Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Candle Island

Rate this book
A moving portrait of loss and the restorative power of art from Lauren Wolk, the Newbery Honor-winning author of Beyond the Bright Sea.

Lucretia Sanderson has a secret.

Lucretia and her mother have come to tiny Candle Island, Maine ( Summer, 986; Winter, 315) to escape—escape memories of the car accident that killed her father and escape the journalists that hound her mother, a famous and reclusive artist. The rocky coast and ocean breeze are a welcome respite for Lucretia, who dedicates her summer days to painting, exploring the island, and caring for an orphaned osprey chick.

But Candle Island has secrets of its own—a hidden room in her new house, a mysterious boy with a beautiful voice—and just like the strong tides that surround the shores, they will catch Lucretia in their wake.

With an unforgettable New England setting and a complex web of relationships old and new, Candle Island is a powerful story about art, loss, and the power of being true to your own voice.

352 pages, Kindle Edition

First published April 22, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Lauren Wolk

12 books881 followers
Lauren Wolk is an award-winning poet and author of the bestselling Newbery Honor–winning Wolf Hollow, described by the New York Times Book Review as "full of grace and stark, brutal beauty." She was born in Baltimore and has since lived in California, Rhode Island, Minnesota, Canada, and Ohio. She now lives with her family on Cape Cod.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,021 (46%)
4 stars
848 (38%)
3 stars
294 (13%)
2 stars
42 (1%)
1 star
9 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 477 reviews
Profile Image for Betsy.
Author 17 books3,353 followers
February 12, 2025
An author that can tell you at the beginning of their book that there’s a big secret lurking in its pages, then subsequently make you completely forget all about it until the right time is, to my mind, a good writer. And I surprise absolutely no one when I say that Lauren Wolk? She is a good writer. Not an easy writer. After all, none of her books ever strike me as particularly simple to plot out and write, but a strong one just the same. When I see a new Wolk, I don’t know what to expect or even, in many ways, when or where I am until she tells me. With her latest book, Wolk tackles recovering from trauma (personal, economic, etc.) within the context of a small class war. She also takes time to focus on the process of creating art and what it means to both the creator and the recipients. And that secret? Don’t be surprised if you forget all about it… until it’s too late.

Change can be good. After her father was killed in a car crash, Lucretia and her mother run away from the world to Candle Island, a tiny tourist destination just off the coast of Maine. They’re not going for a vacation, though, but to stay. In the real world, Lucretia and her mother paint and her mother sustains them both with selling paintings. The subsequent fame has turned into a curse. On Candle Island they hope to be anonymous, but that hope is dashed fairly early on. While Lucretia befriends a local boy named Seb and attempts to come to terms with the prickly girl her age, Murdock, her mother discovers an art critic on the island who is determined to interview her. Then there are the wary locals, as well as the snide tourists. Lucretia takes time to tend to a wounded osprey chick, paints in her barn, rides her horse, and tries to avoid three rich teens with trouble on their minds. But when one of the docks is set alight one evening, things on the island take a turn for the serious.

Like many people I first came to Ms. Wolk’s books through her unforgettable Newbery Honor winning title Wolf Hollow. There are elements to that book that still haunt me to this day. Somehow, in the span of just a few pages, Lauren managed to conjure up the most unrepentantly evil little blonde girl you will ever find in a work of realistic fiction for kids. My lingering discomfort has had longstanding consequences, of course. Mainly, that I have difficulty reading other Lauren Wolk books without constantly looking over my proverbial shoulder every page or so for similar villains. Are there bad children in Candle Island? Of course there are. Three little wealthy weasels that pose a threat to our heroine’s happiness. Are they at the same level as Betty Glengarry? They are not, for while Betty was a burgeoning sadist, these three are precisely what they appear to be: rich and bored. That didn’t stop me from worrying about them constantly during my read, which is not the worst way to go through this book. They’re just not on her level.

