Stephen Hudson fell in love with the girl next door when he was six years old.
She was his best friend and all his favorite firsts.
She was his everything, and for as long as he can remember he has always put her first.
And when she left him at eighteen with nothing but a note, he did what he always did—put her first, even though it broke his heart.
Dottie Lynn Hart has a love and hate relationship with LA.
The glamour’s gone, her career’s lost its sparkle, and she’s lonelier than she’ll admit. So when her best friend drags her back to Fox Hole, Tennessee for the holidays, she runs out of excuses…and right into the past she’s been avoiding.
And Dottie can’t seem to tamp down the niggling curiosity in her brain that wants to know what might happen if she looks into the eyes of the boy she left behind when she was younger one more time.
Emily Shacklette is an avid reader, Swiftie and cat lady. She loves romantic tension and spice that lasts for pages. She currently resides in the heart of beautiful San Francisco with her husband and Olive, Punky, and Chicken (her cat children). When she's not reading or writing, you can find her watching Community, riding her Peloton, or listening to Taylor Swift as loudly as the volume will go. Find her on Instagram (@authoremilyshack) and TikTok (@authoremilyshaack). authoremilyshack.com
𝐌𝐲 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬 ↴ First time reader of Emily Shacklette and I’m hoping to find a better book from her in the future. Though this was a cute read it wasn’t a favorite which sucks for me. The spice was spicing though and Dottie was doing the damn thing and y’all… HE WHIMPERS!!!! That gets a bonus point. This book does go between the past and the present so keep that in mind. Chapters based on the past were labeled with the age of whose POV it was and the chapters that went back to the present weren’t labeled. I did like the ending and I loved the two epilogues that were included!
𝐃𝐢𝐬𝐜𝐥𝐚𝐢𝐦𝐞𝐫 ↴ This is an Advanced Reader copy. Although this book was given to me as an ARC my thoughts are my own. Thank you to Emily Shacklette and Truly Yours PR for the ARC opportunity!
𝐖𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐓𝐨 𝐄𝐱𝐩𝐞𝐜𝐭 ↴ ✨ Small Town(ish) 💜 Dual Timelines ✨ Second Chance 💜 She’s A Flight Risk ✨ “It’s Always Been You” 💜 Accidental-on-Purpose Celibacy ✨ He’s a Golden Retriever with a Golden Retriever 💜 Childhood Best Friends to High School Sweethearts
This was such a cute book!! I loved the writing style and the dual POVs! I loved all the flirting banter between the girls in this book!! It had me laughing out loud at some parts! Very romantic feel! Loved the ending
I'm not fine! I'm definitely NOT fine! And I don't know how to find words. This book... It's. Yes, it is. That's it. It just is.
God, Stephen 😍 He is sooo wonderful 😍 First, he is a dog dad. Give me a dog dad and I'm already half done 🥵 But he doesn't just have a golden retriever, he IS a golden retriever himself. He is no billionaire or millionaire, but he has a heart worth that's invaluable. It's soooo huge. He fell in love with Dottie... no sorry he fell in love with Dorothea, when he was 7 years old and didn't realize it until he was a teen. Honestly, how cute is that???? 🥰 He and Dottie were inseparable as kids. But when they were 18... I just say they "break up" 😭
I didn't understand it. I just didn't. Until I did and it broke my heart 💔 For both of them.
Dottie seems like a strong woman. She is a model, an influencer, and a DJ. She lives alone in LA. But on the inside, she isn't that strong 😞 At least she has her friends the "P*ssy Posse". But they are all in San Francisco...
