What do you think?
Rate this book
Enduring Hope #1
The Angel of Second Street
How Can Compassion be Considered Wrong?
When life is weighed down by challenges, pillars of enduring hope and love are always waiting to be discovered.
Ida Dempsey has grown up in a privileged life of luxury thanks to her aunt and uncle. Although Second Street—where women of ill repute ply their wares—is off limits to respectable citizens, her heart of compassion compels her to frequent the area, hoping to make a difference in their lives. Ida has also befriended Qui Shau, a Chinese woman who keeps house for her family, but friendships between the whites and Chinese are taboo in Eureka. Ida tries to keep secret her forbidden compassion, but someone is watching and will use it against her.
When Blaine Prescott meets Ida at a church picnic, his parents warn him away from any relationship with the young lady who has been seen on Second Street in the company of a Chinese woman. But how could such a kindhearted, lovely young woman be anything but good? But when riots break out in Chinatown and Ida disappears, Blaine will do anything to find out where and why she has gone.
Other books in the Enduring Hope series
The Undercover Heiress of Brockton by Kelly Goshorn
When life is weighed down by challenges, pillars of enduring hope and love are always waiting to be discovered.
Ida Dempsey has grown up in a privileged life of luxury thanks to her aunt and uncle. Although Second Street—where women of ill repute ply their wares—is off limits to respectable citizens, her heart of compassion compels her to frequent the area, hoping to make a difference in their lives. Ida has also befriended Qui Shau, a Chinese woman who keeps house for her family, but friendships between the whites and Chinese are taboo in Eureka. Ida tries to keep secret her forbidden compassion, but someone is watching and will use it against her.
When Blaine Prescott meets Ida at a church picnic, his parents warn him away from any relationship with the young lady who has been seen on Second Street in the company of a Chinese woman. But how could such a kindhearted, lovely young woman be anything but good? But when riots break out in Chinatown and Ida disappears, Blaine will do anything to find out where and why she has gone.
Other books in the Enduring Hope series
The Undercover Heiress of Brockton by Kelly Goshorn
256 pages, Paperback
First published May 1, 2025
7 people are currently reading
1265 people want to read
About the author
Barbara Tifft Blakey
5 books79 followersBarbara Blakey is a freelance writer and the author of the award-winning literature-based language arts program Total Language Plus. Barbara is also a nationally recognized speaker, conducting workshops and seminars for Christian women's groups and homeschooling conventions for more than fifteen years. She lives in Olympia, Washington, with her husband, Terry.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 88 reviews
May 3, 2025
2 stars, personally ⭐️ Christian Fiction - Historical Fiction
About this book:
“How Can Compassion be Considered Wrong?
When life is weighed down by challenges, pillars of enduring hope and love are always waiting to be discovered.
Ida Dempsey has grown up in a privileged life of luxury thanks to her aunt and uncle. Although Second Street—where women of ill repute ply their wares—is off limits to respectable citizens, her heart of compassion compels her to frequent the area, hoping to make a difference in their lives. Ida has also befriended Qui Shau, a Chinese woman who keeps house for her family, but friendships between the whites and Chinese are taboo in Eureka. Ida tries to keep secret her forbidden compassion, but someone is watching and will use it against her.
When Blaine Prescott meets Ida at a church picnic, his parents warn him away from any relationship with the young lady who has been seen on Second Street in the company of a Chinese woman. But how could such a kindhearted, lovely young woman be anything but good? But when riots break out in Chinatown and Ida disappears, Blaine will do anything to find out where and why she has gone.”
Series: Book #1 in the multi-authored series “Enduring Hope” and does not seem like it will be connected to any of the other books.
Spiritual Content- Scriptures are quoted, mentioned, & remembered; Prayers; Witnessing to others; Church going, singing hymns, worshiping, & trying to focus on the sermon; Many talks about God, witnessing to others, & His will; 'H's are capital when referring to God; Blaine has been praying for God to direct his steps to find the right woman to marry and shortly after meeting Ida, believes her to be the one; Ida desperately wants to share about Jesus with others, especially with the women of ill repute and the Chinese people she knows; Ida and Blaine both notice hypocrisy from others about helping missionaries in foreign countries, but not being willing to witness to people in their own area; Ida doesn’t like to “bother” her heavenly Father with every little thing in her life, but prays about an overwhelming event; Ida’s best friend reminds her that women can’t be preachers and later Ida pretends when alone in her church by reading a Scripture from the pulpit (she doesn’t want to get up in front of everyone and is very embarrassed by being caught by her reverend because “women were not allowed to preach!”, but he is kind about it); Ida is discouraged when her reverend says that God will use her in ways she is better suited for (compared to her hopes of witnessing to the prostitutes), but their next conversation is him apologizing for discrediting her; When at church, Ida wonders if her prayers will be more effective there or even in front of the altar; Blaine wonders if there are situations where God approved of duplicity (in terms of deceit and lies), but sincerely doubts it; Ida struggles with thoughts about Scriptures telling one to obey their parents when she is hiding her actions from her guardians; Blaine believes that Jesus is the answer to everything, including poverty and crime; Ida thinks that going against what Jesus has called her to do will grieve her soul and thus continues to do it even if it grieves her conscience to disobey her aunt; Mattie, Ida’s best friend, says she gets enough religion on Sunday in church; Many mentions of God, Jesus, witnessing to others and sharing the gospel, faiths, & God’s will; Many mentions of churches, church going, services, sermons, hymns, & a reverend; Mentions of Bibles, Bible reading, & Bible studies; Mentions of those, events, & books of the Bible; Mentions of prayers, praying, & blessings over food; Mentions of missionaries; Mentions of a Chinese gang forbidding for their people to convert to Christianity & possible persecution; A few mentions of a nativity scene; A few mentions of sins; A couple mentions of Christian denominations; A mention of the Holy Spirit; A mention of morning devotions; A mention of Sunday school; A mention of Ida making a “holier-than-thou” impression on some of the prostitutes;
*Note: Ida’s best friend says she prays for finding a rich husband; Chinatown is called a pagan community twice; Someone says the Chinese has their own religion and it isn’t possible for a Chinese woman to understand Christianity as it will only confuse her because of her own religion; A few mentions of mythological creatures (nymphs, gnomes, and fairies).
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘balderdash’, a ‘blast it’, a ‘dumb’, a ‘stupid’, and two ‘idiot’s, A bit of eye rolling; Blaine thinks of a sarcastic retort to something his mother says, but chooses to reply with respect instead; Being hit, Pain, Injuries, Blood/Bleeding (up to semi-detailed); Ida lies & tells half-truths often because of her plans; Ida struggles with hiding her plans and her feelings from her aunt (which she wonders if that’s part of growing up and if so, she doesn’t like it; She thinks the deception of it all and disobeying doesn’t suit her and is unsettled by going behind her aunt’s back); Ida’s aunt forbids her to go to Second Street (known for prostitution) because it could shame their family if she’s seen there, so Ida has the idea to dress like the prostitutes to blend in with them (she keeps this a secret from her aunt and feels twinges of guilt; She wonders if the end justify the means and hopes it does; Later, Ida consoles herself that the greater good demands the skulking around; Her best friend joins her as well, but is more excited to toe the line and go to taboo places; Towards the end, Ida grieves going against her aunt, but the idea of going against what she believes Jesus called her to do would grieve her soul); Ida has not specifically been forbidden to visit Chinatown, so she ventures there (despite knowing it’s not a place for moral young ladies to visit); Ida’s cousin drinks from a flask and offers it to her (which she does not partake in); Mentions of deaths & grief (Ida’s parents); Mentions of a massacre (which killed women and children as well) & planned hangings; Mentions of gangs, rival gangs, violence, and shootings (which causes a death); Mentions of criminals, thieves/looters, & stealing; Mentions of a man drinking from a flask, drunks, saloons, & bootleggers; Mentions of lies, lying, & deceit; Mentions of gossip & rumors; Mentions of opium dens, gambling dens, & gamblers; Mentions of pipes & smoking; A mention of a woman threatening to drown herself in the sea (not seriously);
*Note: Blaine’s parents are against him courting Ida, but he continues on with that plan because he believes she is the woman God has for him; Blaine’s friend wants his help deceiving her parents, but she doesn’t think of it like that because they refuse her happiness because of their misconceptions and says it wouldn’t be her fault; Blaine recalls his mother saying that women who attend college are unfit for domestic life; Many mentions of prejudice (towards Chinese workers and prostitutes; There are talks from business men in the town about removing the Chinese people, burning down Chinatown, making it illegal to hire them, and making them board an outbound ship; Blaine doesn’t see the problem if the Chinamen do their jobs and handle things themselves as along as no one on the outside gets hurt; Towards the end, tensions continue to rise and the white townsmen call for the Chinese to be hanged; Blaine doesn’t understand how some of the men like his father can go to church every Sunday and still be so prejudice); A couple mentions of a book & a quote from it (Pride and Prejudice).
