Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Sea of Exiles

Rate this book
Some bonds are stronger than memory. Some loves are worth burning kingdoms for.

Margot Hawthorne’s life is falling apart. She can barely afford rent. Her nightmares are getting worse, and now she’s waking up in a place where she doesn’t remember falling asleep. But when she goes to bed one night and wakes up in a land of twin moons and shadowed forests, she realizes something is very, very wrong.

Faerie is nothing like the stories. There are no pixies or flower rings or playful sprites. Magic thrums in the air, the land beautiful but treacherous, and ruthless fae hunt the weak like sport. When she’s nearly captured by them—a group who seems to know exactly who she is—she’s saved by a silver-eyed demon with a blade at his hip and secrets carved into his skin.

Cillian is dangerous. Merciless. And her only chance of survival.

Bound by necessity, Margot and Cillian embark on a journey across Faerie to unravel the truth of why she was brought there and why the fae are hunting her. But the more time she spends with him, the more she realizes his darkness isn’t just skin-deep—there’s something deeper, something broken. And something about her is changing, too. Because Faerie is waking something up inside her, something ancient and powerful—something that shouldn’t exist. And as her bond with Cillian deepens, Margot is left with an impossible choice: reclaim the life she lost, or embrace the one fate has written in blood.


Sea of Exiles is a dark romantic fantasy with mature themes and sensitive subjects that may disturb some readers. Reader discretion is advised.

540 pages, Kindle Edition

Published March 13, 2025

45 people are currently reading
183 people want to read

About the author

Paige Annabentleah

6 books17 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
37 (62%)
4 stars
12 (20%)
3 stars
5 (8%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
5 (8%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 33 reviews
Profile Image for Max Busch.
11 reviews
February 19, 2025
I received this as an ARC in exchange for a review!

Sea of Exiles wrecked me in the best possible way. Halfway through the third act, Labour by Paris Paloma started playing, and it was like the final piece clicking into place—this book is all about the raw, unrelenting rage of being a woman in a world that tries to control you.

Paige weaves the world of Faerie seamlessly with elements of our own, creating something both haunting and beautiful. Margot and Cillian’s story is one of love fighting against all odds, of forces trying to tear them apart, only for love to triumph in the end.

And then there’s Nym and Corym—what little we see of their relationship hints at something deep, turbulent, and utterly compelling. Their story is waiting to be told, and I need to know more. Every side character is richly developed, adding layers to an already stunning narrative.

I can’t believe I’m saying this, but this book gets my first-ever 6/5 cats—because whoa. It was an experience, and I know I’ll be rereading this masterpiece multiple times. I need the next book immediately!

Bookcat review: 🐈‍⬛️🐈‍⬛️🐈‍⬛️🐈‍⬛️🐈‍⬛️🐈‍⬛️
Spice: 🌶🌶🌶🌶🌶
Profile Image for L.D..
Author 8 books81 followers
March 4, 2025
After closing my kindle, having read the last pages of Sea of Exiles, I just stared off into space and wanted to cry. Yes, it was that good. There were parts where I wanted to throw my kindle, and there were the other parts where I didn't want the story to end. Margot and Cillian's journey was filled with angst, romance, heartbreak, and a solidarity that can only be brought to life through a deep and resounding love. The pace was fantastic and the adventure was enough to hold me over for a long time! The romance was on point! All in all, I give this book. 6/5 stars 🌟 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟! I highly recommend this read for all romantasy lovers!
Profile Image for Samantha Robinson.
8 reviews
February 18, 2025
**I received a copy of Sea of Exiles to read in exchange for my honest review!!**

Such a fun read - and it was awesome to get to read it early!! I got swept up in the romance, the mystery, and the drama - the writing was so good, and the ending left me wanting more in the best way! So happy to add a new author to my favorites!!
Profile Image for Katie Walker.
2 reviews
March 14, 2025
I received an ARC of this book to read and review. Overall, I enjoyed this book and there were a lot of fun fantasy elements to it. I found for me, the first portion of the book did not flow nearly as well as the latter portions did. If the entire book was written how the last instalment was it would have been closer to a five star read.
Profile Image for Lindsey Gordon.
4 reviews
March 5, 2025
Firstly, a thank you to the author for allowing me to read the ARC of this debut novel. As a reader of many genres, fantasy isn’t always my favorite thing to read but I thoroughly enjoyed this. It took me a bit longer to read than most, only because it didn’t always flow effortlessly for me. The world building and character development were great, however. The ending made me look forward to seeing where Margot and Cillian’s next adventures take them.
Profile Image for Maggie.
13 reviews
Read
March 21, 2025
I'm biased since I created art for the book, but I'll leave a note with some interesting key aspects for future readers:

