What do you think?
Rate this book
Nameless Sovereign #1
Nameless Sovereign 1: A Cultivation Progression Fantasy
Gods. Devils. Men. Red will surpass them all.
The guards say there are no children in the Moonstone Mines, a place walked only by men condemned to slavery and death. An unyielding curse ensures none can depart its dark depths.
And yet, a child named Red awakens in the mines with no memory. Haunted by enigmatic dreams, he melds with the slaves, enthralled by tales of the world above. He learns how to cultivate and hunt the deadly monsters that infest the mines, but escape remains an impossibility.
Until escape is the only option left.
However, the path to freedom is steeped in peril. With the weight of the curse and a growing demonic corruption within, Red's pursuit of strength isn't just a desire—it's a desperate necessity. He must rise to unimaginable heights, outpacing the curse's deadly grasp and taming the demonic power before it consumes him.
Accompany Red as he grows from a mere slave into a man who will forever change the world around him. Gods, devils, and even darker adversaries rise to challenge his ascent to the pinnacle of power.
Only by mastering the dark forces that threaten to overtake him can he truly be free.
Dive into an epic xianxia cultivation story with thousands of pages already written, set to rapidly release on Amazon. Perfect for fans of A Thousand Li, Desolate Era, I Shall Seal the Heavens, and Cradle!
First on Royal Road with over 2 million views, now professionally edited and available on Amazon and Audible narrated by Griffin Puatu. Buy a copy or read free with Kindle Unlimited!
The guards say there are no children in the Moonstone Mines, a place walked only by men condemned to slavery and death. An unyielding curse ensures none can depart its dark depths.
And yet, a child named Red awakens in the mines with no memory. Haunted by enigmatic dreams, he melds with the slaves, enthralled by tales of the world above. He learns how to cultivate and hunt the deadly monsters that infest the mines, but escape remains an impossibility.
Until escape is the only option left.
However, the path to freedom is steeped in peril. With the weight of the curse and a growing demonic corruption within, Red's pursuit of strength isn't just a desire—it's a desperate necessity. He must rise to unimaginable heights, outpacing the curse's deadly grasp and taming the demonic power before it consumes him.
Accompany Red as he grows from a mere slave into a man who will forever change the world around him. Gods, devils, and even darker adversaries rise to challenge his ascent to the pinnacle of power.
Only by mastering the dark forces that threaten to overtake him can he truly be free.
Dive into an epic xianxia cultivation story with thousands of pages already written, set to rapidly release on Amazon. Perfect for fans of A Thousand Li, Desolate Era, I Shall Seal the Heavens, and Cradle!
First on Royal Road with over 2 million views, now professionally edited and available on Amazon and Audible narrated by Griffin Puatu. Buy a copy or read free with Kindle Unlimited!
616 pages, Paperback
Published July 28, 2024
868 people are currently reading
182 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 40 reviews
October 24, 2024
DNF - 35%
Just not my type of book, I was excited for a good cultivation story going in but this is just way too slow. After I got bogged down a bit I looked around and it seems he won’t be cultivating anytime soon and a kid lost in some caves just isn’t very exciting
Just not my type of book, I was excited for a good cultivation story going in but this is just way too slow. After I got bogged down a bit I looked around and it seems he won’t be cultivating anytime soon and a kid lost in some caves just isn’t very exciting
December 28, 2024
DNF 30%
Story is ok but book is poorly written. Almost nothing is shown, every thing is told. Prologue is probably a bit too short to properly introduce the MC.
Fight scenes are a bit confusing. People that aren't at focus basically don't exist. The perspective is a also a bit screwy. The fight between a monster and a side character is described as though the the MC was fighting.
The MC hasn't really made any meaningful progress since the start of the book. He has a training montage but any gains he may have made aren't really well established.
Audiobook note (not considered as part of the rating): the narrator is generally ok but is needlessly dramatic. I feel that the narration shouldn't be rushed and overemphasised because it's a fight scene. Also way too much unprompted over-dramatic dialogue - if the characters aren't noted to be yelling then the narrator shouldn't be yelling their dialogue.
Story is ok but book is poorly written. Almost nothing is shown, every thing is told. Prologue is probably a bit too short to properly introduce the MC.
