What do you think?
Rate this book
The Girls of Good Fortune: A Novel
From the New York Times bestselling author of Sold on a Monday and The Ways We Hide
She came from a lineage known for good fortune…by those who don't know the whole story.
Portland, 1888. Amid the subterranean labyrinth of the notorious Shanghai Tunnels, a woman awakens in an underground cell, drugged and disguised. Celia soon realizes she's a "shanghaied" victim on the verge of being shipped off as forced labor, leaving behind those she loves most. Although well accustomed to adapting for survival—being half-Chinese, passing as white during an era fraught with anti-Chinese sentiment—she fears that far more than her own fate lay at stake.
As she pieces together the twisting path that led to her abduction, from serving as a maid for the family of a dubious mayor to becoming entwined in the case of a goldminers' massacre, revelations emerge of a child left in peril. Desperate, Celia must find a way to escape and return to a place where unearthed secrets can prove even more deadly than the dark recesses of Chinatown.
A captivating tale of resilience and hope, The Girls of Good Fortune explores the complexity of family and identity, the importance of stories that echo through generations, and the power of strength found beneath the surface.
She came from a lineage known for good fortune…by those who don't know the whole story.
Portland, 1888. Amid the subterranean labyrinth of the notorious Shanghai Tunnels, a woman awakens in an underground cell, drugged and disguised. Celia soon realizes she's a "shanghaied" victim on the verge of being shipped off as forced labor, leaving behind those she loves most. Although well accustomed to adapting for survival—being half-Chinese, passing as white during an era fraught with anti-Chinese sentiment—she fears that far more than her own fate lay at stake.
As she pieces together the twisting path that led to her abduction, from serving as a maid for the family of a dubious mayor to becoming entwined in the case of a goldminers' massacre, revelations emerge of a child left in peril. Desperate, Celia must find a way to escape and return to a place where unearthed secrets can prove even more deadly than the dark recesses of Chinatown.
A captivating tale of resilience and hope, The Girls of Good Fortune explores the complexity of family and identity, the importance of stories that echo through generations, and the power of strength found beneath the surface.
416 pages, Hardcover
First published May 20, 2025
760 people are currently reading
18118 people want to read
About the author
Kristina McMorris
17 books2,910 followersKRISTINA MCMORRIS is a New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and USA Today bestselling author of two novellas and seven historical novels, including the million-copy bestseller Sold on a Monday and, most recently, the instant international bestseller The Ways We Hide, selected as Target’s top-five reads of 2022. A recipient of more than twenty national literary awards, she previously hosted weekly TV shows for Warner Bros. and an ABC affiliate, beginning at age nine with an Emmy Award-winning program, and owned a wedding-and-event-planning company until she had far surpassed her limit of "Y.M.C.A." and chicken dances. Kristina splits her time between San Diego and Portland, Oregon, where she’s the proud mom of two teenage boys who recently stripped her of her longstanding boast of being “tall for an Asian.” For more, visit KristinaMcMorris.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 577 reviews
May 3, 2025
Moving, gripping, and heart-breaking at times,
The Girls of Good Fortune
by Kristina McMorris is a historical fiction tale of strength and hope. It starts with a chilling prologue set in July 1888 when a woman realizes she’s trapped underground and the door has no handle. While Celia Hart is used to adapting to circumstances due to her genetic heritage, this situation is beyond anything she has experienced. Her memory is spotty, but she knows she must escape as well as regain her full memory to understand what led to her abduction.
The plot is exceptional and filled with events that the author has researched well. It’s also a powerful story of family, identify, love, motherhood, strength, murder, political influence, racism, and corruption. The story goes back and forth between 1888 and 1885, except for the epilogue set in 1995. My main quibble is that this switching of timelines adversely affected the pacing for me until about chapter thirty-two when the story starts with June 1888 and moves forward in time from there.
The author’s note discusses some of the real historical aspects and atrocities contained in the story and there’s a reading group guide that raises some interesting questions for thought and discussion. There are also some recipes included at the end of book.
Overall, this was a riveting, intense, and heart-breaking story that was also filled with hope, compassion, and joy. Those who enjoy historical fiction will likely appreciate this well-researched novel.
SOURCEBOOKS Landmark and Kristina McMorris provided a complimentary digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own. Publication date is currently set for May 20, 2025.
----------------------------------------
My 3.96 rounded to 4 stars review is coming soon.
The plot is exceptional and filled with events that the author has researched well. It’s also a powerful story of family, identify, love, motherhood, strength, murder, political influence, racism, and corruption. The story goes back and forth between 1888 and 1885, except for the epilogue set in 1995. My main quibble is that this switching of timelines adversely affected the pacing for me until about chapter thirty-two when the story starts with June 1888 and moves forward in time from there.
The author’s note discusses some of the real historical aspects and atrocities contained in the story and there’s a reading group guide that raises some interesting questions for thought and discussion. There are also some recipes included at the end of book.
Overall, this was a riveting, intense, and heart-breaking story that was also filled with hope, compassion, and joy. Those who enjoy historical fiction will likely appreciate this well-researched novel.
SOURCEBOOKS Landmark and Kristina McMorris provided a complimentary digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own. Publication date is currently set for May 20, 2025.
----------------------------------------
My 3.96 rounded to 4 stars review is coming soon.
June 2, 2025
Portland, 1888. Amid the subterranean labyrinth of the notorious Shanghai Tunnels, a woman awakens in an underground cell, drugged and disguised. Celia soon realizes she's a "shanghaied" victim on the verge of being shipped off as forced labor, leaving behind those she loves most. Although well accustomed to adapting for survival—being half-Chinese, passing as white during an era fraught with anti-Chinese sentiment—she fears that far more than her own fate lay at stake.
As she pieces together the twisting path that led to her abduction, from serving as a maid for the family of a dubious mayor to becoming entwined in the case of a goldminers' massacre, revelations emerge of a child left in peril. Desperate, Celia must find a way to escape and return to a place where unearthed secrets can prove even more deadly than the dark recesses of Chinatown.
A captivating tale of resilience and hope, The Girls of Good Fortune explores the complexity of family and identity, the importance of stories that echo through generations, and the power of strength found beneath the surface.
I love this author! I really loved her book, Sold On A Monday and I have The Ways We Hide on my TBR.
This was a very powerful story. I love learning about a time period that I didn't know anything about That's why I love
historical fiction novels. You can tell that the author did a lot of research on this book. She is a great storyteller. I thought that this was very entertaining and a great adventure. This book is heartbreaking and tormenting. This was such a sad time in our history. I love reading historical fiction so that our history will not be forgotten.
My favorite character was Celia. I felt so sorry for her. She awakes in an underground cell drugged and disguised. Celia then realizes that she is a shanghaied victim on the verge of being shipped off, as forced labor leaving behind those she loves most. She is abducted and wants to get her memory back. She was dressed like a man. Celia is a little naive and too trusting but very brave. She fights for what she feels is right. She is very kind. She is half Chinese passing as white .
I love the ending and thought it was heartwarming.
I want to thank Netgalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for the copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Available Now!
As she pieces together the twisting path that led to her abduction, from serving as a maid for the family of a dubious mayor to becoming entwined in the case of a goldminers' massacre, revelations emerge of a child left in peril. Desperate, Celia must find a way to escape and return to a place where unearthed secrets can prove even more deadly than the dark recesses of Chinatown.
A captivating tale of resilience and hope, The Girls of Good Fortune explores the complexity of family and identity, the importance of stories that echo through generations, and the power of strength found beneath the surface.
I love this author! I really loved her book, Sold On A Monday and I have The Ways We Hide on my TBR.
This was a very powerful story. I love learning about a time period that I didn't know anything about That's why I love
historical fiction novels. You can tell that the author did a lot of research on this book. She is a great storyteller. I thought that this was very entertaining and a great adventure. This book is heartbreaking and tormenting. This was such a sad time in our history. I love reading historical fiction so that our history will not be forgotten.
My favorite character was Celia. I felt so sorry for her. She awakes in an underground cell drugged and disguised. Celia then realizes that she is a shanghaied victim on the verge of being shipped off, as forced labor leaving behind those she loves most. She is abducted and wants to get her memory back. She was dressed like a man. Celia is a little naive and too trusting but very brave. She fights for what she feels is right. She is very kind. She is half Chinese passing as white .
I love the ending and thought it was heartwarming.
I want to thank Netgalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for the copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Available Now!
February 25, 2025
A gripping and moving tale of family, motherhood, love, resiliency, identity, and class. The Girls of Good Fortune had a great opening scene with a woman waking up, wearing clothes that are not hers, and not knowing her surroundings. From there readers learn the story of Celia, a half Chinese young woman who falls in love with her employer's son in Portland in the late 188o's.
Celia's life is not easy. She is living during a time of anti-Chinese sentiment. Kristina McMorris weaves the Hells Canyon massacre into the story as well as how many found themselves "shanghaied" to be shipped off for forced labor. Celia, who can pass as white, endures many hardships during the novel. Being a young woman, she is naive and often exhibits poor decisions making and judgement calls. She also is brave, determined, resourceful, and loving.
In the beginning of the book, I went from being gripped by the captivating opening scene to wondering if this was the book for me. That changed drastically in the second half of the book where I was hooked, hoping for the best, fearing the worst, and rooting for Celia the entire way. She goes through a lot in this book from falling in love and being kidnapped to name a few, I wondered just how much more can one person take?
I appreciated the amount of research that went into the writing of this book. I also enjoyed how the book picked up and slowly wrapped me around its finger. I felt for several of the characters and the injustice that they faced.
Wonderfully written, well thought out, moving, and captivating.
*A wonderful witches words buddy read with Carolyn and Mary Beth! Please read their reviews as well to get their thoughts on The Girls of Good Fortune!
Thank you to Sourcebooks Landmark and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Read more of my reviews at www.openbookposts.com 📖
Celia's life is not easy. She is living during a time of anti-Chinese sentiment. Kristina McMorris weaves the Hells Canyon massacre into the story as well as how many found themselves "shanghaied" to be shipped off for forced labor. Celia, who can pass as white, endures many hardships during the novel. Being a young woman, she is naive and often exhibits poor decisions making and judgement calls. She also is brave, determined, resourceful, and loving.
In the beginning of the book, I went from being gripped by the captivating opening scene to wondering if this was the book for me. That changed drastically in the second half of the book where I was hooked, hoping for the best, fearing the worst, and rooting for Celia the entire way. She goes through a lot in this book from falling in love and being kidnapped to name a few, I wondered just how much more can one person take?
I appreciated the amount of research that went into the writing of this book. I also enjoyed how the book picked up and slowly wrapped me around its finger. I felt for several of the characters and the injustice that they faced.
Wonderfully written, well thought out, moving, and captivating.
*A wonderful witches words buddy read with Carolyn and Mary Beth! Please read their reviews as well to get their thoughts on The Girls of Good Fortune!
Thank you to Sourcebooks Landmark and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Read more of my reviews at www.openbookposts.com 📖
March 1, 2025
I received a free copy of, The Girls of Good Fortune, by Kristina McMorris, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. In 1888 in Portland, Celia finds she has been kidnapped. This was a heavy read. but a good read.
May 19, 2025
3.5⭐
Set in Portland, Oregon in 1885 and 1888 and ending with an epilogue in 1995, this novel weaves into its narrative a little-known piece of history. Thirty Chinese gold miners were brutally murdered in Oregon and "no one was held accountable", even though it went to trial. It was labeled the Hells Canyon Massacre. This story was eye opening and often read like an action-adventure novel.
The MC, Celia, is a live-in nanny in the mayor's household. Her employer knows that she is one quarter Chinese, but she hides it from others to avoid being ostracized. She loses her job when she becomes pregnant and is forced to work as a housekeeper at a brothel in exchange for room and board, holding out hope that she will eventually be reunited with her baby's father, the mayor's son.
Celia is a very capricious character. She seems to be overly committed to seeking justice for a murdered group of miners that she doesn't know. Considering her status and that she is a new mother her plans become somewhat ludicrous, as well as extremely dangerous, but she is very brave and resourceful.
This is an adventuresome novel of resilience, bravery, friendship, trust, honesty, and the search to find answers. Along the way, Celia learns about herself and others, and her link to her family's heritage.
I didn't like this book as much as I liked this author's previous book, The Ways We Hide, but it was still an enjoyable read. Fans of historical fiction are sure to enjoy this well researched and interesting novel.
My sincere thanks to Sourcebooks Landmark and NetGalley for providing me with a digital ARC of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
Set in Portland, Oregon in 1885 and 1888 and ending with an epilogue in 1995, this novel weaves into its narrative a little-known piece of history. Thirty Chinese gold miners were brutally murdered in Oregon and "no one was held accountable", even though it went to trial. It was labeled the Hells Canyon Massacre. This story was eye opening and often read like an action-adventure novel.
The MC, Celia, is a live-in nanny in the mayor's household. Her employer knows that she is one quarter Chinese, but she hides it from others to avoid being ostracized. She loses her job when she becomes pregnant and is forced to work as a housekeeper at a brothel in exchange for room and board, holding out hope that she will eventually be reunited with her baby's father, the mayor's son.
Celia is a very capricious character. She seems to be overly committed to seeking justice for a murdered group of miners that she doesn't know. Considering her status and that she is a new mother her plans become somewhat ludicrous, as well as extremely dangerous, but she is very brave and resourceful.
This is an adventuresome novel of resilience, bravery, friendship, trust, honesty, and the search to find answers. Along the way, Celia learns about herself and others, and her link to her family's heritage.
I didn't like this book as much as I liked this author's previous book, The Ways We Hide, but it was still an enjoyable read. Fans of historical fiction are sure to enjoy this well researched and interesting novel.
My sincere thanks to Sourcebooks Landmark and NetGalley for providing me with a digital ARC of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
May 12, 2025
Celia Hart wakes up in an underground cell, and once gathers her senses, Celia works out she’s been drugged and is being held captive in the infamous Shanghai Tunnels, and will be transported to a ship.
Three years prior Celia whose half Chinese was passing as white and working as a maid for Mr. Bettencourt the Mayor of Portland and her widowed father was employed by the Union Pacific Railway and then as a miner. Celia falls in love with Stephen and finds herself pregnant and she's banished to Chinatown and lives in a brothel and here she's employed by Madame Marie as a servant.
In America there was a lot of prejudice, hostility and violence towards Chinese people and it escalates at Hells Canyon where miners were massacred and their gold stolen. Celia knows there's been a miscarriage of justice, and she’s been kidnapped to stop her from telling the truth about the incident and she fears what will happen to her daughter and somehow she needs to escape.
I received a copy of The Girls of Good Fortune from the publisher Sourcebooks and in exchange for an honest review. Kristina McMorris is known for writing meticulously researched and interesting historical fiction based around true facts and my main issue was her latest novel was the plot and it became a little unrealistic in the last half of the book it starts in 1888, goes back to 1883 and then ends in 1995.
