What do you think?
Rate this book
The Mizzy Mysteries #1
A Skeleton in the Closet
Brand new for 8- to 12-year-old murder-mystery readers in 2025, debut author Claire Hatcher-Smith’s unique detective heroine Mizzy will steal your heart! Perfect for fans of Robin Stevens and Sharna Jackson.‘A brilliant debut’ The BooksellerTwelve-year-old Mizzy dreams of being a detective and she won't let anything stand in her way — not her reputation for tall tales, or her embarrassing fear of escalators, and definitely not her Down syndrome. Dumped for the summer with cousins who've outgrown her, Mizzy feels even more sidelined than usual. But when she discovers Great Aunt Jane's diaries in a locked wardrobe in their spare room, and realises her aunt didn't die in her sleep but under suspicious circumstances, everything changes. What's more … someone in the family appears to have been involved.
Under the guise of a family-tree project for school, and armed with a brand new set of Pipsqueak markers, Mizzy grabs the chance to prove herself to her cousins — and the world.
"A total triumph for representation” First News
Under the guise of a family-tree project for school, and armed with a brand new set of Pipsqueak markers, Mizzy grabs the chance to prove herself to her cousins — and the world.
"A total triumph for representation” First News
288 pages, Kindle Edition
Published February 27, 2025
3 people are currently reading
94 people want to read
About the author
Claire Hatcher-Smith
4 books6 followersClaire is a speech and language therapist, with a masters in special education.
Originally from the UK, she now lives surrounded by sea on Vancouver Island, with her husband, their son and a Korean rescue dog. Neurodivergent herself, when she isn't writing, Claire runs peer-support groups for autistic tweens and teens.
Originally from the UK, she now lives surrounded by sea on Vancouver Island, with her husband, their son and a Korean rescue dog. Neurodivergent herself, when she isn't writing, Claire runs peer-support groups for autistic tweens and teens.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 41 reviews
May 29, 2025
I received a free copy of, A Skeleton in the Closet, by Claire Hatcher-Smith, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Mizzy has down syndrome, but she does not let it stop her from much. Mizzy finds a diary and has a mystery to solve. This was a nice family mystery.
October 29, 2025
The main character narrator and the audiobook narrator both have Down’s Syndrome.
The mystery seemed exceedingly weak to me but at age 9 I might have been enthralled and the book is written for 8-12 year old readers.
I enjoyed the London and the village settings.
What seemed off to me (but the author knows more about Down’s Syndrome than I do) is that Mizzy can and does read and yet she misspells most words including words that she’s just seen on the page or on signs. She also has a large vocabulary. Mizzy/the author say that trouble with spelling is a “Down’s Syndrome thing” but is that true for words she’s read just a few minutes prior? I get the trouble with directions and other challenges Mizzy faces. The author also does fit into the narrative some of the physical characteristics and issues that people with Down’s Syndrome have. I’m hopeful that from learning about someone (who happens to also be smart and appealing) with Down’s Syndrome that young readers will feel empathy for people who are in some ways different from them.
I loved being in Mizzy’s head and in observing others around her, the way she sees them and the way the reader might see them.
I think that young readers will identify with Mizzy. They will understand her wanting to be taken more seriously and as more mature than others treat her and of having a great desire to be successful at something that is important to her. They will enjoy her prying into what seems to be a family secret. They will know what it feels like to sometimes feel left out and left behind by other kids and of being disapproved of sometimes by some adults and of knowing that others are disappointed in them. For facing one fears as well. Kids will like Mizzy for doing the “right thing” and for being a quiet heroine.
I hate the frequency with which Mizzy talks about barf/sick in her mouth, something that happens when she gets particularly anxious, and every time I read about it I felt nauseated. Ugh! One or two mentions would have been more than enough.
This is a beautifully written story, all narrated by Mizzy, who is 12-3/4 years old.
There are lots of lovely quotes. Here is just one that I liked:
“...warm air wraps around me like an unwanted hug from a little old lady, stale and sickly sweet.”
I loved reading the audio and the eBook simultaneously. The audio book is in the original British English which I enjoyed. The eBook was heavy on U.S. English translation, even more so than in most books. I kvetch about that every time I read a British book translated to U.S. English because it’s awful that they do that. I don’t know anybody who likes or appreciates the translations. This book actually had some British words I didn’t know (which is now unusual) but I could have and would have looked them up and would have enjoyed doing that. I was seeing the translation on the page so I didn’t have to research the words while I was reading this book.
I don’t know whether or not I’ll continue with the series but if I had read it when I was nine (or eight or 10) I’m sure I would have read however many books will be in the series.
I won this book at LibraryThing. I assumed too early that I was not going to get a copy. I need to stop making assumptions. It arrived on 10/29 which was the last day it was supposed to arrive. I won the book on 9/3. I read a library copy (e and audio) from 10/24-26 and I reviewed the book on 10/27. I’m thrilled that the book arrived because it’s a book that I’m happy to own and it’s the completed hardcover edition, not an ARC. Thank you to Penguin Random House/Tundra Books and to LibraryThing! (Book released 8/26.)
The mystery seemed exceedingly weak to me but at age 9 I might have been enthralled and the book is written for 8-12 year old readers.
I enjoyed the London and the village settings.
What seemed off to me (but the author knows more about Down’s Syndrome than I do) is that Mizzy can and does read and yet she misspells most words including words that she’s just seen on the page or on signs. She also has a large vocabulary. Mizzy/the author say that trouble with spelling is a “Down’s Syndrome thing” but is that true for words she’s read just a few minutes prior? I get the trouble with directions and other challenges Mizzy faces. The author also does fit into the narrative some of the physical characteristics and issues that people with Down’s Syndrome have. I’m hopeful that from learning about someone (who happens to also be smart and appealing) with Down’s Syndrome that young readers will feel empathy for people who are in some ways different from them.
I loved being in Mizzy’s head and in observing others around her, the way she sees them and the way the reader might see them.
I think that young readers will identify with Mizzy. They will understand her wanting to be taken more seriously and as more mature than others treat her and of having a great desire to be successful at something that is important to her. They will enjoy her prying into what seems to be a family secret. They will know what it feels like to sometimes feel left out and left behind by other kids and of being disapproved of sometimes by some adults and of knowing that others are disappointed in them. For facing one fears as well. Kids will like Mizzy for doing the “right thing” and for being a quiet heroine.
I hate the frequency with which Mizzy talks about barf/sick in her mouth, something that happens when she gets particularly anxious, and every time I read about it I felt nauseated. Ugh! One or two mentions would have been more than enough.
This is a beautifully written story, all narrated by Mizzy, who is 12-3/4 years old.
There are lots of lovely quotes. Here is just one that I liked:
“...warm air wraps around me like an unwanted hug from a little old lady, stale and sickly sweet.”
I loved reading the audio and the eBook simultaneously. The audio book is in the original British English which I enjoyed. The eBook was heavy on U.S. English translation, even more so than in most books. I kvetch about that every time I read a British book translated to U.S. English because it’s awful that they do that. I don’t know anybody who likes or appreciates the translations. This book actually had some British words I didn’t know (which is now unusual) but I could have and would have looked them up and would have enjoyed doing that. I was seeing the translation on the page so I didn’t have to research the words while I was reading this book.
I don’t know whether or not I’ll continue with the series but if I had read it when I was nine (or eight or 10) I’m sure I would have read however many books will be in the series.
I won this book at LibraryThing. I assumed too early that I was not going to get a copy. I need to stop making assumptions. It arrived on 10/29 which was the last day it was supposed to arrive. I won the book on 9/3. I read a library copy (e and audio) from 10/24-26 and I reviewed the book on 10/27. I’m thrilled that the book arrived because it’s a book that I’m happy to own and it’s the completed hardcover edition, not an ARC. Thank you to Penguin Random House/Tundra Books and to LibraryThing! (Book released 8/26.)
