What do you think?
Rate this book
Chronicles of Elira #3
The Lost Rose
Book #3 in the Award winning Chronicles of Elira Series
Years have passed, the world has shifted, and the Eliran people have faced unimaginable loss.
Elgon, ensnared in a royal catastrophe, must navigate betrayals and personal grief. With his kingdom's fate hanging by a thread, he clings to a sliver of hope, waiting desperately for the return of his most trusted knight.
Malcolm's quest is a treacherous odyssey, fraught with danger and shrouded in secrecy. With a charge to rescue and protect, the weight of his past mistakes threatens to crush him. Can he redeem himself in the eyes of his brother and king, or will their secret mission be discovered and ended by their enemies?
Rosalie, isolated in a castle tower for most of her life, knows little of the world beyond her prison walls. Rescued by a mysterious stranger and propelled towards her destiny, she embarks on a perilous adventure. Will she survive the grueling journey, or will the trials of a lost heir prove too great?
A knight on a quest, a lost princess, a malevolent foreign ruler, and a secret of epic proportions will alter the fate and future of Elira forever.
Years have passed, the world has shifted, and the Eliran people have faced unimaginable loss.
Elgon, ensnared in a royal catastrophe, must navigate betrayals and personal grief. With his kingdom's fate hanging by a thread, he clings to a sliver of hope, waiting desperately for the return of his most trusted knight.
Malcolm's quest is a treacherous odyssey, fraught with danger and shrouded in secrecy. With a charge to rescue and protect, the weight of his past mistakes threatens to crush him. Can he redeem himself in the eyes of his brother and king, or will their secret mission be discovered and ended by their enemies?
Rosalie, isolated in a castle tower for most of her life, knows little of the world beyond her prison walls. Rescued by a mysterious stranger and propelled towards her destiny, she embarks on a perilous adventure. Will she survive the grueling journey, or will the trials of a lost heir prove too great?
A knight on a quest, a lost princess, a malevolent foreign ruler, and a secret of epic proportions will alter the fate and future of Elira forever.
593 pages, Kindle Edition
Published November 1, 2024
38 people are currently reading
553 people want to read
About the author
Victoria Lynn
9 books1,060 followersVictoria Lynn has an insatiable desire for truth, light, and beauty and has always sought to find them in story. Joining the Indie scene at the age of 18 with her debut novel, she has been writing and publishing ever since. She seeks to bring the life-giving words of the Savior to a dark and broken world that desperately needs to know of His sacrifice. A writing and publishing coach, best-selling author, seamstress and creator, she loves spending her spare time traveling deep into the mountains and forests, surfing the ocean waves, spending time with her family, turning her 2 acre plot into a homestead, or sewing gowns fit for a princess. She thinks perhaps she was once a woodland fairy and her current greatest desire is to own a mini-cow.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
November 1, 2024
Endorsement:
The Lost Rose kept me in suspense from the goosebump-worthy prologue to the very end. Fans of the prior two books will be so curious to see what’s happened to favorite characters in this third book and meet a new character to cheer for and love. Brace yourself for all the emotions in this book and dare to hold onto Hope with the characters. (And you might want to grab a box of tissues as well!) - Lindsey Z, Books for Christian Girls
🌹 🕊️ 🥹
About this book:
“Years have passed, the world has changed, and loss has punctuated the lives of the Eliran people.
A royal disaster, a changing country, and political alliances faltering at every turn, the land of Elira is struggling to maintain its borders, its perseverance… and its hope.
A knight on a quest, a lost princess, an evil foreign ruler, and a secret of epic proportions will change the face - and the future - of Elira forever.”
Series: Book #3 in “The Chronicles of Elira” series. Review of Book #1 Here! and Book #2 Here! (Best to read the books in order.)
Spiritual Content- Many, many Scriptures are quoted, remembered, mentioned, thought about, & discussed; Many, many prayers (including it being said that characters are praying in tongues (not written) and with incoherent words) & Thanking God; Worshiping & Hymns/songs of worship; Many talks about God, Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit, trusting in Him, Him always being with us, having hope, & witnessing; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God and Jesus; God speaks to the main characters (usually Scriptures changed to be as if God was saying it to them); Feeling peace from & the nearness of God; Taking communion together with a group; Rosalie was told that no matter what happened to her, the Lord’s words would always comfort her & has many Scriptures memorized; In his time of grief, Elgon asks God why something happened and what did he do wrong (a Scripture comes to mind at this); Elgon feels a sickening ache at the thought of going against an order from God (so he does not go against it); Many, many mentions of God, Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit, trusting in Him, having and holding onto hope, & having peace; Many mentions of prayers, praying, answered prayers, praying in tongues and in “words [the character] didn’t even know”, thanking God, & praising God; Mentions of witnessing & bringing Christ to other lands; Mentions of those & events in the Bible; Mentions of hymns & singing Scriptures; Mentions of Heaven (including being given a perfect body and soul & spending every second in worshiping the King of kings); Mentions of others being attuned to the spirit realm (including by prophetic dreams); Mentions of miracles; A few mentions of angels; A few mentions of blessings; A mention of fasting; A mention of someone having God-given magic (her talent for healing and helping others, not actual magic);
*Note: Religious phrases are said such as: “Mój boże.” is said once by a side character, a ‘God alive’, a ‘for the King’s sake’, a ‘for heaven’s sake’, a ‘law’ (exclamation), a ‘merciful heavens’, two ‘saints alive’, and two ‘sakes alive’; A person is said to have been “damned” to a life imprisonment; A man is called a demon; *Spoiler* ; Rosalie thinks that to truly know someone is to “know the depths of the evil inside” of the person and is concerned if others will see evil in her; Elgon feels the weight of his crown with the monarchs of past “hanging about the metal circlet like ghosts crowded around their past lives”; Rumors about Rosalie being a witch (locked in a tower) were spread & Malcolm uses it to their advantage (such as threatening that she’ll put a spell on the person of he talks about seeing her; This is done for her safety and Malcolm asks God to forgive him); When thinking about a certain forest that has rumors of ghosts and demons, Malcolm doesn’t doubt that there are demons as they use peoples’ fear against them and adds that “lands carried the sins of those that made them, and when allowed to stay, the evil was given a right to what should never have been under its authority in the first place” (but he notes he has a weapon that would defeat such spirits); Rosalie doesn’t believe in ghosts, but does wonder if there’s something that will harm them in a forest; Mentions of the devil & the enemy; Mentions of hell (Christ saving us from eternal hell, a battle being referred to as “the very gates of hell”, there being “hell to pay” if something happens, all hell breaking loose, “holding back hell” with a battle, someone taking in the “very depths of hell” to get someone back, Rosalie’s prison being referred to as “the hell” she had left twice, a literal mention of hell (the place), & the “hell” of someone’s injuries being his penance); Mentions of mountains and a forest that seem “otherworldly” and that is rumored to have “cursed/evil spirits”, ghosts, or “demons of the past” (the latter adds those demons are “witches and devils and the bodies of those [the king] had defeated who had been too cursed to pass into the heavenly realm”) lurking in them (someone else says that the people in that country believe in “witches, spirits and seances with ghosts” in the forest, but she and her group know there is only one Spirit, the Holy Spirit who is “more powerful than anything than they will ever give Him credit for”); Mentions of a superstitious country and the people there living in fear of a spiritual battle that may not exist because of the lack of knowledge about Christ; Mentions of rumored witches & them casting a spell on others (including rumors about Rosalie & an elderly woman that the villagers call a witch but is not one); Mentions of the ghosts of someone’s past; Mentions of evil (including evil people and their evil actions); A couple mentions of unseen force of darkness being felt; A couple mentions of bad memories being like ghosts trying to hunt someone down; A couple mentions of past demons (in someone’s life); A mention of “ungodly” voices in a forest; A mention of a “god forsaken” land; A mention of something not being written by God in the stars; A mention of hellfire befalling someone; A mention of an evil man being called a demon; A mention of a legend about the “king of the dark realm” mining a place and creating a castle; A mention of musicians casting a “spell” on their listeners; A mention of something calling to someone like a siren; A mention of a rabbit’s foot (to keep a plague away; not sincerely believed in and called witchcraft); A mention of a witches brew.