What do you think?
Rate this book
Arles Shepherd #2
The Fairest
When a young girl seeks out sanctuary with a total stranger, a nightmare follows in this riveting novel of suspense by Jenny Milchman, the USA Today bestselling author of The Usual Silence.
Author Kara Parsons is at a book signing in the town where she was raised. Before it’s over, a young girl approaches with a copy of Kara’s book containing a handwritten I am a missing child.
Most people would alert the police, but Kara knows what happens to the young and vulnerable when the system fails them. She turns to her former therapist, Arles Shepherd, who’s recovering from injuries and staying off the grid. But even Arles, who’s seen everything, finds something off about this girl who refuses to reveal her own name. What is she running from? And how much of what she says can be believed?
When a man with a gun manages to locate Arles’s remote wilderness home, the true threat is revealed, and Arles and Kara go on the run. But fleeing only gets them so far. To save this child, Arles must allow her to be found. And that’s when the real danger begins.
Author Kara Parsons is at a book signing in the town where she was raised. Before it’s over, a young girl approaches with a copy of Kara’s book containing a handwritten I am a missing child.
Most people would alert the police, but Kara knows what happens to the young and vulnerable when the system fails them. She turns to her former therapist, Arles Shepherd, who’s recovering from injuries and staying off the grid. But even Arles, who’s seen everything, finds something off about this girl who refuses to reveal her own name. What is she running from? And how much of what she says can be believed?
When a man with a gun manages to locate Arles’s remote wilderness home, the true threat is revealed, and Arles and Kara go on the run. But fleeing only gets them so far. To save this child, Arles must allow her to be found. And that’s when the real danger begins.
367 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 16, 2025
276 people are currently reading
2276 people want to read
About the author
Jenny Milchman
17 books625 followersJenny Milchman is the USA Today bestselling author of three novels, as well as the forthcoming Wicked River. Her books have won the Mary Higgins Clark and Silver Falchion awards, been praised by the New York Times, San Francisco Review of Books, the AP, and many other publications.
Jenny has given over five hundred workshops and talks on the writing and publishing process. She sits on the board of directors of International Thriller Writers, is a member of the Sisters in Crime speakers bureau, and founded Take Your Child to a Bookstore Day, which is celebrated annually in all fifty states and on five continents.
Jenny has given over five hundred workshops and talks on the writing and publishing process. She sits on the board of directors of International Thriller Writers, is a member of the Sisters in Crime speakers bureau, and founded Take Your Child to a Bookstore Day, which is celebrated annually in all fifty states and on five continents.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 26 of 26 reviews
September 1, 2025
4.5★s
The Fairest is the second book in the Arles Shepherd Thriller series by award-winning, best-selling American author, Jenny Milchman. Crime author, Kara Cross is at her local bookstore in Wedeskyull for a reading/signing event for her new novel when a young girl silently asks for her help with a written message: “I am a missing child”. It’s what Kara writes about, and this doesn’t seem like some Tik Tok stunt. In her own experience, involving the police is worse than useless, so her immediate solution to the dilemma is to take the child to her former therapist, Arles Shepherd at her mountain retreat, Fir Cove.
Arles is just about recovered from injuries sustained some four months earlier, but arrives back from a lengthy drive feeling rather unwell. When revived, she takes on the problem Kara has brought her with mixed feelings: keeping this expensively coiffed, manicured and dressed child, who refuses to give her name or any other details, who displays an unusual sense of entitlement, without notifying the relevant authorities, as Kara has requested, could land her in hot water.
Arles is puzzled, when she drives down the mountain to where the signal cuts in, that there is no Amber alert. And the new, trustworthy police chief is busy with something else. Arles checks out the Books and Brew shop to see that the other event that night was a PR do for a soon-to-be-released movie starring Kip Stratton. And while she stands there, a weird guy who is clearly a Kip Stratton superfan asks about a little girl.
Back at Fir Cove, carefully, without a tail, meals are prepared, beds are made, goodnights said. But early the next morning there are two fancy black cars in her driveway, and a small man with a gun is asking about a girl in the company of a woman. When Arles has seen him off, Kara and the girl have fled. With the help of a game camera, Arles figures out where they have gone, but the next day, the police chief has some bad news, and Arles is soon trekking through the woods hoping to find the girl.
Much more can’t be said without spoilers, but before matters are resolved, there are some nail-biting moments, a killing by axe and a collision take the body-count to four, and there are some jaw-dropping revelations about several persons charged with the care of minors.
Two narratives carry the story, and while Arles’s can be trusted, Kara’s might be unreliable. The girl, though, definitely has a talent for lying. The dialogue is often blackly funny. This instalment has plenty of twists and turns and red herrings to keep the reader guessing and the pages turning, and a neat resolution: will there be more of Arles Shepherd from Jenny Milchman?
This unbiased review is from an uncorrected proof copy provided by NetGalley and Thomas & Mercer.
The Fairest is the second book in the Arles Shepherd Thriller series by award-winning, best-selling American author, Jenny Milchman. Crime author, Kara Cross is at her local bookstore in Wedeskyull for a reading/signing event for her new novel when a young girl silently asks for her help with a written message: “I am a missing child”. It’s what Kara writes about, and this doesn’t seem like some Tik Tok stunt. In her own experience, involving the police is worse than useless, so her immediate solution to the dilemma is to take the child to her former therapist, Arles Shepherd at her mountain retreat, Fir Cove.
Arles is just about recovered from injuries sustained some four months earlier, but arrives back from a lengthy drive feeling rather unwell. When revived, she takes on the problem Kara has brought her with mixed feelings: keeping this expensively coiffed, manicured and dressed child, who refuses to give her name or any other details, who displays an unusual sense of entitlement, without notifying the relevant authorities, as Kara has requested, could land her in hot water.