- divided into 3 parts
- forced proximity
- spicy
- multiple POVs in 3rd person
- themes of memory loss & abuse
4 reviews
March 17, 2025
I received an ARC copy of this book and holy cow I was blown away with how good it was!! It's a fantasy book which I love reading and honestly I was amazed how hooked I was. I couldn't stop thinking about it whenever I'd have to put it down to deal with real life I couldn't wait to dive back in!! This is truly an amazing read and I hope more people pick it up!! It deserves the attention. Well written! Can't wait to read more from this author!!
Profile Image for Dark Bedroom Books.
149 reviews7 followers
April 8, 2025
⭐ 4.5/5
🌶 3/5
“Sometimes the scariest choices lead us exactly where we’re meant to be.”
 
Want to be neck-deep in a story from page one? Sea of Exiles is your ticket.
I had this quiet feeling that this book would be a hidden gem — and wow, was I right! This is the kind of fantasy tale that deserves way more noise!
I've always wanted a rich story tangled up with elves and other magical creatures — and here it is!
Faerie is layered, vivid, and full of secrets. The worldbuilding is lush, the writing flows effortlessly, and the pacing? Rocket-fast at first. The story pulls you through this unique universe before slowing down and going deeper — emotionally and psychologically. It’s hard to even describe in words...
This isn’t a short one, but somehow still not enough. There’s so much more to explore in this world. And the characters? Colorful, complex, and not always what they seem.
Let’s talk romance: it’s deliciously torturous. All the longing, lust, love, rejection, and burning pain your heart can take.
And when your love interest is a General of the Dread Lord and keeper of Olvath’s demonic forces? Yeah… say no more. 🥵💘
This is just the beginning. And I can’t wait to see what comes next. 👀

Fantasy Romance
Forbidden Romance
Magic
Powerful FMC
Memory Loss
Blood Bond
3rd person, multi POV
18+ / TW
Profile Image for Danielle Fekkos-Mendoza.
1 review
April 18, 2025
World building was 10/10! The story moves quickly but doesn’t feel rushed. For me. This was a plus because there was always more to dive into.

Definitely a good book for curing ACOTAR hangover.
Profile Image for Brooke.
223 reviews3 followers
June 15, 2025
God this was so good. I'm gonna need book 2 immediately
8 reviews5 followers
April 16, 2025
This book was wonderful. It was such a different take on faerie and poor Margot was stuck in the middle. This is a darker fantasy story, so read the reviews and blurb to make sure it is for you

For a debut, Paige outdid herself. I am eagerly awaiting the sequel!!!

Profile Image for C.L. Adams.
Author 4 books6 followers
May 13, 2025
Y'all I just got done reading this on KU, and it was incredible. it is the sort of book you want to dive into the next one right away (but it's not out yet 🥺). Meet Cillian and Margot, an adorable Demon x Human couple who really go through some shit. Featuring Lord Dickhead (Vesryn), sweetiepies (Talhsia, Edea), and dumbasses that grow on you (Nym, Corym). Gotta be aware that the villain is actually evil, in a very non-redeemable way.
TWs: gaslighing/manipulation/abuse/literal mindfuckery/SA
Profile Image for Michelle.
67 reviews
March 1, 2025
What a way to end this first book, great cliffhanger! Cillian is by far my favorite character, although Nym is a close second, with a storyline I am dying to read as this series continues. Loved the world building. Can’t wait to read the next book in the series!
Profile Image for Kayla.
28 reviews3 followers
March 7, 2025
In her ambitious debut novel, Paige Annabentleah weaves a spellbinding tale that masterfully blends dark fantasy with romance, creating a haunting and heartfelt story. "Sea of Exiles" marks the beginning of The Exiled Chronicles series, and it's clear from the first chapter that Annabentleah isn't afraid to venture into deeper, darker waters.

The story follows Margot, whose nightmares become a gateway to Faerie—a realm as beautiful as it is deadly. When she finds herself in this dangerous new world, her survival depends on an unlikely ally: Cillian, a silver-eyed demon whose presence radiates danger. What begins as an alliance of necessity evolves into something far more complex as they journey across Faerie, searching for answers about Margot's mysterious arrival and why the fae are hunting her.