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘blasted’, a cut-off “bit him on the a—“, a cut-off “horse—“, an ‘idiot’, a ‘shift it’, two ‘stupid’s, and five ‘shut up’s; Mentions of curses (said, but not written including by Malcolm); A bit of eye rolling; Good characters lie to the enemy for the sake of their or others’ safety; Almost falling off a cliff, a cave-in, Fighting/Attacking, Shooting arrows, Being shot/shot at, Being slapped, Being kicked, Being captured/tied-up, Being sick, Pain, Injuries, Blisters, Blood/Bleeding, Passing out, & Throwing up (up to semi-detailed); *Spoiler* ; Grief & Heartbreak/Pain (up to semi-detailed); Recalling fighting, battles, pain, injuries, blood/bleeding, & throwing up (up to semi-detailed); Seeing someone with a slit throat & not being able to be saved (border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed); Seeing fighting, battles, someone held at knife-point, others injured and bleeding/blood, & bodies (up to semi-detailed); Seeing the death of a pony (falling off a cliff and crying over it) & a horse being shot by an arrow (border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed); A villain slaps his son (in his point of view, up to semi-detailed); Rosalie recalls her childhood days of pain and abuse (barely-above-not-detailed); Malcolm is tempted to kill someone and call it self-defense (though it would be unprovoked and an enemy); Both Rosalie & Malcolm have a hot toddy to get warm; During communion, Malcolm has a sip of the wine (unsaid if Rosalie does); Later, Malcom is given wine to drink for his injuries; Malcolm acts drunk to get by some guards; Elgon doesn’t care for wine after losing his memory (Book #1) and being unable to control his own mind; *Spoilers* ; Rosalie grieves someone she believe has died & also what could have been (had she not be taken from her parents); Many, many mentions of wars, battles, fighting, being under attack, weapons, deaths, & bodies (up to semi-detailed); Many mentions of slavery, slaves, slave traders, being held captive, hostages, prison-like places, & abuse; Many mentions of fevers/illnesses, injuries, pain, blood/bleeding, & losing limbs (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of villages being ransacked/raided, stealing, & deaths; Mentions of plagues & deaths; Mentions of poisons & deaths/murders; Mentions of deaths, grieving (including of missing loved ones), & widows and orphans; Mentions of people willing to lay down their lives for others or their country (including for Rosalie); Mentions of guards roughing Rosalie around (& getting in trouble for it as they’re not supposed to harm her); Mentions of possible injuries (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of throwing up; Mentions of alcohol, drinking (including for injuries and to stay warm), & drunks; Mentions of gossip & rumors; Mentions of lies, lying, & liars; Mentions of nightmares (including ones of Rosalie waking up that she is going to be held captive again by an enemy); Mentions of tattoos (including by a group of good people to recognize others in their group; looked upon positively); Mentions of hunting & traps; A few mentions of starving children; A few mentions of hatred; A couple mentions of torture; A couple mentions of threatening to slit someone’s throat (a hostage); A couple mentions of burns/scars; A couple mentions of jealousy; A mention of a fire sacrifice; A mention of gambling; A mention of wolves attacking shepherds and their flock; A mention of a place smelling like a chamber pot;
*Note: Rosalie recalls the feeling of being held captive & struggles to breath when thinking about it and possibly being held captive again at times; Both Rosalie and Malcom have a negative voice telling them lies (including Rosalie not understand why others believe her to be worth a great sacrifice on their parts); Malcolm feels like a failure and has guilt over not being able to protect someone & at one point, thinks he deserves to die; Malcolm doesn’t want to get married or have children because he was seen others grieve and doesn’t want to be the reason someone has a lifetime of sorrow.
Sexual Content- A hand kiss and seven kisses by married couples (most barely-above-not-detailed with one being borderline to semi-detailed); A few touches, embraces, nearness, & smelling between a married couple (borderline barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed); Rosalie expects that the king’s plan for her is to join his courtesans (which she adds that those women are “nice enough” but that they have to live their lives pleasing the king and she hopes there’s more for her life than that); The king wants Rosalie brought to him on her fifteenth birthday & she didn’t understand as a child, but started to understand as a teen when he would visit her more frequently with a look that brought her “fear and confusion” (*Spoiler*); A guard grabs Rosalie’s face and says she’s becoming pretty (she demands he let her go and he slaps her; it’s said that other guards that tried to touch her were never heard from again as she is the king’s); Mentions of girls being rescued from another country (implied human trafficking and/or prostitution) & a bordello (added that the young women were rescued from a place they were in against their wills and “made to do things that no human being should ever have to do outside of their own wishes or desires”); Mentions of married couples kissing & their kisses (barely-above-not-detailed); A couple mentions of blushes; A mention of a woman (who is hinted to have been abused by men) shuddering when innocently touched by a man; A mention of a flirtatious grin;
*Note: A mention of a mother nursing her baby.
-Rosalie
-Malcum
-Elgon
P.O.V. switches between them & others
602 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- Two Stars
Early High School Teens- Three Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars (and a half)
I have so many emotions and I don’t know where to start. When I first began this book, I was eager to find out what’s happened to these characters in the last fourteen years, but also very nervous as well. Which was totally fair and reasonable because ahhh! So much has happened and not all of it is good. My heart is ripped out of my chest a bit, I won’t lie over that ending, but I’m holding onto hope that we’ll see certain characters again in the next book.
Speaking of hope. The faith content in this book was absolutely lovely and so incredibly encouraging to read. The messaging of hanging onto hope and fully trusting on God is something I so needed to read and it touched my heart in more ways than one. The faiths, prayers, Scriptures, and living fully for the Lord is such a prevalent part of this book and is truly the backbone of the plot in such a brilliant way.
To my fellow fans of the prior two books: Brace yourself. That’s all I can say without giving spoilers, but know that as I say those two words about twenty different emotions flashed on my face and tears welled up in my eyes. Brace yourself.
I had goosebumps at the prologue and was kept in suspense the entire book, waiting on two important scenes to happen. Like I said above, my heart is slightly battered after reading everything that these characters have gone through in the last fourteen years since the first book and then also in just the current-day setting of this book. So many scenes played out in my head like a movie, which not every book does that for me. I think that’s why this book flew by despite being 600+ pages long—and probably because I was desperate for reunion scenes.
Rosalie was a dear girl and has been through so much in her fourteen years. While I’m never quite sure what to think about characters in books getting older and reading about their children, I could see so much of her parents in her and that truly endeared her to me. Her faith, courage, and outlook on life was all so similar to Violet and Elgon, my heart was warmed by it. Also seeing her open up to Malcom and him to her was precious. The protector/uncle storyline was so well-done and such an important part of this book that I immensely enjoyed.
I needed book four yesterday when I started this book, haha. If anyone needs me, I’m going to be cuddled with an emotional-support, fluffy blanket and a cup of tea until it releases. I’m only slightly kidding as I type that. Only slightly. I’ll just be here, waiting and holding onto hope for a certain reunion scene. (Please, dear author, please.)
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Author for this honest review and endorsement.
The Lost Rose kept me in suspense from the goosebump-worthy prologue to the very end. Fans of the prior two books will be so curious to see what’s happened to favorite characters in this third book and meet a new character to cheer for and love. Brace yourself for all the emotions in this book and dare to hold onto Hope with the characters. (And you might want to grab a box of tissues as well!) - Lindsey Z, Books for Christian Girls
🌹 🕊️ 🥹
About this book:
“Years have passed, the world has changed, and loss has punctuated the lives of the Eliran people.
A royal disaster, a changing country, and political alliances faltering at every turn, the land of Elira is struggling to maintain its borders, its perseverance… and its hope.
A knight on a quest, a lost princess, an evil foreign ruler, and a secret of epic proportions will change the face - and the future - of Elira forever.”
Series: Book #3 in “The Chronicles of Elira” series. Review of Book #1 Here! and Book #2 Here! (Best to read the books in order.)
