In The Rose, award-winning poet Ariana Reines navigates the intersection of power and surrender. Drawing on the history of “romance” as the troubadours knew it and the titular flower’s ancient allegories for sexuality and mystery, Reines plunges into feminine archetypes to explore masculine “I have always liked helpless / & terrible men because they break my mind.” In these poems, inherited ideologies of gender performance are replaced with bold paradoxes of power and surrender transmute the speaker’s understanding of suffering, desire, and the soul. The voice in The Rose is wry and bare, approaching the connection between erotic love and spirituality with humor. Investigating war, maternity, violent sensuality, and the role of language in magical acts, Reines is unafraid to uncover the “secret / & terrible shovelings / Of love,” and the result is a bloody and pulsing, sexy and unabashed bloom.
Ariana Reines is the author of The Cow (Alberta Prize, FenceBooks: 2006), Coeur de Lion (Mal-O-Mar: 2007; Fence: 2011), and MERCURY (Fence: forthcoming fall 2011), plus the LP/audiobook SAVE THE WORLD starring Lili Taylor (Fence: forthcoming spring 2011).
Volumes of translation include My Heart Laid Bare by Charles Baudelaire, (Mal-O-Mar:2009), The Little Black Book of Grisélidis Réal: Days and Nights of an Anarchist Whore by Jean-Luc Hennig, (Semiotext(e): 2009), and the forthcoming Preliminary Notes Toward a Theory of the YoungGirl by TIQQUN, (Semiotext(e): 2012).
TELEPHONE, her first play, was commissioned and produced by The Foundry Theatre and presented at The Cherry Lane Theatre in New York, February 2009. The production won two Obies and a spin-off was featured in the Works+Process series at the Guggenheim Museum in New York, Fall 2009. TELEPHONE was be published in Fall 2009 in PLAY: A Journal of Plays.
The Rose is a provocative collection of poetry that, like the flower from which it takes its name, offers sweetness or suffering depending on your approach. This is raw unadulterated poetry, cut with black tar candor and heated until incandescent over a fierce flame of lasciviousness.
Many of the poems are quite sexually charged (though seldom erotic). One of my favorites in the collection, ‘After Coming’, cheerfully scuppers the notion of “post nut clarity” and replaces it with a beguiling post orgasmic mania- one in which the poet is able to extract validation from her partner. It is a striking piece that explores the sometimes transactional nature of relationships.
‘Eros is bad’ ruminates on falling in love. Is it a happy accident like Alice floating downward or does it require more deliberate intention like Orpheus descending into the underworld?
Medea, Aphrodite, and Prometheus all receive mentions and lend their mythological symbolism to the poetry. Yet, despite this occasional broadside from the western cannon the poems feel contemporary, experimental and suffused with vivid but oblique imagery. A skillful poet, Ariana Reines, has transformed the barren underworld into a fertile womb from whence chimeric (and thirsty) poetry springs forth.
ariana reines is the goat. that’s all. fav poems were probably theory of the flower, eye of death (that i originally read in harper’s) and the one where she talks about UTIs… i don’t remember what the word magnanimous means but i feel like it applies here
not my fav of hers but hard to not enjoy spending time in her voice. i think i end up a little not as into her more mystic voice as opposed to her more stein-inflected earlier work … but i’ve got a lot more to learn
Hard to distinguish whether I need a breather from Ariana’s work to become infatuated with it again, or whether I wanted a book that surpassed A Sand Book, a colossal work of career-defining proportions. Either way it’s excellent, but it didn’t mystify me.