Arles is puzzled, when she drives down the mountain to where the signal cuts in, that there is no Amber alert. And the new, trustworthy police chief is busy with something else. Arles checks out the Books and Brew shop to see that the other event that night was a PR do for a soon-to-be-released movie starring Kip Stratton. And while she stands there, a weird guy who is clearly a Kip Stratton superfan asks about a little girl.
Back at Fir Cove, carefully, without a tail, meals are prepared, beds are made, goodnights said. But early the next morning there are two fancy black cars in her driveway, and a small man with a gun is asking about a girl in the company of a woman. When Arles has seen him off, Kara and the girl have fled. With the help of a game camera, Arles figures out where they have gone, but the next day, the police chief has some bad news, and Arles is soon trekking through the woods hoping to find the girl.
Much more can’t be said without spoilers, but before matters are resolved, there are some nail-biting moments, a killing by axe and a collision take the body-count to four, and there are some jaw-dropping revelations about several persons charged with the care of minors.
Two narratives carry the story, and while Arles’s can be trusted, Kara’s might be unreliable. The girl, though, definitely has a talent for lying. The dialogue is often blackly funny. This instalment has plenty of twists and turns and red herrings to keep the reader guessing and the pages turning, and a neat resolution: will there be more of Arles Shepherd from Jenny Milchman?
This unbiased review is from an uncorrected proof copy provided by NetGalley and Thomas & Mercer.
December 18, 2025
This is the second book in the stellar psychological thriller series set in the Adirondacks wilderness featuring psychologist Arles Shepherd. A young girl approaches an author at a book signing saying she is in danger. The author seeks the help of Dr. Shepherd. As the women seek to unravel the mystery of who this girl is and what she is running from, some questionable people approach them, creating chaos and uncertainty for all. I’ve found this series to be both entertaining and satisfying. I like Arles Shepherd and Milchman has done an exceptional job with her characterization. This series will appeal to fans of Mindy Mejia and Paul Doiron.
Many thanks to Netgalley, Thomas & Mercer and Jenny Milchman for my complimentary e-book ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Many thanks to Netgalley, Thomas & Mercer and Jenny Milchman for my complimentary e-book ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
September 12, 2025
4.5★s
The Fairest is the second book in the Arles Shepherd Thriller series by award-winning, best-selling American author, Jenny Milchman. The audio version is narrated by Sarah Mollo-Christensen. Crime author, Kara Cross is at her local bookstore in Wedeskyull for a reading/signing event for her new novel when a young girl silently asks for her help with a written message: “I am a missing child”. It’s what Kara writes about, and this doesn’t seem like some Tik Tok stunt. In her own experience, involving the police is worse than useless, so her immediate solution to the dilemma is to take the child to her former therapist, Arles Shepherd at her mountain retreat, Fir Cove.
Arles is just about recovered from injuries sustained some four months earlier, but arrives back from a lengthy drive feeling rather unwell. When revived, she takes on the problem Kara has brought her with mixed feelings: keeping this expensively coiffed, manicured and dressed child, who refuses to give her name or any other details, who displays an unusual sense of entitlement, without notifying the relevant authorities, as Kara has requested, could land her in hot water.
Arles is puzzled, when she drives down the mountain to where the signal cuts in, that there is no Amber alert. And the new, trustworthy police chief is busy with something else. Arles checks out the Books and Brew shop to see that the other event that night was a PR do for a soon-to-be-released movie starring Kip Stratton. And while she stands there, a weird guy who is clearly a Kip Stratton superfan asks about a little girl.
Back at Fir Cove, carefully, without a tail, meals are prepared, beds are made, goodnights said. But early the next morning there are two fancy black cars in her driveway, and a small man with a gun is asking about a girl in the company of a woman. When Arles has seen him off, Kara and the girl have fled. With the help of a game camera, Arles figures out where they have gone, but the next day, the police chief has some bad news, and Arles is soon trekking through the woods hoping to find the girl.
Much more can’t be said without spoilers, but before matters are resolved, there are some nail-biting moments, a killing by axe and a collision take the body-count to four, and there are some jaw-dropping revelations about several persons charged with the care of minors.
Two narratives carry the story, and while Arles’s can be trusted, Kara’s might be unreliable. The girl, though, definitely has a talent for lying. The dialogue is often blackly funny. This instalment has plenty of twists and turns and red herrings to keep the reader guessing and the pages turning, and a neat resolution: will there be more of Arles Shepherd from Jenny Milchman?
This unbiased review is from an audio copy provided by NetGalley and Brilliance audio
The Fairest is the second book in the Arles Shepherd Thriller series by award-winning, best-selling American author, Jenny Milchman. The audio version is narrated by Sarah Mollo-Christensen. Crime author, Kara Cross is at her local bookstore in Wedeskyull for a reading/signing event for her new novel when a young girl silently asks for her help with a written message: “I am a missing child”. It’s what Kara writes about, and this doesn’t seem like some Tik Tok stunt. In her own experience, involving the police is worse than useless, so her immediate solution to the dilemma is to take the child to her former therapist, Arles Shepherd at her mountain retreat, Fir Cove.
Arles is just about recovered from injuries sustained some four months earlier, but arrives back from a lengthy drive feeling rather unwell. When revived, she takes on the problem Kara has brought her with mixed feelings: keeping this expensively coiffed, manicured and dressed child, who refuses to give her name or any other details, who displays an unusual sense of entitlement, without notifying the relevant authorities, as Kara has requested, could land her in hot water.
