Morvenn Vahl is the Abbess Sanctorum and a High Lord of Terra, a warrior born and a faithful daughter of the Emperor. Yet she is only mortal, performing no miracles, untouched by divinity, and though she was chosen not by the Master of Mankind but by his living thralls, the faith is hers to command and to protect.
READ IT BECAUSE It’s a story of doubt and faith. It’s a story of the light of the God-Emperor against the darkness of the Night Lords. Can Morvenn Vahl lead the faithful to triumph, or will Ophelia VII fall to the traitors?
THE STORY When a monster from myth threatens the cardinal world of Ophelia VII, Morvenn Vahl defies the Senatorum Imperialis and heads to the planet's defence. There, she finds a world in terror – the warlord Kol Rakhul, known as the Death of Saints, has come for the faithful and, with his Heldrake and a host of Night Lords at his back, plans to enshroud the world in flame and blood.
This is a reckoning. A holy world is being defiled, and in its defence, Morvenn Vahl must wield an army of Living Saints to stand a hope of survival, let alone victory.
It's not often that I leave a written review on my goodreads rating, but considering how bad the book was, I felt obliged.
It feels like the author doesn't understand certain aspects of the 40k universe. The bits about space warfare were a huge letdown. Moreover, I feel like there's no logical string to the story whatsoever. It really makes you wonder why the plot is happening in the first place.
It doesn't help that the story is written in present tense. IMHO, it's very hard to pull off and works only in some very specific context.
Really enjoyed reading this book, my only gripe with it and why I did not give it 5 stars is that I thought Lethes story was pointless. Whenever it came up in the book I sighed because it had no real effect on the story, just showed how cruel both the sisters and the night lords could be. Otherwise I really enjoyed this book, as it showed that while the sisters are the most faithful to the imperium that they are not without their faults either.
I wasn't entirely sold on this at first, but I am very glad I stuck with it. For the first little while with this book I was thinking how Morvenn is getting overshadowed by The Death of Saints. I really was enjoying his character and the flashbacks to his childhood were some real highlights, and I love the Night Lords... but I came here for Morvenn Vahl! Then, when Reid actually gets down to the meat and bones of her protagonist, displaying her inner conflicts, having her dialogue with other characters forge her into an actual Abbess Sanctorum, that's when this really shines. Her character arc is great. She takes a more of a backseat towards the beginning of the novel because she *is* unsure. She is put in situations she struggles to control, like void warfare on someone else's ship, for example. But that great conversation, after Morvenn is looking for a miracle and her battle sister says, 'No, we prayed for the miracle, and here you are.' That's really great stuff. Grounds the faith element of the Adepta Sororitas in a way that goes beyond miracles and shining lights of the God-Emperor. Her willpower is miracle enough, and it's that revelation that leads her to winning the war, beheading that bastard, and stepping up to lead in a more concrete and fulfilling manner. Great read by the end, and I'd actually say that Jude Reid should explore some dirty, grimy heretics more closely in the future much in the same manner she did here, maybe as the protagonists? Oh also Lethe is great. I love a 'human caught in the affairs of the gods' kind of subplot.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Unfortunately, Spear of Faith reads like glorified bolter porn—and not even a particularly good one. Morvenn Vahl, despite her lofty title as Abbess Sanctorum and High Lord of Terra, is written with the depth and gravitas of a standard Sister Superior. There’s almost no character development, no internal conflict, and no meaningful growth. She comes across less like a stateswoman or a spiritual leader and more like a cardboard cutout in perpetual righteous rage mode.
And then there’s the armor.
It’s honestly comical how she struts around in her gigantic Paragon war suit all the time. Not even Horus walked around his own battleship fully armored. Is this some kind of overcompensation? Does the Abbess even own casual wear? The visual borders on parody—it’s hard to take her seriously when she’s essentially cosplaying a walking cathedral 24/7.