Being of the future Being of the future With all the plastic you'll know is in me & all the rays From other worlds Streaming through my hair I want you to know I too sometimes feel An unnatural feeling Electric Humming in my head & inner ear Nearly metallic Like the static when you put on What used to be called A synthetic Shirt (7)
2003 There wasn't enough room On my face. Sorrow stretched From bone to bone. My hips were grim & held their protest like a shoebox Full of photographs from the war I couldn't stop Bleeding & half my hair fell out How could I have let this happen? I let my country go to war I let my mother lose her mind Brother too. I let my country go. So much power & no idea how to use it (18)
Medicine Winged seeds flying everywhere The trees smell like semen The caduceus has nothing To do with healing Said Conrad It has bite marks at the end of it From the dead trying to claw Their way back to the living I have always liked helpless & terrible men because they break my mind I see my brains lolling open Like the fleshes of oysters & crabs ripped from the shell Aphrodite surrounded by shells, flying From the sea to heaven (27)
Hellmouth I lost my mother on the surface Of the Earth. I lost her in public. Never agreed to what We've been doing with Nature Of which I am a part. After pulling Flowers I had nightmares Rusted trowels & spades In radial formation Each displaying a single human organ As if dug up. As if an offering. I crush my "need for self- Expression" all the time Even though it's my profession Do human bodies come From underground as the ancients Thought snakes did? I compress My thoughts: the bodies of serpents Under the amorous bulk of a mountain. If you fail to build in yourself a secret Room the culture will simply Conduct its cargo & traffic up & down you: you'll begin To feel like an airport Commending their Product efficiently from mouth To gate. Host body. Interrogation Devolving into X-ray. I see through Everything passing by way Of me. Mouth Of the city. Lip Of the country. Making Improvements on the danger In me: revising the charter I drafted to kill with I got so angry I could no longer eat. My charter governed Only me. Grenades & pomegranates Growing underground. There is a secret culture Underground, whose womb Foments visions Here lie Also the black Hole & the solar Neutrino. The secret & terrible shovelings Of love. Loading my chasm With myth & gunpowder Tamping it all down With a stick. When you're A revolutionary soldier With only one bullet What else can you do? In this economy myth Costs less than a bullet Hardly anyone understands it Anymore which's why You can't really sell it. They ruined the internet For weeks we were looking For Wild at Heart Finally accepting what felt like our final Night together it'd been scrubbed From the ether If you didn't already know it How would you know To seek it? Or the reality of fire As even recent artists have shown it? Ours was a love our phones Made possible & tooketh Away. Buying & selling Our worst nightmare To one another was a speedy Intimacy—sheer drop To the depths. Fabricating Mutual dreams at the edges Of our mouth—where Grandparents who lose Their native language hide Their dreams. Like a stone Phallus manufactured For the hand of a devotee Communicating cult drugs To the core of me. Where business also Is transacted. For vision Too is business. & so Is love—like ours. I seated myself in silence Votary offering To all of shrieking Time. I found a quiet place For my heart to harden As it filled up with blood I lost my mother. I rejected Love. You belong To Earth, spoke something Inside me. The actual Smell of fish. The powerful Would have me forget my body. The place of terror Is a place of arousal Where I would not build Our house. Red tide. River of burning Shit. Convection of an empty Feeling. Daniela described to me The reverse tectonics on the sea Floor pulling souls down To the Earth's core she saw In a vision. Souls So furious this was their only Way back to the maternal embrace. We both cried when she said it: You can't read things like this In a book or say them in public. The cool room at the center Of my house, monster Attracting me like no man. I am so angry. I have gotten So angry. The little Room in the middle Of me. Where I see What I can't say. I have to stay Moving, evade The imperial calendar— My father's beard whitening & the blackening sockets Of his eyes. I live in Time Chasm of stars Discipline of magnetism In the navel of the labyrinth. Horned monster. Potions Of the eye. Attributes I share with the spider Light my way It's better not to speak Of such things The girl in the story often Doesn't even want a man But they don't teach you that do they. She wants a devil. An animal. To escape The raping god—to be a tree. The girl Who pulled flowers to be sucked Under—the girl who led the hero Through the core of his ordeal All heroes grow ashamed Of the assistance they depend on All sorceresses who once gave So freely of their wisdom Will live to meet the day at last— Because no witch dies She finally wants her magic for herself. When Vesuvius erupted no authority Could divide punishment from climax Blood's hot