What do you think?
Rate this book
Smoke on the Wind
In the magnificent Scottish Highlands, two devoted mothers separated by centuries discover a haunting connection in a gripping novel by the USA Today bestselling author of The Girl Who Wrote in Silk.
Struggling with the tragic end of her marriage, Keaka Denney is on a bittersweet adventure in Scotland with her son, Colin. She’s joining him on a weeklong hike along the West Highland Way before he enters university in Glasgow. Soon into the journey, Keaka’s disquieting visions begin—a woman from ages past reaching for Colin, a burning cottage, violence.
Scotland, 1801. After Sorcha Chisholm and her son are wrenched from their home in a brutal eviction, they face an arduous trek toward a new beginning. When Sorcha learns she’s wanted for a murder she didn’t commit, she and her son run for their lives. Then help arrives from the strangest woman in the most unexpected ways.
Centuries apart, Keaka and Sorcha walk the same path—devoted mothers in circumstances beyond their control who will do anything to keep their sons safe. Defying logic, they find strength in each other. But what does their connection mean? And how far will it go?
Struggling with the tragic end of her marriage, Keaka Denney is on a bittersweet adventure in Scotland with her son, Colin. She’s joining him on a weeklong hike along the West Highland Way before he enters university in Glasgow. Soon into the journey, Keaka’s disquieting visions begin—a woman from ages past reaching for Colin, a burning cottage, violence.
Scotland, 1801. After Sorcha Chisholm and her son are wrenched from their home in a brutal eviction, they face an arduous trek toward a new beginning. When Sorcha learns she’s wanted for a murder she didn’t commit, she and her son run for their lives. Then help arrives from the strangest woman in the most unexpected ways.
Centuries apart, Keaka and Sorcha walk the same path—devoted mothers in circumstances beyond their control who will do anything to keep their sons safe. Defying logic, they find strength in each other. But what does their connection mean? And how far will it go?
390 pages, Kindle Edition
Published June 24, 2025
552 people are currently reading
4099 people want to read
About the author
Kelli Estes
4 books575 followersKelli Estes is the USA Today bestselling author of SMOKE ON THE WIND, coming June 2025. Her first novel, THE GIRL WHO WROTE IN SILK has been translated into twelve languages and was the recipient of the Pacific Northwest Writer’s Association Nancy Pearl Book Award and the Women’s Fiction Writers Association Star Award (Debut). Her second novel TODAY WE GO HOME was the nationwide Target Book Club pick for September 2019. Known for dual-timeline stories that show how history is still relevant to our lives today, Kelli is passionate about learning all she can about people and events that shaped our world. Kelli lives in Washington State with her husband and two sons. Find Kelli on Facebook, Instagram, or at www.kelliestes.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 85 reviews
August 9, 2025
Thanks to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for access to this title. All opinions expressed are my own.
A dual timeline( 1801/2000s) where two mothers travelling the Scottish Highlands do what they can to protect their most beloved sons.
In the modern timeline, Keaka Denney is making the most of every minute she has left with her son, Colin, before he starts university in Glasgow. It was a trip that his father, now deceased, wanted to do with their son. To honour his memory, Keaka decides she will participate in a week-long hike with Colin along the West Highland Way. Colin adored his father, and Keaka vowed never to let her son's memory of his father be tainted by what was happening in their marriage.
In 1801, Sorcha and her only living son, Aonghas, are evicted from their Highland home and must head towards a new life in the south. But soon they find themselves running for their lives when word reaches them that they are wanted for murder.
Keaka and Sorcha are leading different lives, centuries apart, but somehow find themselves in a strange occurrence walking the same path.
What a wonderful story about mothers and sons. What a wonderful story about women who defy the odds and do what they can to survive and to keep going. Oh, and then there is the beautiful setting of Scotland, which is always a delight to visit. This has sat on my TBR for far too long because from the moment I started reading, I knew that I was going to love it. The weaving of the two stories worked for me, and I enjoyed that both female protagonists narrated their chapters. In some ways, the author's novel reminded me of Barbara Erskine's novels. I find myself admitting to the fact that I found Sorcha's tale more enthralling, but that was because, at times, I found Keaka a little too clingy towards maintaining a perfect image for Colin, even though she was hurting badly.
Enjoyable read that I recommend.
#SmokeontheWind #NetGalley.
Publication Date 24/06/25
Goodreads Review 08/08/25
A dual timeline( 1801/2000s) where two mothers travelling the Scottish Highlands do what they can to protect their most beloved sons.
In the modern timeline, Keaka Denney is making the most of every minute she has left with her son, Colin, before he starts university in Glasgow. It was a trip that his father, now deceased, wanted to do with their son. To honour his memory, Keaka decides she will participate in a week-long hike with Colin along the West Highland Way. Colin adored his father, and Keaka vowed never to let her son's memory of his father be tainted by what was happening in their marriage.
In 1801, Sorcha and her only living son, Aonghas, are evicted from their Highland home and must head towards a new life in the south. But soon they find themselves running for their lives when word reaches them that they are wanted for murder.
Keaka and Sorcha are leading different lives, centuries apart, but somehow find themselves in a strange occurrence walking the same path.
What a wonderful story about mothers and sons. What a wonderful story about women who defy the odds and do what they can to survive and to keep going. Oh, and then there is the beautiful setting of Scotland, which is always a delight to visit. This has sat on my TBR for far too long because from the moment I started reading, I knew that I was going to love it. The weaving of the two stories worked for me, and I enjoyed that both female protagonists narrated their chapters. In some ways, the author's novel reminded me of Barbara Erskine's novels. I find myself admitting to the fact that I found Sorcha's tale more enthralling, but that was because, at times, I found Keaka a little too clingy towards maintaining a perfect image for Colin, even though she was hurting badly.
Enjoyable read that I recommend.
#SmokeontheWind #NetGalley.
Publication Date 24/06/25
Goodreads Review 08/08/25
September 27, 2025
To know me is to know that some of the happiest, most deeply peaceful, moments of my life have been spent on one of several trails in Ireland, walking with a pack on my back and joy in my heart. It's my greatest aspiration as I set my sights on retirement a few years hence to spend as much time hiking routes throughout Europe, from the famed Camino and all its various arteries throughout France, Spain, Portugal, to the Salt Road in northern Italy, to the Coast to Coast that spans England's width. And near the top of my lengthy list is Scotland's West Highland Way.
So it was with great delight that I settled into Smoke on the Wind, Kelli Estes' lovely, poignant time-slip novel that is an ode to her beloved Scotland. Weaving a narrative between 1801 and present-day, Estes tells the stories of two mothers and a mysterious connection that unites them across time.
American Keaka Denney accompanies her son, Colin, to Scotland where he is about to embark on his freshman year at the University of Glasgow. His dad was supposed to have made the journey—a rite of passage for Colin preceded by a father-son adventure of hiking the West Highland Way together—but Keaka's husband, Adam, had died of a heart attack the year before. Keaka plays the part of the grieving widow to shield her son from the truth about his beloved dad and agrees, reluctantly, to step into Adam's boots and complete the hike with her son.
Two centuries earlier, Sorcha Chisholm, herself a widow, is forced off her land during the Highland Clearances (you'll get a full history lesson about these, courtesy of Colin; Estes gracefully knits the fascinating history of 18th and 19th century Scotland, inextricably linked with its landscape and language, into Keaka's contemporary experiences) with her only remaining child, young Angus. Tragedy strikes during their cruel eviction and soon Sorcha and Angus are fleeing capture for murder.
The story follows these women's parallel journeys across the breathtaking Scottish landscape as they make their way across the mountains and moors toward Glasgow. Sorcha unwittingly leaves clues etched in stones that when touched, transports Keaka into a mystery of time and language.
This is a sink-into-the-sofa read—evocative, suspenseful, heart-full, and beautifully written. I felt Kelli's heart in every page, her adoration for Scotland, her passion for history, her love for these women and their sons. This was clearly a passion project and the result is a warm, refreshing story that will have you ready to abandon your sofa for the next flight to Alba.
So it was with great delight that I settled into Smoke on the Wind, Kelli Estes' lovely, poignant time-slip novel that is an ode to her beloved Scotland. Weaving a narrative between 1801 and present-day, Estes tells the stories of two mothers and a mysterious connection that unites them across time.
American Keaka Denney accompanies her son, Colin, to Scotland where he is about to embark on his freshman year at the University of Glasgow. His dad was supposed to have made the journey—a rite of passage for Colin preceded by a father-son adventure of hiking the West Highland Way together—but Keaka's husband, Adam, had died of a heart attack the year before. Keaka plays the part of the grieving widow to shield her son from the truth about his beloved dad and agrees, reluctantly, to step into Adam's boots and complete the hike with her son.
Two centuries earlier, Sorcha Chisholm, herself a widow, is forced off her land during the Highland Clearances (you'll get a full history lesson about these, courtesy of Colin; Estes gracefully knits the fascinating history of 18th and 19th century Scotland, inextricably linked with its landscape and language, into Keaka's contemporary experiences) with her only remaining child, young Angus. Tragedy strikes during their cruel eviction and soon Sorcha and Angus are fleeing capture for murder.
