Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Song of the Wooden Sparrow

Rate this book
1894-Devastated by the deaths of her husband and son during an epidemic in Ghana, Dr. Leah Maays returns home to Edith's Bay, Maine. Hoping to continue her medical career, she discovers the community is hostile to female doctors.

Enter Duncan Shay. After years of being ostracized for murdering a man while robbing a bank, he's developed a persona that can freeze a glass of water.

Unaware Duncan is shunned, Leah tends to a gouge on his hand as if he's just another regular fellow, making Duncan realize the walls he's built to keep others out are too weak to contain his yearnings to belong.

Though drawn to him, Leah resists Duncan's friendship because she can't establish a practice if she, too, is ostracized. To have Leah in his life, Duncan must convince everyone, including himself, that he's more than the worst thing he's ever done in his life.

The novel explores the machinations of a small, rural community in Maine at the turn of the century just as women were beginning to step out of traditional roles.

326 pages, Kindle Edition

Published September 3, 2024

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Isabel Tutaine

2 books3 followers
Isabel Tutaine writes about ordinary people who summon the courage to take control of their lives. She is Cuban by birth, American by citizenship, Cuban-New Englander by culture. She lives in midcoast Maine where she listens to what the ocean has to say, then runs home to write it down.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
16 (94%)
4 stars
1 (5%)
3 stars
0 (0%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews
Profile Image for Anne.
876 reviews7 followers
May 26, 2025
Delightful book and story. I met the author at a Maine Authors book fair and it sounded good, it was! Lovely story about two people who don't fit in, in their small Maine town in the late 1800's. The author sets a good scene and writes well. Would highly recommend.
17 reviews
October 27, 2024
I loved this book. Isabel's sense of humor definitely came through in her writing. I loved the development of the characters and the research about how women were treated at that time.
There were some laugh out loud moments for sure. I'm hoping she writes a sequel!!
Profile Image for Luanne Oleas.
Author 3 books22 followers
October 17, 2024
When you read Isabel Tutaine's book, Song of the Wooden Sparrow, you don't just get to know the main character, Dr. Leah Maays, and her love interest, Duncan Shay, you experience a village.

Everything about this book enlightens the reader about the culture and manners of the late 1800s in the town of West Edith's Bay, Maine. It's a time when female doctors are dismissed, relationship taboos abound, and community means survival.

When Leah returns from practicing medicine in Africa, she does so without her husband and young son, both of whom died while Leah and her husband tried to save others from illness. The unfairness continues when Leah reaches her old home in Maine. Her uncle and aunt who raised her take her into their home, but don't agree with her behavior, which includes her struggle to keep practicing medicine and her association with the town pariah, Duncan Shay.

Even the local doctor [read: quack] is dismissive. He can't abide a woman practicing medicine and so Leah is forced to see patients in the backroom of the local mercantile—when she isn't waiting on the store's patrons—a job she took to earn enough money to support herself and hopefully open her own practice.

One of her first emergency patients is Duncan Shay, the local cabinetmaker that the town despises for his sordid past. No one speaks to him, but clients in the nearby, larger town of Edith's Bay can't pay enough for the stylish furniture he makes. When he injures his hand at work, Leah offers her services. He's stunned she even speaks to him and relents to receive treatment from her. It starts them both down a path that the rest of the town can't wait to gossip about and condemn.

The time period is expressed well through each character. There are the Hoburns, the husband-and-wife owners of the mercantile. Leah's aunt and uncle, Martha and Utterance, own the local apple orchard. Henry Moore, the postmaster also deigns to befriend Duncan and accepts Leah as a medical professional. There is also the stuck-up elite woman of the town who controls everyone by threatening to withhold funds that keeps the roof over the local church.

Amazingly presented are the customs of the time. They range from what's appropriate at a local dance (including who you dance with and what you wear) as well as the penal system procedures which Duncan has experienced. What is presented vividly is how achingly slow it is to try and change long-held customs and beliefs. Simply holding hands is enough to get someone shunned. Speaking to the wrong person in the wrong way could well get you thrown out of town. So much pressure is exerted by the community to keep people on the straight and narrow, it's a wonder anyone had a relationship at all.... let alone enjoy one.