Spiritual Content- Many, many Scriptures are quoted, remembered, mentioned, thought about, & discussed; Many, many prayers (including it being said that characters are praying in tongues (not written) and with incoherent words) & Thanking God; Worshiping & Hymns/songs of worship; Many talks about God, Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit, trusting in Him, Him always being with us, having hope, & witnessing; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God and Jesus; God speaks to the main characters (usually Scriptures changed to be as if God was saying it to them); Feeling peace from & the nearness of God; Taking communion together with a group; Rosalie was told that no matter what happened to her, the Lord’s words would always comfort her & has many Scriptures memorized; In his time of grief, Elgon asks God why something happened and what did he do wrong (a Scripture comes to mind at this); Elgon feels a sickening ache at the thought of going against an order from God (so he does not go against it); Many, many mentions of God, Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit, trusting in Him, having and holding onto hope, & having peace; Many mentions of prayers, praying, answered prayers, praying in tongues and in “words [the character] didn’t even know”, thanking God, & praising God; Mentions of witnessing & bringing Christ to other lands; Mentions of those & events in the Bible; Mentions of hymns & singing Scriptures; Mentions of Heaven (including being given a perfect body and soul & spending every second in worshiping the King of kings); Mentions of others being attuned to the spirit realm (including by prophetic dreams); Mentions of miracles; A few mentions of angels; A few mentions of blessings; A mention of fasting; A mention of someone having God-given magic (her talent for healing and helping others, not actual magic);
*Note: Religious phrases are said such as: “Mój boże.” is said once by a side character, a ‘God alive’, a ‘for the King’s sake’, a ‘for heaven’s sake’, a ‘law’ (exclamation), a ‘merciful heavens’, two ‘saints alive’, and two ‘sakes alive’; A person is said to have been “damned” to a life imprisonment; A man is called a demon; *Spoiler* ; Rosalie thinks that to truly know someone is to “know the depths of the evil inside” of the person and is concerned if others will see evil in her; Elgon feels the weight of his crown with the monarchs of past “hanging about the metal circlet like ghosts crowded around their past lives”; Rumors about Rosalie being a witch (locked in a tower) were spread & Malcolm uses it to their advantage (such as threatening that she’ll put a spell on the person of he talks about seeing her; This is done for her safety and Malcolm asks God to forgive him); When thinking about a certain forest that has rumors of ghosts and demons, Malcolm doesn’t doubt that there are demons as they use peoples’ fear against them and adds that “lands carried the sins of those that made them, and when allowed to stay, the evil was given a right to what should never have been under its authority in the first place” (but he notes he has a weapon that would defeat such spirits); Rosalie doesn’t believe in ghosts, but does wonder if there’s something that will harm them in a forest; Mentions of the devil & the enemy; Mentions of hell (Christ saving us from eternal hell, a battle being referred to as “the very gates of hell”, there being “hell to pay” if something happens, all hell breaking loose, “holding back hell” with a battle, someone taking in the “very depths of hell” to get someone back, Rosalie’s prison being referred to as “the hell” she had left twice, a literal mention of hell (the place), & the “hell” of someone’s injuries being his penance); Mentions of mountains and a forest that seem “otherworldly” and that is rumored to have “cursed/evil spirits”, ghosts, or “demons of the past” (the latter adds those demons are “witches and devils and the bodies of those [the king] had defeated who had been too cursed to pass into the heavenly realm”) lurking in them (someone else says that the people in that country believe in “witches, spirits and seances with ghosts” in the forest, but she and her group know there is only one Spirit, the Holy Spirit who is “more powerful than anything than they will ever give Him credit for”); Mentions of a superstitious country and the people there living in fear of a spiritual battle that may not exist because of the lack of knowledge about Christ; Mentions of rumored witches & them casting a spell on others (including rumors about Rosalie & an elderly woman that the villagers call a witch but is not one); Mentions of the ghosts of someone’s past; Mentions of evil (including evil people and their evil actions); A couple mentions of unseen force of darkness being felt; A couple mentions of bad memories being like ghosts trying to hunt someone down; A couple mentions of past demons (in someone’s life); A mention of “ungodly” voices in a forest; A mention of a “god forsaken” land; A mention of something not being written by God in the stars; A mention of hellfire befalling someone; A mention of an evil man being called a demon; A mention of a legend about the “king of the dark realm” mining a place and creating a castle; A mention of musicians casting a “spell” on their listeners; A mention of something calling to someone like a siren; A mention of a rabbit’s foot (to keep a plague away; not sincerely believed in and called witchcraft); A mention of a witches brew.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘blasted’, a cut-off “bit him on the a—“, a cut-off “horse—“, an ‘idiot’, a ‘shift it’, two ‘stupid’s, and five ‘shut up’s; Mentions of curses (said, but not written including by Malcolm); A bit of eye rolling; Good characters lie to the enemy for the sake of their or others’ safety; Almost falling off a cliff, a cave-in, Fighting/Attacking, Shooting arrows, Being shot/shot at, Being slapped, Being kicked, Being captured/tied-up, Being sick, Pain, Injuries, Blisters, Blood/Bleeding, Passing out, & Throwing up (up to semi-detailed); *Spoiler* ; Grief & Heartbreak/Pain (up to semi-detailed); Recalling fighting, battles, pain, injuries, blood/bleeding, & throwing up (up to semi-detailed); Seeing someone with a slit throat & not being able to be saved (border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed); Seeing fighting, battles, someone held at knife-point, others injured and bleeding/blood, & bodies (up to semi-detailed); Seeing the death of a pony (falling off a cliff and crying over it) & a horse being shot by an arrow (border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed); A villain slaps his son (in his point of view, up to semi-detailed); Rosalie recalls her childhood days of pain and abuse (barely-above-not-detailed); Malcolm is tempted to kill someone and call it self-defense (though it would be unprovoked and an enemy); Both Rosalie & Malcolm have a hot toddy to get warm; During communion, Malcolm has a sip of the wine (unsaid if Rosalie does); Later, Malcom is given wine to drink for his injuries; Malcolm acts drunk to get by some guards; Elgon doesn’t care for wine after losing his memory (Book #1) and being unable to control his own mind; *Spoilers* ; Rosalie grieves someone she believe has died & also what could have been (had she not be taken from her parents); Many, many mentions of wars, battles, fighting, being under attack, weapons, deaths, & bodies (up to semi-detailed); Many mentions of slavery, slaves, slave traders, being held captive, hostages, prison-like places, & abuse; Many mentions of fevers/illnesses, injuries, pain, blood/bleeding, & losing limbs (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of villages being ransacked/raided, stealing, & deaths; Mentions of plagues & deaths; Mentions of poisons & deaths/murders; Mentions of deaths, grieving (including of missing loved ones), & widows and orphans; Mentions of people willing to lay down their lives for others or their country (including for Rosalie); Mentions of guards roughing Rosalie around (& getting in trouble for it as they’re not supposed to harm her); Mentions of possible injuries (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of throwing up; Mentions of alcohol, drinking (including for injuries and to stay warm), & drunks; Mentions of gossip & rumors; Mentions of lies, lying, & liars; Mentions of nightmares (including ones of Rosalie waking up that she is going to be held captive again by an enemy); Mentions of tattoos (including by a group of good people to recognize others in their group; looked upon positively); Mentions of hunting & traps; A few mentions of starving children; A few mentions of hatred; A couple mentions of torture; A couple mentions of threatening to slit someone’s throat (a hostage); A couple mentions of burns/scars; A couple mentions of jealousy; A mention of a fire sacrifice; A mention of gambling; A mention of wolves attacking shepherds and their flock; A mention of a place smelling like a chamber pot;
*Note: Rosalie recalls the feeling of being held captive & struggles to breath when thinking about it and possibly being held captive again at times; Both Rosalie and Malcom have a negative voice telling them lies (including Rosalie not understand why others believe her to be worth a great sacrifice on their parts); Malcolm feels like a failure and has guilt over not being able to protect someone & at one point, thinks he deserves to die; Malcolm doesn’t want to get married or have children because he was seen others grieve and doesn’t want to be the reason someone has a lifetime of sorrow.
Sexual Content- A hand kiss and seven kisses by married couples (most barely-above-not-detailed with one being borderline to semi-detailed); A few touches, embraces, nearness, & smelling between a married couple (borderline barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed); Rosalie expects that the king’s plan for her is to join his courtesans (which she adds that those women are “nice enough” but that they have to live their lives pleasing the king and she hopes there’s more for her life than that); The king wants Rosalie brought to him on her fifteenth birthday & she didn’t understand as a child, but started to understand as a teen when he would visit her more frequently with a look that brought her “fear and confusion” (*Spoiler*); A guard grabs Rosalie’s face and says she’s becoming pretty (she demands he let her go and he slaps her; it’s said that other guards that tried to touch her were never heard from again as she is the king’s); Mentions of girls being rescued from another country (implied human trafficking and/or prostitution) & a bordello (added that the young women were rescued from a place they were in against their wills and “made to do things that no human being should ever have to do outside of their own wishes or desires”); Mentions of married couples kissing & their kisses (barely-above-not-detailed); A couple mentions of blushes; A mention of a woman (who is hinted to have been abused by men) shuddering when innocently touched by a man; A mention of a flirtatious grin;
*Note: A mention of a mother nursing her baby.
-Rosalie
-Malcum
-Elgon
P.O.V. switches between them & others
602 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- Two Stars
Early High School Teens- Three Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars (and a half)
I have so many emotions and I don’t know where to start. When I first began this book, I was eager to find out what’s happened to these characters in the last fourteen years, but also very nervous as well. Which was totally fair and reasonable because ahhh! So much has happened and not all of it is good. My heart is ripped out of my chest a bit, I won’t lie over that ending, but I’m holding onto hope that we’ll see certain characters again in the next book.
Speaking of hope. The faith content in this book was absolutely lovely and so incredibly encouraging to read. The messaging of hanging onto hope and fully trusting on God is something I so needed to read and it touched my heart in more ways than one. The faiths, prayers, Scriptures, and living fully for the Lord is such a prevalent part of this book and is truly the backbone of the plot in such a brilliant way.
To my fellow fans of the prior two books: Brace yourself. That’s all I can say without giving spoilers, but know that as I say those two words about twenty different emotions flashed on my face and tears welled up in my eyes. Brace yourself.
I had goosebumps at the prologue and was kept in suspense the entire book, waiting on two important scenes to happen. Like I said above, my heart is slightly battered after reading everything that these characters have gone through in the last fourteen years since the first book and then also in just the current-day setting of this book. So many scenes played out in my head like a movie, which not every book does that for me. I think that’s why this book flew by despite being 600+ pages long—and probably because I was desperate for reunion scenes.
Rosalie was a dear girl and has been through so much in her fourteen years. While I’m never quite sure what to think about characters in books getting older and reading about their children, I could see so much of her parents in her and that truly endeared her to me. Her faith, courage, and outlook on life was all so similar to Violet and Elgon, my heart was warmed by it. Also seeing her open up to Malcom and him to her was precious. The protector/uncle storyline was so well-done and such an important part of this book that I immensely enjoyed.
I needed book four yesterday when I started this book, haha. If anyone needs me, I’m going to be cuddled with an emotional-support, fluffy blanket and a cup of tea until it releases. I’m only slightly kidding as I type that. Only slightly. I’ll just be here, waiting and holding onto hope for a certain reunion scene. (Please, dear author, please.)
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Author for this honest review and endorsement.
November 1, 2024
This book, is the kind of story we need a little more of.
With action and loss and growth and light, there are few books I would trust to place in the hands of my kids one day, and know that it will be a joy and encouragement to them, but this is one.
Lynn writes about hard topics in this story, but she does it in a way that reminds me a lot of one of my favorite childhood series, Crown and Covenant by Doug Bond. This book I think fits perfectly into about that same age range, but on the girls side. That series is for boys around 12-16, and this one I think would be perfect for girls around 13-17. It's got redemption and shame and guilt and hope and many good things for teens to be reading about, with heroes who struggle *and then continue to fight* for what is right.
That's the kind of thing we need.
“Since it is so likely that children will meet cruel enemies, let them at least have heard of brave knights and heroic courage. Otherwise you are making their destiny not brighter but darker.” -C.S Lewis.
The writing style is youthful in places, but I think it's meant to be, because Lynn aims to keep this story simple, while still speaking of truth, something that she did well.
Looking forward to sharing this with younger girls I know who are looking for stories to read that remind us of courage.
With action and loss and growth and light, there are few books I would trust to place in the hands of my kids one day, and know that it will be a joy and encouragement to them, but this is one.
Lynn writes about hard topics in this story, but she does it in a way that reminds me a lot of one of my favorite childhood series, Crown and Covenant by Doug Bond. This book I think fits perfectly into about that same age range, but on the girls side. That series is for boys around 12-16, and this one I think would be perfect for girls around 13-17. It's got redemption and shame and guilt and hope and many good things for teens to be reading about, with heroes who struggle *and then continue to fight* for what is right.
That's the kind of thing we need.
“Since it is so likely that children will meet cruel enemies, let them at least have heard of brave knights and heroic courage. Otherwise you are making their destiny not brighter but darker.” -C.S Lewis.
The writing style is youthful in places, but I think it's meant to be, because Lynn aims to keep this story simple, while still speaking of truth, something that she did well.
Looking forward to sharing this with younger girls I know who are looking for stories to read that remind us of courage.
November 9, 2024
This book was a hunk! Almost 600 pages y'all! I can't believe I finished it in like 5 days! I mean...there was a small bit of skimming involved...but only a little.
Characters:
Rosalie was a darling, so sweet despite all that she had been through. I just wanted to hug here the whole time!
Malcolm was conflicted, so weighted down by his self-appointed failures. I felt so bad for him. Just wanted to hug and slap some sense into him at the same time. But how can you not love a guy who's willing to give everything he has for his charge...and everything is not an understatement.
Elgon...wow, hats off to you, man. I would not have handled the situation as well as he did...I'd have been a crumbled heap or have made things ten times worse with my impulsiveness.
I loved Kenton and Tobias! They were so great!
And Nim! I wanted more Nim! Like so much more Nim!
It was also great to see bits and pieces of characters we'd met in the other books, Everard here, Marcus and Dalara there, bit of Violet, and some Fendrel! Even Rensen got a few mentions and a couple of lines!
Themes:
Holding onto hope even in the deepest of dark times. Even when there doesn't seem to be any hope left to be had. It was a beautifully rich theme and incorporated very well.
Language:
A few uses of h-e-double hockey sticks, pertaining to down under.
Romance:
A few kisses and touches between married couples, nothing inapproriate.
Violence/Gore:
Someone battles, being chased, mentions of slaves, mentions of blood seeping from a wound or blocking vision. Mentions of their being too much blood, people white or pale. A character loses a limb, not detailed. Mentions of blood pooling on the ground, cover hands, ect. Nothing super gory but there are several mentions of blood. Just fyi.
Magic:
N/A
Overall:
This was a really good book and I really enjoyed it! The world building, the themes, the plot, quite enjoyable. I rated 4 stars because I'm a bit upset about a certain character that I won't mention because of spoilers and because I skimmed a bit at parts to get to other characters, such as Rosalie and Malcolm...sorry, Elgon! I just really needed to know what happened to them so I skimmed some of your chapters a bit! I don't normally do that but because Elgon's were in the past I had most the important details filled in from Malcolm taking to Rosalie *shrugs* it happened.
I did enjoy the story overall, though book 2, This Life of Mine, is still my favorite in the series! Marcus has me heart, y'all. Okay? Nuh, said there.
I would recommend this for ages 15+
Themes are a bit heavy, not overly so.
Characters:
Rosalie was a darling, so sweet despite all that she had been through. I just wanted to hug here the whole time!
Malcolm was conflicted, so weighted down by his self-appointed failures. I felt so bad for him. Just wanted to hug and slap some sense into him at the same time. But how can you not love a guy who's willing to give everything he has for his charge...and everything is not an understatement.
Elgon...wow, hats off to you, man. I would not have handled the situation as well as he did...I'd have been a crumbled heap or have made things ten times worse with my impulsiveness.
I loved Kenton and Tobias! They were so great!
And Nim! I wanted more Nim! Like so much more Nim!
It was also great to see bits and pieces of characters we'd met in the other books, Everard here, Marcus and Dalara there, bit of Violet, and some Fendrel! Even Rensen got a few mentions and a couple of lines!
Themes:
Holding onto hope even in the deepest of dark times. Even when there doesn't seem to be any hope left to be had. It was a beautifully rich theme and incorporated very well.
Language:
A few uses of h-e-double hockey sticks, pertaining to down under.
Romance:
A few kisses and touches between married couples, nothing inapproriate.
Violence/Gore:
Someone battles, being chased, mentions of slaves, mentions of blood seeping from a wound or blocking vision. Mentions of their being too much blood, people white or pale. A character loses a limb, not detailed. Mentions of blood pooling on the ground, cover hands, ect. Nothing super gory but there are several mentions of blood. Just fyi.
Magic:
N/A
Overall:
This was a really good book and I really enjoyed it! The world building, the themes, the plot, quite enjoyable. I rated 4 stars because I'm a bit upset about a certain character that I won't mention because of spoilers and because I skimmed a bit at parts to get to other characters, such as Rosalie and Malcolm...sorry, Elgon! I just really needed to know what happened to them so I skimmed some of your chapters a bit! I don't normally do that but because Elgon's were in the past I had most the important details filled in from Malcolm taking to Rosalie *shrugs* it happened.
I did enjoy the story overall, though book 2, This Life of Mine, is still my favorite in the series! Marcus has me heart, y'all. Okay? Nuh, said there.
I would recommend this for ages 15+
Themes are a bit heavy, not overly so.
April 24, 2025
Well, this book was heartbreaking.
November 1, 2024
😭🥰🌹🕊️👑⚔️✝️🤗🥹
Release day review:
The Lost Rose
By Victoria Lynn
5⭐️ (could be 6⭐️)
Wow! Such an amazing story filled with trials, hope, and themes that will last for a lifetime.
Victoria Lynn knocks it out of the park with Book 3 of the Chronicles of Elira. The world grows tremendously for the reader as we explore different cultures, lands, and people. This story is heartbreakingly beautiful. It tore my heart to shreds, but is slowly being put back together by the hopeful ending and the Healer Himself.
Plot: Extremely intriguing. Lynn threads high action moments against the calm, cozy times. The plot was so intriguing that I found it difficult to ever put the book down. Her pacing was phenomenal, because this is a 600+ page book, and I flew through the last 400ish pages. The intensity and complexity of the plot is compelling and gripping. Malcolm, Rosalie, and Elgon are the main characters who truly make the story what it is.
Setting: Beautifully done. The way Lynn mixes culture with description was one of my favorite parts. It is great storytelling lesson, but for a reader, it makes the scenes of a book feel and look like scenes in a movie. My favorite non-character part was definitely the cultural aspects in the people we meet. The Vagari was literally stunning. I want more time with them! The Highlanders, enemy lands, and Elira were description-filled in a way that showed you what was going on, not told.
Characters: My absolute favorite part. Elgon…loved seeing him so much. He was such a delight, but at the same time I found it so easy to connect with him and his emotions. Rosalie is such an amazingly hopeful character. It’s hard to characterize her in just a few words. She has such a strong will, and she didn’t let her circumstances break her, but rather chose to bloom. I adored her strength and curiosity for the world around her with the determination from her parents. Malcolm was an interesting character. He seems so tough and unemotional, but that doesn’t mean he has no heartaches. He will was unbreakable. His faith ran deep, but was realistic. The side characters and villains were done stupendous. I loved how each had such a deep personality.
Overall, an outstanding book in the realm of Christian fiction. Now, I will willingly sign a petition for a certain character who deserves justice. If you know who that is, let’s start a petition. To the author, please! We are gently begging you!! Also, I am so ready for book four. I know it’s going to be amazing!