Arles is puzzled, when she drives down the mountain to where the signal cuts in, that there is no Amber alert. And the new, trustworthy police chief is busy with something else. Arles checks out the Books and Brew shop to see that the other event that night was a PR do for a soon-to-be-released movie starring Kip Stratton. And while she stands there, a weird guy who is clearly a Kip Stratton superfan asks about a little girl.
Back at Fir Cove, carefully, without a tail, meals are prepared, beds are made, goodnights said. But early the next morning there are two fancy black cars in her driveway, and a small man with a gun is asking about a girl in the company of a woman. When Arles has seen him off, Kara and the girl have fled. With the help of a game camera, Arles figures out where they have gone, but the next day, the police chief has some bad news, and Arles is soon trekking through the woods hoping to find the girl.
Much more can’t be said without spoilers, but before matters are resolved, there are some nail-biting moments, a killing by axe and a collision take the body-count to four, and there are some jaw-dropping revelations about several persons charged with the care of minors.
Two narratives carry the story, and while Arles’s can be trusted, Kara’s might be unreliable. The girl, though, definitely has a talent for lying. The dialogue is often blackly funny. This instalment has plenty of twists and turns and red herrings to keep the reader guessing and the pages turning, and a neat resolution: will there be more of Arles Shepherd from Jenny Milchman?
This unbiased review is from an audio copy provided by NetGalley and Brilliance audio
September 12, 2025
Out September 16th, 2025
During a routine book signing in her hometown, author Kara Parsons is approached by a young girl clutching a copy of her novel. Inside is a chilling handwritten message: I am a missing child. Rather than alerting the authorities, Kara—haunted by past failures of the system—chooses a more unconventional path. She seeks help from Arles Shepherd, her former therapist, who is recovering from injuries and living off the grid. The girl refuses to reveal her name, and her cryptic behavior raises unsettling questions about what she’s running from and whether her story can be trusted.
Arles, no stranger to trauma and psychological complexity, senses something deeply off about the girl. His instincts tell him that the danger surrounding her is not just imagined—it’s imminent. When a gunman tracks them down in Arles’s remote wilderness hideaway, the threat becomes terrifyingly real. Forced to flee, Kara and Arles embark on a tense journey through backroads and emotional landmines, trying to protect the girl while unraveling the mystery of her past.
As the trio navigates a landscape filled with secrets and shadows, the story delves into themes of trust, redemption, and the limits of protection. Kara must confront her own history and the ethical boundaries she’s willing to cross to save someone who may not be telling the whole truth. Arles, meanwhile, is pulled back into a world he tried to leave behind, where every decision could mean life or death. Their bond is tested as they face not only external threats but the ghosts of their own unresolved pain.
This psychological thriller blends suspense with emotional depth, exploring the fragility of safety and the resilience of those who dare to offer sanctuary. The narrative challenges assumptions about innocence and danger, asking whether the fairest among us are always what they seem. With its taut pacing and layered character dynamics, the story builds toward a climax where survival depends not just on escape, but on confronting the truth that has been hiding in plain sight.
Thank you so much to NetGalley and Thomas & Mercer for this arc!
During a routine book signing in her hometown, author Kara Parsons is approached by a young girl clutching a copy of her novel. Inside is a chilling handwritten message: I am a missing child. Rather than alerting the authorities, Kara—haunted by past failures of the system—chooses a more unconventional path. She seeks help from Arles Shepherd, her former therapist, who is recovering from injuries and living off the grid. The girl refuses to reveal her name, and her cryptic behavior raises unsettling questions about what she’s running from and whether her story can be trusted.
Arles, no stranger to trauma and psychological complexity, senses something deeply off about the girl. His instincts tell him that the danger surrounding her is not just imagined—it’s imminent. When a gunman tracks them down in Arles’s remote wilderness hideaway, the threat becomes terrifyingly real. Forced to flee, Kara and Arles embark on a tense journey through backroads and emotional landmines, trying to protect the girl while unraveling the mystery of her past.
As the trio navigates a landscape filled with secrets and shadows, the story delves into themes of trust, redemption, and the limits of protection. Kara must confront her own history and the ethical boundaries she’s willing to cross to save someone who may not be telling the whole truth. Arles, meanwhile, is pulled back into a world he tried to leave behind, where every decision could mean life or death. Their bond is tested as they face not only external threats but the ghosts of their own unresolved pain.
This psychological thriller blends suspense with emotional depth, exploring the fragility of safety and the resilience of those who dare to offer sanctuary. The narrative challenges assumptions about innocence and danger, asking whether the fairest among us are always what they seem. With its taut pacing and layered character dynamics, the story builds toward a climax where survival depends not just on escape, but on confronting the truth that has been hiding in plain sight.
Thank you so much to NetGalley and Thomas & Mercer for this arc!
December 13, 2025
THE FAIREST grabbed my attention from the getgo. I was expecting a different type of story, one with a more victimized child. Instead Lark is articulate, wise behind her years and crafty. If she was a book, she’d be an unreliable narrator.
Arles Shepard bothered me much less than she did in the first book, because she wasn’t in her professional capacity as a therapist committing malpractice.
Though far fetched, the plot intrigued me and I rooted for a good ending for Lark.
Arles Shepard bothered me much less than she did in the first book, because she wasn’t in her professional capacity as a therapist committing malpractice.
Though far fetched, the plot intrigued me and I rooted for a good ending for Lark.
October 25, 2025
3 1/2 Stars
The second novel in the Dr. Arles Shepherd series, THE FAIREST, is a complex character study that author Jenny Milchman sets within her frequent setting of upstate New York. It follows the previous Shepherd novel, THE USUAL SILENCE.