September 10, 2025
Looking for the first mystery for your middle-aged child?
Interested in a neurodiverse heroine?
How about an illustrated murder mystery?
A Canadian author, publisher and printer?
You need this one!
Review to follow at end of book tour.
=======================================
What a great experience! Review below.
With a well-honed set of detective skills, a fantastic imagination, the freedom to investigate, and a new set of Pip Squeak Markers, 12-year-old Mizzy embarks on her first murder mystery case. Mizzy has been sent to her cousins for the summer and discovers a case worth investigating when she finds a locked closet in her room. This challenge seems like a godsend to Mizzy, who’s been struggling her whole life to prove herself to everyone.
The heroine of this first novel in a new detective series is instantly lovable. Despite being labeled as neurodivergent, Mizzy never misses a chance to prove that nothing stands in her way; not her cousins, her parents, nor her different ability. Armed with decades of experience in working alongside children with Down Syndrome, Claire Hatcher-Smith has created a unique heroine in Mizzy. I love that she’s a compilation of all the wonderful children the author has met in her career.
Mizzy’s personality is the star of this twisty debut, but the illustrations come a close second. I read this one with my niece and nephew, and they loved Mizzy as much as I did. In fact, they’re still talking about her. As a teacher, this book was a great segue into teaching acceptance, kindness, and spelling lessons.
I didn’t solve the mystery before Mizzy, but I learned lots about taking case notes and linking suspects to past events. I can’t wait for the next mystery in this series.
I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
Interested in a neurodiverse heroine?
How about an illustrated murder mystery?
A Canadian author, publisher and printer?
You need this one!
Review to follow at end of book tour.
=======================================
What a great experience! Review below.
With a well-honed set of detective skills, a fantastic imagination, the freedom to investigate, and a new set of Pip Squeak Markers, 12-year-old Mizzy embarks on her first murder mystery case. Mizzy has been sent to her cousins for the summer and discovers a case worth investigating when she finds a locked closet in her room. This challenge seems like a godsend to Mizzy, who’s been struggling her whole life to prove herself to everyone.
The heroine of this first novel in a new detective series is instantly lovable. Despite being labeled as neurodivergent, Mizzy never misses a chance to prove that nothing stands in her way; not her cousins, her parents, nor her different ability. Armed with decades of experience in working alongside children with Down Syndrome, Claire Hatcher-Smith has created a unique heroine in Mizzy. I love that she’s a compilation of all the wonderful children the author has met in her career.
Mizzy’s personality is the star of this twisty debut, but the illustrations come a close second. I read this one with my niece and nephew, and they loved Mizzy as much as I did. In fact, they’re still talking about her. As a teacher, this book was a great segue into teaching acceptance, kindness, and spelling lessons.
I didn’t solve the mystery before Mizzy, but I learned lots about taking case notes and linking suspects to past events. I can’t wait for the next mystery in this series.
I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
September 8, 2025
5⭐️/ 5⭐️
“I liked how she said ‘you m*rdered him.’ The suspect I thought it was was Cheree.”
“My favourite part is like when they solve the mysteries. I wanted my mum more to me because the book was very very good.”
I read this to my kids every night! We are very much in our family reading era. My daughter in particular loved this book and we are excited for the second book to come out in March.
I also LOVED the representation, a main character with Down Syndrome was such a treat to see. We all fell in love with Mizzy.
Thank you so much tandem collective and tundra for the copy and for the readalong.
“I liked how she said ‘you m*rdered him.’ The suspect I thought it was was Cheree.”
“My favourite part is like when they solve the mysteries. I wanted my mum more to me because the book was very very good.”
I read this to my kids every night! We are very much in our family reading era. My daughter in particular loved this book and we are excited for the second book to come out in March.
I also LOVED the representation, a main character with Down Syndrome was such a treat to see. We all fell in love with Mizzy.
Thank you so much tandem collective and tundra for the copy and for the readalong.
February 24, 2025
I loved this book. Mizzy is a brilliant main character; I loved her voice, and her personality bursts from the page. She is soon to turn 13 and that brings a whole lot of new concerns: like any teen, Mizzy is more conscious of how she dresses; how she behaves; and how she’s treated by others. Conversely, her parents are going to have to adapt to parenting a teenager.
Mizzy has Down Syndrome and lots of those around her seem to underestimate & baby her. She’s always felt so at home with her cousins, Niko and Oli, but her latest trip reveals that they’re growing up too & that seems to include growing apart from Mizzy. When Mizzy turns up at her cousins’ house expecting to pick up with their game of Sherlock and the Two Watsons, she finds herself alone in a neglected spare room instead.
Marvellous Mizzy’s interest in detection doesn’t stop at games, however: she has a knack for noticing strange behaviour, which without knowing the wider context, has led her to a few awkward misunderstandings, tellings-off and self-doubts.
When Mizzy stumbles across a real mystery in the heart of her family, she realises she has a real talent for sleuthing. But, how will she make anyone take her seriously when their preconceptions keep getting in the way? Can she push herself further out of her comfort zone to go it alone? Will the truth bring more harm than good?
I think the representation of an adolescent with Down Syndrome is really sensitive and considered. Mizzy is an amazing, positive character. But, society that surrounds her has some learning to do. Claire Hatcher-Smith does a great job of showing Mizzy’s frustrations as she tries to assert her increasing need for independence in a world that’s sometimes difficult for her to navigate on her own.
The pacing is great and it’s brimming with heart and humour. I can’t wait to read what Mizzy gets up to next!
Mizzy has Down Syndrome and lots of those around her seem to underestimate & baby her. She’s always felt so at home with her cousins, Niko and Oli, but her latest trip reveals that they’re growing up too & that seems to include growing apart from Mizzy. When Mizzy turns up at her cousins’ house expecting to pick up with their game of Sherlock and the Two Watsons, she finds herself alone in a neglected spare room instead.
Marvellous Mizzy’s interest in detection doesn’t stop at games, however: she has a knack for noticing strange behaviour, which without knowing the wider context, has led her to a few awkward misunderstandings, tellings-off and self-doubts.
When Mizzy stumbles across a real mystery in the heart of her family, she realises she has a real talent for sleuthing. But, how will she make anyone take her seriously when their preconceptions keep getting in the way? Can she push herself further out of her comfort zone to go it alone? Will the truth bring more harm than good?
I think the representation of an adolescent with Down Syndrome is really sensitive and considered. Mizzy is an amazing, positive character. But, society that surrounds her has some learning to do. Claire Hatcher-Smith does a great job of showing Mizzy’s frustrations as she tries to assert her increasing need for independence in a world that’s sometimes difficult for her to navigate on her own.
The pacing is great and it’s brimming with heart and humour. I can’t wait to read what Mizzy gets up to next!
August 4, 2025
Thank you to Net Galley for providing me with an arc of this book for my unbiased review. Mizzy is a middle schooler who lives to solve mysteries. The fact that she also has Down’s Syndrome does not stop Mizzy from her mission to solve a long held secret family mystery. Lived this book and Mizzy’s spunk! Great middle grade fiction. Highly recommend.
June 15, 2025
I hope this book is part of a brand new detective series because I absolutely adored the main character, Mizzy and want to read her solving more mysteries!
She’s a feisty, nearly 13 year old girl who just happens to have Down’s Syndrome. She wants to be a marvellous detective although her family think she’s more like her dad’s (Great) Aunt Jane, the village busybody. To date she hasn’t solved a single mystery although that might change when the holidays start.