I found this title both enlightening and engaging. I'd love to see a sequel.

Profile Image for MaryAnn Shank.
Author 5 books2 followers
September 9, 2024
THE SONG OF THE WOODEN SPARROW speaks to us gently about the nature of loss, the meaning of trust, how to grow your persona when fingers point wickedly at you.

The story is set in the 17th century, but is as real as yesterday, or tomorrow. A young woman, a doctor, loses her husband and her son to an epidemic while working in Africa. As she struggles to establish her credentials in her home town in the United States, she faces fierce opposition from the local doctor. And she falls in love with a local master carpenter, a convicted murderer.

The characters are wonderfully quirky, just like your next door neighbors. The details of the town, her life, her family are all spot on, bringing even proud, condescending people to life.

For those who enjoy historical romance, this is a splendid read.
Profile Image for Deanna Milford.
800 reviews1 follower
August 8, 2025
The only disappointment I had was when this beautiful story was over. This Historical Fiction from the late 1800’s was centered around the town of Edith’s Bay, Maine. It followed a female Doctor who returned home from practicing in Ghana treating a deadly unknown plague. Dealing with her own tragedies she meets Duncan who has his own past that the people have not let him forget. How this story was done was so unique. Each chapter had its own stories told about the towns people and peeling back the layers of the main characters as they get to know each other. There was drama as well as a little comedy. A truly enjoyable read. Will be watching for more from this author.
Profile Image for Laura Bonazzoli.
Author 3 books4 followers
January 19, 2025
I don't usually read historical romance, or romance of any kind, but I heard this author at a reading and decided to try her novel. I'm glad I did, as it was a delightful read. It reminded me of a book that Jane Austen would have written if she'd lived in the late 19th century in Maine: a love story with lessons of redemption and grace. The characters and situations reveal the author's wit as well as her wisdom, and although the plot is unsurprising, the incidents move the story briskly along to its heartwarming conclusion.
Profile Image for Tree Tree.
1 review
November 19, 2024
I've read this book twice now because I loved it so much. The writing is exquisite and the characters stay with you. I was hooked watching these two outcasts find themselves and their places in society and life while falling for one another. You know when you read a story and you fall in love right along with/ as the characters do? Yeah...that's this book. Leah and Duncan touched my heart deeply. I know it will touch yours too.
Profile Image for LORAINE JANELLE.
2 reviews
September 16, 2024
I have just finished the first three chapters and have to say this a refreshing read for me. It's been years since I've read fiction and love Isabel Tutaine's style!

Her wonderful use of similes and metaphors create a vivid picture while moving the story along at a steady pace. I can see the characters clearly...
1 review
April 24, 2025
I loved the book!

This book was lots of fun to read. I fell in love with the characters, especially Duncan. What an interesting and complex character he is! Very skillful writing. I, reader, I was taken to deeper levels without even realizing it.
Profile Image for Tycelia.
77 reviews7 followers
April 6, 2026
Beautifully written with careful plot development and wonderful , original characters - passages of insight and humor. Highly recommend Song of the Wooden Sparrow!
Profile Image for Suanne.
Author 10 books1,009 followers
April 28, 2025
After a tropical disease kills her infant son and husband in Ghana in 1894, Dr. Leah Maays returns to her hometown. In Edith’s Bay, Maine, Leah moves in with her aunt and uncle, Martha and Utterance, owners of a local apple orchard. Martha is as uptight as they come, though Utterance is more easy going. Their attitudes toward their niece as a female physician fully reflect those of the village.
In Edith’s Bay, Leah meets Duncan Shay, a cabinet maker who is shunned because of his sordid past. He is her first patient, appearing the moment she arrives in town, with a gouge to his hand, which she successfully treats. Later, she tries to establish a medical practice but is obstructed both by the mores of the town and the objections of the local quack.
The prose in Song of the Wooden Sparrow is spare and in keeping with the late 19th century as are the descriptions of customs that seem far too strait-laced in this day and age. The sexual tension between Leah and Duncan is restrained yet blazing. As a physician, I can attest that Tutaine does a great job capturing the treatment of women physicians that persists to this day. This book is a lovely look at prejudice on many levels, yet is also about goodness and redemption. Loved reading it.
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews