There are page-turners, and then there are page-flippers. Page-flippers are books that inspire you to flip through them, looking for the next part that's relevant to the plot. I actually enjoyed this book quite a bit after I decided to skim it; it has a strong cast of main characters, some fun plot points, and some genuinely moving exchanges. It also has about 200 pages of fluff and repetition. Had this book been only 200 pages, I probably would have laughed, cried, and bought it for all my friends. As it is, it got a lot of eyerolls and a quick return to the library. The plot involves bullied kids, disabled orphans, brave/funny/brilliant disfigured kids, sad drug addicts, dying nice old people, and a self-sacrificing earth mother, so I'm going to come off as totally heartless by criticizing this thing, but I'm going to anyway!
The rundown: Jaden is the single mother of a disfigured, genius highschool boy, who was abandoned by Jaden's drug-addict sister when he was 2 hours old. His dream is to play basketball. Jaden is scared he'll get 1) mocked and 2) injured or possibly killed; any rough action MIGHT dislodge the shunt in his brain. The argument between them over whether or not he can join the team is repeated so often you could make it a drinking game. The first few times it was moving; boy with dreams, mom with valid concerns. After a while, I wanted them both to just shut up about the dratted basketball team, and I LIKE basketball.
The son, Tate, has a blog about his disfigurement that, naturally becomes a big hit. We are told repeatedly how brilliant this budding chemist/neuroscientist is, but his blog reads like the writings of a bright 8 year-old rather than a genius 16 year-old. I've read blogs by my high school and college students, and they were more informative than these entries. They were not believable based on his precocious, mature character, and the blog was the first thing I started skimming.
Jaden works as a hospice nurse, and repeated scenes with a new cast of patients every few chapters are done to death, pun intended and regretted not a whit. Again, at first these scenes were exciting. Her reflections on the various ways sick patients and their families face the inevitable death, and a complication with one obnoxious adult son decides to make trouble, intrigued me. After a while, though, I felt like I was rereading the same scene.
There are some humorous, zany scenes with her nieces and nephews that just didn't quite work for me. There is a lot of basketball. Did you get wish there were more Quidditch scenes in Harry Potter? You will love this book! Do you like reading scenes when a kid gets bullied, and then some other guy who would normally be on the bully's side, but is now disgusted by his cruelty is all "HEY STOP BEING A JERK, I'M ASHAMED OF YOU!" and then the bullied kids get dragged out of the room, and then that happens about 10 more times? You will like this book too!
The best part of the book was Jaden's history of magic and her relationship with her mother and drug addict sister; witchcraft supposedly runs in her family, though she doesn't believe it. We get some terrific stories about her ancestors. Jaden herself gets premonitions when she works with herbs, and for most of the book, she keeps smelling death, which naturally freaks her out even more regarding her son's safety.
The worst part, for me, was the love interest angle and the ensuing dialogue. Can I just say that I really don't like love scenes in which 1) a man declares his love 2) the woman declares her love 3) the woman argues that she is not lovable (I'm so temperamental, etc) and 4) the man argues that yes, she is (I love your passion)! Kiss first, fish for compliments later, sez I.
By the way, did people in 19th century Great Britain have witch burnings? I thought they didn't. Could cruel slaveowners from South Carolina easily track women down in early Oregon settlements? I thought that might be difficult, given the absence of easy travel and communication. This book indicates I may have been wrong, though. It really made me think.