Mizzy spends every summer with her (second) cousins, Oli and Finn in St Jude’s Junction. However, this summer everyone’s grown up and no-one has time for Mizzy, not even sweet Auntie G. This might have ruined Mizzy’s holiday were it not for the fact that she stumbles upon Great Aunt Jane’s missing diaries. It transpires that somebody actually poisoned the old relative and she didn’t just die in her sleep.
An interesting mystery that made me laugh out loud at times. I totally understood Mix’s fear of escalators because I was the same growing up.
I would recommend this book to fans of Melissa Savage, Enid Blyton and Lauren St John and Lauren Child. Mizzy reminded me of a young Miss Marple and Columbo.
She’s a feisty, nearly 13 year old girl who just happens to have Down’s Syndrome. She wants to be a marvellous detective although her family think she’s more like her dad’s (Great) Aunt Jane, the village busybody. To date she hasn’t solved a single mystery although that might change when the holidays start.
Mizzy spends every summer with her (second) cousins, Oli and Finn in St Jude’s Junction. However, this summer everyone’s grown up and no-one has time for Mizzy, not even sweet Auntie G. This might have ruined Mizzy’s holiday were it not for the fact that she stumbles upon Great Aunt Jane’s missing diaries. It transpires that somebody actually poisoned the old relative and she didn’t just die in her sleep.
An interesting mystery that made me laugh out loud at times. I totally understood Mix’s fear of escalators because I was the same growing up.
I would recommend this book to fans of Melissa Savage, Enid Blyton and Lauren St John and Lauren Child. Mizzy reminded me of a young Miss Marple and Columbo.
September 20, 2025
Book: A Skeleton in the Closet
Author: Claire Hatcher-Smith
Rating: 4/5 stars
Mizzy the Marvellous is on the case in A Skeleton in the Closet…or at least she’s trying her best to be!
A Skeleton in the Closet is a brand-new middle-grade mystery novel that features 12 3/4-year-old Mizzy as the main character. Mizzy has Down syndrome and is trying her best to be a detective that can prove to her family she can solve mysteries and that she is no longer a baby. She doesn’t plan on letting anything, including her disability, get in the way of her detective work. By using her imagination, strong detective skills, and Pip Squeak markers, she plans on proving that she is the right fit for any case.
Mizzy is sent to St. Jude’s Junction to spend the summer with her aunt, uncle, and cousins. Mizzy is thrilled to visit them but finds out that everyone is either too busy or too grown up to spend time with her like they have in previous years. During her boredom, Mizzy discovers old diaries from an aunt who had passed away years ago locked in a wardrobe in the spare room she is staying in. This means that a new case could be on the horizon! After reading Great Aunt Jane’s diaries, Mizzy believes that she might have actually been murdered, and she decides to take it upon herself to investigate and find out what really happened to her. With her new notebook and Pip Squeak Markers, she begins her investigation by first questioning her family members to try and get to the bottom of what really happened all those years ago.
Right from the first page, Mizzy is a spunky and strong character. She is strong in who she is as a person and won’t let anyone stand in her way. I found myself laughing out loud a few times at things that Mizzy said or at her internal thoughts. Although she is almost 13, she has a large personality!
I thought that the representation in the book was wonderfully done. I thought that reading a book with a main character who has Down syndrome was refreshing, and Mizzy is a great example of a heroine for younger readers to root for!
While reading, I guessed a few elements of the mystery, but I wasn’t expecting all the twists and turns! I enjoyed how the mystery played out, as it kept me guessing while reading.
A Skeleton in the Closet is a middle-grade novel, but there are some mature topics that are touched upon. I would advise parents to check content warnings beforehand for younger readers.
This was the first book by the author featuring Mizzy and her mysteries. I look forward to seeing what mysteries and adventures she will be going on and solving in the future! I also hope that some of her family and friends will help her out more in the future with her future investigations and believe in her a bit more with the way she proved herself with the mystery in this book.
Thank you to Tundra Books, Penguin Teen Canada, and Tandem Collective Global for the copy of A Skeleton in the Closet and for hosting the readalong that I took part in!
Author: Claire Hatcher-Smith
Rating: 4/5 stars
Mizzy the Marvellous is on the case in A Skeleton in the Closet…or at least she’s trying her best to be!
A Skeleton in the Closet is a brand-new middle-grade mystery novel that features 12 3/4-year-old Mizzy as the main character. Mizzy has Down syndrome and is trying her best to be a detective that can prove to her family she can solve mysteries and that she is no longer a baby. She doesn’t plan on letting anything, including her disability, get in the way of her detective work. By using her imagination, strong detective skills, and Pip Squeak markers, she plans on proving that she is the right fit for any case.
Mizzy is sent to St. Jude’s Junction to spend the summer with her aunt, uncle, and cousins. Mizzy is thrilled to visit them but finds out that everyone is either too busy or too grown up to spend time with her like they have in previous years. During her boredom, Mizzy discovers old diaries from an aunt who had passed away years ago locked in a wardrobe in the spare room she is staying in. This means that a new case could be on the horizon! After reading Great Aunt Jane’s diaries, Mizzy believes that she might have actually been murdered, and she decides to take it upon herself to investigate and find out what really happened to her. With her new notebook and Pip Squeak Markers, she begins her investigation by first questioning her family members to try and get to the bottom of what really happened all those years ago.
Right from the first page, Mizzy is a spunky and strong character. She is strong in who she is as a person and won’t let anyone stand in her way. I found myself laughing out loud a few times at things that Mizzy said or at her internal thoughts. Although she is almost 13, she has a large personality!
I thought that the representation in the book was wonderfully done. I thought that reading a book with a main character who has Down syndrome was refreshing, and Mizzy is a great example of a heroine for younger readers to root for!
While reading, I guessed a few elements of the mystery, but I wasn’t expecting all the twists and turns! I enjoyed how the mystery played out, as it kept me guessing while reading.
A Skeleton in the Closet is a middle-grade novel, but there are some mature topics that are touched upon. I would advise parents to check content warnings beforehand for younger readers.
This was the first book by the author featuring Mizzy and her mysteries. I look forward to seeing what mysteries and adventures she will be going on and solving in the future! I also hope that some of her family and friends will help her out more in the future with her future investigations and believe in her a bit more with the way she proved herself with the mystery in this book.
Thank you to Tundra Books, Penguin Teen Canada, and Tandem Collective Global for the copy of A Skeleton in the Closet and for hosting the readalong that I took part in!
August 25, 2025
Mizzy is twelve and ¾ years old.. yes it has to be specific. She dreams of becoming a detective. Her down syndrome is not the issue, issue is the lack of a case. She has a beautiful and close knit family. But every family has secrets. Mizzy’s too. So when in summer holidays at her cousins’ place, she finds a mystery, she jumps right it. Will she able to solve it? What family secrets are buried in the closet? Will Mizzy be able to overcome her fears? Read this to find out.
Mizzy is a bright and intelligent young girl who does not let her disability come in between to achieve her dreams. She is a keen observer just like her great aunt Jane. Readers learn to appreciate family and bondings. Small victories are equally important as the big ones.
It’s a cozy mystery. Once you start, it will be hard to put it down. Language is easy and settings are lovely. Characters are wonderful and their growth is good as per the children’s story. Can be read in one sitting.
I thoroughly enjoyed it. A perfect read for a rainy day at home. I’m looking forward to read more of Mizzy’s adventures. Hopefully Oli will also join her this time from the beginning. Liked their cousin bonding.
Highly recommend!! If you like cozy mystery set in a small town, then it is the perfect fit. It can be enjoyed by both kids and adults alike. Go for it.
Mizzy is a bright and intelligent young girl who does not let her disability come in between to achieve her dreams. She is a keen observer just like her great aunt Jane. Readers learn to appreciate family and bondings. Small victories are equally important as the big ones.
It’s a cozy mystery. Once you start, it will be hard to put it down. Language is easy and settings are lovely. Characters are wonderful and their growth is good as per the children’s story. Can be read in one sitting.