As I said, I have massive problems finding the right words. I'm still crying because it's so emotional. But the book is also VERY funny. I laughed at least the same amount of times as I cried 😎
I love the strong friendship between Dottie and Kira. And I can't wait to read the final book with Kira's story. Oh, I think that will be really crazy. Kira is crazy. I don't think there is another word that can describe her better 🙈 I loved how Kira's dads (yes she has two dads) welcomed Dottie back. Because of Dottie's horrible childhood, the McKennas were like her second (better) family. Nearly the same as Stephen's family 🩷
And sure as hell, James gets his appearance. Honestly, how freaking crazy is this scene??? 🙈 You don't know who James is? Ooooh 😯 Then you need to read book one in this series! Instantly! You don't want to miss him. And then you can go to this book. After you read book 2 😉 You won't regret it. The men in this series are 🥵🥵🥵 I'm really not sure how man no 4 will stand against these 3 other men... 🙈 But better how he can stand Kira 🤣🤣🤣
Dottie Lynn Hart ran from abusive neglectful mother in Fox Hole, Tennessee when she was 18. In her quest to make a life for herself away from that pain, she left behind the one person her heart never let go of. Stephen Hudson fell in love with his Dorothea when they were both too young to really know what love was, and when she fled their hometown to save herself the day after they had finally admitted what they were to each other, he stayed behind. Now nine years have passed, and Dorothea is finally coming home for the holidays. ‘Tis the damn season. This book was a balm to my soul. It sounds dramatic, but that’s the way it felt this week when I finished it. I had been feeling like hope was in short supply, and this was a lovely reminder that there is still beauty in art and in people. I have previously read another of Emily Shacklette’s books (The Brotherly Shove) and absolutely loved it. I had high hopes coming into When We Were Younger, and it was even better than I imagined. The journey this story will take you on is wistful, melancholy, inspirational, aspirational (we all need a pussy posse), and damn sexy. Swifties will notice tons of easter eggs and sly winks from Emily throughout the book that while they won’t make you feel like you’re missing something if you don’t get them, feel like an inside joke from a friend who wrote this story just for you. So go ahead, grab yourself a peppermint white hot chocolate and settle in for a great time. Thank you so much to Truly Yours PR and Emily Shacklette for the ARC opportunity!
This book was given to me as an eARC, but my opinion is honest. Thank you so much for the opportunity.
This was my first time reading Emily Shacklette's work and I gotta say that I liked her writing.
Overall I think it was a cute book and it was an easy and fast read. Loved the fact that has a double POV. I loved the second chance story, how they re-live their past, while building a future together. It gave us some back information about their relationship.
However, there were somethings that I didn't understand/liked: - I didn’t understand Dottie's true reasons to why she left the way she did. I understand that what happened to her was really bad and that she had enough of living in that situation, but why leave just a note and not explaining? Stephen didn't do anything to hurt her and he could actually have helped her if she had let him.
- I was kinda expecting that Stephen would've been a little more mad or hurt for the way that Dottie left, but he just accepts her with arms wide open and she doesn't have to grovel, not even a little bit.
I binged this book so hard. I love everything about it! As a Swiftie, I appreciated seeing Stephen and Dorothea come to life. Stephen is such a sweet caring golden retriever. I also love that he has a man bun and is a dog dad. Dorothea has been through a lot growing up and I loved seeing her stop running and embracing her love with Stephen. Kira and her Dads are the absolute best! I love their family relationship as well as how they are with Dorothea. I want to join their family!
Read this book if: you’re a Swiftie, you love a golden retriever MMC, you love a second chance romance, you love a happily ever after, you love a sassy girl gang.
Thank you to Truly Yours PR and marketing and Emily Shacklette for the opportunity to read and review this ARC copy.
I was not prepared for this book to put me through the ringer. My heart was not ok most of the story, but Emily did put it back together, thankfully! This book was a great read and I didn’t want to put it down. The journey our MCs go through is one readers become invested quickly and the now and then storyline is beautifully written. I loved seeing these two grow up together and go through so much together.
Stephen is a wonderful man! He is a dog dad, which you already know is a good sign. Even more, he himself is a golden retriever. He has such a huge heart and gives of himself to everyone. He has loved Dottie since he was a kid, but didnt’ even admit it to himself until his teens. As they navigate childhood and young adulthood, you think they will be together forever. When high school ends though, life has other plans.