The narrative does explore topics such racism, what it was like for Chinese people living in America, it was hard and they were judged for taking jobs, corruption and misconduct, lies and deception, love and family, loss and survival and the use of opium. The character I liked the most was Madame Marie, underneath the tough exterior she was kind and she did her best to look after her the young women who worked for her.
Four stars from me, I suggest reading The Girls of Good Fortune for yourself and making up your own mind and I preferred the author’s previous book Sold on a Monday.
Three years prior Celia whose half Chinese was passing as white and working as a maid for Mr. Bettencourt the Mayor of Portland and her widowed father was employed by the Union Pacific Railway and then as a miner. Celia falls in love with Stephen and finds herself pregnant and she's banished to Chinatown and lives in a brothel and here she's employed by Madame Marie as a servant.
In America there was a lot of prejudice, hostility and violence towards Chinese people and it escalates at Hells Canyon where miners were massacred and their gold stolen. Celia knows there's been a miscarriage of justice, and she’s been kidnapped to stop her from telling the truth about the incident and she fears what will happen to her daughter and somehow she needs to escape.
I received a copy of The Girls of Good Fortune from the publisher Sourcebooks and in exchange for an honest review. Kristina McMorris is known for writing meticulously researched and interesting historical fiction based around true facts and my main issue was her latest novel was the plot and it became a little unrealistic in the last half of the book it starts in 1888, goes back to 1883 and then ends in 1995.
The narrative does explore topics such racism, what it was like for Chinese people living in America, it was hard and they were judged for taking jobs, corruption and misconduct, lies and deception, love and family, loss and survival and the use of opium. The character I liked the most was Madame Marie, underneath the tough exterior she was kind and she did her best to look after her the young women who worked for her.
Four stars from me, I suggest reading The Girls of Good Fortune for yourself and making up your own mind and I preferred the author’s previous book Sold on a Monday.
June 9, 2025
Oregon, 1888. Amid the subterranean labyrinth of Portland's notorious Shanghai Tunnels, a woman awakens in an underground cell, drugged and disguised. Celia soon realizes she's a "shanghaied" victim on the verge of being shipped off as forced labor, leaving behind those she loves most.
This story takes place in the late 1800s and deals partly with anti-Chinese sentiment in Portland during that time. Celia, the main female character, is half Chinese, passing for white, who is a maid in the Mayor's home as the story begins. I really liked the first part of this book but I felt that it soon became too unrealistic as Celia got involved in trying to right the horrific treatment of Chinese miners and bring the perpetrators to justice. She experienced too many narrow escapes to be believable and I was confused at times by the constant jumping back and forth between 1885 and 1888. The book contained some good characters but I thought the ending was a bit cheesy. I enjoyed the Author's Note with a description of the amount of research she did for the book. Quite impressive.
Along with a digital ARC, I also had access to the audiobook, narrated by Cindy Kay. She had a pleasant voice and did a satisfactory job although I had to listen to it at 1.25 speed, something I've never done before.
Thanks to Sourcebooks Landmark for access to a digital review copy and to RB Media for approving my request to listen to the audiobook, both via Netgalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
Publication Date: May 20, 2025
This story takes place in the late 1800s and deals partly with anti-Chinese sentiment in Portland during that time. Celia, the main female character, is half Chinese, passing for white, who is a maid in the Mayor's home as the story begins. I really liked the first part of this book but I felt that it soon became too unrealistic as Celia got involved in trying to right the horrific treatment of Chinese miners and bring the perpetrators to justice. She experienced too many narrow escapes to be believable and I was confused at times by the constant jumping back and forth between 1885 and 1888. The book contained some good characters but I thought the ending was a bit cheesy. I enjoyed the Author's Note with a description of the amount of research she did for the book. Quite impressive.
Along with a digital ARC, I also had access to the audiobook, narrated by Cindy Kay. She had a pleasant voice and did a satisfactory job although I had to listen to it at 1.25 speed, something I've never done before.
Thanks to Sourcebooks Landmark for access to a digital review copy and to RB Media for approving my request to listen to the audiobook, both via Netgalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
Publication Date: May 20, 2025
December 3, 2024
The Girls of Good Fortune explores the complexity of family and identity set in the era troubled with anti-Chinese sentiment.
Portland, end of 19th century. Celia’s family escaped China for America, a place advertised as the Golden Mountain, only to face a new set of hardship. As Celia’s father works at a coal mine, she works as a maid for mayor’s family, where she falls in love with the mayor’s son. It’s a challenging situation for both of them, and they’d have to move to Washington Territory for their marriage to be legal.
The story begins with a romance which has dire consequences for Celia. It is further intertwined with her abduction and stark reality for Chinese immigrants, and scary underground world of the Portland’s Shanghai Tunnels.
The story tangles between two timelines. It takes time to make sense and get connected with the present timeline, which is abduction. Once, present timeline makes more sense, then the story becomes more engrossing in its entirety.
Celia, half-Chinese, had to learn how to adapt to prejudice. She is a strong character who quickly learns resilience and finds her ways out of difficult situations. A protagonist that searches every fiber within her to find the strength to fight for what she believes in.
Source: ARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Portland, end of 19th century. Celia’s family escaped China for America, a place advertised as the Golden Mountain, only to face a new set of hardship. As Celia’s father works at a coal mine, she works as a maid for mayor’s family, where she falls in love with the mayor’s son. It’s a challenging situation for both of them, and they’d have to move to Washington Territory for their marriage to be legal.
The story begins with a romance which has dire consequences for Celia. It is further intertwined with her abduction and stark reality for Chinese immigrants, and scary underground world of the Portland’s Shanghai Tunnels.
The story tangles between two timelines. It takes time to make sense and get connected with the present timeline, which is abduction. Once, present timeline makes more sense, then the story becomes more engrossing in its entirety.
Celia, half-Chinese, had to learn how to adapt to prejudice. She is a strong character who quickly learns resilience and finds her ways out of difficult situations. A protagonist that searches every fiber within her to find the strength to fight for what she believes in.
Source: ARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
June 11, 2025
It was the 1880s and Celia Hart was a maid in a well to do family in Portland, Oregon, when she and the family son, Stephen, fell in love. They knew his parents would disapprove, especially as Celia had Chinese heritage. But she vowed to wait for him while he was away with his studies, and they would marry when he returned. But misfortune struck and Celia was ejected from the home, sent to a brothel to work in the kitchens, as well as cleaning. It was hard work, but her strength of character kept her going. Until she was tricked into entering Chinatown to speak to a man who could "help".
When Celia woke, tied up and disguised, in an underground tunnel - the terrifying Shanghai Tunnels - she had no idea what was ahead. Drugged again, thrown on a ship where she was to work her way, she found one person who might be able to help. But the whole situation frightened her, although she couldn't show it. Would she be able to escape and return to her loved ones? Or was she destined to remain in slavery?
The Girls of Good Fortune is the 2nd I've read by Kristina McMorris after Sold on a Monday and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Celia was a naive young woman when we first meet her, but she had to grow up quickly, gain a strength and determination of character which she would have to rely on the keep her safe. She had a purpose, and nothing would stop her! Highly recommended.
With thanks to NetGalley & Cristina Arreola of Sourcebooks for my digital ARC to read and review.
When Celia woke, tied up and disguised, in an underground tunnel - the terrifying Shanghai Tunnels - she had no idea what was ahead. Drugged again, thrown on a ship where she was to work her way, she found one person who might be able to help. But the whole situation frightened her, although she couldn't show it. Would she be able to escape and return to her loved ones? Or was she destined to remain in slavery?
