In the 1860s, on Virginia’s Appalachian frontier, the fates of five people are forever linked as they navigate love, loss, and the cost of buried secrets amid the strife and turmoil of an unimaginable civil war.
In 1854, on the lawless western edge of Virginia, Elizabeth Young stands among the throngs and watches as her beloved uncle is hanged for murder. There is more to this spectacle than meets the eye, she can tell, and she vows then and there she’ll get to the bottom, she’ll uncover truths, then she’ll leave these godforsaken mountains. She’ll go where the land is flat, where life is in the open, where dreams have room to roam.
But fate has another idea. Into her life come three strangers with dreams and secrets of their Patrick Hagan, Irish Catholic immigrant and a bright young attorney with a dogged determination to do good and make good; Mary Lenore Kitchens, the sophisticated teacher who’s come to Virginia’s hinterlands, who knows why; handsome Ben Grubb, local boy, banjo prodigy, a mischievous sort who wants only to play. Soon their lives become inextricably linked, along with that of Red Hopkins, an old friend to Elizabeth’s Papa, and in marches the Civil War.
Punctuated by class and the realities of a devastating conflict, That Which Binds Us is a broad work of historical fiction that celebrates our best and explores our worst, that serves to remind us that across continents and cultures and generations, love holds the greatest power of all.
Cathy Rigg is an author and maker with far more interests than she has time. Born and raised in Virginia’s Appalachian Mountains, her debut novel, THAT WHICH BINDS US, was published by Keylight Books in June of 2025. A work of historical fiction, the story is set in those beloved mountains and centers around five people whose lives intersect during the tumultuous years of the Civil War.
“It is love, not war, that does the most damage of all.”
That Which Binds Us is a heartfelt historical tale of the people residing in the Southern Appalachian of Virginia and a testament of their resilience and courage and an homage to the ever-reaching love and connection to the land on which they live - an unbreakable bond that stands the test of time, as well as fate. Set during the years before and after the Civil War, it is a nonlinear narrative told through alternating multi-faceted perspectives that brings forth a story of longing and grief and redemption, and of how the ties that bind us compel us to our roots, despite our personal desires, which ultimately set us forward the path our lives will follow forever.
“And still there is a kinship I feel with this land... There is so much to gain, and there is so much to lose.”
It is the hanging of her father's twin brother, Uncle Ruck, that thirteen-year-old Elizabeth witnessed at the start of the story that set the stage for what will transpire as the plot progresses. The secrets and guilt we carry onto ourselves for the sake of family - bound by a code that cannot be broken to protect our hearts from grief unbeknownst to them.
Loyal, fierce, and defiant Elizabeth is an inquisitive young girl with the desire for more, which is as offensive, and almost unbearable for how there is no hope for it. Duty and responsibility to familial obligations stifles her imagination and limits her mind to the mountain rural life she wishes to escape. But, amidst the moments which hold her back, there are brief moments of respite. The dawning attention from handsome young Banjo Ben, that strikes up a bittersweet but rather cute romance between the two of them that I liked. 'I wanted to be there. I wanted you to see me there.' It serves as the catalyst for much as time and events weave together to paint the tapestry of the lives of those caught up in the Civil War.
“We was just going on with our days, our land and our families being what we valued most; our land and our families, it turning out, being what we was fierce to protect.”
The writing was filled with respect and beauty for family and religion and the mountains they call home - 'they will not let you go. You are theirs forever' - that shines in the narrative. Rich with characters from different backgrounds and social status, it is a testament to each of their strength and convictions - moral obligations that propels them to behave that they do, to still be grateful for the opportunities they are blessed with Intertwined is the inescapable faith of trusting in love and commitment and yielding their hearts and dreams to a future unbeknownst to them. Times are tough and tragedy prevails, but the author steadfastly guides her readers through a journey of courage during a time when war is here, even in the mountains that they hold so dear.
“... a cry against the woes of life, the pain that comes with loss, the price of loving somebody so much.”
The story is divided into four time periods, and I would have preferred if the years of the war had not transpired in an epistolary format as it takes away the essence of emotions of the lives affected by it. Although, perhaps, it belonged to the one character that my heart felt for the most - one of such pure determination and kindness - 'my will nor my heart will they break, so strong is my promise, the love I've for you.' I felt such a loss of the unflinching courage and loneliness displayed on both sides and despite how their riches may be in ruin, hateful differences coursing on both sides, they would still find ways to begin again.
