Jude Warren was due to marry John Stewart but at the last minute left John at the altar. Jude always wanted to please her mother even to the extent of using her mother’s wedding dress, which was not really suitable, as her mother was very small and Jude was much bigger. As Aunt Agnes said ‘she was very biddable’. Also her older sister Rose had died at the age of twelve and this left a hole in the family and lots of resentment bubbling under the surface. It must be so awful to lose a sibling and then for nobody to talk about it. Anyway like most families the lack of communication did not bode well for the family with an English mother and an American father. Obviously this book is based on very rich people with very intelligent minds having access and contacts which could benefit the whole. Jude naturally had to have been to Oxford University (not some redbrick) and knew about Petroc Trevillion who wrote English Gardens and Medieval Gardens, the very subject that Jude had majored in a university. Jude at Barbara’s behest went to Pengarrock to work for Petroc. She also met Tristan (it’s all in the name) Petroc’c son and the family dogs Gin and Rum. However the most absorbing thing about the story is the missing sapphire and the riddle: ‘Not of the land, Not of the sea, Visible only, When August Rock sees’. Hard work and magic all added to the pleasure of reading the novel.
The descriptions of the paintings at Pengarrock was quite absorbing and how the women were so very beautiful, rich, intelligent but so dependent upon the men in the family who on the whole just lived out the expectations of previous generations. They were never free, always subjected to the husbands, fathers etc. but in their way very brave. Look at Octavia who loved her mother Clarissa, her cat, her painting and Pengarrick but took the boat out and smashed it against the rocks and drowned rather than be forced into a marriage with someone she didn’t love.
There was nothing to dislike and lots to like about this tale set in Cornwell. The hidden caves around the coast of Cornwall and the romantic vision of whole communities becoming tax evaders by bringing their boats into bays and inlets of Cornwall. Liz Fenwick certainly seemed to know her history and her gardens. I really liked Barbara who called a spade a shovel but had some very interesting contacts. Also thought Jude, though a bit self-obsessed, really changed her life without clinging to her past or her family. Rose was always the elephant in the room whilst she was at Cape Cod but she really changed her life. It is the kind of book that has something for everybody – a love story, an historical mystery, a whodunit, a nature book, a geographical excursion, a mother/daughter conflict, the outsider and the traditional runaway from the East Coast of America. A bit like a grown-up take on Enid Blyton’s ‘Famous Fiver’ and the dog. Loved it.