Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
He’s New York’s most eligible billionaire.

And I’ve been hired to find him love.

I’ve built a thriving business doing what I love—connecting soulmates.

So, when a woman begs me to help her father, I’m on the first flight from London.

My track record is flawless.

Until I meet Sterling Beaufort.

Suave. Charming. Devastatingly handsome.

The owner of the world’s most luxurious diamond empire.

But behind the silver fox’s billion-dollar smile is a complex man I’m determined to unravel.

The harder I push, the fiercer he resists.

Until I snap and demand to know why he’s sabotaging his chance at happiness.

He doesn’t tell me…

He shows me.

God, does he show me.

But a twenty-year age gap, a family tragedy, and the fact he’s my client aren’t all I have to consider.

There’s a reason I find love for other people and never for myself.

This time, the universe has it wrong.

Because falling for Sterling Beaufort is the match that could burn everything.

(Perfect for fans of age-gap, forced proximity billionaire romance, featuring a brooding, untouchable silver fox and a fearless heroine who refuses to be intimidated. With scorching chemistry, heartbreaking angst, and a sizzling tension that’s waiting to snap)

446 pages, Kindle Edition

Published March 13, 2025

1593 people are currently reading
1547 people want to read

About the author

Elle Nicoll

25 books1,046 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,427 (48%)
4 stars
912 (31%)
3 stars
456 (15%)
2 stars
108 (3%)
1 star
37 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 290 reviews
December 14, 2025
When you come for one thing but stay for another

First of all, let's all be honest here: That cover? jail.

With that out of the way~

The audiobook became available and I thought: why not? And I'm ✨oh so happy✨ that I did.


───〃⟡ ⋅ Tropes




━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
🕮⋆˚࿔✎𓂃 𝐣𝐨𝐢𝐧 𝐦𝐲 𝐜𝐨𝐦𝐦𝐮𝐧𝐢𝐭𝐲 𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐦𝐲 𝐟𝐮𝐥𝐥 𝐫𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Profile Image for Jamie.
1,122 reviews276 followers
May 21, 2025
I hate dead ex books, but this one wasn’t bad in my opinion. Of course I’d prefer if there was no dead ex, but you can’t always win 🙃 sadly 🤣
Also I’m usually pretty neutral on audio narrators, they don’t usually affect my ratings they’re usually just there to read the book, however I feel like these two narrators did a great job!
Profile Image for Jessica Alcazar.
4,421 reviews629 followers
March 17, 2025
🎧🎧AUDIO REVIEW🎧🎧

I love a good swoon factor in a romance story and The Matchmaker almost broke the equation!! Phew, (*fans self*) this is a story that took me a little by surprise. You see, when I saw the words age gap billionaire, I just assumed that’d I’d be getting the typical billionaire cliché characteristics (you know the ones …), but nope, what I got was complete swoon with a side of dirty sexy that I found hard to put down! I listened to this audiobook in about three quarters of the time an audiobook of this length normally would take. I just couldn’t stop. I was captivated by both Sterling and Halliday as individuals and as a couple. I just wanted more and more of whatever was coming next!

The story had a few subplots related to the MCs but not directly influential to the romance journey which would normally put them in the dramatics category that would make my eye twitch (lol) but they worked with this story. I mean there’s only so much sexy-sexy you can put on the page before a book just becomes porn on paper, so these sub-plots worked as a way to add a little substance to the story.

This story was a triple “new-to-me” situation with the author and both narrators. I can definitely say that I will be looking out for more stories written by Elle Nicoll and the narration by Madison Mitts was really well done. Her voice was “easy” to listen to and she did a really good job with all her voices. I can’t say the same for Theodore Zephyr. *sad face* You know that thing that sometimes happens when we’re telling a story and our breath is an audible escape? Yeah, he did that a lot, and while it wasn’t all the time, it was enough that my eye twitched often. You have to be careful with audiobooks that are longer than about 7 hours because at that point, even the most innocuous thing could completely upend a listener’s experience. *shrug*
Profile Image for Priscilla.
168 reviews3 followers
March 6, 2025
THIS BOOK!!!!!! This book is the grail of all "daddies/silver foxes". This is THE book that broke the mold for age gap, silver fox, daddy.....whatever you want to call it. Elle, you outdid yourself with this one. As my favorite trope (silver fox/age gap) I knew it would be amazing, but I had no idea the Calibur of this story.