career Behind white-blue Marble death conceals a riot Of misspent emotion. Harassment Of silence, tissue Of horrors. Explosions On the surface of the sun. Last night the sky was electric I wouldn't let my lover get near me Even though I yearned for him Coronal mass ejection Contradiction. How else Could I open my mouth? But you can write without speaking. But do it too much you'll lose Your womanhood. When I turned 5 My mother hired a pony I was so overwhelmed By surprise at the sight of it That I refused to ride it. Everybody rode that animal But me. I watched them all Go up & down our yard Surprise led to a force of will I still don't understand. The larger the lust The more erotic its refusal. What is "no"? Not the withdrawal Of consent—at its secret, esoteric Best. No meant: I want a force Of Nature. Nothing less. My grandmother's words Press against my navel When I'm sleeping: Give me a child She says. Tell your baby My story. But the red Priapic face of life Offends me with its cheer & sanity. All you have to do Is say yes. Life smiles Like a lurid frankness. I would grow to a great size & piss On this Earth till it drowns but I'm forced To govern my territory With absolute rationality & so I do & so I shall Til Nature itself overwhelms me What I repress contributes to the force Of what I show. Lust Is dignified by ash for eternity Revenge of the living planet: indissoluble From generosity, the only Feminine law. (30-41)
from Jack & Joe I feel just. The heroine of nothing at all Save the dead hours, the ones that leap To their grave at the center of me I can give all this up— This kind of poetry (73)
Eye of Death Me & Amanda went to see David Blaine the night of the Scorpio
Eclipse. He held his breath For over ten minutes in an orb
Of water. I remember His daughter doing a dance
Then we walked soft thru the casino BBLs & tiny dresses, the lull of slots
& AC—there’s a feeling of safety in there you know & A powerful idea America hates: that there’s dignity
In pleasure. Copious good quality intelligence spent Working out the right way to make even me feel happy
Floating thru the crowd on the unnerving Feats of David Blaine
We found our bodies drawn Toward an almost serpentine
Cerebral energy—you could feel it yards Away—before you saw them—a table of men
Poring over their cards like nuclear Physicists on deadline—
Strange electric brain Power physically stimulating
The asp uncoiled from its tree Inside me, drawing us from the pink
Lights of the money machines To halogen-white intensity
When a man dressed impeccably in gray Looked up from his cards & stared
At me—long & hard. A lock
Of combed hair dropped Over his brow
He held my gaze Till I couldn’t take it anymore
& dropped my eyes— Amanda gripped my arm
Wait—were we already walking arm in arm? She, the beautiful one, steadied me
Did that really just happen I said It really did she said. Give me a second I need
To catch my breath I said, steering us Cowardly just slightly out of the guy’s
Sightline. I think I understand Dante now I said
& also Beatrice. Did you know Petrarch’s Laura Was the great-grandmother of the Marquis
De Sade? This is the kind of conversation I make when I’m stalling.
What if one look is all you get Century to century?
Only one poker room in this whole giant casino This the era of the starved polar
Bear & the skinny lion—predators In a growing wasteland devoid of prey.
The most famous game—font of metaphor— Relegated to the back of the hall & only a few
Tables & most of them empty Gorgonic eye fucking with me
He shocked me back into the ancient World. Saw me back
Into poetry (81-3)
from Wife I did not in the end Desire the poet as I thought I would Watching him sink his enormous & beautiful body into a jacuzzi, I loved him exactly As long as I could, just a few minutes Longer in the ancient realms of the broken Hearted & the distorted Where I have made my bed these ten Thousand years. Where I no longer Make my bed. My flight was delayed By many hours but I had already committed To being gone. I feel I will see you somewhere Soon he said as we hugged goodbye. I will see You in the Holy Land, I said. I will see you in Hell. (95-6)
from Theory of the Flower I studied the winds Of Oc—Occitanic—informally—
I studied them by having them Blow on me. [...] There's only one World & it is full of rhyme... (112)
I feel like reines excels in short form and her power gets a little muddied in long form poems. Luckily there were several shorter brilliances in this collection.
I’d never heard of Reines prior to this, and while at first I wasn’t too sure about the collection, by the end I really enjoyed her style. Reines is very much a contemporary feminist poet focusing on the body, sex, and femininity and how these converge in womanhood beneath the patriarchy.
- theory of the flower fucking amazing and worth studying again for theme and also for pacing and voluptuousness - I really enjoyed the Greek mythology woven throughout and themes of philosophy, especially when ruminating on suffering and trauma. Done well
These poems feel raw, visceral, accurate, exquisite, hypnotic, mystical, spiritual, sexual … an opening up, an adjusting of the lens. Her sharpest yet.