Sexual Content- a cheek kiss (barely-above-not-detailed), a nose kiss, four head/forehead kisses, two blown kisses, two barely-above-not-detailed kisses, and a semi-detailed kiss (which makes Ida think afterwards “So that was kissing. No wonder people did it” and wishes to “explore this kissing thing” with Blaine again; Later, her aunt who witnessed the kiss tells Ida that she is too young for such things and makes Ida promise her not to let that happen again); Wanting to kiss & Thinking about kisses/kissing (barely-above-not-detailed); Touches, Embraces, Cuddling/Snuggling (including falling asleep next to each other on a couch over night), Hand holding, Tingles, Warmth, & Nearness (up to semi-detailed); Winks & Blushes; Noticing & Staring (barely-above-not-detailed); Two ‘hussy’s; Ida thinks her father might have been a “rogue” based on the way her aunt avoids talking about him (*Spoiler* *Major Spoilers*); Ida asks Blaine if he has ever visited Second Street (known for the red-light district) and he has not; Ida has the idea to dress like the prostitutes to blend in and not be noticed (so she won’t bring shame to her family) and her best friend joins the plan, asking if they can show cleavage (which makes Ida blush; Later, her friend says they are “missionaries with cleavage” and they try on their form-fitting dresses which makes Ida blush and Mattie proclaim to liking the bare shoulders; Ida feels older and less innocent in the dress, which she doesn’t understand because it’s not like she’s done anything impure in her life; Mattie says one of the prostitutes is jealous of the two of them because they aren’t “droopy” anywhere like her; Mattie comments on the prostitutes covering up with a lot of make-up and Idea says they are covering up the wrong thing; Ida wears her “provocative” dress and does a “sultry sashay” like she’s seen the prostitutes do; One of the prostitutes asks if Ida is working around the area); Ida’s aunt, uncle, and reverend are concerned about her being exposed to the seedier side of town and her innocence being tarnished; Ida only goes to Second Street in broad daylight (because her “timidity disallowed going at night”) and doesn’t see any men; When referring to the prostitutes’ “work”, Ida stumbles and is awkward when referring to it; Ida’s best friend is also interested in Blaine and Mattie asks if she can have him (it causes a rift in their friendship for a bit); Many mentions of the women in an area known for prostitution, brothels (including one with the name “Joy Emporium”), the women (who have fake names like “Delight” and “Midnight Joy”; Ida comments she would have a Bible name and her best friend offers “Jezebel”), & them working at night and sleeping late into the day; Mentions of the prostitutes being checked for health concerns every two weeks, conditions such as “syphilis” and “gonorrhea” (which Ida does not know what those are), some of the women receiving pills to “set herself right” after missing their monthlies (which Ida isn’t sure what that means either and asks her best friend about it), & women lifting their dresses for a doctor (which makes Ida think that the others might be right and she’s too young to see this); Mentions of women having to turn to prostitution because of desperation; Mentions of out-of-wedlock pregnancies & unwed mothers (one says that her baby is her biggest blessing); Mentions of kisses & kissing; Mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of the men (also called “clients”) who visit Second Street and the women there; A mention of a woman being found beaten and having torn clothing outside of an opium den; Love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: Blaine has to change his wet clothes, but a female friend won’t leave the room and turns around instead which makes him unable to change his britches; A couple mentions of a mother nursing her baby; A couple mentions of scandalous dresses with high slits; A mention of modest, virtuous women not visiting men in their private rooms; A mention of a theater not being of a burlesque nature or of otherwise questionable on moral grounds.
-Ida Dempsey, age 17
-Blaine Prescott, age 24
P.O.V. switches between them
Set in 1884-1885
256 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- One Star
Older High School Teens- Two Stars
My personal Rating- Two Stars
You could say this book was a wild card for me. I’m hesitant about reading books that deal with prostitution because that always adds in some sexual content and sexual innuendoes; but on the other hand with this book, I was interested in seeing Chinese characters in a Christian Fiction book. It’s unfortunately not the most positive representation or treatment, but our main characters are determined to do right for the Chinese workers and the prostitutes in their town even when prejudice runs rampant.
As far as our main characters: Ida feels like God has put not only the Chinese workers on her heart, but also the prostitutes. I mean this as nicely as I can say it: Her heart was in the right place, but her brain wasn’t fully in a logical place. Her first idea is to blend in with the women of ill repute is to dress like them and go to town during the day. Thankfully, nothing happens to her, but there’s so many ways this could have gone wrong. It was good to see the final plan and how it impacted not only the women, but also Ida and her best friend. It took some trials and errors on Ida’s part, but that final idea was a better one.
I will note that Ida is seventeen and she felt every bit of it. I don’t mean to say that rudely, but it’s a fact that she’s been coddled by her lavish lifestyle and act very young for most of the book. Perhaps that’s an element of her child-like faith and these experiences will grow her, I’m sure, but she had her moments of being a teeny-bopper that made me cringe.
With Blaine, it was very much love at first sight for him and yes, they were definitely cheesy together, but I really liked that they both had strong faiths and encouraged each other to pray and seek what God has for them to do. Overall the plot-line was pretty simple with a basic writing style, but it had some cute parts and strong faith content.
I will say that while the prostitution parts were lightly handled in regard to the details of their actions and “work”, I found it sad to see a doctor hand the women pills that would take care of the problem interfering with their periods. Ida isn’t sure what this all means, but because we can read between the lines to know it’s a birth control pill that will kill a baby, it’s not commented upon negatively or frowned upon. Yes, that’s life and it happened in this setting, I’m sure, but for a Christian Fiction book to just brush it under the rug really disappointed me. Compared to the other Christian Fiction books I’ve read that feature prostitution, this was definitely on the lighter side, but it’s still not one I would recommend because of Ida’s actions. She means well but has little tact or grace when handling what she thinks she’s been called to do.
The ending was really rushed and a bit choppy. An event that is shared on the back-cover doesn’t happen until the last five percent, which felt added in at last minute for some additional angst/grief for the couple. Not a bad story as a whole, but not one I’m going to highly recommend.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Barbour) for this honest review.
About this book:
“How Can Compassion be Considered Wrong?
When life is weighed down by challenges, pillars of enduring hope and love are always waiting to be discovered.
Ida Dempsey has grown up in a privileged life of luxury thanks to her aunt and uncle. Although Second Street—where women of ill repute ply their wares—is off limits to respectable citizens, her heart of compassion compels her to frequent the area, hoping to make a difference in their lives. Ida has also befriended Qui Shau, a Chinese woman who keeps house for her family, but friendships between the whites and Chinese are taboo in Eureka. Ida tries to keep secret her forbidden compassion, but someone is watching and will use it against her.
When Blaine Prescott meets Ida at a church picnic, his parents warn him away from any relationship with the young lady who has been seen on Second Street in the company of a Chinese woman. But how could such a kindhearted, lovely young woman be anything but good? But when riots break out in Chinatown and Ida disappears, Blaine will do anything to find out where and why she has gone.”
Series: Book #1 in the multi-authored series “Enduring Hope” and does not seem like it will be connected to any of the other books.