The Girls of Good Fortune is the 2nd I've read by Kristina McMorris after Sold on a Monday and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Celia was a naive young woman when we first meet her, but she had to grow up quickly, gain a strength and determination of character which she would have to rely on the keep her safe. She had a purpose, and nothing would stop her! Highly recommended.
With thanks to NetGalley & Cristina Arreola of Sourcebooks for my digital ARC to read and review.
March 23, 2025
The Girls of Good Fortune is a historical drama set on the West Coast during the time of the Chinese Exclusion Act. Anti-Chinese sentiment was prevalent, and systemic racism and prejudice were rampant at all levels of society. In a world that seems determined to oppose her, Celia must not only survive as a single, unprotected woman but also strive to preserve her heritage and dignity.
Celia’s mixed heritage allows her to pass as Caucasian in an era characterized by prejudice. This enables her to secure a job with a wealthy family, but it also leads her to fall in love with their son. The family, recognizing the social dilemma, separates the two with an ocean and a web of lies. Left alone and pregnant, Celia is displaced from the only security she knows. As she navigates the dangers of society, she tries to keep her daughter with her while seeking employment. A kidnapping further tears her away from her daughter, and she must find a way to reunite with her. The journey is challenging, but fortune will be on her side.
I appreciated the historical accuracy of this novel and its focus on the prejudice against Asians that persisted for decades, manifested in the form of federal laws and government action. It is crucial to highlight the struggles of minorities during this era and the significant obstacles they had to overcome to simply reside in the United States.
Thank you to NetGalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for allowing me to read this novel in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own and reflect my personal background and experiences.
Celia’s mixed heritage allows her to pass as Caucasian in an era characterized by prejudice. This enables her to secure a job with a wealthy family, but it also leads her to fall in love with their son. The family, recognizing the social dilemma, separates the two with an ocean and a web of lies. Left alone and pregnant, Celia is displaced from the only security she knows. As she navigates the dangers of society, she tries to keep her daughter with her while seeking employment. A kidnapping further tears her away from her daughter, and she must find a way to reunite with her. The journey is challenging, but fortune will be on her side.
I appreciated the historical accuracy of this novel and its focus on the prejudice against Asians that persisted for decades, manifested in the form of federal laws and government action. It is crucial to highlight the struggles of minorities during this era and the significant obstacles they had to overcome to simply reside in the United States.
Thank you to NetGalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for allowing me to read this novel in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own and reflect my personal background and experiences.
April 28, 2025
'...Chinese men who'd been so eagerly recruited for backbreaking labor in America were now deemed threats to white men's jobs, resented for their willingness to endure longer hours and lower pay'.
Celia's story begins near its end; groggily waking up in a dark room dressed in men's clothing. Going back a few years, we begin to learn Celia's story which starts with having had to hide her mixed heritage. Being able to pass as white, changing her surname and living away from her Chinese father seemed to work fine - until it didn't. When violent protests and mass killings become too personal, Celia seeks justice for what she knows to be right. Surely it's time for fortune to balance out all her misfortune.
'The Girls of Good Fortune' is an easy-to-read adventure. I admit that after reading the first half of the book, I thought it was heading in a totally different direction than what actually unfolded. I really enjoyed learning more about the history of Chinese migrants to Portland and the Shanghai tunnels under Portland's Old Chinatown. Although I love a plucky FMC, I did feel that some of Celia's feats were 'out of character'. Overall though, very enjoyable, readable book.
'Fortune rests in misfortune'.
Celia's story begins near its end; groggily waking up in a dark room dressed in men's clothing. Going back a few years, we begin to learn Celia's story which starts with having had to hide her mixed heritage. Being able to pass as white, changing her surname and living away from her Chinese father seemed to work fine - until it didn't. When violent protests and mass killings become too personal, Celia seeks justice for what she knows to be right. Surely it's time for fortune to balance out all her misfortune.
'The Girls of Good Fortune' is an easy-to-read adventure. I admit that after reading the first half of the book, I thought it was heading in a totally different direction than what actually unfolded. I really enjoyed learning more about the history of Chinese migrants to Portland and the Shanghai tunnels under Portland's Old Chinatown. Although I love a plucky FMC, I did feel that some of Celia's feats were 'out of character'. Overall though, very enjoyable, readable book.
'Fortune rests in misfortune'.
May 1, 2025
Thanks to NetGalley and SOURCEBOOKS Landmark for access to this title. All opinions expressed are my own.
As our historical fiction begins, it is 1888, and Celia is drugged and unaware of how she ended up in the Shanghai Tunnels. In 1885, we learn that Celia, daughter of a Chinese father and a white woman, is working as a maid in Portland, Oregon. In love with her employer's son, Celia is thrown out of the family home when the family discover that she is pregnant and they refuse to send word to their son, Stephen, away at medical school. With a baby on the way and reeling from the devastating loss of her father, a Chinese miner killed in a massacre, Celia finds herself working as a housekeeper in a brothel. Celia vows to find justice for her father and begins to make a home for her daughter, Pearl. But there is still the question as to how Celia finds herself so far from her home.
As I often find myself when it comes to Kristina McMorris, I read this novel in one sitting. The author's notes, interview, and acknowledgments show the passion and hard work of the author. I felt that Celia was a compelling character, even if she was a bit naive for the majority of the book. Learning about the Hells Canyon Massacre and the Shanghai Tunnels, two aspects of history that I wasn't familiar with, kept me engaged in the story. It also had me doing some sleuthing on the internet after my read was over.
It's a difficult history to read, but I became wrapped up in Celia's fierce determination to survive her ordeals. Luckily, a sweet ending along with a series of recipes helps the novel end on a note of hope. Something which we all need in this day and age.
If you enjoy books by Kristin Harmel, Pam Jenoff, and Ariel Lawhon, I do believe that you will fall for this title as well.
#TheGirlsOfGoodFortune #NetGalley.
Expected Publication 20/05/25
Goodreads Review 20/04/25
As our historical fiction begins, it is 1888, and Celia is drugged and unaware of how she ended up in the Shanghai Tunnels. In 1885, we learn that Celia, daughter of a Chinese father and a white woman, is working as a maid in Portland, Oregon. In love with her employer's son, Celia is thrown out of the family home when the family discover that she is pregnant and they refuse to send word to their son, Stephen, away at medical school. With a baby on the way and reeling from the devastating loss of her father, a Chinese miner killed in a massacre, Celia finds herself working as a housekeeper in a brothel. Celia vows to find justice for her father and begins to make a home for her daughter, Pearl. But there is still the question as to how Celia finds herself so far from her home.
As I often find myself when it comes to Kristina McMorris, I read this novel in one sitting. The author's notes, interview, and acknowledgments show the passion and hard work of the author. I felt that Celia was a compelling character, even if she was a bit naive for the majority of the book. Learning about the Hells Canyon Massacre and the Shanghai Tunnels, two aspects of history that I wasn't familiar with, kept me engaged in the story. It also had me doing some sleuthing on the internet after my read was over.
It's a difficult history to read, but I became wrapped up in Celia's fierce determination to survive her ordeals. Luckily, a sweet ending along with a series of recipes helps the novel end on a note of hope. Something which we all need in this day and age.
If you enjoy books by Kristin Harmel, Pam Jenoff, and Ariel Lawhon, I do believe that you will fall for this title as well.
#TheGirlsOfGoodFortune #NetGalley.
Expected Publication 20/05/25
Goodreads Review 20/04/25
June 14, 2025
3.5 ⭐️
A different story that takes place in the late 1880’s. Celia has a child with a man whose home she was working at. He leaves and so she must work as a Maid at a Brothel. She keeps Pearl, but is left to fend for herself. Considering, she is quite resourceful, but looking for a better life.
Many incidents occur throughout a 3 year period. Some realistic, some not as much. Overall, enjoyable read. Contains Historic Details I had not known about. The Chinese Workers Massacre where 30 Chinese Gold Miners are murdered is known as the Hells Canyon Massacres. No one was ever brought to justice. Then she is shanghaied, which means stealing Chinese Workers and taking them by boat to work in another country, and also just general hatred for Chinese Americans. Although Celia can pass as White, she is actually 1/2 Chinese and this causes trouble and confusion for her.
The story jumps back and forth between 1888 and 1885, which I found a little confusing. This made it hard to follow at times. Also, considering that Celia is a Poor, Single Mother working at a Brothel, some of the situations she finds herself in seem fairly unrealistic. That includes the ending. Overall, it was a well paced and intriguing read though and I did really route for Celia. She is resourceful, quick thinking, smart, industrious, and a caring person who really wants a good life for her daughter.
Thank you NetGalley, Sourcebooks, and Kristina McMorris for a copy of this book. I always leave reviews for books I read.
A different story that takes place in the late 1880’s. Celia has a child with a man whose home she was working at. He leaves and so she must work as a Maid at a Brothel. She keeps Pearl, but is left to fend for herself. Considering, she is quite resourceful, but looking for a better life.
Many incidents occur throughout a 3 year period. Some realistic, some not as much. Overall, enjoyable read. Contains Historic Details I had not known about. The Chinese Workers Massacre where 30 Chinese Gold Miners are murdered is known as the Hells Canyon Massacres. No one was ever brought to justice. Then she is shanghaied, which means stealing Chinese Workers and taking them by boat to work in another country, and also just general hatred for Chinese Americans. Although Celia can pass as White, she is actually 1/2 Chinese and this causes trouble and confusion for her.
The story jumps back and forth between 1888 and 1885, which I found a little confusing. This made it hard to follow at times. Also, considering that Celia is a Poor, Single Mother working at a Brothel, some of the situations she finds herself in seem fairly unrealistic. That includes the ending. Overall, it was a well paced and intriguing read though and I did really route for Celia. She is resourceful, quick thinking, smart, industrious, and a caring person who really wants a good life for her daughter.
Thank you NetGalley, Sourcebooks, and Kristina McMorris for a copy of this book. I always leave reviews for books I read.
February 13, 2025
What a great historical fiction book! Full RTC.
May 21, 2025
Excellent storyline and research.
We see Celia in the opening chapter drugged and in a cell with no idea how she got there.
We then meet Celia as a housekeeper in a wealthy family and a predicament that has her being removed from the home.
THE GIRLS OF GOOD FORTUNE takes us back and forth from Celia's time before the imprisonment and during the imprisonment at a time when there was anti-Chinese sentiment.
It is a bit confusing at first with the two timelines, but both are so well done that they pull you right in.
This is another Kristina McMorris gem that you won't be able to put down, and you will feel for every heartache Celia endures.
I do wish Celia would have made different decisions with some of her predicaments.
Don't miss this one even though it is a bit of heavy reading and at times intense, but an excellent historical fiction read that will keep you glued to the pages. 5/5
Thank you to the publisher for a copy of the book. All opinions are my own.
We see Celia in the opening chapter drugged and in a cell with no idea how she got there.
We then meet Celia as a housekeeper in a wealthy family and a predicament that has her being removed from the home.
THE GIRLS OF GOOD FORTUNE takes us back and forth from Celia's time before the imprisonment and during the imprisonment at a time when there was anti-Chinese sentiment.
It is a bit confusing at first with the two timelines, but both are so well done that they pull you right in.
This is another Kristina McMorris gem that you won't be able to put down, and you will feel for every heartache Celia endures.
I do wish Celia would have made different decisions with some of her predicaments.
Don't miss this one even though it is a bit of heavy reading and at times intense, but an excellent historical fiction read that will keep you glued to the pages. 5/5
Thank you to the publisher for a copy of the book. All opinions are my own.
May 29, 2025
This is a good example of why I don't care for women's literature in the guise of historical fiction. The action vacillated between melodrama and improbable, the set piece being totally unbelievable and the romance laughable.
March 2, 2025
The girls of Good Fortune brings to light horrifying events against Chinese immigrants that were unfortunately forgotten.
Kristina McMorri's depiction of the struggles and racism the Chinese immigrants faced is well done. It was the most compelling part of the story.
Celia, the protagonist, is a chinese woman who's passing white. Through a series of misfortune she ends up being kidnapped and "Shanghaied" to serve in a ship.
I enjoyed the first 50% of this book, but when Celia started making a dumb decision after the other, I was ready to give up. I feel this book lost the plot in the middle and it just kept getting worse for me.
I feel the synopsis of the book should be revised because it's a little misleading.
Thank you to Netgalley and Sourcebooks for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Kristina McMorri's depiction of the struggles and racism the Chinese immigrants faced is well done. It was the most compelling part of the story.
Celia, the protagonist, is a chinese woman who's passing white. Through a series of misfortune she ends up being kidnapped and "Shanghaied" to serve in a ship.
I enjoyed the first 50% of this book, but when Celia started making a dumb decision after the other, I was ready to give up. I feel this book lost the plot in the middle and it just kept getting worse for me.
I feel the synopsis of the book should be revised because it's a little misleading.
Thank you to Netgalley and Sourcebooks for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
November 21, 2024
The Girls of Good Fortune is a historical fiction novel that explores the gritty, dangerous world of the Shanghai Tunnels, the infamous underground network in Portland, Oregon, where people were abducted and forced into servitude on ships. The story centres on a woman, Celia, who wakes up in an underground cell, drugged and disguised—she's been "shanghaied," kidnapped and sold into forced labour.
The novels greatest success is in it's historical context, and McMorris has done a commendable job of depicting the harsh realities faced by the Chinese community in the late 1800s in the USA. The treatment of Chinese workers is a sobering theme that is well-explored, shedding light on the exploitation, racism, and violence they endured during this era. McMorris has successfully weaved this historical backdrop into the plot, and I found this the most compelling aspect of the book.
However, while the historical setting is well-crafted, I felt that Celia was a difficult protagonist to connect with. She was reckless and thoughtless in ways that felt out of step with her situation, the time period, and the dangerous circumstances she finds herself in. Her actions throughout the book often made me cringe, and I found her very hard to empathise with in her plight for freedom. I also found that many of the minor characters were very underdeveloped, and there was an implausibility to some of the plot elements.
Whilst this book does offer a glimpse into a dark chapter of American history, and its portrayal of the exploitation of Chinese immigrants provides a poignant reminder of the struggles faced by marginalized communities. I felt that the characters within the novel were too unrelatable, and I was frustrated by many of their choices; this left the book from reaching its full potential.
Thanks NetGalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for the ARC copy of this book in return for my honest review.
The novels greatest success is in it's historical context, and McMorris has done a commendable job of depicting the harsh realities faced by the Chinese community in the late 1800s in the USA. The treatment of Chinese workers is a sobering theme that is well-explored, shedding light on the exploitation, racism, and violence they endured during this era. McMorris has successfully weaved this historical backdrop into the plot, and I found this the most compelling aspect of the book.
However, while the historical setting is well-crafted, I felt that Celia was a difficult protagonist to connect with. She was reckless and thoughtless in ways that felt out of step with her situation, the time period, and the dangerous circumstances she finds herself in. Her actions throughout the book often made me cringe, and I found her very hard to empathise with in her plight for freedom. I also found that many of the minor characters were very underdeveloped, and there was an implausibility to some of the plot elements.
Whilst this book does offer a glimpse into a dark chapter of American history, and its portrayal of the exploitation of Chinese immigrants provides a poignant reminder of the struggles faced by marginalized communities. I felt that the characters within the novel were too unrelatable, and I was frustrated by many of their choices; this left the book from reaching its full potential.
Thanks NetGalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for the ARC copy of this book in return for my honest review.
May 11, 2025
This is an entertaining, well-written, meticulously researched, historical fiction novel which is based on actual persons and occurrences. It has a likable, strong and resilient female protagonist, and vividly describes a heartbreaking historical tragedy, and events and attitudes of the time period. The theme of identity and the sprinkling of proverbs add meaning to this engaging story. The author's note, the conversation with the author, and her personal insight, are interesting and informative, and are truly appreciated. The recipes which are included are a nice touch. Many thanks to Sourcebooks Landmark, Ms. McMorris, and NetGalley, who provided me with an advanced reader copy of this wonderful novel. This is my honest opinion.
June 6, 2025
*3.5 stars rounded up.
This is a work of historical fiction set in Portland, Oregon in 1888, about a half-Chinese girl named Celia Therese Chung, who finds herself in trouble after falling in love with the mayor's son. As she tries to make a life for herself, she has anything BUT good fortune.
The author brings to light the anti-Chinese sentiment of that era which resulted in two horrific massacres of Chinese workers. No one was brought to justice at that time. It's horrific to once again learn that human beings are capable of such hatred and pure evilness.
Many thanks to the author and publisher for providing me with an arc of this new novel via NetGalley. My review is voluntary and the opinions expressed are my own.
This is a work of historical fiction set in Portland, Oregon in 1888, about a half-Chinese girl named Celia Therese Chung, who finds herself in trouble after falling in love with the mayor's son. As she tries to make a life for herself, she has anything BUT good fortune.
The author brings to light the anti-Chinese sentiment of that era which resulted in two horrific massacres of Chinese workers. No one was brought to justice at that time. It's horrific to once again learn that human beings are capable of such hatred and pure evilness.
Many thanks to the author and publisher for providing me with an arc of this new novel via NetGalley. My review is voluntary and the opinions expressed are my own.
May 21, 2025
Kristina McMorris has written another well researched novel (and so well timed). McMorris writes of Portland’s past history when America’s anti-Chinese rhetoric was at its peak, and thanks to KM, I’ve learned more and have a better understanding of the early Chinese migrant experience.
I know this is fictional, but what a phenomenal portrayal of a woman facing injustice because of her ethnic heritage and for being born female. This is such a heartbreaking yet hopeful story of survival going back in time to the late 1800s. Our MC Celia is a shanghaied victim; -kidnapped and forced as a laborer in the Shanghai Tunnels. McMorris portrayed a realness in her characters, of their feelings, and shows you the desperate circumstances as if you’re there living it. I loved this story. Just make sure you have the Kleenex as this is a heartstring puller.. and don’t forget the authors note at the end. 5 stars — Pub. 5/20/25
Thanks to NetGalley for the advanced reading copy in exchange for an honest review.
I know this is fictional, but what a phenomenal portrayal of a woman facing injustice because of her ethnic heritage and for being born female. This is such a heartbreaking yet hopeful story of survival going back in time to the late 1800s. Our MC Celia is a shanghaied victim; -kidnapped and forced as a laborer in the Shanghai Tunnels. McMorris portrayed a realness in her characters, of their feelings, and shows you the desperate circumstances as if you’re there living it. I loved this story. Just make sure you have the Kleenex as this is a heartstring puller.. and don’t forget the authors note at the end. 5 stars — Pub. 5/20/25
Thanks to NetGalley for the advanced reading copy in exchange for an honest review.
April 28, 2025
Special thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free, electronic ARC of this novel received in exchange for an honest review.
Expected publication date: May 20, 2025
Portland, Oregon, 1888: A young woman named Celia wakes up alone and completely disoriented- somewhere in an underground cell. As her memories slowly return Celia realizes that she has been “shanghai’ed”, captured by a group of seamen to be used as a hired hand on a shipping vessel. As Celia recalls her journey, starting as a maid for the wealthy mayor and a year spent in a local brothel, the only thing Celia knows is that she needs to return to Portland, and fast, before everything she loves is taken from her, never to be seen again.
Kristina McMorris is the historical fiction author known for “Sold on a Monday” and “The Ways We Hide”. Her newest novel, “The Girls of Good Fortune”, goes even farther back than her typical World War Two timeline, to the late nineteenth century in Oregon, where the anti-Chinese sentiment is rampant.
As a part Asian writer, McMorris connects to this story and it shows through her passionate writing and engaging, entertaining plot. Highlighting a time in American history that isn’t often talked about, when the construction of the railroads brought Chinese workers to American shores, only to leave them stigmatized and outcast when the job was done, McMorris ensures that it will not easily be forgotten.
“Fortune” is dual timeline, narrated by Celia before her abduction and after, with only a few years between. The epilogue occurs over one hundred years later, in 1995, allowing readers to come full circle with Celia’s history and understand how her journey ended.
I felt for Celia from the beginning and empathized with her throughout. She was completely relatable as a young woman, struggling with the confines of her gender and station, desperate to fight for what she feels is right. She takes on not just the patriarchy, but the racial injustices around her, which makes her a character I could easily get behind.
McMorris is a gifted writer, to be sure, with the power to immerse twenty-first century readers in her nineteenth century environments through motivational characters, flowing and emotional storylines and well-researched plots. Although I am a fan of World War Two fiction, I love when writers introduce me to a time that is not often talked about in historical fiction, allowing me to experience a new element of understanding and compassion. Whether McMorris returns to World War Two with her next novel, or not, I look forward to reading and enjoying it.
Expected publication date: May 20, 2025
Portland, Oregon, 1888: A young woman named Celia wakes up alone and completely disoriented- somewhere in an underground cell. As her memories slowly return Celia realizes that she has been “shanghai’ed”, captured by a group of seamen to be used as a hired hand on a shipping vessel. As Celia recalls her journey, starting as a maid for the wealthy mayor and a year spent in a local brothel, the only thing Celia knows is that she needs to return to Portland, and fast, before everything she loves is taken from her, never to be seen again.
Kristina McMorris is the historical fiction author known for “Sold on a Monday” and “The Ways We Hide”. Her newest novel, “The Girls of Good Fortune”, goes even farther back than her typical World War Two timeline, to the late nineteenth century in Oregon, where the anti-Chinese sentiment is rampant.
As a part Asian writer, McMorris connects to this story and it shows through her passionate writing and engaging, entertaining plot. Highlighting a time in American history that isn’t often talked about, when the construction of the railroads brought Chinese workers to American shores, only to leave them stigmatized and outcast when the job was done, McMorris ensures that it will not easily be forgotten.
“Fortune” is dual timeline, narrated by Celia before her abduction and after, with only a few years between. The epilogue occurs over one hundred years later, in 1995, allowing readers to come full circle with Celia’s history and understand how her journey ended.
I felt for Celia from the beginning and empathized with her throughout. She was completely relatable as a young woman, struggling with the confines of her gender and station, desperate to fight for what she feels is right. She takes on not just the patriarchy, but the racial injustices around her, which makes her a character I could easily get behind.
McMorris is a gifted writer, to be sure, with the power to immerse twenty-first century readers in her nineteenth century environments through motivational characters, flowing and emotional storylines and well-researched plots. Although I am a fan of World War Two fiction, I love when writers introduce me to a time that is not often talked about in historical fiction, allowing me to experience a new element of understanding and compassion. Whether McMorris returns to World War Two with her next novel, or not, I look forward to reading and enjoying it.
April 20, 2025
Thank you NetGalley,for the opportunity to read the arc ebook,The Girls of Good Fortune by,Kristina McMorris and Sourcebooks Landmark Publishers.
I found this 416 page book,a historical novel,a fast read even though lengthy. It takes place in Portland, in 1888 where a large number of residents were Chinese and not looked upon kindly but used for cheap labor.I thought that was mainly in San Francisco and knew nothing about Oregon.The main character Cecile being half Chinese on her father’s side and half American White on her mother’s side,lives an early life of many adventures while hiding her father’s identity. I enjoyed the factual parts of the book but found the love interest,adventure at sea,on a train boxcar and living in a bordello just filler that’s been written before and also seen in movies.
It’s written ok but on a sophomoric level.
On sale,May 20,2025.
I found this 416 page book,a historical novel,a fast read even though lengthy. It takes place in Portland, in 1888 where a large number of residents were Chinese and not looked upon kindly but used for cheap labor.I thought that was mainly in San Francisco and knew nothing about Oregon.The main character Cecile being half Chinese on her father’s side and half American White on her mother’s side,lives an early life of many adventures while hiding her father’s identity. I enjoyed the factual parts of the book but found the love interest,adventure at sea,on a train boxcar and living in a bordello just filler that’s been written before and also seen in movies.
It’s written ok but on a sophomoric level.
On sale,May 20,2025.
September 10, 2024
What a fun book! It starts off really strong with the hidden romance, Celia’s family and the drama of the fallout. Celia was such a compelling protagonist and I enjoyed the supporting characters (especially Marie and Lettie!). There are so many interesting components to this book (class, Chinese immigration, children out of wedlock, etc) that added to the interest of the story. I appreciated how the author taught me about that time period in a way that felt fast paced. Super good book and can’t wait to read more by this author!
May 18, 2025
”Strange, the way some days stretched into eternity, while the months, at least upon reflection, passed in a blink.”
While I had some awareness of Chinese American history (the Exclusion Act, the railroad and the Gold Rush), I had never heard of the Hells Canyon Massacre or the Rock Springs Massacre until reading The Girls of Good Fortune. That alone speaks volumes about how much of this history is still buried and how much it belongs in classrooms and not only on footnotes.
One of the most interesting aspects of the story is how it explores the identity of biracial characters, especially those who are white-passing. Celia’s father silence about their culture, her mother’s whiteness, the need to suppress half of herself to survive… I found myself reflecting on how easily heritage can be lost in just one generation, especially when assimilation feels like the only safe path.
This isn’t a love story in the traditional sense and I really appreciated that. Celia’s connection to Stephen is important but the book stays focused on motherhood, identity and the hardship of protecting your child in a world that sees you as inferior. Celia’s kindness, empathy, strength, courage and resistance made the story all the more powerful.
If you end up reading this novel, please don’t skip the author’s note. It ties everything together and reminds us why this history is so urgently relevant today. An important, beautiful novel I won’t forget.
A thank you to the author, the publisher and NetGalley for providing me a copy of the book in exchange for an unbiased and honest review.
While I had some awareness of Chinese American history (the Exclusion Act, the railroad and the Gold Rush), I had never heard of the Hells Canyon Massacre or the Rock Springs Massacre until reading The Girls of Good Fortune. That alone speaks volumes about how much of this history is still buried and how much it belongs in classrooms and not only on footnotes.
One of the most interesting aspects of the story is how it explores the identity of biracial characters, especially those who are white-passing. Celia’s father silence about their culture, her mother’s whiteness, the need to suppress half of herself to survive… I found myself reflecting on how easily heritage can be lost in just one generation, especially when assimilation feels like the only safe path.
This isn’t a love story in the traditional sense and I really appreciated that. Celia’s connection to Stephen is important but the book stays focused on motherhood, identity and the hardship of protecting your child in a world that sees you as inferior. Celia’s kindness, empathy, strength, courage and resistance made the story all the more powerful.
If you end up reading this novel, please don’t skip the author’s note. It ties everything together and reminds us why this history is so urgently relevant today. An important, beautiful novel I won’t forget.
A thank you to the author, the publisher and NetGalley for providing me a copy of the book in exchange for an unbiased and honest review.
May 16, 2025
The Girls of Good Fortune by Kristina McMorris. Thanks to @bookmarked for the gifted copy ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Oregon 1888. A woman pieces together the events in her life that led her drugged and imprisoned in underground tunnels.
This was everything that I want in a historical fiction. I learned a little about a time I knew nothing about, while reading an entertaining story as well. It was a wild tale that I would have expected difficult to put into less than 400 pages, but it worked! I loved everything about this one and hope you will too.
“She recognized more than ever the stories people tell, to themselves above all, were often what kept them going. When looking back on life, really, who was anyone without them?”
The Girls of Good Fortune comes out 5/20.
Oregon 1888. A woman pieces together the events in her life that led her drugged and imprisoned in underground tunnels.
This was everything that I want in a historical fiction. I learned a little about a time I knew nothing about, while reading an entertaining story as well. It was a wild tale that I would have expected difficult to put into less than 400 pages, but it worked! I loved everything about this one and hope you will too.
“She recognized more than ever the stories people tell, to themselves above all, were often what kept them going. When looking back on life, really, who was anyone without them?”
The Girls of Good Fortune comes out 5/20.
May 30, 2025
Well. This is the longest review I’ve ever written for a book.
I feel I’m in the minority here regarding this book and that’s fine.
I really enjoyed parts of this novel. It was a fun read, and a major plus I have to give the author was the historical accuracy.
That being said, convenient plot explanations in the last 15 pages to explain big plot threads set up through the ENTIRE STORY, the kidnapped part of the book (the opening scene and entire premise!) being like 30-40 pages, uhhh. We needed an extra 100 or so pages of development. What happened to Owen? Last we saw he was bleeding out on a table? Okay? Like whatever? No significant backstory for Marie who ended up being a key player, I didn’t even know who the guy that died at the end was because he’s apparently the big bad but so irrelevant to the character’s struggles that I forgot he existed.
Why was Stephen so okay with Georgia’s excuse in her letters? Why was Georgia partially redeemed in 3 sentences when she’s an evil, evil, EVIL lady? Why did Stephen get 10-15 pages of spotlight at the end when 3/5ths of the entire book has been Celia curled up in a ball crying about him? Why did Celia not try to move on? (Except she apparently had THOUGHTS about it, as we find out in, you guessed it, the last 10-15 pages pre-epilogue!) And I get that sure, it’s more historically accurate, but why did we have a white man save Celia from all her troubles at the very end? Felt like this sent the wrong message and was NEVER addressed negatively or critically in the epilogue, only with praise for Stephen (which, by the way, the epilogue is WAYYY too short). Why was your protagonist so rash and thoughtless for a majority of the book?
This is one of those books that has good bones but ends up just being the protagonist suffering for hundreds of pages. Just misery and agony, awful things happening. I mean, a BROTHEL? Raising a child while hearing people getting railed a room away??? This is just tough, and while I understand it’s accurate and I do like books that have challenging moments, we HAVE to counteract misery with some light scenes (not even necessarily hopeful!) that can flesh out our protagonist rather than making them suffer. Even the one moment I thought would be fun, Celia going window shopping with Lettie turned into agonizing sadness after 2 pages of fun. At some point your need to depict every possible societal issue a person could face in the 1800’s within the span of only 360 pages stunts your character’s development.
(Side note - one thing that fried me was that the author changed around dates of actual historical events that were previously covered up for hundreds of years. CHANGE YOUR STORY, NOT HISTORY. Let’s not alter real historical massacre trials and only state the changes in the author’s note!)
I also thought the author’s depiction of other societal issues besides anti-Chinese sentiments (LGBTQ+ issues, women’s rights, court manipulation, etc.) could’ve been handled with more time and care. These issues are all given maybe one page of discussion and nothing more, because it does not directly affect Celia - which is fine, but these felt like they served as pity points to paint Celia as a compassionate person, rather than heartfelt discussion.
Not even going into it because this review has been a character and general plot critique but the entire swashbuckling adventure the second half has is completely and utterly unbelievable and is as convincing as a Mission Impossible film lmao.
Why was my understanding of the theme and POINT of the story dependent on the author’s note and reader’s guide questions?
If I could give this book like a 2.2-2.3 I would. I won’t give it less because this book does do a great job of honoring heritage and exploring the time period through the lens of a mixed-race woman; there was care here, and the idea and it’s initial explorations are good.
I just truly believe that this book needed a lot more development and maybe an extra year in the oven. That being said, I would recommend, if not just for the learning you can gather from this book.
I feel I’m in the minority here regarding this book and that’s fine.
I really enjoyed parts of this novel. It was a fun read, and a major plus I have to give the author was the historical accuracy.
That being said, convenient plot explanations in the last 15 pages to explain big plot threads set up through the ENTIRE STORY, the kidnapped part of the book (the opening scene and entire premise!) being like 30-40 pages, uhhh. We needed an extra 100 or so pages of development. What happened to Owen? Last we saw he was bleeding out on a table? Okay? Like whatever? No significant backstory for Marie who ended up being a key player, I didn’t even know who the guy that died at the end was because he’s apparently the big bad but so irrelevant to the character’s struggles that I forgot he existed.
Why was Stephen so okay with Georgia’s excuse in her letters? Why was Georgia partially redeemed in 3 sentences when she’s an evil, evil, EVIL lady? Why did Stephen get 10-15 pages of spotlight at the end when 3/5ths of the entire book has been Celia curled up in a ball crying about him? Why did Celia not try to move on? (Except she apparently had THOUGHTS about it, as we find out in, you guessed it, the last 10-15 pages pre-epilogue!) And I get that sure, it’s more historically accurate, but why did we have a white man save Celia from all her troubles at the very end? Felt like this sent the wrong message and was NEVER addressed negatively or critically in the epilogue, only with praise for Stephen (which, by the way, the epilogue is WAYYY too short). Why was your protagonist so rash and thoughtless for a majority of the book?
This is one of those books that has good bones but ends up just being the protagonist suffering for hundreds of pages. Just misery and agony, awful things happening. I mean, a BROTHEL? Raising a child while hearing people getting railed a room away??? This is just tough, and while I understand it’s accurate and I do like books that have challenging moments, we HAVE to counteract misery with some light scenes (not even necessarily hopeful!) that can flesh out our protagonist rather than making them suffer. Even the one moment I thought would be fun, Celia going window shopping with Lettie turned into agonizing sadness after 2 pages of fun. At some point your need to depict every possible societal issue a person could face in the 1800’s within the span of only 360 pages stunts your character’s development.
(Side note - one thing that fried me was that the author changed around dates of actual historical events that were previously covered up for hundreds of years. CHANGE YOUR STORY, NOT HISTORY. Let’s not alter real historical massacre trials and only state the changes in the author’s note!)
I also thought the author’s depiction of other societal issues besides anti-Chinese sentiments (LGBTQ+ issues, women’s rights, court manipulation, etc.) could’ve been handled with more time and care. These issues are all given maybe one page of discussion and nothing more, because it does not directly affect Celia - which is fine, but these felt like they served as pity points to paint Celia as a compassionate person, rather than heartfelt discussion.
Not even going into it because this review has been a character and general plot critique but the entire swashbuckling adventure the second half has is completely and utterly unbelievable and is as convincing as a Mission Impossible film lmao.
Why was my understanding of the theme and POINT of the story dependent on the author’s note and reader’s guide questions?
If I could give this book like a 2.2-2.3 I would. I won’t give it less because this book does do a great job of honoring heritage and exploring the time period through the lens of a mixed-race woman; there was care here, and the idea and it’s initial explorations are good.
I just truly believe that this book needed a lot more development and maybe an extra year in the oven. That being said, I would recommend, if not just for the learning you can gather from this book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 20, 2025
The Girls of Good Fortune is a remarkable story that will leave you breathless. Set in Oregon in the late 19th century, the main character, Celia, is half Chinese at a time when racism toward Chinese Americans is rampant. Celia’s story is complicated and difficult as her life becomes one of survival and resilience. This riveting story takes readers on a journey through both the best and worst in people, in society, and even families. There is heart-pounding-action, too, in this novel of justice, strength, and love in all its forms. I received an advance reader copy of this book.
March 22, 2025
[NetGalley Read #26]
4 ⭐️
'Strange, the way some days stretched into eternity, while the months, at least upon reflection, passed in a blink.'
'She recognized more than ever: the stories people tell, to themselves above all, were often what kept them going. When looking back on life, really, who was anyone without them?'
Good!
Really beautifully written (there are so many great lines) with great characters. Highlighting an important aspect of history often forgotten.
Felt a bit uneven at times. But the characters more than make up for it.
Recommended (especially if you like Historical Fiction). 👍
4 ⭐️
'Strange, the way some days stretched into eternity, while the months, at least upon reflection, passed in a blink.'
'She recognized more than ever: the stories people tell, to themselves above all, were often what kept them going. When looking back on life, really, who was anyone without them?'
Good!
Really beautifully written (there are so many great lines) with great characters. Highlighting an important aspect of history often forgotten.
Felt a bit uneven at times. But the characters more than make up for it.
Recommended (especially if you like Historical Fiction). 👍
May 15, 2025
This historical fiction story is an enlightening and entertaining story for readers. Set in 1880's Oregon the story centres around Celia Hart, a biracial young woman - half white, half Chinese - who passes as white in a society where racism and mistreatment of minorities, particularly of Asian descent, is rampant and often deadly.
Told in two timelines, the first shows Celia in a frightening situation, leaving readers to wonder how she got there. The second timeline takes readers to the beginning of Celia's story when she was a servant in the home of the mayor, until she became pregnant and is sent to work as a cleaner in a brothel. There Celia finds her own 'found family' and raises her child until her past influences the present and sends Celia on a quest to stand up for the rights of Chinese workers.
This book has a decidedly different feel in the first half compared to the second half and it was jarring, to be honest. The first half felt like a historical fiction novel with great insight and atmosphere (reminiscent of Janie Chang and Kate Quinn's The Phoenix Crown). The second half relies on Celia's naive and impulsive decisions (which were at times frustrating) that send her on a dangerous quest filled with kidnapping, ships, train jumping and more that required me to suspend disbelief.
This is a well-researched story that goes a bit off the traditional historical fiction rails. The first half is atmospheric as it teaches readers about racism, long-forgotten massacres against Chinese Americans and the limited choices of women, while the second half is more of an entertaining madcap adventure. Personally, I preferred the first half and found the second half was too over-the-top, but the ending will appeal to readers who like their stories tied up nice and neatly.
Disclaimer: Thanks to Sourcebooks Landmark for the complimentary digital copy of this book which was given in exchange for my honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 577 reviews