I know with the right target audience there will be a beautiful message to walk away from - an ode to women who wear scars like armor, when 'life is a battle'. And perhaps if events had transpired differently, my heart would be more at ease with the final outcome - for which I will address my grievances in a vague manner afterwards. But, for the most part, I was fully committed and interested in Elizabeth's story - both her own and that of her parent's past - the crossroads of life with decisions we do not foresee. It is those very secrets that willingly compels us to what we believe is right, even if it disappoints. It was a hard-fought and determined journey, one not without its sadness and secrets, but ultimately, one which captured what it means when one accepts what it means to be wholeheartedly content by That Which Binds Us for our happiness and protection and our future.
Personal Rant - Feel Free to Ignore
*Thank you to Edelweiss for a DRC in exchange for an honest review.
I will preface my review by telling you that historical fiction is not my first choice in genres. I began the book sitting on my deck on a sunny afternoon and was so engrossed that it was dark and a little chilly when I moved inside to complete the book! The characters are well developed, funny, strong willed, kind and loving At first I wasn’t sure I would like the chapters being labeled and told from different characters points of view, but that actually was the perfect way to present this wonderful story of the trials of the Appalachian mountain people just before and during the Civil War. Definitely recommend!! I think we will see more from this author and I look forward to reading her next novel!
“For if it should prove to be God’s will that her heart never recovered or her resolve never faded, I would spend the rest of my days loving Elizabeth Young Grubb the only way I could: from afar.”
Multiple Viewpoints 🔍 Historical Fiction 📖 Faith 🙏🏼 Family 🧑🧑🧒🧒
This was a sweet historical fiction full of love and heartbreak set in the Appalachian mountains of SW Virginia. This takes place during the years leading up to and through the Civil War. We see glimpses of reluctant mountaineers who wanted nothing to do with the war. I had never really thought much about the women and children left behind when conscription was enforced.
I loved the sweet young romance and the love fought for after the war had hardened the hearts of so many.
It took me a bit to get all of the characters straight with the multiple viewpoints but it added a lot of depth once you got into the story.
Patrick Hagan will be your new favorite book boyfriend. 🫶🏼
I also really appreciated the Author’s Note to give context to the real people and imagined characters.
Thank you to #NetGalley and Turner Publishing Company for the ARC of this book. Opinions are my own. #ThatWhichBindsUs
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. As an avid reader of historical fiction, I've read many books set during WWII, but this is the first I've read set during the Civil War era. It was a refreshing change. The story comes to life through the viewpoints of the five main characters. Rigg brings these characters to life in a way that is true and authentic. I hope this debut novel will lead to more from this author.
Being of the Appalachian Mountains, I was very excited to read this book. The vivid imagery paints a portrait of the mountains I love perfectly. There are so many stand out sentences and paragraphs that I had to write them down so that I can keep them with me forever. The women depicted in this novel, while set during the Civil War era, are still the types of women you will find in these mountains— strong, resilient, hardworking, loyal. The characters and this story will stay with you long after you put the book down. I so hope this becomes a movie, because I believe it is a story that would translate well on screen. The author did immense research while writing the novel, as she tells in the Author’s note at the end of the book. It was interesting to see how many of the characters and places were very authentic. Even if you aren’t from these mountains, or even a lover of historical fiction, I feel that you will enjoy this book. I could not put it down and had to find out what would become of these beloved characters! I need more from this author!!
Lovely historical fiction set in SW Virginia in the years culminating the Civil War. Told through the perspectives of lives interwoven with one another in a hard time.A rugged, yet breathtaking setting sets the scene for how our relationships with one another can help us truly survive. Highly recommended! #thatwhichbindsus #cathyrigg #netgalley #goodreads
Told from the perspective of five people with intertwining stories in the time just before and after the start of the Civil War, the story is an immersive page-turner. The character development was excellent and I was impressed that this is a debut novel. It describes the Appalachian mountain people in Virginia in a time period that I haven't read much about. I look forward to reading more by this author. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advance copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Lovely such a truly lovely escape into the hills of Southwest Virginia and into history. I thought at first I would have trouble with the chapters being told from different character’s perspectives- but as I continued, I got to know each character. They are lovely people.
