What do you think?
Rate this book
In the Castle Library #1
Christmas in the Castle Library (Christian Series Level II
Ellie Sawyer has always felt more comfortable with books than people, which explains why she’s a PhD history student neck deep in research and trying to complete her doctoral dissertation in time to graduate. But the final books she needs are half a world away in the tiny European kingdom of Lethersby, and the only time she can access the secretive Royal Castle Library is during the Christmas holiday.
Ellie is determined to get to the bottom of the mystery that has eluded Lethersby scholars for more than 100 hundred years by figuring out what happened to their long-lost queen, a young royal who disappeared shortly after the outbreak of the First World War. With the help of Mark, a handsome castle staff member who shares her love of history, she might be able to unravel the queen’s story. But Mark is keeping his own secret from her, and what they discover together could change everything for Ellie—and the entire kingdom.
Ellie is determined to get to the bottom of the mystery that has eluded Lethersby scholars for more than 100 hundred years by figuring out what happened to their long-lost queen, a young royal who disappeared shortly after the outbreak of the First World War. With the help of Mark, a handsome castle staff member who shares her love of history, she might be able to unravel the queen’s story. But Mark is keeping his own secret from her, and what they discover together could change everything for Ellie—and the entire kingdom.
462 pages, Library Binding
First published October 1, 2024
62 people are currently reading
2207 people want to read
About the author
Ann Swindell
6 books248 followersAnn Swindell writes stories that point to Christ’s presence in our day-to-day lives and the hope He brings to our hearts. She is the author of multiple books and the owner of Writing with Grace, where she teaches Christ-centered writing classes for women. Ann lives in West Michigan, and she enjoys adventuring with her family…usually with a cup of Earl Grey tea in hand.
Learn more at annswindell.com.
Learn more at annswindell.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 339 reviews
December 5, 2024
Aw, this was really cute!
A scholar is trying to uncover the mystery of a missing monarch from years ago. There’s a sweet librarian who helps her with research😉
There was deep faith content, super sweet romance, and strong character development.
I recommend as a solid Christmas book option!
A scholar is trying to uncover the mystery of a missing monarch from years ago. There’s a sweet librarian who helps her with research😉
There was deep faith content, super sweet romance, and strong character development.
I recommend as a solid Christmas book option!
December 14, 2024
What a tremendous book.....such likeable people, no ridiculous nor exasperating characters with the miscommunication that drives me around the bend! This was truly one of the most Christian stories ever with so much faith content, all woven in naturally. The theme was based a fair bit on not feeling loved because of being unworthy despite the fact which is hard for many of us to accept ; being accepted, cherished, and cared for unconditionally as not one of us is ever actually 'worthy" so to speak when it comes to the Lord. Such pleasant reading as I was curious about the mystery being solved.
The prince Mark was truly a gentleman; how we would all love such an admirable person. It was a totally satisfying read for this author but definitely not the last by her as she passed my "one chance" test hands down and I will gladly buy the next in the series! Well worth buying this heart warming story :)
The prince Mark was truly a gentleman; how we would all love such an admirable person. It was a totally satisfying read for this author but definitely not the last by her as she passed my "one chance" test hands down and I will gladly buy the next in the series! Well worth buying this heart warming story :)
December 26, 2024
3 stars, personally ✨ Christian Fiction - Christmas - Contemporary
About this book:
“Ellie Sawyer has always felt more comfortable with books than people, which explains why she’s a PhD history student neck deep in research and trying to complete her doctoral dissertation in time to graduate. But the final books she needs are half a world away in the tiny European kingdom of Lethersby, and the only time she can access the secretive Royal Castle Library is during the Christmas holiday.
Ellie is determined to get to the bottom of the mystery that has eluded Lethersby scholars for more than 100 hundred years by figuring out what happened to their long-lost queen, a young royal who disappeared shortly after the outbreak of the First World War. With the help of Mark, a handsome castle staff member who shares her love of history, she might be able to unravel the queen’s story. But Mark is keeping his own secret from her, and what they discover together could change everything for Ellie—and the entire kingdom.”
Series: Book #1 in an unnamed series.
Spiritual Content- Many Scriptures are mentioned, read, remembered, & thought over; Many, many prayers & Thanking God; Church going, a Christmas Eve service, & a sermon; Many talks about & Discussions of God, Jesus Christ, Him pursuing us, strong faiths, Bible reading, love, & being chosen by God; Most 'H's are capital when referring to God; Set during Christmastime; At the beginning of the book, Ellie surprises herself by praying as she hasn’t done that in months or years due to being too busy to pray or read her Bible; Ellie recalls how she would crave reading her Bible and thinks that her relationship with the Lord is dry now, so she starts to read her Bible and pray again; Ellie feels a Presence with her at times & hears God talking to her (most are Scripture references); Many, many mentions of God, Jesus Christ, Scriptures, strong faiths, prayers, & praying; Many, many mentions of Bibles, Bible reading, & books of the Bible; Mentions of those & events in the Bible; Mentions of churches/chapels, church going, sermons, and either paying or not paying attention to the preacher; Mentions of Christmas & Christmas hymns.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a form of ‘drat’, an ‘idiot’, an ‘oh my gosh’, two ‘stupid’s, three forms of ‘dumb’; Eye rolling; Ellie eavesdrops and though she doesn’t want to, she becomes curious about what is being said (twice); Many mentions of wars, fighting, deaths, & neutral countries; Mentions of deaths (cancer) & grief (including a wife for her husband and daughter & a daughter for her father); Mentions of lies & lying; Mentions of gossip & rumors; Mentions of jealousy; A few mentions of eavesdropping; A mention of college parties; A mention of the lottery;
*Note: Ellie struggles a lot with self-confidence, self-doubt, comparison, and thinking she will be rejected by others (lots of this is on-page including her thinking she is a failure, always doomed to fail, and not good enough; Others try to tell her that that is not true and encourage her); Ellie has a near panic attack (barely-above-not-detailed) & anxiety; Mentions of books, authors, & fictional characters (The Odyssey, Beowulf, Paradise Lost, Gerard Manly Hopkins, Narnia, & Ebenezer Scrooge); A few mentions of a car brand; A couple mentions of Google Translate; A mention of a Barbie doll.
Sexual Content- A fingers-to-lips touch, five hand kisses, three head/forehead kisses, three barely-above-not-detailed kisses, and two semi-detailed kisses; Touches, Embraces, Dancing, Hand holding, Warmth, Shivers/Tingles, Flutters, Nearness, & Smelling (barely-above-not-detailed); A bit of wanting to touch (barely-above-not-detailed); Noticing (barely-above-not-detailed); Flirting, Winks, & Blushes; Ellie blushes about the thought of a honeymoon and can’t wait for it; Mentions of theories that Queen Alma left because of a secret lover or because she was pregnant out of wedlock; Mentions of dates, dating, boyfriends/girlfriends, crushes, & exes; A couple mentions of kisses & an excellent kisser; A couple mentions of wanting to kiss; A couple mentions of blushes; A couple mentions of flirting; Love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: Ellie is self-conscious about her outward appearance, including her weight and thinks about her body in negative ways often (including noticing her thighs, soft middle, her clothes feeling tight, and how she’s easily winded) and how she doesn’t love her body; Most of her self-consciousness stems from a boy in high school backing out of taking her to prom because she was “too fat” and told her so when she pressed him about the reason in the cafeteria (in front of many others) & she recalls this and her feelings about it a handful of times; Ellie thinks that Mark is out of her league; A few mentions of Ellie’s curves (which she is self-conscious about, but Mark tells her he loves them); A mention of a revealing dress.