I thoroughly enjoyed it. A perfect read for a rainy day at home. I’m looking forward to read more of Mizzy’s adventures. Hopefully Oli will also join her this time from the beginning. Liked their cousin bonding.
Highly recommend!! If you like cozy mystery set in a small town, then it is the perfect fit. It can be enjoyed by both kids and adults alike. Go for it.
August 24, 2025
Mizzy is thrilled to be going to visit her favorite cousins over the school holidays, but her cousins seem to have outgrown her. Not one to let Down's syndrome keep her from having a good time, Mizzy instead starts investigating the spare room and finds a decades-old murder just waiting for her to solve.
I picked this book up because I was looking for good representation for Down's, and I'm pretty pleased to say I got what I came for. This book does a great job noting Mizzy's limitations and accommodations without being pitying. It's clear that Mizzy thinks a little differently than the average kid, but we get to see her poking at stereotypes and reminding us of how human she is. The mystery is suitably twisty, reminding me of a classic cozy mystery but making room for a strong character arc. The writing style is engaging, and Mizzy has a strong literary voice that I won't forget anytime soon.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC. All opinions are my own.
I picked this book up because I was looking for good representation for Down's, and I'm pretty pleased to say I got what I came for. This book does a great job noting Mizzy's limitations and accommodations without being pitying. It's clear that Mizzy thinks a little differently than the average kid, but we get to see her poking at stereotypes and reminding us of how human she is. The mystery is suitably twisty, reminding me of a classic cozy mystery but making room for a strong character arc. The writing style is engaging, and Mizzy has a strong literary voice that I won't forget anytime soon.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC. All opinions are my own.
August 14, 2025
Mizzy is almost 13, and wishes people would stop treating her like a baby all the time. So what if she has Down's? She's super smart, and is determined to prove it. She and her cousins spend all of their holidays playing detective, and this time, she's determined to be Sherlock and not Watson. Problem is, when Mizzy arrives, she finds that her cousins have abruptly outgrown her. Nicky is always out or on his phone, and Ollie [I think those are the names] has grown about a foot and is always off to football. They have no interest in detective games anymore, or in Mizzy. Depressed, she's rooting around in the spare bedroom she's staying in, when she finds her great aunt Jane's journals. Jane died in 1974, in her sleep, but Mizzy learns that, wait, her death might have been suspicious. A mystery! Mizzy is determined to solve it on her own and show everyone how smart she is. Pretending to research a family tree project, she starts interviewing her family members--and getting some interesting reactions. Just what is the skeleton in the closet?
This turned out to be quite the twisty mystery, and I didn't guess the ending, which makes for a good mystery in my book! Mizzy is a determined and resourceful character, and though she makes a lot of mistakes and causes a lot of trouble--mostly for herself--she doesn't give up. The clues are well-presented here, and they all track. I did sometimes get confused by the plethora of family members, but I got it sorted out in the end. I thought the author did a great job of giving voice to a character with Down's, though I don't believe this is an #ownvoices author? The representation is awesome, though. I listened to the audiobook, which is narrated by a person with Down's; it took some getting used to, but it did give a lot of depth to the protagonist and her story. Thanks to Libro.FM for a free educator copy of the audiobook.
This turned out to be quite the twisty mystery, and I didn't guess the ending, which makes for a good mystery in my book! Mizzy is a determined and resourceful character, and though she makes a lot of mistakes and causes a lot of trouble--mostly for herself--she doesn't give up. The clues are well-presented here, and they all track. I did sometimes get confused by the plethora of family members, but I got it sorted out in the end. I thought the author did a great job of giving voice to a character with Down's, though I don't believe this is an #ownvoices author? The representation is awesome, though. I listened to the audiobook, which is narrated by a person with Down's; it took some getting used to, but it did give a lot of depth to the protagonist and her story. Thanks to Libro.FM for a free educator copy of the audiobook.
August 4, 2025
Honestly, I would probably have given the plotline a four, but it gets some major bonus points. I am so thankful for Libro FM for this free ALC!
Not only is this an adorable mystery, but it is told from the perspective of a girl who has down syndrome and feels like no one in her family believes her nor thinks she is capable. I particularly appreciated that the audiobook narrator also had down syndrome.
Not only is this an adorable mystery, but it is told from the perspective of a girl who has down syndrome and feels like no one in her family believes her nor thinks she is capable. I particularly appreciated that the audiobook narrator also had down syndrome.
August 3, 2025
Solid read! Cozy mystery and an endearing yet fierce main character who knows what she’s worth and how she wants to be treated and refuses to accept anything less. Lots of family secrets. Love the representation in this book. We need more downs rep!
May 18, 2025
I quite enjoyed this book. It was very well written, however the family bit was quite confusing at some points in the book.
Mizzy has a knack for finding little tiny mysteries to solve. Even if it’s just someone taking something out a bag, she’s always observing everything. However, when she figures out that someone killed Aunt Jane, she won’t let anyone get in her way of figuring whodunnit. Not her reputation of tall tales, not her slightly embarrassing fear of escalators, and definitely not her Down Syndrome. She has the perfect excuse; she is doing a family tree project for school, so she can easily get around and ask people strange questions. She is very determined to solve the case, and prove that she is not Mizzy, but Mizzy the Marvellous Detective
I enjoyed this murder mystery novel. It was quite funny at some points, and I liked the story line, the family tree did confuse me at some points, and I feel like that the family could be made a bit smaller. Other than that, this book was amazing! I liked Mizzy’s personality, and I thought it was quite interesting because I have never read a book with a protagonist who had Down Syndrome, which I think we need to write more about, as this needs to be seen more, as it will make more people be heard and seen. Overall, I would definitely recommend this book!
Mizzy has a knack for finding little tiny mysteries to solve. Even if it’s just someone taking something out a bag, she’s always observing everything. However, when she figures out that someone killed Aunt Jane, she won’t let anyone get in her way of figuring whodunnit. Not her reputation of tall tales, not her slightly embarrassing fear of escalators, and definitely not her Down Syndrome. She has the perfect excuse; she is doing a family tree project for school, so she can easily get around and ask people strange questions. She is very determined to solve the case, and prove that she is not Mizzy, but Mizzy the Marvellous Detective
I enjoyed this murder mystery novel. It was quite funny at some points, and I liked the story line, the family tree did confuse me at some points, and I feel like that the family could be made a bit smaller. Other than that, this book was amazing! I liked Mizzy’s personality, and I thought it was quite interesting because I have never read a book with a protagonist who had Down Syndrome, which I think we need to write more about, as this needs to be seen more, as it will make more people be heard and seen. Overall, I would definitely recommend this book!
June 14, 2025
This engaging and refreshing murder mystery follows Mizzy, a 12-year-old neurodivergent heroine with Down's syndrome, as she becomes an incredible detective. The author captures her experiences and perspectives beautifully, making her an easy character to root for.
The mystery is a rollercoaster of surprises, with a skeleton in the closet that kept me guessing until the end. The plot is fun and complex, yet easy enough for younger readers to follow while still keeping adults entertained.
The book features dynamic illustrations that bring the characters and scenes to life, enhancing the mood of the mystery.
The book is about embracing individuality, overcoming challenges, and uncovering the truth.
Mizzy is a relatable and inspiring protagonist, breaking stereotypes and offering representation for neurodivergent individuals.
The story explores themes of family, acceptance, and self-belief, providing valuable lessons for readers.
The book has an engaging and twisty plot suitable for middle-grade readers with engaging and accessible narrative, making it a great read for young and adult mystery enthusiasts.
The mystery is a rollercoaster of surprises, with a skeleton in the closet that kept me guessing until the end. The plot is fun and complex, yet easy enough for younger readers to follow while still keeping adults entertained.
