What do you think?
Rate this book
The Cornish Witch
Preorder the BRAND NEW spellbinding historical novel from bestseller Elena Collins. ‘Heartbreaking and hopeful, it’s a brilliant read.' Nicola Cornick When Megan’s father gets a letter containing a secret from the past, he asks her to go to the Cornish village of St Mawgen Cove to get to the bottom of the mystery. Megan is happy to take a holiday after a challenging year but as soon as she checks into The Ship Inn something feels amiss. There are noises in the room above, the locals tell tales of smugglers and shipwrecks and she can’t escape the story of the witch who waits and watches, weeping on the top of the cliff.
1625: Susanna and her daughter Katel live a contented life, but without the protection of a husband and father, Susanna fears for Katel’s future as she blossoms into womanhood. The fishing community of St Mawgen Cove is close knit but when misfortune arrives in the cove, it’s not long before villagers are looking for someone to blame. And when talk turns to witches, Susanna knows she and Katel are no longer safe.
Can Megan bring peace to St Mawgen and to two women who have been broken-hearted for centuries?
Bestseller Elena Collins is back with an unforgettable historical mystery about secrets, longing and the power of a mother’s love. Perfect for fans of Barbara Erskine, Nicola Cornick, Diana Gabaldon and Louise Douglas.
Readers love Elena
‘This is a wonderfully well-written book, atmospheric, immersive, heart-touching, heart-breaking.’
‘Really well written book, love the history and the mystery surrounding the story, what sadness surrounds this lady of old, cannot wait for your next book Elena.’
‘An enthralling blend of known fact, myth and imagination with believable characters, atmospheric descriptions and fascinating locations all told with warmth and compassion.’
‘The brilliant story of Kate Ferrers was entrancing with all of the well written characters coming to life from the page in a thrilling tale of love, friendships and loss, magnificent!’
‘Elena writes so cleverly and with good humour, I was gripped and couldn't wait to read more and have my imagination play me the story as I swept from page to page. 5 big shiny stars!!!!’
Praise for Elena
'The emotionally powerful story of Katherine Ferrers really gripped me and the spooky sightings of her ghost were spine-tingling. Elena writes so beautifully and weaves the threads of the stories together so masterfully. Both heartbreaking and hopeful, it’s a brilliant read.' Nicola Cornick
'A wonderful book by a fabulous author. Very highly recommended.’ Louise Douglas
'The Lady of The Loch held me spellbound from the first page to the last. With two storylines beautifully woven together to create a seamless tale of love, loss, betrayal and, above all, hope, it’s a must-read. Collins’s detailed knowledge of the period trickles through the tale wrapping the reader in a vivid shifting world as it moves between the 14th century and present day. Cleverly researched and exquisitely written, The Lady of The Loch is a timeless story of hope, family and love. I loved it.
1625: Susanna and her daughter Katel live a contented life, but without the protection of a husband and father, Susanna fears for Katel’s future as she blossoms into womanhood. The fishing community of St Mawgen Cove is close knit but when misfortune arrives in the cove, it’s not long before villagers are looking for someone to blame. And when talk turns to witches, Susanna knows she and Katel are no longer safe.
Can Megan bring peace to St Mawgen and to two women who have been broken-hearted for centuries?
Bestseller Elena Collins is back with an unforgettable historical mystery about secrets, longing and the power of a mother’s love. Perfect for fans of Barbara Erskine, Nicola Cornick, Diana Gabaldon and Louise Douglas.
Readers love Elena
‘This is a wonderfully well-written book, atmospheric, immersive, heart-touching, heart-breaking.’
‘Really well written book, love the history and the mystery surrounding the story, what sadness surrounds this lady of old, cannot wait for your next book Elena.’
‘An enthralling blend of known fact, myth and imagination with believable characters, atmospheric descriptions and fascinating locations all told with warmth and compassion.’
‘The brilliant story of Kate Ferrers was entrancing with all of the well written characters coming to life from the page in a thrilling tale of love, friendships and loss, magnificent!’
‘Elena writes so cleverly and with good humour, I was gripped and couldn't wait to read more and have my imagination play me the story as I swept from page to page. 5 big shiny stars!!!!’
Praise for Elena
'The emotionally powerful story of Katherine Ferrers really gripped me and the spooky sightings of her ghost were spine-tingling. Elena writes so beautifully and weaves the threads of the stories together so masterfully. Both heartbreaking and hopeful, it’s a brilliant read.' Nicola Cornick
'A wonderful book by a fabulous author. Very highly recommended.’ Louise Douglas
'The Lady of The Loch held me spellbound from the first page to the last. With two storylines beautifully woven together to create a seamless tale of love, loss, betrayal and, above all, hope, it’s a must-read. Collins’s detailed knowledge of the period trickles through the tale wrapping the reader in a vivid shifting world as it moves between the 14th century and present day. Cleverly researched and exquisitely written, The Lady of The Loch is a timeless story of hope, family and love. I loved it.
378 pages, Kindle Edition
Published April 20, 2025
1354 people are currently reading
836 people want to read
About the author
Elena Collins
29 books199 followersElena Collins is a pseudonym of author Judy Leigh.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 208 reviews
April 9, 2025
My Reviews Can Also Be Found On:
The Book Review Crew Blog
This is a story which tells a captivating tale that intwines a historical mystery with a touch of magic. And all of it takes place in atmospheric Cornwall. I loved the dual timeline that switches between the 17th century and the present. I enjoyed the author's world-building, and her descriptive style brought St. Mawgan to life, which enhanced the story's sense of mystery and intrigue. The back and forth between the two storylines is written so as they are clearly defined while at the same time portraying the sense of connection between the past and present. The slow reveal of the secrets of the past added multiple layers of depth to the present mystery.
This is a multi-genre book, and the author mixes historical fiction, mystery and witchcraft elements successfully. It created an excellent amount of suspense that had me glued to the pages. Witches and ghosts and smugglers...oh my! I found the pacing to be a tad on the slow side, but I think it added to the suspense and worked well here. And if you're a historical fiction purist, you may not appreciate the witchcraft sections. If I have to mention one niggle it would be the ending, I wish there was more to it.