-Ellie Sawyer,
P.O.V. of Ellie
312 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- Two Stars
Older High School Teens- Three Stars
My personal Rating- Three Stars
{ Add up to a full star for older teens who struggle with self-confidence }
This wasn’t what I was expecting. I thought it would be dual-time period and go back and forth for the historical element, when it was actually just a modern-day setting with Ellie trying to figure out the mystery. It definitely had the Hallmark-storyline with the prince falling for the American, the wonderful library academia vibes, and great faith content. But it also had a more sensitive message because of Ellie’s major insecurities in herself.
I’ll admit that shortly into reading this book and seeing her lack of confidence and lack of interest in her Bible, I was concerned that the male lead would swoop in and rescue her (which is something I’ve seen a lot in Christian Fiction). I was pleasantly surprised that did majorly not happen—there’s a bit of it at the end with him commenting on loving her curves—and was overall heartened by the lack of that element and seeing her journey of faith in this book.
At the risk of sounding unfeeling and harsh, I also must admit that I grew tired of Ellie’s woes about her insecurities, physical appearance, and how she’s “just a scholar”. This is rehashed and rehashed again and again which made the book feel so slooooooow to me. I would usually fly through this kind of plotline, but because of the lack of interest at times and the constant repetition, it dragged. I know that some truths will just not stick to our mind, and we have to repeat and repeat them to get it to stick, but it felt redundant at times with Ellie. She was often comparing herself to others around her and my heart hurt for her.
That said, the faith content was great, and it truly was the main focus of the book—let’s say 50% romance and then split the remaining half between the romance and the mystery of the queen? So, it was nice to see the faith content and discussions and lots of Scriptures, but at the same time, it also got to be repetitive quickly.
Besides the faith content, this book went just about as I thought it would—particularly with the missing queen (called it early on) and the romance—Ellie was really oblivious to who the handsome guy in the library was. She reacted just as well to the news as I expected her to (so not well at all) and when a certain other common trope (another woman) came into play, I was a little annoyed.
Final verdict? This was a pretty clean, faith heavy book. I liked some aspects of it, but I do think it could have been at least a hundred pages shorter. For teen readers, I would say it would be better for those who struggle with their insecurities like Ellie did, particularly about her outward appearance and finding her identity in Christ. It’s clean enough for younger girls/teens, but because of her lack of self-confidence and thinking about her flaws often, I wouldn’t want a younger girl to then notice these things about themselves if they hadn’t already been aware of it.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
About this book:
“Ellie Sawyer has always felt more comfortable with books than people, which explains why she’s a PhD history student neck deep in research and trying to complete her doctoral dissertation in time to graduate. But the final books she needs are half a world away in the tiny European kingdom of Lethersby, and the only time she can access the secretive Royal Castle Library is during the Christmas holiday.
Ellie is determined to get to the bottom of the mystery that has eluded Lethersby scholars for more than 100 hundred years by figuring out what happened to their long-lost queen, a young royal who disappeared shortly after the outbreak of the First World War. With the help of Mark, a handsome castle staff member who shares her love of history, she might be able to unravel the queen’s story. But Mark is keeping his own secret from her, and what they discover together could change everything for Ellie—and the entire kingdom.”
Series: Book #1 in an unnamed series.
Spiritual Content- Many Scriptures are mentioned, read, remembered, & thought over; Many, many prayers & Thanking God; Church going, a Christmas Eve service, & a sermon; Many talks about & Discussions of God, Jesus Christ, Him pursuing us, strong faiths, Bible reading, love, & being chosen by God; Most 'H's are capital when referring to God; Set during Christmastime; At the beginning of the book, Ellie surprises herself by praying as she hasn’t done that in months or years due to being too busy to pray or read her Bible; Ellie recalls how she would crave reading her Bible and thinks that her relationship with the Lord is dry now, so she starts to read her Bible and pray again; Ellie feels a Presence with her at times & hears God talking to her (most are Scripture references); Many, many mentions of God, Jesus Christ, Scriptures, strong faiths, prayers, & praying; Many, many mentions of Bibles, Bible reading, & books of the Bible; Mentions of those & events in the Bible; Mentions of churches/chapels, church going, sermons, and either paying or not paying attention to the preacher; Mentions of Christmas & Christmas hymns.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a form of ‘drat’, an ‘idiot’, an ‘oh my gosh’, two ‘stupid’s, three forms of ‘dumb’; Eye rolling; Ellie eavesdrops and though she doesn’t want to, she becomes curious about what is being said (twice); Many mentions of wars, fighting, deaths, & neutral countries; Mentions of deaths (cancer) & grief (including a wife for her husband and daughter & a daughter for her father); Mentions of lies & lying; Mentions of gossip & rumors; Mentions of jealousy; A few mentions of eavesdropping; A mention of college parties; A mention of the lottery;
*Note: Ellie struggles a lot with self-confidence, self-doubt, comparison, and thinking she will be rejected by others (lots of this is on-page including her thinking she is a failure, always doomed to fail, and not good enough; Others try to tell her that that is not true and encourage her); Ellie has a near panic attack (barely-above-not-detailed) & anxiety; Mentions of books, authors, & fictional characters (The Odyssey, Beowulf, Paradise Lost, Gerard Manly Hopkins, Narnia, & Ebenezer Scrooge); A few mentions of a car brand; A couple mentions of Google Translate; A mention of a Barbie doll.
Sexual Content- A fingers-to-lips touch, five hand kisses, three head/forehead kisses, three barely-above-not-detailed kisses, and two semi-detailed kisses; Touches, Embraces, Dancing, Hand holding, Warmth, Shivers/Tingles, Flutters, Nearness, & Smelling (barely-above-not-detailed); A bit of wanting to touch (barely-above-not-detailed); Noticing (barely-above-not-detailed); Flirting, Winks, & Blushes; Ellie blushes about the thought of a honeymoon and can’t wait for it; Mentions of theories that Queen Alma left because of a secret lover or because she was pregnant out of wedlock; Mentions of dates, dating, boyfriends/girlfriends, crushes, & exes; A couple mentions of kisses & an excellent kisser; A couple mentions of wanting to kiss; A couple mentions of blushes; A couple mentions of flirting; Love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: Ellie is self-conscious about her outward appearance, including her weight and thinks about her body in negative ways often (including noticing her thighs, soft middle, her clothes feeling tight, and how she’s easily winded) and how she doesn’t love her body; Most of her self-consciousness stems from a boy in high school backing out of taking her to prom because she was “too fat” and told her so when she pressed him about the reason in the cafeteria (in front of many others) & she recalls this and her feelings about it a handful of times; Ellie thinks that Mark is out of her league; A few mentions of Ellie’s curves (which she is self-conscious about, but Mark tells her he loves them); A mention of a revealing dress.
-Ellie Sawyer,
P.O.V. of Ellie
312 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- Two Stars
Older High School Teens- Three Stars
My personal Rating- Three Stars
{ Add up to a full star for older teens who struggle with self-confidence }
This wasn’t what I was expecting. I thought it would be dual-time period and go back and forth for the historical element, when it was actually just a modern-day setting with Ellie trying to figure out the mystery. It definitely had the Hallmark-storyline with the prince falling for the American, the wonderful library academia vibes, and great faith content. But it also had a more sensitive message because of Ellie’s major insecurities in herself.
I’ll admit that shortly into reading this book and seeing her lack of confidence and lack of interest in her Bible, I was concerned that the male lead would swoop in and rescue her (which is something I’ve seen a lot in Christian Fiction). I was pleasantly surprised that did majorly not happen—there’s a bit of it at the end with him commenting on loving her curves—and was overall heartened by the lack of that element and seeing her journey of faith in this book.