The book features dynamic illustrations that bring the characters and scenes to life, enhancing the mood of the mystery.
The book is about embracing individuality, overcoming challenges, and uncovering the truth.
Mizzy is a relatable and inspiring protagonist, breaking stereotypes and offering representation for neurodivergent individuals.
The story explores themes of family, acceptance, and self-belief, providing valuable lessons for readers.
The book has an engaging and twisty plot suitable for middle-grade readers with engaging and accessible narrative, making it a great read for young and adult mystery enthusiasts.
April 9, 2025
Oh, I loved this one. Mizzy is such a wonderful protagonist. You really get a sense of how capable she is and how frustrating she finds it to be underestimated by her family, who are sometimes guilty of treating her first and foremost as someone with Down syndrome rather than as a nearly teenage girl. And her sense of being left behind as her cousins seem to outgrow the detective games they used to play together is very well done.
The murder mystery that Mizzy sets out to solve is also really satisfying. It resolves itself in a way that works perfectly and I also loved the nods to Agatha Christie for the adult readers: Great Aunt Jane 'Maypole', who was a gossip or a keen observer of human life (depending who you ask), and whose long-ago death is the one being investigated; her nephew Raymond, the famous author; and her housekeeper Cherry Butcher (or is it Baker?).
I would definitely recommend this book to young readers who like mysteries or real-life stories or both.
The murder mystery that Mizzy sets out to solve is also really satisfying. It resolves itself in a way that works perfectly and I also loved the nods to Agatha Christie for the adult readers: Great Aunt Jane 'Maypole', who was a gossip or a keen observer of human life (depending who you ask), and whose long-ago death is the one being investigated; her nephew Raymond, the famous author; and her housekeeper Cherry Butcher (or is it Baker?).
I would definitely recommend this book to young readers who like mysteries or real-life stories or both.
March 6, 2025
This is a book that NEEDS listening to! I don't think I've ever had a more impactful audiobook, and I listen to a lot of books!
The thing about this book is that Mizzy has Down's Syndrome and in the printed book version, I think that'll get lost after the first couple of chapters. In this audio version, the narrator also has Down's Syndrome, so you never lose sight of it and really it's a big part of the plot.
Mizzy wants to be a detective. She's also (like most 12yo) desperate to grow up. Her summer is NOT going to plan. In fact, the further into the summer we get, the worse things become. There are laugh-out-loud moments and "Nooooooo" moments.
Poppy Mae Barrett really brings Mizzy to life and I can't wait to see if there will be more.
The thing about this book is that Mizzy has Down's Syndrome and in the printed book version, I think that'll get lost after the first couple of chapters. In this audio version, the narrator also has Down's Syndrome, so you never lose sight of it and really it's a big part of the plot.
Mizzy wants to be a detective. She's also (like most 12yo) desperate to grow up. Her summer is NOT going to plan. In fact, the further into the summer we get, the worse things become. There are laugh-out-loud moments and "Nooooooo" moments.
Poppy Mae Barrett really brings Mizzy to life and I can't wait to see if there will be more.
May 18, 2025
Claire Hatcher-Smith's debut novel, "A Skeleton in the Closet," skillfully explores the complexities of the mystery genre, presenting a sophisticated combination of detailed character development and intriguing plot twists that keep readers engaged. The author expertly weaves a narrative rich in suspense and introspective moments, encouraging readers to delve deeper into the storyline and the characters' lives, prompting reflection on profound themes and emotions throughout the tale.
The characters in this novel are exceptionally well-developed, each possessing unique traits and backstories that ensure readers will find someone relatable. Mizzy, the protagonist and aspiring detective, stands out as a symbol of the idea that anyone, regardless of background or experience, can become a keen observer and detective with dedication and self-belief, inspired by legendary figures like Rachel Bailey, Sherlock Holmes, and Dr. Watson. Through Mizzy's perspective, readers witness her growth and determination as she navigates the complexities of her investigations. Her family members add a delightful layer of humor, relatability, and intrigue to the narrative, grounding the story and enhancing its authenticity. Each family member contributes to the overall dynamic, enriching the plot and providing moments of levity amidst the mystery's tension.
The novel's UK settings are vividly depicted, allowing readers to visualize the scenes clearly while leaving room for personal imagination. Hatcher-Smith's writing is engaging and detailed, creating an immersive world for readers. However, some of the dialogue may present challenges for younger readers, potentially requiring guidance from guardians to assist with language or conversational nuances. This aspect of the narrative offers a valuable opportunity for discussion and language exploration, fostering a deeper understanding of the text.
The plot is a delightful blend of entertainment, humor, and creativity. While some elements may be somewhat predictable, numerous twists and turns keep readers eager to solve the mystery alongside Mizzy. The book effectively maintains reader interest by allowing them to deduce clues with the protagonist, creating an immersive experience that gives them a sense of agency in the detective work. Additionally, the novel sensitively addresses significant topics such as Down Syndrome and Alzheimer's/memory loss, highlighting how perceived disadvantages can also manifest as strengths. This exploration challenges societal assumptions about disabilities, offering a nuanced and compassionate perspective on these important issues.
The narrative also explores the complexities of family relationships, illustrating how family secrets can lead to miscommunication, conflicts, and intriguing mysteries among loved ones. This emphasis on understanding all facts before making assumptions and the value of open communication resonates deeply with readers, encouraging them to reflect on their own relationships and family dynamics.
"A Skeleton in the Closet" by Claire Hatcher-Smith is not just an engaging middle-grade mystery; it is a multifaceted narrative that offers insights into living with Down Syndrome while inviting readers to join the detective journey alongside the main characters. Through Mizzy's adventures and the lessons learned, readers are encouraged to embrace curiosity, empathy, and the pursuit of truth, making this novel a meaningful addition to the genre that resonates with audiences of all ages. Stay tuned to the author's website to discover what mystery Mizzy will solve next in this series.
I extend my gratitude to NetGalley, Claire Hatcher-Smith, and Tundra for providing a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
The characters in this novel are exceptionally well-developed, each possessing unique traits and backstories that ensure readers will find someone relatable. Mizzy, the protagonist and aspiring detective, stands out as a symbol of the idea that anyone, regardless of background or experience, can become a keen observer and detective with dedication and self-belief, inspired by legendary figures like Rachel Bailey, Sherlock Holmes, and Dr. Watson. Through Mizzy's perspective, readers witness her growth and determination as she navigates the complexities of her investigations. Her family members add a delightful layer of humor, relatability, and intrigue to the narrative, grounding the story and enhancing its authenticity. Each family member contributes to the overall dynamic, enriching the plot and providing moments of levity amidst the mystery's tension.
The novel's UK settings are vividly depicted, allowing readers to visualize the scenes clearly while leaving room for personal imagination. Hatcher-Smith's writing is engaging and detailed, creating an immersive world for readers. However, some of the dialogue may present challenges for younger readers, potentially requiring guidance from guardians to assist with language or conversational nuances. This aspect of the narrative offers a valuable opportunity for discussion and language exploration, fostering a deeper understanding of the text.
The plot is a delightful blend of entertainment, humor, and creativity. While some elements may be somewhat predictable, numerous twists and turns keep readers eager to solve the mystery alongside Mizzy. The book effectively maintains reader interest by allowing them to deduce clues with the protagonist, creating an immersive experience that gives them a sense of agency in the detective work. Additionally, the novel sensitively addresses significant topics such as Down Syndrome and Alzheimer's/memory loss, highlighting how perceived disadvantages can also manifest as strengths. This exploration challenges societal assumptions about disabilities, offering a nuanced and compassionate perspective on these important issues.
