My rating: 3.75/5 stars ⭐⭐⭐
BOOKISH YAYS!
*The cover. I cannot get over how lovely it is! I’ve given up not judging books by their covers at this point. A book’s cover is it’s first impression, and this one made a very good impression on me!
*The character development. There are 8 main characters in this book and several more minor ones. Sometimes with a large cast, especially in the fantasy genre, it is hard not to only focus on your main character, and the others recede to the background or may display stereotypes of certain people/behaviors. (the villain, the sidekick, the mentor, etc) However, each main character had a distinct personality and voice. Gabe, Bandit, and Tara were my favorite characters by far!
*The worldbuilding was very complex and well-rounded. Worldbuilding (or lack thereof) can make or break a story, and I enjoyed certain aspects in The Shattered Ones such as the sci-fi desert vibes, the way characters interacted with technology, and the layers of history and backstory which are revealed throughout.
*Gabe's first-person narrative. There were times when I felt like he fell into a bit of the stereotypical “I’m an orphan; therefore, I don’t deserve love/I can’t let myself care for others” YA protagonist, overall, he had a good story arc and raw voice which pulled me in. He had a good arc as well, his journey taking him to a place where he had to confront the lies he believed and step up to face his fears.
*Caleb & Tara’s relationship as husband and wife was so sweet. Under the joking, you could see they deeply cared for each other. They complemented (and complimented) each other so well. I wanted them to be able to go back to their quiet, safe life so badly!
*The Shattered abilities were cool! For some reason, it reminded me of Star Wars?1
BOOKISH OKAYS:
*While I loved the friendships present throughout this book (especially Caleb & Tara’s and Bandit & Gabriel’s), I had a hard time with the fact that 80% of the friendship we see is people “bantering” or using sarcasm. There were serious moments, but they felt too overshadowed.
*Some of the worldbuilding felt a bit overwhelming, but this may be because I haven’t read a lot of sci-fi or dystopian stories. From the ending, it seems that the author will write another book and so some questions may be answered there.
*I wish there had been more of a faith element to this book. I feel it could have helped develop several of the characters. At one point, a character is mentioned as praying his friends are safe. But we never see Who he prays to, and it’s never mentioned again.
BOOKISH NAYS:
*Swearing. Okay, this was the main reason for the lowered rating. I went into this book expecting a clean, YA read. And for the most part, it delivered. Now, characters do say things like “stupid” and “idiot” which I personally don’t care for. There are also mentions of d*** several times as well as how YA fiction usually covers language - by referring to it without the words - “cursed,” “swore a blue streak,” “I didn’t know the words but they must have been swearing,” etc. This seems to be the main reaction of the adult characters in The Shattered Ones whenever they are mad. One character in particular seemed to have this reaction. And towards the end, this ramped up (b*****d, p****d off, etc. 😭) It felt as though once you were invested enough in the story to keep going to the end (because it does ramp up, and I was very invested) the characters could speak freer because you would ignore it to get to the end? So that was a bit of a let-down.
OVERALL…
This was an interesting read. I wish there hadn’t been instances of swearing, as I probably would have given it a 4 or 4.5 star rating then. Apart from that, I am glad I read it. It reminded me that I haven’t read much sci-fi outside of CS Lewis’ Space Trilogy!