A beautiful, captivating historical fiction surrounding themes of love, loss, grief, and the choice to overcome all the death and destruction of the civil war. The characters are ones you will both root for and fall in love with. What an incredible story to come of the Appalachian Mountains. If Atmospheric is your thing, you’ll love this writing!!
“That Which Binds Us” by Cathy Rigg is a novel with ambition and heart. It is a gorgeous, heartbreaking, and ultimately, hopeful story of people caught up in the savage American Civil War. There are shades of “Cold Mountain” here - poor mountain folk who are clawing out a hardscrabble life yet who are swept up into a war instigated by and for the wealthy and powerful. Through Rigg’s deft storytelling, we experience the angst of the times in the endearing and distinct voices of a cast of memorable characters. A beautiful debut!
Descriptive painting of the time period and landscape. Excellent character development. I feel like I know them personally. I highly recommend this book!
That Which Binds Us by Cathy Rigg is set in western Virginia in the Appalachian Mountains. Mutiple characters weave their way through the novel with the main characters of Elizabeth and Patrick. As each character 'takes the stage' the story is told from their point of view which makes it important to pay attention to who that character is by the title of the chapter. In some ways I found this frustrating, but it offered a deeper understanding of each character. The strength of the characters is vividly displayed, especially during the time period during the Civil War.
Releases June 10th. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Clearly, Cathy Rigg loves the rugged Appalachian Mountains of southwestern Virginia where her family ties go back seven generations. The four narrators of this beautifully written Civil War-era novel—Riggs’s debut—feel that land’s pull with varying but intense passions:
Elizabeth Young, the smart and outspoken daughter of a local shop owner, is 13 years old when the novel begins in 1854 and itching to escape to the bigger world.
Mary Lenore (Marilee) Kitchens, the new schoolteacher, arrives in the mountains from her privileged life in Charlottesville, Virginia, feeling compelled to educate the “people of such limited experience, stuck like they are in the hills.” She becomes a mentor to Elizabeth–and also, though she won’t really admit it, a rival.
Patrick Hagan managed to escape the potato famine of his native Ireland thanks to the help of a successful uncle. After studying law, he ends up with his uncle in Appalachia and slowly begins to feel like he belongs with the land and its people, even though he is so different from them in terms of class, money, and religion. As the area’s only two educated outsiders, he and Marilee would seem to make a perfect couple.
Red Hopkins, a farmer born-and-bred to the rugged terrain, is a close friend to Elizabeth’s father and his brother, who themselves have become bitter enemies. Red has never lived anywhere else and never wanted to.
Riggs, the author, does an amazing job at finding unique voices for each of these four—plus Ben Grubb, another love interest, who writes many letters home to Appalachia from the Civil War’s increasingly bloody frontlines. (The book’s main flaw is that the section containing his letters goes on too long.)
In addition, the characters offer an unusual vantage point into slavery and the origins of the war. These impoverished folks are instinctively loyal to their homeland, the Confederacy; yet, other than Marilee’s family, they have never been enslavers. So this is far from another Gone with the Wind.
In the years leading up to the war, Patrick and Marilee engage in strongly matched debates. She points out that “slavery is protected in the Constitution.” He believes that slavery is wrong but also wants to avoid a war over the issue.
The plot is also compelling in other ways, with surprising twists and turns, and secrets that keep unraveling.
Altogether, the book raises important questions about loyalty and belonging—questions that will linger with the reader. (A longer version of this review was first posted on Story Circle Network)
That Which Binds Us" by Cathy Rigg is her debut book and I look forward to reading any subsequent books based on this one. Set in the Appalachian Mountains in West Virginia during the Civil War, this beautifully descriptive book draws you not only into rugged mountains, the historical details makes you feel a part of the town, its characters and the culture built in family, loyalty, faith, friendship and strength. Based on 5 main characters POV's, the book opens with the main protagonist, 13 year old Elizabeth, witnessing her uncle's death, then introduces the rest of the characters, Patrick, Mary Lenore, Ben, and Red with depth in layered stories, weaving their connections throughout the story. . There is suspense, surprises, war, struggle's and plot twists with authentic characters that will capture your attention and keep you engaged. There is some violence, both local and during the war, appropriate to the story and history.. The romance is sweet and clean and language mostly clean as well. I really appreciated the Author’s Note explaining the real people in history and imagined characters, her research is outstanding.