At the risk of sounding unfeeling and harsh, I also must admit that I grew tired of Ellie’s woes about her insecurities, physical appearance, and how she’s “just a scholar”. This is rehashed and rehashed again and again which made the book feel so slooooooow to me. I would usually fly through this kind of plotline, but because of the lack of interest at times and the constant repetition, it dragged. I know that some truths will just not stick to our mind, and we have to repeat and repeat them to get it to stick, but it felt redundant at times with Ellie. She was often comparing herself to others around her and my heart hurt for her.
That said, the faith content was great, and it truly was the main focus of the book—let’s say 50% romance and then split the remaining half between the romance and the mystery of the queen? So, it was nice to see the faith content and discussions and lots of Scriptures, but at the same time, it also got to be repetitive quickly.
Besides the faith content, this book went just about as I thought it would—particularly with the missing queen (called it early on) and the romance—Ellie was really oblivious to who the handsome guy in the library was. She reacted just as well to the news as I expected her to (so not well at all) and when a certain other common trope (another woman) came into play, I was a little annoyed.
Final verdict? This was a pretty clean, faith heavy book. I liked some aspects of it, but I do think it could have been at least a hundred pages shorter. For teen readers, I would say it would be better for those who struggle with their insecurities like Ellie did, particularly about her outward appearance and finding her identity in Christ. It’s clean enough for younger girls/teens, but because of her lack of self-confidence and thinking about her flaws often, I wouldn’t want a younger girl to then notice these things about themselves if they hadn’t already been aware of it.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
December 16, 2024
Easiest five-star I've given for romance in a LONG time.
Christmas in the Castle Library has the depth of faith found in a Michael Phillips novel, a setting rivaling Lori Wick's "royal" story," and the romantic swoonyness of Pepper Basham (but without needing a freezer after reading kisses. Thank you, Ann!)
Seriously, though. I can't tell you what I didn't love about this book. My only quibble is just a personal issue that is no fault of the book's. And I wouldn't change that for anything. It is an important part of the story (and thank you, Ann for not emphasizing it so much that it lost its value and punch). What was it? Well, I guess I can tell (I was afraid of spoilers but there aren't any). Our hero comments that he likes her curves. Seriously, now you know what a prude I am. I'm GLAD he said it... even if it makes me uncomfortable.
What you do get is a story about a brilliant woman who isn't so brilliant at seeing truths about herself. (the age-old story, no?) Hiding in a world of books and the knowledge found there, she tries to compensate for perceived flaws by being smarter than others and invisible to the world, all while hating her invisibility. Again, so very like most of us. And like most of us, this might not have become a problem if she'd looked to the Lord and His Word rather than distancing herself from the only Source of worth that can help.
In the end, you get two flawed people trying to navigate difficult circumstances while also researching a century-old mystery. Beautiful, rich, powerful, and all in a gentle and delightful Christmas read (perfect for any time of the year, though).
Drumming my fingers for the next.
Christmas in the Castle Library has the depth of faith found in a Michael Phillips novel, a setting rivaling Lori Wick's "royal" story," and the romantic swoonyness of Pepper Basham (but without needing a freezer after reading kisses. Thank you, Ann!)
Seriously, though. I can't tell you what I didn't love about this book. My only quibble is just a personal issue that is no fault of the book's. And I wouldn't change that for anything. It is an important part of the story (and thank you, Ann for not emphasizing it so much that it lost its value and punch). What was it? Well, I guess I can tell (I was afraid of spoilers but there aren't any). Our hero comments that he likes her curves. Seriously, now you know what a prude I am. I'm GLAD he said it... even if it makes me uncomfortable.
What you do get is a story about a brilliant woman who isn't so brilliant at seeing truths about herself. (the age-old story, no?) Hiding in a world of books and the knowledge found there, she tries to compensate for perceived flaws by being smarter than others and invisible to the world, all while hating her invisibility. Again, so very like most of us. And like most of us, this might not have become a problem if she'd looked to the Lord and His Word rather than distancing herself from the only Source of worth that can help.
In the end, you get two flawed people trying to navigate difficult circumstances while also researching a century-old mystery. Beautiful, rich, powerful, and all in a gentle and delightful Christmas read (perfect for any time of the year, though).
Drumming my fingers for the next.
December 11, 2025
I've been looking forward to reading Christmas in the Castle Library since it came out last year, but by the time I got to it, the holiday season had passed, so I decided to wait until the next one was upon us and so, here we are.
The audiobook was nice, but what I'd like to focus on is the Hallmark vibes I got from the plot. You can't convince me this isn't a movie in the making!! I was expecting it to be at least partially a historical read though, and was surprised when it was all set in the present.
There was a lot of faith content, right from the get go, and I really enjoyed that part of the story, with Ellie learning to reconnect with God and deepening her faith as she went along.
Something I wasn't the biggest fan of, was her insecurities. Not the fact that she had them, or that they were relatable, but because she kept mentioning them over and over again. She didn't feel good enough, and she let all of us know it, repeatedly. It only got marginally better at the end.
The romance was cute, though I think she and Mark could've used a bit more chemistry. I liked them as a pairing, but they're not a couple that's going to stick with me in the long run, if that makes sense.
The mystery moved a little too slow for my liking, but it was a nice addition to the story, and it's what kept me engaged throughout.
Christmas in the Castle Library was an alright read overall, but it could've been just a tad shorter, and the world a little more developed.
The audiobook was nice, but what I'd like to focus on is the Hallmark vibes I got from the plot. You can't convince me this isn't a movie in the making!! I was expecting it to be at least partially a historical read though, and was surprised when it was all set in the present.
There was a lot of faith content, right from the get go, and I really enjoyed that part of the story, with Ellie learning to reconnect with God and deepening her faith as she went along.
Something I wasn't the biggest fan of, was her insecurities. Not the fact that she had them, or that they were relatable, but because she kept mentioning them over and over again. She didn't feel good enough, and she let all of us know it, repeatedly. It only got marginally better at the end.
The romance was cute, though I think she and Mark could've used a bit more chemistry. I liked them as a pairing, but they're not a couple that's going to stick with me in the long run, if that makes sense.
The mystery moved a little too slow for my liking, but it was a nice addition to the story, and it's what kept me engaged throughout.
Christmas in the Castle Library was an alright read overall, but it could've been just a tad shorter, and the world a little more developed.
December 4, 2025
Oh my goodness! I absolutely loved this book! Just amazing. This book is set in modern day. Ellie is working on her dissertation for her doctorate. This involves going to Lethersby which a country in Europe, where she can hopefully solve the mystery behind what happened to a Queen that disappeared a long time ago. No scholars have been able to do it but she hopes to be the one. While researching in the castle library she meets Mark who soon helps her with the research.
Ellie and Mark were a great couple. I loved all there library meetings, and everything about them. The setting of Christmas at castle library showed vividly throughout the book. Mark’s secret was obvious but I was here for it! Loved it! Ellie is convinced she is not adequate or pretty and has been putting God on the back burner. I loved seeing her turn around and start embracing God, making sure she spent time with him and making him a priority! The Christian content in this book is outstanding! The mystery of what happened to the queen was very interesting! Also I listened to the audiobook and it was excellent! If you are looking for a cozy Christmas romance with mystery and strong Christian Content then you need to read this book! I highly recommend!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Ellie and Mark were a great couple. I loved all there library meetings, and everything about them. The setting of Christmas at castle library showed vividly throughout the book. Mark’s secret was obvious but I was here for it! Loved it! Ellie is convinced she is not adequate or pretty and has been putting God on the back burner. I loved seeing her turn around and start embracing God, making sure she spent time with him and making him a priority! The Christian content in this book is outstanding! The mystery of what happened to the queen was very interesting! Also I listened to the audiobook and it was excellent! If you are looking for a cozy Christmas romance with mystery and strong Christian Content then you need to read this book! I highly recommend!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
December 18, 2024
4.5 stars ✨
What a delightful Christmas novel! It has a little bit of everything: a queen who disappeared into the night, history, royal balls, and deep, faith-filled lessons. I especially enjoyed the growth of Ellie’s character as she wrestled with her struggles around self-worth and body image. Her journey felt relatable and heartfelt, and the story beautifully wove in scriptural truths and God’s Word.