Spiritual Content- Scriptures are quoted, mentioned, & remembered; Prayers; Witnessing to others; Church going, singing hymns, worshiping, & trying to focus on the sermon; Many talks about God, witnessing to others, & His will; 'H's are capital when referring to God; Blaine has been praying for God to direct his steps to find the right woman to marry and shortly after meeting Ida, believes her to be the one; Ida desperately wants to share about Jesus with others, especially with the women of ill repute and the Chinese people she knows; Ida and Blaine both notice hypocrisy from others about helping missionaries in foreign countries, but not being willing to witness to people in their own area; Ida doesn’t like to “bother” her heavenly Father with every little thing in her life, but prays about an overwhelming event; Ida’s best friend reminds her that women can’t be preachers and later Ida pretends when alone in her church by reading a Scripture from the pulpit (she doesn’t want to get up in front of everyone and is very embarrassed by being caught by her reverend because “women were not allowed to preach!”, but he is kind about it); Ida is discouraged when her reverend says that God will use her in ways she is better suited for (compared to her hopes of witnessing to the prostitutes), but their next conversation is him apologizing for discrediting her; When at church, Ida wonders if her prayers will be more effective there or even in front of the altar; Blaine wonders if there are situations where God approved of duplicity (in terms of deceit and lies), but sincerely doubts it; Ida struggles with thoughts about Scriptures telling one to obey their parents when she is hiding her actions from her guardians; Blaine believes that Jesus is the answer to everything, including poverty and crime; Ida thinks that going against what Jesus has called her to do will grieve her soul and thus continues to do it even if it grieves her conscience to disobey her aunt; Mattie, Ida’s best friend, says she gets enough religion on Sunday in church; Many mentions of God, Jesus, witnessing to others and sharing the gospel, faiths, & God’s will; Many mentions of churches, church going, services, sermons, hymns, & a reverend; Mentions of Bibles, Bible reading, & Bible studies; Mentions of those, events, & books of the Bible; Mentions of prayers, praying, & blessings over food; Mentions of missionaries; Mentions of a Chinese gang forbidding for their people to convert to Christianity & possible persecution; A few mentions of a nativity scene; A few mentions of sins; A couple mentions of Christian denominations; A mention of the Holy Spirit; A mention of morning devotions; A mention of Sunday school; A mention of Ida making a “holier-than-thou” impression on some of the prostitutes;
*Note: Ida’s best friend says she prays for finding a rich husband; Chinatown is called a pagan community twice; Someone says the Chinese has their own religion and it isn’t possible for a Chinese woman to understand Christianity as it will only confuse her because of her own religion; A few mentions of mythological creatures (nymphs, gnomes, and fairies).
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘balderdash’, a ‘blast it’, a ‘dumb’, a ‘stupid’, and two ‘idiot’s, A bit of eye rolling; Blaine thinks of a sarcastic retort to something his mother says, but chooses to reply with respect instead; Being hit, Pain, Injuries, Blood/Bleeding (up to semi-detailed); Ida lies & tells half-truths often because of her plans; Ida struggles with hiding her plans and her feelings from her aunt (which she wonders if that’s part of growing up and if so, she doesn’t like it; She thinks the deception of it all and disobeying doesn’t suit her and is unsettled by going behind her aunt’s back); Ida’s aunt forbids her to go to Second Street (known for prostitution) because it could shame their family if she’s seen there, so Ida has the idea to dress like the prostitutes to blend in with them (she keeps this a secret from her aunt and feels twinges of guilt; She wonders if the end justify the means and hopes it does; Later, Ida consoles herself that the greater good demands the skulking around; Her best friend joins her as well, but is more excited to toe the line and go to taboo places; Towards the end, Ida grieves going against her aunt, but the idea of going against what she believes Jesus called her to do would grieve her soul); Ida has not specifically been forbidden to visit Chinatown, so she ventures there (despite knowing it’s not a place for moral young ladies to visit); Ida’s cousin drinks from a flask and offers it to her (which she does not partake in); Mentions of deaths & grief (Ida’s parents); Mentions of a massacre (which killed women and children as well) & planned hangings; Mentions of gangs, rival gangs, violence, and shootings (which causes a death); Mentions of criminals, thieves/looters, & stealing; Mentions of a man drinking from a flask, drunks, saloons, & bootleggers; Mentions of lies, lying, & deceit; Mentions of gossip & rumors; Mentions of opium dens, gambling dens, & gamblers; Mentions of pipes & smoking; A mention of a woman threatening to drown herself in the sea (not seriously);
*Note: Blaine’s parents are against him courting Ida, but he continues on with that plan because he believes she is the woman God has for him; Blaine’s friend wants his help deceiving her parents, but she doesn’t think of it like that because they refuse her happiness because of their misconceptions and says it wouldn’t be her fault; Blaine recalls his mother saying that women who attend college are unfit for domestic life; Many mentions of prejudice (towards Chinese workers and prostitutes; There are talks from business men in the town about removing the Chinese people, burning down Chinatown, making it illegal to hire them, and making them board an outbound ship; Blaine doesn’t see the problem if the Chinamen do their jobs and handle things themselves as along as no one on the outside gets hurt; Towards the end, tensions continue to rise and the white townsmen call for the Chinese to be hanged; Blaine doesn’t understand how some of the men like his father can go to church every Sunday and still be so prejudice); A couple mentions of a book & a quote from it (Pride and Prejudice).
Sexual Content- a cheek kiss (barely-above-not-detailed), a nose kiss, four head/forehead kisses, two blown kisses, two barely-above-not-detailed kisses, and a semi-detailed kiss (which makes Ida think afterwards “So that was kissing. No wonder people did it” and wishes to “explore this kissing thing” with Blaine again; Later, her aunt who witnessed the kiss tells Ida that she is too young for such things and makes Ida promise her not to let that happen again); Wanting to kiss & Thinking about kisses/kissing (barely-above-not-detailed); Touches, Embraces, Cuddling/Snuggling (including falling asleep next to each other on a couch over night), Hand holding, Tingles, Warmth, & Nearness (up to semi-detailed); Winks & Blushes; Noticing & Staring (barely-above-not-detailed); Two ‘hussy’s; Ida thinks her father might have been a “rogue” based on the way her aunt avoids talking about him (*Spoiler* *Major Spoilers*); Ida asks Blaine if he has ever visited Second Street (known for the red-light district) and he has not; Ida has the idea to dress like the prostitutes to blend in and not be noticed (so she won’t bring shame to her family) and her best friend joins the plan, asking if they can show cleavage (which makes Ida blush; Later, her friend says they are “missionaries with cleavage” and they try on their form-fitting dresses which makes Ida blush and Mattie proclaim to liking the bare shoulders; Ida feels older and less innocent in the dress, which she doesn’t understand because it’s not like she’s done anything impure in her life; Mattie says one of the prostitutes is jealous of the two of them because they aren’t “droopy” anywhere like her; Mattie comments on the prostitutes covering up with a lot of make-up and Idea says they are covering up the wrong thing; Ida wears her “provocative” dress and does a “sultry sashay” like she’s seen the prostitutes do; One of the prostitutes asks if Ida is working around the area); Ida’s aunt, uncle, and reverend are concerned about her being exposed to the seedier side of town and her innocence being tarnished; Ida only goes to Second Street in broad daylight (because her “timidity disallowed going at night”) and doesn’t see any men; When referring to the prostitutes’ “work”, Ida stumbles and is awkward when referring to it; Ida’s best friend is also interested in Blaine and Mattie asks if she can have him (it causes a rift in their friendship for a bit); Many mentions of the women in an area known for prostitution, brothels (including one with the name “Joy Emporium”), the women (who have fake names like “Delight” and “Midnight Joy”; Ida comments she would have a Bible name and her best friend offers “Jezebel”), & them working at night and sleeping late into the day; Mentions of the prostitutes being checked for health concerns every two weeks, conditions such as “syphilis” and “gonorrhea” (which Ida does not know what those are), some of the women receiving pills to “set herself right” after missing their monthlies (which Ida isn’t sure what that means either and asks her best friend about it), & women lifting their dresses for a doctor (which makes Ida think that the others might be right and she’s too young to see this); Mentions of women having to turn to prostitution because of desperation; Mentions of out-of-wedlock pregnancies & unwed mothers (one says that her baby is her biggest blessing); Mentions of kisses & kissing; Mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of the men (also called “clients”) who visit Second Street and the women there; A mention of a woman being found beaten and having torn clothing outside of an opium den; Love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: Blaine has to change his wet clothes, but a female friend won’t leave the room and turns around instead which makes him unable to change his britches; A couple mentions of a mother nursing her baby; A couple mentions of scandalous dresses with high slits; A mention of modest, virtuous women not visiting men in their private rooms; A mention of a theater not being of a burlesque nature or of otherwise questionable on moral grounds.