The one actual bright spot is the Night Lords antagonist—dramatically dubbed the “Death of Saints.” He had potential: brooding, brutal, and genuinely intimidating. But alas, he ends up playing the role of episodic supervillain and dies in the most anticlimactic way imaginable. What could have been a compelling arc fizzles into trope.
And yes, I do like the Adeptus Sororitas faction. I’ve enjoyed Mark of Faith, Fire & Faith, and even Pilgrims of Fire. This, however, doesn’t do the faction justice. It mistakes spectacle for substance, and iconography for identity.
Out of all characters in this book, the titular one, Morvenn, must've been the most plain of them all. This goes for a lot of hyper religious characters, where their main drive is their faith. The character of The Death Of Saints and especially my girl Lethe were in opposition, very enjoyable.
Morvenn Vahl: Spear of Faith is hamstrung by its genre and setting, turning it from what could have been a journey of self discovery and overcoming ones faults to grow into leadership when it is demanded of them, into something more akin to a good early 2000s action movie. It's not bad, but the potential so visibly left on the table leaves a bittersweet taste in the mouth.
Morvenn Vahl is the primary and titular character, the head of the Adeptus Sororitas - an order of futuristic battle nuns. If you're new to this setting, stop here. This book is not an introduction to the world of Warhammer - it is instead deep in the mythos already, and takes no time bothering to get you up to speed with the state of things. Instead of painting a clear picture of the general setting, it paints one of Vahl. A brash woman that is unsure of herself, quick to temper, and lacking in subtlety in both the arts of politics and war. When called to defend an important and holy world, she's forced to contend with both an enemy more cunning than her, and her own self doubt in order to win the day.
The most fun to be had is in the front to back action. The fights are well described and visceral, if tending towards long winded in moments. Jude Reid is excellent at setting the scene and especially at making the enemy a real threat. In addition, time is spent early on to remind you that the protagonists aren't necessarily the good guys - as they support incredibly awful practices that may see you silently hoping neither force makes it out alive. But when they clash she makes sure it is a spectacle that utilises much of the settings most enjoyable elements.
The issues tend to turn their heads when it comes to the characters. The primary cast sees far less development than one would think - and this is mostly noticeable in Vahl. Throughout the book, Vahl makes fairly boneheaded tactical choices. She angers allies, runs headfirst into battle, and does little to truly try to understand her much more tactically minded foe. She's confronted on this, her self doubt, and her faith throughout - and though her self doubt and faith reach a modestly reasonable conclusion - her ability falls flat. She does make some choices near the end of the book that let be a more levelheaded commander, but this is still a warhammer action novel. She must duel the big monsters, and fight the big bad guy alone. Even if it means abandoning that part of the character arc to do it.
She's not the only one to suffer in this regard. The supporting cast do not get the time you'd want. A lot of Vahls issues are internal, and being a stoic general means facing them alone. The other primary perspective of a slave freed by the Night Lords and taken in by their leader is also missing a strong supporting cast. The evil, murdering, space marines are fun and their petty squabbles are handled well enough, but much of the book lacks the build up of its cast in order to facilitate the action.
This isn't to say this is a Do Not Read. If you're interested in either the sisters of battle, the Night lords, or enjoy the setting than this is a perfectly fine, easy read. Though not the settings best, Spear of Faith manages to be enjoyable front to back.
I think there’s potential here, but that the book doesn’t quite reach it. The idea of contrasting the faithless, terrifying Night Lords and devout, inspiring Sisters of Battle is both ingenious and not obvious. The scenes paralleling The Death of Saints (who is supremely self-confident and rules through terror) with Morvenn (who is much less self-assured and leads by example) are very good. And a lot of the action kicks ass (in particular, there’s a scene where Morvenn fights a dragon that rules). But, aside from Morvenn and The Death’s, the characters are pretty undercooked. And the plotting is very messy for this kind of book, with weird niggling details (an unpowered blade cutting through ceramite, Sisters of Battle apparently marching as quickly as marines deploying via airship) and oddly dangling threads (Morvenn’s brief idolization of Elena, the strange business with the prophecy). I think Jude Reid has a great warhammer book in her, but didn’t quite produce one here. Still, it’s pretty entertaining, and there is good stuff in it. I would have given it 3.5 stars if goodreads let me.