In this new series we are introduced to a new set of characters, the main ones being Sterling (MMC/50) and Halliday (FMC/30). Halli is hired by Sterling's daughter to find love for her dad. The moment those two meet, sparks are flying but they don't know why. As Halli continues to find suitable suitors for Sterling, they spark a friendship that leads to feelings. They immediately fall for each other. The way this man is towards the female lead will have your panties soaked.

The voices narrated for these characters was PERFECTION! Theodore Zephyr and Madison Mitts brought those characters to life in a way that no one else could of. Theodore's grovely voice...*fanning myself* and the feminine twang that Madison put for Haliday......standing ovation for both. This audio deserves to be herd by everyone.

Overall, THIS is my top read of 2025 so far and probably will be. I do not know if another book will top it, honestly. This author deserves to be HUGE in her own right. The stories she's come up with, the characters, the writing is SUBPURB. Thank you so much Elle for this one.
Profile Image for serafina.
259 reviews38 followers
July 18, 2025
Everything was ruined when he started to call her “Baby girl”
21 reviews
July 17, 2025
dnf. Could not continue once she started going on about crystals. Willing to try the next book in the series though.
Profile Image for Judy Portelles.
501 reviews55 followers
March 7, 2025
The Matchmaker is an age gap, forced proximity, forbidden and billionaire romance. This is my first book by this author and I’m ooking forward to more in this series. Sterling and Hallie were so hot and good together I couldn’t get enough of them.
Theodore Zephyr and Maddison Mitts did an amazing job bringing these characters to life. Highly recommend listening to the audiobook.
Profile Image for Lola Shug.
172 reviews
May 14, 2025
Ok I know I’m a whore for saying this, but all the sweet talk during the sexy scenes turned me off. Listen I know I need therapy!!! But I was like can yall shut up and just fuck?? I’m a walking red flag I know. I will see myself out 🫡

“Thank you for being so patient.”
I sink down another inch, and his eyes flare with desire.”

“his eyes dropping to where he’s buried inside me. I’d have waited an eternity for you.”

“buries himself inside me again with a rough groan.
You’re everything I gave up hoping for a long time ago.”

“You’re not only my first choice.” I lift up and sink down onto him again. “You’re the only choice I will ever make. It could never have been anyone else.”

Too sappy for me so I had to DNF.


Profile Image for Erin Lynn  Jones.
19 reviews
April 9, 2025
Getting bored with the falling in love after a week of knowing each other.
Profile Image for Hailey Siedel.
484 reviews10 followers
August 6, 2025
I loved this book!!! it was so good! There was not a dull moment! I’m so happy I saw the authors TikTok and decided to read it!

Sterling was so swoon worthy and Halliday was so sweet and cool! I loved both their characters so much! They complemented each other so well! I love how much Sterling loved the crystal she put in his office, how he held it and took it with him when they took a trip!

I really enjoyed the book! My only note is that we never learned his son’s name, the one that passed, I wish we did.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
🌶️🌶️/5
Profile Image for Claire Ingledew.
1,101 reviews13 followers
March 13, 2025
Wow what a book loved every minute of Sterling and Halliday story.

My emotions are shot these two were a delight to read the chemistry between these two was 🥵. I don’t want to spoil it it so I will say is give this a read it won’t disappoint going to have to listen to this on audio as i know it will make the story better

Can’t wit for the rest of the Beaufort series as Sinclair and Sullivan characters had be intrigued

For me its 5 huge 🌟
Profile Image for Ana Decosta.
467 reviews20 followers
July 21, 2025
Yes, the story was hot but why so loooong?
The minute Hallie and Sterling got their freak on it started to drag like hell. How many times do you need to read about how much they love each other? We got the point pretty soon. Same goes with Rory’s shenanigans and Sinclair’s pretend dislike of Denver. I think this story should be cut by at least 40%.
I didn’t think I’d ever say that there were too many sex scenes in the book (!) and I found myself skipping some. This is a first for me, but reading about how they were perfect for each other and always came like crazy was getting boring pretty fast. Btw, how come a 30 years-old uses a chart?! How is this any reliable these days for someone sex-craved?
Drama-parts were not at all dramatic, and I stopped caring about what was about to happen, just went through pages like a boring flyer. Too much insta-attraction and slow pace decided it’s a 2stars book for me. Will still read about Sinclair and Denver hoping it’s going to be a more interesting story.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Nicole Ortiz.
2,076 reviews55 followers
July 7, 2025
Sterling and Holly

I listened to the audio.The narrators did a good job the FMC accent was enjoyable to listen to and the MMC was sexy. The other characters too.

