The book is mostly fine, akin to what you’d read in an early-2010s creepypasta, but in book form. I love physical media of less-traditional works such as this, so I was excited to get this book. The story carries an interesting premise and so it gets some stars for that.
A loss of stars stems from the lack of vocabulary from this new author. There were a plethora of opportunities to replace words with adjectives, synonyms, or substitutions of more succinct descriptors to break up the constant re-use of smaller, foundational words.
Another subtraction of stars is derived from the fact that this author desperately needs an editor, or at the very least a proofreading audience. Words are misspelled (ally versus alley, pg.36), character’s names change (Zachary versus Zackery, pg.98), and… whatever the heck a “screed” is in the context of pg.135. Those are just some, but there are dozens more. They don’t take away from much, but until errors like that are minimized if not outright proofed-out, I’d be hard-pressed to think the author’s writings will improve beyond three-star work.
Lastly, no stars lost because in a way, I’m happy I got to experience it, but chapter nine induced some light cringe. There’s this out-of-place back and forth “skit” between the protagonist and another character (pg.106) that doesn’t match the tone of the chapter, nor is it a tone that’s present at any other period in the book.
Anyway, still a fun read. I’m glad this book exists, and I hope the author has an opportunity to take this feedback seriously for their next project.