-Ida Dempsey, age 17
-Blaine Prescott, age 24
P.O.V. switches between them
Set in 1884-1885
256 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- One Star
Older High School Teens- Two Stars
My personal Rating- Two Stars
You could say this book was a wild card for me. I’m hesitant about reading books that deal with prostitution because that always adds in some sexual content and sexual innuendoes; but on the other hand with this book, I was interested in seeing Chinese characters in a Christian Fiction book. It’s unfortunately not the most positive representation or treatment, but our main characters are determined to do right for the Chinese workers and the prostitutes in their town even when prejudice runs rampant.
As far as our main characters: Ida feels like God has put not only the Chinese workers on her heart, but also the prostitutes. I mean this as nicely as I can say it: Her heart was in the right place, but her brain wasn’t fully in a logical place. Her first idea is to blend in with the women of ill repute is to dress like them and go to town during the day. Thankfully, nothing happens to her, but there’s so many ways this could have gone wrong. It was good to see the final plan and how it impacted not only the women, but also Ida and her best friend. It took some trials and errors on Ida’s part, but that final idea was a better one.
I will note that Ida is seventeen and she felt every bit of it. I don’t mean to say that rudely, but it’s a fact that she’s been coddled by her lavish lifestyle and act very young for most of the book. Perhaps that’s an element of her child-like faith and these experiences will grow her, I’m sure, but she had her moments of being a teeny-bopper that made me cringe.
With Blaine, it was very much love at first sight for him and yes, they were definitely cheesy together, but I really liked that they both had strong faiths and encouraged each other to pray and seek what God has for them to do. Overall the plot-line was pretty simple with a basic writing style, but it had some cute parts and strong faith content.
I will say that while the prostitution parts were lightly handled in regard to the details of their actions and “work”, I found it sad to see a doctor hand the women pills that would take care of the problem interfering with their periods. Ida isn’t sure what this all means, but because we can read between the lines to know it’s a birth control pill that will kill a baby, it’s not commented upon negatively or frowned upon. Yes, that’s life and it happened in this setting, I’m sure, but for a Christian Fiction book to just brush it under the rug really disappointed me. Compared to the other Christian Fiction books I’ve read that feature prostitution, this was definitely on the lighter side, but it’s still not one I would recommend because of Ida’s actions. She means well but has little tact or grace when handling what she thinks she’s been called to do.
The ending was really rushed and a bit choppy. An event that is shared on the back-cover doesn’t happen until the last five percent, which felt added in at last minute for some additional angst/grief for the couple. Not a bad story as a whole, but not one I’m going to highly recommend.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Barbour) for this honest review.
June 25, 2025
This was an enjoyable as well as thought provoking to consider how we would treat others during times such as these; history certainly repeats itself! I learned more about the Chinese who were burned out of their homes sadly during the riot but I hadn't known about the massacre of natives 25 years earlier; the men had left to go hunting so the women and children were all slaughtered.....
One of the main characters named Ida, was likeable despite being idealistic ( she was only 17) yet I couldn't help but admire her enthusiasm and zeal in trying to minister to the Chinese community in telling them about the Lord. There were other rather pompous and selfish characters which were typical of those in authority.....so much despair and injustice while many courageous ones who try to make a difference.
An insightful book overall that I was quite taken up with! A first for this author but I wouldn't mind reading another by her with the wonderful spiritual elements throughout so I was so pleased.
One of the main characters named Ida, was likeable despite being idealistic ( she was only 17) yet I couldn't help but admire her enthusiasm and zeal in trying to minister to the Chinese community in telling them about the Lord. There were other rather pompous and selfish characters which were typical of those in authority.....so much despair and injustice while many courageous ones who try to make a difference.
An insightful book overall that I was quite taken up with! A first for this author but I wouldn't mind reading another by her with the wonderful spiritual elements throughout so I was so pleased.
May 25, 2025
What does it mean to walk step-by-step following God’s call, even when it leads you down streets the world calls off-limits?
In Angel of Second Street, I felt as if Barbara Tifft Blakey had an inside scoop on my own heart and soul. This is so much more than a Christian historical fiction novel—it’s a story of obedience to God’s Word, even when it’s costly. Ida’s compassion shines bright against the harsh prejudice of her world, and every choice she makes felt like Scripture brought to life. “I want to serve God… I want to talk about Jesus, share His love.” That heartbeat of faith ran through every page.
I was moved by how God opened Ida’s eyes to see the hurting around her—how she saw souls, not social status or skin color. Ida’s courage to step into places deemed off-limits, to befriend those shunned by society, reminded me that real faith always crosses the lines of comfort and convention.
Blaine’s journey—his wrestling with what others think, his search for the truth about the woman he’s come to care for—added a tender echo to this story of standing firm in faith. Together, Ida and Blaine’s choices made me ask: Am I living out God’s call in the face of fear? Am I loving with compassion that doesn’t flinch?
Barbara Tifft Blakey’s storytelling is a beautiful reminder that God’s Word isn’t meant to be read and set aside—it’s meant to be lived out loud with joy and determination. In Ida’s passion to obey, I found a challenge and a quiet reassurance: that grace shines brightest when it’s lived in the streets, not just in the pews.
In my heart, this is a five-star story—a reminder of what God continually puts on my own heart and a living testimony to the quiet, bold faith He calls me to each day.
I received a digital ARC of this book from Celebrate Lit and the publisher Barbour Fiction via NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review nor paid to do so. This is my honest and unbiased review. My thoughts and opinions expressed in this book review are my own. My review focuses on writing and story’s content, ensuring transparency and reliability.
In Angel of Second Street, I felt as if Barbara Tifft Blakey had an inside scoop on my own heart and soul. This is so much more than a Christian historical fiction novel—it’s a story of obedience to God’s Word, even when it’s costly. Ida’s compassion shines bright against the harsh prejudice of her world, and every choice she makes felt like Scripture brought to life. “I want to serve God… I want to talk about Jesus, share His love.” That heartbeat of faith ran through every page.
I was moved by how God opened Ida’s eyes to see the hurting around her—how she saw souls, not social status or skin color. Ida’s courage to step into places deemed off-limits, to befriend those shunned by society, reminded me that real faith always crosses the lines of comfort and convention.
Blaine’s journey—his wrestling with what others think, his search for the truth about the woman he’s come to care for—added a tender echo to this story of standing firm in faith. Together, Ida and Blaine’s choices made me ask: Am I living out God’s call in the face of fear? Am I loving with compassion that doesn’t flinch?
Barbara Tifft Blakey’s storytelling is a beautiful reminder that God’s Word isn’t meant to be read and set aside—it’s meant to be lived out loud with joy and determination. In Ida’s passion to obey, I found a challenge and a quiet reassurance: that grace shines brightest when it’s lived in the streets, not just in the pews.
In my heart, this is a five-star story—a reminder of what God continually puts on my own heart and a living testimony to the quiet, bold faith He calls me to each day.
I received a digital ARC of this book from Celebrate Lit and the publisher Barbour Fiction via NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review nor paid to do so. This is my honest and unbiased review. My thoughts and opinions expressed in this book review are my own. My review focuses on writing and story’s content, ensuring transparency and reliability.
May 8, 2025
In Eureka California in 1884 two God-fearing young people are trying to live up to their parents’ expectations while still trying to honor God. Ida just wants to spread the good news of Jesus to the Chinese community and the ladies of questionable virtue on Second Street, although her methods are decidedly immature. Blaine has graduated college and plans on joining his father in the family business, but his parents are pushing him to find a suitable bride.
A meeting at a picnic has Blaine pursuing Ida who he finds captivating, refreshing and meets his standards for a Christian wife.
The story captures the atmosphere of 1884 and the controversy over the Chinese taking over jobs and living in squalid conditions.
The characters are mostly likable and the situations are realistic for the times. It would not be a good story if there was not conflict and godly situations represented. The author draws on historical events to put that into play, and the personal struggles of the main characters give many lessons.