Overall, I enjoyed this book and its blend of the past with the present. It was captivating when it needed to be and a slow burn when it didn't. I think the best part of the book was the setting and the way the author melded an intriguing mystery with a hint of magic. I recommend it to those who enjoy a captivating story with a touch of hocus pocus.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the Advance Readers Copy.
The Book Review Crew Blog
This is a story which tells a captivating tale that intwines a historical mystery with a touch of magic. And all of it takes place in atmospheric Cornwall. I loved the dual timeline that switches between the 17th century and the present. I enjoyed the author's world-building, and her descriptive style brought St. Mawgan to life, which enhanced the story's sense of mystery and intrigue. The back and forth between the two storylines is written so as they are clearly defined while at the same time portraying the sense of connection between the past and present. The slow reveal of the secrets of the past added multiple layers of depth to the present mystery.
This is a multi-genre book, and the author mixes historical fiction, mystery and witchcraft elements successfully. It created an excellent amount of suspense that had me glued to the pages. Witches and ghosts and smugglers...oh my! I found the pacing to be a tad on the slow side, but I think it added to the suspense and worked well here. And if you're a historical fiction purist, you may not appreciate the witchcraft sections. If I have to mention one niggle it would be the ending, I wish there was more to it.
Overall, I enjoyed this book and its blend of the past with the present. It was captivating when it needed to be and a slow burn when it didn't. I think the best part of the book was the setting and the way the author melded an intriguing mystery with a hint of magic. I recommend it to those who enjoy a captivating story with a touch of hocus pocus.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the Advance Readers Copy.
April 11, 2025
I love this author's books and this is another great addition to her catalogue. Whenever I had to put it down, I couldn't wait to get back to it!
Two timelines, the present which is focused on Megan while 1625 is all about Susanna and her daughter Katel. Megan goes to Mawgen Cove on her father's behalf to search out a secret from his past that she has just learned. She stays at The Ship Inn which has lately changed hands and is rumored to be haunted.
Susanna is a pellar or healer and is very good at what she does. She and her daughter live alone and she's teaching Katel her trade. There's an old woman in the village who believes in the old ways and she's trying to get Katel to learn these things. She's trouble and causes havoc in the small community.
I loved the past story! The parts about the healing, detailing what was used and how things were done back then was brilliant. Also reading about the old ways and how easy it was to be convicted of witchcraft was quite scary. Life was precarious and you had to always be on the alert. My heart went out to Susanna. She was my favourite character in the whole story.
In the present the descriptions of Cornwall were wonderful. It explains a lot about diving and surfing too but not enough to detract from the story.
The reason I dropped a star was because the story was a little drawn out, especially the modern one. Then the last three chapters or so galloped along and everything was sorted very easily, too easily. There is an epilogue, it's just to tie up loose ends.
There are some lovely sea shanties in the book, including one at the start and the author includes links at the end for further information. I also have to mention the gorgeous cover.
A really great read and I'm already looking forward to her next book.
Many thanks to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for an early copy of this book.
Two timelines, the present which is focused on Megan while 1625 is all about Susanna and her daughter Katel. Megan goes to Mawgen Cove on her father's behalf to search out a secret from his past that she has just learned. She stays at The Ship Inn which has lately changed hands and is rumored to be haunted.
Susanna is a pellar or healer and is very good at what she does. She and her daughter live alone and she's teaching Katel her trade. There's an old woman in the village who believes in the old ways and she's trying to get Katel to learn these things. She's trouble and causes havoc in the small community.
I loved the past story! The parts about the healing, detailing what was used and how things were done back then was brilliant. Also reading about the old ways and how easy it was to be convicted of witchcraft was quite scary. Life was precarious and you had to always be on the alert. My heart went out to Susanna. She was my favourite character in the whole story.
In the present the descriptions of Cornwall were wonderful. It explains a lot about diving and surfing too but not enough to detract from the story.
The reason I dropped a star was because the story was a little drawn out, especially the modern one. Then the last three chapters or so galloped along and everything was sorted very easily, too easily. There is an epilogue, it's just to tie up loose ends.
There are some lovely sea shanties in the book, including one at the start and the author includes links at the end for further information. I also have to mention the gorgeous cover.
A really great read and I'm already looking forward to her next book.
Many thanks to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for an early copy of this book.
April 25, 2025
I know, I know, it's another book about witches!
But what can I say, they have me under a spell. And I'm here for it!
I cannot get enough of these books, and I will absolutely read more from this author after this one!
It had me gripped straight away and had characters I adored.
Loved it!
But what can I say, they have me under a spell. And I'm here for it!
I cannot get enough of these books, and I will absolutely read more from this author after this one!
It had me gripped straight away and had characters I adored.
Loved it!
Read
March 8, 2025The Cornish Witch is an atmospheric blend of history, mystery, and the supernatural, set against the hauntingly beautiful backdrop of St Mawgen Cove. When Megan arrives to uncover a long-buried secret, she finds herself entangled in a ghostly tale that stretches back to 1625, when whispers of witchcraft put two women in grave danger.
The novel’s dual timeline adds intrigue, with the modern-day mystery unfolding alongside the tension of the past. While the historical sections are richly detailed, their dense language made the pacing feel slower at times, especially compared to the more fluid present-day chapters. However, the novel’s themes of resilience and injustice, along with its vivid Cornish setting, create a compelling, immersive read.
For readers who love slow-burning historical fiction with a touch of the supernatural, The Cornish Witch offers a haunting and evocative journey through time.
The novel’s dual timeline adds intrigue, with the modern-day mystery unfolding alongside the tension of the past. While the historical sections are richly detailed, their dense language made the pacing feel slower at times, especially compared to the more fluid present-day chapters. However, the novel’s themes of resilience and injustice, along with its vivid Cornish setting, create a compelling, immersive read.
For readers who love slow-burning historical fiction with a touch of the supernatural, The Cornish Witch offers a haunting and evocative journey through time.
October 19, 2025
The story intertwined centuries before in a great story that was believable and told very well. Enjoyed this story immensely
April 27, 2025
Firstly, set in Cornwall, I love that the author took time to research and use the true names of Cornish towns (I often find that it is a bit of a rarity or places are just given made up names which bothers me to no end). The author did a brilliant job to include some Cornish heritage through the use of sea shanties and other phrases from the Cornish language which hit a real sweet spot for me.