That Lauren Wolk has given herself the unforgiving goal of writing about the magic of the artistic process is clear. It is also a thankless task, to say the least. While art can be defined in words, the effect it has on the artist, in the midst of their creativity, often defies explanation. Not content to simply discuss Lucretia and her paintings, Wolk doubles down by making two of the other kids on island a singer and a poet. They discover one another’s gifts late in the game but the clear indication is that this is a bond they share, whether known or unknown. And since our heroine is Lucretia, the key to the book are the moment when she paints. She can recognize art in other people, whether it’s a song or a poem, but when she’s in the zone, that’s when Wolk has to put the reader in a similar kind of zone as well. Some kids will come out of this book wanting to paint themselves. Others will take a broader interpretation, and may feel inclined to pursue their own art. Still others, without any artistic inclinations at all, may read Candle Island and come away from it with a slightly better understanding of what it means to either create or appreciate art. That’s what we can hope for anyway.

As for her writing itself, it’s what we come for, isn’t it? There are certain authors for children that are capable of the kind of writing that is not merely full of strong character growth and interesting plotting, but legitimately lovely prose as well. On a single page I found lines that end with glimpses of a “bruise-blue sea.” Or, when Lucretia thinks about befriending the prickly Murdock, she is thinking of, “How adding even a little yellow to the coldest gray could warm it toward something altogether new. But Murdock was a girl, not a painting. I would have to remember that.” I mark in my copy of this book the lines I like best. What’s remarkable about them is how seamlessly they’re integrated into the plot. I suppose, when you get right down to it, not a ton of things happen in this story. There are tense, and sometimes even terrible, moments but at no point did I ever quite figure out where the book was going. I figured that Lucretia would befriend Murdock eventually, and there would be some big scene involving the three spoiled preps, but when the big reveal does happen in the book it caught me wholly off-guard. So off-guard, in fact, that I actually needed one of the characters to spell everything out to me (which, nice guy that he is, he did readily). It’s really a talented title from start. You get what you come for when you read a Lauren Wolk book, even if you’re not certain why you came.

If I seek to find flaw, finding flaws is hard to do. However, there were a couple elements of the book I would have liked to see tightened up. The time period, for one thing, is fairly unclear throughout the book. If I had to guess, I’d say that the story takes place before the advent of cell phones. Otherwise, the book could easily take place today. It’s not like class warfare has gotten any less acute in recent decades. Of course, thinking about it, I’m not entirely certain that Ms. Wolk has ever given a strict date to any of her books. Wolf Hollow and its sequel did, but that may have been because there was a specific war that the plot hinged around. This book could technically take place today, but only if you squint and try to imagine cell phones and the internet not being a thing. It’s easy if you try.

At the end of the day, this is the kind of book that can include a Mark Twain quote like, “The very ink with which history is written is merely fluid prejudice,” without anyone batting an eye. Or, my personal favorite, the Edith Wharton line, “There are two ways of spreading light: to be the candle or the mirror that reflects it.” And remember that secret I alluded to earlier? The Prologue is where you’ll find it. Lucretia tells you that six mysteries waited for her on Candle Island, and she ticks them off. Then she ends by saying, “Each of them exciting in its own way. But none more interesting than the mystery I took there with me.” Challenge the kid you hand this book to (the kind of kid who doesn’t get scared off by slower realistic titles) to try and figure out what that mystery is as they read the book. Odds are, they’ll get so wrapped up in Ms. Wolk’s writing that they completely forget to search for it. That’s Wolk’s power. The ability to intrigue, enchant, and eventually surprise. A beautiful book that is about art while being art.
Profile Image for Benji Martin.
875 reviews68 followers
April 7, 2025
I'm not on the 2026 Newbery committee, but if I was, we would be talking about this book.
Profile Image for L A.
904 reviews395 followers
September 27, 2025
"A moving portrait of loss and the restorative power of art from Lauren Wolk, the Newbery Honor-winning author of Beyond the Bright Sea."
This middle grade book is written beautifully with descriptive language and a lot of sensory images capturing Candle Island's beauty. The New England setting is home now to Lucy and her mother. Even though she is 12 years old her actions are much older. After losing her father in an accident, she mourns for him daily but finds life in her animals, a horse, goat and an osprey. She finds dangerous behavior that comes with the tourists compared to the islanders. Three wealthy teens (bullies) try to wreak havoc on the island and even though she wants to belong, she remains true to herself. She is mature for her age showing empathy for others and caring for her mother. The author displays the artistic talent in Lucy and her mother, although her mother is reclusive, she is very famous for her artwork. This tender story delivers atmospheric with the rocky coast and ocean breeze makes this very enjoyable for all ages. All of her books deliver emotional and realistic characters that are not easily forgotten. There are some mysteries to be solved as Lucy explores the island, a mysterious boy and a hidden room.
Profile Image for John Gilbert.
1,574 reviews243 followers
July 18, 2025
This is my sixth Lauren Wolk book, and the fifth of hers I've given five stars (the sixth only 4 stars). So I guess I'm a fan, I do indeed love her writing.

Here our MC is Lucretia (Lucy) who is just moving to Candle Island off the coast of Maine, from Vermont, with her mum. Lucy is 12 and both are trying to get a new start. Both love to paint and recently lost their father/husband in an accident because of black ice. This is a classic tale of locals (townies) versus the rich summer people. Lucy starts out as a flatlander (as the outsiders are called, both in Maine and in Vermont) as the locals see her as one of 'them'.

This is a feel good story with surprises, animals (both rescue and domestic), hidden talents, but in the end, the locals getting it over the rich blow ins. Five stars.
Profile Image for Manybooks.
4,097 reviews99 followers
October 24, 2026
In Lauren Wolk’s 2025 middle grade novel Candle Island, twelve year old and first person narrator Lucretia Sanderson’s welcome to the island of the book tile (situated off the coast of Maine and indeed entirely fictional, although Maine of course is not) has not been all that warm and welcoming (to put things mildly), as many of the permanent residents of Candle Island tend to actively resent the elitist full of themselves yachters (tourists) who tie up there for the summer and act like they own the place. And even though in Candle Island Lucretia and her mother Eliza are in fact neither tourists nor part time Candle Island residents, since they are being shown by Wolk’s story and by Lucretia’s narration intending to make Candle Island their permanent home, partly because the mother, because renowned artist Eliza Sanderson (whose paintings have recently been bought by the First Lady) needs somewhere to paint in anonymity (and away from public scrutiny, way from public nosiness) and also because both she and her daughter need a peaceful home by the sea to process their sorrow and their grief regarding the recent death of Lucretia’s father (and Eliza’s husband), they unfortunately so are still approached by the vast majority of Candle Islanders (even if totally erroneously) as being of the same arrogant and at best patronisingly condescending attitude and mindset of the for the most part horridly entitled yacht owners.

But while the negative (and at best majorly reserved) attitude of Candle Island residents is (due to their own personal experiences with full of themselves island tourists) both justifiable and is as such also kind of if not even hugely understandable to a point (well, at least in my humble opinion), sorry, but I personally also tend to think that Lauren Wolk has a trifle frustratingly and unnecessarily massively exaggerated the locals versus tourists conflict and nastiness in Candle Island more than a bit and that there actually often does not even seem to be any legitimate reasons for the intense conflict and for lashing out, unless the mean-spirited Candle Island kids making things so horrible and so uncomfortable for Lucretia are just bored, looking for excitement, and yes, that how cardboard flat and almost fairytale like villainous mean and nasty many of the bullies being textually encountered in Candle Island are presented as being, this has definitely a trifle negatively affected my reading pleasure (both for my inner middle grade reader and probably even more so for adult me).

Furthermore, and indeed why my rating for Candle Island can only be a very low three star rating, yes, this specifically has to do with how the main protagonist, how Lucretia herself appears and acts in Wolk’s story. For one, while much of Candle Island is absolutely beautifully written by Lauren Wolk, with vivid and also with intensely colourful (even artistic) imagery, to and for me (actually to and for us, since adult I and middle grade I collectively agree here) Lucretia’s voice, her first person narration in and throughout Candle Island does not sound and feel like a tween, but more like an adult woman in her twenties or maybe even in her thirties (that she feels far too perceptive for a twelve year old and that this also makes Lucretia Sanderson not really all that much of a true kindred spirit so to speak in Candle Island either, that she seems simply too experienced regarding life itself, too unnaturally old and philosophical for someone of her still pretty tender and young age). And for two, sorry, but the major secret revealed in Candle Island (that it is in fact not her mother Eliza but Lucretia Sanderson herself who is the artist), not only did I kind of suspect this anyhow, but to be honest, it does make in particular adult me quite massively frustrated and even a bit livid that Lucretia needs to be some huge and all-encompassing child prodigy regarding her artistic abilities. For yes indeed, this makes her removed and also kind of seems to say that children who are artistically inclined are somehow only sufficiently interesting to be featured as main characters in a story if they are not just interested in art but are also so advanced and so talented that they are and must be above and beyond everything and everyone else (which I also find to be an issue regarding children’s STEM novels as well, that far too many STEM novels feature socially problematic geniuses), and just to also point out that while I did manage to successfully enough skip and skim over the rather copious (in my opinion at least) examples of animal cruelly encountered in Candle Island, this does also and indeed rub me the wrong proverbial way (and equally so makes me wonder why Wolk would need to include and to have so many examples of this, of animal cruelty in Candle Island, I mean, really, why).