Annabentleah's world-building is richly detailed and immersive, creating a version of Faerie that feels both familiar and freshly imagined. The magic system is intricate but never overwhelming, serving the story rather than overshadowing it. But where the author truly excels is in her character work. Margot and Cillian's relationship develops with a slow-burn intensity that will keep readers turning pages well into the night. Their dynamic is complicated by secrets, trauma, and the constant threat of danger, making their growing connection feel earned rather than inevitable.

The prose strikes a delicate balance between lyrical and direct, with moments of surprising humor punctuating the darker themes. Annabentleah doesn't shy away from exploring mature subjects, handling sensitive topics with appropriate gravity while maintaining the story's momentum. The pacing is particularly noteworthy—even in quieter moments, there's an underlying tension that propels the narrative forward.

What sets "Sea of Exiles" apart in the crowded romantasy genre is its willingness to explore the psychological impact of its fantasy elements. This isn't just a story about magic and romance; it's an exploration of trauma, resilience, and the price of survival. The blood bond/fated mates' trope is handled with surprising nuance, adding depth to the traditional fantasy romance framework.

While the novel doesn't reinvent the wheel, it polishes familiar tropes to a high shine. The friends-to-lovers progression feels organic, and the fantasy elements serve the emotional core of the story rather than acting as mere window dressing. The author's background as a dark fantasy romance enthusiast shine through in her careful attention to both genres' conventions while finding fresh ways to subvert expectations.

However, readers should note that this isn't a light read. The book comes with content warnings for mature themes and sensitive subjects, making it firmly adult fiction rather than YA fantasy. The darkness in this story isn't just for show—it's woven into the fabric of the narrative and serves a purpose beyond mere atmosphere.

"Sea of Exiles" is a promising debut that should appeal to fans of Sarah J. Maas and Jennifer L. Armentrout, while carving out its own unique space in the genre. It's a testament to Annabentleah's skill that she can balance the demands of both fantasy and romance without shortchanging either genre. The novel ends with enough resolution to satisfy readers while leaving them eager for the next installment in The Exiled Chronicles.

A darkly enchanting debut that announces the arrival of a compelling new voice in romantic fantasy.

Perfect for fans of:

Dark fantasy romance
Complex character dynamics
Fae mythology with a twist
Slow-burn relationships
Stories that balance romance with solid world-building
63 reviews2 followers
March 4, 2025
First, I want to thank Paige for this ARC and allowing me to go into her world!

When you meet Margot, her entire life feels a lot like how many of our lives go at one time or another. She is working as hard as she can, but barely keeping everything together because her landlord, once again, raised her rent. Everything is feeling hopeless.

On top of all her stress in her life, she also can't seem to get any sleep. These vivid dreams keep her from resting, and in these dreams, she is running for her life. Running from someone chasing her. Everything seems so real until she wakes up in her bed. Again. This has been going on for months, and she is sick of it! This time, she is getting the strongest sleep aid she can find and getting some dang rest!

Again, she lands in these creepy woods, running for life. But this time something is different. She runs with everything she has only to be met by a giant of a man. He helps her escape and tells her that the Fae King is after her and he has all his men trying to find her. She doesn't understand! She is just a plain girl. Why does anyone want to find her?

Welcome to Faerie. Land of the Fae.

There is simply no choice. To get away from these people, Margot decides to join this strange man on his boat. At least Cillian has some experience escaping the king. Since he is in exile from his own kingdom and has been running from the Fae for years. No one could even come close to predicting how this story plays out!