This book offers surprising depth for a cozy Christmas read, delivering hope and encouragement alongside a sweet and tender romance.
Read if you enjoy:
✨A cozy library and castle backdrop
✨Heartwarming Christmas themes
✨Hidden identity trope
✨A curvy female main character
✨ A peek inside royal life
✨A beautiful journey of growing closer to God
What’s even more exciting is that the series continues with another character from this book, promising to take the mystery even deeper! I can’t wait to see where the story leads next.
What a delightful Christmas novel! It has a little bit of everything: a queen who disappeared into the night, history, royal balls, and deep, faith-filled lessons. I especially enjoyed the growth of Ellie’s character as she wrestled with her struggles around self-worth and body image. Her journey felt relatable and heartfelt, and the story beautifully wove in scriptural truths and God’s Word.
This book offers surprising depth for a cozy Christmas read, delivering hope and encouragement alongside a sweet and tender romance.
Read if you enjoy:
✨A cozy library and castle backdrop
✨Heartwarming Christmas themes
✨Hidden identity trope
✨A curvy female main character
✨ A peek inside royal life
✨A beautiful journey of growing closer to God
What’s even more exciting is that the series continues with another character from this book, promising to take the mystery even deeper! I can’t wait to see where the story leads next.
January 13, 2026
"And you're just what I've always needed, darling."
4.5 stars rounded up!
Christmas in the Castle Library is a beautifully written story about Ellie who has lost her way spiritually. It is also about her working on her dissertation for her Ph.D. and gets invited to Leathersby to solve the mystery of the disappearance of the queen from the early 1900s.
Ann did a beautiful job of weaving together romance, mystery, and Christian messages about finding Christ again and seeking Him in all things. Ellie discovers and realizes what is truly important as she researches and petitions God in prayer for help.
I really enjoyed this sweet story. There were some messages I needed to hear. And I loved the chemistry between Mark and Ellie. I loved her relationship with her sister and how she strengthens it by the end of the story.
Just a heads up, the Christian messages are very prominent and strong throughout, which didn't bother me, but for some readers it might be a turn off if they aren't aware going in.
Content Guide:
Language: none
Sexual Content: Clean-sweet kissing, feelings of spiritual/intellectual/physical attraction
Violence/gore: none
Substance Use: Mild-Mention of casual drinking of what might be wine or something similar
Prejudices: none
Religious Content: Christian-Strong messages of faith, turning one's life over to God, prayer, etc.
Other: Feelings of insecurity mainly regarding inadequacies and body image
4.5 stars rounded up!
Christmas in the Castle Library is a beautifully written story about Ellie who has lost her way spiritually. It is also about her working on her dissertation for her Ph.D. and gets invited to Leathersby to solve the mystery of the disappearance of the queen from the early 1900s.
Ann did a beautiful job of weaving together romance, mystery, and Christian messages about finding Christ again and seeking Him in all things. Ellie discovers and realizes what is truly important as she researches and petitions God in prayer for help.
I really enjoyed this sweet story. There were some messages I needed to hear. And I loved the chemistry between Mark and Ellie. I loved her relationship with her sister and how she strengthens it by the end of the story.
Just a heads up, the Christian messages are very prominent and strong throughout, which didn't bother me, but for some readers it might be a turn off if they aren't aware going in.
Content Guide:
Language: none
Sexual Content: Clean-sweet kissing, feelings of spiritual/intellectual/physical attraction
Violence/gore: none
Substance Use: Mild-Mention of casual drinking of what might be wine or something similar
Prejudices: none
Religious Content: Christian-Strong messages of faith, turning one's life over to God, prayer, etc.
Other: Feelings of insecurity mainly regarding inadequacies and body image
December 24, 2024
I must start by admitting something that is probably controversial and unexpected. Anytime I see a royal Christmas movie on Hallmark Channel, I cringe and turn to something else. 🫣
I am not a fan of royal romances—or so I thought. But Ann Swindell has changed my mind with this beautiful book! 😍
Ellie Sawyer has been obsessed with the disappearance of Queen Alma of Leathersby for as long as she can remember. Now her doctoral dissertation is riding on her solving the century-old mystery.
After being granted a one-month Christmastime residency at the Royal Castle Library, she’s determined to figure out what happened to the queen and bring closure to the people of Leathersby. But her plan is complicated by a gorgeous history-loving castle employee and his unexpected secret. Will Ellie be able to get to the bottom of the mystery or will she sabotage the opportunity of a lifetime because of fear?
This was so much more than a romance. It was full of mystery, depth, faith, and heart. I know when I find myself highlighting a fiction book, I know it’s going to be a 5-star read. 🤩
I loved Ellie’s journey and identified with her in so many ways. Faith was a major part of her story—specifically rediscovering and deepening her faith. There was a clear thread of God’s sovereignty that was woven throughout the pages and it was so lovely to read!
The end progressed a bit faster than I anticipated (and than I typically like), but I was so enchanted by the story that I wasn’t particularly bothered by it. I can’t wait for the next book in this series!
A special thank you to the author for sending me a copy of this book to review and share (along with a sweet handwritten note). She did such a beautiful job!! ♥️
I am not a fan of royal romances—or so I thought. But Ann Swindell has changed my mind with this beautiful book! 😍
Ellie Sawyer has been obsessed with the disappearance of Queen Alma of Leathersby for as long as she can remember. Now her doctoral dissertation is riding on her solving the century-old mystery.
After being granted a one-month Christmastime residency at the Royal Castle Library, she’s determined to figure out what happened to the queen and bring closure to the people of Leathersby. But her plan is complicated by a gorgeous history-loving castle employee and his unexpected secret. Will Ellie be able to get to the bottom of the mystery or will she sabotage the opportunity of a lifetime because of fear?
This was so much more than a romance. It was full of mystery, depth, faith, and heart. I know when I find myself highlighting a fiction book, I know it’s going to be a 5-star read. 🤩
I loved Ellie’s journey and identified with her in so many ways. Faith was a major part of her story—specifically rediscovering and deepening her faith. There was a clear thread of God’s sovereignty that was woven throughout the pages and it was so lovely to read!
The end progressed a bit faster than I anticipated (and than I typically like), but I was so enchanted by the story that I wasn’t particularly bothered by it. I can’t wait for the next book in this series!
A special thank you to the author for sending me a copy of this book to review and share (along with a sweet handwritten note). She did such a beautiful job!! ♥️
February 3, 2025
It was a joy to write this book, and I’m so thankful for the support I’ve experienced in sending my first novel into the world. It’s been an immense gift, and one I am deeply grateful for. 💛
Book #2 in the series is in the works, releasing October of 2025!
Book #2 in the series is in the works, releasing October of 2025!
December 18, 2025
This is much more that just a Christmas read. There is a mystery to unlock, learning to love yourself and who you are in Christ and romance as well. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.
December 20, 2025
I can understand all of the rave reviews for this book after experiencing a Christmas in Lethersby. Getting to meet Ellie and Mark, I can't help but fall in love with their quiet demeanors and faithful devotion to the Lord. Factor in the academic elements of Ellie working to complete her dissertation and it's a researcher's dream to step into these pages. I truly love that Ellie's thoughts reflect so many of my own as she leans on God to work past her inhibitions. Her natural reticence and fear of rejection takes quite the journey, but it is satisfactorily worthwhile to see how everything unfolds.