The story follows these women's parallel journeys across the breathtaking Scottish landscape as they make their way across the mountains and moors toward Glasgow. Sorcha unwittingly leaves clues etched in stones that when touched, transports Keaka into a mystery of time and language.
This is a sink-into-the-sofa read—evocative, suspenseful, heart-full, and beautifully written. I felt Kelli's heart in every page, her adoration for Scotland, her passion for history, her love for these women and their sons. This was clearly a passion project and the result is a warm, refreshing story that will have you ready to abandon your sofa for the next flight to Alba.
July 7, 2025
5 Glowing Stars for this amazing historical fiction. I absolutely fell in love with this story and the characters. The writing took me right to Scottland with them as if I was along for the adventure. This made me cry, smile, and get a little mad at a few points. If you loved Outlander - you will love this book just as much.
July 27, 2025
SMOKE ON THE WIND by Kelli Estes
Thank you #lakeunionpublishing for my gifted copy.
My fellow Outlander (books or TV show) fans, this ones for you! With the series finale last year, I've been missing Scotland, and yearned to be transported back to the majestic Highlands. Kelli Estes' new book did just that! It was fantastic!!! 👏🏼
Smoke on the Wind is a dual-timeline blend of historical fiction and magical realism. The story follows two mothers, centuries apart, who are bound by a fierce love for their sons and a mysterious connection that spans time.
This book is breathtaking! Beautifully written, meticulously researched, perfectly paced, and deeply moving. Smoke on the Wind is a tribute to the unwavering strength of a mother’s love. Highly recommend!
📌 Available now, and free on Kindle Unlimited.
Thank you #lakeunionpublishing for my gifted copy.
My fellow Outlander (books or TV show) fans, this ones for you! With the series finale last year, I've been missing Scotland, and yearned to be transported back to the majestic Highlands. Kelli Estes' new book did just that! It was fantastic!!! 👏🏼
Smoke on the Wind is a dual-timeline blend of historical fiction and magical realism. The story follows two mothers, centuries apart, who are bound by a fierce love for their sons and a mysterious connection that spans time.
This book is breathtaking! Beautifully written, meticulously researched, perfectly paced, and deeply moving. Smoke on the Wind is a tribute to the unwavering strength of a mother’s love. Highly recommend!
📌 Available now, and free on Kindle Unlimited.
May 11, 2025
Beautifully written, this is a memorable story involving two timelines with a similar 100-mile hike across the Scottish countryside.
In 1801, Sorcha and her teenaged son, Aonghas, were forced out of their community when their cottage was set on fire. The landlords pushed the rent-payers out of the Scottish Highlands by burning the village when they could make more money on the land grazing sheep. Where would they go with no food and only a few coins?
In the present, Keaka and her son, Colin, from Portland, OR were taking a 7-day hike in this same area of Scotland. Colin and his dad had planned this trip filled with history of the Highland Clearances. However, his dad died 10 months ago. Keaka stepped into his role with the sadness that she lost her husband and was about to say goodbye to her son. After the hike, Colin would be entering the University of Glasgow.
When I saw that Kelli Estes wrote another book, I was thrilled as I loved “The Girl Who Wrote in Silk.” Her last story also had two timelines around 1880s with the harsh prejudice against the Chinese in Seattle. Now, Estes enriches us with Scottish history. She shows the effects of a community that is displaced like the Japanese who were forced into US camps during WWII.
This book helps you understand the complex relationship a mother has with her son. She includes Gaelic words and a dialogue that feels genuine. Again, this author highlights history that is often overlooked. It’s similar to a hiker experiencing nature’s wonders for the first time. Scotland is a beautiful setting that makes you want to go there.
In this book, Keaka has some wild dreams that take her back 200 years. Wouldn’t we all like to go into such explorations at night? The book is a mixture of history, adventure and includes all sorts of emotions. It’s also a wish for a better world.
My thanks to Lake Union Publishing and NetGalley for allowing me to read an advanced copy of this book with an expected release date of June 24, 2025.
In 1801, Sorcha and her teenaged son, Aonghas, were forced out of their community when their cottage was set on fire. The landlords pushed the rent-payers out of the Scottish Highlands by burning the village when they could make more money on the land grazing sheep. Where would they go with no food and only a few coins?
In the present, Keaka and her son, Colin, from Portland, OR were taking a 7-day hike in this same area of Scotland. Colin and his dad had planned this trip filled with history of the Highland Clearances. However, his dad died 10 months ago. Keaka stepped into his role with the sadness that she lost her husband and was about to say goodbye to her son. After the hike, Colin would be entering the University of Glasgow.
When I saw that Kelli Estes wrote another book, I was thrilled as I loved “The Girl Who Wrote in Silk.” Her last story also had two timelines around 1880s with the harsh prejudice against the Chinese in Seattle. Now, Estes enriches us with Scottish history. She shows the effects of a community that is displaced like the Japanese who were forced into US camps during WWII.
This book helps you understand the complex relationship a mother has with her son. She includes Gaelic words and a dialogue that feels genuine. Again, this author highlights history that is often overlooked. It’s similar to a hiker experiencing nature’s wonders for the first time. Scotland is a beautiful setting that makes you want to go there.
In this book, Keaka has some wild dreams that take her back 200 years. Wouldn’t we all like to go into such explorations at night? The book is a mixture of history, adventure and includes all sorts of emotions. It’s also a wish for a better world.
My thanks to Lake Union Publishing and NetGalley for allowing me to read an advanced copy of this book with an expected release date of June 24, 2025.
Read
June 16, 2025Nope. Dnf @32%
Read
June 25, 2025Smoke on the Wind
by Kelli Estes
This book presents a complex challenge to rate because, while the story deeply moved me, I struggled with the pacing and comprehension due to the frequent use of the Gaelic language, which made certain passages difficult to follow.
It is an emotional read, artfully told across two timelines that intertwine in unexpected ways. In the present day, we meet Keaka and her son, Colin, as they embark on a hiking adventure along the breathtaking West Highland Way in Scotland. This journey holds significant meaning for them, particularly as it occurs before Colin heads off to university in Glasgow, marking a pivotal transition in both their lives.
Simultaneously, two hundred years earlier, we are introduced to Sorcha Chisholm and her young son, Aonghas. They are desperately fleeing their burning home in the Scottish Highlands, confronting the stark realities of survival as they travel the very same trail. The contrast between the two journeys highlights themes of resilience, loss, and the enduring bond between mother and child, making for a powerful story that captures the spirit of both past and present.
The book transported me back to my unforgettable trip to Scotland last year, igniting vivid memories of its breathtaking landscapes. I can't wait to return to this enchanting country, where rugged mountains rise majestically against the skyline, their peaks often cloaked in a soft mist. The endless lochs, like shimmering blue gems, reflect the dramatic scenery and invite peaceful contemplation. I vividly recall the charm of the moss-covered stone walls that trace the contours of the hills, each telling a story of the land's history. Scattered throughout the landscape are majestic castles, their ancient stones standing guard over the valleys, evoking a sense of wonder and intrigue. I relished every description and detail, each one pulling me deeper into the beauty and spirit of Scotland.
by Kelli Estes
This book presents a complex challenge to rate because, while the story deeply moved me, I struggled with the pacing and comprehension due to the frequent use of the Gaelic language, which made certain passages difficult to follow.
It is an emotional read, artfully told across two timelines that intertwine in unexpected ways. In the present day, we meet Keaka and her son, Colin, as they embark on a hiking adventure along the breathtaking West Highland Way in Scotland. This journey holds significant meaning for them, particularly as it occurs before Colin heads off to university in Glasgow, marking a pivotal transition in both their lives.
Simultaneously, two hundred years earlier, we are introduced to Sorcha Chisholm and her young son, Aonghas. They are desperately fleeing their burning home in the Scottish Highlands, confronting the stark realities of survival as they travel the very same trail. The contrast between the two journeys highlights themes of resilience, loss, and the enduring bond between mother and child, making for a powerful story that captures the spirit of both past and present.
The book transported me back to my unforgettable trip to Scotland last year, igniting vivid memories of its breathtaking landscapes. I can't wait to return to this enchanting country, where rugged mountains rise majestically against the skyline, their peaks often cloaked in a soft mist. The endless lochs, like shimmering blue gems, reflect the dramatic scenery and invite peaceful contemplation. I vividly recall the charm of the moss-covered stone walls that trace the contours of the hills, each telling a story of the land's history. Scattered throughout the landscape are majestic castles, their ancient stones standing guard over the valleys, evoking a sense of wonder and intrigue. I relished every description and detail, each one pulling me deeper into the beauty and spirit of Scotland.
September 29, 2025
"The hardest part of being a parent is letting go."
Separated by hundreds of years in time, the stories of Sorcha (and Aonghas) and Keaka (and Colin) as they walked the beautiful, rugged and challenging West Highland Way in Scotland will stay with me. Chapter after chapter was filled with the love for their sons. Smoke on the Wind reminds us that the heart and perseverance of a mother's love has no borders and transcends time.
Thank you NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for providing me the opportunity to read the advanced e-copy of; Smoke on the Wind by Kelli Estes.
Separated by hundreds of years in time, the stories of Sorcha (and Aonghas) and Keaka (and Colin) as they walked the beautiful, rugged and challenging West Highland Way in Scotland will stay with me. Chapter after chapter was filled with the love for their sons. Smoke on the Wind reminds us that the heart and perseverance of a mother's love has no borders and transcends time.