Content: violence (semi-detailed), h-word and d-word (used in context), minor romance content (lightly detailed), lightly detailed aspects of human trafficking (handled in a beautiful, Christian way), mentions of and praying in tongues (lightly detailed)
Release day review:
The Lost Rose
By Victoria Lynn
5⭐️ (could be 6⭐️)
Wow! Such an amazing story filled with trials, hope, and themes that will last for a lifetime.
Victoria Lynn knocks it out of the park with Book 3 of the Chronicles of Elira. The world grows tremendously for the reader as we explore different cultures, lands, and people. This story is heartbreakingly beautiful. It tore my heart to shreds, but is slowly being put back together by the hopeful ending and the Healer Himself.
Plot: Extremely intriguing. Lynn threads high action moments against the calm, cozy times. The plot was so intriguing that I found it difficult to ever put the book down. Her pacing was phenomenal, because this is a 600+ page book, and I flew through the last 400ish pages. The intensity and complexity of the plot is compelling and gripping. Malcolm, Rosalie, and Elgon are the main characters who truly make the story what it is.
Setting: Beautifully done. The way Lynn mixes culture with description was one of my favorite parts. It is great storytelling lesson, but for a reader, it makes the scenes of a book feel and look like scenes in a movie. My favorite non-character part was definitely the cultural aspects in the people we meet. The Vagari was literally stunning. I want more time with them! The Highlanders, enemy lands, and Elira were description-filled in a way that showed you what was going on, not told.
Characters: My absolute favorite part. Elgon…loved seeing him so much. He was such a delight, but at the same time I found it so easy to connect with him and his emotions. Rosalie is such an amazingly hopeful character. It’s hard to characterize her in just a few words. She has such a strong will, and she didn’t let her circumstances break her, but rather chose to bloom. I adored her strength and curiosity for the world around her with the determination from her parents. Malcolm was an interesting character. He seems so tough and unemotional, but that doesn’t mean he has no heartaches. He will was unbreakable. His faith ran deep, but was realistic. The side characters and villains were done stupendous. I loved how each had such a deep personality.
Overall, an outstanding book in the realm of Christian fiction. Now, I will willingly sign a petition for a certain character who deserves justice. If you know who that is, let’s start a petition. To the author, please! We are gently begging you!! Also, I am so ready for book four. I know it’s going to be amazing!
Content: violence (semi-detailed), h-word and d-word (used in context), minor romance content (lightly detailed), lightly detailed aspects of human trafficking (handled in a beautiful, Christian way), mentions of and praying in tongues (lightly detailed)
November 3, 2024
I had the honor of beta reading “The Lost Rose,” and it has since become my favorite book yet in the Chronicles of Elira series. It's also my personal opinion that it is Victoria’s best work yet, out of all of her books, not just this series.
This book is rather chunky and that’s because its story is more complex than the previous two. The story follows three different perspectives: King Elgon, Princess Rosalie, and the knight Malcolm. The story follows Rosalie and Malcolm’s adventure trying to get back home to Elira and we also have flashbacks from the king’s perspective to show us what happened in the years since his family went missing. The scope of this story could easily become overwhelming for any writer, but Victoria handles it so skillfully.
For one thing, I appreciated that this wasn't a romance. It was refreshing to see something more like a father/daughter relationship between the princess and her rescuing knight as they both helped each other learn to heal from the pains of the past. Meanwhile, I adored how the flashbacks to Elgon's past were perfectly timed to give more insight into the present-day situation, and how that storyline eventually caught up to and connected with the present day to bring all the characters together into one place.
I also loved seeing so much more of this world than we had before. It felt so big and lived in. I especially loved the Vagari people and the faith that infuses their culture. Faith infused the entire book, really, and I loved that too!
Overall, nothing that I say can truly capture the scope and depth of this story, so you're just going to have to go read it. ;) I'm already excited to read this story all over and to see what comes next in this beautiful series!
This book is rather chunky and that’s because its story is more complex than the previous two. The story follows three different perspectives: King Elgon, Princess Rosalie, and the knight Malcolm. The story follows Rosalie and Malcolm’s adventure trying to get back home to Elira and we also have flashbacks from the king’s perspective to show us what happened in the years since his family went missing. The scope of this story could easily become overwhelming for any writer, but Victoria handles it so skillfully.
For one thing, I appreciated that this wasn't a romance. It was refreshing to see something more like a father/daughter relationship between the princess and her rescuing knight as they both helped each other learn to heal from the pains of the past. Meanwhile, I adored how the flashbacks to Elgon's past were perfectly timed to give more insight into the present-day situation, and how that storyline eventually caught up to and connected with the present day to bring all the characters together into one place.
I also loved seeing so much more of this world than we had before. It felt so big and lived in. I especially loved the Vagari people and the faith that infuses their culture. Faith infused the entire book, really, and I loved that too!
Overall, nothing that I say can truly capture the scope and depth of this story, so you're just going to have to go read it. ;) I'm already excited to read this story all over and to see what comes next in this beautiful series!
January 30, 2025
Wow. I highlighted so many lines in this book. It’s been a bit since I’ve read anything from the Chronicles of Elira, but I jumped into this book without a refresh and I’m ok with that decision. First off, this book is huge. Like plot-wise and page-wise. I did find myself feeling like the first-half of the book dragged a bit, but I think part of that is the necessary buildup that pays off in the second-half. I’m just impatient to know what happens sometimes. 😂 Sometimes the descriptions of everything felt like they were pulling me out of the story, but again, I find the second-half really well written. I really did love the theme of hope. And Christian Fantasy books with strong characters and good character development are so needed in the book world. I did like this book, but maybe not as much as the previous two in the series? The ending did have me a little teary eyed (iykyk)
Sorry if this review is a little all over the place. It’s just hard to encapsulate my thoughts for this book for some reason.
Sorry if this review is a little all over the place. It’s just hard to encapsulate my thoughts for this book for some reason.
January 17, 2025
I love the story but it kinda ruined the 1st book for me. I mean the fact that Violet died really threw me off. I felt like it didint complement the other books in the seires. (Victoria, I cant read the 1st book without silently weeping!) Violet was one of my favorite people in the series. But I love the authors passion to write good books!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 31, 2024
Wow! 😍 The Lost Rose by Victoria Lynn is the medieval, faith-filled, epic adventure fantasy of your dreams. I stayed up way past my bedtime to finish this book because I simply could not put it down! At 560 pages long, it is a formidable read but worth every page turned and hour(s) of sleep lost! This is the third book in Victoria’s Chronicles Of Elira series. While it can be read as a standalone novel, I highly recommend you read the first two to get a better understanding of the side characters and their backstories. This is a non-magical fantasy!
This novel follows three different points of view - Malcolm, Elgon, and Rosalie - and spans over the course of 14 years! Victoria does a fantastic job of keeping the pace and the switch between the three different views only adds depth and richness to the tale. This story takes a delightfully noticeable turn from the previous two novels by adding a larger cast of characters and thrilling and suspenseful action. The romance is very light and is not the main focus of the plot or storyline. If you enjoy excellent character development and depth, Victoria Lynn knocks it out of the park with this one! 😍
This book does not shy away from Christ - faith is a central character in the story. It was both endearing and heartbreaking to read the struggles and growth (some painful) that each of the characters went through at a time when everything in the Kingdom of Elira seemed to be on its head. This novel truly is a testament to the fact that no matter how dark the world may seem, Christ’s light shines brighter still. Victoria does not avoid the ugly truth of sin while wrapping it beautifully with the power and grace of Christ who is the only one powerful enough to overcome. This book tackles hard questions and there was more than one time I found myself questioning how I would have reacted if such a tragedy were to ever occur in my life. This read is both inspiring and convicting.
Thanks to the author’s generosity, I received a complimentary copy of this novel. All opinions expressed in this review are truly my own and a positive review was not required.
This novel follows three different points of view - Malcolm, Elgon, and Rosalie - and spans over the course of 14 years! Victoria does a fantastic job of keeping the pace and the switch between the three different views only adds depth and richness to the tale. This story takes a delightfully noticeable turn from the previous two novels by adding a larger cast of characters and thrilling and suspenseful action. The romance is very light and is not the main focus of the plot or storyline. If you enjoy excellent character development and depth, Victoria Lynn knocks it out of the park with this one! 😍
This book does not shy away from Christ - faith is a central character in the story. It was both endearing and heartbreaking to read the struggles and growth (some painful) that each of the characters went through at a time when everything in the Kingdom of Elira seemed to be on its head. This novel truly is a testament to the fact that no matter how dark the world may seem, Christ’s light shines brighter still. Victoria does not avoid the ugly truth of sin while wrapping it beautifully with the power and grace of Christ who is the only one powerful enough to overcome. This book tackles hard questions and there was more than one time I found myself questioning how I would have reacted if such a tragedy were to ever occur in my life. This read is both inspiring and convicting.
Thanks to the author’s generosity, I received a complimentary copy of this novel. All opinions expressed in this review are truly my own and a positive review was not required.
