I will give this book five stars, because it's a well-written and passionate defense of Fair Trade from one of the founders of the ethical sourcing/conscious capitalism movement. Paul Rice has done a great job describing the history and background of Fair Trade, what its impacts have been, and what its future may hold. This book should be read by anybody who cares where their coffee comes from, or who simply wants to make the world a better place.
It's not a flawless book, though. Rice bends over backwards to avoid criticizing big corporations such as Walmart, who sell a huge volume of the overall Fair Trade products sold in America, though they make up only a tiny fraction of Walmart's sales and Rice has to be well aware of the massive damage such companies inflict upon small farmers and local communities in our country. I understand that he has to remain on good terms with these corporations, but it still feels like there's a big elephant in the room.
One other minor irritation: virtually every person he quotes in the book is described as his "dear friend", "mentor", "brother", "soulmate", or some other such thing. It got a little tiresome after a while.
Those quibbles aside, I strongly recommend reading this book. You'll be a better-informed consumer after doing so.