The novel opens with a curious scene between two characters, Kip and Janelle, who appear to be lost on a trip to the countryside somewhere. It is unclear whether this is a flashback moment or a fictional scene between characters in a novel by author Kara Parsons, who is the first person we meet in this story. As the novel progresses, this introduction, along with various additional moments spliced into the novel, will become quite clear.
Author Kara Parsons is attending a book signing in the upstate New York town of Wedeskyull at the Books & Brew bookshop. The last person waiting for a signed book is a young girl, aged nine, who hands Kara a note that reads: I AM A MISSING CHILD. Of course, this alarms Kara, and she responds in a way that is unique to her own personal history. Rather than calling the authorities or child services, Kara takes the unnamed girl and brings her to the one person she knows can truly help in this situation, her former therapist Dr. Arles Shepherd. Shepherd now lives in a remote cabin in the Adirondacks wilderness as she is still recovering from physical and emotional injuries suffered at the hands of a killer in the previous novel.
The spread of land that Shepherd lives on is called Fir Cove and contains other cabins, one of which is currently being used by a mother and daughter who have just set off on a vacation trip. When Kara and the girl arrive, Shepherd is initially taken aback but quickly agrees that she did the right thing by coming to her first. Shepherd takes a ride to check out the bookstore for herself but can find nothing suspicious. In addition to the girl refusing to provide a name, Kara claims she was speaking under her breath in what appeared to be a chant or prayer. They were both worried that she might be an escapee from some religious cult, but Shepherd is the best person to deal with the young girl to discover the details they need to fill in these blanks.
An armed man shows up unexpectedly to Fir Cove and Shepherd puts him off about ever seeing Kara and a young girl, who were hiding in the attic of her large home. He reluctantly leaves, but the trio recognize that the people the young girl is running from are definitely dangerous and will do anything to get her back. Kara gives the girl the name of ‘Maeve’ just to have something to call her. At one point, while Kara and Maeve are making their way through the woods, they come upon a young girl who leads them to another home. It ends up being a place Kara was familiar with, a home that protected foster and abused young people who were well aware of Dr. Shepherd.
This place sets up a way for both Kara and Maeve to get away to safety, especially after the visit from the armed man, but the car pick up goes horribly wrong. There is an accident that takes the life of Kara as Maeve escapes and ends up back with Shepherd. This plot turn is a gut punch, but it leaves the rest of the novel firmly in the hands of our main protagonist, Dr. Shepherd, and she ends up not only discovering Maeve’s true identity but also the identity of the people from whom she is running.
The conclusion is a harrowing one where all questions that have been raised are finally answered. Jenny Milchman has a terrific character in Dr. Arles Shepherd, a person who really feels for the people in her care and I hope that this engaging series continues to grow.
Reviewed by Ray Palen for Book Reporter
The second novel in the Dr. Arles Shepherd series, THE FAIREST, is a complex character study that author Jenny Milchman sets within her frequent setting of upstate New York. It follows the previous Shepherd novel, THE USUAL SILENCE.
The novel opens with a curious scene between two characters, Kip and Janelle, who appear to be lost on a trip to the countryside somewhere. It is unclear whether this is a flashback moment or a fictional scene between characters in a novel by author Kara Parsons, who is the first person we meet in this story. As the novel progresses, this introduction, along with various additional moments spliced into the novel, will become quite clear.
Author Kara Parsons is attending a book signing in the upstate New York town of Wedeskyull at the Books & Brew bookshop. The last person waiting for a signed book is a young girl, aged nine, who hands Kara a note that reads: I AM A MISSING CHILD. Of course, this alarms Kara, and she responds in a way that is unique to her own personal history. Rather than calling the authorities or child services, Kara takes the unnamed girl and brings her to the one person she knows can truly help in this situation, her former therapist Dr. Arles Shepherd. Shepherd now lives in a remote cabin in the Adirondacks wilderness as she is still recovering from physical and emotional injuries suffered at the hands of a killer in the previous novel.
The spread of land that Shepherd lives on is called Fir Cove and contains other cabins, one of which is currently being used by a mother and daughter who have just set off on a vacation trip. When Kara and the girl arrive, Shepherd is initially taken aback but quickly agrees that she did the right thing by coming to her first. Shepherd takes a ride to check out the bookstore for herself but can find nothing suspicious. In addition to the girl refusing to provide a name, Kara claims she was speaking under her breath in what appeared to be a chant or prayer. They were both worried that she might be an escapee from some religious cult, but Shepherd is the best person to deal with the young girl to discover the details they need to fill in these blanks.
An armed man shows up unexpectedly to Fir Cove and Shepherd puts him off about ever seeing Kara and a young girl, who were hiding in the attic of her large home. He reluctantly leaves, but the trio recognize that the people the young girl is running from are definitely dangerous and will do anything to get her back. Kara gives the girl the name of ‘Maeve’ just to have something to call her. At one point, while Kara and Maeve are making their way through the woods, they come upon a young girl who leads them to another home. It ends up being a place Kara was familiar with, a home that protected foster and abused young people who were well aware of Dr. Shepherd.
This place sets up a way for both Kara and Maeve to get away to safety, especially after the visit from the armed man, but the car pick up goes horribly wrong. There is an accident that takes the life of Kara as Maeve escapes and ends up back with Shepherd. This plot turn is a gut punch, but it leaves the rest of the novel firmly in the hands of our main protagonist, Dr. Shepherd, and she ends up not only discovering Maeve’s true identity but also the identity of the people from whom she is running.
The conclusion is a harrowing one where all questions that have been raised are finally answered. Jenny Milchman has a terrific character in Dr. Arles Shepherd, a person who really feels for the people in her care and I hope that this engaging series continues to grow.