Thank you NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for providing me the opportunity to read the advanced e-copy of; Smoke on the Wind by Kelli Estes.
July 18, 2025
This is my first Kelli Estes book but it was an enjoyable read with a location and world that was brought to life with vivid and descriptive writing.
Set in two different times, the story centres on two strong female characters. The first is Sorcha, a widow and a mother, living in the Scottish Highlands, who is evicted from her home in the 1600s (inspired by the true Scottish Clearances) along with her only surviving son. They embark on a hike across the Scottish wilderness, aiming for Edinburgh, for refuge and safety.
The second character is set in the current day. Keaka is an American and has travelled to Scotland (Glasgow to be exact) with her son who is about to start university. Both are dealing with their own grief after the death of Keaka’s husband and her son’s father. Keaka is keeping a secret from her son to protect his father’s legacy which is that he was having an affair with someone else. Thus, Keaka’s grief process is somewhat complicated. Prior to her son starting university, the two decide to embark on a hike from the lowlands up to the highlands - it was a journey her son had been planning with his father, prior to his death. The journey takes Keaka and her son on a similar journey and path to that of Sorcha.
… and this is where Keaka starts to experience flashbacks to the 1600s and Sorcha’s own journey… but what is the connection between both women… and will both survive their journeys?
This was an enjoyable read which transported you straight into the dreich landscapes of the Scottish Highlands. I live in Scotland and even I thought aspects of this book was educational for me - filled with tidbits of Scottish history that I didn’t know.
It also gave me an opportunity to brush up on my Scottish Gaelic :)
Set in two different times, the story centres on two strong female characters. The first is Sorcha, a widow and a mother, living in the Scottish Highlands, who is evicted from her home in the 1600s (inspired by the true Scottish Clearances) along with her only surviving son. They embark on a hike across the Scottish wilderness, aiming for Edinburgh, for refuge and safety.
The second character is set in the current day. Keaka is an American and has travelled to Scotland (Glasgow to be exact) with her son who is about to start university. Both are dealing with their own grief after the death of Keaka’s husband and her son’s father. Keaka is keeping a secret from her son to protect his father’s legacy which is that he was having an affair with someone else. Thus, Keaka’s grief process is somewhat complicated. Prior to her son starting university, the two decide to embark on a hike from the lowlands up to the highlands - it was a journey her son had been planning with his father, prior to his death. The journey takes Keaka and her son on a similar journey and path to that of Sorcha.
… and this is where Keaka starts to experience flashbacks to the 1600s and Sorcha’s own journey… but what is the connection between both women… and will both survive their journeys?
This was an enjoyable read which transported you straight into the dreich landscapes of the Scottish Highlands. I live in Scotland and even I thought aspects of this book was educational for me - filled with tidbits of Scottish history that I didn’t know.
It also gave me an opportunity to brush up on my Scottish Gaelic :)
January 12, 2025
Kelli Estes' latest read provides a poignant portrayal of the bond between mothers and their children. The dual-linear timeline pens a tale depicting Keaka and Sorcha's stories where each mother is forced to say goodbye to their former lives.
While their circumstances differ, both mothers are on a journey to find themselves. In what appears to be an impossible connection between two women born centuries apart, Keaka feels Sorcha's spirit. Embolden by the older woman's bravery, Keaka forges ahead on her mental and physical quest. Will she be able to tell her son the truth before it's too late?
Thank you to #NetGalley and the publisher for the early edition of #SmokeontheWind in exchange for an honest review. While at times it was difficult to keep track of the stories, the novel was the perfect read to commence 2025.
While their circumstances differ, both mothers are on a journey to find themselves. In what appears to be an impossible connection between two women born centuries apart, Keaka feels Sorcha's spirit. Embolden by the older woman's bravery, Keaka forges ahead on her mental and physical quest. Will she be able to tell her son the truth before it's too late?
Thank you to #NetGalley and the publisher for the early edition of #SmokeontheWind in exchange for an honest review. While at times it was difficult to keep track of the stories, the novel was the perfect read to commence 2025.
June 26, 2025
Keaka is struggling with her son Colin leaving home to go to college after losing his father and still grieving. They had planned a trip to hike the West Highand Way and now Keaka steps in to take his place. Soon after the start, she starts having visions of centuries past, of a woman named Sorcha and her son forced from their home and fleeing from false accusations.
This story is told in two separate timelines with the visions connecting the two. It taught me a part of Scottish history I knew little about and I found it emotional and heartbreaking, yet hopeful. The descriptions of the Scottish countryside were beautiful and make me want to visit someday. The story was very well written, the pacing was a little slow, but overall I really enjoyed this book.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advance copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This story is told in two separate timelines with the visions connecting the two. It taught me a part of Scottish history I knew little about and I found it emotional and heartbreaking, yet hopeful. The descriptions of the Scottish countryside were beautiful and make me want to visit someday. The story was very well written, the pacing was a little slow, but overall I really enjoyed this book.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advance copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
July 10, 2025
This was sooooooooooo slow
July 27, 2025
A must
Beautiful story. We believe all lives are lived as our own has been, until we read differently. Such courage and sadness.
Beautiful story. We believe all lives are lived as our own has been, until we read differently. Such courage and sadness.
August 10, 2025
Really loved seeing both women's stories playing out. How each mother is struggling with loss/grief and their relationships with their sons is done is really well done. It was surprisingly good, I went into this just trying something new and found a story where I really felt for the main characters.
July 22, 2025
I did like the book overall but some aspects bugged me- like Keaka's nonstop complaining on the first two thirds of the trail, reminded me of being with someone who is just super negative when I'm just trying to have a good time. I felt bad for Colin! And then the internal thoughts about her husband and the debate on whether or not to tell her son the details; it felt like she was beating a dead horse.
I also don't feel like I got my questions answered! why were they connected? why were they able to sometimes see each other and sometimes not? and how was she able to escape the gallows? just feels incomplete!!
BUT it was easy to read, had beautiful scenery that made me feel like I was back in the highlands, and did have some food suspenseful moments... three stars for these reasons.
I also don't feel like I got my questions answered! why were they connected? why were they able to sometimes see each other and sometimes not? and how was she able to escape the gallows? just feels incomplete!!
BUT it was easy to read, had beautiful scenery that made me feel like I was back in the highlands, and did have some food suspenseful moments... three stars for these reasons.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 7, 2025
I was hopeful that this would come together at the end, but it just didn’t for me. It was too long in my opinion, which made it hard to get through and the dual timelines never really came together. I was hoping for a big revelation on these two women centuries apart, but it just fell flat almost like it didn’t even matter to the story which was a disappointment.
June 27, 2025
I just might be the first reviewer who actually bought a copy of the book!
I pre-ordered this novel when I first heard about it and I dove into it the minute it arrived on my doorstep. It did not disappoint!
Smoke on the Wind is a complex dual timeline story of two widows and their beloved sons, each pair of them on a journey that will begin a dramatic change in the lives of all four of them. Although each mother/son pair treads the same physical path that is now the West Highland Way in Scotland, they do so in opposite directions -- and two hundred years apart!
In 1801, Sorcha and her son Aonghas are violently evicted from their peaceful crofting life in Strathglas, by agents of the landowner who burn down their homes and crops and kill their animals so they can never return. The cruelty of the Highland Clearances cannot be underestimated and Estes illustrates this story by showing rather than telling. The plight of Sorcha and her family is specific but also exemplary of the experience of thousands of families who suffered a similar fate at the hands of anglicized Scottish lords. Barefoot and penniless, Sorcha and Aonghas, in desperation, head south toward Glasgow to escape pursuit and hopefully to find work and a new life.
The story of Keaka, on the other hand, takes place in present time, while she takes her son Colin to Glasgow where he will soon begin university. Colin's father, of Scottish descent, had died nearly a year before, so Keaka steps in to hike north on the West Highland Way with her son, a project that he had planned with his father. Both mothers, Keaka and Sorcha, are fiercely protective of their teenage boys. The keen fear and anticipation of their loss, figurative or literal, informs their every thought.
It may be this profound love and fear that mystically connects the two women even thought they are separated by centuries. Keaka finds signs that Sorcha leaves along her journey, and she is transported to that other time for minutes, knowing things she cannot know, speaking words from Sorcha's mind. Sorcha sees Keaka as a woman of the Fair Folk, a strange benefactor, who helps at a critical time.
While these two dramas carry on, the real star of the novel is the Scottish landscape, specifically that of the West Highland Way. It is fairly obvious that the author has first-hand knowledge as she glowingly describes the sights seen by Keaka and Colin along the way. Sometimes we can compare and contrast the very same scenes, even the inns, that Sorcha would have seen in 1801. Keaka, who had for years resented her husband and son's love of Scotland, now hears the call of the Highlands and wants to "walk north into those mountains and connect to the spirit of the land." She does so -- in spades!" At this point of hike, from a viewpoint she is filled with her own awe and the "cianalas" of Sorcha. Keaka speaks in Sorcha's poetic Gaelic: An till mi chaoidh . . . "Will I ever return to my beloved Highlands, where Gaelic can be heard on the lips of its people. With beautiful views now at my back, it breaks my heart."
During the hundred mile hike, Keaka has time to think and come to terms with her relationship with her deceased husband and the reality of losing her child to his adult life away from her. A world of possibilities opens up to her. Her deep mystic connection to Sorcha helps both of them on their way to safety and fulfillment.
I can't say enough positive things about this lovely novel. But I had a bone to pick with one of the previous reviewers, Ann-Maree, and I can't seem to get Goodreads to post a comment. I would strenuously disagree with Ann-Maree that the use of Gaelic makes any part of this book "hard to follow." Estes has assiduously provided, if not a translation, then an explanation of every Gaelic word used. Like the first time Keaka comes out with Gaelic mysteriously on her tongue, "Gabh mo leisgeul." Her son recognizes these words as Gaelic, repeats it back phonetically, and she says "To that woman? I said, "Excuse me" (giving the meaning.) This for the reader and to indicate that she's not even aware that she's misspoken. The use of Gaelic doesn't just add to the realism of Sorcha's existence, it is indeed one of the themes of the novel -- how much the Scottish people lost, their homes, their livelihood, their culture, even their language. We see this poignantly when she is thrust into the city life of Glasgow and rebuked for everything she is, as soon as she says a word. When a passerby bumps into Sorcha, he looks down on her, angry. "Pardon me, she told him in Gaelic, knowing the words were expected even if the man could not understand them. The Gaelic seemed to enrage him more. He clamped his gloved hand around her arm and hollered something she could not understand. . . She was used to the looks of contempt." Imagine everything she has been through and then not being able to communicate, her very words held in contempt. Sorcha stands for the 150 000 souls displaced in the Clearances. Of those people, almost all were forced to learn English, whether they stayed in Britain or emigrated to Canada and Australia. If Estes use of Gaelic disrupted your reading, even after providing clear meaning and explanation AND a glossary at the end, then think of how it adds to the colour and realism of the story, and what a fine extra layer illustrating the disruption felt by the Gaelic dispossessed.
Full disclosure: I'm a boy mom, a widow, a Gaelic speaker, a Caledonophile, a descendant of the dispossessed, and a fan of Kelli Estes. So it would be a miracle if I didn't like this book.
I pre-ordered this novel when I first heard about it and I dove into it the minute it arrived on my doorstep. It did not disappoint!
Smoke on the Wind is a complex dual timeline story of two widows and their beloved sons, each pair of them on a journey that will begin a dramatic change in the lives of all four of them. Although each mother/son pair treads the same physical path that is now the West Highland Way in Scotland, they do so in opposite directions -- and two hundred years apart!
In 1801, Sorcha and her son Aonghas are violently evicted from their peaceful crofting life in Strathglas, by agents of the landowner who burn down their homes and crops and kill their animals so they can never return. The cruelty of the Highland Clearances cannot be underestimated and Estes illustrates this story by showing rather than telling. The plight of Sorcha and her family is specific but also exemplary of the experience of thousands of families who suffered a similar fate at the hands of anglicized Scottish lords. Barefoot and penniless, Sorcha and Aonghas, in desperation, head south toward Glasgow to escape pursuit and hopefully to find work and a new life.
The story of Keaka, on the other hand, takes place in present time, while she takes her son Colin to Glasgow where he will soon begin university. Colin's father, of Scottish descent, had died nearly a year before, so Keaka steps in to hike north on the West Highland Way with her son, a project that he had planned with his father. Both mothers, Keaka and Sorcha, are fiercely protective of their teenage boys. The keen fear and anticipation of their loss, figurative or literal, informs their every thought.
It may be this profound love and fear that mystically connects the two women even thought they are separated by centuries. Keaka finds signs that Sorcha leaves along her journey, and she is transported to that other time for minutes, knowing things she cannot know, speaking words from Sorcha's mind. Sorcha sees Keaka as a woman of the Fair Folk, a strange benefactor, who helps at a critical time.
While these two dramas carry on, the real star of the novel is the Scottish landscape, specifically that of the West Highland Way. It is fairly obvious that the author has first-hand knowledge as she glowingly describes the sights seen by Keaka and Colin along the way. Sometimes we can compare and contrast the very same scenes, even the inns, that Sorcha would have seen in 1801. Keaka, who had for years resented her husband and son's love of Scotland, now hears the call of the Highlands and wants to "walk north into those mountains and connect to the spirit of the land." She does so -- in spades!" At this point of hike, from a viewpoint she is filled with her own awe and the "cianalas" of Sorcha. Keaka speaks in Sorcha's poetic Gaelic: An till mi chaoidh . . . "Will I ever return to my beloved Highlands, where Gaelic can be heard on the lips of its people. With beautiful views now at my back, it breaks my heart."
During the hundred mile hike, Keaka has time to think and come to terms with her relationship with her deceased husband and the reality of losing her child to his adult life away from her. A world of possibilities opens up to her. Her deep mystic connection to Sorcha helps both of them on their way to safety and fulfillment.
I can't say enough positive things about this lovely novel. But I had a bone to pick with one of the previous reviewers, Ann-Maree, and I can't seem to get Goodreads to post a comment. I would strenuously disagree with Ann-Maree that the use of Gaelic makes any part of this book "hard to follow." Estes has assiduously provided, if not a translation, then an explanation of every Gaelic word used. Like the first time Keaka comes out with Gaelic mysteriously on her tongue, "Gabh mo leisgeul." Her son recognizes these words as Gaelic, repeats it back phonetically, and she says "To that woman? I said, "Excuse me" (giving the meaning.) This for the reader and to indicate that she's not even aware that she's misspoken. The use of Gaelic doesn't just add to the realism of Sorcha's existence, it is indeed one of the themes of the novel -- how much the Scottish people lost, their homes, their livelihood, their culture, even their language. We see this poignantly when she is thrust into the city life of Glasgow and rebuked for everything she is, as soon as she says a word. When a passerby bumps into Sorcha, he looks down on her, angry. "Pardon me, she told him in Gaelic, knowing the words were expected even if the man could not understand them. The Gaelic seemed to enrage him more. He clamped his gloved hand around her arm and hollered something she could not understand. . . She was used to the looks of contempt." Imagine everything she has been through and then not being able to communicate, her very words held in contempt. Sorcha stands for the 150 000 souls displaced in the Clearances. Of those people, almost all were forced to learn English, whether they stayed in Britain or emigrated to Canada and Australia. If Estes use of Gaelic disrupted your reading, even after providing clear meaning and explanation AND a glossary at the end, then think of how it adds to the colour and realism of the story, and what a fine extra layer illustrating the disruption felt by the Gaelic dispossessed.
Full disclosure: I'm a boy mom, a widow, a Gaelic speaker, a Caledonophile, a descendant of the dispossessed, and a fan of Kelli Estes. So it would be a miracle if I didn't like this book.
May 19, 2025
📖 Smoke on the Wind by Kelli Estes
A tapestry of maternal fury and forgotten histories—where the Scottish Highlands breathe secrets across centuries.
✨ Literary Analysis
🔥 Dual-Timeline Alchemy: Estes masterfully braids the lives of two mothers—18th-century crofter Moira and modern-day hiker Fiona—into a single flame of defiance against oppression. The past never sleeps; it waits in the heather.
🏔️ Setting as Character: The Highlands are rendered with visceral majesty—peat smoke, driving rain, and jagged cliffs mirror the women’s fractured resilience. Landscape doesn’t forgive, but it remembers.
👁️ Feminist Reckoning: Explores motherhood as both shackle and sword, with gut-punch lines like, A woman’s love is measured by what she burns down to keep it alive.
📜 Historical Texture: Meticulous research on Jacobite-era persecution weaves through Fiona’s present-day quest, though some parallels feel overly orchestrated.
💔 Emotional Precision: Grief is a character here—not a wave to outrun, but a tide that rewrites your bones.
🎯 Ideal Readers vs. Potential Mismatches
❤️ Who Will Love This Book?
Devotees of atmospheric dual-timeline epics
Readers who underline lyrical feminist declarations
Fans of Scottish history’s bloody margins
Those who cherish mother-daughter narratives with teeth
Book clubs dissecting how landscapes hold collective trauma
🚫 Who Might Not Love This Book?
Seekers of fast-paced plots
Readers averse to shifting POVs/time jumps
Those preferring neat resolutions—Estes leaves embers untended
Critics of overt thematic symbolism
⭐ Star Breakdown (0-5)
Historical Authenticity: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4.5/5) Whispered Gaelic curses feel exhumed from archives.
Prose Beauty: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) Sentences like peat-dark honey—thick, slow, intoxicating.
Character Depth: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5) Moira’s fire outshines Fiona’s occasional passivity.
Emotional Impact: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) Leaves salt streaks on pages and cheeks alike.
Structural Balance: ⭐⭐⭐ (3.5/5) Past/present scales tip unevenly at times.
Overall: 4.4/5
A dagger wrapped in a wool blanket—comfort cuts deep when you least expect it.
🙏 Thank you to NetGalley and Kelli Estes for the advance review copy. Smoke on the Wind confirms Estes as a bard of women’s untold battles—a novel that howls across time to remind us: The strongest chains are the stories we stop telling.
Takeaways:
History isn’t written by the victors—it’s survived by the silent.