Incorporating meaningful references from the Bible, this book reads as if moving through a topical study on everything from perfect love casting out fear to abiding in Christ. It's a devotional pilgrimage as Ellie discovers who God has created her to be and how she can fully step into her calling to serve Him. Readers seeking clearly Christian content in their books will find Christmas in the Castle Library to be a story that is wholly inseparable from its ultimate message of hope and new life in the Gospel, making it one of the most wonderous reads of the Christmas season.
Review link: https://christianshelves.blogspot.com...
Incorporating meaningful references from the Bible, this book reads as if moving through a topical study on everything from perfect love casting out fear to abiding in Christ. It's a devotional pilgrimage as Ellie discovers who God has created her to be and how she can fully step into her calling to serve Him. Readers seeking clearly Christian content in their books will find Christmas in the Castle Library to be a story that is wholly inseparable from its ultimate message of hope and new life in the Gospel, making it one of the most wonderous reads of the Christmas season.
Review link: https://christianshelves.blogspot.com...
November 19, 2025
Reread Nov. 2025: in preparation to read book 2, I happily reread Christmas in the Castle Library. Love this book, the characters, setting, and spiritual encouragement! ❤️
Original Review Dec. 2024:
There was a lot of hype about this book, and I’m happy to say the rumors are true! It’s such a good story 😍
Ellie’s battle with her own image was very touching. I actually think most ladies struggle with this in some form or fashion in life, so it was very easy to relate to her (at least for me). I LOVED how the author pointed everything back to Christ. He is our home; He is the vine and our source of strength and acceptance. So good!
There were also many wonderful side characters! Mark (of course, he could be classified as a MC) was such a gentleman. I also loved Thomas the chauffeur 🥰 Delphine was a great friend for Ellie, and I’m glad she gets her own story in the next book.
Definitely add this to your Christmas TBR❤️ I know I plan to read it again in the future 🥰
Original Review Dec. 2024:
There was a lot of hype about this book, and I’m happy to say the rumors are true! It’s such a good story 😍
Ellie’s battle with her own image was very touching. I actually think most ladies struggle with this in some form or fashion in life, so it was very easy to relate to her (at least for me). I LOVED how the author pointed everything back to Christ. He is our home; He is the vine and our source of strength and acceptance. So good!
There were also many wonderful side characters! Mark (of course, he could be classified as a MC) was such a gentleman. I also loved Thomas the chauffeur 🥰 Delphine was a great friend for Ellie, and I’m glad she gets her own story in the next book.
Definitely add this to your Christmas TBR❤️ I know I plan to read it again in the future 🥰
December 23, 2025
This was really cute! It sorta reminded me of Hallmark/old Barbie movie😆 It was a little predictable but very clean and overall a great Christmas read. :)
Full review to come soon<3
Full review to come soon<3
October 10, 2024
"Bookworms, Christmas connoisseurs, and lovers of royalty, add Christmas in the Castle Library to your stockings (and/or wishlists) this Christmas! Ann Swindell's debut novel is such a beautiful tale of love, worth, and what it truly means to live by faith, tucked within the pages a sweet Christmas romance. The truth and wisdom found inside this delightful story will stay with me a long time."
...Is my official endorsement for the book, but (slightly less flowery language aside), I really loved this book. I wasn't sure what to think when I first started. It almost seemed more non-fiction than fiction at times because of the depth of discussions and research the main character took part in but I pretty quickly realized that's just her character. She's a scholar, she thinks things through deeply. I came to really appreciate that.
It ended up being equal parts super cute, adorably swoony, and deep. If you're looking for a light, romantic Christmas read without too much faith or challenge then, well, this one might not be for you. While it's definitely a sweet read, it has a lot of depth to it, and a lot of faith themes not only touched on but truly journeyed through.
Beautiful read and one I'm already looking forward to reading again.
...Is my official endorsement for the book, but (slightly less flowery language aside), I really loved this book. I wasn't sure what to think when I first started. It almost seemed more non-fiction than fiction at times because of the depth of discussions and research the main character took part in but I pretty quickly realized that's just her character. She's a scholar, she thinks things through deeply. I came to really appreciate that.
It ended up being equal parts super cute, adorably swoony, and deep. If you're looking for a light, romantic Christmas read without too much faith or challenge then, well, this one might not be for you. While it's definitely a sweet read, it has a lot of depth to it, and a lot of faith themes not only touched on but truly journeyed through.
Beautiful read and one I'm already looking forward to reading again.
November 13, 2024
Charming, romantic and uplifting, Ann Swindell’s newest release, Christmas in the Castle Library, is a must read this holiday season. Upon reading the first chapter, I was drawn in by the mystery of the missing Queen Alma and Ellie’s determination to discover the truth. While the mystery drives the story, the tender romance makes for a pleasant trip. I loved the sweetness in the romance. Mark is a patient, tenderhearted gentleman. As the book progressed, I was pleasantly surprised by the amount of Biblical Truth Swindell laced through the story. Christmas in the Castle Library is a sweet, romantic Christmas mystery, but it’s also so much more than that.
I discovered so much about myself while reading the book in addition to enjoying the pure, sweet romance. Swindell crafted the story in such a way that while Ellie fights through her insecurities in the book, the reader can also gently examine their own as well. I absolutely loved the depth and emotion in Ellie and Mark’s story. The lessons unfold perfectly in a way that is thought-provoking without being preachy. The character development was excellent as well. I was thoroughly invested in not just the main characters, but the side characters as well. I absolutely recommend this book and I’m looking forward to reading book two when it releases!
Intimacy: Sweet Kisses Only
Language: None
I discovered so much about myself while reading the book in addition to enjoying the pure, sweet romance. Swindell crafted the story in such a way that while Ellie fights through her insecurities in the book, the reader can also gently examine their own as well. I absolutely loved the depth and emotion in Ellie and Mark’s story. The lessons unfold perfectly in a way that is thought-provoking without being preachy. The character development was excellent as well. I was thoroughly invested in not just the main characters, but the side characters as well. I absolutely recommend this book and I’m looking forward to reading book two when it releases!
Intimacy: Sweet Kisses Only
Language: None
October 11, 2024
Christmas in the Castle Library read like the soft, melodious rise and fall of a a piece of classical music that feels like home.
This book has the vibes of a Hallmark Christmas royal romance movie plus serious themes, enjoyable and relatable characters, and a historical mystery I itched to get to the bottom of. I'm excited there'll be a second book that goes deeper into the second phase of the mystery!
Some of the themes I especially related to were...
🕯️ second-guessing yourself and irrational fear of failure (I had a similar experience as Ellie in university where I was afraid of answering questions in class even though I knew I knew the answer—because I'd end up tripping over myself and saying nothing consequential in the end)
🕯️ life feeling too busy to keep up with your spiritual life
🕯️ learning who you are at a fundamental level, apart from your traits and interests
The romance was quite light, but I loved how it was portrayed! I particularly appreciated this line:
"He wasn't just a cute guy; he was Mark, and the thing about him that truly made her heart ache was the very thing that she didn't even know how to name."
I feel that way about my husband and I've rarely heard anyone else acknowledge it! I couldn't tell you what makes me love him; I just do.
I seriously could not recommend a book with more exquisite Christmas vibes ❄️🕯️🎄 (and there was frost on the ground this morning... perfect timing!)
Thank you to WhiteCrown Publishing for the complimentary ARC! I wasn't required to post a review and all opinions are my own.
This book has the vibes of a Hallmark Christmas royal romance movie plus serious themes, enjoyable and relatable characters, and a historical mystery I itched to get to the bottom of. I'm excited there'll be a second book that goes deeper into the second phase of the mystery!
