moments and, while I don’t know what it’s like to live somewhat publicly, whatever can be conserved of their privacy seems important to respect.
Jumping topics to more general book stuff, I’m unclear how this book came to be green lighted in the first place aside from jumping on a gossip train and selling books due to the expected controversy. This is a legit publisher that most people have heard of and I would have expected better review. Did they not edit for clarity of content? Tone? Vocabulary? Did they not edit at all? This sounds like her when she speaks, so that is authentic. However, this reads, tone wise, as though it is a series of social media posts. Each chapter follows the theme, but there are so many moments that don’t add up to build a cohesive narrative. And the vocabulary choices? Sure, I’m a lover of fancy word choices when applied in the right way, but in this book it came off desperate, to make her sound wise and clever, and some of the words used were clearly not the correct ones. On a few occasions I looked up the words that caused me to question my understanding and found that no, she meant to use a similar sounding word that would have illustrated her thought.
I can’t give any time to hearsay and the controversy, I don’t have any insider information, I don’t know any of these people. Whoever Allison is at her core, she is still human, she loved someone she lost, and everyone deserves some grace. But I am going to offer some “both things can be true” opinions.
I feel truly bad for her. I feel bad that her team, friends, family, therapist didn’t protect her from speaking out as an authority when she isn’t one, when she is so green in her healing that she can’t see that there was nothing helpful in this book. I feel sorry that despite being out of the Mormon faith she still fell into a shame based version of Christianity where her pastor encouraged her to focus more on the sin and shame of Steven’s act than the reality of despair that consumes the person. I see her professional and contrary “I can do it all and nothing will stop me” attitude in this healing journey, now that she has gotten to this benchmark, hit this “expiration date” as she likes to cite, she is healed. But if she can’t adjust her brain and her heart she will be stuck with this anger and judgement forever.
I am also disgusted by her. There is no right way to grieve, but there are many paths, respectful or disrespectful. To feel so emboldened to share your spouse’s alleged trauma (that he did not share) in detail when all of the points could have been expressed with vaguely and in a way that would not have lessened the impact or message is hateful. She also stated early on she wouldn’t be sharing the details her own teenage traumatic experience, but what about those girls who see themselves in Allison? Doesn’t she also want to help them? We aren’t entitled to her (or anyone’s) details, but if her aim is to help people and tell HER story, the contradictions are glaring. She is justifiably angry, no one can begrudge her of that. And suicide is an especially messy grief process for the loved ones left behind. But if this book has any impact, it would likely compound the shame of a suicidal reader who went in thinking her intentions were good, to help, as she stated. She is not intending to help, she is intending to explain how he got it so shamefully wrong and how she, who she called the true victim/survivor of suicide (truly, page 204), is doing it right despite him, the shame he brought on her, and “mess he left (her) with.” If she does not find herself ashamed of this down the road once she’s found many additional layers of grief to emerge from, she is truly lost.