Motherhood is the first country men invade.
Some truths are only spoken in the language of scars.
(Note: Keep a dram of whisky nearby—for toasting the fallen and steeling your nerves.)
A tapestry of maternal fury and forgotten histories—where the Scottish Highlands breathe secrets across centuries.
✨ Literary Analysis
🔥 Dual-Timeline Alchemy: Estes masterfully braids the lives of two mothers—18th-century crofter Moira and modern-day hiker Fiona—into a single flame of defiance against oppression. The past never sleeps; it waits in the heather.
🏔️ Setting as Character: The Highlands are rendered with visceral majesty—peat smoke, driving rain, and jagged cliffs mirror the women’s fractured resilience. Landscape doesn’t forgive, but it remembers.
👁️ Feminist Reckoning: Explores motherhood as both shackle and sword, with gut-punch lines like, A woman’s love is measured by what she burns down to keep it alive.
📜 Historical Texture: Meticulous research on Jacobite-era persecution weaves through Fiona’s present-day quest, though some parallels feel overly orchestrated.
💔 Emotional Precision: Grief is a character here—not a wave to outrun, but a tide that rewrites your bones.
🎯 Ideal Readers vs. Potential Mismatches
❤️ Who Will Love This Book?
Devotees of atmospheric dual-timeline epics
Readers who underline lyrical feminist declarations
Fans of Scottish history’s bloody margins
Those who cherish mother-daughter narratives with teeth
Book clubs dissecting how landscapes hold collective trauma
🚫 Who Might Not Love This Book?
Seekers of fast-paced plots
Readers averse to shifting POVs/time jumps
Those preferring neat resolutions—Estes leaves embers untended
Critics of overt thematic symbolism
⭐ Star Breakdown (0-5)
Historical Authenticity: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4.5/5) Whispered Gaelic curses feel exhumed from archives.
Prose Beauty: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) Sentences like peat-dark honey—thick, slow, intoxicating.
Character Depth: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5) Moira’s fire outshines Fiona’s occasional passivity.
Emotional Impact: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) Leaves salt streaks on pages and cheeks alike.
Structural Balance: ⭐⭐⭐ (3.5/5) Past/present scales tip unevenly at times.
Overall: 4.4/5
A dagger wrapped in a wool blanket—comfort cuts deep when you least expect it.
🙏 Thank you to NetGalley and Kelli Estes for the advance review copy. Smoke on the Wind confirms Estes as a bard of women’s untold battles—a novel that howls across time to remind us: The strongest chains are the stories we stop telling.
Takeaways:
History isn’t written by the victors—it’s survived by the silent.
Motherhood is the first country men invade.
Some truths are only spoken in the language of scars.
(Note: Keep a dram of whisky nearby—for toasting the fallen and steeling your nerves.)
June 23, 2025
This book brought me back to one of my favorite places in the world, Scotland. The rugged mountains, the endless lochs, the moss-covered walls, castles dotting the landscape, the heather dancing in the wind. I loved each and every description and detail. Let me talk about the details for a minute, the book is oozing with history. Well thought out and presented in such a way that it will always stick in my mind. The research that Kelli Estes must have put into this book is truly astonishing. I am always fascinated by the history of Scotland. The Highland Clearances is just another horrifying chapter that makes my mind spin. It always leads back to greed, money, and power. Tearing apart the Scots traditions, connections, and roots to the land. I have gotten a little off track. If you break this book down, it is about motherhood. What a mother would do in different situations for their sons. This book made me weep, made my heart soar, and made me hug my son that much tighter.
I love a good dual timeline that weaves together like a well-loved wool sweater. Keaka is in Scotland to drop off her son Colin to Uni. Her husband passed ten months ago, and they are still trying to figure out their new lives. Colin and his father planned on walking the West Highland Way for a week and Keaka has decided to step in and be the best replacement possible. The hike starts off a bit bumpy, with Keaka getting her hiking feet under. She soon forgets the aches and pains and is taken in by the stunning beauty and the visions that she keeps having of another woman. In 1801, Sorcha is in the fields taking in the views of her home. When cries of anguish and the smell of smoke fills her nose. She runs barefoot back to her home to find her son inside their home standing over a dead man. They run for their lives. Trying to make their way to Edinburgh so they can hide amongst the crowd. With men hunting them down and finding them at every turn. They must keep one step ahead or be caught and hanged.
As these two stories intertwine, I was left speechless with how Sorcha was able to overcome every obstacle in her way. Her son is the most important person in the world and the only thing she has left in this life, and she will make sure he survives. Keaka and her son face some hard truths about her marriage and life back in Oregon. Her only concern is to make sure that Colin is on solid ground when she makes the trip back home. Keaka also comes into herself and becomes okay with being on her own. Both women accept their shortcomings and head toward a new life. I have not done this book justice; just know you need to read it. Thank you to Kelli Estes, Lake Union Publishing, Amazon Publishing and Kay Publicity for gifting me one of my favorite reads of the year.
I love a good dual timeline that weaves together like a well-loved wool sweater. Keaka is in Scotland to drop off her son Colin to Uni. Her husband passed ten months ago, and they are still trying to figure out their new lives. Colin and his father planned on walking the West Highland Way for a week and Keaka has decided to step in and be the best replacement possible. The hike starts off a bit bumpy, with Keaka getting her hiking feet under. She soon forgets the aches and pains and is taken in by the stunning beauty and the visions that she keeps having of another woman. In 1801, Sorcha is in the fields taking in the views of her home. When cries of anguish and the smell of smoke fills her nose. She runs barefoot back to her home to find her son inside their home standing over a dead man. They run for their lives. Trying to make their way to Edinburgh so they can hide amongst the crowd. With men hunting them down and finding them at every turn. They must keep one step ahead or be caught and hanged.
As these two stories intertwine, I was left speechless with how Sorcha was able to overcome every obstacle in her way. Her son is the most important person in the world and the only thing she has left in this life, and she will make sure he survives. Keaka and her son face some hard truths about her marriage and life back in Oregon. Her only concern is to make sure that Colin is on solid ground when she makes the trip back home. Keaka also comes into herself and becomes okay with being on her own. Both women accept their shortcomings and head toward a new life. I have not done this book justice; just know you need to read it. Thank you to Kelli Estes, Lake Union Publishing, Amazon Publishing and Kay Publicity for gifting me one of my favorite reads of the year.
June 28, 2025
BOOK: SMOKE ON THE WIND
AUTHOR: KELLI ESTES
PUB DATE: JUNE 2025
👩👦👩👦
REVIEW- 4.5 stars
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
👩👦👩👦
This book was a full package, emotional, tear jerking, informational, and just amazing with the storyline, characteristics, author's description, and setting. I've never read a book like this, and I learned a LOT. I learnt about the depravity of the nobility. Of course, it's something I'm aware of, but I've never seen it described in a book like this. The highland clearance was horrific, those poor people wrongly evicted from their houses, their livelihoods, and the people who did it were probably never punished. On a lighter note, I loved the West Highland way hike. The way the author described the setting, it felt like I was on the hike, too, getting tired and viewing all the beautiful scenes.
👩👦👩👦
Sorcha and her son Aonghas went through a lot, especially Sorcha. The poor woman had lost a lot but still kept going just for her child. Her story is a bit of a tear jerker, and I cried at the end. I can't imagine losing everything and still being wrongly accused of murder and running for my life. But, Sorcha, the strong woman that she was, never gave up despite how tired she was. I loved her love for the highlands and her dead family members. She was an admirable character.
👩👦👩👦
On the other hand, we have Keaka, ab American mother who followed her son, Colin to Scotland, for his university admission and the seven days hike. The one thing I admired about Keaka was how she was a good mother. She put her son first, hid harmful secrets from him, and went on a strenuous hike. I liked that she admitted how she went wrong in her marriage, BUT it didn't justify her husband cheating. They could have gone for therapy or something. And I liked that she was finally able to let her son go.
👩👦👩👦
Both women went through struggles of their own, but Sorcha's one was greater, and to be honest, there were no similarities between them. Sometimes, I felt Keaka was too much and too clingy, but she got over it. Another thing was that the time both of them intertwined was less, I thought it would be a greater part of the book, but it felt like a minor theme. I really wanted both of them to actually interact more, but I didn't get it.
👩👦👩👦
Anyway, this book was amazing, thrilling, and informative. I lived reading it and loved that it had a HEA. I would definitely recommend this.
👩👦👩👦
AUTHOR: KELLI ESTES
PUB DATE: JUNE 2025
👩👦👩👦
REVIEW- 4.5 stars
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
👩👦👩👦
This book was a full package, emotional, tear jerking, informational, and just amazing with the storyline, characteristics, author's description, and setting. I've never read a book like this, and I learned a LOT. I learnt about the depravity of the nobility. Of course, it's something I'm aware of, but I've never seen it described in a book like this. The highland clearance was horrific, those poor people wrongly evicted from their houses, their livelihoods, and the people who did it were probably never punished. On a lighter note, I loved the West Highland way hike. The way the author described the setting, it felt like I was on the hike, too, getting tired and viewing all the beautiful scenes.