Dottie has always dreamed of more out of life. On the outside her life looks amazing. She lives in LA; a model, influencer, and a DJ; but take a closer look and she is lonely. Even her closest friends aren’t nearby, but in San Francisco. She did not have an easy childhood, Stephen being one of the only consistent presences, she doesn’t open up easily. Going home to visit isn’t an easy decision, but overall she is glad she does.
Emily takes us on a beautiful journey of the innocence of childhood, to the muddied waters of young adulthood, to the sheer craziness that is adulthood. Reminding us of the importance of having people you can lean on, believing in yourself, and it’s ok to not be ok. I loved watching Stephen be there for Dottie, even after everything that has happened. With one more storyline to complete this interconnected series, I am excited to see what Emily has in store for her readers next.
As always, review any author notes before reading.
Tropes: ✨ Small Town 💜 Dual Timelines ✨ Second Chance 💜 She’s A Flight Risk ✨ “It’s Always Been You” 💜 Golden Retriever ✨ Childhood Besties to Lovers
💜Second Chance 🌌Dual Timeline 💜Childhood Friends to High School Sweethearts 🌌It’s Always (only) Been You 💜Small Town (sort of) 🌌He’s a Golden Retriever, She’s a Bolter
Seriously, if Emily writes it, I will read it!! I love how Taylor Swidt coded (most of) Emily’s books are but this is the most TS-coded by far and I could not get enough! I make. I make no apologies for the pleasure this brings me. More than half of my highlights are TS related 💁🏻♀️🫶🏼. There will be Taylor Swift songs that will make me think of Dottie and Stephen now (besides the obvious!).
This final 1/3 of this book had me bawling and I continued randomly afterword. That is the feeling I love about reading, how immerse you become in the book and feelings it depicts and invokes. Stephen was perfect! Swoony, sweet, understanding, accepting, forgiving, and so in love. I love “my girl” moments and vibes and he had this but it was him wanting to be her man that got me. Also the”good boy” moments were so 😏😏!
Dottie broke my heart! The parental indifference, neglect, and emotional abuse gutted me. This makes her being “bolter”/flight risk understandable, I only hurt for her and was never mad or even irked at her for it.
Even though she was reluctant to come “home” to visit, Dottie sure was enjoying the “home-cumming”🤭. You can say this book was a slow-burn but only because it was dual timeline. This may be Emily’s least spicy book compared to her others but it was still so freaking hot. 🥵 Sometimes a book of lovemaking can get boring but that was not the case here because even though every intimate scene was sweet and emotional, it was making me sweat…and more!
I loved all the Kira, Rachel and Am, Daisy May and GEORGIE and JAMES content! It was absolute PERFECTION!!! I cannot wait for Kira, the last single girl of the Pu$$¥ Posse, to get her story! She is a right and her book will be so insane!!
“You’re my best friend, my girl, and sometimes when I think about how much you mean to me, it’s overwhelming.”
I truly loved Dottie and Stephen’s story. It was a very quick read (I almost didn’t take a break while reading it), though not short, with very endearing characters. I had the best of times. I loved the second chance story, how they re-live their past, while building a future together. The flashbacks, especially, are amazing, and soothing. However, if it makes sense during the aforementioned flashbacks, or while making a reference to their teenage years, I found there are too many references to pop culture. It feels like they haven’t grown up, that they are stuck in their past –and it, in my opinion, lessens (a little) the effect of the second chance story (they don’t love each other, even though they are adults, because they never truly changed). (possible spoilers) Also, but that’s on me, I didn’t understand the conflict resolution when it comes to Dottie, or her reasons as an adult. It lacked a bit of adult communication. I liked, however, that for once the guy is the one who will change his life, even though I would have liked to see how he’ll adjust, as all the book was written where he lives –and has lived all his life. (end of possible spoilers) Despite these points of details, I spent a great time with When We Were Younger, loved the little holidays vibes, I would recommend it to you if you are looking to an easy read, steamy and with loveable characters (or if you love Taylor Swift).
Thank you Emily Shacklette and Truly Yours for the ARC. My opinions are my own.
