I have very mixed feelings about stories that are told through a collection of interconnected short stories. As someone who is hard to please when it comes to short stories, it means my feelings are usually very mixed. However, as I am a fan of Karin Slaughter – and I have also enjoyed some of the authors who contributed to Like a Charm – I decided to give it a try.
Rootbound by Karin Slaughter was a three-star rating. I will be honest and say that this was a rounded up two-point-five-star rating. It did not wow me and was lacking the usual intensity of a Slaughter story, but it did leave me curious about where everything would head. The fact that it set up the rest of the novel in an interesting way was enough to have me rounding my rating up.
Vanitas by Emma Donoghue was a two-star rating. While I liked the idea of this story, I feel the connection to the prior story was not as strong as it could have been. There were some nice elements within, but they were not explored enough to allow me to feel the connection I had hoped to experience.
Cornelius Jubb by Peter Robinson was a three-star rating. This story had more depth to it and did a better job at cementing the storyline together. It was a bleak tale, highlighting the bleakness of the time it was set. While I did not particularly enjoy the story, I did appreciate the way it put a spotlight on the time. It was due to this aspect that I gave it a three-star rating.
Down and Dirty by Fidelis Morgan was a three-star rating. This was a story that grew on me. At first, I was a little uncertain. However, the way the pieces came together was super intriguing. Although it did not add as much to the overall storyline as the prior story, I appreciated the way this tale played out. It felt like a snippet of something much bigger that could be enjoyed without the bigger picture, and I appreciated that. It’s also a story that hit harder than anticipated, which also added to my enjoyment.
The Goblin by Lynda La Plante was a three-star rating. This was a story that packed plenty into the pages, ensuring I was hooked throughout. It pulled me in deeper than expected, and I enjoyed watching the pieces fall into place. I feel this worked well as a powerful standalone story, yet it continued with the theme of the overall storyline not feeling fully connected. In fact, this would work perfectly without the aid of the bracelet due to the main character of this tale.
The Snake Eater by the Numbers by Lee Child was a three-star rating. This was a story that hooked me with ease, pulling me in and leaving me eager for more. While I feel like it was a little too easy – it was clear where things were heading – it was not enough to take away from my enjoyment of the story. Although it linked well with following from where the last story ended, I feel like my understanding of the supernatural element has lessened. Nevertheless, it was an addictive addition to the overall story.
Stroke of Luck by Mark Billingham was a two-star rating. I will admit that this was a story that did grow on me as I worked through it, yet it never really stood out to me in the way I had hoped. There were many elements to this that I wish had been explored in more detail, and the lack of depth meant it ended up being a rather forgettable addition to the collection.
Two Deaths and a Mouthful of Worms by Denise Mina was a two-star rating. There was an interesting idea within the pages of this story, yet I found I was not as sucked into it as I had hoped. I think, in some ways, it felt too much like other stories in this collection. The way things ended was enjoyable and added a nice little punch, yet the overall did not stand out in the way I had hoped.
Favour by John Harvey was a two-star rating. This was another case of the story feeling much the same as the rest of the collection. While I appreciated the slight change of setting, focusing on something more, the overarching storyline was much the same as other stories in the collection. Thus, again, I found it did not stand out in the way I had hoped it would.
Plan B by Kelley Armstrong was a three-star rating. This was a story that easily had me turning the pages, eager to see how the pieces would come together. This focused more on the deceit side of things rather than simply reiterating the same types of violence as the prior stories, which meant it stood out because of the shift in focus. As much as I enjoy the grittiness of the other stories, this shift in focus meant I was able to appreciate other elements of the story as well.
The Inkpot Monkey by John Connolly was a three-star rating. This story offered something different to the prior tales, which meant I was instantly invested. It added a new supernatural element, focusing on the strange rather than simply being a case of the same type of misfortune that seems to be befalling everyone in this collection. It made it stand out, which certainly made it easy to power through.
Acts of Corporal Charity by Jane Haddam was a one-star rating. Unfortunately, this was a story that failed to grab me. In truth, for me, it is the most forgettable of the stories. While I did find it easy to power through, it failed to hit the mark for me.
Not Quite U. by Laura Lippman was a three-star rating. This was an interesting story that focused more on drama than the curse. Due to this, the story stood out and had me powering through it with ease. Although it did not have the level of shock that I had hoped for, it certainly kept me engaged and powering through the pages.
The Things We Did to Lamar by Peter Moore Smith was a three-star rating. This story was more powerful than I anticipated it to be. Although I had wanted a bit more from the ending, the way things played out throughout kept me turning the pages. It hit the mark over and over, ensuring I was gripped on the way the elements were playing out.
The Eastlake School by Jerrilyn Farmer was a two-star rating. In truth, this was a one-point-five-star rating that I decided to round up. The style of the storytelling did not work for me, but I did appreciate how everything came together in the end. It was not as shocking as it could have been, but the closed loop of the story worked well.
The Blessing of Brokenness by Karin Slaughter was a two-star rating. In truth, this was a two-point-five-star rating that I opted to round down. It was interesting to see how the pieces came together and the way it made a small nod to other stories, but it did not hit the mark as a conclusion that I had hoped. While different to the rest, it still left me hoping there had been more.
All in all, as with many short story collections, this was a mixed bag for me. I enjoyed some of these stories much more than others, and I appreciated the overall idea, yet the whole was not quite what I had expected.