Some of the themes I especially related to were...
🕯️ second-guessing yourself and irrational fear of failure (I had a similar experience as Ellie in university where I was afraid of answering questions in class even though I knew I knew the answer—because I'd end up tripping over myself and saying nothing consequential in the end)
🕯️ life feeling too busy to keep up with your spiritual life
🕯️ learning who you are at a fundamental level, apart from your traits and interests
The romance was quite light, but I loved how it was portrayed! I particularly appreciated this line:
"He wasn't just a cute guy; he was Mark, and the thing about him that truly made her heart ache was the very thing that she didn't even know how to name."
I feel that way about my husband and I've rarely heard anyone else acknowledge it! I couldn't tell you what makes me love him; I just do.
I seriously could not recommend a book with more exquisite Christmas vibes ❄️🕯️🎄 (and there was frost on the ground this morning... perfect timing!)
Thank you to WhiteCrown Publishing for the complimentary ARC! I wasn't required to post a review and all opinions are my own.
October 8, 2025
I love fiction books about books. Especially books about bookstores, libraries, and academia. As a PhD-seeking-wannabe, I love that this book was not only Christian, but also about a library And academia… in a castle!
🤩
It's a rare occurrence that I pick up a contemporary book these days, but took a chance on this one.
While it was wordy and could have been shorter, I enjoyed the clean romance, deep faith, relevant topics, engaging history mystery, side characters, and again, geeky scholar stuff. This was not a cheesy contemporary romance in my opinion.
✨📚✨A more in-depth review soon on my “Clean Reads” channel
🤩
It's a rare occurrence that I pick up a contemporary book these days, but took a chance on this one.
While it was wordy and could have been shorter, I enjoyed the clean romance, deep faith, relevant topics, engaging history mystery, side characters, and again, geeky scholar stuff. This was not a cheesy contemporary romance in my opinion.
✨📚✨A more in-depth review soon on my “Clean Reads” channel
October 27, 2024
I don't read a lot of Christmas novels, mainly because a lot of them are similar, Hallmark-like, and unrealistic. Sure, I love a fun read that I don't have to think through every now and then, but I mostly enjoy books with a lot of depth and needs-to-be-dwelt-on passages. And then, I saw Christmas in the Castle Library. The cover drew me first. Yes, I am one of those people who are a hundred times more likely to pick a book up if it has a gorgeous cover! Add to that missing royalty and a book about books?! I had to pick it up. And yes, this book could be likened to a holiday Hallmark movie--it's sweet, has a picturesque city, castle, nice people, that Hallmark drama, but it's more. It has depth, it has character growth, it made me cry when a section didn't go as I wished it to, but appreciated how it made the characters grow. I loved the themes in this book of trust in God and love for God, being the ultimate fulfillment in life.
Christmas in the Castle Library is the kind of book you want to pick up and snuggle in a cozy blanket, hot chocolate in hand, in front of a fire on a cold day. And, please, no distractions! This book feels like watching snow fall softly and hearing classical music playing.
My only disappointment with this book was a couple of things written implying that the King James Bible is too difficult to understand, so one of the characters switched to an app on her phone. I find the language of the King James Bible beautiful, lyrical, and more easy to understand due to its precise language, and was saddened to see it portrayed almost as less-than because it uses beautiful language that a scholar who adores studying should find intriguing, wonderful for meditating, and, being well educated, should have no problem understanding, especially since she spends her days with historical research and ancient books.
Overall, however, this book is a beautiful read, and I highly recommend reading it during the holidays.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher and was not required to leave a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Christmas in the Castle Library is the kind of book you want to pick up and snuggle in a cozy blanket, hot chocolate in hand, in front of a fire on a cold day. And, please, no distractions! This book feels like watching snow fall softly and hearing classical music playing.
My only disappointment with this book was a couple of things written implying that the King James Bible is too difficult to understand, so one of the characters switched to an app on her phone. I find the language of the King James Bible beautiful, lyrical, and more easy to understand due to its precise language, and was saddened to see it portrayed almost as less-than because it uses beautiful language that a scholar who adores studying should find intriguing, wonderful for meditating, and, being well educated, should have no problem understanding, especially since she spends her days with historical research and ancient books.
Overall, however, this book is a beautiful read, and I highly recommend reading it during the holidays.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher and was not required to leave a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
November 25, 2024
This is the perfect book to read with a comfy blanket and hot cup of tea. The characters, setting, and writing are delightful! It has the best Hallmark Christmas vibes but rings with Truth.
February 8, 2026
Stars: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️+ (5 plus stars)
Read: October 2024
Series: In the Castle Library, #1
Format: Kindle e-Book
Challenge Prompt: CNL's #10 of 50 - "Published in 2024"
Book #113 of 2024:
THIS. BOOK. 🥰 Sighhhhhhh…….
I saw this debut novel a week ago and I couldn’t stop thinking about it. So I bought it two days ago and finished at 1:13am CDST. Ironically, it’s my 113th book for 2024.
This has the wonderment of Cinderella but with so much more depth, growth, meaning, and spiritual reflection. It’s a contemporary romance and mystery but most of it takes place in a castle in Europe. It has an old world charm to it. I’m not even one to follow or be interested in royalty at all but these Christlike servants redefine royalty.
The Ingredients:
- a European castle
- a library
- a royal mystery
- gowns, a ball, Christmas & royal finery
- a budding romance between a self-conscious doctoral scholar of European history and a handsome history lover and fellow reader
- lots of Scripture and a focus on spiritual growth
Mix the above ingredients. Proceed with finding a recliner or a comfy couch, some hot tea, and a throw blanket. Notify everyone that you’ve gone off the grid until further notice 🤣
🎺 Let me just call it now:
This novel will be loved by many and posted about numerous times in the months to come amongst Christian fiction readers. Go and buy it, borrow it, or read over a shoulder! (You’re welcome!) 😉
I found myself strolling through this book, re-reading parts, highlighting many times, and just reflecting on it. I took my time and just let myself be in a Christmas-y state of hygge over a novel. I didn’t want it to end so I’m so thankful that this is a series and more bookish bliss is coming.
I loved it start to finish and knew it was 5+ stars early on. Sometimes you just KNOW❣️
Read: October 2024
Series: In the Castle Library, #1
Format: Kindle e-Book
Challenge Prompt: CNL's #10 of 50 - "Published in 2024"
Book #113 of 2024:
THIS. BOOK. 🥰 Sighhhhhhh…….
I saw this debut novel a week ago and I couldn’t stop thinking about it. So I bought it two days ago and finished at 1:13am CDST. Ironically, it’s my 113th book for 2024.
This has the wonderment of Cinderella but with so much more depth, growth, meaning, and spiritual reflection. It’s a contemporary romance and mystery but most of it takes place in a castle in Europe. It has an old world charm to it. I’m not even one to follow or be interested in royalty at all but these Christlike servants redefine royalty.
The Ingredients:
- a European castle
- a library
- a royal mystery
- gowns, a ball, Christmas & royal finery
- a budding romance between a self-conscious doctoral scholar of European history and a handsome history lover and fellow reader
- lots of Scripture and a focus on spiritual growth
Mix the above ingredients. Proceed with finding a recliner or a comfy couch, some hot tea, and a throw blanket. Notify everyone that you’ve gone off the grid until further notice 🤣
🎺 Let me just call it now:
This novel will be loved by many and posted about numerous times in the months to come amongst Christian fiction readers. Go and buy it, borrow it, or read over a shoulder! (You’re welcome!) 😉
I found myself strolling through this book, re-reading parts, highlighting many times, and just reflecting on it. I took my time and just let myself be in a Christmas-y state of hygge over a novel. I didn’t want it to end so I’m so thankful that this is a series and more bookish bliss is coming.