WRITTEN CONCURRENTLY WITH Wave of Blood, perhaps? The Rose is mentioned a time or two in Wave of Blood, so perhaps it was already finished by October 2023, even though it appeared after Wave of Blood had already been out a few months. If conceived concurrently, they would be fraternal rather than identical twins--a lot in common, but easily told apart.
Reading The Rose reminded me a lot of reading Reines's other collection of poetry--not so much because she revisits material she has written of before (although, yes, she does) as because it conjures that same headlong feeling, that feeling that you had better not stop reading, that there is no way off this roller coaster until it comes to its end. That, and the feeling that you are playing a game of chess with Reines, but she has already finished the game in her head and has already started playing the next game while you are still trying to figure out her moves in this one.
So: familiar material? Yes, in that Reines again writes of her mother and again embraces abjection...that is, somehow, Reines turns being treated badly into a kind of agency, an assertiveness, a claim to power...ehh, that doesn't make any sense. But if it made sense, why would she write about it?
If our fathers
& mothers loved us right
Would we need to write
At all? If we were more tele-
Pathic as a species
Which we should have
Become by now, let's
Be honest, what would
Become of writing & art
But explosions in the heart
Mansions of great intricacy
We'd create invariably & constantly
On behalf of one another
With no need of a culture
To transact these things
For us?
Part I seems to come out of the aftermath of a difficult love affair, while Part II seems to be written during the affair, creating the odd feeling that that the difficult affair has already been lived through before it has been experienced. And then Part III is a long poem, "Theory of the Flower," which starts with Molly Bloom (if you have not heard Siobhan McKenna's reading of Molly's soliloquy, you should find it just to hear her say "swimming in roses") and pinballs through Joni Mitchell, Cynthia Nixon, Ezra Pound, and the Roman de la Rose before, in its last four pages...turning into...something utterly...different...and pivoting back to Joyce, only not exactly. Whew. Maybe the best thing she has ever done.
I have often thought of Reines as a contemporary confessional poet, and I still do, but I am grateful for the clear line she draws on p. 107:
& long ago I made a solemn vow not to go
The way the Confessionals went. I just don't see my death bringing Justice.
Thanks to NetGalley and Graywolf Press for the ARC!
Ariana Reines’s The Rose is a collection of love(?) poems that would reward analysis more than reading.
The book has an interesting premise—essentially, how does one reconcile the idea of love with the reality of power? Is this power inherently problematic, or is it simply just the way life is?
In one early poem, we read about how the speaker suppresses their desire to be hurt out because of the cultural emphasis on self-respect. Poems later, we see this sentiment inverted with the admission that the speaker's masochism is simply misplaced boredom in light of the evil in the world.
This kind of nuanced vulnerability is rewarding, and I wish it were more prominent throughout the book. While moments like this recur, they are buried deep in the kind of esoteric poetry that feels designed for analysis in graduate seminars. It's mechanical and mathematical. Frankly, the form feels largely incongruous with the collection’s themes, but I think this tension may have felt productive in a chapbook with a tighter edit.
The Rose has an author blurb from Jenny Zhang, and readers of My Baby First Birthday may recognize a kinship between the gross-out crassness of that book and this one. Unfortunately, where Zhang demonstrates precision in her perversity, the voice at work here feels generally unfocused, the volume so constantly elevated that it loses all dimension.
As a final note, and one that is entirely personal yet perhaps relevant for interested readers, The Rose is just not the kind of poetry that sits well in this sociopolitical climate. Violent sex and jouissance through masc-coded language don’t feel transgressive or satirical when every political act in the headlines seems to celebrate male-driven violence. It’s not the poet’s fault that the collection would have landed differently if it were released six months earlier, but for readers who feel fatigued by the world, this collection may be one to avoid for a while.
ARC given by NetGalley for Honest Review 3.5 stars rounded up
I went back and forth with "The Rose." Reines is a talented writer and this collection is reflective, playful, and unabashedly unafraid to pull punches. Some poems left me with irritation, finding the subject of the "man hating woman" to be overplayed. Other poems took me on a journey of self-reflection through gender ideology, sensuality, and grief. It's a hard book to pin down. There's a lot I liked, for example: Reines look at the role of society as it interacts through sex and romance to keep us apart or bring us together is poignant and refreshing. On the other hand, portions of the collection rely on the misandry/misogyny of broken relationships and that (while it's definitely satire) may go over heads.