I found this to be a bit of a hallmark movie with some spice. Holly is hired to find a love match for Sterling by his daughter. Sterling has feeling for Holly but tries to fight them off because of the age difference until they can't anymore. Throw in some chaos to the story as their is an I don't know what he was before a friend of a friend takes advantage of Holly in Vegas and then starts blackmailing her. A jealous family friend. Sterling trying to figure out what happened that ended in the death of his wife and youngest son. I would say my only problem was Sterling just keeps throwing money her way from donating to charity in her name to paying people to go away.

I received a copy from Home Cooked Books and listened to it through Bookfunnel.
Profile Image for Andie Jensen .
96 reviews3 followers
May 29, 2025
This was one of my first Elle Nicoll book. I was not disappointed! For those of you who know me I am obsessed with Age gap! This man! Sterling! You made my insides crawl of hotness! The age gap between you and Hallie was sexy and amazing! This book didn’t disappoint.

Hallie you are a strong independent women who helped sterling find someone who ended up falling for him and things turned spicy!

Sterling is considered a sexy, smart man the moment you professed your love for Hallie was the best part of the book. The sexy talk you had made you swoon. Your love for Hallie was sooo sweet! I couldn’t get enough of you calling her “BABY GIRL” ahhhhh *screaming in my head*

I loved the narrators of this book! I have been following these two for a while and when I found out they narrated this book I went crazy! I love this duo! Madison and Theodore are amazing!!
Profile Image for Anita.
1,133 reviews1 follower
April 13, 2025
Loved this book!

STERLING........OMG he is just a dream, I truly beautiful soul that pulls you in. I loved this book so much that I've read it twice and even listened to the audible. I can't get enough of him,
Halliday is perfect for sterling. He knew after their first introduction, she was definitely a gift, his gift. This book is certainly a must-read, and I would highly recommend it. I can't wait to see what Elle brings us next.
Profile Image for Taylor - Shesaysgetbooked.
335 reviews15 followers
March 14, 2025
If you love a fast paced, sizzling age gap romance with an irresistible forbidden twist, The Matchmaker is the perfect read! This story delivers an intoxicating mix of insta love, undeniable chemistry, and a whirlwind romance that will have you hooked from page one.

Halliday, a renowned matchmaker with a talent for finding love, for others, has built a career on perfect pairings. But when she’s hired by Sinclair to find her single father the perfect match, she never expects to be the one falling. Enter Sterling: polished, powerful, and effortlessly charming. A clean-cut businessman with a commanding presence, he isn’t exactly keen on his daughter meddling in his love life. But the moment he meets Halliday, everything changes.

From their first interaction, the sparks are undeniable. Their attraction is instant, their chemistry explosive, and despite every reason to keep things professional, their connection is impossible to ignore. Sterling is decisive, confident, and completely taken with Halliday. He doesn’t hesitate when he knows what he wants. And what he wants? Her.

Elle does not hold back in The Matchmaker. The romance is fast, the tension is intense, and the spice is off the charts.. Halliday tries to resist, knowing the complications of their situation, but their love story is a runaway train…unstoppable, exhilarating, and completely consuming.

If you’re a fan of agegap romances that bring the heat, forbidden attraction that feels deliciously wrong yet so right, and a love story that grabs you from the first page, The Matchmaker is a must read. A perfect blend of passion, intensity, and heart. This book will leave you swooning, fanning yourself, and desperate for more.
Profile Image for Casey (casey_bookish).
97 reviews12 followers
March 13, 2025
Elle Nicoll is an auto buy author for me and she has smashed the start of the new series. I’m excited to see what is going to unfold.

This was a one sitting book. It draws you in and consumes you to your core.
Having the opportunity to both read and listen to this book was out of this world.

Sterling Beaufort is everything we want and need in a man. He’s silver fox personified, protective to his core, gentle, caring and deserves all the happiness in the universe.

Halliday ‘Hallie’ Burton is a strong, independent woman, who has been though so much and still pushes on to keep her sisters legacy growing.

💛 Sterling’s daughter hired Hallie to help find her dad love after the loss he faced two years earlier. What neither of them banked on was being soulmates and falling in love, a love that is undeniably earth shattering filled with an energy that all would envy.