I am telling you right now I will never be over this book. I wanted the pages to last forever and I intentionally took my time reading so I could linger on every word. I previously read Emily’s The Brotherly Shove so I knew I would love this book and it definitely did not disappoint!
Stephen and Dorothea are childhood friends to teenage lovers. They spend so many years together and then something happens that causes Dorothea to flee to California. She returns with her friend during the holiday season and ends up getting tangled up with Stephen. You’ll have to read to find out what happens next! 💓
Dorothea, or Dottie as she’s sometimes known, was so cute and relatable. I honestly felt so much emotion towards her character after hearing all she had been through. She had the best found family with the posse and with Kira and Stephen’s families. I was so happy to see her find happiness by the end of the book! 🍩
Stephen was precious. I felt he had so many fears and self doubt and was able to overcome them by the end of the book to embrace love. His best pal, Daisy May, was absolutely adorable and the coolest golden retriever I’ve ever read about! I loved how he was willing to give Dottie space yet show up for her when needed!
You absolutely NEED to read this book! I loved it! 😍
𝘞𝘩𝘦𝘯 𝘞𝘦 𝘞𝘦𝘳𝘦 𝘠𝘰𝘶𝘯𝘨𝘦𝘳 by Emily Shacklette is a heartwarming second-chance romance about two childhood friends turned lovers. After Dorothea "Dottie" Lynn Hart leaves Tennessee without warning to start her life as an influencer in LA, Stephen Hudson lets her go, even though it destroys him. Dottie returns to her small hometown for the holidays after being away for nine years, and the sparks between them reignite as they navigate old wounds and new feelings.
Dottie’s journey was everything. Watching her deal with her past and figure out what she really wants was so relatable. I loved reading her and Stephen’s love story! The dual timeline was perfect! It gave just the right mix of sweet flashbacks and present-day tension. The childhood friends-to-lovers trope was done so well, and the small-town holiday vibes made it feel extra cozy. I couldn’t put it down!
Overall, I highly recommend reading 𝘞𝘩𝘦𝘯 𝘞𝘦 𝘞𝘦𝘳𝘦 𝘠𝘰𝘶𝘯𝘨𝘦𝘳 if you’re a fan of second-chance romance, childhood friends-to-lovers, and small-town feels! It’s such a beautiful story and a great pick for anyone who loves nostalgic vibes and heartwarming holiday moments.
Thank you to TrulyYours PR and the author for the advanced copy of this book.
This is a series, but I read this as a standalone and am hooked on these characters. From the female friendships to the gay parental figures that took Dorothea in, each character adds dimension and humor to the town and the story.
This is a second chance, childhood friends to lovers, and found family. After 9 years apart, Stephen and Dorothea find themselves facing their past, and each other, when Dorothea returns home for the holidays. Old feelings resurface and they find themselves starting back to where they left off.
This book is spicy with the last 1/4 of the book being a repetitive sex scene. I'm not mad about it as the characters had some catching up to do.
I do wish with there had been more backstory and conflict regarding Dorothea's leaving. Stephen's love for her was unwavering despite her attempt to run away with nothing more than a few sentences written on a scrap piece of paper. I would have liked more angst and buildup with their reconciliation.
Overall, I would recommend for anyone looking for a straightforward book featuring second chance and lots of spice.
I could never pick a favorite of this series (of definite standalones) because Emily tackles new tropes full of angst and romance with so much care and also humor.
So we have 2 high school sweethearts turned estranged for like 10 years until Dottie goes back to her small town for the holidays and like fate runs right into her ex. And they haven’t been with anyone else in the intervening years which brings me the upmost peace.
I love the backdrop of the holidays happening around them in the present time with just enough dual timeline chapters to explain what went so right then so wrong as they grew up together. Emily’s dual timelines are always the best because you always feel so grounded in the present and the context is actually important/helpful for whenever you do go back to the past (you see this in Brotherly Shove as well).
The spice in this is so good. They are simply soulmates. And I love the tis the d*mn season angsty vibes of wondering when one could bolt or when it could all just fall apart.
