I received an ARC of this book and this is my honest review. I believe this book appears on Goodreads under the title “Reese’s Long Hot Summer” (Hickory Ridge series #3), but the NetGalley title I read is “A Summer Changes Everything.”
“A Summer Changes Everything” is a small-town romance with cowboy-romance vibes due to its setting on a Virginia horse and cattle farm. If you like any of the following, this story might be for you:
small-town romance, single-dad romance, low-angst romance with no 3rd act breakup
“A Summer Changes Everything” provides a smooth, easy read with familiar tropes, no surprises, and a reliable happy ending for all parties.
Reese, a youngish widower and the oldest of four sons of a well-off farm/ranch family, has spent the last year and a half burying himself in work, isolating himself not only from the outside world but also from his two young sons, whose care has fallen to his mother. With his dad recovering from serious heart surgery and his mom worn out from caring for both the boys and her husband, Reese’s parents and grandparents decide to take an extended European vacation, and Reese’s mom calls in Shelby, the niece of her best friend, to serve as nanny, cook, and housekeeper for Reese and the boys while the older folks are gone.
Shelby is a PE teacher who has the summer off anyway and who is eager to escape her own town where people have been pressuring her to reconcile with her cheating ex-fiancé. She fits easily into Reese’s household, striking an easy rapport with the rambunctious little boys. She and Reese are immediately attracted to each other, though they resist acting on it for much of the book. Shelby believes Reese isn’t ready and needs to focus on recementing his relationship with his kids. Reese isn’t sure what he’s ready for, but his attraction to Shelby feels to him like unfaithfulness to his late wife. Over the course of the story, we see Shelby and Reese form a good parenting team for the little boys as their respect and liking for each other grows, with little to no conflict between anyone.
A few things didn’t work well for me with this story; one was that I didn’t feel like I got to know any of the characters very well, and so I couldn’t share their emotions. This perhaps explained my frustration that Shelby—like Reese’s previous wife—seemed mainly a vessel for his needs, with few thoughts or needs or goals that didn’t revolve around him and his boys. The relationship worked because she gave and gave and never asked for anything in return. I wasn’t convinced Reese deserved that, after basically neglecting his newly-motherless kids for over a year. He turned around on a dime when Shelby arrived, but…I wasn’t convinced.
With that said, if you are looking for a reprieve from deeply troubled characters in traumatizing situations, and would instead like a pleasant read that won’t cause strong or turbulent emotions, “A Summer Changes Everything” might be just the escape you’re looking for.
3.6 stars rounded up to 4