The narrative also explores the complexities of family relationships, illustrating how family secrets can lead to miscommunication, conflicts, and intriguing mysteries among loved ones. This emphasis on understanding all facts before making assumptions and the value of open communication resonates deeply with readers, encouraging them to reflect on their own relationships and family dynamics.
"A Skeleton in the Closet" by Claire Hatcher-Smith is not just an engaging middle-grade mystery; it is a multifaceted narrative that offers insights into living with Down Syndrome while inviting readers to join the detective journey alongside the main characters. Through Mizzy's adventures and the lessons learned, readers are encouraged to embrace curiosity, empathy, and the pursuit of truth, making this novel a meaningful addition to the genre that resonates with audiences of all ages. Stay tuned to the author's website to discover what mystery Mizzy will solve next in this series.
I extend my gratitude to NetGalley, Claire Hatcher-Smith, and Tundra for providing a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
September 9, 2025
What worked:
Mizzy views herself as a detective, even though she often comes to the wrong conclusions. Initially, the plot takes on a little-boy-who-cried-wolf vibe, as other family members know how she tends to exaggerate. However, Mizzy notices things that others might miss, and she’s very curious. She’s constantly looking for mysteries to solve, which means she’s ready for clues hidden in a locked wardrobe. Readers know Mizzy has Down syndrome, but they may forget that fact as the story unfolds. Down syndrome causes her poor spelling, but she still follows the process of identifying suspects, collecting clues, and considering suspects’ motives. The story is told from Mizzy’s point of view, so readers understand that she feels underappreciated and wants to prove herself to her family.
Great Aunt Jane’s death might, or might not, be an actual mystery, as everyone seems to agree she died in her sleep. Her diary says she had important news to reveal at a family gathering, but she never got the chance. The last diary entry, torn from the book, says she might have been poisoned, but there’s still a possibility Mizzy is jumping to conclusions, again. Clues are hard to find since Great Aunt Jane passed away in 1973. The only suspects are family members, but why would any of them want to commit murder?
What didn’t work as well:
The mystery is restricted due to the age of the case, the few suspects, and the limited motives. Mizzy doesn’t have any special detective training, and she makes investigative mistakes along the way. Her persistence and determination are key character traits, but readers may think she lucks into solving the mystery.
The final verdict:
There aren’t many books featuring characters with Down syndrome, and Mizzy highlights her independence and capabilities. The last fourth of the story is full of developments, as new information is revealed. The story may be more about family relationships than mystery, but I suggest you try it out for yourself.
Mizzy views herself as a detective, even though she often comes to the wrong conclusions. Initially, the plot takes on a little-boy-who-cried-wolf vibe, as other family members know how she tends to exaggerate. However, Mizzy notices things that others might miss, and she’s very curious. She’s constantly looking for mysteries to solve, which means she’s ready for clues hidden in a locked wardrobe. Readers know Mizzy has Down syndrome, but they may forget that fact as the story unfolds. Down syndrome causes her poor spelling, but she still follows the process of identifying suspects, collecting clues, and considering suspects’ motives. The story is told from Mizzy’s point of view, so readers understand that she feels underappreciated and wants to prove herself to her family.
Great Aunt Jane’s death might, or might not, be an actual mystery, as everyone seems to agree she died in her sleep. Her diary says she had important news to reveal at a family gathering, but she never got the chance. The last diary entry, torn from the book, says she might have been poisoned, but there’s still a possibility Mizzy is jumping to conclusions, again. Clues are hard to find since Great Aunt Jane passed away in 1973. The only suspects are family members, but why would any of them want to commit murder?
What didn’t work as well:
The mystery is restricted due to the age of the case, the few suspects, and the limited motives. Mizzy doesn’t have any special detective training, and she makes investigative mistakes along the way. Her persistence and determination are key character traits, but readers may think she lucks into solving the mystery.
The final verdict:
There aren’t many books featuring characters with Down syndrome, and Mizzy highlights her independence and capabilities. The last fourth of the story is full of developments, as new information is revealed. The story may be more about family relationships than mystery, but I suggest you try it out for yourself.
November 10, 2025
3.5 Stars. Mystery isn’t a genre I reach for all that often, but this one stood out for its heroine, twelve year old Mizzy has down syndrome, and over the course of the story you get to see the sorts of things she struggles with, her insecurities, some moments where she loses her cool, and more so, moments where you get to see how capable she is.
I tend to like to dive into a character’s personal life a bit, so I definitely would have liked a few more conversations that didn’t revolve around the mystery, like maybe Mizzy talking with Oli about growing apart, and I especially wanted more exchanges with the parents. I don’t mean I needed scenes where they’re the ideal warm fuzzy parents who always say the right things, it’s realistic that they’re busy, that they care yet they don’t see their child as she wants to be seen, but when she breaks their rules, when she spends the entire book telling the reader she doesn’t want to be babied, when her first foray into makeup doesn’t go well, etc., I want some discussions between Mizzy and her parents about these relatable things most kids go through, but their interractions were few and far between.
That’s the kind of stuff I like to read about, but most readers will be here mainly for the mystery, and this delivers on that. There are a few twists along the way and plenty of suspects, all of whom are Mizzy’s family and none of them are outright villains, so that keeps things intriguing. I also liked that the situation is fairly tangled and complicated, it didn’t feel like the author wrote down to her young audience, and when I was a kid that’s something I would have appreciated.
I received this book through a giveaway
I tend to like to dive into a character’s personal life a bit, so I definitely would have liked a few more conversations that didn’t revolve around the mystery, like maybe Mizzy talking with Oli about growing apart, and I especially wanted more exchanges with the parents. I don’t mean I needed scenes where they’re the ideal warm fuzzy parents who always say the right things, it’s realistic that they’re busy, that they care yet they don’t see their child as she wants to be seen, but when she breaks their rules, when she spends the entire book telling the reader she doesn’t want to be babied, when her first foray into makeup doesn’t go well, etc., I want some discussions between Mizzy and her parents about these relatable things most kids go through, but their interractions were few and far between.
That’s the kind of stuff I like to read about, but most readers will be here mainly for the mystery, and this delivers on that. There are a few twists along the way and plenty of suspects, all of whom are Mizzy’s family and none of them are outright villains, so that keeps things intriguing. I also liked that the situation is fairly tangled and complicated, it didn’t feel like the author wrote down to her young audience, and when I was a kid that’s something I would have appreciated.
I received this book through a giveaway
November 18, 2025
I really enjoyed The Mizzy Mysteries: A Skeleton in the Closet, especially because Mizzy feels like a real kid detective, not a perfect pint-sized prodigy like Nancy Drew. She makes mistakes, misreads situations, and even upsets people along the way: exactly what you’d expect from a curious twelve-year-old poking around old family secrets. The details about challenges she faced as a person with Down Syndrome and her feelings that everyone treats her like a baby helped me get to know Mizzy. I hadn’t read a book from the perspective of someone with Down Syndrome before, and I liked that her disability didn’t define her character. Throughout the book, she was curious and interested in understanding how this mystery fit into her family dynamics. She seemed like a very authentic character in a way that made the story compelling.
The extended family she interacts with is a wonderfully eccentric bunch, and their quirks keep the story interesting. However, with so many characters, it was hard to get enough information to feel like I really knew any of them. The family tree illustrations (presented as Mizzy’s drawings) throughout the book were a lot of fun and helped me keep track of everyone involved.
One of my favorite parts was the British setting and voice. The London details and British-isms gave the story charm, though I can imagine many young American readers struggling if they don’t have much background knowledge about the UK. Still, it added a lot of personality to the book.
Overall, this is an engaging mystery with a refreshingly realistic heroine. It is a strong start for an appealing mystery series for middle grade readers.
I received my copy of this book through the LibraryThing Early Reviewers Program in exchange for providing an honest review.