Therefore and especially, how in Candle Island, Lauren Wolk for me, well, for us, needs Lucretia Sanderson to be a child prodigy with regard to painting, with regard to the visual arts, that Wolk sadly cannot just have Lucretia be a typical tween with an interest and a budding and blossoming artistic ability but without being a genius, without being some huge prodigy, how while Candle Island has much that is textually hugely and delightfully enjoyable, there is indeed also much that is verbally frustrating and even rather textually grating (and yes indeed, with that above mentioned child prodigy angle especially being thus in and throughout Candle Island, since it kind of puts Lucretia Sanderson on an unattainable, unrelatable pedestal and makes the visual arts something on a pedestal as well).
Profile Image for Libby.
278 reviews21 followers
May 1, 2025
Lauren W does it again! So much wisdom and beauty in this middle grade book. I’ll need to read it again to catch all the snippets one more time!
Profile Image for Hannah .
282 reviews63 followers
September 18, 2026
You guys are not talking about this book enough! This is literally one of THE MOST fun books I’ve read this year! Our main character Lucy has just moved to Candle Island with her mom following her father’s death. The story follows her as she explores the town and makes friends with the locals.

This book deals with so many heavy topics beautifully. The depiction of grief in this book was one of the best done I’ve seen in a while and that says a lot since this is a middle grade book!

I like can’t recommend this enough! It was so much fun seeing Lucy with her animal friends and how she interacted with the locals.
Profile Image for Jennifer.
1,233 reviews576 followers
Read
June 5, 2025
DNF.

I started this book back in March but got really bogged down in it, set it down, and have had no desire to return to it. Even though I read over 75%, I am not motivated to pick it back up. My biggest issue was that our main character felt too grown up and her mother felt more like the child than the adult in their relationship. I just didn’t find it believable and the bullying also got to be too much for me.
Profile Image for Madeline.
121 reviews9 followers
March 8, 2025
Lauren Wolk knows how to craft a beautiful sentence. She writes in a really lovely, vivid way. I felt invested in this book’s characters and setting (and wanted to spend much more time on Candle Island). I was interested until the end, and I think kids would find this story appealing overall.

But… the credibility. Grieving her dad, twelve-year-old Lucretia moves to fictional Candle Island off the coast of Maine with her mom, who wants to be able to paint in peace. After the First Lady bought one of her paintings, she’s been hounded by art critics wanting an interview.

There’s tension on Candle Island between “townies,” who live there year-round, and “summer people,” and Lucy quickly draws the ire of individuals from both groups. Three truly horrible summer kids target her, and a townie named Murdock immediately dislikes Lucy because Lucy and her mom live in Murdock’s old house, which was seized by the bank. Murdock, whose parents are deceased, is close with her cousin, Bastian, who becomes Lucy’s friend.

There are several threads that come together in this story. First, there’s the osprey chick that Lucy finds and takes home; she plans to care for him until he’s old enough to survive on his own, though she knows that doing so is illegal. There’s the mysterious Italian aria that Lucy hears when she is out exploring. There's a secret about her mom's paintings. And there’s the rash of crimes taking place around the island. These threads all come together in a contrived yet satisfying way.

There is just so much in this novel that is either 1) an incredible coincidence, or 2) simply unrealistic. I suppose I could accept–grudgingly–And of course Lucy finds the missing cat from the posters she sees in town, and naturally it belongs to an art critic who lives on Candle Island and is familiar with her mother's art.