I strongly recommend this captivating historical read that brings in a unique perspective to the Civil War through engaging characters set in the beautiful landscape of the Appalachian Mountains, sprinkled with Freemasonry history and mysteries revealed in a well paced unveiling.
A big note of gratitude to NetGalley and Turner Publishing Company for the ARC, it was a pleasure reading this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
That Which Binds Us is a sweeping yet intimate portrait of 1860s Appalachian Virginia. From the very first chapter, Riggs’s depth of research is undeniable and evident in her portrayal of legal tensions, class divides, folk traditions, and the Civil War. I was truly blown away by how immersive this book was. The mountains are no passive backdrop, they are living, breathing. I could feel the land in this book as it bore witness to the characters’ journeys. Elizabeth, Patrick, Mary Lenore, Ben, and Red each bring their own rich, layered stories. Riggs masterfully captures their inner monologue and spoken voice with such clarity and distinction that I could hear each one individually. Their experiences of love, loss, and connection felt achingly real. If you enjoy multi-POV historical fiction novels that slowly reveal connections, you’ll love this book. I believe this novel will resonate with fans of Cold Mountain by Charles Frazier and Horse by Geraldine Brooks. A stunning debut that will stay with me for years to come!
I can’t say enough good things about THAT WHICH BINDS US. From the moment I picked it up, I was hooked. The story is beautifully written with rich, descriptive language that made me feel like I was right there—I could hear the music, see the landscape, and feel every emotion the characters experienced.
The use of native speech and dialect from the western Appalachian Mountains adds so much authenticity. The historical details are spot-on, especially the insights into Appalachian life and the Freemason brotherhood. It’s clear a lot of research and heart went into this book.
The plot flows smoothly through the lives of the main characters as they live through the harsh realities of the Civil War. Their struggles felt deeply personal and moving.
If you love historical fiction with strong characters, emotional depth, and vivid settings, I highly recommend this novel. Perfect for your book club—you’ll be glad you picked it up!
I can’t wait for everyone to have an opportunity to join me in reading this novel by Cathy Rigg! I loved getting to know each character and (as a Southerner myself) appreciate the local dialogue/dialect of Ms. Rigg’s characters- especially Elizabeth. The characters are authentic and experience real events of their time.
That Which Binds Us brings to life the difficulty of surviving in the Appalachian Mountains, the authenticity of the Appalachian people and takes us through their days of the Civil War. The characters are beautifully created, honest and believable.
I am a huge fan of historical fiction and this one is a gem! The author’s attention to historical and geographical details paint a vivid portrait for the reader. I could just “see” the mountains. For lovers of historical fiction this is a Must Read!
So much has been written about the Civil War, and the Appalachian people are well known for their storytelling tradition. Yet That Which Binds Us reaches well beyond these standard bearers and carves out its own position of historical fiction. Cathy Rigg combines intense historical research that brings readers front and center to the moment with language that is both lyrical and transcendent, placing us within the hearts of the characters and the landscape that is the beating heart of this novel.
Through the author’s loving craftsmanship, That Which Binds Us once again reminds us that regardless of our circumstances or place in history we are all human, and we experience in equal measure the intricate dimensions of love: joy, loss, forgiveness and redemption. You will be swept away by this tale.
This book was one of the most heartbreakingly beautiful historical fiction stories I have ever read. The story takes place in Southwest Virginia immediately prior to, during, and following the civil war. The author was inspired by real people from this area during the time the book takes place. I think it can be difficult to navigate the civil war and the issue of slavery with the sensitivity it deserves while remaining historically accurate in literature, and I think author does this well. She does a masterful job weaving tales of change, love, and tragedy throughout the story while giving readers an ultimately hopeful ending. I think she captured so much of what makes the Appalachian people so unique; their fortitude and strength, and their love and devotion to their families and the land. 5⭐️
That Which Binds Us vividly captures the feel of Appalachia, from the people to the land, as told from the perspectives of five very different characters brought together during the turmoil and devastation of the Civil War. Irish immigrant Patrick, liberal-minded schoolteacher Marilee, banjo playing Ben, strong-willed dreamer Elizabeth, and Red Hopkins, Freemason and general wise old soul — their stories weave in and around each other in the mountains of Virginia. Part love story, part reflection of the effect a brutal war had on the American south, this mildly faith-based historical novel is an engaging read.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the opportunity to read and review this book.