🌶️ The spice between Sterling and Hallie, is scorching, it will burn through your veins. The hot, sultry moments are so heated that you feel like you’re in a fiery inferno. 🔥

@theo_and_madi brought this book to life as Sterling and Hallie and they were perfect, the emotion, tension and chemistry were flawless.

There is no rating high enough for this book, infinity would not be enough. I love this book so much and can’t wait to see what happens next in the series. I already know it’s going to be perfect.

Congratulations Elle, on yet another masterpiece. Your writing is next level.
Profile Image for Jennifer  Hicks .
95 reviews10 followers
March 21, 2025
I had the pleasure of being introduced to Drew Harper in "Handling Mr. Harper" last year and I thought he was a true golden retriever but I believe Sterling Beaufort has him beat.

Sterling is a fifty-year old, widower, who has also lost his son in a tragic accident. When his daughter hires thirty-year old, Halliday to find love for her father, what could possibly go wrong?

My heart went out to Sterling. There was this man who appeared to have it all; wealth, material things, and any woman he wanted. But deep down, he's a grieving man who has never known the kind of love that feels impossible to live without. True, he was married, but they didn't love each other. Then comes Hallie, who is grieving for her sister, she is determined to bring love into Sterling life. To give him that sense of want and belonging he's never felt. The two were perfect for each other.

If you want a sweet, butterflies in the stomach, romance with just the right of spice, The Matchmaker is for you.
Profile Image for Erin Lewis.
6,250 reviews219 followers
July 9, 2025
4 Star Review The Matchmaker (Beaufort Billionaires #1] by Elle Nicoll

Audio:
Elle Nicoll is a new author to me as are the narrators Theodore Zephyr and Maddison Mitts.

This is Sterling Beaufort and Halliday (Hallie’s) age gap romance, a genre that I don’t often read or listen too.

Matchmaker Hallie is hired by Sterling’s daughter to find him a perfect match. However complications arise as the chemistry between Sterling and Hallie is intense.

There were a number of twists and turns that had me wondering if they would get their happily ever after.

The narration by Madison Mitts and Theodore Zephyr brought the characters to life for me. Their voices were easy to listen too and they brought all the passion, drama, romance and angst to their performances. The narrators did justice to the story and characters that the author created.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Katiereadingcorner.
397 reviews18 followers
August 1, 2025
Halliday is a brilliant matchmaker. She’s been hired by Sinclair Beaufort to match her father, Sterling Beaufort. Sterling was married but lost his wife in an accident along with his youngest son, it’s been two years since their death and Sinclair would like to see her father happy again.

Sterling is the owner of the Beaufort Diamonds, he is very family oriented and will do anything to see his children smile. When Sinclair brings him Halliday she tells him it’s his gift, and he likes what he sees.

Halliday believes in crystals and sets them up in Sterling’s office to help calm and bring love to him. One stone in particular she puts on his desk, a rose quartz heart.

This is an age gap romance, Sterling is 50 and and Halliday is 29, but we love an age gap ;)

Halliday has a dilemma when she starts to really like Sterling, but he’s her client and doesn’t want to ruin her business, and Sterling has his children to think about, even though they are adults they are closer in age to Halliday than he is.

We love a HEA and Elle doesn’t disappoint with this matchmaking love story.
Profile Image for Kelsi.
546 reviews27 followers
March 13, 2025
Rating:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️

Once again Elle Nicole has hooked me into a new series with a devastatingly perfect series starter! The Matchmaker was an amazing read! It was the perfect age gap, uplifting, everyone deserves love romance, full of swoon-worthy moments, kindle meeting spice, hilarious banter, incredible friendships, amazingly flawed but love able characters and a plot that showed sometimes we have to fight through some dark days to find love on the other side! Sterling and Halliday were such a perfect couple, they fought for each other, they understood each other, and they understood that the other one was flawed and had been dealt some rough hands and that they were never looking for the perfect person, just the perfect person for them, and their happily ever after was absolutely deserved! I can absolutely say that I will be recommending this book to any and all romance readers and I can’t wait to see what’s to come in this series!

HAPPY READING 📖
Profile Image for Lauren (laurenreads_7) .
157 reviews3 followers
March 15, 2025
Have. Mercy.

Is Sterling Beaufort the ultimate silver fox?! I have loved everything I’ve read for Elle Nicoll but this right here was on another level!!