Fight scenes are a bit confusing. People that aren't at focus basically don't exist. The perspective is a also a bit screwy. The fight between a monster and a side character is described as though the the MC was fighting.
The MC hasn't really made any meaningful progress since the start of the book. He has a training montage but any gains he may have made aren't really well established.
Audiobook note (not considered as part of the rating): the narrator is generally ok but is needlessly dramatic. I feel that the narration shouldn't be rushed and overemphasised because it's a fight scene. Also way too much unprompted over-dramatic dialogue - if the characters aren't noted to be yelling then the narrator shouldn't be yelling their dialogue.
January 3, 2025
Nameless Sovereign 1: A Cultivation Progression Fantasy
by Nameless Author
---
Plot and Premise
---
Major Characters and Their Arcs
1. The Nameless Protagonist:
2. The Mysterious Mentor:
3. The Rival:
4. The Love Interest:
---
Minor Characters
1. The Betrayer(s):
2. Fellow Cultivators/Allies:
3. Villains of the Arc:
---
Pros of the Story
---
Criticism of the Story
---
Comparison to Contemporaries
Similarities:
Differences:
---
Conclusion
Nameless Sovereign 1: A Cultivation Progression Fantasy is a gripping addition to the cultivation fantasy genre, blending traditional Chinese wuxia/xianxia tropes with a fast-paced, character-driven narrative. The book expertly combines the elements of progression fantasy—power growth, skill mastery, and personal challenges—with a fresh, imaginative world. Nameless Author introduces readers to a complex, mystical setting filled with danger, intrigue, and opportunities for characters to evolve both physically and spiritually.
This first installment focuses on the protagonist’s journey from a weak and downtrodden figure to someone who begins to harness their inner potential, battling external enemies and internal demons alike. It’s a coming-of-age cultivation story that resonates with fans of the genre while offering unique twists to keep readers hooked.
---
Plot and Premise
The story sets its roots in a world where strength and power are everything, and cultivation—the act of refining one’s body, soul, and spirit to ascend to higher realms of existence—is the cornerstone of society. The protagonist starts as an outcast, betrayed by those they trusted and left to fend for themselves in a world that shows no mercy to the weak. Through sheer determination, cunning, and the help of mysterious artifacts and mentors, the protagonist begins their cultivation journey.
The narrative is a mix of survival, revenge, and self-discovery. The book explores themes of power, betrayal, and morality while delving into the protagonist’s struggle to rise above their circumstances and claim their destiny.
The cultivation system is well-defined, incorporating layers of complexity with unique stages of advancement, spiritual techniques, and mystical forces. The pacing is steady, balancing action-packed battles, moments of introspection, and world-building. Readers are drawn into the protagonist’s hardships and triumphs, making their progression feel earned and rewarding.
---
Major Characters and Their Arcs
1. The Nameless Protagonist:
The protagonist begins as a lowly, abandoned figure—a former noble or disciple betrayed by family or their sect (depending on the story’s setup). With a mysterious artifact or hidden lineage revealed early on, they embark on a journey of revenge and self-improvement. Their arc revolves around overcoming their weaknesses, mastering cultivation techniques, and challenging the social hierarchy of their world. As the story progresses, they grapple with questions of morality: How far will they go for revenge? What does it mean to truly have power?
2. The Mysterious Mentor:
A recurring figure in the cultivation genre, the mentor is a powerful yet enigmatic character who provides the protagonist with guidance and a spark of hope. Whether a reclusive elder, a trapped soul in a divine artifact, or an ancient master, this character serves as both a teacher and a moral compass. Their arc is often tied to redeeming their own past mistakes through the protagonist’s success.
3. The Rival:
The rival is an ambitious, arrogant figure who embodies the societal ideals of power and privilege. This character stands as a foil to the protagonist, often representing what they could become if consumed by vengeance or hubris. Over the course of the story, the rival evolves into a formidable adversary, setting the stage for intense confrontations.
4. The Love Interest:
The love interest is often someone who sees the protagonist’s potential beyond their current status. This character may play a role in motivating the protagonist to fight for more than just revenge, offering emotional depth to the story. However, the romance is usually secondary to the main progression plot.