I loved it start to finish and knew it was 5+ stars early on. Sometimes you just KNOW❣️
Read
December 28, 2025I loved the centrality of Scripture in this book and the strong faith message that was spot on and a very important reminder. It was lovely to escape to a fictional castle library with a handsome prince and a historic mystery with an academic historian as the main character, since I could relate to her nerdiness and value of history.
I listened to the audiobook though, and majorly struggled with the narrator. The audiobook was very dramatic which meant that the main character sounded shocked, horrified, close to tears, etc. for most of the book. The narrator added so much to the story that I had trouble knowing what the author intended and what the narrator inserted. I would have enjoyed the book far more had I read it myself with my normal amounts of inflection in my head and no fake male French accents.
As it was, Ellie came across as very insecure, cowardly, and ultimately hard to like, which I think was compounded by the narrator's dramatics. There was a great deal of repetition in her thoughts and motives. The plot was good, the faith was great, but at least with the audiobook, the main character became difficult to spend time with.
I listened to the audiobook though, and majorly struggled with the narrator. The audiobook was very dramatic which meant that the main character sounded shocked, horrified, close to tears, etc. for most of the book. The narrator added so much to the story that I had trouble knowing what the author intended and what the narrator inserted. I would have enjoyed the book far more had I read it myself with my normal amounts of inflection in my head and no fake male French accents.
As it was, Ellie came across as very insecure, cowardly, and ultimately hard to like, which I think was compounded by the narrator's dramatics. There was a great deal of repetition in her thoughts and motives. The plot was good, the faith was great, but at least with the audiobook, the main character became difficult to spend time with.
January 1, 2026
What a lovely book! I really enjoyed the story and the fairytale of it all. The process of trusting God that you can do more than you think you can with His help. Love how the main character came to know this.
January 3, 2026
This book captivated me from the beginning. The story was so unique and different, it was so fun to read this book! I mean, a queen who disappears and a castle at Christmas, who wouldn’t like that! I related to Ellie a lot. She reminds me of myself in many ways. In her growing faith, were lessons that enriched my soul as well.
When I received this book as part of my book subscription, I was expecting a sweet/cheesy Christmas romance. To be clear, there were moments of that in the story, but it was so much deeper than that. There was so many great, deep heart moments included as well. It was a beautiful balance and also a great picture of how we often need to be reminded of things more than once before change begins to happen in our hearts.
As I mentioned, I related to Ellie the most. I have struggled with anxiety most of my childhood. It is better now, but there are definitely still moments I have it. As Ellie grew in her faith in God, and learned so many truths of God’s love, grace, and desire for us. It reminded me of times in my life when those same truths were spoken to me. I loved how the Bible verses were included as well. I definitely wanted to shake Ellie multiple times (IYKYK), but truly enjoyed her and Mark’s story!
Another element that I really enjoyed was Ellie being a curvier FMC. As a fellow curvy girly, it was great to see that represented in the novel. I also appreciated the little aspects of this that were included in Ellie’s thoughts and emotions (Awareness of space, insecurities, difficulty with dressing, comparison, etc). It felt realistic, even though I still wanted to shake her when she was degrading on herself. A great reminder to find beauty in the body God gave us!
Ann Swindell definitely knocked this one out of the castle with this one! I look forward to the next book to find out more! If you enjoy deep faith elements, romance, slight mystery, then this book is definitely for you!
Content Guide:
Language: None
Spice: Level 1
TW: Anxiety Rep
When I received this book as part of my book subscription, I was expecting a sweet/cheesy Christmas romance. To be clear, there were moments of that in the story, but it was so much deeper than that. There was so many great, deep heart moments included as well. It was a beautiful balance and also a great picture of how we often need to be reminded of things more than once before change begins to happen in our hearts.
As I mentioned, I related to Ellie the most. I have struggled with anxiety most of my childhood. It is better now, but there are definitely still moments I have it. As Ellie grew in her faith in God, and learned so many truths of God’s love, grace, and desire for us. It reminded me of times in my life when those same truths were spoken to me. I loved how the Bible verses were included as well. I definitely wanted to shake Ellie multiple times (IYKYK), but truly enjoyed her and Mark’s story!
Another element that I really enjoyed was Ellie being a curvier FMC. As a fellow curvy girly, it was great to see that represented in the novel. I also appreciated the little aspects of this that were included in Ellie’s thoughts and emotions (Awareness of space, insecurities, difficulty with dressing, comparison, etc). It felt realistic, even though I still wanted to shake her when she was degrading on herself. A great reminder to find beauty in the body God gave us!
Ann Swindell definitely knocked this one out of the castle with this one! I look forward to the next book to find out more! If you enjoy deep faith elements, romance, slight mystery, then this book is definitely for you!
Content Guide:
Language: None
Spice: Level 1
TW: Anxiety Rep
August 17, 2025
I'd heard so many great things about this story and it turns out it was all true!
I liked Ellie from the start. She seems so normal and relatable. Ellie has an easy way about her that draws you to her. It's evident when she arrives at the castle in Lethersby, where she needs to finish research for her dissertation. I love that she's captivated by what happened to their queen because she disappeared and was never heard from again.
Lo and behold, there's a man at the castle who seems like he should be able to help! On top of that, he's not hard to look at and is incredibly kind. Poor Ellie can't see herself past events that happened to her when she was younger (something I can still relate to), but Mark sees her for who she is and he has an incredible impact on her. He does have a secret that will change the trajectory of their friendship on an incredibly important day for her.
The hunt to learn more about the missing queen certainly kept me turning the page. I loved how Mark and Ellie searched the clues as much as they could. The supporting cast was the chef's kiss to this story. Yes, it gives Hallmark feels all around, but this is one I'd be interested in for a change. lol Delphine was an early favorite and I can't wait to read her story.
The faith was incredibly strong in this story, and I don't ever feel like I can ever get enough, especially when it's done so well as it was!
I liked Ellie from the start. She seems so normal and relatable. Ellie has an easy way about her that draws you to her. It's evident when she arrives at the castle in Lethersby, where she needs to finish research for her dissertation. I love that she's captivated by what happened to their queen because she disappeared and was never heard from again.
Lo and behold, there's a man at the castle who seems like he should be able to help! On top of that, he's not hard to look at and is incredibly kind. Poor Ellie can't see herself past events that happened to her when she was younger (something I can still relate to), but Mark sees her for who she is and he has an incredible impact on her. He does have a secret that will change the trajectory of their friendship on an incredibly important day for her.
The hunt to learn more about the missing queen certainly kept me turning the page. I loved how Mark and Ellie searched the clues as much as they could. The supporting cast was the chef's kiss to this story. Yes, it gives Hallmark feels all around, but this is one I'd be interested in for a change. lol Delphine was an early favorite and I can't wait to read her story.
The faith was incredibly strong in this story, and I don't ever feel like I can ever get enough, especially when it's done so well as it was!
January 11, 2025
This book deserves 10 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟.
Absolutely beautiful faith content and believable characters. Written with so much historical detail, I had to check and see if Lethersby is a real country!
HIGHLY recommend 💙♥️💚.
Absolutely beautiful faith content and believable characters. Written with so much historical detail, I had to check and see if Lethersby is a real country!
HIGHLY recommend 💙♥️💚.
December 15, 2024
I'm so glad I picked up this book. What a beautiful and heartwarming story! I started it hoping to be entertained, but as I got to know Ellie, I felt a deep connection to her. I found myself cheering her on, but also relating to her fears. I appreciated the messages of hope and faith woven throughout the book. Mark was charming and such a sweetheart. He and Ellie were such an adorable couple. I simply loved this book and can't wait until the next one!