January 29, 2025
4.5 Stars!
I've waited so long for this story and its ending is bittersweet. So well written! There's only a few small issues I had (faith wise) but they were minor and easy to over look. This book gave me chills, hope and a longing to serve our King even more <3
I've waited so long for this story and its ending is bittersweet. So well written! There's only a few small issues I had (faith wise) but they were minor and easy to over look. This book gave me chills, hope and a longing to serve our King even more <3
April 4, 2025
Overall, I enjoyed the story itself.
There were more than a few spelling/punctuation errors that distracted me a lot [ex. “taught” instead of the correct “taut” multiple times throughout the book].
There were more than a few spelling/punctuation errors that distracted me a lot [ex. “taught” instead of the correct “taut” multiple times throughout the book].
November 17, 2024
“Stay strong, but hold onto hope. The world may press on your shoulders and try to make you collapse, but hope in the darkest of times will get you through anything. He is hope. Never fear.”
This is an EPIC read that you'll want to pick up and read again and again.
Take time to savor this big beautiful book like a nice cup of coffee or a favorite chocolate bar.
This is the biggest book I've ever read on Kindle or paperback to date, and it is an amazing read! It took me a while to read it, but it was worth every minute.
The writing style was perfectly poetical, and made the chapters fly by. The scenery is described some, but not in a boring sort of way.
The great cast of characters and their struggles were relatable. I especially loved the scenes with Violet and Elgon, and the Vagari camp scene.
I really appreciated the encouraging faith content in this book as well. It was so good, and something I haven't seen as much of in many books.
Here's another quote from the book that I loved:
"Truth would be unearthed, no matter the cost, as long as hope was fought for with a tenacious grip."
The Lost Rose is a breathtaking tale of faith, grit, and finding your way home.
I'm glad to recommend it.
I received a complimentary e-book from the author to review as part of her launch team. I was not required to write a positive review, and the thoughts above are my own.
Content Review
There's not a huge lot here, but just a couple things to mention.
Fool and fools is used a total of three times (a couple times it was thought not spoken), and hell or hellfire is used six times, but only in reference to evil (not as a swear word, but I wasn't really comfortable with it), a regime that rejoiced in evil, and bouts of tortuous guilt and grief that one person suffered.
A mention of someone wanting "to curse the ground, the enemy, and the plans that had been laid and the thievery of youth that had pervaded his country."
I still absolutely love this book, and I'd definitely recommend it, but this was the reason I rated it 4 stars instead of 5.
This is an EPIC read that you'll want to pick up and read again and again.
Take time to savor this big beautiful book like a nice cup of coffee or a favorite chocolate bar.
This is the biggest book I've ever read on Kindle or paperback to date, and it is an amazing read! It took me a while to read it, but it was worth every minute.
The writing style was perfectly poetical, and made the chapters fly by. The scenery is described some, but not in a boring sort of way.
The great cast of characters and their struggles were relatable. I especially loved the scenes with Violet and Elgon, and the Vagari camp scene.
I really appreciated the encouraging faith content in this book as well. It was so good, and something I haven't seen as much of in many books.
Here's another quote from the book that I loved:
"Truth would be unearthed, no matter the cost, as long as hope was fought for with a tenacious grip."
The Lost Rose is a breathtaking tale of faith, grit, and finding your way home.
I'm glad to recommend it.
I received a complimentary e-book from the author to review as part of her launch team. I was not required to write a positive review, and the thoughts above are my own.
Content Review
There's not a huge lot here, but just a couple things to mention.
Fool and fools is used a total of three times (a couple times it was thought not spoken), and hell or hellfire is used six times, but only in reference to evil (not as a swear word, but I wasn't really comfortable with it), a regime that rejoiced in evil, and bouts of tortuous guilt and grief that one person suffered.
A mention of someone wanting "to curse the ground, the enemy, and the plans that had been laid and the thievery of youth that had pervaded his country."
I still absolutely love this book, and I'd definitely recommend it, but this was the reason I rated it 4 stars instead of 5.
May 3, 2025
When I was reading the final climax of this book, I couldn’t put it down. I literally brought it into the restaurant, and sat there crying at the table when I finished!
The sacrifices made from these characters is inspiring, and so meaningful. I just could feel their failures, triumphs, grief, and joy right along side them.
4.5 ⭐️, as the leading up to the end was just a touch too long for me, but I do understand why as it had to cover many different character’s POVs.
“She named me Rosalie,” she whispered. His breath caught…🌹
The sacrifices made from these characters is inspiring, and so meaningful. I just could feel their failures, triumphs, grief, and joy right along side them.
4.5 ⭐️, as the leading up to the end was just a touch too long for me, but I do understand why as it had to cover many different character’s POVs.
“She named me Rosalie,” she whispered. His breath caught…🌹
March 7, 2025
What a stunning read! My favorite in the series so far!
October 11, 2024
This book is #3 of The Chronicles of Elira series, yet it maintains the wonderful ability to stand on its own. I have not yet been able to read the previous two books in this series ( Once I Knew and This Life of Mine), but in no way did I feel like I was missing any pieces of the story. This is one of those rare pieces of literature that needs another whole book of praise written to almost do it justice. If The Lord of the Rings and The Chronicles of Narnia had a baby that was a book with elements of your favorite fairytales and legends mixed in, the result would be The Lost Rose. Victoria Lynn’s old-fashioned more literary style is a hard sought after treasure in these modern times. Someone please write this book a soundtrack because that is the only thing that could possibly be missing.
I was so honored to be selected as an E-ARC reader for The Lost Rose and the first pages had me feeling literal chills. As a King James Version user myself I was excited to learn that all the scripture in this book was from the KJV. For two nights in a row I stayed up entirely too late reading, completely immersed in this gut-wrenching, soul-searching work; desperate to learn what happened next to this incredibly well-rounded cast of characters. The men truly embody the warrior poet spirit; while the women, not afraid to fight and die for what they believe or those they love, maintain strength in their nurturing femininity. Each supporting character was so well developed I was left wanting to know more of their individual stories.
One of the things I most appreciated about this book was the author’s willingness to show the true darkness which lurks in this world, but in such a way that it merely served to reveal just how brightly the Light of Christ shines in contrast. In illustrating the sin and sorrow found on this earth, Victoria Lynn simultaneously reminds us to look to the sweetness of Heaven for our hope and true healing. I also found the little glimpses of romance between the married characters so sweet and refreshing. The Lost Rose is a message of hope, a showcase of faith, and a testament to bravery; not only of and from the characters, but the author’s own heart and soul.
However, I did find myself disappointed in the end by a *certain* element of the plot. While I completely understand the significance this element holds for the greater spiritual theme and message of the book, my human fleshly self was still saddened. Now please excuse me while I go think about this until the end of time. You can find me in a corner crying and re-reading The Lost Rose until my eyes want to fall out.
The only criticism I can find to make would be the mention of characters “praying in tongues” on multiple occasions. This is simply a doctrine I personally do not adhere to. However, this is the author’s story to tell, not mine, so I will leave that between her and the Lord.
In conclusion, The Lost Rose is one of the best books I have read in a very very long time. Please please please do yourself a favor and check it out.
I was so honored to be selected as an E-ARC reader for The Lost Rose and the first pages had me feeling literal chills. As a King James Version user myself I was excited to learn that all the scripture in this book was from the KJV. For two nights in a row I stayed up entirely too late reading, completely immersed in this gut-wrenching, soul-searching work; desperate to learn what happened next to this incredibly well-rounded cast of characters. The men truly embody the warrior poet spirit; while the women, not afraid to fight and die for what they believe or those they love, maintain strength in their nurturing femininity. Each supporting character was so well developed I was left wanting to know more of their individual stories.
One of the things I most appreciated about this book was the author’s willingness to show the true darkness which lurks in this world, but in such a way that it merely served to reveal just how brightly the Light of Christ shines in contrast. In illustrating the sin and sorrow found on this earth, Victoria Lynn simultaneously reminds us to look to the sweetness of Heaven for our hope and true healing. I also found the little glimpses of romance between the married characters so sweet and refreshing. The Lost Rose is a message of hope, a showcase of faith, and a testament to bravery; not only of and from the characters, but the author’s own heart and soul.
However, I did find myself disappointed in the end by a *certain* element of the plot. While I completely understand the significance this element holds for the greater spiritual theme and message of the book, my human fleshly self was still saddened. Now please excuse me while I go think about this until the end of time. You can find me in a corner crying and re-reading The Lost Rose until my eyes want to fall out.
The only criticism I can find to make would be the mention of characters “praying in tongues” on multiple occasions. This is simply a doctrine I personally do not adhere to. However, this is the author’s story to tell, not mine, so I will leave that between her and the Lord.
In conclusion, The Lost Rose is one of the best books I have read in a very very long time. Please please please do yourself a favor and check it out.
November 20, 2024
Victoria Lynn is the author through whom I discovered the concept of "clean Christian fiction". Her books are filled with hope, courage, and faith, and The Lost Rose is no different, though it may be her best one yet.