That Which Binds Us is an excellent historical fiction novel that is very well written and researched. While there are many fine novels set in Civil War times, I have not run across many that take place in the remote areas of the Appalachian Mountains. Detailed descriptions of the mountains and landscape made me feel like I was right there in that beautiful setting, almost as if it was a sixth main character. The character development was intriguing, both the main characters and side characters such as the colorful Abijah Alley, who I was amazed to find was a real person. Even Edgar Allen Poe makes an appearance! I love when historical fiction encourages me to learn more by researching real people and places as this novel did. Highly recommend!!
Deep in the Appalachian mountains of West Virginia, this compelling story of life and love during the Civil War is a lesson in the resilience of the human spirit. From the very first page, I was captivated by the characters that Cathy Rigg brings to life - inspired by their faith in each other and the mountains that tie them together. This is one of those rare reads that stays with you for a long time. A reminder that no matter our progress from generation to generation - our greatest strength as a people, is in the purity of our relationships. Don't miss this wonderful book, you won't be able to put it down.
I am usually not a fan of historical fiction but this book pulled me in and took me on a journey back to the Civil War. The story takes place in the mountains of Southwest Virginia, a place near and dear to my heart. A place where I grew up and still live today. It is a love story with enough twists and turns to keep my interest. In the pages of “That Which Binds Us”, I found my newest favorite character, Patrick Hagen”. I am not going to say much here because I want you to read this special book and find out for yourself. Be sure to read the Author’s Note! What fun facts about Southwest Virginia you will find! I love this novel. It’s characters and their stories will be long remembered.
I loved the way this book dropped me out of the modern world and into a different time and space, where most everything operated differently. And yet, resolving problems of family, friends, and lovers all remain constant in our larger condition. Beautifully written, it takes off in the second half as five perspectives merge together. And, if you’re interested after, you can research Patrick Hagan, from Dungannon, County Tyrone, Ireland all the way to Scott County, Virginia. Who knew the gift the Irish gave southwestern Virginia? It took this book to learn of it.
That Which Binds Us was a deep exploration of not just Appalachian life before and during the Civil War era but also how one navigates the bombshells that appear in everyday life. I applaud how Cathy Rigg deftly chucked the expected and traditional story flow by pivoting the trajectory and point of view of the story. As someone living in the South, I have always craved to understand how it must have felt to be in the middle of that horrible time. She explored many aspects of that experience (and some I'd never even considered) in her novel. Loved it!
I couldn’t put this book down! That Which Binds Us is a powerful Civil War-era novel set in the Appalachian Mountains, told through five unforgettable characters. Each voice brought a unique perspective, and I felt deeply invested in their lives. The story is rich, emotional, and beautifully written—full of heart, history, and humanity. I felt like I truly knew these characters. A must-read for historical fiction fans!
At its heart, this story intertwines love, loss, conflict and redemption into an extraordinary journey. The author brings the characters to life in such a compelling narrative that you can’t help being invested in the story’s outcome. Ultimately, the novel reminds the reader that roots of relationships can bind us as much as those of the trees growing on the land where we were born. You will be drawn in, and you will be reminded of what binds us all.
This book was recommended to me by a friend. This work of historical fiction captured my attention from the first chapter. Even though the book covers an extended period of time leading up to, during and after the US Civil War, the author‘a writing and character development kept me engaged and wanting more. The war letters were especially powerful to read. I really enjoyed reading this one and look forward to reading more from this author.
Beautifully written, full of gorgeous Appalachian imagery, historical events, intriguing characters and ‘can’t put it down’ plot lines! This debut novel is a love letter to mountain culture and all of its people during their most turbulent time; - a time of loss, love, challenge and perseverance- while showing us how socio-economic differences effected the impacts of war in the 1800s. Best book I’ve picked up in years! I hope there’s more, and quickly!