For some reason, when this book was announced, I was under the impression that it would be a Little Red Riding Hood kind of story, so when I saw the author describe it as a mix of Gothic Horror, a touch of Buffy the Slayer, and "The Name of the Rose," I groaned. I don't like vampire stories in the least, and I avoid Gothic Horror like the plague, plus I rarely read mysteries.
So everything was stacked against this. And yet, it worked!
Mostly because A. G. Slatter writes beautifully. I've not cared for the topics and subjects she chooses for her plots other times before, too, but her prose, her ability to create atmosphere, to give her characters depth in a few paragraphs is matched by very few authors. Her writing has always drawn me in, it's absorbing, engrossing, and containing pretty imagery without falling into a baroque pit.
So I read this, and liked it fairly well. No, it doesn't mean I've changed my mind at all about hypercompetent assassins and vampires and whatnot; I still don't like this type of stories and I will likely not revisit this. It means I was able to enjoy a plot premise with characters I normally loathe thanks to the author doing a good job. That's what a good author does, grabs you by the arm and out of your comfort zone.
If you asked me what was so good about The Crimson Road besides the writing, I would say it was Violet. You'd expect her to be a walking trope of a trained assassin, and she does follow the expected lines for her type indeed, but she's also fragile and has a richer emotional life that her very restrained viewpoint first leads you to think. She does make a point of being a strong woman without hammering on it each time. If this had been a LRHH retelling, she'd have worked as good with the Big Bad Wolf as she was with the Leech Lords, methinks. You can see the imagery of the fairy tale even though it wasn't intended, it's not that hard to notice when you're familiar with it. It's probably because the author borrowed from Buffy heavily and Buffy has strong LRHH thematic undertones, so strong I'm surprised more fans of the show don't notice it.
You do the symbolism and metaphors right, and I'm a happy reader. Simple, but hard to pull off.
Of course, the book also has flaws. Namely, that the pacing goes from slow-burn for the first half to a tad rushed in the second half. As a result of that uneven escalation, the mystery about Violet's father and brother is taken care of too quickly for my tastes, she takes care of all the Leech Lords fast, and we have a quick reunion with her love that closes the plot with an abrupt end with Violet, Rab, and the child all together. That should've taken at least the entire chapter, not been unceremoniously dealt with in one line or two. Showing a tiny glimpse of the trauma Violet endures instead of developing it a bit more also bothered me, because the early Violet showed so much of her inner world that this hurried closure didn't feel right. It's so annoying when you are treated to a complex, rich character's inner workings only to get mere drops of a conclusion and an That's-All-Folks wrap-up later.
Slatter still has to work on her pacing, I believe. It's been a problem since her first long-form fiction (she does better with the shorties, no pacing problems there), but you can't fault her prose and her worldbuilding. I had no idea this was in the same universe as "The Path of Thorns," and that was an Easter egg I was pleasantly surprised by, because that one was another book I picked up under the mistaken impression that it was a fairy tale retelling and liked it a lot.
That makes it two times that Slatter has conned me into reading her books, ha! It's the vibes, you know? I don't know how Angela does it, but her stories read to me like fairy tale retellings without being retellings. Now that I think about it, I bought the 3rd book set in this universe, which I haven't read yet, also thinking it was a retelling. Three times fooled, indeed, but I am not complaining.
3.5 stars rounded up!
I received an ARC through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.