As for the book itself, I loved the dual timeline. Discovering what happened in the cove and to the residence in the 17th century whilst in the current timeline, history and connections to the past were slowly being uncovered. There was some gorgeous world-building and I especially loved some of the descriptions used around parts of the story set in the 1600s.
I think it's maybe the first witchy/ghosty book I've read that's also been quite cute and cosy and still had a level of historical mystery to it. A lovely atmospheric blend of genres.
As for the book itself, I loved the dual timeline. Discovering what happened in the cove and to the residence in the 17th century whilst in the current timeline, history and connections to the past were slowly being uncovered. There was some gorgeous world-building and I especially loved some of the descriptions used around parts of the story set in the 1600s.
I think it's maybe the first witchy/ghosty book I've read that's also been quite cute and cosy and still had a level of historical mystery to it. A lovely atmospheric blend of genres.
September 14, 2025
Two thirds of this book could have been edited out. The idea is interesting and is what kept me listening, but the execution needed work. Everything felt flat and unrealistic.
September 18, 2025
The first book I’ve read by Elena Collins and definitely won’t be the last. It’s a very well written and well-constructed dual-timeline book with one foot in the 17th century and one in the 21st. We follow Megan holidaying in the fictional Cornish village of St. Mawgen gradually unravelling the ghostly secrets of the cove’s past. I particularly appreciated all the research the author must have done & the knowledge she put in to the book of Cornwall’s rich history, its language and its folklore. The two timelines balance each other perfectly & it’s all done in a really engaging style. I loved the spookiness of it & although an awful lot seemed to happen in a two week holiday it was just about ‘believable’ & I throughly enjoyed it.
April 9, 2025
I’m not usually one for ghosts and witches but I figured I’d try this one anyways, since quite often old 1600’s witch trials were a complete farce. This, however was a legitimate witch and ghost story, but I didn’t feel like it was all that creepy or eerie.
The storyline was interesting, going back and forth in the two timelines and I thought the build up was well done. I wasn’t a huge fan of the writing style - it just felt kind of flat, at least for Megan’s timeline, and some of the dialogue felt unnatural or mechanical.
The ghosts depicted in the book supposedly sent people screaming in terror but I never got that from the writing. They felt more like a weird interruption without much description to back up the declared emotional reaction. Susanna’s chapters were more fleshed out and better described, though the characters across the board felt fairly inconsistent.
Thanks to Netgalley for the advanced copy of this book. All opinions are mine.
The storyline was interesting, going back and forth in the two timelines and I thought the build up was well done. I wasn’t a huge fan of the writing style - it just felt kind of flat, at least for Megan’s timeline, and some of the dialogue felt unnatural or mechanical.
The ghosts depicted in the book supposedly sent people screaming in terror but I never got that from the writing. They felt more like a weird interruption without much description to back up the declared emotional reaction. Susanna’s chapters were more fleshed out and better described, though the characters across the board felt fairly inconsistent.
Thanks to Netgalley for the advanced copy of this book. All opinions are mine.
April 24, 2025
Megan heads to the Cornish village of St Mawgen Cove for a vacation. She plans on doing a lot of surfing and diving. She also hopes to meet her half sister whom she just found out about.
This book has dual timelines, I found the one set in the present more interesting. There’s a bit of a ghost story and a hint of romance to come.
It’s another good book by this author.
This book has dual timelines, I found the one set in the present more interesting. There’s a bit of a ghost story and a hint of romance to come.
It’s another good book by this author.
May 6, 2025
Another fascinating book by Elena. Dual timeline and such a great read. Witches, childbirth and death featured in this book. Creepy at times but I thoroughly enjoyed this one. My thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for giving me the opportunity to read this book in return for an honest review.
November 3, 2025
the main character going on a solo trip to cornwall, finding out that the inn she’s staying at is haunted, and learning all the folklore of the town oHhhhh she’s living my dream xx
October 28, 2025
Really enjoyed! Perfect for spooky season!
April 22, 2025
The Cornish Witch by Elena Collins is a dual timeline novel, set both in 1625 as well as the present. 1625 follows Susanna Boram, a healer, and her daughter Katel, a teenager interested in finding her prince while looking nice and smelling good. Present timeline follows Megan Hammond, who sets off to meet her half-sister Emma when she learns of her existence. The setting is the same—St. Mawgen Cove—and the inn Megan stays in, too, has been in existence for centuries. With an old inn comes old ghosts, including a Drenched Man and a Weeping Woman, and they’re joined by the Waiting Witch on the cliffs, who comes into town to murder the men.
The premise is interesting; I always enjoy a little magic and the supernatural, especially when the author leaves you wondering for a good portion of the book whether the magic is real or not. Historical fiction, too, is another thing that always catches my attention, and I personally preferred the past timeline to the present. I just felt more wrapped up and interested in Katel and Susanna’s story, and it was more urgent in the telling given that it had witchcraft vs a woman looking to meet her half-sister.
I think a problem with the book is it doesn’t really give room to breathe. Two examples from the past passages: one character curses another, and the effects of that curse IMMEDIATELY happen eight pages (eight digital pages, whatever that translates to) later. The second instance is two characters verbalising how they’ve never been happier and in the VERY next paragraph, a tragedy happens. There’s no real foreshadowing or a chance for the reader to be like “oh no! I can’t wait to see what happens; it’s gonna be intense!” because it just instantly happens.
The love story between Megan and Patrick is kind of silly as well. They knew each other three days and Megan didn’t want to leave. The date he asked her to happens off page before they go to dinner, and we’re repeatedly told how handsome he is, usually in conjunction with the explanation he doesn’t know it or doesn’t know how it affects Megan. It’s just very quick and I didn’t really get to know him as a character. This isn’t the meat of the text, however, so it’s easier to forgive.
I think I would have liked more interaction with the ghosts; the end bit was very engaging and made the final pages fly by. All in all, it’s a pretty quick read and kept my attention, mostly because I wanted to see how Katel’s childish impetuosity would turn out.
3.5 stars.
I received a copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
The premise is interesting; I always enjoy a little magic and the supernatural, especially when the author leaves you wondering for a good portion of the book whether the magic is real or not. Historical fiction, too, is another thing that always catches my attention, and I personally preferred the past timeline to the present. I just felt more wrapped up and interested in Katel and Susanna’s story, and it was more urgent in the telling given that it had witchcraft vs a woman looking to meet her half-sister.