* A complementary copy of this book was provided by Barbour via NetGalley. All opinions are mine alone.*
A meeting at a picnic has Blaine pursuing Ida who he finds captivating, refreshing and meets his standards for a Christian wife.
The story captures the atmosphere of 1884 and the controversy over the Chinese taking over jobs and living in squalid conditions.
The characters are mostly likable and the situations are realistic for the times. It would not be a good story if there was not conflict and godly situations represented. The author draws on historical events to put that into play, and the personal struggles of the main characters give many lessons.
* A complementary copy of this book was provided by Barbour via NetGalley. All opinions are mine alone.*
March 28, 2025
Angel of Second Street has Ida (an orphan raised by her aunt/uncle) who feels to her bones that she has a calling to take care of the prostitutes and Chinese immigrants. NO MATTER WHAT. Blaine asked God to show him a wife and then he meets Ida at a church picnic and determines to marry her. Ida wasn't so sure. But then agrees to give it a try. Blaine's family is against it and tries to thwart it.
Now Throw in heavy prejudices against the Chinese workforce of the time...which Blaine's father wants to get rid of. And Ida wants to preach the gospel to the Chinese too--so his family cuts Blaine out because he won't stop with Ida.
The story started slow. I had to stop reading it also because of Ida's senseless behavior. Seriously. She acted like such an immature 17 year-old. No care for what anyone says about her visiting places on her own. Completely rejecting common sense. I can't stand characters like that. And even as the story continued and she learned some lessons--well She didn't improve on me. Honestly her friend was a better character.
I grudgingly finished the book but i won't be reading anymore in the series. it just didn't do it for me. I just felt Blaine and Ida fell flat.
Now there is a heavy Christian message in this book which is refreshing after so many CF lacking one. So you will definitely find that in this book.
2 stars because it just didn't do it for me and I had to keep putting it down and taking a break.
*Thanks to NetGalley and the PUblisher for a chance to read the ARC. All opinions are 100% my own.
Now Throw in heavy prejudices against the Chinese workforce of the time...which Blaine's father wants to get rid of. And Ida wants to preach the gospel to the Chinese too--so his family cuts Blaine out because he won't stop with Ida.
The story started slow. I had to stop reading it also because of Ida's senseless behavior. Seriously. She acted like such an immature 17 year-old. No care for what anyone says about her visiting places on her own. Completely rejecting common sense. I can't stand characters like that. And even as the story continued and she learned some lessons--well She didn't improve on me. Honestly her friend was a better character.
I grudgingly finished the book but i won't be reading anymore in the series. it just didn't do it for me. I just felt Blaine and Ida fell flat.
Now there is a heavy Christian message in this book which is refreshing after so many CF lacking one. So you will definitely find that in this book.
2 stars because it just didn't do it for me and I had to keep putting it down and taking a break.
*Thanks to NetGalley and the PUblisher for a chance to read the ARC. All opinions are 100% my own.
March 14, 2025
I have enjoyed many books from Barbour Publishing and when I saw they were coming out with a new series, I knew I wanted to check it out. The Angel of Second Street is the first book in Barbour’s new Enduring Hope series and focuses on a young woman, Ida Dempsey, and her zeal to share the Gospel with the less fortunate and those who would not otherwise have a chance to hear its message. While her beau in the story, Blaine Prescott, had been praying for such a godly woman, their relationship is fraught with many challenges. It was very interesting to read about historical events not as well-known to me in a California town I had never heard of. The author brought to light the prejudice against Chinese immigrants, combining her fictional tale with real-life events as mentioned in the author’s notes at the end of the book. This book also examined how we treat others who are different from ourselves whether in social classes, economic levels or other walks of life. While the novel seemed to end abruptly, I found this to be an informative and fascinating read and would definitely recommend it for individual reading or book clubs. Looking forward to reading more in this series!
I received an advanced reader copy from the publisher via NetGalley. A positive review was not required and these are my own and honest opinions.
I received an advanced reader copy from the publisher via NetGalley. A positive review was not required and these are my own and honest opinions.
April 4, 2025
Beautiful story of Ida and Blaine! These two individuals come from different worlds but won’t that stop their love or faith in God. Ida and Blaine want to be with together but are they just two different for each other? Racial divide in town, social status, and difficult family members are a lot to overcome for each other. Can they overcome?
I liked this story. I loved that the author touched on topics like social divide and the struggles of Chinese people in that time. I do think the story like was a little bit quick and felt slightly forced. I would probably recommend to friend and family.
I liked this story. I loved that the author touched on topics like social divide and the struggles of Chinese people in that time. I do think the story like was a little bit quick and felt slightly forced. I would probably recommend to friend and family.
May 14, 2025
This is a faith filled tale of a time when social standing was of the utmost importance and prejudice reigned. Ida has grown into a tender-hearted young lady under the care of her aunt and uncle, the only parents she has ever known, but even they have their prejudices. Blaine is kind, polite and always considerate of his parents, but when he returns home from college to join the family business, he finds that he disagrees with them on many points in regarding to acceptance in society and racism directed at the Chinese immigrants inhabiting their city. Both Blaine and Ida have a deep faith and a yearning to share that faith with others who may not know the joys in serving Jesus. Meeting each other at a picnic, they both feel as if they have discovered the one God has chosen for them. Unfortunately Ida doesn't meet the expectations of Blaine's mother which sets off a course of events that cause them to have to fight for their relationship, often butting heads with their families. Ida's desire to share her faith with the ladies of ill repute working on Second Street, also intrigues Blaine, but their parents forbid it as well as sharing their faith with th Chinese servants who work in their homes.
Will Blaine and Ida stand strong in their determination to do God's will and follow His way, or will they let the love they have found for each other dwindle as one by one, their hopes and dreams seem to shatter around them. This is a heartfelt, faith-filled story of romance despite the difficulties, fighting for they believe in and trusting God to point the way.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review
Will Blaine and Ida stand strong in their determination to do God's will and follow His way, or will they let the love they have found for each other dwindle as one by one, their hopes and dreams seem to shatter around them. This is a heartfelt, faith-filled story of romance despite the difficulties, fighting for they believe in and trusting God to point the way.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review
March 13, 2025
The Angel of Second Street wasn't what I expected; it was much more, with its secrets, historical events, and forbidden love. The vivid descriptions of Eureka and San Francisco, CA, in 1884, had quite a diverse group of characters. The author does a wonderful job describing the darker side of Chinese Immigration and Second Street's "working women" while showing the Christian aspects of faith, love, grace, and forgiveness.
I enjoyed Ida and Blaine's love for each other despite all the challenges they faced. Their holding on to their faith and their desire to help the less fortunate were encouraging and inspiring. The story had me drawn in not long after I started reading and held my interest until the end. There were lots of surprises and twists, but everything wrapped up nicely in the end.
I received a complimentary copy from the author through Net Galley; a positive review is not required. All opinions are my own.
I enjoyed Ida and Blaine's love for each other despite all the challenges they faced. Their holding on to their faith and their desire to help the less fortunate were encouraging and inspiring. The story had me drawn in not long after I started reading and held my interest until the end. There were lots of surprises and twists, but everything wrapped up nicely in the end.
I received a complimentary copy from the author through Net Galley; a positive review is not required. All opinions are my own.
May 4, 2025
3.5 stars
I'm not sure how to review this book. On one hand, I found it refreshing that Ida has a passion for reaching out to prostitutes on second street and presenting the hope & love Jesus has for them. As well as Chinese immigrants—especially their cook Qui—in her hometown of Eureka California in 1884. On the other hand, her methods of going about it shows she lacks the maturity or common sense a young lady of her standing should. With no idea of the level of danger going into areas of Chinatown or the red light district unaccompanied poses, she puts herself in precarious situations seemingly without thought as to what could happen. I feared for her character on more than one occasion & the position she often put herself in. However, I do admire how Blaine helps her find ways to fulfill her desire to reach out to the lost and lessen the dangers surrounding her impulsive nature. It seems these two work well together in spite of resistance from their families.
Overall, it's a good book and the intent of the heart of both Ida & Blaine is admirable. It made me ponder ways in which I can reach the lost in my own life; whether it be unsaved coworkers, family members or those whom I deal with in everyday life. To have the same passion & drive to want to preach Jesus is what I want more than anything. It gave me much to think about!