Overall I loved this so much. Thank you to truly yours PR and the author for the eARC!
Dottie returning to her hometown after becoming a successful model in L.A. was a reluctant move. She’d move from there with her friend to get away from bad memories and leave her past behind. But the chemistry she had with Stephen when she was a teen is still there when she sees him as a grown man. And despite denying things couldn’t work out, there was just so much of their past that they shared. The fact that he knew he loved her since he was a boy amazed me. Talk about he falls for her! And it never changed when Stephen sees Dottie back home for the holidays after so long and, Dottie assumed he moved on with a family and everything. This kinda had Hallmark vibes to me a little. Dottie having been gone for a while she doesn’t know what to do at first but Stephen kinda just wants to pick up where they left off. It’s sweet and wonderful, working well with dual POV and all the supporting characters. The flow was very good. If this was to be played out on the screen, I would love to see that happen. While this was a book 3, it can he read as a stand-alone. But, now having read it, I need the other 2!
When We Were Younger completely wrecked me in the best way. I am OBSESSED with Dottie and Stephen and their love story. I adored how we went from past to present and got to see the parallels between those moments. It was the cutest second chance romance!
The love between these characters is so beautiful, and I love the added trope of found family for Dottie. While she has the gift of Stephen’s family, she also has the beautiful friendships with her girls that carry her through. It really speaks to the power of healthy female friendship and how it helps every aspect of a woman’s life.
I’m a huge fan of the beautiful character development that Emily Shacklette does. Dottie and Stephen are surrounded by a plethora of characters that all manage to be completely unique and interesting. I’m dying to go back and read Georgia and Rachel’s stories now, and I cannot wait for Kira’s book If I Catch You next spring.
I voluntarily reviewed a free advance copy of this book provided by the author. The opinions expressed are my own.
This book was really cute and the characters totally grew on me. I couldn’t help but feel bad for Dottie. She grew up in a household with an abusive and neglectful mother and her only way out was to leave town once she turned 18. She left nothing behind but a note for her best friend Stephen.
Fast forward 10 years later and she is back in Fox Hole, TN to spend Christmas with her best friends family. While at the store, she runs into Stephen and it is as if they were able to pick back up where they left off.
The two of them spend time together and Stephen finds out the real reason why she left and Dottie realizes why Stephen didn’t chase her all those years ago.
I loved watching their relationship grow and the dual timelines really helped pull this story together.
Thank you to @trulyyours.pr and @authoremilyshack for sending me an early e-copy of this book. This was my first book by Emily and it won’t be my last ✨
This book is INCREDIBLE! This story is so beautiful and so sweet! Dottie was such a beautiful FMC, and her journey to self acceptance and what she wants in her life was so raw and real to watch. I just wanted to reach into the book and wrap her up in a blanket! And Stephen was so swoony and such a wonderful gentleman! The way he was supportive of Dottie and helped her ease into what she needed and wanted was just so sweet! And getting to see these side characters again was so much fun!! I'd do some sketchy things for a night with the McKenna family!! I cannot wait for the next book!! Emily Shacklette is now solidly in my list of auto-read authors!! 4.75 stars; 3.5 chili peppers
Tropes: - Childhood Friends to Lovers - Small Town - Dual Timeline - Flight Risk FMC - Second Chance
After almost a decade of leaving Fox Hole, Tennessee behind, Dottie finally returns for a holiday thanks to her best friend Kira. Before she left, she broke Stephen’s heart. Stephen was her childhood friend, her best friend, before they became more.
Now that she is back in town, Stephen goes all out to win her back. He is such a cinnamon roll, and I loved how much of a gentleman he is. But can Dottie overcome her doubts due to her past and accept how loved she is? Read this to find out.
I have always loved the found family trope and in this book, my favourite scene was the one between Mrs Hudson and Dottie. My heart broke for her whenever we see flashbacks from her childhood. Thank God for the Hudsons and for Kira and the McKenna family.
The ending was such a sweet one and the perfect way to start a new phase of life together. I can’t wait for Kira’s story!