There's also the matter of the remarkable competence and skill of Bastian and Murdock. Everywhere Lucy goes, she runs into one or both of them. She wants to learn how to sail? Bastian can teach her. She spies a lobster boat on the water? Bastian and Murdock are working it. She goes to the library? Murdock volunteers there. She peeks into the forge? There are Murdock and Bastian MAKING BELLS OUT OF MOLTEN BRASS. These kids are twelve. Related to that, Lucy has the emotional maturity of a 30-year-old. The way she talks and reasons and responds to situations… no kid would ever.

On the one hand, I was really invested in this story and enjoyed the writing, and on the other, I felt myself getting more and more incredulous as I read. But perhaps this won't bother young readers at all!
Profile Image for Faith.
586 reviews22 followers
October 19, 2026
It is well written and explores some interesting topics such as dealing with grief and loss, friendship, trust, boundaries, and art, but overall, I just didn't like it very much and I'm not sure why. I read it with my middle grader and he said he liked it, although didn't seem super excited about it and didn't offer any other thoughts about it. It felt a little contrived maybe, I don't know.
Profile Image for DaNae.
2,369 reviews109 followers
June 13, 2025
Sanctimonious and without nuance. I know the writing will be celebrated, but I found most lines so self-aware I could hardly keep my eyes in their sockets. I found the main characters annoying in their moral sureness - so upright and without blemish. Can you tell it pushed all the wrong buttons in me? I’m becoming more and more impatient with tweens who sound more like grown women sharing their agendas. Most of the dialogue and exposition was syrupy and precious. Underneath the platitudes and judgyness the bones of the story were not bad. There is a twist midway through that was well done. I’m sure there will be readers for it. I found myself annoyed with how bad the baddies were and how pure Lucretia and her mother were. I am wondering about the setting. What era did it take place? It seemed contemporary but technology seemed limited to landlines and the most recent book mentioned was published in the 1950s. Maybe it was made clear in a print version, but I could suss it out in the audio.
Profile Image for Jenn.
5,251 reviews75 followers
Read
December 16, 2024
DNF. This writing is good and the story engaging. It's just not for me. Also, the MC is 12, but seems like she's at least 25. 🤷‍♀️
775 reviews7 followers
August 29, 2024
I received an ARC of this book for my honest opinion.

This is my favorite middle-grade book that I have read in a long time. The characters are well-rounded, interesting, and dealing with real troubles at a young age. This is not a book where kids are talked down to but shown how to process their tough emotions and that they can be managed with time. Although two of the characters are dealing with the death of a parent (or for one of them, both parents), their grief is diverse and realistic without this being a downer of a book. The most fun is in the animals, an orphaned osprey chick, family horse, and sweet goat. Wolk writes nature in its full beauty, with the stunning and ugly hand in hand while reminding us that humans are also part of the natural world. I also appreciate the reality of what it is like to live in a place of extreme ruralism and yet also of tourism, holding the latter with a level of respectful responsibility that this is still someone’s home. Lastly, there is a great call to parents on the importance of childhood freedom even, and perhaps more so, if the child has some level of prodigy. A wonderful book for any home or classroom and especially for any kids who are dealing with the loss of a parent or need to be reminded to embrace their childhood.
Profile Image for Shella.
1,221 reviews2 followers
July 3, 2025
This would be a 4.5. I love this author’s writing style. There is not a lot of action/ it is more of a slow burn. This would be a great character study for a book club. If you know a student that has experienced loss or is in the “have not”group, it would be a great relatable title. One part I would change is to give more background story to the kids that were the bullies. There is enough to make an inference- but more in this area would but this up to a five.
Profile Image for Mitzi.
421 reviews55 followers
October 29, 2025
Wow--there was a lot in this middle grade novel: a car accident that left a grieving 12-year-old daughter and a wife; a secret closet; an orphaned osprey chick named 'Gulliver'; a goat named 'Nellie'; a horse named 'Hog'; a mother-daughter secret; a missing painting; ill will between islanders and 'the summer people' and some pretty impressive artistic talents! There's a lot here and Lauren Wolk is such a descriptive and beautiful writer that you feel you're right on Candle Island with the characters. My two favorite quotes:
* "There are two ways of spreading light: to be the candle or the mirror that reflects it".
* "I would not become a better artist because of their praise. Or their complaints. I would become a better painter by painting".
Profile Image for Ms. Yingling.
4,712 reviews659 followers
February 9, 2025
E ARC provided by Edelweiss Plus

