1.5 stars
It wasn’t the best of times, it wasn’t the worst of times but definitely not the happiest of times. The book reads more like an exercise in clever abstraction than an attempt to tell a well-crafted story. Quin, the protagonist, is at once human and extreme. He's not always likable, but believable enough. His drinking, health issues, and uncertain online relationship with a Ukrainian woman provide through lines, yet they’re constantly chopped up by fragmented scenes and abrupt POV shifts.
At moments, if you isolate segments and ignore others, a worthwhile story peeks through. But a reader shouldn’t have to do that heavy lifting. Instead, the book leans into experiment for experiment’s sake. It’s hard to imagine it would have gained much notice without the Miles Franklin Award elevating it.