This cosmic thrill ride doesn’t let you catch your breath. The pacing is relentless, whether it is launching characters into trans-dimensional uncertainty or assaulting an armata of enemy ships. I think the world-building is maybe what ended up being the most effective part of this story for me, especially as I was doubtful of it at first. Set in the not-especially-distant future but with (almost inconceivably) advanced tech, the story is able to ground itself in contemporary cultural references without sacrificing its futurity. I was doubtful at first of the decision to embrace the eldritch mythology of the elder gods, thinking it was just a convenient skin for what is an otherwise generic alien enemy. However, as the story progressed I was disabused of that notion, as Maberry doesn’t rely simply on the imagery of that mythology but also embraces its tone and outlook, bringing the soul-shattering bleakness of the infinitesimal and the infinite into active conversation with an otherwise raucous military sci-fi story. He is able to build within and on top of the cosmic mythos to create a world that is deep, dark, and endlessly unknowable.
The philosophically-rich nature of the world is highlighted by having one of the main characters be a theologian of cosmic philosophy, asking very real questions about how contemporary (Earthly) religious ideas will be tested when and if humans can expand our reach past known stars. The story doesn’t attempt any deep answers regarding spirituality, but by having this character at the forefront it adds a really engaging humanity to what might otherwise be a story of big machines blowing up other big machines. Because at its heart this is a military sci-fi story, with multiple heart-pounding battle scenes, creating new tech and then exploiting it and pushing it to its limits to paint a sky full of violent explosions. The other primary character in this story is the leader of a squad of what are essentially fighter pilots, and so our story is contained between these two poles of cosmic wonder and well-earned bravado. Yet neither character, nor the cast of various ancillary characters, is a flat stereotype. There is vulnerability and depth to all our characters, an emotional investment that makes all of the more fantastic elements of the story have actual stakes. The large cast is diverse in terms of (future) ethnicities and cultural origins, although the lack of explicit queer characters felt a little disappointing given the scope of the world and story. The story still felt inclusive and embracing, though, and there is certainly space for the world to grow.
The writing is smart and propulsive, with wonderfully descriptive prose that makes every scene come to life, whether that be a séance or an interstellar dogfight. The plotting is effective, introducing a lot of ideas but never lingering on them, giving enough information to keep the reader understanding but while in constant motion. Every larger section is made up of many shorter chapters, and this did really keep the story active, but it did come at the expense of some character depth. The characters were well-rounded and complicated, they felt real, but a lot of that was more done through explanation than experience, because so often our scenes were brief and constantly shifting focus. In the few sections where there was a little more room to breathe Maberry did use that space well, elaborating on the world and characters in ways that were really rewarding, and I do wish there had been a few more sections like these. Still, though, the overall plotting was quite effective and made it difficult to put the book down.
At the end of the day there were certain things that were somewhat expected, playing into the tropes of military sci-fi in ways that were reliable and tested. It never felt boring, though, because this military sci-fi epic had so many interesting layers of cosmic horror and techno-thriller surrounding it that every plot beat, whether it was ultimately fitting into common tropes or not, had new ideas, new demons, and new emotional depths to plumb. Even when certain characters’ narrative trajectories map out more or less as you could guess the experience is still thrilling. This all combines with explorations of cosmic meaning, faith, fealty, family, and responsibility, explorations of how individuals within communities can celebrate their unique gifts and contributions to strengthen the whole. In short, it’s a lot of fun. An unexpected mash-up that exploits the best parts of cosmic horror and military sci-fi, forging something that is simultaneously emotionally resonant, existentially terrifying, and full of action.
(Rounded from 3.5)