Reviewed by Ray Palen for Book Reporter
October 26, 2025
As THE FAIREST opens, two people appear to be lost on a trip to the countryside somewhere. It is unclear if this is a flashback or a fictional scene between characters in a book by author Kara Parsons. As the story progresses, this introduction --- along with various other moments spliced into the novel --- will become quite clear.
Kara is attending a book signing in the upstate New York town of Wedeskyull. The last person waiting for a signed book is a nine-year-old girl who hands her a note that reads: I am a missing child. This of course alarms Kara, and she responds in a way that is unique to her personal history.
Rather than call the authorities or child services, Kara brings the girl to the one person she knows can truly help in this situation: her former therapist, Dr. Arles Shepherd. Arles now lives in a remote cabin in the Adirondacks wilderness as she is still recovering from physical and emotional injuries suffered at the hands of a killer in THE USUAL SILENCE, which kicked off Jenny Milchman’s series.
The spread of land that Arles lives on is called Fir Cove and contains other cabins, one of which is currently being used by a mother and daughter who have just left on a trip. When Kara and the girl arrive, Arles is initially taken aback but quickly agrees that Kara did the right thing by coming to her first. Arles checks out the bookstore for herself but finds nothing suspicious. Kara says that the child, who refuses to provide a name, speaks under her breath in what appears to be a chant or prayer. They are worried that she might have escaped a religious cult, but Arles is the best person to figure out the details they need to fill in these blanks.
An armed man shows up unexpectedly to Fir Cove. Arles vehemently denies ever seeing Kara and the girl, who are hiding in the attic of her large house. He reluctantly leaves, but it’s clear that the child is running away from people who are extremely dangerous and will do anything to get her back. Kara gives her the name “Maeve” just to have something to call her. At one point, while Kara and Maeve are making their way through the woods, they come upon a girl who leads them to a home that protects foster children and those who have been abused.
But it isn’t long before the plot turns, and it’s quite a gut punch. The conclusion is a harrowing one where all questions that have been raised are finally answered. Jenny Milchman has a terrific protagonist in Arles Shepherd, who genuinely cares about her patients, and I hope that this engaging series continues to grow.
Reviewed by Ray Palen
Kara is attending a book signing in the upstate New York town of Wedeskyull. The last person waiting for a signed book is a nine-year-old girl who hands her a note that reads: I am a missing child. This of course alarms Kara, and she responds in a way that is unique to her personal history.
Rather than call the authorities or child services, Kara brings the girl to the one person she knows can truly help in this situation: her former therapist, Dr. Arles Shepherd. Arles now lives in a remote cabin in the Adirondacks wilderness as she is still recovering from physical and emotional injuries suffered at the hands of a killer in THE USUAL SILENCE, which kicked off Jenny Milchman’s series.
The spread of land that Arles lives on is called Fir Cove and contains other cabins, one of which is currently being used by a mother and daughter who have just left on a trip. When Kara and the girl arrive, Arles is initially taken aback but quickly agrees that Kara did the right thing by coming to her first. Arles checks out the bookstore for herself but finds nothing suspicious. Kara says that the child, who refuses to provide a name, speaks under her breath in what appears to be a chant or prayer. They are worried that she might have escaped a religious cult, but Arles is the best person to figure out the details they need to fill in these blanks.
An armed man shows up unexpectedly to Fir Cove. Arles vehemently denies ever seeing Kara and the girl, who are hiding in the attic of her large house. He reluctantly leaves, but it’s clear that the child is running away from people who are extremely dangerous and will do anything to get her back. Kara gives her the name “Maeve” just to have something to call her. At one point, while Kara and Maeve are making their way through the woods, they come upon a girl who leads them to a home that protects foster children and those who have been abused.
But it isn’t long before the plot turns, and it’s quite a gut punch. The conclusion is a harrowing one where all questions that have been raised are finally answered. Jenny Milchman has a terrific protagonist in Arles Shepherd, who genuinely cares about her patients, and I hope that this engaging series continues to grow.
Reviewed by Ray Palen
May 10, 2025
2,75 ⭐
at a book signing in her hometown, author kara parsons is approached by a girl with a copy of her book, claiming to be a missing child. instead of calling the police, kara - aware of how the system can fail the young and vulnerable - seeks help from her former therapist, arles shepherd. she quickly realizes there's something strange about the girl, who won't even reveal her name.
when a man with a gun tracks them down at arles's secluded cabin, the real danger emerges, forcing her and kara to go on the run.
first of all, i was totally unaware that this is the second book in a series, but i still continued reading, and i didn't feel like i was missing out on anything - so i assume it can be read as a standalone.
the premise was really good, but the book just didn't deliver. a lot of the storyline felt pretty unbelievable and far-fetched. in many parts the book was just dragging a bit too much.
considering the book is in the thriller genre, at times i didn't feel like i was reading one. the thrills just weren't there. i mean, there was some action when the guy with the gun approached them and when they went on the run, but it just fell flat to me. i definitely liked the last 35% of the book and i really enjoyed the ending, though.
as for the characters - kara was really empathetic, and i liked how both she and arles tried to help the girl.
arles took care of her and did her best to keep her safe, which i do admire, although i questioned some of their decisions.
i also liked the way the relationship between the girl and her parents was portrayed - it was kinda sad to read about.
overall, the story was decent, but it just didn’t resonate with me personally. i can see why some people would enjoy it, but it just didn't click with me.
