If you grew up with 70s and 80s comic books, this is the graphic novel for you. Or, at least it was for me. And obviously Cullen Bunn and Shawn Lee, who seem to have tapped a childhood vein here. The Tooth is a loving homage to that era of comic book storytelling. The Tooth is a... well, a mystical tooth that turns into an evil-smashing monster, complete with a dark backstory steeped in mythology. It's just slightly absurd -- just enough to really cast the stories within through a modern lens. It all works.
And I really have to say something about the design and packaging of the book. Matt Kindt is both artist and designer, and he's created the package of The Tooth to resemble a stack of old comics. Throughout the book there are little bits like D&D style character sheets, a list of back issues that need to be acquired, fake 70s-style ads -- everything to give you not just the time/place that these stories exist in the eyes of the authors, but also creating another layer to the story -- who is this boy, collecting these issues? What role did they play in the era in which they were presumably published?
One of my favorite nuanced bits: There's a missing issue in this volume. There's a note that mentions that issue 37 is "hard to find," and then if you look at the covers that make up each chapter break, issue 37 is actually missing. At the end of the following chapter, there's a letter column in which readers have written in to talk about issue #37, and everything that happened in the issue. It's touches like this that really elevate this book and bring it to The Next Level.
Okay, enough gushing. Seriously, buy this book. So much fun.