Jude Reid is fast becoming one of my favourite authors from the Black Library. I managed to get one of the sumptuous mega editions and it’s now taking pride of place in my office!
I didn’t known much about Morvenn Vahl beyond painting her miniature. It’s not often we get to spend time with a High Lord of Terra. Jude Reid not only made her feel like a real person, but she also made the (cool but rather impractical) armour she wears feel natural and realistic.
Ophelia VII under attack by the Night Lords is a great premise and it was interesting to see how it tied into the invasion of the Tyrant of the Blueflame.
Also, no spoilers, but the final scene of the book… Holy hell. I didn’t see that coming.
While not the best that the Black Library has to offer, this dense novel rewards the reader with interesting shifts from one point of view to the other - we see a "young" Morvenn Vahl coming to grips with the duty of command, an unwillingly aspiring young saint facing the unknowability of faith, an escapee from the mines drawn to the dark(er) side, and the background of one of the more fascinating villains in the franchise - the Death of Saints. The action is tight, almost unputdownable, and the descriptions of architectural grandeur provide a solid background to the internal turmoil of the protagonists. It's a good read, that would have benefitted from just a slightly more polished work on the introspections of the characters - especially, Aleyna.
Actual rating would be 3½ stars. I hadn't expected to read this book, having little interest in the Adepta Sororitas, until I watched a Warhammer lore video about the Death of Saints. Since reading Night Lords: The Omnibus, I've been curious to find out more about the Night Lords. The book doesn't offer that much backstory, but I thought Kol Rakhul's origin was compelling.
The book was competently written and the characters interesting. In the end, I enjoyed it, though it wasn't my favorite Black Library book. Not the fault of the writer—I think it's just a matter of what I prefer to read about in the Warhammer universe.
Took a bit of time to settle into a rhythm and the standard detailed, grimy human suffering you get in sisters’ books felt very heavy early on.
Morvenn feels like a well-rounded character and her flaws made her human and more likeable in my opinion.
The fight scenes were a a little bolter porn-y but there were some satisfying clashes and the Big Bad felt like they had it coming, even if their flaws were on show, too.
As a Night Lords player, I really liked the villain of this book. Otherwise, this is pretty much bolter-porn, with the probably most whiny and pathetic Lord of Terra (Morvenn Vahl) known to the Imperium of Man. She constantly questions herself and lacks most of the self-rightiousness and self-confidence a High Lord should possess, especially the leader of the Sororitas! Entertaining, but in the end, inconsequential.
Great fun, really enjoyed this book for the most part. The only thing that keeps it from a 5 star for me is they spend so much time describing rotting bodies that it gets repetitive, and it doesn’t add anything except for the grossness of it. Not to mention it distracts from when it could be very impactful (like when a certain characters head gets delivered in a box).
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This author is an excellent new addition to the already incredible crew writing for Games Workshop. She nailed this one. I am an unapologetic Night Lords fan and the primary antagonist in this did not disappoint. Excellently written, action-packed, and a depth of characters on all sides that delivered fully.
The entire story is written in present tense, which I'm simply unable to cope with as a writing style. Hugely disappointing since I collect all the Adeptas Sororitas books and was really looking forward to reading this one.
Wow. What a read!! Jude Reed brings Morvenn Vahl to life and then some. It’s a big book but it’s full of character and action. I loved her take on the Night Lords. The death of saints is possibly my favourite Night Lords character since ADB’s stuff.
Really good read and good insight into the second fight for Ophelia VII. Awesome to see a High Lord that is a warrior first, fighting to clasp the role of leadership. Overall to the timeline it's only important if you are reading Battle Sisters Lore.
This book gave me so much anxiety for what might come next. Each chapter led me deeper and deeper into the intoxicating cocktail of hope and despair that has been woven together as wet follow the Sisters of Battle and their fight for their most holy of worlds.