The extended family she interacts with is a wonderfully eccentric bunch, and their quirks keep the story interesting. However, with so many characters, it was hard to get enough information to feel like I really knew any of them. The family tree illustrations (presented as Mizzy’s drawings) throughout the book were a lot of fun and helped me keep track of everyone involved.
One of my favorite parts was the British setting and voice. The London details and British-isms gave the story charm, though I can imagine many young American readers struggling if they don’t have much background knowledge about the UK. Still, it added a lot of personality to the book.
Overall, this is an engaging mystery with a refreshingly realistic heroine. It is a strong start for an appealing mystery series for middle grade readers.
I received my copy of this book through the LibraryThing Early Reviewers Program in exchange for providing an honest review.
September 11, 2025
I was very excited to be asked to participate in a Tandem read along for A Skeleton in the Closet as the main character has Down syndrome, similar to one of my nephews, and I want him to grow up seeing himself represented in books, movies and advertisements where people such as himself are thriving and living fulfilling lives.
This was a middle grade read about Mizzy, a girl who wants to be treated like every other almost-thirteen-year-old and who doesn’t want limitations placed on her based on other people’s assumptions about what she can or can’t do. While the characters and family dynamic were quirky, and the mystery was clever, I was a bit dismayed at everyone treating Mizzy like a much younger child than her 12 year old counterparts, which I know is a situation people with Down syndrome are often found in.
I would have really liked to have at least one character that trusted Mizzy and let her have some autonomy within reason, and to watch her flourish and become more confident in herself. I think if she had that person in her life, she wouldn’t doubt herself and her abilities. It would have been a great way to show that people who have Down syndrome can do many things, and that society does not need to impose constraints due perceived inabilities.
This was a 2.5 rounded up.
AD-PR Product
This was a middle grade read about Mizzy, a girl who wants to be treated like every other almost-thirteen-year-old and who doesn’t want limitations placed on her based on other people’s assumptions about what she can or can’t do. While the characters and family dynamic were quirky, and the mystery was clever, I was a bit dismayed at everyone treating Mizzy like a much younger child than her 12 year old counterparts, which I know is a situation people with Down syndrome are often found in.
I would have really liked to have at least one character that trusted Mizzy and let her have some autonomy within reason, and to watch her flourish and become more confident in herself. I think if she had that person in her life, she wouldn’t doubt herself and her abilities. It would have been a great way to show that people who have Down syndrome can do many things, and that society does not need to impose constraints due perceived inabilities.
This was a 2.5 rounded up.
AD-PR Product
December 19, 2025
I didn't particularly like this book. I liked the main character, Mizzy, and learning about her Down Syndrome was interesting - I love to see representation in books, especially books aimed at children.
However, I didn't like the overall story. I did not find the mystery particularly interesting, and when the mystery was solved I was a little unfulfilled. I personally didn't like the wrap up at the end either, I thought it was a bit morally vague. Grandma Mabel and Lionel committed an accident 50 years ago which may have ended in someone's death, and it's treated almost lightheartedly. Maybe I'm missing something, but it didn't sit right with me.
Also, I worry about the wheelchair that was left in the Underground. Where did that go? What if you were a permanent wheelchair user and you got off at that station with a non-working lift - what would you do? I thought they would have had more lifts that they could possibly take, so as things like that do not happen, though I think this was written in so Mizzy could face her fear of escalators.
Overall, I'm sad that I didn't like it, because it could've been an incredible introduction to the world of Mizzy! But for me, it just fell a bit flat.
However, I didn't like the overall story. I did not find the mystery particularly interesting, and when the mystery was solved I was a little unfulfilled. I personally didn't like the wrap up at the end either, I thought it was a bit morally vague. Grandma Mabel and Lionel committed an accident 50 years ago which may have ended in someone's death, and it's treated almost lightheartedly. Maybe I'm missing something, but it didn't sit right with me.
Also, I worry about the wheelchair that was left in the Underground. Where did that go? What if you were a permanent wheelchair user and you got off at that station with a non-working lift - what would you do? I thought they would have had more lifts that they could possibly take, so as things like that do not happen, though I think this was written in so Mizzy could face her fear of escalators.
Overall, I'm sad that I didn't like it, because it could've been an incredible introduction to the world of Mizzy! But for me, it just fell a bit flat.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 17, 2025
“𝐆𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐭 𝐀𝐮𝐧𝐭 𝐉𝐚𝐧𝐞’𝐬 𝐝𝐢𝐚𝐫𝐢𝐞𝐬 𝐚𝐫𝐞 𝐦𝐲𝐬𝐭𝐞𝐫𝐲 𝐚𝐥𝐥 𝐨𝐟 𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐢𝐫 𝐨𝐰𝐧. 𝐈 𝐦𝐞𝐚𝐧, 𝐰𝐡𝐲 𝐰𝐞𝐫𝐞 𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐲 𝐥𝐨𝐜𝐤𝐞𝐝 𝐚𝐰𝐚𝐲? 𝐖𝐡𝐲 𝐰𝐚𝐬 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐤𝐞𝐲 𝐡𝐢𝐝𝐝𝐞𝐧? 𝐔𝐧𝐥𝐞𝐬𝐬 𝐬𝐡𝐞 𝐰𝐫𝐨𝐭𝐞 𝐬𝐨𝐦𝐞𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐧𝐨 𝐨𝐧𝐞 𝐰𝐚𝐬 𝐬𝐮𝐩𝐩𝐨𝐬𝐞𝐝 𝐭𝐨 𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐝. 𝐋𝐢𝐤𝐞 𝐚 𝐝𝐢𝐟𝐟𝐞𝐫𝐞𝐧𝐭 𝐬𝐨𝐫𝐭 𝐨𝐟 𝐬𝐤𝐞𝐥𝐞𝐭𝐨𝐧 𝐢𝐧 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐜𝐥𝐨𝐬𝐞𝐭. 𝐀 𝐬𝐞𝐜𝐫𝐞𝐭.”
Mizzy is a detective that readers of all ages will love!
When 12 year old Mizzy discovers her Great Aunt Jane's missing diaries in a forgotten locked wardrobe, she discovers that Great Aunt Jane's death may not have been natural, and that one of her family members might be responsible! Will Mizzy be able to piece it all together and prove that she truly is Mizzy the Marvellous to her family?!
Mizzy is observant, curious and loyal; having Down Syndrome only makes her more determined to prove her independence, especially when the people around her treat her like she is younger than her actual age. I adore her cousin, Oli, who makes a great teammate in supporting Mizzy (eventually), and their friendship felt very realistic. The setting of St. Jude's Junction has an Agatha Christie St. Mary's Mead-like quality to it with its cozy village vibes, that juxtaposes well with the busy moments set in London. The mystery of Great Aunt Jane's death, and all the family secrets surrounding it, is solid, keeping you getting as Mizzy uncovers the truth and encounters real danger with a culprit who is definitely cunning. I loved the Down Syndrome representation, but wish Mizzy had even one person who trusts her instincts and encourages her independence to give her the support she needs. Hopefully that trust will be developed in further stories.
A Skeleton In The Closet is a great middle grade read with a unique and loveable protagonist, lots of questionable suspects, and an intriguing mystery. It will make a great addition to my classroom library. Thank you to Tundra Books and Tandem Global Collective for the gifted copy!
Mizzy is a detective that readers of all ages will love!
When 12 year old Mizzy discovers her Great Aunt Jane's missing diaries in a forgotten locked wardrobe, she discovers that Great Aunt Jane's death may not have been natural, and that one of her family members might be responsible! Will Mizzy be able to piece it all together and prove that she truly is Mizzy the Marvellous to her family?!