Set as an epic adventure, this book follows three main characters, each with a unique set of fears and struggles they must overcome. This makes them instantly lovable and relatable, and their progress becomes an inspiration, as well as a plea for perseverance in the face of adversity, of hope in spite of evil.
The Lost Rose also greatly expands the world of Elira, introducing us to new places and characters, while also giving us more insight into the lives of well-known and well-loved characters from previous books. Personally, I enjoyed the worldbuilding, which is done elegantly, without overloading us with information.
Another thing that shines in this book is the Christian themes, which are visible even to the untrained eye. Each character has a personal relationship with their Saviour, and the book highlights how God can talk differently to people, meeting everyone where they are and using even the broken and unprepared to shine a light in this dark world.
What I loved most though is what I initially feared I would dislike the most, that being the alternating POVs between past and present. It wasn't hard to follow, and the conclusion resonated with me: you may not see now how God is working, but if you trust His timing, he can work miracles that will touch so many lives. The fourteen years that this book spans feels like a lifetime (which, for the younger readers, it is), yet in the waiting and uncertainty, God's faithfulness shines through.
Lastly, another highlight for me was the ending. At one point the book had fallen into a sort of rhythm and I thought I knew where it was going, but the climax took an unexpected turn, which brought me even more satisfaction for the ending.
All in all, The Lost Rose rose to my expectations and even exceeded them. Definitely a must-read for all Christian fiction lovers!
Set as an epic adventure, this book follows three main characters, each with a unique set of fears and struggles they must overcome. This makes them instantly lovable and relatable, and their progress becomes an inspiration, as well as a plea for perseverance in the face of adversity, of hope in spite of evil.
The Lost Rose also greatly expands the world of Elira, introducing us to new places and characters, while also giving us more insight into the lives of well-known and well-loved characters from previous books. Personally, I enjoyed the worldbuilding, which is done elegantly, without overloading us with information.
Another thing that shines in this book is the Christian themes, which are visible even to the untrained eye. Each character has a personal relationship with their Saviour, and the book highlights how God can talk differently to people, meeting everyone where they are and using even the broken and unprepared to shine a light in this dark world.
What I loved most though is what I initially feared I would dislike the most, that being the alternating POVs between past and present. It wasn't hard to follow, and the conclusion resonated with me: you may not see now how God is working, but if you trust His timing, he can work miracles that will touch so many lives. The fourteen years that this book spans feels like a lifetime (which, for the younger readers, it is), yet in the waiting and uncertainty, God's faithfulness shines through.
Lastly, another highlight for me was the ending. At one point the book had fallen into a sort of rhythm and I thought I knew where it was going, but the climax took an unexpected turn, which brought me even more satisfaction for the ending.
All in all, The Lost Rose rose to my expectations and even exceeded them. Definitely a must-read for all Christian fiction lovers!
November 5, 2024
From the first chapter, I was hooked.
The story and characters were so well thought out, the prose was meaningful, and the message was clear. God's light is with you even in the darkest of places. He will never leave you, or let you go.
Even though this is quite the chonky read, I buzzed through it and loved being absorbed into the world of Elira with their noble king, secret spies, and fierce determination to rescue those in need. I loved all the side characters and felt their kinship with the FMC Rosalie deeply.
This is a book that leaves you feeling whole again, hopeful, and able to face down the dark pits in your life. It comes at a poignant time in my own life, and I will treasure this book, the characters, and the truths within for a long time. After reading the ARC, I promptly bought myself the hardcover and can't wait to see its beautiful cover grace my shelves.
The Lost Rose can be read as a stand-alone or as the third book in The Chronicles of Elira saga. I would recommend to anyone looking for a book to spend some time with, who loves historical fantasy, secret hideaways, and colorful descriptions. To those who may be critics of the amount of Scripture used, I would say the verses shared here were used so seamlessly, I found it highly appropriate and a salve to my soul. Not every book is for every person and The Lost Rose does not shy away from the critical importance of a healthy, personal relationship with the Lord Jesus. The Holy Spirit is highlighted and I found that to be a refreshing change.
The story and characters were so well thought out, the prose was meaningful, and the message was clear. God's light is with you even in the darkest of places. He will never leave you, or let you go.
Even though this is quite the chonky read, I buzzed through it and loved being absorbed into the world of Elira with their noble king, secret spies, and fierce determination to rescue those in need. I loved all the side characters and felt their kinship with the FMC Rosalie deeply.
This is a book that leaves you feeling whole again, hopeful, and able to face down the dark pits in your life. It comes at a poignant time in my own life, and I will treasure this book, the characters, and the truths within for a long time. After reading the ARC, I promptly bought myself the hardcover and can't wait to see its beautiful cover grace my shelves.
The Lost Rose can be read as a stand-alone or as the third book in The Chronicles of Elira saga. I would recommend to anyone looking for a book to spend some time with, who loves historical fantasy, secret hideaways, and colorful descriptions. To those who may be critics of the amount of Scripture used, I would say the verses shared here were used so seamlessly, I found it highly appropriate and a salve to my soul. Not every book is for every person and The Lost Rose does not shy away from the critical importance of a healthy, personal relationship with the Lord Jesus. The Holy Spirit is highlighted and I found that to be a refreshing change.
December 18, 2025
The Lost Rose is a sweeping and emotionally resonant continuation of the award-winning Chronicles of Elira, deepening the series’ themes of faith, sacrifice, redemption, and destiny. Set in a world reshaped by loss and political upheaval, this third installment broadens the scope of Elira while drawing readers closer to its characters’ inner struggles.
Lynn skillfully interweaves multiple character arcs, each carrying its own emotional weight. Elgon’s storyline is marked by grief and quiet endurance as he navigates betrayal and the fragile survival of his kingdom. His longing for the return of a trusted knight underscores the novel’s strong emphasis on loyalty and hope amid despair. Malcolm’s journey, by contrast, is a tense and morally complex quest for redemption, where past failures loom as large as the dangers he faces in the present.
Rosalie’s arc is especially compelling a sheltered life giving way to a perilous awakening. Her transformation from imprisoned innocence to a figure of destiny is handled with sensitivity and purpose, reinforcing the novel’s exploration of identity, calling, and courage. Together, these narratives converge into a story rich with intrigue, spiritual undertones, and epic consequence.
The Lost Rose will strongly appeal to readers of epic and Christian fantasy who value character-driven storytelling, moral depth, and richly imagined medieval worlds. It’s a powerful installment that raises the stakes for Elira while rewarding long-time readers with emotional payoff and thematic depth.
Lynn skillfully interweaves multiple character arcs, each carrying its own emotional weight. Elgon’s storyline is marked by grief and quiet endurance as he navigates betrayal and the fragile survival of his kingdom. His longing for the return of a trusted knight underscores the novel’s strong emphasis on loyalty and hope amid despair. Malcolm’s journey, by contrast, is a tense and morally complex quest for redemption, where past failures loom as large as the dangers he faces in the present.
Rosalie’s arc is especially compelling a sheltered life giving way to a perilous awakening. Her transformation from imprisoned innocence to a figure of destiny is handled with sensitivity and purpose, reinforcing the novel’s exploration of identity, calling, and courage. Together, these narratives converge into a story rich with intrigue, spiritual undertones, and epic consequence.
The Lost Rose will strongly appeal to readers of epic and Christian fantasy who value character-driven storytelling, moral depth, and richly imagined medieval worlds. It’s a powerful installment that raises the stakes for Elira while rewarding long-time readers with emotional payoff and thematic depth.
October 25, 2024
This is the third book in The Chronicles of and it's my new favorite book in this series! It's amazing and well-written!
Malcolm is on a quest to rescue Rosalie who is hidden away in enemy territory. The epic adventure they go on isn't easy. It's filled with danger at every turn, but Malcolm and Rosalie turn to God through prayer and scripture as they cling to Hope in Christ. It's a beautifully written tale that is both heartbreaking and heartwarming, but also redemptive!
Possible concerns/my thoughts.
There is some mild violence. Most of it is non-descriptive.
There are multiple references to praying in tongues which I wouldn't agree with theologically, but I do appreciate how they quickly turn to God In prayer.
Without giving away any spoilers there is something that broke my heart and made me cry, but at the same time it's also
beautiful and redemptive and I love it! You will understand when you read it.
What I love.
I love the Christian themes throughout the book, especially that of hope.
I like the strong, godly marriage between Rosalie's parents.
I admire Malcolm's willingness to lay down his life if need be to save his friend's daughter. This reminds me of John 15:13.
This story shows the importance of teaching children about God at a young age. Rosalie had been taught well, and her faith runs deep!
Malcolm is on a quest to rescue Rosalie who is hidden away in enemy territory. The epic adventure they go on isn't easy. It's filled with danger at every turn, but Malcolm and Rosalie turn to God through prayer and scripture as they cling to Hope in Christ. It's a beautifully written tale that is both heartbreaking and heartwarming, but also redemptive!
Possible concerns/my thoughts.
There is some mild violence. Most of it is non-descriptive.
There are multiple references to praying in tongues which I wouldn't agree with theologically, but I do appreciate how they quickly turn to God In prayer.