I don't believe I have read such a beautifully written book in a long time! The entire world captivated you with how deep you get to dive into the lore and magical elements. I truly didn't know where this book was going to take me, but I am so very happy I got to experience it. The characters grab you from the beginning, and you get whirled into the mystery, romance, and drama of Faerie. I couldn't put it down. And never in a million years could I have guessed that ending! I need the next book! Now! Please!!
Profile Image for Toni.
2,378 reviews24 followers
March 15, 2025
Margot is having a dream where she is hiding. She's in a forest scene and she hears two men talking about a "her" and realizes that that's her. They say something about her almost being corporeal then head to the sea. She runs into the forest. Then she wakes.She's at work with her boss and friend, Janey. Janey tells her she needs to sleep more. After a conversation Janey suggests she move into an apartment she's fixing up. Just Margot needs to get more rest.After leaving work she goes to get sleep meds. Then home to take one.
When she wakes she is someplace different. Not home. A man finds her and before she knows it she's over his shoulder. They run when it seems someone is chasing after them. They hide and he tells her to be quiet before the fae find them. She senses he was there the other times she was in her nightmare. He takes her and heads to the sea. When they make it somewhere safe he tells her she's in Faerie. She doesn't understand anything. This is only a dream..He lets her know that if she's here then Faerie wanted her here. But she can go with the men from Ravara’s cabal but it would not work out too well for her if she does.
Cillian is a demon, a powerful one, and is feared in Faerie. He was cast out of his home in Olvath because of his radical views. He came through the veil like she did. He explains how she has magic and that Faerie pulled her through to regain it's lost magic. But he is thinking she needs to be away from him. He wants to own her.
So once she figures out she wants to find out what happened to draw her here she convinces him she'll be safer with him. Now they embark on a journey of discovery. Why was she drawn here? What magic does she have? Is magic she somehow took from Faerie in her nightmares or is it something more? And will Cillian be able to find peace.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Selene Evenstar.
38 reviews
February 28, 2025
**I received a copy of Sea of Exiles to read in exchange for an honest review!!**

I was quite excited for this one - I saw the cover and was immediately drawn in by how stunning it looked - it made me think "I must have this on my shelves". This is an interesting first novel by author Paige Annabenthlea. The book has stronger and weaker parts, yet I am giving grace, as I am aware traditionally published novels are quite the collective effort, whereas self-publishing is much more daunting of a task.

To me, the strongest bit of the novel comes in its third part, where the exposition has been mostly pushed through, and the final face-off is going down. I believe the author is very talented in portraying the madness and mayhem of battle and is able to keep you at the edge of your seat for the final resolution. The writing in the third part is vivid and you can almost feel the magic surging off the page. The book ends on a cliffhanger, but this is expected as it is to be a series.

Sometimes the actions of the characters seemed inconsistent to me and the relationship felt a bit too insta-lusty, but slow burns are just a personal preference of mine. I particularly enjoyed Cillian's POV chapters as they felt to be charged with more purpose and felt more concise.

It felt to me like the world itself was created around the characters and not the other way round - sometimes things were happening and the lore was just created to advance the plot - future installments will be even better if more dimension is added to the world, the islands are more developed and elves and fae are given more agency, outside of their respective "kings". I am looking forward to the next installment in the series as it will be an interesting change of scenery and I believe it creates ample opportunity to further explore and develop character relationships in a meaningful way.
Profile Image for Caity.
63 reviews7 followers
March 25, 2025
I would not have guessed that this was Paige Annabentleah's debut novel because it was so well written, I was so surprised when I saw that at the very end!!

I love a good Fairyland is not the place you want to end up story so this book was right up my alley. Margot and Cillian had great chemistry so watching them fall for each other was such a delight. The side characters were pretty cool too, especially Nym, I hope we see him again in the future.

My only issue would be a small pet peeve for me regarding the archery scenes on the boat in the beginning. Why in the world doesn't Cillian get that girl an arm guard?! He must have bought like a million arrows since they are practicing on a boat but no arm guard for the beginner?

That and when Margot keeps coming up out of the cabin when its very dangerous and she is obviously just a liability, but I understand that this is to move the plot forward but gosh darn it it peeves me so when characters get in the way trying to help... its not help if you make more work/cause trouble.

That ending though!! So many good plot points in this story that I did not anticipate that kept me wanting more and the very end I kinda picked up on a few pages before as the author built up to it, but I just can't wait to see what happens next!! Like the ending isn't cliffhanger per se since the first story arc is definitely wrapped up, but I need to know what happens next?!! I will most certainly be getting the next book!

Warning: the author isn't kidding when they say "dark romantic fantasy with mature themes and sensitive subjects" so reader bewared and take that into consideration, its all handled very well imo but don't go into this expecting all light and fluffy romance fantasy.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for jax bailey.
34 reviews
Read
November 1, 2025
So, heeeeere‘s the thing: when I started reading this, I was just looking for a paranormal demon romance. I DID NOT look at the publication date. And I frankly wish I had.

While the story is rich and the characters are plentiful, there were moments when this was difficult to read. I am NOT a fan of non-con. And although there isn’t anything outright, the character has no free will… so if there’s no free will, is there consent? Debatable.

Regardless, I hung through. The battle for Margot and Cillian to find their way back to each other is long and hard fought. And juuuuuust when I think they’ve gotten over the hump, I’m reading the “thanks for reading, don’t forget to leave a review page”. So this is my review. I’m not leaving a rating because right at the moment, I’m still mad at where it ended and that THERE IS CURRENTLY NO BOOK 2.

Will I read it again before book 2 comes out? Will I read book 2? Hard to tell on both counts. But for now, my rating is firmly neutral with the warning of violence, torture, and what is essentially non con. We shall see if there’s more to come for me.

At this moment, though, I’m unhappy that I am currently unable to finish this story.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
9 reviews
March 24, 2025
I received an ARC copy of this for an honest review and I thoroughly enjoyed the story! The beginning of the story did take a little bit to stitch together for me and where the plot overall was headed, but the story ended up progressing nicely and definitely leaves you wanting more. There were a few open door spice scenes, but nothing crazy and definitely not the main focus of the story. I found some of the fantasy elements new and unique the way they were done instead of being very similar to other fae and fantasy stories which was refreshing. The character development is done well for the most part and once through some of the initial muddiness at the beginning, the rest of the story moves at a nice consistent pace. I found the writing style easy to read, but still descriptive enough to provide an image of the world. I enjoyed the story of Margot and Cillian and will definitely be looking forward to book 2 as this does have an ending that sets up for further books!
Profile Image for Andi Downs.
1,459 reviews14 followers
March 8, 2025
This has been the longest book I've read in quite some time and will admit to putting it down at times but still read daily until I had finished it. Our main characters ae a human - Margot and a Demon - Cillian. She finds herself in this different world and through Cillian, manages to survive what the world throws at them. Full of emotion, adventure and dark moments as these two battle the odds against them. One point I will say, there will be more, so don't expect a hea, as those of us who have read this, will looking for, I hope. I'm not a fan of 'cliffhanger' type endings but hope the author will not keep us waiting too long for more of these two and their friends.
I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Carlisle.
13 reviews1 follower
March 18, 2025
I received this book as an arc for a honest review**

This book is a wonderful fantasy story that brings so many fantasy elements into one book. I will say, this book was a great read but the first half of the book was either slower paced or not as fluid as the second half. All in all it is a great read- captivating mmc and mfc, I love their love. It is written in many povs (at the start of the parts it will disclose whos povs we will see) it doesn’t say at each chapter whos pov you will be reading at that time. But being also in 3rd person you do find out fairly quickly- nothing wrong with this, it was just something I haven’t seen before!
26 reviews1 follower
March 12, 2025
Well developed storyline of magic in overlapping realities that will pull you through the full range of emotions. This isn't a quick evening read but will draw you in with a rich tapestry of characters struggling to do what needs to be done in trying times. Trigger warning: Sexually explicit, mature psychological topics and violent scenes.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Barbara.
19.2k reviews8 followers
March 15, 2025
The beginning of the Exiled Chronicles, Margot and Cillian will have a lot to over come as they find out why she was brought to Faerie and who she is exactly. This story is written in three parts, Faerie, Caramis and Downfall. They are joined by Corym. The story held my interest but it ends on a cliff-hanger. This is a new Author to me and is her debut book. I received a copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Aussie.
1,429 reviews37 followers
June 30, 2025
my favourite quote:

" you may not control all the events that happens to you, but you can decide not to be reduced by them " - Maya Angelou

I love the cover so much ! The story was just very addictive and i couldn't get enough of it! The characters Cillian and Margot are a Demon x Human couple which was just so perfect and i love them. I can't wait till i read book 2 and read more from Paige
931 reviews22 followers
March 14, 2025
I could not get enough of this Astounding debut novel! I have now read it 3 times. The beginning sucked me in and I felt like I was along for the boat ride! The world building was so incredibly well done! The spice was amazing. I was left wanting more! I need book 2 at least a week ago!
1 review
July 21, 2025
Extremely well written. Without makes you feel every ounce of Margot's happiness, pain, and paints a vivid picture per chapter. I feel like I'm in faerie. I would recommend this book x 1000 if I could. It's a thick read but worth it
Profile Image for Brianna Whittaker.
11 reviews12 followers
February 23, 2025
I received Sea of Exiles copy for an honest review. I honestly loved the book. Perfectly written. I’ve been in a fantasy kick and this hit the spot!
7 reviews
June 5, 2025
This book was incredible and so well thought out. It had exactly the right amount of spice, tension, and world building. I couldn't put it down! This is a legit page turner.
2 reviews
June 5, 2025
Really enjoyed the characters, world, etc. and think it may be my new favorite book! Can't wait for the 2nd book. Highly recommend.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 33 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.