What a sweet, though sometimes heart wrenching story! This is my first book by Emily — and Inso enjoyed her writing style, bouncing back and forth not only between POVs but also timelines so we can see what happened to our MCs in childhood and as teens to bring them where they are today.
💜 Second chance/ “it’s always been you” vibes 💙 Childhood besties to lovers to strangers to…😉 💜 Golden retriever MMC 💙 Dual Timeline 💜 Found family/girl gang 💙 Note: mention of mostly emotional abuse by FMCs mom in the past
I love a small town romance and this one was no exception. It was sweet, swoony, and spicy — wrapped up in a story of second chance love between the most doting, loyal Stephen, and the one who got away (lots of trauma to unpack for our girl Dottie).
You can’t help but root for these two to find their HEA - and you’ll enjoy the journey to get there, without a doubt.
Thanks to Emily and Truly Yours PR for the chance to read this one in advance!
First I would like to thank the author for allowing me to read this amazing story!
Let’s get into this review, the story follows the troubles of Miss Dottie Lynn and Mr Stephen Hudson, who where boy/girl next door, where he falls hard, when they turn 18 Dottie flees leaving Mr Stephen alone I ma little town, with out going further and ruining this story,here are my thoughts on it, NOW did I absolutely cry my eyes out while reading this book, yes I did, I feel for the characters and I felt horrible when it came to Dotties upbringing, and the way it effected her love life with not just her friends, but the only boy shes ever loved, like ARE YOU KIDDING ME!!!
this book is a blend of spice and comedy, now dont get me wrong, I did cry, but doesnt mean i wasn’t laughing at a lot too!
i loved this book so much! the writing was so fun and i really loved both main characters a ton. and her best friend’s family are the best found family i’ve read about in a while. i don’t usually gravitate towards second chance romance cause a lot of the time i am stressed about the initial breakup but this one was so well thought out. the parental trauma in the story was so heavy but not gratuitous at all.
stephen is the perfect book boyfriend and is not only a golden retriever, but also has one!!! dottie is a great FMC and i appreciate that she’s great at standing up for herself.
the holiday vibes are so sweet and i seriously picked the perfect time to read it because it’s nice and chilly. also a big fan of all the 1D references throughout LOL
thank you so much emily (and truly yours PR) for the ARC of your novel and i truly loved it!!!
What a cute read! This mmc was soooo in love with the fmc at times it seemed like he loved her a lot more than she loved him however I think that just has to do with her upbringing (without spoiling anything) The mmc is a dog dad and his pup is adorable! There was such a strong bond between the fmc and her friendship group. The fmc went through a lot in her childhood and made her life a success in spite of it. Please check your triggers.
❤️ childhood friends to high school sweethearts ❤️ Second chance ❤️ She’s a flight risk ❤️ Accidental-on-purpose celibacy ❤️ Dual timeline ❤️ Braiding his hair ❤️ Golden retriever mmc with a golden retriever (dog dad) ❤️ It’s always been you ❤️ Found family
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 🌶️🌶️.5 Thank you Truly yours PR & Emily Shacklette for the ARC 💋
These two crazy kids 🥹 Gosh I love a small town, cozy, CHRISTMAS romance. It just does something to me. This was so swoon worthy and just fantastically written. The tears I shed for these two was absolutely unexpected. So many heartwarming moments between friends and family. I just cannot get over this. It was so great! This is a stand alone series, book 3! I NEED to go back and read the first 2 while I patiently wait for book 4 in the spring! 💙 Tropes: 💜 Second Chance 💙 Childhood Best Friends to HS Sweethearts 💜 Small Town 💙 Dual Timeline 💜 Accidental-On-Purpose Celibacy 💙 “It’s Always Been You” 💜 She’s A Flight Risk 💙 He’s A Golden Retriever WITH A Golden Retriever
Oh, this was such an adorable book. The friendship was everything and the romance that kept building, top notch.
Despite this having some type of sadness, it was such a nice story. I still can’t believe some background information that was given. It made this sad, but would come back to it being romantic and the spice did not disappoint. It wasn’t overly done, it was just perfect for the type of story it was for.