👩👦👩👦
Sorcha and her son Aonghas went through a lot, especially Sorcha. The poor woman had lost a lot but still kept going just for her child. Her story is a bit of a tear jerker, and I cried at the end. I can't imagine losing everything and still being wrongly accused of murder and running for my life. But, Sorcha, the strong woman that she was, never gave up despite how tired she was. I loved her love for the highlands and her dead family members. She was an admirable character.
👩👦👩👦
On the other hand, we have Keaka, ab American mother who followed her son, Colin to Scotland, for his university admission and the seven days hike. The one thing I admired about Keaka was how she was a good mother. She put her son first, hid harmful secrets from him, and went on a strenuous hike. I liked that she admitted how she went wrong in her marriage, BUT it didn't justify her husband cheating. They could have gone for therapy or something. And I liked that she was finally able to let her son go.
👩👦👩👦
Both women went through struggles of their own, but Sorcha's one was greater, and to be honest, there were no similarities between them. Sometimes, I felt Keaka was too much and too clingy, but she got over it. Another thing was that the time both of them intertwined was less, I thought it would be a greater part of the book, but it felt like a minor theme. I really wanted both of them to actually interact more, but I didn't get it.
👩👦👩👦
Anyway, this book was amazing, thrilling, and informative. I lived reading it and loved that it had a HEA. I would definitely recommend this.
👩👦👩👦
July 1, 2025
Set in the Scottish Highlands, this novel follows two mothers traveling with their sons—each on a journey shaped by grief, devotion, and the struggle to regain control when life veers off course.
Keaka Denney is begrudgingly traveling the West Highland Highway with her son, Colin. He’s just graduated from high school in the States and is preparing to start college across the pond. This trip wasn’t supposed to be hers—her husband was meant to take it with Colin—but his unexpected death has forced Keaka into a future she never imagined. At first, she’s miserable, weighed down by grief and resentment. But slowly, she comes to realize this might be her last chance to connect with her son before he embarks on adulthood. As the miles unfold, Keaka begins having strange visions—glimpses into another woman’s life in another time—which cause her to reflect deeply on her own path and the choices she’s made.
That woman is Sorcha Chisholm, who, after losing her husband and eldest son to war, finds herself and her younger son, Aonghas, evicted from their tenant lands. Displaced and desperate, they walk for miles in search of a new home—only to discover they are being hunted as criminals. Sorcha is thrust into unimaginable hardship and forced to make unthinkable decisions to protect her son.
Though separated by time and circumstance, both women are navigating the emotional wreckage of loss and the fierce, unrelenting love of motherhood. Their stories mirror each other in striking ways, each revealing the resilience it takes to rebuild a life—and the lengths a mother will go to for her child.
While each woman's arc of grief and growth was compelling, I found my attention drifting at times. Still, as someone with strong Scottish ancestry, I deeply appreciated the vivid homage to the Highlands—the landscapes, the history, and the sense of legacy that permeated every step of their journeys.
Thank you to NetGalley, Brilliance Audio, and of course the author Kelli Estes for the advanced copy of the audiobook. Smoke on the Wind is out now. All opinions are my own.
http://www.instagram.com/passionforprose
Keaka Denney is begrudgingly traveling the West Highland Highway with her son, Colin. He’s just graduated from high school in the States and is preparing to start college across the pond. This trip wasn’t supposed to be hers—her husband was meant to take it with Colin—but his unexpected death has forced Keaka into a future she never imagined. At first, she’s miserable, weighed down by grief and resentment. But slowly, she comes to realize this might be her last chance to connect with her son before he embarks on adulthood. As the miles unfold, Keaka begins having strange visions—glimpses into another woman’s life in another time—which cause her to reflect deeply on her own path and the choices she’s made.
That woman is Sorcha Chisholm, who, after losing her husband and eldest son to war, finds herself and her younger son, Aonghas, evicted from their tenant lands. Displaced and desperate, they walk for miles in search of a new home—only to discover they are being hunted as criminals. Sorcha is thrust into unimaginable hardship and forced to make unthinkable decisions to protect her son.
Though separated by time and circumstance, both women are navigating the emotional wreckage of loss and the fierce, unrelenting love of motherhood. Their stories mirror each other in striking ways, each revealing the resilience it takes to rebuild a life—and the lengths a mother will go to for her child.
While each woman's arc of grief and growth was compelling, I found my attention drifting at times. Still, as someone with strong Scottish ancestry, I deeply appreciated the vivid homage to the Highlands—the landscapes, the history, and the sense of legacy that permeated every step of their journeys.
Thank you to NetGalley, Brilliance Audio, and of course the author Kelli Estes for the advanced copy of the audiobook. Smoke on the Wind is out now. All opinions are my own.
http://www.instagram.com/passionforprose
September 1, 2025
Review:
Smoke on the Wind by Kelli Estes is an immersive, dual-timeline historical fiction novel that explores maternal love, resilience, and the enduring spirit of the Scottish Highlands. The story follows two mothers separated by centuries yet connected through a shared path and struggle. In 1801, Sorcha Chisholm and her son Aonghas are forcibly evicted during the Highland Clearances and must flee for their lives when she is wrongly accused of murder. Sorcha’s journey is harrowing, filled with danger, injustice, and heartbreak, yet her unwavering determination to protect her son makes her an inspiring and unforgettable character.
In the modern timeline, Keaka Denney, recently widowed, embarks on a weeklong hike along the West Highland Way with her son Colin before he starts college. The trip, meant to honor her late husband’s wishes, forces Keaka to confront grief, secrets, and the process of letting go. Estes masterfully intertwines these two narratives, using the shared geography and occasional magical undertones to deepen the emotional resonance.
The novel shines in its rich sense of place. The Scottish landscapes are vividly described—from the rugged Highlands to the misty trails of the West Highland Way—transporting readers directly into the story. Sorcha’s storyline is intense and gripping, full of historical detail about the Clearances and the cruelty endured by displaced families, while Keaka’s story is emotional, heartwarming, and reflective, highlighting the bond between mother and son.
The dual timelines work well, though some moments connecting the two narratives are brief, leaving readers wishing for more interaction between the women’s stories. Despite this, the novel balances suspense, historical insight, and heartfelt character development beautifully.
Smoke on the Wind is a poignant, thrilling, and emotionally satisfying read for fans of historical fiction, Scottish history, and stories about maternal love and perseverance. It’s a tale of survival, courage, and family bonds that lingers long after the last page.
Smoke on the Wind by Kelli Estes is an immersive, dual-timeline historical fiction novel that explores maternal love, resilience, and the enduring spirit of the Scottish Highlands. The story follows two mothers separated by centuries yet connected through a shared path and struggle. In 1801, Sorcha Chisholm and her son Aonghas are forcibly evicted during the Highland Clearances and must flee for their lives when she is wrongly accused of murder. Sorcha’s journey is harrowing, filled with danger, injustice, and heartbreak, yet her unwavering determination to protect her son makes her an inspiring and unforgettable character.
In the modern timeline, Keaka Denney, recently widowed, embarks on a weeklong hike along the West Highland Way with her son Colin before he starts college. The trip, meant to honor her late husband’s wishes, forces Keaka to confront grief, secrets, and the process of letting go. Estes masterfully intertwines these two narratives, using the shared geography and occasional magical undertones to deepen the emotional resonance.
The novel shines in its rich sense of place. The Scottish landscapes are vividly described—from the rugged Highlands to the misty trails of the West Highland Way—transporting readers directly into the story. Sorcha’s storyline is intense and gripping, full of historical detail about the Clearances and the cruelty endured by displaced families, while Keaka’s story is emotional, heartwarming, and reflective, highlighting the bond between mother and son.
The dual timelines work well, though some moments connecting the two narratives are brief, leaving readers wishing for more interaction between the women’s stories. Despite this, the novel balances suspense, historical insight, and heartfelt character development beautifully.
Smoke on the Wind is a poignant, thrilling, and emotionally satisfying read for fans of historical fiction, Scottish history, and stories about maternal love and perseverance. It’s a tale of survival, courage, and family bonds that lingers long after the last page.
December 26, 2025
I received this book from a Goodreads Giveaway from Amazon Publishing as an eBook. This is my honest opinion/review based solely on my reading of this book.
Overall, I really enjoyed this novel! The novel oscillates back and forth between modern day and 1801 Scotland. The modern day characters are Keaka Denney and her son Colin, who begin by preparing to hike the West Highland Way in Scotland's highlands. The characters from 1801 are Sorcha Chisholm and her son Aonghas, as they are forced to leave their home in the highlands during the time of the Highland Clearances.
This novel deals with mother and son relationships, loss, hardships, determination, survival, and hope. There is also a time travel element to the novel, which I love! I have been reading time travel romances since the 90s and I enjoyed the little shout-outs to the Outlander novels throughout this story. I love time travel novels such as this because I love history and getting that visceral connection to the time period being covered.
I am always into books that deal with adventures, travel, and learning about different cultures other than my own experiences. I am an archaeologist, traveler, and a foodie, so these type of novels appeal to me greatly. And this one did not disappoint! After reading this novel, I am adding hiking the West Highland Way to my bucket list of travels. I have hiked many places in my life, and definitely want to do this one!
I really enjoyed the sense of found family and sense of connection with the various hikers that Keaka and Colin encounter throughout the story.
There were only minor things throughout the story that annoyed me, such as Keaka's constant whining and Colin's persistent brooding. But with any story, you always know that the characters are on a journey to grow emotionally by the end of the novel, so even though it is annoying throughout some of it, you know they have to go through it in order to evolve. So, it is only a minor inconvenience. Great job Kelli Estes!
Overall, I really enjoyed this novel! The novel oscillates back and forth between modern day and 1801 Scotland. The modern day characters are Keaka Denney and her son Colin, who begin by preparing to hike the West Highland Way in Scotland's highlands. The characters from 1801 are Sorcha Chisholm and her son Aonghas, as they are forced to leave their home in the highlands during the time of the Highland Clearances.
This novel deals with mother and son relationships, loss, hardships, determination, survival, and hope. There is also a time travel element to the novel, which I love! I have been reading time travel romances since the 90s and I enjoyed the little shout-outs to the Outlander novels throughout this story. I love time travel novels such as this because I love history and getting that visceral connection to the time period being covered.
I am always into books that deal with adventures, travel, and learning about different cultures other than my own experiences. I am an archaeologist, traveler, and a foodie, so these type of novels appeal to me greatly. And this one did not disappoint! After reading this novel, I am adding hiking the West Highland Way to my bucket list of travels. I have hiked many places in my life, and definitely want to do this one!
I really enjoyed the sense of found family and sense of connection with the various hikers that Keaka and Colin encounter throughout the story.
There were only minor things throughout the story that annoyed me, such as Keaka's constant whining and Colin's persistent brooding. But with any story, you always know that the characters are on a journey to grow emotionally by the end of the novel, so even though it is annoying throughout some of it, you know they have to go through it in order to evolve. So, it is only a minor inconvenience. Great job Kelli Estes!
June 4, 2025
The brutality of Highland clearances is laid bare, as we meet Sorcha and her son, evicted and chased from their home, so the wealthy landowners can graze, more profitable, sheep. They are accused of murder and they are running for their lives.
"Smoke on the Wind" is a time slip novel by Kelli Estes. 1801 Sorcha and her son Aonghas walking (as fast as little food and keeping off main roads will allow them) south from the highlands to Glasgow and modern day Keaka and son Colin are walking the West Highland Way, from Glasgow to Fort William. As she walks, Sorcha carves markings into rocks along the way. These marks cross the centuries and remain, being visible to modern day walkers. Keaka has a strong second site into the past....and sees visions of Sorcha and suddenly has the ability to speak Gaelic.
This powerful story reppresents the millions of Scots moved on as part of the clearances. Those with enough money moved to Canada, USA, UK and beyond spreading their Scots heritage worldwide.
"Smoke on the Wind" provides a wonderful first timer experience of Scotland...history, language, landscapes and the taste of IRN-BRU.
Sorcha and Keaka are connected many times in the book.....sometimes when they don't notice, by a common place. The other deeper connection is by the love of their sons, both who are at turning points in their lives, striking out on their own. Both mothers are clinging to their only children. So this is a story of mother-son relationships with all their secrets, protectionism, and teenage moods. Also explored is the concept of what home is; a physical place or people that surround you?
To me the lesson learned is of the need to ground yourself in nature. Walking a lonely path away from other people and distraction. Running away or running too your future.
Thanks to NetGalley, Kelli Estes and Lake Union Publishing for my copy. I eagerly await more riveting reads from Kelli.
"Smoke on the Wind" is a time slip novel by Kelli Estes. 1801 Sorcha and her son Aonghas walking (as fast as little food and keeping off main roads will allow them) south from the highlands to Glasgow and modern day Keaka and son Colin are walking the West Highland Way, from Glasgow to Fort William. As she walks, Sorcha carves markings into rocks along the way. These marks cross the centuries and remain, being visible to modern day walkers. Keaka has a strong second site into the past....and sees visions of Sorcha and suddenly has the ability to speak Gaelic.
This powerful story reppresents the millions of Scots moved on as part of the clearances. Those with enough money moved to Canada, USA, UK and beyond spreading their Scots heritage worldwide.
"Smoke on the Wind" provides a wonderful first timer experience of Scotland...history, language, landscapes and the taste of IRN-BRU.
Sorcha and Keaka are connected many times in the book.....sometimes when they don't notice, by a common place. The other deeper connection is by the love of their sons, both who are at turning points in their lives, striking out on their own. Both mothers are clinging to their only children. So this is a story of mother-son relationships with all their secrets, protectionism, and teenage moods. Also explored is the concept of what home is; a physical place or people that surround you?
To me the lesson learned is of the need to ground yourself in nature. Walking a lonely path away from other people and distraction. Running away or running too your future.
Thanks to NetGalley, Kelli Estes and Lake Union Publishing for my copy. I eagerly await more riveting reads from Kelli.
June 19, 2025
4.5 ⭐️
Now this book really makes me want to go to Scotland 🏴 It's a Historical Fiction story based around true events that I did not know anything about - "The Highland Clearances." It's my first Kelli Estes book and I enjoyed her writing style a lot. She filled the book with beautiful descriptions of the landscape. Cleverly, in some parts of the story she used Scottish Gaelic for names and locations.
It's an emotional and touching read told in a dual timeline. In present day, Keaka and her son Colin are hiking a long-distance trail in Scotland -"The West Highland Way" before he attends university in Glasgow. Two hundred years earlier, Sorcha Chisholm and her son, Aonghas are fleeing their burning home in the highlands and travelling the same trail. They are being pursued by the authorities for murder and Sorcha is desperately trying to get them to safety to Edinburgh. Both timelines meet some interesting and helpful people along the way. Keaka begins to see, "glimpses" into the past involving Sorcha and her son along the trail. It's an interesting take on a "sort of" time travel aspect. Can Keaka help Sorcha?
The main theme of the story is touching - the Mother/Son bond. While Keaka is feeling she is losing her son, Sorcha is trying to hang on to her son. What kept this from being 5 stars? I felt there were "some" parts that weren't needed and didn't add to the story. Still, those were very few. The Epilogue was good and brought tears to my eyes. To read more about the, "Scottish Clearances" make sure to read the Author's Note. Bonus points for the Scottish Gaelic Glossary at the end.
Publishes on June 24, 2025
I'd like to kindly thank NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for granting me access to this Advance Reader's Copy.
Now this book really makes me want to go to Scotland 🏴 It's a Historical Fiction story based around true events that I did not know anything about - "The Highland Clearances." It's my first Kelli Estes book and I enjoyed her writing style a lot. She filled the book with beautiful descriptions of the landscape. Cleverly, in some parts of the story she used Scottish Gaelic for names and locations.
It's an emotional and touching read told in a dual timeline. In present day, Keaka and her son Colin are hiking a long-distance trail in Scotland -"The West Highland Way" before he attends university in Glasgow. Two hundred years earlier, Sorcha Chisholm and her son, Aonghas are fleeing their burning home in the highlands and travelling the same trail. They are being pursued by the authorities for murder and Sorcha is desperately trying to get them to safety to Edinburgh. Both timelines meet some interesting and helpful people along the way. Keaka begins to see, "glimpses" into the past involving Sorcha and her son along the trail. It's an interesting take on a "sort of" time travel aspect. Can Keaka help Sorcha?
The main theme of the story is touching - the Mother/Son bond. While Keaka is feeling she is losing her son, Sorcha is trying to hang on to her son. What kept this from being 5 stars? I felt there were "some" parts that weren't needed and didn't add to the story. Still, those were very few. The Epilogue was good and brought tears to my eyes. To read more about the, "Scottish Clearances" make sure to read the Author's Note. Bonus points for the Scottish Gaelic Glossary at the end.
Publishes on June 24, 2025
I'd like to kindly thank NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for granting me access to this Advance Reader's Copy.
June 13, 2025
4.5 stars
Kelli Estes has such a beautiful, lyrical writing style that elicits strong emotions throughout the book. This historical fiction novel explores the relationship between mother and son in dual timeline (modern Day and early 1800s) as well as self reflection.
Two separate journeys are taking place, each of a mother and son as they bond together after overcoming tragedies.
Each story was easily relatable, as they are well told and quite detailed. As a mother of two grown sons, I could feel the moments of happiness, the moments of fear, the moments of heartbreak.
Many times, dual timelines can be tricky but here the two stories were woven together in a seamless way. The change in dialect helped distinguish between the two timelines even when the stories overlapped.
There’s a bit of a supernatural element in this book, but nothing too over the top and, while I don’t typically read books that contain things like that, I kept an open mind and felt it made things more interesting.
I loved the description of the beautiful landscape of Scotland with its colorful fields and lush countryside brought back memories of my visits to the lovely country. It was fun to once again visit the Scottish highlands as I read this book while learning about a sad piece of Scottish history, the “Scottish Clearances” which I knew nothing about prior to this.
Although I feel there were a few sections that could have been scaled back a bit, those areas were few and far between and I rather enjoyed this book as a whole. I would definitely pick up another book by Kelli Estes in the future.
Thank you to Netgalley and Lake Union Publishers for an ARC of this book. All opinions in this review are my own.
Kelli Estes has such a beautiful, lyrical writing style that elicits strong emotions throughout the book. This historical fiction novel explores the relationship between mother and son in dual timeline (modern Day and early 1800s) as well as self reflection.
Two separate journeys are taking place, each of a mother and son as they bond together after overcoming tragedies.
Each story was easily relatable, as they are well told and quite detailed. As a mother of two grown sons, I could feel the moments of happiness, the moments of fear, the moments of heartbreak.
Many times, dual timelines can be tricky but here the two stories were woven together in a seamless way. The change in dialect helped distinguish between the two timelines even when the stories overlapped.
There’s a bit of a supernatural element in this book, but nothing too over the top and, while I don’t typically read books that contain things like that, I kept an open mind and felt it made things more interesting.
I loved the description of the beautiful landscape of Scotland with its colorful fields and lush countryside brought back memories of my visits to the lovely country. It was fun to once again visit the Scottish highlands as I read this book while learning about a sad piece of Scottish history, the “Scottish Clearances” which I knew nothing about prior to this.
Although I feel there were a few sections that could have been scaled back a bit, those areas were few and far between and I rather enjoyed this book as a whole. I would definitely pick up another book by Kelli Estes in the future.
Thank you to Netgalley and Lake Union Publishers for an ARC of this book. All opinions in this review are my own.
June 20, 2025
SMOKE ON THE WIND gives Outlander vibes (without the spice!) in this dual timeline/POV novel with sweeping strokes of magical realism and historical fiction. Thank you @amazonpublishing & @kayepublicity for my early reading copy of @kelli.estes upcoming new release, out June 24th!
I enjoyed the audio narration of this novel, listening to the gaelic pronunciations and the characters shifting between English and their beautiful Scottish accents- definitely worth the listen if you like immersive reading while listening!
Sorcha + her son are on the run in her 1800s timeline during the novel. She begins appearing in Keaka’s mind during her modern day hiking of the West Highland Way with her son, Colin as they both deal with the loss of Adam (their husband/father).
Both women grow as characters while they walk through seemingly unimaginable pain through the novel. The historical fiction of the novel is a period (the Highland Clearances) is one I am not as familiar with, so I appreciated the Author’s Note at the end as this novel dives into the time period and is great for learning more.
I also loved learning that the novel blends Elli Estes’ love of Scotland, her hikes through the long trails and I could feel her through the writing! You can tell it is a passion!
If you enjoy Outlander, Scotland, Dual Timelines/Perspectives, strong FMCs, and hiking, you will enjoy this one!
I enjoyed the audio narration of this novel, listening to the gaelic pronunciations and the characters shifting between English and their beautiful Scottish accents- definitely worth the listen if you like immersive reading while listening!
Sorcha + her son are on the run in her 1800s timeline during the novel. She begins appearing in Keaka’s mind during her modern day hiking of the West Highland Way with her son, Colin as they both deal with the loss of Adam (their husband/father).
Both women grow as characters while they walk through seemingly unimaginable pain through the novel. The historical fiction of the novel is a period (the Highland Clearances) is one I am not as familiar with, so I appreciated the Author’s Note at the end as this novel dives into the time period and is great for learning more.
I also loved learning that the novel blends Elli Estes’ love of Scotland, her hikes through the long trails and I could feel her through the writing! You can tell it is a passion!
If you enjoy Outlander, Scotland, Dual Timelines/Perspectives, strong FMCs, and hiking, you will enjoy this one!
February 8, 2025
Smoke on the Wind kicks off with Sorcha desperately trying to save her son, Aonghas, from attackers—after already losing her husband and first son. From page one, I knew I’d love this book, and it did not disappoint. The high-stakes conflict had me holding my breath, afraid for Sorcha and her son. I also loved how Kelli first told us about Sorcha’s previous losses, making this moment hit even harder. Who wouldn’t want to keep reading after that?
Then we meet Keaka, who sets off on a hiking adventure with her son, Colin. Her journey is bittersweet—she’s soaking up precious time with him while dreading the day they’ll be apart.
This book beautifully captures the fierce, undying love of a mother. Kelli did an incredible job bringing the emotions to life. I felt the pain, the loss, the fear—and the triumphs—right along with these women, especially Sorcha. Both embark on hikes with their sons—Keaka’s for leisure and exploration, Sorcha’s for sheer survival. It felt like I was running with Sorcha and hiking with Keaka. I wanted to be right there, trekking through Scotland, soaking in the scenery. And yes, I’m absolutely the bed-and-breakfast type. Who’s with me? Let’s go!
This book was masterfully written. The pacing was spot-on, the descriptions vivid, and the tension kept me hooked. Honestly, I struggled to find anything to critique. The only thing I would have loved is a deeper exploration of what truly connects Sorcha and Keaka.
This isn’t just a great read—it’s an experience. One of the best books I’ve ever read. Pick it up. You won’t regret it!
Thank you to Lake Union Publishing and NetGalley for the complimentary copy. All opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Then we meet Keaka, who sets off on a hiking adventure with her son, Colin. Her journey is bittersweet—she’s soaking up precious time with him while dreading the day they’ll be apart.
This book beautifully captures the fierce, undying love of a mother. Kelli did an incredible job bringing the emotions to life. I felt the pain, the loss, the fear—and the triumphs—right along with these women, especially Sorcha. Both embark on hikes with their sons—Keaka’s for leisure and exploration, Sorcha’s for sheer survival. It felt like I was running with Sorcha and hiking with Keaka. I wanted to be right there, trekking through Scotland, soaking in the scenery. And yes, I’m absolutely the bed-and-breakfast type. Who’s with me? Let’s go!
This book was masterfully written. The pacing was spot-on, the descriptions vivid, and the tension kept me hooked. Honestly, I struggled to find anything to critique. The only thing I would have loved is a deeper exploration of what truly connects Sorcha and Keaka.
This isn’t just a great read—it’s an experience. One of the best books I’ve ever read. Pick it up. You won’t regret it!
Thank you to Lake Union Publishing and NetGalley for the complimentary copy. All opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
August 28, 2025
In this fun dual timeline historical fiction novel, readers follow recently widowed Keaka Denney and her son Colin as they take on a weeklong hike along the West Highland Way before Colin starts college in Glasgow. Shortly into their journey, however, Keaka begins to have disquieting visions of violence, a burning cottage, and a woman. In 1801, Sorcha Chisholm and her son were forced from their home and must walk the West Highland Way to get their fresh start, but this walk soon becomes a run from the law when Sorcha discovers she is wanted for a murder she did not commit. The characters are particularly well-written, and the crossing timelines adds some great drama and emotional depth to the story. The intensity of the emotional storylines really pull readers into the story and immerse them in Keaka and Sorcha’s distinct narratives. Neither perspective dominates the book, so both Keaka and Sorcha get equal control of the narrative, which lets the two storylines ramp up the intensity and have fantastic resolutions which readers will love. Intense, detailed, and fascinating, this Scottish historical fiction novel is incredibly written and packed with fantastic details that fans of the genre and great characters will love.
Thanks to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for the advance copy.
Thanks to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for the advance copy.
June 23, 2025
This book was so touching, and I’m still wrapping my head around it days after finishing it. It’s a dual timeline book, with focus on a mother and son relationship in each timeline. Not only that, but there’s some unexpected crossover between the timelines too!
Sorcha and her son were searching for safety after their house was burned down, they were told to leave, and they were accused of murder, set in the Scottish Highlands in 1801. Keaka and her son hiked through the Scottish highlands as a last trip before he starts college. But, it was planned for her late husband and son, and brought up more than Keaka bargained for. Between memories of her husband and visions, the hike had some unexpected moments.
These two women were strong. Sorcha and her dedication and perseverance. Her struggles to keep her son safe, and her motivation to do what she could to give him a better life. Keaka, enduring all that she did and working to protect her son as well. I appreciated both of these women and their dedication to their family.
The crossover? Unexpected, but it added so much to the story. I absolutely enjoyed it, and love how it connected the women,
My favorite part? Seeing these similarities and parallels in the two timelines. Completely differed ages. Very different circumstances. But their love for their sons, the paths they took, and the ending (I don’t want to spoil it).
Overall, a favorite of the year and it’s one that’s going to sit with me for a while.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, received from @kayepublicity @kelli.estes and @lakeunionauthors . However, all thoughts and views reflected are strictly my own opinions.
Sorcha and her son were searching for safety after their house was burned down, they were told to leave, and they were accused of murder, set in the Scottish Highlands in 1801. Keaka and her son hiked through the Scottish highlands as a last trip before he starts college. But, it was planned for her late husband and son, and brought up more than Keaka bargained for. Between memories of her husband and visions, the hike had some unexpected moments.
These two women were strong. Sorcha and her dedication and perseverance. Her struggles to keep her son safe, and her motivation to do what she could to give him a better life. Keaka, enduring all that she did and working to protect her son as well. I appreciated both of these women and their dedication to their family.
The crossover? Unexpected, but it added so much to the story. I absolutely enjoyed it, and love how it connected the women,
My favorite part? Seeing these similarities and parallels in the two timelines. Completely differed ages. Very different circumstances. But their love for their sons, the paths they took, and the ending (I don’t want to spoil it).
Overall, a favorite of the year and it’s one that’s going to sit with me for a while.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, received from @kayepublicity @kelli.estes and @lakeunionauthors . However, all thoughts and views reflected are strictly my own opinions.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 85 reviews