I think a problem with the book is it doesn’t really give room to breathe. Two examples from the past passages: one character curses another, and the effects of that curse IMMEDIATELY happen eight pages (eight digital pages, whatever that translates to) later. The second instance is two characters verbalising how they’ve never been happier and in the VERY next paragraph, a tragedy happens. There’s no real foreshadowing or a chance for the reader to be like “oh no! I can’t wait to see what happens; it’s gonna be intense!” because it just instantly happens.
The love story between Megan and Patrick is kind of silly as well. They knew each other three days and Megan didn’t want to leave. The date he asked her to happens off page before they go to dinner, and we’re repeatedly told how handsome he is, usually in conjunction with the explanation he doesn’t know it or doesn’t know how it affects Megan. It’s just very quick and I didn’t really get to know him as a character. This isn’t the meat of the text, however, so it’s easier to forgive.
I think I would have liked more interaction with the ghosts; the end bit was very engaging and made the final pages fly by. All in all, it’s a pretty quick read and kept my attention, mostly because I wanted to see how Katel’s childish impetuosity would turn out.
3.5 stars.
I received a copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
March 27, 2025
The Cornish Witch is another fascinating, atmospheric, paranormal mystery romance from Elena Collins. A dual timeline novel of secrets from both past and present. Our modern day heroine, Megan is the one to put it all together and solve the centuries old mystery along with the current one by bringing two separated families together with their members. The stories unfold slowly giving us a chance to get to know the characters and understand the trials they face. There are some complex threads to unravel and the journey of both are intriguing and mesmerising. The two timelines cross over in the finale and we are given a wonderful conclusion to a dramatic and sometimes heartbreaking plot: though there is tragedy in both times, rectification is possible so that restoration can begin.
When Megan’s father receives a letter that divulges a secret from the past, he is quite shaken and not sure what to do. He eventually unloads his worries with his daughter with whom he shares a close relationship and she offers up a solution. She will go to the Cornish Village of St Mawgen Cove to unravel the mystery for him but under the guise of a surfing holiday. When she lands at the Cove and checks in at The Ships Inn, she is soon captivated by another mystery that surrounds the accommodation and St. Mawgen community. Yes, there are ghosts with bad odours, wailing and other strange sounds that go bump in the night. These paranormal activities certainly set her on edge but her desire to help those spirits left behind, drives her forward to solve a centuries old mystery. Elena gives us lots of clues, vivid imagery and accounts of events to keep us turning the pages as we move from one timeline to the next, as we learn about the past villagers of the 1600s while keeping our eyes open on the present.
The second timeline set in 1625 delivers interesting characters such as Susanna, the villager’s choice herbalist-healer, a single parent who lives with her daughter Katel. The father of Katel is unaware of his offspring but as Katel grows up, many strange things begin to happen as she is drawn into the circle of a woman who may be a witch. Many misfortunes happen and the villagers are looking for someone to blame. And when the topic of witches arises, Susanna knows that her daughter’s association with Tedda (accused of using witchcraft to evil ends) means she is no longer safe. Quickly the world around her begins to crack as explosive accusations fly.
This is a story about broken hearts, secrets, misunderstandings, the strength of a mother’s love and how it may take centuries for healing to come. But I am happy to say the novel, though often sad, ends on a high note: with all mysteries solved, not only for those from the past but also for Megan and her family in the present. There’s even a new romance on the horizon for our modern day heroine!
For those who love Elena’s previous paranormal novels, you will enjoy this one as well. I was charmed by the characters and appreciated both timelines equally. I also loved how the past slides into the present ending in a grand finale. An enthralling, spellbinding dual timeline from a much loved author once again! 4 Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thanks to Boldwood Books and Netgalley for a review copy.
When Megan’s father receives a letter that divulges a secret from the past, he is quite shaken and not sure what to do. He eventually unloads his worries with his daughter with whom he shares a close relationship and she offers up a solution. She will go to the Cornish Village of St Mawgen Cove to unravel the mystery for him but under the guise of a surfing holiday. When she lands at the Cove and checks in at The Ships Inn, she is soon captivated by another mystery that surrounds the accommodation and St. Mawgen community. Yes, there are ghosts with bad odours, wailing and other strange sounds that go bump in the night. These paranormal activities certainly set her on edge but her desire to help those spirits left behind, drives her forward to solve a centuries old mystery. Elena gives us lots of clues, vivid imagery and accounts of events to keep us turning the pages as we move from one timeline to the next, as we learn about the past villagers of the 1600s while keeping our eyes open on the present.
The second timeline set in 1625 delivers interesting characters such as Susanna, the villager’s choice herbalist-healer, a single parent who lives with her daughter Katel. The father of Katel is unaware of his offspring but as Katel grows up, many strange things begin to happen as she is drawn into the circle of a woman who may be a witch. Many misfortunes happen and the villagers are looking for someone to blame. And when the topic of witches arises, Susanna knows that her daughter’s association with Tedda (accused of using witchcraft to evil ends) means she is no longer safe. Quickly the world around her begins to crack as explosive accusations fly.
This is a story about broken hearts, secrets, misunderstandings, the strength of a mother’s love and how it may take centuries for healing to come. But I am happy to say the novel, though often sad, ends on a high note: with all mysteries solved, not only for those from the past but also for Megan and her family in the present. There’s even a new romance on the horizon for our modern day heroine!
For those who love Elena’s previous paranormal novels, you will enjoy this one as well. I was charmed by the characters and appreciated both timelines equally. I also loved how the past slides into the present ending in a grand finale. An enthralling, spellbinding dual timeline from a much loved author once again! 4 Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thanks to Boldwood Books and Netgalley for a review copy.
April 10, 2025
A timeslip novel of love, loss and superstition.
Set in 1625 and 21st century Cornwall, The Cornish Witch takes you back to a time when being woman with a knowledge of healing, and adhering to old 'traditional' ways, was a dangerous thing.
In 21st century Somerset the story follows Megan. A young woman in the midst of dealing with a painful breakup, her father Bill suddenly receives a letter that throws comfortable, if not predictable, life into disarray.