*thanks to NetGalley, Thomas & Mercer and the author for the opportunity to review this ARC.*
at a book signing in her hometown, author kara parsons is approached by a girl with a copy of her book, claiming to be a missing child. instead of calling the police, kara - aware of how the system can fail the young and vulnerable - seeks help from her former therapist, arles shepherd. she quickly realizes there's something strange about the girl, who won't even reveal her name.
when a man with a gun tracks them down at arles's secluded cabin, the real danger emerges, forcing her and kara to go on the run.
first of all, i was totally unaware that this is the second book in a series, but i still continued reading, and i didn't feel like i was missing out on anything - so i assume it can be read as a standalone.
the premise was really good, but the book just didn't deliver. a lot of the storyline felt pretty unbelievable and far-fetched. in many parts the book was just dragging a bit too much.
considering the book is in the thriller genre, at times i didn't feel like i was reading one. the thrills just weren't there. i mean, there was some action when the guy with the gun approached them and when they went on the run, but it just fell flat to me. i definitely liked the last 35% of the book and i really enjoyed the ending, though.
as for the characters - kara was really empathetic, and i liked how both she and arles tried to help the girl.
arles took care of her and did her best to keep her safe, which i do admire, although i questioned some of their decisions.
i also liked the way the relationship between the girl and her parents was portrayed - it was kinda sad to read about.
overall, the story was decent, but it just didn’t resonate with me personally. i can see why some people would enjoy it, but it just didn't click with me.
*thanks to NetGalley, Thomas & Mercer and the author for the opportunity to review this ARC.*
September 15, 2025
3.75/5. Thank you to Jenny Milchman, the publisher, and Netgalley for the ALC!
Note: I need to go back and listen to the first book to get ALL the context, but I would say coming into this book first works fine. While I may have been curious about some of the backstory, it wasn't something I needed to get the gist.
Kara Parsons, an author in the middle of a book signing, is confronted with a young girl who claims to be a missing girl. With memories of her own dark past, Kara brings her to the one person she knows can help: her former therapist, Arles Shepherd. What unfolds is a mystery far deeper than why the girl is missing - who exactly is this girl?
During their journey to unravel the girl's past and present, we flip between Kara and Arles, each with difficult histories with their families. As we discover the darkness in both of them, we realize why they are trying to stop this girl from falling into it herself.
I will say that there is one storyline that seems to be a little out of place, but it may be on me for not reading the first book. While the author does try to tie it back in, it seems a little forced, for lack of better words (again, caveat, it may make sense to those who have read the first and I will edit this if, after reading the first, it does!).
My biggest issue was the obvious one: as a trained therapist, Arles makes a decision that I'm not sure I'd agree with if confronted with the situation. Of course, there are past issues and a valid explanation as to why, but if I wasn't suspending my disbelief - I'd disbelieve. It didn't draw me fully out of the story, but I did do a few, "why?"s.
As to the audiobook quality and production, Sarah Mollo-Christensen is able to do a variety of voices in a way that don't feel too similar. Even the tone and dictation of words fits.
Overall, this is a series I'll keep on my radar!
Note: I need to go back and listen to the first book to get ALL the context, but I would say coming into this book first works fine. While I may have been curious about some of the backstory, it wasn't something I needed to get the gist.
Kara Parsons, an author in the middle of a book signing, is confronted with a young girl who claims to be a missing girl. With memories of her own dark past, Kara brings her to the one person she knows can help: her former therapist, Arles Shepherd. What unfolds is a mystery far deeper than why the girl is missing - who exactly is this girl?
During their journey to unravel the girl's past and present, we flip between Kara and Arles, each with difficult histories with their families. As we discover the darkness in both of them, we realize why they are trying to stop this girl from falling into it herself.
I will say that there is one storyline that seems to be a little out of place, but it may be on me for not reading the first book. While the author does try to tie it back in, it seems a little forced, for lack of better words (again, caveat, it may make sense to those who have read the first and I will edit this if, after reading the first, it does!).
My biggest issue was the obvious one: as a trained therapist, Arles makes a decision that I'm not sure I'd agree with if confronted with the situation. Of course, there are past issues and a valid explanation as to why, but if I wasn't suspending my disbelief - I'd disbelieve. It didn't draw me fully out of the story, but I did do a few, "why?"s.
As to the audiobook quality and production, Sarah Mollo-Christensen is able to do a variety of voices in a way that don't feel too similar. Even the tone and dictation of words fits.
Overall, this is a series I'll keep on my radar!
September 22, 2025
Jenny Milchman delivers another suspenseful tale with The Fairest, a novel that blends tension, atmosphere, and originality into a story that feels fresh within the genre. From the very start, the book draws you in with its unique premise and keeps you invested through well-developed characters and steadily building suspense.
The strength of this novel lies in its cast. Milchman has a gift for creating layered, believable characters whose choices feel authentic and whose flaws make them relatable. Their interactions carry emotional weight, and you quickly become attached to their struggles, which raises the stakes as the suspense intensifies.
The plot itself is compelling and moves with a deliberate pace, offering plenty of twists and turns to keep you engaged. While it certainly delivers in terms of tension and originality, there are moments where the story feels like it could have gone even further—pushing certain plot points or reveals to an even higher level of intensity. That said, the foundation Milchman builds is strong, and the story remains gripping throughout.
What truly makes The Fairest stand out is the way it blends suspense with a sense of uniqueness. Rather than relying on tired tropes, Milchman shapes her narrative with fresh angles and unexpected directions, keeping readers on edge as they try to anticipate what will happen next.
Overall, this is a novel that offers sharp suspense, memorable characters, and a storyline that is both intriguing and original. While there are places where it could have soared even higher with just a bit more intensity, The Fairest remains a strong and satisfying thriller that fans of character-driven suspense will definitely enjoy.
The strength of this novel lies in its cast. Milchman has a gift for creating layered, believable characters whose choices feel authentic and whose flaws make them relatable. Their interactions carry emotional weight, and you quickly become attached to their struggles, which raises the stakes as the suspense intensifies.
The plot itself is compelling and moves with a deliberate pace, offering plenty of twists and turns to keep you engaged. While it certainly delivers in terms of tension and originality, there are moments where the story feels like it could have gone even further—pushing certain plot points or reveals to an even higher level of intensity. That said, the foundation Milchman builds is strong, and the story remains gripping throughout.
What truly makes The Fairest stand out is the way it blends suspense with a sense of uniqueness. Rather than relying on tired tropes, Milchman shapes her narrative with fresh angles and unexpected directions, keeping readers on edge as they try to anticipate what will happen next.
Overall, this is a novel that offers sharp suspense, memorable characters, and a storyline that is both intriguing and original. While there are places where it could have soared even higher with just a bit more intensity, The Fairest remains a strong and satisfying thriller that fans of character-driven suspense will definitely enjoy.
September 18, 2025
I listened to an audio arc of The Fairest and soon discovered this was book 2 in a series. Unsure if that impacted my enjoyment, but I'd recommend starting at 1 since at times it felt like I was missing out on information which might have made a difference. This one is a general mystery, and for me, was a little slow and, sadly, a bit unbelievable.
This brief description is from the publisher, so I'm able to share without giving anything away:
Author Kara Parsons is at a book signing in the town where she was raised. Before it’s over, a young girl approaches with a copy of Kara’s book containing a handwritten inscription: I am a missing child.
Most people would alert the police, but Kara knows what happens to the young and vulnerable when the system fails them. She turns to her former therapist, Arles Shepherd, who’s recovering from injuries and staying off the grid. But even Arles, who’s seen everything, finds something off about this girl who refuses to reveal her own name. What is she running from? And how much of what she says can be believed?
I just couldn't get past the fact that independent of police, or any authority, this individual just took it upon herself to take the child. Sigh. Other reviewers seem to love the book, so please do give it a go (but check out book 1 first).
This brief description is from the publisher, so I'm able to share without giving anything away:
Author Kara Parsons is at a book signing in the town where she was raised. Before it’s over, a young girl approaches with a copy of Kara’s book containing a handwritten inscription: I am a missing child.
Most people would alert the police, but Kara knows what happens to the young and vulnerable when the system fails them. She turns to her former therapist, Arles Shepherd, who’s recovering from injuries and staying off the grid. But even Arles, who’s seen everything, finds something off about this girl who refuses to reveal her own name. What is she running from? And how much of what she says can be believed?
I just couldn't get past the fact that independent of police, or any authority, this individual just took it upon herself to take the child. Sigh. Other reviewers seem to love the book, so please do give it a go (but check out book 1 first).
September 13, 2025
This review is for the audio version of the book, narrated by Sarah Mollo-Christensen.
3.5/5
Author Kara Parsons just wanted to get done with her book signing and leave but at the end of the line, she looks up to see a young girl holding out one of her (not for children) books. When she opens the front cover to sign it, she finds a message already waiting, "I am a missing child".
Kara doesn't trust the police and the girl obviously needs help so she decides to turn to the person who helped her through her own traumatic past. Her therapist, Dr. Arles Sheppard.
This was just kind of "ok" for me. The characters were pretty good, and Arles seemed to be a very thoroughly researched character. She's fascinating and I'm glad there's an entire series surrounding her, I'd like to read more.
The plot was interesting, but it felt like there were pieces missing.
X is happening and someone is being looked for, but we found them, and we're suddenly back somewhere safe!
It was odd and took me out of the story.
It wasn't bad, but it did feel a little incomplete in places.
If these things vibe with you, worth the time to read.
3.5/5
Author Kara Parsons just wanted to get done with her book signing and leave but at the end of the line, she looks up to see a young girl holding out one of her (not for children) books. When she opens the front cover to sign it, she finds a message already waiting, "I am a missing child".
Kara doesn't trust the police and the girl obviously needs help so she decides to turn to the person who helped her through her own traumatic past. Her therapist, Dr. Arles Sheppard.
This was just kind of "ok" for me. The characters were pretty good, and Arles seemed to be a very thoroughly researched character. She's fascinating and I'm glad there's an entire series surrounding her, I'd like to read more.
The plot was interesting, but it felt like there were pieces missing.
X is happening and someone is being looked for, but we found them, and we're suddenly back somewhere safe!
It was odd and took me out of the story.
It wasn't bad, but it did feel a little incomplete in places.
If these things vibe with you, worth the time to read.
September 14, 2025
The second installment in the Arles Shepherd series, The Fairest is a rather unique mystery. The characters are interesting but quite flawed. Author Kara Parsons is concerned about the young girl and does what she can to protect her. Arles is therapist who has been recovering from being shot. The mysterious child is well-adjusted but quite evasive. The storyline is intriguing but it does not always flow smoothly. Suspension of disbelief is required once the mystery is completely solved. Jenny Milchman brings the story to an uplifting conclusion.
September 26, 2025
I read the first one and had to look for more!
I like psychological thrillers.
While I don't wish it on anyone.
I can understand that a lot of people become therapists because of their own trauma.
The writing while fictional had a believable story line.
It was entertaining.
Looking forward to more books.
I enjoyed so many parts of it.
Especially, the outdoor survival skills while hiding away, releasing stress, yet also being a way to integrate therapy.
I was happy that she decided on safety by making sure she could make a call out
I like psychological thrillers.
While I don't wish it on anyone.
