Thank you, first of all, for making me preorder a book that comes out in a few weeks. My bank account really appreciates this. But I read this in one sitting and I knew I had to have it. (Seriously, thank you for releasing it in paperback on preorder.)
First of all, love the cover. Love the concept. I was worried it would border on fantasy too much--a genre which usually drops you in a completely unknown world and just expects you to roll with it without much beginner explanation--but it didn't. I quickly caught on and didn't feel like I was trying to swim my way around and figure out what was going on. I appreciate that.
I loved the author's writing style. It was beautiful and flowed well. I know some people don't care for the more flowery type of writing, but that is 100% my jam and so I ate this like candy. You know, if I... liked candy.
The story, I thought, was very good. Very, very unique. I felt so bad for MC and though I understood why Bast did what he did, I don't know that I personally could have ever forgiven him. Friede is a better woman than I. I am glad that she didn't her sorrow and misery stop her in her tracks, though, and that she got an adventure out of things. I also enjoyed the way her story ended, as I think that having her own terms was the least that could be done for her. So, overall, I was very satisfied with the story. I would actually love to read more about that down and the dead who come back, hint, hint, not so subtle hint.
Just a couple of small critiques, one of which I'm sure will be fixed in the final version and I worry will come off as rude, but my wife assured me since it's not published yet, it's okay. Please forgive me if it's not.
1. Kamil was referred to as 'her' at one point in the book. Since they were referred to as 'them' to rest of the time, this threw me. I wish I could remember where it happened exactly, but I know it was closer toward the end of the book.
2. Did I miss something? Following along, I thought Lor was the villain and then Lor was the saviour and then bam, Lor was the villain again. I don't know if I just didn't understand what was going on or if that wasn't explained very well. It could very well just be a me thing. Either way, I kind of wound up feeling really bad for her because of her actual motives (though, she, like Bast, was trying to take away Friede's anatomy.) It made me further question how I felt about Bast, which I never ended up figuring out. He was like a train that just kept derailing and saying, "Sorry," and then derailing again. (Though I do understand WHY. He was very, very human and I am grateful he did not fight Friede at the end.)
Overall, I loved this book. I will be recommending this book for anyone who likes the strange, tragic and beautiful. I am really, really, really looking forward to seeing more from this author.