That being said, I'm not sure this book was for me. The story was well-paced, well-written, engaging and left me pondering my own walk with Christ. I think because of Ida's immaturity & impulsive ways, it was quite off-putting. I do realize she was only 17—and sometimes young people of this age bracket don't always think things through—but with her genteel upbringing & time period in history, I feel she would have been a bit more mature in her decisions. Lastly, the story ended much too abruptly and left me with more questions than answers. I did enjoy reading the Author's Note at the end of the book explaining much of the historical tidbits included in the book.
I hope as a reader you come to your own conclusion about this story, it might be just the perfect book for you!
* I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review *
I'm not sure how to review this book. On one hand, I found it refreshing that Ida has a passion for reaching out to prostitutes on second street and presenting the hope & love Jesus has for them. As well as Chinese immigrants—especially their cook Qui—in her hometown of Eureka California in 1884. On the other hand, her methods of going about it shows she lacks the maturity or common sense a young lady of her standing should. With no idea of the level of danger going into areas of Chinatown or the red light district unaccompanied poses, she puts herself in precarious situations seemingly without thought as to what could happen. I feared for her character on more than one occasion & the position she often put herself in. However, I do admire how Blaine helps her find ways to fulfill her desire to reach out to the lost and lessen the dangers surrounding her impulsive nature. It seems these two work well together in spite of resistance from their families.
Overall, it's a good book and the intent of the heart of both Ida & Blaine is admirable. It made me ponder ways in which I can reach the lost in my own life; whether it be unsaved coworkers, family members or those whom I deal with in everyday life. To have the same passion & drive to want to preach Jesus is what I want more than anything. It gave me much to think about!
That being said, I'm not sure this book was for me. The story was well-paced, well-written, engaging and left me pondering my own walk with Christ. I think because of Ida's immaturity & impulsive ways, it was quite off-putting. I do realize she was only 17—and sometimes young people of this age bracket don't always think things through—but with her genteel upbringing & time period in history, I feel she would have been a bit more mature in her decisions. Lastly, the story ended much too abruptly and left me with more questions than answers. I did enjoy reading the Author's Note at the end of the book explaining much of the historical tidbits included in the book.
I hope as a reader you come to your own conclusion about this story, it might be just the perfect book for you!
* I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review *
March 13, 2025
A story of following God's calling despite what others try to tell you, The Angel of Second Street by Barbara Tifft Blakey has strong messages of faith, seeking God's directives, and reliance on God. Blakey developed strong characters in Ida and Blaine who each sought God's plan in their lives. Book #1 in the Enduring Hope series.
Releases May 1st. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Releases May 1st. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
May 15, 2025
Barbara Tifft Blakey is a new author to me and it was a delightful discovery!
I love Historical Romances, and I liked that this one was based on true events that happened in Eureka, California during the 1800´s.
Ida Dempsey, an orphan raised by her aunt and uncle, has lived a comfortable life. One day, she meets a poor woman named Esther at a drugstore, that makes her want to help her and tell her about Jesus so she can discover truth and happiness. But the woman lives in Second Street, which is an area where women of ill-repute live. She feels the call of God to minister to these women, but she is faced with many challenges. Not only putting her reputation at risk, but the women do not seem interested in what she has to offer, least of all Esther. Even more, she also wants to teach her Chinese cook about her faith, and is supported by her pastor to do it, but her aunt won’t have it. Many prejudices against the Chinese -who do all the heavier work- are rounding the town, and many local people are even trying to get them expelled from there.
Blaine Prescott has just returned from studying college and is eager to start his dream of working with his father in the family shipping business. He meets Ida at a Church picnic and it’s love at first sight. He’s been asking God to show him a good Christian woman for him, and he is immediately certain that Ida -even if she’s still a young girl of 17- is the one meant to be his wife. But his parents have other ideas, and Ida’s questionable escapades to help the needy makes it even more difficult. When his parents put him before the difficult choice of choosing between working at the family business or Ida, will he be able to sacrifice his long-life dream for the girl of his dreams?
The story is well written and fast paced. There are many inspirational and thought-provoking things about this book: the Christian compassion of helping those less fortunate and the immigrants, the courage to do what is right before God rather than please family and society expectations, the generosity to sacrifice dreams and comfort for integrity and doing what is right, even if it means going against family wishes. Both Ida and Blaine are admirable characters in their own way. Blaine, for his honesty, his integrity and strength to stand up to the manipulative ways of his family. His devotion to Ida is so loyal and endearing, you end up wishing many Blaines existed in this world. Although, I do think he could be a little less perfect to make him even more relatable. The way he looked up to his father and how both his parents just wanted to manipulate him to their standards, tugged at my heart. But he made the right and difficult decisions when circumstances demanded it. I loved that of him. Ida was innocent and naïve -maybe a little too much- which made her take rash and daring decisions that put her reputation -and even her life- at risk. She needed a bit of maturing, but I guess seventeen years old and being pampered all her life may be a good excuse. I have to say she had a heart of gold, kind compassionate and free of prejudices, which helped her grow out of her comfort zone and make sacrifices in order to help people that needed light in their life. Whatever she did, she did it passionately and made her so lovable. Still, I did want to shake her at times!
Both Ida and Blaine had a strong faith and a personal relationship with God that inspired me, and made me want for more in my relationship with God. The way they prayed and talked to God all the time felt natural and genuine. The story tackles strong issues like the lives of the lost women and the deplorable situation of the Chinese, but it was realistic and approached with humanity.
There are some unexpected twists to the story that made it even more intriguing and dramatic. The ending was good, I loved their happily ever after, but it felt a little rushed and I ended up wondering about things that didn’t get completely resolved.
All in all, a delightful and very inspiring historical romance. I recommend it!
I received a complimentary copy from Barbour Publishers but was not required to write a positive review. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
I love Historical Romances, and I liked that this one was based on true events that happened in Eureka, California during the 1800´s.
Ida Dempsey, an orphan raised by her aunt and uncle, has lived a comfortable life. One day, she meets a poor woman named Esther at a drugstore, that makes her want to help her and tell her about Jesus so she can discover truth and happiness. But the woman lives in Second Street, which is an area where women of ill-repute live. She feels the call of God to minister to these women, but she is faced with many challenges. Not only putting her reputation at risk, but the women do not seem interested in what she has to offer, least of all Esther. Even more, she also wants to teach her Chinese cook about her faith, and is supported by her pastor to do it, but her aunt won’t have it. Many prejudices against the Chinese -who do all the heavier work- are rounding the town, and many local people are even trying to get them expelled from there.
Blaine Prescott has just returned from studying college and is eager to start his dream of working with his father in the family shipping business. He meets Ida at a Church picnic and it’s love at first sight. He’s been asking God to show him a good Christian woman for him, and he is immediately certain that Ida -even if she’s still a young girl of 17- is the one meant to be his wife. But his parents have other ideas, and Ida’s questionable escapades to help the needy makes it even more difficult. When his parents put him before the difficult choice of choosing between working at the family business or Ida, will he be able to sacrifice his long-life dream for the girl of his dreams?
The story is well written and fast paced. There are many inspirational and thought-provoking things about this book: the Christian compassion of helping those less fortunate and the immigrants, the courage to do what is right before God rather than please family and society expectations, the generosity to sacrifice dreams and comfort for integrity and doing what is right, even if it means going against family wishes. Both Ida and Blaine are admirable characters in their own way. Blaine, for his honesty, his integrity and strength to stand up to the manipulative ways of his family. His devotion to Ida is so loyal and endearing, you end up wishing many Blaines existed in this world. Although, I do think he could be a little less perfect to make him even more relatable. The way he looked up to his father and how both his parents just wanted to manipulate him to their standards, tugged at my heart. But he made the right and difficult decisions when circumstances demanded it. I loved that of him. Ida was innocent and naïve -maybe a little too much- which made her take rash and daring decisions that put her reputation -and even her life- at risk. She needed a bit of maturing, but I guess seventeen years old and being pampered all her life may be a good excuse. I have to say she had a heart of gold, kind compassionate and free of prejudices, which helped her grow out of her comfort zone and make sacrifices in order to help people that needed light in their life. Whatever she did, she did it passionately and made her so lovable. Still, I did want to shake her at times!
Both Ida and Blaine had a strong faith and a personal relationship with God that inspired me, and made me want for more in my relationship with God. The way they prayed and talked to God all the time felt natural and genuine. The story tackles strong issues like the lives of the lost women and the deplorable situation of the Chinese, but it was realistic and approached with humanity.
There are some unexpected twists to the story that made it even more intriguing and dramatic. The ending was good, I loved their happily ever after, but it felt a little rushed and I ended up wondering about things that didn’t get completely resolved.
All in all, a delightful and very inspiring historical romance. I recommend it!
I received a complimentary copy from Barbour Publishers but was not required to write a positive review. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
May 29, 2025
“On my way to the picnic yesterday, I asked God to show me the woman He’d chosen to be my wife, someone who loves Jesus as much as I do. I saw you first.”
Wow! Barbara Tifft Blakey held me spellbound as she wove the historical story of 1884 Eureka, California, and its Chinatown. While I love to read historical romances, I am finding they are often not something I would want to live through. The Angel of Second Street tells of two young people who are immediately attracted to each other upon meeting. Rich, eligible Blaine sees beautiful Ida as a direct answer to his prayers for a godly mate. His family puts up every roadblock possible to keep the two apart, including throwing a family friend’s daughter into his path repeatedly.
I love Ida and Blaine. Both truly want to do more than follow society’s rules and make their families happy. Ida’s biggest wish in life is to tell others about Jesus. “God had opened the eyes of her heart, and everywhere Ida looked she saw hurting people. Even Mrs. Prescott.” She has a purpose, a mission, and a passion. She doesn’t give up. But she does battle within herself, having to deceive in order to carry out her definition of doing right. “Was anything more important than telling the lost about Jesus? But also important were the scriptural directives to obey one’s parents. In her case, didn’t that mean her aunt and uncle? Never before had she been forced to choose between two equally indispensable commands.” Blaine has his own struggles with his shipping tycoon father who has no interest in anyone’s true well-being.
Whew, it’s incredible the mental struggles both Ida and Blaine must wade through, accompanied by much prayer, to figure out the right path. Sometimes the paths they choose are funny. Sometimes the resulting paths are loaded with strife. I wondered if I’d be brave enough to choose some of the paths they did, or would I choose to please people and just make life easy?
I loved seeing the growth of thinking in both Ida and Blaine.
Some characters are surprising. How fun it was, to discover characters acting quite differently than what I expected of them! Great twists!
My fave character is Reverend Huntington. It took me a while to figure out how he feels about the workers from Chinatown that the town wants to expel, or the ladies of Second Street that Ida is determined to help. At first he is unwilling to encourage Ida in her endeavors. Eventually, we see him in another light.
It is so sad to see the general attitude of the town’s affluent businessmen. While their households and sometimes businesses benefit greatly from the Chinese workers, they despise them immensely. “Less than.” That is the rich, white opinion towards the Chinese. Blaine is like Ida in his disregard for class. He understands the prejudice he is seeing, directed at the Chinatown residents. “The way he saw it, the problems discussed were symptoms of underlying issues. Tackle those, and the contemptible manifestations would take care of themselves.” Hmmm… makes one think about today’s atmosphere of cancelling whole groups of people for the actions of a few.
Notable Quotables:
“My heavenly Father is responsible for my joy—and for yours. You cannot protect me from this world’s trials. You don’t need to, because I have His defense and refuge.”- Ida
“If a man lost integrity, what did he have left?”
“I believe God is calling me to act, and I’m willing.”
Wow! Barbara Tifft Blakey held me spellbound as she wove the historical story of 1884 Eureka, California, and its Chinatown. While I love to read historical romances, I am finding they are often not something I would want to live through. The Angel of Second Street tells of two young people who are immediately attracted to each other upon meeting. Rich, eligible Blaine sees beautiful Ida as a direct answer to his prayers for a godly mate. His family puts up every roadblock possible to keep the two apart, including throwing a family friend’s daughter into his path repeatedly.
I love Ida and Blaine. Both truly want to do more than follow society’s rules and make their families happy. Ida’s biggest wish in life is to tell others about Jesus. “God had opened the eyes of her heart, and everywhere Ida looked she saw hurting people. Even Mrs. Prescott.” She has a purpose, a mission, and a passion. She doesn’t give up. But she does battle within herself, having to deceive in order to carry out her definition of doing right. “Was anything more important than telling the lost about Jesus? But also important were the scriptural directives to obey one’s parents. In her case, didn’t that mean her aunt and uncle? Never before had she been forced to choose between two equally indispensable commands.” Blaine has his own struggles with his shipping tycoon father who has no interest in anyone’s true well-being.
Whew, it’s incredible the mental struggles both Ida and Blaine must wade through, accompanied by much prayer, to figure out the right path. Sometimes the paths they choose are funny. Sometimes the resulting paths are loaded with strife. I wondered if I’d be brave enough to choose some of the paths they did, or would I choose to please people and just make life easy?
I loved seeing the growth of thinking in both Ida and Blaine.
Some characters are surprising. How fun it was, to discover characters acting quite differently than what I expected of them! Great twists!
My fave character is Reverend Huntington. It took me a while to figure out how he feels about the workers from Chinatown that the town wants to expel, or the ladies of Second Street that Ida is determined to help. At first he is unwilling to encourage Ida in her endeavors. Eventually, we see him in another light.
It is so sad to see the general attitude of the town’s affluent businessmen. While their households and sometimes businesses benefit greatly from the Chinese workers, they despise them immensely. “Less than.” That is the rich, white opinion towards the Chinese. Blaine is like Ida in his disregard for class. He understands the prejudice he is seeing, directed at the Chinatown residents. “The way he saw it, the problems discussed were symptoms of underlying issues. Tackle those, and the contemptible manifestations would take care of themselves.” Hmmm… makes one think about today’s atmosphere of cancelling whole groups of people for the actions of a few.
Notable Quotables:
“My heavenly Father is responsible for my joy—and for yours. You cannot protect me from this world’s trials. You don’t need to, because I have His defense and refuge.”- Ida
“If a man lost integrity, what did he have left?”
“I believe God is calling me to act, and I’m willing.”
May 1, 2025
The Angel of Second Street by Barbara Tifft Blakey
Book 1 of 2: Enduring Hope
How Can Compassion be Considered Wrong?
Ida Dempsey has grown up in a privileged life of luxury thanks to her aunt and uncle. Although Second Street—where women of ill repute ply their wares—is off limits to respectable citizens, her heart of compassion compels her to frequent the area, hoping to make a difference in their lives. Ida has also befriended Qui Shau, a Chinese woman who keeps house for her family, but friendships between the whites and Chinese are taboo in Eureka. Ida tries to keep secret her forbidden compassion, but someone is watching and will use it against her.
When Blaine Prescott meets Ida at a church picnic, his parents warn him away from any relationship with the young lady who has been seen on Second Street in the company of a Chinese woman. But how could such a kindhearted, lovely young woman be anything but good? But when riots break out in Chinatown and Ida disappears, Blaine will do anything to find out where and why she has gone.
Ida Dempsey pinned her bonnet on and skipped down the staircase, eager to enjoy the church picnic among the redwoods. It was a perfect sunny day for such an outing. She bobbed into the kitchen where Qui Shau prepared food for the hamper.
“Come on, Qui,” Ida’s older cousin, Wallace, begged. “Just one piece.” He eyed the three-layer chocolate cake then winked at Ida. “Shouldn’t someone taste it to make sure it’s up to snuff?”
Qui slapped his hand. “No, you wait.” As her lips drew thin, a twinkle remained in her eyes. She pointed toward the door. “Go! You get out my kitchen.”
Wallace grabbed a cookie. “Thanks, Qui.” The door banged shut behind him.
“Yes, Father, I’ll be there.” Blaine Prescott handed his mother into the brougham coach. “I’ve a few things to do, but I’ll arrive before the croquet game begins.”
“See that you do.” Mr. Prescott closed the coach door.
Mrs. Prescott addressed Blaine through the carriage window. “We are eager for you to meet important people. It is imperative you make a good impression.”
“You mean important people in the form of eligible young ladies, I assume?”
His father leaned forward, making eye contact with Blaine. “I didn’t send you to Santa Clara University so you could fritter away your life. Now that you’ve graduated, it’s time you married.”