The letter sets off a chain of events that Megan did not see coming. It's written by an Emma Davey who claims to be Bill's daughter, one that his wife Jackie, and Megan for that matter, knows nothing of. In order to help her father, Megan takes a holiday to Cornwall in the hope of finding out more about her half sister Emma.
But it's in Cornwall, and her stay at The Ship Inn, that sees the start of the timeslip - the Inn dating from the mid 1600s and steeped in local history.
It's here we're introduced to Susanna and her daughter Katel. Slowly, invitingly, we're introduced to more 17th century characters who will each play a part in how Susanna and Katel's story culminate; Colan, Tedda, Beaten, Yowann. At the start we're not told who Katel's father is and this unknowing plays a big role in Katel's life - she's arguably wild and untamed due to the lack of fatherly supervision which manifests in later difficulties. But Katel and Susanna are both well loved in their community, for Susanna is a trusted healer.
Throughout their story we, the readers, are absorbed in witnessing the harshness of small coastal village life. Everyone knows everyone else's business, very little is secret, and friendships are thus tested when 'truths' come to light.
One of these supposed 'truths' is how Tedda is a witch, Tedda who then implicates Katel as following her suit and equally to blame for misfortunes that fall upon the community.
What follows is a series of events which are perceived to be the result of witchcraft. Collins writes with such vivid storytelling and rich detail that you are swept along in the story. You feel as if you are witnessing firsthand what's unfolding and it's emotive, you can't help but be drawn to these women, spurring them on and hoping that their resilience prevails. It's captivating and I appreciated how the chapters were distinctly of different centuries, making it easy to follow and understand storylines, but yet it never felt disjointed. Collins' writing beautifully bridged the centuries, emphasising a connection between the two settings that added to the mystical nature of the plot.
Meanwhile in the 21st century, Megan meets several characters; Carly, Tom, Patrick, the cleaner and Julien. These likewise help carry the story along at a nice pace. While it sometimes feels like Collins loses sight of the direction Megan is going in (i.e trying to find Emma Davey) the storyline nevertheless portrays the idyllic Cornish landscape and offers an encouraging if slightly eccentric romance for Megan.
The story is well written and generally well paced (I did find the ending to the 1625 storyline a bit abrupt). The storylines are neatly tied up, there is the odd twist that keeps you wanting to read more and past events are explained to fulfil everyone's satisfaction.
I've not read anything by this author before, but I think The Cornish Witch is the perfect introduction to more of Collins' books. I read it in 3 days, and thoroughly enjoyed it. I've tried not tk give too much away here, but needless to say I think it's perfect for fans of historical storylines or more generally for a holiday read - particularly if you're holidaying in Cornwall!
With thanks to Netgalley for this advance copy!
Set in 1625 and 21st century Cornwall, The Cornish Witch takes you back to a time when being woman with a knowledge of healing, and adhering to old 'traditional' ways, was a dangerous thing.
In 21st century Somerset the story follows Megan. A young woman in the midst of dealing with a painful breakup, her father Bill suddenly receives a letter that throws comfortable, if not predictable, life into disarray.
The letter sets off a chain of events that Megan did not see coming. It's written by an Emma Davey who claims to be Bill's daughter, one that his wife Jackie, and Megan for that matter, knows nothing of. In order to help her father, Megan takes a holiday to Cornwall in the hope of finding out more about her half sister Emma.
But it's in Cornwall, and her stay at The Ship Inn, that sees the start of the timeslip - the Inn dating from the mid 1600s and steeped in local history.
It's here we're introduced to Susanna and her daughter Katel. Slowly, invitingly, we're introduced to more 17th century characters who will each play a part in how Susanna and Katel's story culminate; Colan, Tedda, Beaten, Yowann. At the start we're not told who Katel's father is and this unknowing plays a big role in Katel's life - she's arguably wild and untamed due to the lack of fatherly supervision which manifests in later difficulties. But Katel and Susanna are both well loved in their community, for Susanna is a trusted healer.
Throughout their story we, the readers, are absorbed in witnessing the harshness of small coastal village life. Everyone knows everyone else's business, very little is secret, and friendships are thus tested when 'truths' come to light.
One of these supposed 'truths' is how Tedda is a witch, Tedda who then implicates Katel as following her suit and equally to blame for misfortunes that fall upon the community.
What follows is a series of events which are perceived to be the result of witchcraft. Collins writes with such vivid storytelling and rich detail that you are swept along in the story. You feel as if you are witnessing firsthand what's unfolding and it's emotive, you can't help but be drawn to these women, spurring them on and hoping that their resilience prevails. It's captivating and I appreciated how the chapters were distinctly of different centuries, making it easy to follow and understand storylines, but yet it never felt disjointed. Collins' writing beautifully bridged the centuries, emphasising a connection between the two settings that added to the mystical nature of the plot.
Meanwhile in the 21st century, Megan meets several characters; Carly, Tom, Patrick, the cleaner and Julien. These likewise help carry the story along at a nice pace. While it sometimes feels like Collins loses sight of the direction Megan is going in (i.e trying to find Emma Davey) the storyline nevertheless portrays the idyllic Cornish landscape and offers an encouraging if slightly eccentric romance for Megan.
The story is well written and generally well paced (I did find the ending to the 1625 storyline a bit abrupt). The storylines are neatly tied up, there is the odd twist that keeps you wanting to read more and past events are explained to fulfil everyone's satisfaction.
I've not read anything by this author before, but I think The Cornish Witch is the perfect introduction to more of Collins' books. I read it in 3 days, and thoroughly enjoyed it. I've tried not tk give too much away here, but needless to say I think it's perfect for fans of historical storylines or more generally for a holiday read - particularly if you're holidaying in Cornwall!
With thanks to Netgalley for this advance copy!
April 27, 2025
Historical fiction and magical realism all packaged together in a tragic yet beautiful Cornish bow. The cover alone is breathtaking.
We meet two different women, in two vastly different timelines, wanting to do what comes natural, which is protect their families at all costs. In today's world, Megan is searching for herself and what comes next after difficult break-up. A long the way, her father tells her of a secret he's held close to for so long he fears it may ruin hers and her mother's opinion of him. She travels to St. Mawgen's not only to follow-up on her father's past , but also see what else is out there waiting for her to find. St. Mawgen's in the 1600s is old world and beautiful, completely different from it's present. Here we meet Susanna raising her free-spirited, teenage daughter Katel, on her own without a husband and without naming Katel's father. Though it was difficult to be young, pregnant without a man to take care of them, Susanna became a well respected midwife and healer to the village. All of that comes to a head when her daughter is accused of the practices of old witchcraft.