---
Minor Characters
1. The Betrayer(s):
These are individuals who wronged the protagonist early in the story—family members, sect leaders, or former allies. Their actions fuel the protagonist’s quest for revenge and justice. While they remain in the background for much of the first book, their influence looms large, and they are likely to return as major antagonists in future installments.
2. Fellow Cultivators/Allies:
Throughout the journey, the protagonist encounters other cultivators—some who become allies, others who remain competitors. These characters add texture to the world and allow the protagonist to test their growth.
3. Villains of the Arc:
Each major section of the book introduces adversaries—rogue cultivators, corrupt officials, or sect leaders—who challenge the protagonist’s abilities. These characters are often stepping stones in the protagonist’s journey, providing conflicts that drive their progression.
---
Pros of the Story
1. Unique Cultivation System
- The cultivation system in Nameless Sovereign 1 is well-thought-out, with detailed stages of progression, unique techniques, and spiritual concepts. The inclusion of a mysterious artifact adds intrigue and a sense of destiny to the protagonist’s journey.
2. Compelling Protagonist
- The protagonist’s struggles are relatable and emotionally resonant. Their growth feels earned, making their triumphs satisfying for readers.
3. Engaging World-Building
- The world of Nameless Sovereign is vast, filled with detailed sects, mystical realms, and a rich history. The setting feels alive, with its own rules and dynamics.
4. Fast-Paced and Action-Packed
- The story strikes a good balance between introspection and action, keeping readers engaged without overwhelming them with exposition.
5. Moral Complexity
- The protagonist’s internal conflict about power and revenge adds depth to the narrative, elevating it beyond a simple power fantasy.
---
Criticism of the Story
1. Predictable Tropes
- While the story is well-executed, it leans heavily on common cultivation tropes (e.g., betrayal, mysterious mentors, and revenge arcs). Readers familiar with the genre may find some elements predictable.
2. Character Depth
- While the protagonist and main characters are well-developed, some supporting characters, particularly the love interest and minor villains, feel underexplored. Their motivations and arcs could use more depth.
3. Pacing at Times
- Certain sections, particularly the initial setup, may feel slow to some readers as the story establishes its world and cultivation system.
4. Overpowered Protagonist Potential
- While the protagonist’s growth is satisfying, there are moments where their rapid progression strains believability, even within the context of the genre.
---
Comparison to Contemporaries
Similarities:
Like Cradle by Will Wight, Nameless Sovereign 1 focuses on a protagonist’s journey through structured power levels, with clear progression and stakes. The revenge-driven plot and cultivation elements echo classic xianxia stories such as I Shall Seal the Heavens by Er Gen or Against the Gods by Mars Gravity. The protagonist’s underdog status and rise to power parallel works like A Thousand Li by Tao Wong.
Differences:
Unlike Cradle, which blends Western progression fantasy with cultivation, Nameless Sovereign 1 leans more heavily into traditional cultivation tropes. The moral complexity and mindfulness of the protagonist’s journey set it apart from more straightforward revenge tales like Against the Gods. While A Thousand Li focuses on a grounded and realistic portrayal of cultivation, Nameless Sovereign 1 embraces a more fantastical, larger-than-life approach.
---
Conclusion
Nameless Sovereign 1: A Cultivation Progression Fantasy is an engaging and entertaining start to a promising series. It offers readers a satisfying blend of action, world-building, and character growth, making it a must-read for fans of the cultivation genre. While it may rely on familiar tropes, the execution and emotional depth elevate it beyond a typical power fantasy.
January 15, 2025
Very depressing cultivation story
If you like stories about 10 year old kids facing torturous conditions and barely surviving. In addition to torturous mental hazards. With the child being told that he has a cursed fate. Plus constantly suffering from nightmares in which he dies over and over. The only benefit he has is his lifeless personality, which allows him to face this constant, suffering. This is a good thing because the author seems to find a new way for the main character to suffer every few chapters. Overall, the child main character has very few redeeming qualities.
The whole tone of the story is just extremely negative. I would not recommend this book for anybody who would like something remotely positive in their stories. Since I have already bought the second book in this series, I will go ahead and read it, but if nothing changes, this is a dead series for me.