Overall, I'd recommend this for poetry lovers looking for a new perspective in the themes of romance and relationships, especially when tied to societal pressures and norms.
My favorite poems are: "Divinity School", "Bitch", and "The Hanged Man."
Such an innocent-looking cover for such shocking content, but a poet must resort to whatever means necessary to express her truth, consciously ruining her life to revirginate her soul. That kind of poetry—though not quite in full control of the conceit.
Recurrent dreams Of defective dolls kept coming back To warn me. You are not a thing. You are not the object against which forces Tilt that you cannot control. You are the entire subject of the world. —from “The Economy,” p. 66
What if the universe appears so vast Because the real proportions of our unconscious Suffering & reperpetuated evil take up exactly that much Space? & Voltaire was right? This really is the best Of all possible worlds? —from “Telescope,” p. 74
Favorite Poems: “Being of the future” “I feel like a bag of pork” “Medea” “2003” “Bitch” “Archilochus” “The Hanged Man” “The Economy” “Jack & Joe” “Telescope” “Correction” “Theory of the Flower”
“It may be that I suffer because I use men as muses & because the thought of my muse’s stupidity excites me. It means even naked with them I can protect my privacy. But such men are privileged because I give them *my* stupidity. I preserve my stupidity for them, & I fuck then like a mindless animal” (12)
Some real gems in this book. I adored "Statement of Fact" and "Jack & Joe", but felt that a lot of these poems washed away as I was reading them. The metaphors and imagery of the 'feminine' felt cliche, and the poems didn't interrogate something new, and as a result, I felt a bit disengaged.
I would never compare this book to that of some substack-essayist who just regurgitates cultural commentary that has been milked to death, but some of these poems looked very similar if you took your glasses off.
two short and great poems (Bitch / The Rose) right next to each other. (“Bitch this is nature / shake your book at someone else”) (exactly)
as a collection though this didn’t really land for me, less rangy than Wave of Blood, and certainly less perverted/transgressive than intended. bordering on trite in places. the line “…disdain gripped my clit at his febrile display of need”, hilarious
rereading the blurb and chris kraus calls it Thrilling and Harrowing. when did you last read something truly harrowing, was it a poem riffing greek mythology
The poems in The Rose stained my lips of berry and pressed an ear into a burrowing animals den. Modern and ancient references flitted through this collection of poems.
I found Reines work the used poetry section at community thrift it was her early aughts book called Cœur de Lion which ensnared me with its medieval font and slack jawed confessions.
The Rose is urgent and eternal in its etchings of frayed, tangled emotions. I will return to it.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review --- The Rose is an amazing collection of poetry that blooms and pricks at you just like an actual rose. I feel like short form as opposed to long form poems work better for Reines, however, I did really enjoy this collection. I enjoyed the mythology themes that were woven beautifully into her poems.
I would love to read more of her work in the future!
hdp 😭 creo era mi last straw con ariana… hay una línea muy tenue entre escribir poesía del siglo xxi y escribir pura mamada…. con versos como “i miss you, he whispers, & disdain grips my clit at his febrile display of need” o “a woman / must have everything, sang joni / mitchell, whose records are finally / back on spotify”, creo es EVIDENTE de qué lado estamos…
Everyone was right, this was a really great read. Unexpected rhythms and feelings. Everything felt so raw and genuine. Reminded me that the best writing makes for a vulnerable reading. Helpful during times of heart pain, from all things. Feels almost pyrotechnic with her words. Can't wait to read more of Reines.
Such an awesome book of poems, and I usually don’t like reading poetry. Her writing seems disjoined (like some poetry tends to be) but it all seamlessly flows together to create a patchwork quilt of ideas, thoughts; experiences, anecdotes, and metaphors.
There was also a random ableist slur thrown into the first handful of pages that genuinely caught me off guard. I didn't think we were still doing that so casually anymore and you'd like to think a poet would be able to find better words I guess