Two things stand out to me in this book. One is what a pleasure it is to read a dual-strand narrative where the protagonist of each strand feels distinct from the other, and the second is that the writer has done wonders with a tiny cast of characters and an isolated setting.
Our current-day protagonist, Blake, goes on a snow trip with her boyfriend to a “friend of a friend’s” snow cabin where everything that can go wrong does. There’s a snowstorm, the cabin has no supplies, there is no phone or internet reception, and her boyfriend’s friends don’t make it to the trip. I had an expectation that a cast of two might make for too tight of a story, but that was not the case. The story is expanded in several threads; through our second protagonist, Audrey, and the events that lead to her disappearance a handful of years before; through Blake and Audrey’s respective flashbacks; and through the clues Audrey left for anyone who might care to put together the truth of her disappearance.
If I Disappear is one of those twisty thrillers that is utterly satisfying when it all clicks together. The plot lines, the clues, the revelations – every moment of the story coming together pays off without feeling like it twisted just for the sake of being unpredictable or shocking. All of the clues were there with just the right number of red herrings done subtly enough to lead me as a reader exactly where the writer wanted me. It was nice to be cleverly deceived, to be lead to one understanding of Audrey’s events and how they relate to Blake’s position, only to be left with just enough uncertainty to doubt my own deductions.
This book is assuredly worth a read, though I have one minor gripe. Though I loved the development of Blake’s character, I found her a little irritating in the beginning chapters. She’s been with her boyfriend for seven months and found an engagement ring in his backpack a month ago and is happily setting off on this cabin trip in the belief that she is getting engaged. However, her opinions of her boyfriend aren’t stellar. Our first description of him is his “irritated face”, that he snaps at Blake, that she expects him to lecture her, and that he gets annoyed when she doesn’t do what he tells her. In turn, she gets annoyed when he goes through her duffel bag or when he expects her to do things for him, like… grab him a snack from the gas station? Soon after, she hates how he belittles her, then describes him as “so thoughtful”, that he really is a keeper, and then just as soon she hates how he trivialises her feelings, then he always knows exactly what to say to make her feel better. Blake, come on, girl, I know we’re in a twisty thriller here and things aren’t adding up, but at least try and convince me you like your boyfriend, especially if you’re excited to be engaged soon.