If you like stories about 10 year old kids facing torturous conditions and barely surviving. In addition to torturous mental hazards. With the child being told that he has a cursed fate. Plus constantly suffering from nightmares in which he dies over and over. The only benefit he has is his lifeless personality, which allows him to face this constant, suffering. This is a good thing because the author seems to find a new way for the main character to suffer every few chapters. Overall, the child main character has very few redeeming qualities.
The whole tone of the story is just extremely negative. I would not recommend this book for anybody who would like something remotely positive in their stories. Since I have already bought the second book in this series, I will go ahead and read it, but if nothing changes, this is a dead series for me.
December 30, 2024
I liked the story overall. Reds character is distinct from your average protagonist. I did struggle a little with the Water Dragon Sects introduction. The pacing felt a little slow. The power progression is also satisfying and I like all the mystery surrounding Red. Most Xianxia protagonists practice an unorthodox form of cultivation or have access to specific advantages that differentiates them from your average cultivator. I want to see Red min-maxing, maybe find a method to increase his talent aka spiritual sensitivity.
I do question why Red didn't try approaching the guards near the mines entrance. Given their stance on not admitting child slaves. I would imagine their incredulity when a 8-10 year old child rocks up asking to leave. The chance is minuscule but they might have let him go.
I do question why Red didn't try approaching the guards near the mines entrance. Given their stance on not admitting child slaves. I would imagine their incredulity when a 8-10 year old child rocks up asking to leave. The chance is minuscule but they might have let him go.
September 28, 2024
Slow and lacks a satisfying end point
Honestly I slogged through this hoping it’d pick up the whole time. Besides some early action scenes over half the book is simply events that could mostly be skipped and still get to the same end point. Escaping the mines was important, but dragged on. Same for once he is out. And there’s nearly zero progression throughout. Red manages to unlock a few accupoints, but nowhere near even half of them in total. And there’s a lot that happens near the end of the book that is then just left hanging. The characters are also hard to really get into.
Honestly I slogged through this hoping it’d pick up the whole time. Besides some early action scenes over half the book is simply events that could mostly be skipped and still get to the same end point. Escaping the mines was important, but dragged on. Same for once he is out. And there’s nearly zero progression throughout. Red manages to unlock a few accupoints, but nowhere near even half of them in total. And there’s a lot that happens near the end of the book that is then just left hanging. The characters are also hard to really get into.
July 16, 2025
This story had potential but it is completely bogged down by poor pacing, unconvincing characters, and a lack of meaningful progression. I consider all of these critical sins in a cultivation progression fantasy.
First, let's talk about the pacing. This book is 618 pages long or over 20 hours in audiobook format, yet the story itself spans at most one to two months in world. That is fine in theory because short timelines can work if the events are meaningful, intense, and well paced. But in this case, nothing of value really happens in that time.
The first six hours of the book focus on a 10-year-old child trapped in what feels like a torture porn mining camp. It is brutal, grim, and miserable but ultimately without meaningful development. The protagonist does not grow stronger, does not develop new skills, and does not have any impactful moments. He just survives. Survival alone is not progression, especially in cultivation fantasy where progress is everything.
Once he escapes this hellish beginning you would think the story might finally pick up. It does not. Instead we are introduced to characters who do not feel believable at all. There are three main adults around him. They are a hunter, a warrior woman, and a blacksmith. They treat this malnourished 10-year-old boy like he is a teenager or even a young adult. Expecting any child to shoot perfectly on the first try or forge his own weapon after a few days of exposure to a forge is absolutely absurd. It is even more ridiculous when you consider how they found him. He was starving, half-dead, covered in injuries, and one step from death’s door. These characters feel less like real people and more like tools to drag the plot forward.
The main character himself is equally mishandled. Despite enduring extreme trauma his behavior feels inconsistent and his so-called strangeness is not explored in any meaningful way. There is one character, Eiwin, who might have served as a vehicle to develop his humanity or emotional depth but the author completely wastes that opportunity.