I can understand that a lot of people become therapists because of their own trauma.
The writing while fictional had a believable story line.
It was entertaining.
Looking forward to more books.
I enjoyed so many parts of it.
Especially, the outdoor survival skills while hiding away, releasing stress, yet also being a way to integrate therapy.
I was happy that she decided on safety by making sure she could make a call out
September 19, 2025
Went in blind, and this book hooked me from the get go. I honestly wasn’t expecting to enjoy it as much as I did.
What would you do if a young girl approached you and told you she was missing? Would you do whatever it took to get her back to the parents she belonged to? What if those parents hadn’t even reported her missing? This story had a strange pace, but I didn’t hate it. I didn’t read the first book in this series, but it didn’t seem to matter. Loved it!
Thank you netgalley!
What would you do if a young girl approached you and told you she was missing? Would you do whatever it took to get her back to the parents she belonged to? What if those parents hadn’t even reported her missing? This story had a strange pace, but I didn’t hate it. I didn’t read the first book in this series, but it didn’t seem to matter. Loved it!
Thank you netgalley!
October 8, 2025
4 stars
Well done! Arles Shephard is an interesting character. Almost mortally wounded in book 1, here she is recovering her physical and emotional health. While helping a former patient. And a very enigmatic young girl. The story is wild.
Who is this young girl? She’s stunningly beautiful. Talks like an old movie star. Says she’s a missing child.
Who she is, the whole story of her life, is almost unfathomable.
Sets up the next book nicely, too.
Well done! Arles Shephard is an interesting character. Almost mortally wounded in book 1, here she is recovering her physical and emotional health. While helping a former patient. And a very enigmatic young girl. The story is wild.
Who is this young girl? She’s stunningly beautiful. Talks like an old movie star. Says she’s a missing child.
Who she is, the whole story of her life, is almost unfathomable.
Sets up the next book nicely, too.
September 29, 2025
A fast intriguing read. The second of the series and pretty much a stand alone as I didn’t read the first. Arles a psychologist or psychiatrist don’t recall but in helping a missing girl deals with her personal child hood trauma. It’s twisty. Tw topic of childhood SA is mentioned with some flashbacks.
September 16, 2025
I didn’t read the first book in this series I didn’t realize it was the second one but I still totally enjoyed it. ☺️ the author did a great job of making sure you were caught up throughout the book and all the twists were so entertaining. 🌲
September 27, 2025
Disjointed
It was an interesting premise, but there’s just so many weird gaps. I can’t tell if it’s the way this was written or if it was just poorly edited. I just didn’t love this one.
It was an interesting premise, but there’s just so many weird gaps. I can’t tell if it’s the way this was written or if it was just poorly edited. I just didn’t love this one.
October 2, 2025
I was captivated by the book's synopsis at NetGalley, however, I could not engage with the story or characters which made a quite difficult reading.
I thank the author, her publisher, and NetGalley for this ARC.
I thank the author, her publisher, and NetGalley for this ARC.
October 30, 2025
bad parents and sexual abuse
Really didn’t care for the fact that every major character had a history of being sexually abused or just abused by their parent. And NO ONE ever comes to their aide?? I think the author must have an ax to grind.
Really didn’t care for the fact that every major character had a history of being sexually abused or just abused by their parent. And NO ONE ever comes to their aide?? I think the author must have an ax to grind.
November 18, 2025
Couldn’t get into it
This book took me forever to finish. I wanted to give up so many times but I kept feeling like it had to get better. The storyline was all over the place. It as good as the first one. If a third one comes out, I won’t be reading that one.
This book took me forever to finish. I wanted to give up so many times but I kept feeling like it had to get better. The storyline was all over the place. It as good as the first one. If a third one comes out, I won’t be reading that one.
September 12, 2025
⭐️
1/5
DNF at 30%. Not a fan. It felt like big parts of the stories were being skipped.
Thank you NetGalley, Brilliance Publishing, and Jenny Milchman for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.
1/5
DNF at 30%. Not a fan. It felt like big parts of the stories were being skipped.
Thank you NetGalley, Brilliance Publishing, and Jenny Milchman for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.
September 29, 2025
dark twisty
Fast paced book of mystery and lies. Check tw as child sa is a subject that is approached. Lot of back story and past trauma flashbacks.
Fast paced book of mystery and lies. Check tw as child sa is a subject that is approached. Lot of back story and past trauma flashbacks.
December 5, 2025
I love all of her books. I just felt that this one had too much going on, which made it pretty unrealistic. Still a page turner though.
September 22, 2025
When she is approached for help by an unknown young girl, author Kara Parsons can only think of contacting the one person she feels may know what to do - mental health professional Arles Shepherd, who is recovering from a brutal attack.
But something does not add up in the young girl's story, as Kara and Arles discover to their detriment. And when an armed man appears, posing a clear and present danger, difficult decisions must be taken...
Milchman follows up her first story about an unusual protagonist, therapist Arles, Shepherd, with a worthy successor in the form of this novel. She is a gifted writer and the narrator of the audiobook does a commendable job of rendering Milchman's characters. Overall, this is an interesting and absorbing offering.
I received a free copy of this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
But something does not add up in the young girl's story, as Kara and Arles discover to their detriment. And when an armed man appears, posing a clear and present danger, difficult decisions must be taken...
Milchman follows up her first story about an unusual protagonist, therapist Arles, Shepherd, with a worthy successor in the form of this novel. She is a gifted writer and the narrator of the audiobook does a commendable job of rendering Milchman's characters. Overall, this is an interesting and absorbing offering.
I received a free copy of this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
Displaying 1 - 26 of 26 reviews