This book was utterly ridiculous. The purveyors of the town bookshop invite the local author in for a reading, he dies in their bathroom, and these two unassuming ladies decide it would be fun to investigate his murder, like it was some cute hobby, even going so far as to make a crime board that consists of 3 names, a mysterious figure in an oversized black hoodie, and a million question marks. They are absolutely giddy and excited about this new pastime and seem to have forgotten that a real person actually died. Their sleuthing consists of taking daily walks to discuss over and over and over the few things they think they know, coming up with lame motives for the three suspects, and somehow happening to be in exactly the right place at the right time. Like how they easily befriend two of the suspects who, with little prodding, pour their hearts out to these two women they’ve never met before. Or when they happen to be with one of the suspects in the dead man’s house (because she can’t be there alone, so why not ask the bookshop owner to come along) when the brash and threatening third suspect bursts in demanding money. Or when they happen to be discussing the murder in front of someone who overhears and knows all about the dark web and bitcoin, information key to cracking the case. Or when they just happen to be walking the dog very close to where the killer is trying to burn all the evidence, and when they confront said killer (in an old abandoned building wearing the requisite dark clothes and oversized hoodie, kneeling by the burning evidence), the person lets out a yelp that “sounds familiar” lol. Oh and we can’t forget the required connection to the local police through a personal relationship, who takes all this speculation and conjecture seriously despite having already closed the case. And finally the unveiling. They invite all the suspects to the bookstore to expose them and all their secrets. Why these three people would agree to this scene simply because the local bookshop owner asked them to come by while she accused them of murder and told all of the intimate details of their relationship with the deceased to a roomful of people is beyond me. But not only did it happen, they all became great friends after the real killer was exposed, who also happened to be in the room, and promptly confessed after being confronted with a few facts. And you could spot this killer from a mile away as they kept coming up in great detail despite seemingly having no connection to the victim, the suspects, nor the crime. Of course it’s all topped off with a picturesque little town, an adorable dog, romantic tension, and a lovely bookshop on the verge of becoming the most sought after venue in town because of its comfy, cozy reading nooks, top tier cafe, ample space for large groups and events, and a coveted liquor license so they can serve wine to the murder mystery and chess clubs, who’ll now be holding all their meetings there. I just can’t LOL!
The characters aren’t particularly interesting, aside from the man who died and as it turns out, the killer. The bookshop owners are extremely superficial - there’s just nothing there! I feel completely indifferent to them and they seemed to just be there to recap the “evidence” over and over. The mystery itself was also very thin. It wasn’t even a mystery nor a murder until one of the suspects happened to mention that she didn’t think it was accidental. Apparently this was enough to propel these two women to start digging in - ie, wildly speculating about the suspects’ motives, which were so basic and made no sense at all. They didn’t even bother to try to figure out how the guy ingested the poison - evidently that wasn’t important to the case lol. Of the three suspects they decided right off the bat that one of them was telling the truth and took her word as fact, for no good reason, but the other two not so much since “just because someone says something doesn’t make it true” lol. I couldn’t wait to be done with this thing and have no interest in continuing the series. I can’t comprehend how this has gotten more than 4 stars.