Before I start the review proper, I would like to warn prospective reader to please ignore the synopsis. It is misleading. There are no real mentions that the Wests don’t “join backyard barbecues”, or that they don’t open the door. That’s not mentioned anywhere in this story. In fact, the Wests are portrayed like any normal family. A couple, two kids. And, one day, the day of this story, something goes tremendously wrong and, yes, the door to their house won’t open. But you read the synopsis and you get a whole different idea of what this book is about. And it’s not just about the Wests, as the synopsis hints at. There’s also Gladys, the neighbourhood busybody, who has to deal with her husband’s Parkinson’s disease, and Logan, the delivery man, someone with a violent past.
It was difficult to enjoy the story because what’s happening at the Wests’s is horrible to read and because Trope manipulates the story in such a way that we are lead to think in a certain way, that make the whole thing even worse. The level of manipulation is really high on this one, but I still felt it took a long time to reach the point where we understand what is going on. I was getting upset with what was happening at the West’s house, and I was also a bit lost with Logan’s point of view, as I couldn’t see what could possibly be the connection with everything else. Even Gladys’s POV wasn’t that great; I didn’t like her interactions with her husband Lou.
The fact that we’ve got four different POVs didn’t work that well, as well, in my opinion. Two of them describe what is happening inside the Wests’s house and are full of tension, anger and danger. They’re nerve-wrecking. But the other two, especially in the beginning, are the opposite. So, we jump from a scene filled with tension to one quite sedated in comparison. I thought this was quite tiring, and it made me want to rush through the story.
I was going to rate it 2 stars but the twist was unexpected and I feel I have to admit it: Nicole Trope is strong in the manipulation game. Still, I don’t think this deserves the four stars. For me, the revelation moment wasn’t a jaw-dropping one, and it took me a moment to understand what I was reading, and what that meant to the story, especially considering everything that had happened so far.
Right now, it’s hard to tell if I will pick up another Nicole Trope book. It’s possible I’ll give her another chance in the future.