Megan and Susanna's worlds intertwine as St. Mawgen is still trying to heal from some of it's darker history, and whether or not the local legend of the Witch's Kiss will continue to claim those that that love forever.
I am always a fan of two POVs, especially in historical fiction where both the past and the present are intertwined. This was a lovely, first by the author, book for me. Elena Collins's writing is breathtaking, vivid, and heartfelt in every single sentence. Cornish Witch is a beautifully tragic story of family, grief, and the resilience of love.
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the opportunity to read and provide my opinion of this book.
The Cornish Witch
by Elena Collins
Boldwood Books
Pub date: 4/20/25
We meet two different women, in two vastly different timelines, wanting to do what comes natural, which is protect their families at all costs. In today's world, Megan is searching for herself and what comes next after difficult break-up. A long the way, her father tells her of a secret he's held close to for so long he fears it may ruin hers and her mother's opinion of him. She travels to St. Mawgen's not only to follow-up on her father's past , but also see what else is out there waiting for her to find. St. Mawgen's in the 1600s is old world and beautiful, completely different from it's present. Here we meet Susanna raising her free-spirited, teenage daughter Katel, on her own without a husband and without naming Katel's father. Though it was difficult to be young, pregnant without a man to take care of them, Susanna became a well respected midwife and healer to the village. All of that comes to a head when her daughter is accused of the practices of old witchcraft.
Megan and Susanna's worlds intertwine as St. Mawgen is still trying to heal from some of it's darker history, and whether or not the local legend of the Witch's Kiss will continue to claim those that that love forever.
I am always a fan of two POVs, especially in historical fiction where both the past and the present are intertwined. This was a lovely, first by the author, book for me. Elena Collins's writing is breathtaking, vivid, and heartfelt in every single sentence. Cornish Witch is a beautifully tragic story of family, grief, and the resilience of love.
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the opportunity to read and provide my opinion of this book.
The Cornish Witch
by Elena Collins
Boldwood Books
Pub date: 4/20/25
April 17, 2025
The Present: Megan just found out her father's secret. She will assist him by going to a town in search of her father's secret. She stays at The Ship Inn, which had been built for fishermen many years ago. The inn holds many secrets and even ghosts.
The Past (1665) : Susanna and her daughter Katel live in St. Mawgen Cove in Cornwall.Susanna is the local healer and doula. She is well loved and renowned but after a series of events, Susanna and her daughter are accused of witchcraft. Katel suffers an accident and Susanna dies.
The Present: Megan can see and feel the most famous ghosts in the inn, the Drenched Man and the Weeping Woman. She wants to help the proprietors with the inn and booking more clients, however, the ghosts seem to scare them all away. If only Megan can find a way to help the ghosts move on while also finding love.
The Cornish Witch is a lovely captivating tale of love, sacrifice, redemption and finishing what was started. 💫💫💫💫💫
Thank you Netgalley and Boldwood Books
The Past (1665) : Susanna and her daughter Katel live in St. Mawgen Cove in Cornwall.Susanna is the local healer and doula. She is well loved and renowned but after a series of events, Susanna and her daughter are accused of witchcraft. Katel suffers an accident and Susanna dies.
The Present: Megan can see and feel the most famous ghosts in the inn, the Drenched Man and the Weeping Woman. She wants to help the proprietors with the inn and booking more clients, however, the ghosts seem to scare them all away. If only Megan can find a way to help the ghosts move on while also finding love.
The Cornish Witch is a lovely captivating tale of love, sacrifice, redemption and finishing what was started. 💫💫💫💫💫
Thank you Netgalley and Boldwood Books
April 5, 2025
Thank you to Netgalley and Boldwood for allowing me to read this book before release date.
This book had me from the first sentence.. i was hooked into this story. I loved that we followed present day and the past. Such strong female main characters, in both present and past ! Family, love.. mystery ! Ghosts, witches and history with such strong settings in Cornwall. I felt my heart ache at points in this book... I found myself thinking about this book even when i wasn't reading, It's constant page turner.
It's a 5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ all day long from me..
this book is what i needed to remind me why i love historic novels so much. I will be recommending it fellow book friends.
Now i need my Cornwall fix 🌊
This book had me from the first sentence.. i was hooked into this story. I loved that we followed present day and the past. Such strong female main characters, in both present and past ! Family, love.. mystery ! Ghosts, witches and history with such strong settings in Cornwall. I felt my heart ache at points in this book... I found myself thinking about this book even when i wasn't reading, It's constant page turner.
It's a 5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ all day long from me..
this book is what i needed to remind me why i love historic novels so much. I will be recommending it fellow book friends.
Now i need my Cornwall fix 🌊
November 25, 2025
Book review- The Cornish Witch by Elena Collins
Aww this was such a lovely story, my first book from Elena Collins and won’t be the last . Beautifully written and the current day story was so cozy and the historic story was very atmospheric and a little sad at the end . Altogether a great book and I highly recommend xx
📚4 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Aww this was such a lovely story, my first book from Elena Collins and won’t be the last . Beautifully written and the current day story was so cozy and the historic story was very atmospheric and a little sad at the end . Altogether a great book and I highly recommend xx
📚4 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Read
April 20, 2025This was a book I was invited to read but it really wasn’t for me. I much preferred the recent timeline to the past. A decent enough story but too much romance for me.
May 9, 2025
I love this author so much! Every time there’s a new one out, I usually read it in 1 or 2 sittings. This one has been my least favourite so far- but that’s not to say it wasn’t good.
I find that the past stories are my favourite- I love the eras and details painted. I adore how the dual timeline’s dance with one another- it’s exceptional. In all honesty, the only faults I have are with the modern characters. I don’t know how best to describe it other than, they don’t always have young voices or actions about them. I say this as a person in the demographic of the modern characters. It’s the only thing that ever takes me out of the stories.
SPOILERS AHEAD: BIG ONES *************************
With this book, in particular, I have questions!
There were some minor grievances with the modern plot at the start, solely because I’m from the area, and this is my problem- some aspects took me out of the story because, who doesn’t get annoyed when their home is featured in books, but nuances are missed? Honestly a me problem- and no one will have the book ruined by this.
I found the mystery in this book to be predictable. How the two timelines intersected was too obvious for me. I haven’t felt like that with the other books read by this author.
The romances in this book didn’t captivate me or feel realistic- especially the modern one, because she knew him for 3-4 days, there wasn’t much longing and he got serious VERY FAST- 1 date- I need you to promise that we’ll be something. This is what I alluded to previously.
Biggest question- biggest spoiler- WHY DID THE WAITING WITCH COME AFTER COLAN?!?!
Second biggest question- Anne- you dirty scoundrel- WHY WOULD YOU EVER THINK THAT SHE COULD HAVE KILLED YOUR HUSBAND?!?
They also said that Anchor Cottage was haunted, and the owners couldn’t sell- that story was not wrapped up. (Which I’m assuming it was haunted by the whole family? Maybe just the girl?)
Also, room 4 with The Drenched Man? Where was his resolution?
To sum it up, I’m being a mardy diva, this is honestly a good book with a compelling story- I’ve just read too many of this author’s books, and I’m sad that I didn’t fangirl over this one.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 6, 2025
Captivating
I loved how the past and present were wound together. The story drew me in and had me thinking about it even when I wasn't reading.
I loved how the past and present were wound together. The story drew me in and had me thinking about it even when I wasn't reading.
October 19, 2025
3.5⭐️
A nice easy read but nothing particularly thought provoking, no major twists or wow moments.
Not in the least bit scary or eerie.
A nice easy read but nothing particularly thought provoking, no major twists or wow moments.
Not in the least bit scary or eerie.
October 9, 2025
I love Cornwall and witches and dual timelines. This book had it all. It was creepy, atmospheric to the point I actually felt I was right there in St Mawgan. I devoured this book and its so perfect for Halloween time.
April 26, 2025
A heartbreaking and compelling historical story, an engaging present day thread with a touch of romance and plenty of chills, a present day mystery and another that crosses the centuries – and my goodness, I thoroughly enjoyed this one!
In the present day, Megan’s holiday in St Mawgen Cove isn’t simply the chance to kick back and enjoy some surfing – her father has received a letter raising a secret from his past, and it’s an opportunity for her to try to find out more. Her stay at The Ship Inn brings new friendships and a touch of romance, but also something rather more unexpected when she finds her nights are disturbed – the cove has its own deeply hidden secrets, rather more than mere folk myths and legends and still with a lasting impact, and the souls that remain need some assistance in being able to rest.
In 1625, Susanna is a healer, well regarded, but hiding some of the detail of her past. She lives with her daughter Katel, who is giving her increasing cause for concern by falling under the influence of Tedda, a villager who practices rather darker arts. In an age of suspicion, some unexplained tragedies among the community lead to the conclusion that witchcraft must be involved – and Susanna needs to take desperate action to protect her wayward daughter from the fingers pointing in her direction.
The story moves so smoothly between past and present, with the darkness of the steadily mounting threat to Susanna and Katel – the historical setting quite perfectly recreated in every detail – nicely balanced by Megan’s experiences as she tries to cast some light on her father’s problems but gets increasingly caught up in the mysteries of the past. The supernatural elements of the story are superbly handled, very chilling and particularly real – to such an extent that I’ll admit I did have a few sleepless nights of my own, finding some of the restless spirits and their unfolding stories particularly disturbing.
There are some lovely moments of lightness too – I loved the lady in the teashop who explained some of the legends in such a matter-of-fact way while laying the table, the quirky friend from the surf shack, the owners of the inn despairing of ever making a success of their venture while things keep going bump in the night – and I enjoyed both the slow resolution of Megan’s father’s situation and the developing romance. But it’s really the heartbreaking tale from the past that makes the book such a compelling read – I shed a few tears for the individuals involved, the love of family, the mother doing all she could in the face of mounting odds, all with an outcome that always felt sadly inevitable. But there’s perfect closure to the whole story, drawing together the past and present – and an ending that hit exactly the right note after all the emotional turmoil that had gone before.
I have to say I absolutely loved it – dual time writing at its very best, and perhaps my favourite book to date from this rather special author. Highly recommended, but do learn from my experience – read it in the daylight, not on your own in the dark, and you’ll enjoy it every bit as much as I did.
In the present day, Megan’s holiday in St Mawgen Cove isn’t simply the chance to kick back and enjoy some surfing – her father has received a letter raising a secret from his past, and it’s an opportunity for her to try to find out more. Her stay at The Ship Inn brings new friendships and a touch of romance, but also something rather more unexpected when she finds her nights are disturbed – the cove has its own deeply hidden secrets, rather more than mere folk myths and legends and still with a lasting impact, and the souls that remain need some assistance in being able to rest.
In 1625, Susanna is a healer, well regarded, but hiding some of the detail of her past. She lives with her daughter Katel, who is giving her increasing cause for concern by falling under the influence of Tedda, a villager who practices rather darker arts. In an age of suspicion, some unexplained tragedies among the community lead to the conclusion that witchcraft must be involved – and Susanna needs to take desperate action to protect her wayward daughter from the fingers pointing in her direction.
The story moves so smoothly between past and present, with the darkness of the steadily mounting threat to Susanna and Katel – the historical setting quite perfectly recreated in every detail – nicely balanced by Megan’s experiences as she tries to cast some light on her father’s problems but gets increasingly caught up in the mysteries of the past. The supernatural elements of the story are superbly handled, very chilling and particularly real – to such an extent that I’ll admit I did have a few sleepless nights of my own, finding some of the restless spirits and their unfolding stories particularly disturbing.
There are some lovely moments of lightness too – I loved the lady in the teashop who explained some of the legends in such a matter-of-fact way while laying the table, the quirky friend from the surf shack, the owners of the inn despairing of ever making a success of their venture while things keep going bump in the night – and I enjoyed both the slow resolution of Megan’s father’s situation and the developing romance. But it’s really the heartbreaking tale from the past that makes the book such a compelling read – I shed a few tears for the individuals involved, the love of family, the mother doing all she could in the face of mounting odds, all with an outcome that always felt sadly inevitable. But there’s perfect closure to the whole story, drawing together the past and present – and an ending that hit exactly the right note after all the emotional turmoil that had gone before.
I have to say I absolutely loved it – dual time writing at its very best, and perhaps my favourite book to date from this rather special author. Highly recommended, but do learn from my experience – read it in the daylight, not on your own in the dark, and you’ll enjoy it every bit as much as I did.
April 20, 2025
The Cornish Witch has skyrocketed to the very top of my favourites from Elena Collins, which is quite a feat, as I adored The Wicked Lady. Once again, the book is told as a dual-timeline story with equal presence in the present day and the seventeenth century. In the present day, we meet Megan, who is on a mission from her father to solve the mystery of a letter from the past.
When she arrives in Cornwall, Megan begins to sense presences in the other rooms of the Ship Inn, and she becomes determined to uncover the secrets of what happened in St Mawgen Cove, hoping to bring some relief to the lost souls of the area.
Meanwhile, back in 1625, we meet Susanna and her daughter, Katel. As a single mother, Susanna worries about what will become of her daughter once her advancing years begin to impact her life and choices. While Susanna wants nothing but the best for Katel, it is apparent that Katel is too interested in the lives and opinions of others.
Straddling the two timelines, Collins reveals just enough to keep the reader interested but not to introduce any spoilers as we head for the big reveal and discover more about the local legends and their sources.
As the present day finally meets the past. The feeling of closure is comforting, yet a touch of melancholy remains, evoking past losses and prompting you to remember the names of those who have gone before us. I was moved to tears as I read, and I hope that you get as much joy as I did, despite the sobering context of the story.
When she arrives in Cornwall, Megan begins to sense presences in the other rooms of the Ship Inn, and she becomes determined to uncover the secrets of what happened in St Mawgen Cove, hoping to bring some relief to the lost souls of the area.
Meanwhile, back in 1625, we meet Susanna and her daughter, Katel. As a single mother, Susanna worries about what will become of her daughter once her advancing years begin to impact her life and choices. While Susanna wants nothing but the best for Katel, it is apparent that Katel is too interested in the lives and opinions of others.
Straddling the two timelines, Collins reveals just enough to keep the reader interested but not to introduce any spoilers as we head for the big reveal and discover more about the local legends and their sources.
As the present day finally meets the past. The feeling of closure is comforting, yet a touch of melancholy remains, evoking past losses and prompting you to remember the names of those who have gone before us. I was moved to tears as I read, and I hope that you get as much joy as I did, despite the sobering context of the story.
May 7, 2025
If you’re a fan of witchy reads with a touch of historical intrigue, The Cornish Witch is a captivating choice. This dual-timeline novel transports readers back to 1625, weaving together the intense lives of Susanna and her daughter Katel, alongside a present-day storyline that, while less gripping, adds a modern twist to the tale.
For me, the 1625 timeline truly stole the show. Susanna and Katel’s journey is rich with atmosphere and captures the wild spirit of Cornwall. Their struggles against suspicion, fear and the harsh realities of their time pulled me in from the start, making each chapter feel like a spellbinding piece of living history. The author does a fantastic job of immersing you in their world, where whispers of witchcraft echo against the rugged coastline and flicker through shadowed woods.
While the present-day storyline didn’t quite match the intensity of the historical sections, it still brought some enjoyable moments, especially with its eerie, spirit-laden atmosphere. The ghostly presences that linger between the centuries added a haunting edge that I really appreciated, binding the two timelines together in a satisfying but somewhat predictable way.
Overall, if you’re drawn to stories that blend past and present, with a healthy dose of folklore and witchcraft, this one is well worth a read. Just be prepared to find yourself more enchanted by the old world than the new.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the chance to read an eARC of the book in exchange for my honest review.
For me, the 1625 timeline truly stole the show. Susanna and Katel’s journey is rich with atmosphere and captures the wild spirit of Cornwall. Their struggles against suspicion, fear and the harsh realities of their time pulled me in from the start, making each chapter feel like a spellbinding piece of living history. The author does a fantastic job of immersing you in their world, where whispers of witchcraft echo against the rugged coastline and flicker through shadowed woods.
While the present-day storyline didn’t quite match the intensity of the historical sections, it still brought some enjoyable moments, especially with its eerie, spirit-laden atmosphere. The ghostly presences that linger between the centuries added a haunting edge that I really appreciated, binding the two timelines together in a satisfying but somewhat predictable way.
Overall, if you’re drawn to stories that blend past and present, with a healthy dose of folklore and witchcraft, this one is well worth a read. Just be prepared to find yourself more enchanted by the old world than the new.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the chance to read an eARC of the book in exchange for my honest review.
January 19, 2026
4.5 / 5.0 ✨️
I've never bought a book as fast as this book. When I read it would be a Historical Fiction book about witches, I simply needed to read the whole book, and I couldn't wait until I could start it. Immediately from the beginning of this story, I was interested in both timelines. The "now" timeline was really something to be curious about; what would Megan do and what was going to happen? The "1625" timeline was the timeline which got me wondering how it was connected to "now", and the whole ambiance was simply amazing! I loved all the information written about herbs and stones, which made the story even more witchy. This book contained so much more interesting things than I would've hoped based on the blurb, and I was so here for it! I loved how everything came together at the end, even though it felt a bit rushed, unlike the whole book, which was quite slow. But I loved the writing style a LOT! 4.5 stars for me, and I'll surely read more books by this author :)
I've never bought a book as fast as this book. When I read it would be a Historical Fiction book about witches, I simply needed to read the whole book, and I couldn't wait until I could start it. Immediately from the beginning of this story, I was interested in both timelines. The "now" timeline was really something to be curious about; what would Megan do and what was going to happen? The "1625" timeline was the timeline which got me wondering how it was connected to "now", and the whole ambiance was simply amazing! I loved all the information written about herbs and stones, which made the story even more witchy. This book contained so much more interesting things than I would've hoped based on the blurb, and I was so here for it! I loved how everything came together at the end, even though it felt a bit rushed, unlike the whole book, which was quite slow. But I loved the writing style a LOT! 4.5 stars for me, and I'll surely read more books by this author :)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 208 reviews