Nearly 2 years after losing his wife & son, Sterling’s daughter Sinclair decides it’s time for him to fall in love again. She hires to help of matchmaker Halliday and flies her over from the UK to help set up her dad with his perfect match.

Halliday is special beyond words. She’s in tune with the universe and optimistic in ways that Sterling isn’t used to. Halliday feels her world shift when Sterling enters the room and assumes his love match will be an easy one to make.

Little do they know, Sinclair’s “gift”, as she refers to Hallie as, is about to change their worlds.

Things to expect:
Age Gap
Instant Connection
Shared Grief
HEA
No TAB
Story line & spice
Profile Image for Jocelyne.
4,936 reviews22 followers
March 15, 2025
This was my first Elle Nicoll's book, and won't be my last. It's the first book in the Beaufort Billionaires series, an age-gap billionaire romance. Wow! I loved it! Sterling and Halliday's story is passionate, complex, and engaging, filled with tension, drama, mystery, and suspense. The chemistry is sizzling. Halliday, a matchmaker, is beautiful, sweet, and smart. Sterling, a widower, is handsome, enigmatic, and protective. The world building is intriguing. The supporting characters are great. Madison Mitts and Theodore Zephyr did a fantastic job bringing these characters and this story to life. They are both new narrators to me. I loved their voices together. This is a great job author/narrators. I enjoyed it, and I highly recommend it. #HomeCookedBooks
1,856 reviews50 followers
March 14, 2025
Elle is a new to me author and I really enjoyed this story!

Age gap, billionaire and forced proximity are some of my favorite tropes. This story is full of chemistry, banter, swoony characters and a fabulous love story.

Sterling and Halliday are amazing. I love the push and pull between these two. Their chemistry is off the charts!

Madison Mitts and Theodore Zypher deliver a phenomenal performance. Both are new to me narrators and I LOVED their voices. Theodore can read the phone book to me…lol. His voice is delicious, strong and filled with emotion. Madison’s voice is so delightful, playful but also strong. They gave the characters perfect voice, emotion and personality.
Profile Image for Diana Chiriac.
117 reviews2 followers
March 15, 2025
oh Dear, what a ride

I loved this book because it had everything. A little bit of drama, a little bit of nice, A LOT OF SPICE.
I love me a silver fox and Sterling DID NOT DISAPPOINT. My.oh.my!! was he everything I didn’t know I needed.
And Hadley 🖤 witty and sassy and so proper with her client while thinking dirty hot thoughts. Eeeek!!!
Sterling’s journey through grief and the death of his wife and son and gaining the trust to love again 🥺🥺🥺 everything was on point and so powerful.
Loved every detail about these 2 characters small and big, their interaction, their love, everything. 🖤🔥
Profile Image for Emma Howard.
101 reviews12 followers
March 13, 2025
I have been so excited to read this book from when I first heard the plot line and boy it didn’t disappoint. I absolutely loved the story of Sterling and the prologue was emotional but for all the right reasons, I was drawn into his story! Then along comes the love match maker Halliday and her back story (which unfolds through the book) and boom we have a fantastic story with all the feels and an amazing start to this new series by Elle Nicoll. Now the wait for book 2 as I want more from the Beaufort Billionaires.
Profile Image for the endless tbr.
276 reviews12 followers
March 13, 2025
She did it again! Every time I think Elle can not write a more perfect man, she proves me wrong.

This book is the kind of book you devour in one sitting, you just can't stop reading!
I was listening to the audiobook while driving, and I missed 3 exits because I was swooning over this man! I regret nothing. 🤭

Sterling is a gentleman, so swoony, caring, and protective. The way this man loves is unconditional, he is the perfect man.
I was head over heels in love with him since the first paragraph.

Hallie is an independent, confident woman who is hired to find a love match for Sterling, the universe has other plans, and the chemistry and the sexual tension between these two are explosive.

Sterling & Hallie's relationship is beautiful, natural and HOT! They are soulmates, I can not get enough of these two.

The spicy in this book is out of this world, it's sultry, torrid, boiling, scorching, burning, fiery, heated! 😏🔥👌🏻
My poor airpods almost melted it, I am not even kidding.

Theo&Madi Were spectacular bringing Sterling & Hallie to life! It was emotional, hot, and absolutely perfect! This audiobook is incredible, It was a show apart.

I wish I could give ♾️ stars! I am in love with these characters and I can't wait for the next book of this series.

Thank you, Elle for this masterpiece, you continue to surprise me with your writing, it’s so addictive.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 290 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.