Lucretia Sanderson and her mother Eliza move from their home in Vermont to the remote Candle Island in Maine to escape media attention from the mother's artwork, which has recently become very popular. They also are reeling from the car accident death of their father and husband, and need a location without as many memories. They have bought a large, old house that still has many of the previous owners' possessions in it, as well as a barn for Lucretia's horse and a skiff. Lucretia, who is sometimes called Lucy, finds that the local kids consider her a summer person, and the rich, entitled summer kids think she is a local. It doesn't help that Murdock, whose grandfather Big Seb Lucretia meets upon landing on the island, used to live in the house, and had to move because both of her parents died. Lucretia does befriend Bastian, Murdock's cousin, and the two sail and have some adventures with the baby osprey that Lucretia has rescued. Everyone on the island seems to have secrets, and some of these cause big problems. Lucretia would like to befriend Murdock, but when she shares one of her family's secrets, Murdock alerts a reporter visiting the island. The Sandersons have their reasons for keeping these secrets, but maybe it's time to shed some light on them.

Chris Baron described novels in verse as "lyrical explorations of the internal landscape", and that description fits this heart print, prose book very well. Lucretia seems much older than most middle grade characters, and is certain precocious in many ways. Wolk has written several middle grade novels, but this could easily be an adult novel with a younger character. Candle Island reminded me of the work of Nancy Thayer, and will be a big hit with fans of Mary Oliver's work.
Profile Image for Pam  Page.
1,410 reviews
January 4, 2026
This book is a true gem for middle-grade readers. Although Lucretia Mott is a figure from history, she comes alive as the main character in this story—a seriously talented young artist coping with the recent loss of her father. Set on a fictitious island off the coast of Maine, the novel immerses readers through vivid descriptions. I genuinely felt as though I was living on this beautiful island during the three days it took me to read the book. Themes of bullying, synesthesia, grief, and the loss of a parent are thoughtfully woven together to create a unique and emotional story. I also loved the inclusion of the many animals that enter Lucretia’s life, which added warmth and depth to her journey.
Profile Image for Clay.
Author 12 books116 followers
September 28, 2024
This fine middle grade is about a 12YO artistic girl and her famous artist mom moving to the titular island (1960s?) after the much-loved father's accidental death. All they want is to be left alone to grieve in peace and quiet, but the tense vacationer-townie culture, the presence of a persistent art critic, and a helpless (and protected) osprey chick threaten upheaval in their lives. Many secrets are held and revealed; traumas are brought to life and moved toward healing. I only wished the main younger characters had been a couple of years older, say 14. The book and the first person narrative would have been more believable, the big reveal no less a surprise.
Profile Image for Kelly Anderson.
907 reviews15 followers
April 30, 2025
There is something very timeless about Candle Island and the beautifully moving story that Lauren Wolk weaved so seamlessly. If this does not win a Newbery, I will lose hope in all that is good and right in the world.

Wolk pulls you right into the world of Lucretia, a girl who is wise beyond her years, and is starting a new life with her mother on Candle Island.

Lucretia is learning how to deal with grief from losing her father, while also embracing happiness and the many nuances of life. The Islanders are not easy to please or impress, but she is able to find friendship with a boy named Bastian, and purpose, as she saves a young osprey and takes care of her sweet horse named Mahogany (Hog). Most of all, Lucretia and her mother hold tight a secret that, if discovered, could completely shatter their already fragile life.

There are so many important quotes and themes in this story (fighting for what's right, friendship, grief, the loss of a parent, being true to oneself, the importance of community), but this one quote stood out amongst the rest:

"There are two ways of spreading light: to be the candle or the mirror that reflects it."

This book is like a warm hug. A reminder that we can choose how we fight for what's right, and that people can always find connection - they just have to be willing to look for it.

Thank you, Lauren Wolk, for writing this.
Profile Image for Tara Mickela.
1,031 reviews9 followers
August 25, 2025
It is summer and Lucretia and her mother are moving onto an island off the coast of Maine. She is first greeted by a mean islander who snarkily calls her New York to let Lucretia know she doesn’t belong there. But Lucretia and her mother have a secret just like Murdock and other islanders. Lauren Wolk’s character portraits never disappoint.
Profile Image for Meg.
176 reviews4 followers
May 4, 2025
NOTE: GREAT READ-ALOUD OPTION, esp for kids into the arts (painting, music, poetry, writing)

Again Lauren has written such a beautiful story. Her books always incite a longing to move to whatever rural location she has chosen (which for this was an island off the coast of Maine). Also love the characters - a trio of children, each with a pull toward some form of artistic beauty (art, music, poetry) - although they are more than just what they appear on the surface. Meanwhile Wolk again brings in characters who display the evils of bullying, selfishness, and an overall disregard for other lives. While these ones did seems a little stereotypical (selfish rich kids from “the cities” who vacation on the island in the summers and go around in polo shirts and Sperrys), their impact on the story and the development of the main characters is important.
And the storyline with the bird was endearing. 😊
Profile Image for Whitney.
736 reviews48 followers
December 12, 2025
I was incredibly bored. The story is all over the place. The main character lowkey stalks two other kids. The "rich kids" are awful, but the main characters sail and horseback ride and paint and sing opera (all pretty expensive hobbies, last I checked). There is a TON of animal cruelty in this, which I was not a fan of. Yet another book I read for Mock Newbery that was just...what books are adults choosing? What child is sitting through this?

2.5 rounded to a 2. This wasn't it at all.
169 reviews1 follower
February 4, 2026
Aaaaarghhh, so preachy. And can a 12-year-old girl, the main character, be a Mary Sue sounding like she's over 30? Yes, yes, she can.
It could have been a beautiful Ghibli-type of a book. It's pretentious, heavy handed, and fake deep instead.
Profile Image for Lily.
73 reviews8 followers
July 2, 2025
3.75 stars
rtc
Profile Image for Erica.
1,421 reviews32 followers
December 31, 2025
I read it through to the end, but I didn't enjoy it. If you want to know why, be my guest;

One thing I appreciated was Wolk's differentiation between the odious rich families who were mean-spirited and unethical, and the kind, generous, thoughtful, creative rich families who took care to help others and used patience to express themselves clearly.

Lucretia's first-person descriptions, as she walked around the island and sailed on boats, were sensory-rich, specific, and absorbing. Although the jarring sense that 12-year-olds do not think or talk like this never left me, as an adult, I could relate to most of her descriptions. The one (ongoing) exception was the implication that she experiences sounds (as well as some thoughts and feelings) as colors - something I do not experience - which is stated as her truth without any exploration of the significance or uniqueness of it .

I am wondering when I will come across a young reader who enjoys this.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Mary.
958 reviews
August 14, 2025
This book is beautifully written, using gorgeous visual metaphors to capture feelings, environments, and states of mind. I think it expresses how art and nature can heal, but its message is subtle.

As Lucretia’s relationships with islanders develop, we see her healing from the grief that brought her and her mother to this remote spot. Those friendships don’t come easily, and I enjoyed the character development that happens as these relationships grow. There are also interesting insights into why characters act the way they do.

I think my only quibble is one that I have seen in professional reviews: the subplot with the spoiled summer kids doesn’t really add much to the book. But I definitely won’t be surprised if it at least gets a Newbery Honor next year.
Profile Image for Shelagh Jessop.
1 review
August 22, 2026
I did not realize this was a YA book when I picked it up from the staff recommendation table at the library but I'm so glad I did. Even though this book is written for middle schoolers it was so well written and the characters are so well developed, I loved every moment of reading this book.
Profile Image for Amy Warren.
630 reviews18 followers
May 4, 2025
One of my favorite YA authors, Lauren Wolk, has done it again--created the most beautiful story with a very special young lady at the center. Lucretia (Lucy) and her mother move to Candle Island, Maine to recover from the death of her father and the ongoing pressure from the outside world on her privacy. Her books remind me very much of E.B. White with their blend of humans and animals and the natural world. Highly recommend.
Profile Image for Clelia.
93 reviews1 follower
August 25, 2026
This was the most beautiful book I've read in a really really long time ❤️
Profile Image for Elsa Koehler.
35 reviews1 follower
December 13, 2025
Such an amazing read. Very unpredictable, which equals a good book!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 477 reviews