decent story, poor writing
The plot is imaginative. The writing, though, is often tone-deaf. Early on there’s a multipage monolog by the ship that is plainly the author’s political agenda speaking about today’s current events, and that’s repeated frequently throughout. Sometimes the dialog is realistic, other times it’s stilted in the way actual people would never talk. A few chapters are pure filler — unimportant, and why they were included is a mystery. A good editor would have killed them. And a huge hole: how is it that a few thousand scientists decamped to Pohnpei, a Micronesian island of 129 square miles, and there managed to develop space science and technology to the point of near-light speed travel? Using antimatter? Which now is a product only of particle accelerators? Which are enormous construction projects. I mean, that calls for intensive manufacturing of everything needed, from tools to colliders to plastics and metals and computers and…and all the kinds of things not at all available on a tiny remote island in the Pacific with few natural resources beyond phosphate. How all this could happen in such a place is just not even mentioned. We’re expected to think, well somehow they managed. The book ends on a cliff-hanger — and while I would like to know what happens next because the overall story held my interest, I don’t know if I can put up with more turgid dialogue and improbable science and even more improbable events.