Without giving away any spoilers there is something that broke my heart and made me cry, but at the same time it's also
beautiful and redemptive and I love it! You will understand when you read it.
What I love.
I love the Christian themes throughout the book, especially that of hope.
I like the strong, godly marriage between Rosalie's parents.
I admire Malcolm's willingness to lay down his life if need be to save his friend's daughter. This reminds me of John 15:13.
This story shows the importance of teaching children about God at a young age. Rosalie had been taught well, and her faith runs deep!
October 3, 2024
Once again, Victoria’s writing has left me at a loss for words to describe how much this story touched me. God’s hand has guided the heart that wrote this story, and it is clear within every page. Your heart will be shattered, but your soul will be stirred as well as renewed. This book is a beautiful reminder of the Hope that carries us through the darkness.
My heart has formed a beautiful and unexplainable bond with the characters and their stories. I have celebrated with them in their victories, grieved with them in their heartache, and hoped against all hopes when all seemed lost. They have become much more than real to me.
I cannot recommend this story—and the message woven within—enough.
“You carry the light of Christ, which gives you hope.”
~ Victoria Lynn
My heart has formed a beautiful and unexplainable bond with the characters and their stories. I have celebrated with them in their victories, grieved with them in their heartache, and hoped against all hopes when all seemed lost. They have become much more than real to me.
I cannot recommend this story—and the message woven within—enough.
“You carry the light of Christ, which gives you hope.”
~ Victoria Lynn
November 4, 2024
This was such a good continuation of the Chronicles of Elira series!! I loved the sense of adventure and suspense that came from Lynn's talent for detailed and intentional writing, and I felt that the world was really able to expand as the story goes where it does. I loved Rosalie and Malcolm as main characters; their grit and determination and Hope in the midst of dark circumstances was very well written. The only reason I gave 4 stars instead of 5 was because there were times where the story felt slow or repetitive (with the characters constantly flipping in and out of danger, meeting new people then moving on, etc). But just like the rest of the series, I finished it feeling happy! I can't wait for the next book to come out!
November 16, 2024
Wow! This was such a moving and incredible story! The way faith is woven into a world entirely of Victoria Lynn's creation is stunning.
I had not read her previous books before this one so I was not prepared for how deeply these characters would touch me. I cried so much through the last 100 pages. Her writing is excellent and she truly captures all the turmoil of despair and elation of joy. I felt like I was reading something akin to The Chronicles of Narnia or The Fellowship of the Ring.
I absolutely recommend this book for anyone looking for clean, faith driven stories that have adventure, battles and realistic characters.
Can't wait to get my hands on the other books in this series!!
I had not read her previous books before this one so I was not prepared for how deeply these characters would touch me. I cried so much through the last 100 pages. Her writing is excellent and she truly captures all the turmoil of despair and elation of joy. I felt like I was reading something akin to The Chronicles of Narnia or The Fellowship of the Ring.
I absolutely recommend this book for anyone looking for clean, faith driven stories that have adventure, battles and realistic characters.
Can't wait to get my hands on the other books in this series!!
January 9, 2025
A fantastic third installment in The Chronicles of Elira! This book fairly bristled with action through its entirety! A knight on a quest and a lost princess searching for her family? What’s not to love!?
I absolutely adored all of the different groups of people we encounter in this book and I loved seeing more of the landscape. I kind of want to spend a couple of weeks with Duncan and his family!
Of course, Everard makes an appearance and I will once again emphatically state my NEED for a book about him. He is my favorite character!
I wasn’t expecting to get teary and that took me by surprise. One character seems to do an awful lot of tripping (she must have terrible balance). I can’t wait for the next book!
I absolutely adored all of the different groups of people we encounter in this book and I loved seeing more of the landscape. I kind of want to spend a couple of weeks with Duncan and his family!
Of course, Everard makes an appearance and I will once again emphatically state my NEED for a book about him. He is my favorite character!
I wasn’t expecting to get teary and that took me by surprise. One character seems to do an awful lot of tripping (she must have terrible balance). I can’t wait for the next book!
June 29, 2025
A beautiful story of Hope.
I have loved reading Victoria’s series the Chronicles of Elira, and this 3rd book has been a beautiful addition to the series. Victoria does a fantastic job creating the kingdom of Elira and it’s surrounding countries, the people there, and the extraordinary ways God ties the threads of their lives together, creating a beautiful tapestry of truth, light, hope, and redemption. Victoria masterfully weaves these fantasy stories into a picture of God’s sovereignty, and the strength and hope found in Him no matter our circumstances. The Lost Rose continues on that legacy of storytelling that points the reader to something greater, and encourages the weary soul, with hope, redemption and light written into every page. I look forward to more of this series to come!
I have loved reading Victoria’s series the Chronicles of Elira, and this 3rd book has been a beautiful addition to the series. Victoria does a fantastic job creating the kingdom of Elira and it’s surrounding countries, the people there, and the extraordinary ways God ties the threads of their lives together, creating a beautiful tapestry of truth, light, hope, and redemption. Victoria masterfully weaves these fantasy stories into a picture of God’s sovereignty, and the strength and hope found in Him no matter our circumstances. The Lost Rose continues on that legacy of storytelling that points the reader to something greater, and encourages the weary soul, with hope, redemption and light written into every page. I look forward to more of this series to come!
December 27, 2024
Victoria Lynn books go deep in a way that leaves you entertained yet spiritually full at the same time. This book was no exception! And all of her books also tend to bring on the tears, so this time I was prepared with tissues (yet not prepared for how many I would need!)
Rosalie was the best teenage main character I have seen in a long time! She is not only relatable to other teens and has weaknesses, but she acknowledges them while not letting them hold her back. I loved seeing her push herself and overcome obstacles while admitting she was scared the whole time! Overall, this book was excellent!
And may I say how much I loved how chunky this book is!!! #bigbooklover
Rosalie was the best teenage main character I have seen in a long time! She is not only relatable to other teens and has weaknesses, but she acknowledges them while not letting them hold her back. I loved seeing her push herself and overcome obstacles while admitting she was scared the whole time! Overall, this book was excellent!
And may I say how much I loved how chunky this book is!!! #bigbooklover
May 11, 2025
This became my book to read before bed for a while. It was good but not the edge of your seat couldn't put it down good. That with the biblical truths throughout and the lovable characters made it a perfect book to end the day.
I will say I thought the author spent too much time on some parts. It was like she was rewording parts over and over for an artistic effect that seemed a little much at times. Also, one of the POVs, though I understand why it was there, took me out of the story a bit. These are more preferences rather than remarks on the author's ability.
I already have a list of friends I plan to recommend these books to.
I will say I thought the author spent too much time on some parts. It was like she was rewording parts over and over for an artistic effect that seemed a little much at times. Also, one of the POVs, though I understand why it was there, took me out of the story a bit. These are more preferences rather than remarks on the author's ability.
I already have a list of friends I plan to recommend these books to.
November 7, 2024
I just finished the arc copy of this book and when I say it is one of the best books I have ever read, it is not an exaggeration. Victoria does such a good job of getting you into the world of Eliria. By the end of the book you feel like you know the characters personally and could call them your friend. This is book three of the series and I highly recommend that you read them in order. Not only for the timeline aspect of it, but you get to know and enjoy the characters on a deeper level. If you're still thinking about reading it, just do it...you won't regret it.
March 6, 2025
My favorite things about this book:
1) The beautiful variety of platonic relationships.
2) The Vagari. I loved this vibrant culture and people group! Can we have a whole book about them, please?
3) The CHILDREN. It seems that children are strangely absent from the vast majority of fantasy books, and it was so refreshing to meet adorable little kiddos at every turn in this story.
4) The men who sacrificially protect those in their charge. They reminded me of how things should be--how God created things to be.
1) The beautiful variety of platonic relationships.
2) The Vagari. I loved this vibrant culture and people group! Can we have a whole book about them, please?
3) The CHILDREN. It seems that children are strangely absent from the vast majority of fantasy books, and it was so refreshing to meet adorable little kiddos at every turn in this story.
4) The men who sacrificially protect those in their charge. They reminded me of how things should be--how God created things to be.
December 8, 2024
Words can’t even describe how much I loved this book. Ever since I read the first two books in the series, The Chronicles of Elira have occupied a huge part of my heart.
They are so full of the Holy Spirit and hope, and the characters all feel so real. Like I’ve known them forever.
The message of hope and salvation are everything I’ve always wanted in a book, but never quite found until I read Victoria’s books. ❤️🔥❤️🔥
They are so full of the Holy Spirit and hope, and the characters all feel so real. Like I’ve known them forever.
The message of hope and salvation are everything I’ve always wanted in a book, but never quite found until I read Victoria’s books. ❤️🔥❤️🔥
January 23, 2025
Very touching story! Seemed a bit long at times, but you needed all the details to get the full picture. It does have multiple points of view from different characters and from different time periods, which I usually don't like that style but it worked very well for this book. It was very spiritally uplifting, and I cried in places. Loved the story and took only 4 days to read! Would recommend it to anyone! 5/5 stars
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews