When Cruickshank admitted in the introduction that “I got all the information in these essays from popular science and history books,” I knew I wasn’t the right reader for this book. She engaged with a few academic papers, got books out from her local library (hooray for libraries), and spent a bit of time online, but each of these pieces reads like a blog post, haphazardly researched, overarching aim unclear.
Historically, reliably, I hate popular science and history books. I prefer when writers dive into a topic obsessively, cite sources rigorously, visit the archives in person where possible and, above all, engage with primary sources. If this is also your experience, give the collection a miss. If, however, you want to read essays on our exploitation of the natural world that would have made for solid early-2000s blog posts, and don’t mind that they needed editorial tightening and focus before being turned into a book, carry on.
I did enjoy a few of these the way I appreciate highlights from the depths of Wikipedia — the story of mass poisoning in 1951 Pont-Saint-Esprit, France, was new to me and compellingly described, though she lends far more credence to one journalist's CIA/LSD theory than any of the evidence warrants. I particularly liked Cruickshank’s account of Jemima Wilkinson’s rebirth as the Public Universal Friend in 1776, and could have read a collection on agender and trans experiences across the centuries (because they are not new, but an enduring part of the human experience; we are always at home and not at home in ourselves).
My favorite of the essays, though, and one I heartily recommend to any reader likely to pick this book up, is “Elektron,” Cruickshank’s take on amber. Here’s a snippet that shows some of her strengths as a writer and observer of the natural world.
The word elektron is like a handshake between ancient and modern peoples, between the Mesolithic and the Anthropocene. Amber itself is a reminder from the earth that humans are small and time is large and nature has many ways of healing its wounds.