December 27, 2025
Wow I loved this book 🥹
It was so sweet and filled with God’s truth! I enjoyed the fact that it didn’t follow the predictable plot lines that a lot of romances follow, it had twists and turns that made it hard to put down!
This will for sure not be the book for everyone but I definitely needed the encouragement and hope I read in these pages!!
It was so sweet and filled with God’s truth! I enjoyed the fact that it didn’t follow the predictable plot lines that a lot of romances follow, it had twists and turns that made it hard to put down!
This will for sure not be the book for everyone but I definitely needed the encouragement and hope I read in these pages!!
November 13, 2024
I adored this book. I was hooked from the title and the story did not disappoint. I loved how faith so was effortlessly interwoven into the story, and that the conflict was natural and not highly dramatized as it can be in a romance book. Watching Ellie's faith journey in this beautiful setting of a castle and the castle grounds was inspiring. I could relate to Ellie in so many ways and this book spoke to me. It always amazes me, the ways in which God can use anything to help us work through things and draw closer to Him.
I loved the way Mark and Ellie interacted and how he treated her. I also really got into the mystery side and was so curious about what happened to the queen they were researching. I can't wait to continue finding out more about the previous queen and following the characters into the next installment of the series. Such a wonderful book. Highly recommend.
I loved the way Mark and Ellie interacted and how he treated her. I also really got into the mystery side and was so curious about what happened to the queen they were researching. I can't wait to continue finding out more about the previous queen and following the characters into the next installment of the series. Such a wonderful book. Highly recommend.
December 8, 2024
I had high hopes for Christmas in the Castle Library. The premise had everything I want in a book: a scholarly heroine who loves books and stories, a mysterious legend, a romance, and hello, a castle! In fact, I had such high hopes for this book, I purchased it but didn't read it until two months after it released.
Unfortunately, the actual book's rating is, for me, more a 2.8-3.3 than the perfect novel I sought. Some of that is, I acknowledge, on me because of high expectations. And there is a lot to like here. The country of Lethersby, for instance, is charming and mysterious in the way the best fictional countries are. The mystery of Queen Alma kept my pages turning, and I appreciated the tender chemistry between Mark and Ellie. Besides that, I had some definite suspicions about Mark's true identity. Those suspicions were a bit of a mixed bag for me, but they did add some intrigue to the story.
Beyond that, I did like Ellie because I could identify so much with her. I'm an English scholar, not a history scholar. And while I "kept up" with my faith more than she did in college and grad school, I'll own the fact that was because of legalistic tendencies and fear of God being mad at me. Those differences aside though, I'm as big a bibliophile as Ellie. I've struggled with the same sense of failure as she does, the same insecurities over my appearance, and the same social awkwardness. Thus, I rooted harder for her than usual to succeed not only academically, but spiritually, emotionally, and relationally. I loved seeing her start to come into her own and would've liked more of that character development.
The problem with Christmas at the Castle Library though, is that Ellie, Lethersby, and the rest of the story are not developed. They are told more than shown. Ellie's insecurities and motivations, in particular, are repeated over and over. Sometimes, Ellie or the narrator will say the same thing two or three different ways. Other times, characters will repeat dialogue or information to each other, apparently forgetting the other people in the scene were there the first time.
Additionally, because of the repetition of her negative feelings, Ellie often comes off as angsty and whiny. This is a big strike against her, because she's supposed to be a levelheaded, mature, if spiritually struggling woman. In other words, she's supposed to be a relatable, human, adult character. Characters like that shouldn't sound whiny, but Ellie does. Couple that with the fact that, in over 100 pages, we don't know the exact origins of any of Ellie's insecurities, and it starts to feel like she's just wallowing in self-pity. This didn't put me off her character completely, because I knew it wasn't Ann Swindell's intention. But it certainly didn't help, especially once Mark got involved, because Mark starts to read as if he exists to "rescue" Ellie. While I'm a big fan of a heroine finding her "prince," and a Christmas prince at that...no, Ellie needed to find strength in herself and God first.
Speaking of Mark, I could guess what his character arc would be a mile away. This is partially because such a huge deal is made of Lethersby being a small, private country--which is fine, until you get to the Lethersby scenes and realize...for over 100 pages, other than Mark and Delphine, there are literally no other Lethersbyian characters to be found. Couple that with some absolutely lackluster descriptions of Lethersby and the castle itself, and the entire country and journey became a letdown.
Overall then, Christmas at the Castle Library was a pretty big disappointment. If you don't mind the writing style, you'll probably like it fine. And as noted, you'll probably like it if, like me, you're into scholarly stories. But if you're looking for something a bit "deeper," with both a scholarly and holiday feel, allow me to suggest Melissa Tagg's One Royal Christmas or Rachel Hauck's A Christmas Wedding.
Unfortunately, the actual book's rating is, for me, more a 2.8-3.3 than the perfect novel I sought. Some of that is, I acknowledge, on me because of high expectations. And there is a lot to like here. The country of Lethersby, for instance, is charming and mysterious in the way the best fictional countries are. The mystery of Queen Alma kept my pages turning, and I appreciated the tender chemistry between Mark and Ellie. Besides that, I had some definite suspicions about Mark's true identity. Those suspicions were a bit of a mixed bag for me, but they did add some intrigue to the story.
Beyond that, I did like Ellie because I could identify so much with her. I'm an English scholar, not a history scholar. And while I "kept up" with my faith more than she did in college and grad school, I'll own the fact that was because of legalistic tendencies and fear of God being mad at me. Those differences aside though, I'm as big a bibliophile as Ellie. I've struggled with the same sense of failure as she does, the same insecurities over my appearance, and the same social awkwardness. Thus, I rooted harder for her than usual to succeed not only academically, but spiritually, emotionally, and relationally. I loved seeing her start to come into her own and would've liked more of that character development.
The problem with Christmas at the Castle Library though, is that Ellie, Lethersby, and the rest of the story are not developed. They are told more than shown. Ellie's insecurities and motivations, in particular, are repeated over and over. Sometimes, Ellie or the narrator will say the same thing two or three different ways. Other times, characters will repeat dialogue or information to each other, apparently forgetting the other people in the scene were there the first time.
Additionally, because of the repetition of her negative feelings, Ellie often comes off as angsty and whiny. This is a big strike against her, because she's supposed to be a levelheaded, mature, if spiritually struggling woman. In other words, she's supposed to be a relatable, human, adult character. Characters like that shouldn't sound whiny, but Ellie does. Couple that with the fact that, in over 100 pages, we don't know the exact origins of any of Ellie's insecurities, and it starts to feel like she's just wallowing in self-pity. This didn't put me off her character completely, because I knew it wasn't Ann Swindell's intention. But it certainly didn't help, especially once Mark got involved, because Mark starts to read as if he exists to "rescue" Ellie. While I'm a big fan of a heroine finding her "prince," and a Christmas prince at that...no, Ellie needed to find strength in herself and God first.
Speaking of Mark, I could guess what his character arc would be a mile away. This is partially because such a huge deal is made of Lethersby being a small, private country--which is fine, until you get to the Lethersby scenes and realize...for over 100 pages, other than Mark and Delphine, there are literally no other Lethersbyian characters to be found. Couple that with some absolutely lackluster descriptions of Lethersby and the castle itself, and the entire country and journey became a letdown.
Overall then, Christmas at the Castle Library was a pretty big disappointment. If you don't mind the writing style, you'll probably like it fine. And as noted, you'll probably like it if, like me, you're into scholarly stories. But if you're looking for something a bit "deeper," with both a scholarly and holiday feel, allow me to suggest Melissa Tagg's One Royal Christmas or Rachel Hauck's A Christmas Wedding.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 339 reviews