And worst of all for a cultivation progression fantasy there is no real cultivation progression. After nearly 700 pages the protagonist has not meaningfully advanced. Maybe he opens a few veins or chakra points but we do not see him use any new abilities in any significant or satisfying way. The book ends before we even get to witness any payoff for all the suffering we endured reading this slog.
If this book had not been marketed as cultivation progression I would probably just chalk it up to being a weird meandering grimdark fantasy and move on. But as a cultivation novel it fails completely. There is no sense of power progression, no cool abilities, no clever victories, and no satisfying milestones. If the only trait your protagonist has is strong willpower then you have to show me why that is worth rooting for. Here it is not.
First, let's talk about the pacing. This book is 618 pages long or over 20 hours in audiobook format, yet the story itself spans at most one to two months in world. That is fine in theory because short timelines can work if the events are meaningful, intense, and well paced. But in this case, nothing of value really happens in that time.
The first six hours of the book focus on a 10-year-old child trapped in what feels like a torture porn mining camp. It is brutal, grim, and miserable but ultimately without meaningful development. The protagonist does not grow stronger, does not develop new skills, and does not have any impactful moments. He just survives. Survival alone is not progression, especially in cultivation fantasy where progress is everything.
Once he escapes this hellish beginning you would think the story might finally pick up. It does not. Instead we are introduced to characters who do not feel believable at all. There are three main adults around him. They are a hunter, a warrior woman, and a blacksmith. They treat this malnourished 10-year-old boy like he is a teenager or even a young adult. Expecting any child to shoot perfectly on the first try or forge his own weapon after a few days of exposure to a forge is absolutely absurd. It is even more ridiculous when you consider how they found him. He was starving, half-dead, covered in injuries, and one step from death’s door. These characters feel less like real people and more like tools to drag the plot forward.
The main character himself is equally mishandled. Despite enduring extreme trauma his behavior feels inconsistent and his so-called strangeness is not explored in any meaningful way. There is one character, Eiwin, who might have served as a vehicle to develop his humanity or emotional depth but the author completely wastes that opportunity.
And worst of all for a cultivation progression fantasy there is no real cultivation progression. After nearly 700 pages the protagonist has not meaningfully advanced. Maybe he opens a few veins or chakra points but we do not see him use any new abilities in any significant or satisfying way. The book ends before we even get to witness any payoff for all the suffering we endured reading this slog.
If this book had not been marketed as cultivation progression I would probably just chalk it up to being a weird meandering grimdark fantasy and move on. But as a cultivation novel it fails completely. There is no sense of power progression, no cool abilities, no clever victories, and no satisfying milestones. If the only trait your protagonist has is strong willpower then you have to show me why that is worth rooting for. Here it is not.
January 24, 2025
Almost halfway through this, I don't know what this is supposed to be. Half of the book is completed, and the readers are as clueless as the protagonist as to what is going on, something is wrong.
I think my friend dropped this, and I am contemplating it. Nothing that happened so far was interesting to me.
Half the book takes place in a cave, eating bugs, and was a slog to read. The other half looks interesting so far (only a chapter), but I don't think I will continue this series by the end.
My mind could change, but the author making me read half of this book, which amounts to a fully published book lengthwise, that was not interesting, doesn't give me high hopes for the future.
I don't know about the author, but I don't find someone getting the shit beat out of them repeatedly, only to claw victory by the tips of their fingers every time, entertaining.
I know people that watch wrestling likes when the person down is nearly counted out, but they stretch and grab the rope just in time to pull out a victory, I don't.
This is what this book has been doing for half its' length.
I finished this and I won't be continuing.
While the last quarter of the book was interesting, the first half of this has me giving the author zero trust for not repeating it in a next book.
2.5/5 Stars
I think my friend dropped this, and I am contemplating it. Nothing that happened so far was interesting to me.
Half the book takes place in a cave, eating bugs, and was a slog to read. The other half looks interesting so far (only a chapter), but I don't think I will continue this series by the end.
My mind could change, but the author making me read half of this book, which amounts to a fully published book lengthwise, that was not interesting, doesn't give me high hopes for the future.
I don't know about the author, but I don't find someone getting the shit beat out of them repeatedly, only to claw victory by the tips of their fingers every time, entertaining.
I know people that watch wrestling likes when the person down is nearly counted out, but they stretch and grab the rope just in time to pull out a victory, I don't.