Mizzy is observant, curious and loyal; having Down Syndrome only makes her more determined to prove her independence, especially when the people around her treat her like she is younger than her actual age. I adore her cousin, Oli, who makes a great teammate in supporting Mizzy (eventually), and their friendship felt very realistic. The setting of St. Jude's Junction has an Agatha Christie St. Mary's Mead-like quality to it with its cozy village vibes, that juxtaposes well with the busy moments set in London. The mystery of Great Aunt Jane's death, and all the family secrets surrounding it, is solid, keeping you getting as Mizzy uncovers the truth and encounters real danger with a culprit who is definitely cunning. I loved the Down Syndrome representation, but wish Mizzy had even one person who trusts her instincts and encourages her independence to give her the support she needs. Hopefully that trust will be developed in further stories.
A Skeleton In The Closet is a great middle grade read with a unique and loveable protagonist, lots of questionable suspects, and an intriguing mystery. It will make a great addition to my classroom library. Thank you to Tundra Books and Tandem Global Collective for the gifted copy!
September 7, 2025
Mizzy is twelve, almost, thirteen, and looking forward to summer break when she can spend time with her cousins, Niko and Oli, who always play Sherlock and Watson games and Clue with her and watch mysteries on TV; Mizzy's greatest dream is to become a detective like Rachel Bailey on TV. However, this summer doesn't turn out to be anything like she imagined. Niko and Oli have grown beyond her and no one seems to think she can accomplish anything because of her Down Syndrome. Mizzy sets out to prove everyone wrong and does eventually figure out some family skeletons that no one else even noticed, except those most closely involved in the secrets. Mizzy's determination and persistence were heartwarming to read and I cheered her on through her struggles with feelings of wanting to be independent and accepted as well as her investigations.
March 13, 2025
There are so many things to love in this fantastic debut novel, but the one I loved most of all was Mizzy herself - indomitable, determined, courageous. I was very moved by the way Mizzy copes with the painful experience of feeling that her cousins, once dear friends, seem to have outgrown her and I could imagine how agonising that experience must be, especially for someone with Down’s syndrome who feels she’s being overprotected at the cost of growing up. But it’s not all doom and gloom by any stretch of the imagination - Mizzy sparkles through her investigation, carefully making notes and interviewing her colourful and suspicious family to find out what happened to Great Aunt Jane. It’s a wonderful story and I recommend it so highly.
May 29, 2025
Mizzy has dreams of being a detective. Yes, she has Down syndrome; yes, she is scared of escalators and swimming; but, she knows when there is a mystery afoot. When she stumbles upon her Great Aunt's missing diaries, she senses that her aunt was murdered - and by someone in her family.
I thought this was a really cute kids' mystery. I really liked that the narrator for the audiobook was intentionally chosen to be someone with Down syndrome to best represent Mizzy and her story. All of her great personality shown through. It seems like this could be the first in a new series, so it will be fun to see where Mizzy's stomach fizzies (how she knows a mystery is happening) take her next!
I received my copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
I thought this was a really cute kids' mystery. I really liked that the narrator for the audiobook was intentionally chosen to be someone with Down syndrome to best represent Mizzy and her story. All of her great personality shown through. It seems like this could be the first in a new series, so it will be fun to see where Mizzy's stomach fizzies (how she knows a mystery is happening) take her next!
I received my copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
June 16, 2025
Mizzy is almost 13 years old. She loves what a lot of others her age do. She has Down syndome, so life is more challenging. I love her personality and how observant she is about the world around her.
The book is very visual and the pacing is perfect. I was as excited as she was about the mysteries she wanted to solve.
The story and plot is also very immersive.
Poppy, the narrator, who also has Down syndrome, really brings Mizzy, who is already a well developed character, to life. I like the way that both Mizzy and Poppy have it. It makes the book even more inclusive.
I myself have disabilities (Cerebral Palsy and Hydrocephalus as well as visual disabilities and I am a wheelchair user), and I know how mean other kids, and adults can be and what it's like to feel misunderstood. Mizzy's condition is written about in such a sensitive, yet honest, way. That's something I really value.
A Skeleton in the Closet (Mizzy Mysteries #1) is such a great book and I'd recommend it to everyone, children and adults.
I wish it were around when I was growing up. I can't wait for the next book.
Thanks to Claire Hatcher-Smith and Farshore for my audiobook in exxchange for an honest and vluntary review.
5 stars
The book is very visual and the pacing is perfect. I was as excited as she was about the mysteries she wanted to solve.
The story and plot is also very immersive.
Poppy, the narrator, who also has Down syndrome, really brings Mizzy, who is already a well developed character, to life. I like the way that both Mizzy and Poppy have it. It makes the book even more inclusive.
I myself have disabilities (Cerebral Palsy and Hydrocephalus as well as visual disabilities and I am a wheelchair user), and I know how mean other kids, and adults can be and what it's like to feel misunderstood. Mizzy's condition is written about in such a sensitive, yet honest, way. That's something I really value.
A Skeleton in the Closet (Mizzy Mysteries #1) is such a great book and I'd recommend it to everyone, children and adults.
I wish it were around when I was growing up. I can't wait for the next book.
Thanks to Claire Hatcher-Smith and Farshore for my audiobook in exxchange for an honest and vluntary review.
5 stars
September 16, 2025
It was very nice to read a cozy middle grade mystery after a very, very long time.
The story revolves around the main character, Mizzy, who is tired of being treated like a baby. She is 12 and 3/4 and is looking for a way to prove herself to her family. She is a great detective and soon all her relatives will realize just how awesome she is. If only she could find a great mystery to solve…
It is during her summer break, at her most favourite place in the world, that she finally discovers something suspicious hidden in her late great aunt’s closet. What follows is a delightfully suspenseful investigation, often leading her to the “wrong end of the stick”. But Mizzy trusts her gut (or tummy lol) and carries on, determined to solve this age old mystery- all by herself!
I loved the cute drawings in this book. Mizzy’s character is so endearing, at times I felt bad for the way she was being treated by her parents and cousins. It is awful to need to prove yourself to your loved ones.
Would I recommend this book? Yes, however, I believe this will be better enjoyed by readers between 10-12. Overall, I really appreciated that the author has put the spotlight on Down syndrome; proving that nothing can hold you back and you are truly capable of doing great things.
The story revolves around the main character, Mizzy, who is tired of being treated like a baby. She is 12 and 3/4 and is looking for a way to prove herself to her family. She is a great detective and soon all her relatives will realize just how awesome she is. If only she could find a great mystery to solve…
It is during her summer break, at her most favourite place in the world, that she finally discovers something suspicious hidden in her late great aunt’s closet. What follows is a delightfully suspenseful investigation, often leading her to the “wrong end of the stick”. But Mizzy trusts her gut (or tummy lol) and carries on, determined to solve this age old mystery- all by herself!
I loved the cute drawings in this book. Mizzy’s character is so endearing, at times I felt bad for the way she was being treated by her parents and cousins. It is awful to need to prove yourself to your loved ones.
Would I recommend this book? Yes, however, I believe this will be better enjoyed by readers between 10-12. Overall, I really appreciated that the author has put the spotlight on Down syndrome; proving that nothing can hold you back and you are truly capable of doing great things.
November 11, 2025
I'm not sure about this book. Mizzy has ǰ Syndrome. How do we know that? Well her spelling for her age isn't great and neither are her wee drawings. Yet she is able to use the word 'pointedly' in her internal dialogue. I found her character had such an inconsistency between what we hear in her dialogue and what we see in her writing etc that it made for me, a bumpy ride. I've worked in special-ed for over 25 years and I'm not sure this is truly representative of such individuals or could be misconstrued by others who have little awareness. They are the most loving of the pupils I've worked with and can be smart with a wit to match.
This book is well written and works well. Great characters are created and the pace of the story is effective. For me, the central character didn't work.
This book is well written and works well. Great characters are created and the pace of the story is effective. For me, the central character didn't work.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 41 reviews