I loved the back and forth from their teens to the presence.
It, also, felt like a nice cozy book. Loved it all. The ending was just what I was looking for. If it would have ended any other way, I would have been broken.
While Reading this book, I came to the conclusion that this is the story of "Dorothea" by Taylor Swift. I loved every little detail like lyrics being successfully woven into the story to create this extraordinary backstory of Dorothea who had to leave town, but still thinks about the people she left behind. As well as people at home always waiting for her to come back to their side. These annotations are so well placed and executed that every Taylor Swift listener will have a blast recognizing all the references but still subtle enough for everyone else to read above them and enjoy a perfectly good story.
I adored When We Were Younger by Emily Shacklette. If you’re a fan of Better Than The Movies and Nothing Like The Movies, but wanted more spice, this one is for you!
When We Were Younger follows the story of FMC Dorothea (Dottie Lynn) and MMC Stephen as adults, told in dual POV with flashback chapters to their childhood and teenage years.
Dottie Lynn appears to have it all; success as an influencer/model, a great group of girlfriends (the Pussy Posse) and a beachfront house in Malibu. Sadly she had a very troubled childhood, neglected by an alcoholic mother who never wanted her. The second she’s able to leave Fox Hole, Tennessee, she’s out of there. Even though it means leaving behind her high school sweetheart Stephen, she doesn’t look back.
Almost 10 years have passed since she left, when she reluctantly agrees to return to her hometown with bestie Kira, praying she doesn’t run into Stephen while she’s there. She’s still not over him or the fact she broke his heart. Guess who the first person she runs into is?
Stephen is now a tall, buff, bearded man, working in construction with his father. He’s a golden retriever with a golden retriever! How can she resist this man who is still pining for her?
What follows is a story of second chance love and found family. The flashbacks of them meeting at the age of 7 and becoming best friends are lovely yet heartbreaking. The stories of them discovering they like each other more than friends as young teenagers, then progressing into high school sweethearts are sweet and told in an age appropriate way. While the chapters of them set in the current day are full of longing, rediscovery and spice.
Dottie Lynn has absolutely no intention of staying in Fox Hole, but leaving would mean breaking both her’s and Stephen’s hearts all over again. I’m not going to spoil it for you. This one is well worth the read. The fact it’s set at Christmas time is a bonus.
ARC Review When We Were Younger was such a great read. I love a fantastic second chance romance and "it's always been you" story. Plus the found family between the girls is the best. They are so supportive of each other. Stephen was the best book boyfriend. So loving and supportive. Dottie left her small Tennessee hometown for LA almost a decade ago. Leaving the love of her life Stephen. They both never got over each other. When she finally comes back to town, it's as if they were never apart but Stephen knows Dottie will leave again. Can he show her just how much she means to him?
I ended up reading this as a standalone, but I'm definitely going to be reading the rest of the series. This is one of those books that deserves all the stars, and I'll be recommending this one to all my reading buddies! I literally couldn't get enough of these two, and the author's writing was incredible! I felt so bad for Dottie, and I'm so happy things ended up working out for her. Stephen is a great character, and he made the story so enjoyable!
Thanks so much to the author and Truly Yours Pr for the ARC!
[ARC] It's official: Emily Shacklette is now on my autobuy list and favourite contemporary romance author 👑
This second chance romance is coming out at the perfect time, set during the holidays. It's spicy, heartbreaking, funny, and sweet.
I love the Pussy Posse and would love to have them as friends. Stephen is the perfect balance to Dottie's chaos. Can't wait until Kira finally gets her happily ever after (or gets to take James' private jet)!
this book. oh my god. i was laughing one second and crying the next. a beautifully written story that deals with real life and all the highs & lows that come with it. the relationship between dottie and stephen was everything. the banter was everything. the friend group was everything. and do not get me started on the one direction references. no notes. 5 stars. thank you to emily shacklette and truly yours PR for this advanced readers copy. out today!!!!