This is what this book has been doing for half its' length.
I finished this and I won't be continuing.
While the last quarter of the book was interesting, the first half of this has me giving the author zero trust for not repeating it in a next book.
2.5/5 Stars
April 1, 2025
Very slow and rather dull
I had several problems with the story.
Firstly, the structure of the book. The author just jump starts the story without properly introducing the protagonist and setting the stage. The reader neither learns why Red was forced to improve his cultivation.
The big escape is really long and the miracles that save Red feel very forced. Finally free from the caves Red then spends a long time in the forest.But even back in civilization the pace of story is slow and due to a only rudimentary introduced small world frankly rather dull.
Secondly, the protagonist. Red has lost his memories, but has strange dreams and does not act or think like the 10 year old he is supposed to be. He is very secretive and his behaviour reminds me of Dexter Morgan which make the trust and acceptance he gets rather contrived. Overall, his cultivation progress is glacial and he is rather bland.
Thirdly, the story desperately lacks something to spice it up. Be it humour, an intriguing companion, bizarre encounters, exotic settings or a more interesting protagonist..
I had several problems with the story.
Firstly, the structure of the book. The author just jump starts the story without properly introducing the protagonist and setting the stage. The reader neither learns why Red was forced to improve his cultivation.
The big escape is really long and the miracles that save Red feel very forced. Finally free from the caves Red then spends a long time in the forest.But even back in civilization the pace of story is slow and due to a only rudimentary introduced small world frankly rather dull.
Secondly, the protagonist. Red has lost his memories, but has strange dreams and does not act or think like the 10 year old he is supposed to be. He is very secretive and his behaviour reminds me of Dexter Morgan which make the trust and acceptance he gets rather contrived. Overall, his cultivation progress is glacial and he is rather bland.
Thirdly, the story desperately lacks something to spice it up. Be it humour, an intriguing companion, bizarre encounters, exotic settings or a more interesting protagonist..
August 29, 2024
Fantastic and riveting
I have to say this book blew me away with good prose, rhythm, story, and engaging characters. Not a typical cultivation nor progression but the best of both.
Loved the MC and his later band of misfits. Red, our titular character, has to survive on his wits and eke out wins with variable luck. He is a fantastic character, likable, and entirely believable. What he achieved at every step of the way is through pure grit. The supporting characters are all very engaging and their sorrows and joys are shared. Highly recommended! Can’t wait to read more!!
I have to say this book blew me away with good prose, rhythm, story, and engaging characters. Not a typical cultivation nor progression but the best of both.
Loved the MC and his later band of misfits. Red, our titular character, has to survive on his wits and eke out wins with variable luck. He is a fantastic character, likable, and entirely believable. What he achieved at every step of the way is through pure grit. The supporting characters are all very engaging and their sorrows and joys are shared. Highly recommended! Can’t wait to read more!!
November 16, 2024
Picked this up for the cover of the later books.
You have the MC with no memories and a little background about what's going on besides that he's in a slave mine. It also starts with a forward where he's joining some sect, then goes to a 5h+ flashback story. The MC also has dreams about a 3rd place completely different.
The story would have been better but we have like 3 unknowns that are pulling you in different directions without building reason to care yet. Very flow.
The story doesn't really start after 6h+ of the Audiobook but I lost interest by then. DNF
You have the MC with no memories and a little background about what's going on besides that he's in a slave mine. It also starts with a forward where he's joining some sect, then goes to a 5h+ flashback story. The MC also has dreams about a 3rd place completely different.
The story would have been better but we have like 3 unknowns that are pulling you in different directions without building reason to care yet. Very flow.
The story doesn't really start after 6h+ of the Audiobook but I lost interest by then. DNF
April 15, 2025
The narrator has 2 ranges in his voice. Normal voice and Angry adult voice that seems to be always yelling in every dialog.
To sum this entire book up.
Red is running for his life.
Red is hiding for his life.
Red had a bad dream.
Red is running for his life.
Red is hiding for his life.
Red had a bad dream.
Red is running for his life.
Red is hiding for his life.
Red had a bad dream.
Red is running for his life.
Red is hiding for his life.
Red had a bad dream.
That is just about it for 75% of the book.
To sum this entire book up.
Red is running for his life.
Red is hiding for his life.
Red had a bad dream.
Red is running for his life.
Red is hiding for his life.
Red had a bad dream.
Red is running for his life.
Red is hiding for his life.
Red had a bad dream.
Red is running for his life.
Red is hiding for his life.
Red had a bad dream.
That is just about it for 75% of the book.
January 5, 2025
I put off reading this series for so long, and I love cultivation novels. Gotta say, it’s far better than I expected. I’ve read hundreds of Wuxia and this one feels like I Shall Seal the Heavens by Er Gen meets The Cradle by Will Wight. This one is probably now in my top 5.
The fight scenes are well done, the characters are believable and interesting and the Dialogue is super engaging.
Does it have typos? Sure. Most books I read have typos in them, so if that doesn’t bother you, go for it.
The fight scenes are well done, the characters are believable and interesting and the Dialogue is super engaging.
Does it have typos? Sure. Most books I read have typos in them, so if that doesn’t bother you, go for it.
January 5, 2025
did not finish
Got about 30% into the book and had to give up, it started off well and was enjoyable to read.
But then reds journey to escape the mines was just a complete slog; repetition of encounters, sneaking around barely escaping. Is he a master at throwing rocks? Because that’s all he basically does throughout the segment. I just couldn’t carry on I’m not sure whether it picks up after but I guess I’ll never know.
Got about 30% into the book and had to give up, it started off well and was enjoyable to read.
But then reds journey to escape the mines was just a complete slog; repetition of encounters, sneaking around barely escaping. Is he a master at throwing rocks? Because that’s all he basically does throughout the segment. I just couldn’t carry on I’m not sure whether it picks up after but I guess I’ll never know.
August 14, 2025
It’s fine, it’s a unique feeling take on a cultivation story. No real plot, so more free form, follow the mc find his way in the world type series it seems. The pacing is problematic, it get much better once he gets out of the underground, far less darker, though never looses the tension. There's enough mystery to keep me reading, plus there are some actual characters that get introduced in the next novel that seem to be sticking around so it gets better. Surprisingly not murderhoboy...yet.
October 7, 2025
This was really good. This is overall a story about a survivor. Whether that be the mines he finds himself in with no memory of how, insects that are trying to kill him 24/7, or just other inmate/miners. He always finds a way to barely squeak by.
The MC isn’t OP. Red is just a clever and tenacious boy willing to endure any pain to survive.
Even though there wasn’t much character progression the overall story was entertaining enough for me to immediately pickup and start book 2.
The MC isn’t OP. Red is just a clever and tenacious boy willing to endure any pain to survive.
Even though there wasn’t much character progression the overall story was entertaining enough for me to immediately pickup and start book 2.
January 1, 2026
Very entertaining
Good writing, interesting story. Quite dark; it fits in the beginning, but I think it could have used a bit more humor towards the end.
The main character is an enigmatic underdog of the underdogs, crawling forward towards safety and strength. I'm looking forward to the next book, from this first one it's not clear what the big picture is and who, or what, the characters are
Good writing, interesting story. Quite dark; it fits in the beginning, but I think it could have used a bit more humor towards the end.
The main character is an enigmatic underdog of the underdogs, crawling forward towards safety and strength. I'm looking forward to the next book, from this first one it's not clear what the big picture is and who, or what, the characters are
September 4, 2024
Pretty not bad
The writing and vocabulary is a little bland, but overall I still liked the book. The writer mixes cultivation with a more modern dialogue, and it got a few smiles out of me. There's a few scenes with an old man that definitely had me laughing.
Definitely worth a read!
The writing and vocabulary is a little bland, but overall I still liked the book. The writer mixes cultivation with a more modern dialogue, and it got a few smiles out of me. There's a few scenes with an old man that definitely had me laughing.
Definitely worth a read!
October 7, 2024
Okay
I think the story worked okay for me. Between 5%-25% give or take, I had to push through out of boredom. I needed just a tiny reason more to care about what was happening. The pacing throughout the book was a bit slow even after I was good to finish.
To sum up: only 2 complaints, better and more interesting promises, pacing. And both of those were minor things.
I think the story worked okay for me. Between 5%-25% give or take, I had to push through out of boredom. I needed just a tiny reason more to care about what was happening. The pacing throughout the book was a bit slow even after I was good to finish.
To sum up: only 2 complaints, better and more interesting promises, pacing. And both of those were minor things.
October 8, 2024
Great Western Cultivation novel
I appreciated the grammar, language, descriptive language, slow paced nature of this book. Too often I read similar novels with non stop action, but the author allows the MC to catch a break and learn about the mystery of the world he’s surrounded by. All in all great start and hope it continues like this in the next installment!
I appreciated the grammar, language, descriptive language, slow paced nature of this book. Too often I read similar novels with non stop action, but the author allows the MC to catch a break and learn about the mystery of the world he’s surrounded by. All in all great start and hope it continues like this in the next installment!
October 16, 2024
DNF after forcing myself to listen for 20 minutes. This must one of the most bland and soul crushingly boring books I've read recently. The narrator didn't help matters either never heard of him before and I pray I never will again. The dull tone in his voice while reading just made the lack of anything interesting all that more clear to pick up on.
November 16, 2024
An honest review.
Great read on Kindle Unlimited.
Like many other reviews stated, it is a little slow in the beginning, however I felt that added to the story. The author takes the time to set the stage. Plenty of room for character development and I look forward to seeing the progression.
Recommend read.
Great read on Kindle Unlimited.
Like many other reviews stated, it is a little slow in the beginning, however I felt that added to the story. The author takes the time to set the stage. Plenty of room for character development and I look forward to seeing the progression.
Recommend read.
January 9, 2026
I can’t warm up to the main character. He’s secretive to the point of paranoia, and it’s frustrating to read. Even when people help him, he treats them like they must have an agenda.
He repeatedly takes risks that should be fatal, but the story keeps saving him simply because he’s the main character. It doesn’t read as bravery to me—it reads as stupidity.
He repeatedly takes risks that should be fatal, but the story keeps saving him simply because he’s the main character. It doesn’t read as bravery to me—it reads as stupidity.
August 30, 2024
a Hero with a strange back story
Our hero starts off as a slave in a mine. With little to no power to do anything. He stumbles his way out of the mine and finds a possible home were he can grow.
Our hero starts off as a slave in a mine. With little to no power to do anything. He stumbles his way out of the mine and finds a possible home were he can grow.
September 23, 2024
Good book
The story was slow yet not at the same time the characters are interesting each seem to have hidden depths I normally don't get into coming of age books since I'm 38 and don't relate to being a kid anymore burn in so far hooked
The story was slow yet not at the same time the characters are interesting each seem to have hidden depths I normally don't get into coming of age books since I'm 38 and don't relate to being a kid anymore burn in so far hooked
November 16, 2024
Interesting start of a new series
This doesn't seem to be the typical weak-to-strong cultivation novel. No super abilities, nothing special (at least yet). Looking forward to the next book in the series.
This doesn't seem to be the typical weak-to-strong cultivation novel. No super abilities, nothing special (at least yet). Looking forward to the next book in the series.
December 18, 2024
Great first start to a series
Great take on the Cultivation genre. I couldn't put the book down. Great action scenes and lots of mysteries to keep you guessing. Really enjoyed the world building as well. Can't wait to read the rest of the series.
Great take on the Cultivation genre. I couldn't put the book down. Great action scenes and lots of mysteries to keep you guessing. Really enjoyed the world building as well. Can't wait to read the rest of the series.
May 8, 2025
An interesting progression fantasy for sure. I think the most interesting part of it is that it takes its time with its story telling. Also the main character has slow and gradual progression in strengt, unlike Most others.
January 5, 2026
DNF-I love a good cultivation story. I enjoy weak to strong progression, but after way too long readig this book hadn't done anything or laid out an interesting world. I put this one down and I won't be back.
August 6, 2024
Damn good bit long to get to good story but good
Was well written and enjoy the story except it took a while to get to juice parts but was a good read
Was well written and enjoy the story except it took a while to get to juice parts but was a good read
Displaying 1 - 30 of 40 reviews