I have made no secret of the fact that I love the film, Labyrinth. As a child of the 80's, I grew up with it, and it captured my imagination almost like no other film did. Nearly 40 years later, it remains one of my all time favourite films. Now, I didn't realise it at the time, but back in the day, there was a comic adaptation of the film, spread over 3 issues. This hardback edition is essentially a reprint of this vintage comic bringing all 3 together in one single volume.
Because I have seen the film so many times, I can recite pretty much all of it by heart. And so, when reading this, the main thing which struck me was when the dialogue didn't match up to what they were saying, or doing in the film. And the main problem that I had was that there were times when they seemed to have changed important dialogue, almost iconic parts of it. There also seemed to be some scenes which were added to - when Sarah comes across the Fireys, for instance - but then there were also some scenes which were shortened, taking something away from the heart of the story. Granted, comics do not always lend themselves to being able to flesh out a story, but this adaptation came across as a bit of a let down for me.
As a lover of the film for so many decades, I was always going to buy this book. However, I fear that someone coming to this perhaps either before they have seen the film, or when they are not so familiar with the film, I fear that it would actually do disservice to the memory of it.
Now, there is a novelisation of the film, which I own but haven't actually read yet (there is a part of me, I think,which is a little scared to, in case that also lets me down), but I am wondering if this would be able to do what the original comic did not. And perhaps this is a little unfair of me, as comics and novels are two completely different genres. I just wished for a little more here, and I am sad to say that I think some of the story was sacrificed to make it fit the length required. It does make me wonder too about the graphic adaptation of the novelisation, and how that will look and feel. You can bet on one thing though - I'll definitely be buying that one, too.