The Angel of Second Street: Volume 1 (Enduring Hope) by Barbara Tifft Blakey is a 4 star book.
I voluntarily read an advanced readers copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed here in this review are entirely my own.
Book 1 of 2: Enduring Hope
How Can Compassion be Considered Wrong?
Ida Dempsey has grown up in a privileged life of luxury thanks to her aunt and uncle. Although Second Street—where women of ill repute ply their wares—is off limits to respectable citizens, her heart of compassion compels her to frequent the area, hoping to make a difference in their lives. Ida has also befriended Qui Shau, a Chinese woman who keeps house for her family, but friendships between the whites and Chinese are taboo in Eureka. Ida tries to keep secret her forbidden compassion, but someone is watching and will use it against her.
When Blaine Prescott meets Ida at a church picnic, his parents warn him away from any relationship with the young lady who has been seen on Second Street in the company of a Chinese woman. But how could such a kindhearted, lovely young woman be anything but good? But when riots break out in Chinatown and Ida disappears, Blaine will do anything to find out where and why she has gone.
Ida Dempsey pinned her bonnet on and skipped down the staircase, eager to enjoy the church picnic among the redwoods. It was a perfect sunny day for such an outing. She bobbed into the kitchen where Qui Shau prepared food for the hamper.
“Come on, Qui,” Ida’s older cousin, Wallace, begged. “Just one piece.” He eyed the three-layer chocolate cake then winked at Ida. “Shouldn’t someone taste it to make sure it’s up to snuff?”
Qui slapped his hand. “No, you wait.” As her lips drew thin, a twinkle remained in her eyes. She pointed toward the door. “Go! You get out my kitchen.”
Wallace grabbed a cookie. “Thanks, Qui.” The door banged shut behind him.
“Yes, Father, I’ll be there.” Blaine Prescott handed his mother into the brougham coach. “I’ve a few things to do, but I’ll arrive before the croquet game begins.”
“See that you do.” Mr. Prescott closed the coach door.
Mrs. Prescott addressed Blaine through the carriage window. “We are eager for you to meet important people. It is imperative you make a good impression.”
“You mean important people in the form of eligible young ladies, I assume?”
His father leaned forward, making eye contact with Blaine. “I didn’t send you to Santa Clara University so you could fritter away your life. Now that you’ve graduated, it’s time you married.”
The Angel of Second Street: Volume 1 (Enduring Hope) by Barbara Tifft Blakey is a 4 star book.
I voluntarily read an advanced readers copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed here in this review are entirely my own.
May 18, 2025
When Ida Dempsey's world of wealth comes into contact with those that are less than desirable in her community readers will have their hearts stirred at the lengths Ida will go to bring the Good News of God to them.
Ida Dempsey has grown up with the best that her aunt and uncle could provide enjoying the richness of her life. Caring and a heart of compassion for those less fortunate and who are looked down upon is a driving force in her life. Ida has a fondness for the Chinese woman, Qui Shau and wants desperately to teach her about Jesus even though society said she shouldn't get involved with Qui Shau outside of her caring for the house and family. Ida's friend Mattie helps her devise a plan where they can reach out the women of Second Street (the streets of women of ill repute). Ida is very drawn to one of the women and tried desperately to reach out to her. There is a storyline there I won't spoil for the readers.
Blaine Prescott is a young man who has returned to town to help his father run his business but what Blaine really wants and what he earnestly prayers for is a wife who has a strong faith in God. When Ida and Blaine's world collide, he is very taken with her. His mother has quite a bit to say about Ida not being of a refined enough family to be a
part of Blaine's life and she and Blaine's father take drastic measures to keep the two apart.
When Ida's cover is blown when her disguise wasn't enough to keep her secret of helping the ladies of Second Street she finds another way to continue her mission to bring the ladies to Jesus while making sure Qui Shau and other Chinese workers have access to bibles and study groups.
Blaine deeply adores caring and loving Ida who even though at the age of 17 is wise beyond her years in some instances while at other times her maturity shows at some indiscretions of the ladies she is working with.
What I loved about this book is how it showed how shallow some people can be while being Christians. It shed light on easily we can dismiss those we think aren't worthy of knowing their loving and caring Father in heaven. Ida's character took it to heart that everyone is redeemable, and everyone deserves second chances and to be loved as God has called us to love our neighbors.
I will not spoil the ending of this story where Ida learns about her family, but it was an amazing ending!!
Barbara Tifft Blakey is a new to me author and I will most definitely be searching out more of her books.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and was under no obligation to post a review.
Ida Dempsey has grown up with the best that her aunt and uncle could provide enjoying the richness of her life. Caring and a heart of compassion for those less fortunate and who are looked down upon is a driving force in her life. Ida has a fondness for the Chinese woman, Qui Shau and wants desperately to teach her about Jesus even though society said she shouldn't get involved with Qui Shau outside of her caring for the house and family. Ida's friend Mattie helps her devise a plan where they can reach out the women of Second Street (the streets of women of ill repute). Ida is very drawn to one of the women and tried desperately to reach out to her. There is a storyline there I won't spoil for the readers.
Blaine Prescott is a young man who has returned to town to help his father run his business but what Blaine really wants and what he earnestly prayers for is a wife who has a strong faith in God. When Ida and Blaine's world collide, he is very taken with her. His mother has quite a bit to say about Ida not being of a refined enough family to be a
part of Blaine's life and she and Blaine's father take drastic measures to keep the two apart.
When Ida's cover is blown when her disguise wasn't enough to keep her secret of helping the ladies of Second Street she finds another way to continue her mission to bring the ladies to Jesus while making sure Qui Shau and other Chinese workers have access to bibles and study groups.
Blaine deeply adores caring and loving Ida who even though at the age of 17 is wise beyond her years in some instances while at other times her maturity shows at some indiscretions of the ladies she is working with.
What I loved about this book is how it showed how shallow some people can be while being Christians. It shed light on easily we can dismiss those we think aren't worthy of knowing their loving and caring Father in heaven. Ida's character took it to heart that everyone is redeemable, and everyone deserves second chances and to be loved as God has called us to love our neighbors.
I will not spoil the ending of this story where Ida learns about her family, but it was an amazing ending!!
Barbara Tifft Blakey is a new to me author and I will most definitely be searching out more of her books.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and was under no obligation to post a review.
May 24, 2025
About the Book:
How Can Compassion be Considered Wrong?
When life is weighed down by challenges, pillars of enduring hope and love are always waiting to be discovered.
Ida Dempsey has grown up in a privileged life of luxury thanks to her aunt and uncle. Although Second Street—where women of ill repute ply their wares—is off limits to respectable citizens, her heart of compassion compels her to frequent the area, hoping to make a difference in their lives. Ida has also befriended Qui Shau, a Chinese woman who keeps house for her family, but friendships between the whites and Chinese are taboo in Eureka. Ida tries to keep secret her forbidden compassion, but someone is watching and will use it against her.
When Blaine Prescott meets Ida at a church picnic, his parents warn him away from any relationship with the young lady who has been seen on Second Street in the company of a Chinese woman. But how could such a kindhearted, lovely young woman be anything but good? But when riots break out in Chinatown and Ida disappears, Blaine will do anything to find out where and why she has gone.
My Review:
I really liked Ida's story and how it went in deep to the struggles of that time. Im sure there were many people in that era with the same convictions and heart as Ida. Many suffered with it in silence and many did as Ida did. Went there and tried to help others as the Bible instructs us to do. I dont think the author writing on such a taboo topic of the time was wrong or forced. I actually believe quite the opposite.
I love the story and I love Blaine's part in this whole ordeal and Im glad he was waiting in the wings to in turn help Ida. I like the story and the two rich in detail characters served it well. Too bad we can hear a little more from the two of them.
Great summer beach read!
**Disclosure**This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
How Can Compassion be Considered Wrong?
When life is weighed down by challenges, pillars of enduring hope and love are always waiting to be discovered.
Ida Dempsey has grown up in a privileged life of luxury thanks to her aunt and uncle. Although Second Street—where women of ill repute ply their wares—is off limits to respectable citizens, her heart of compassion compels her to frequent the area, hoping to make a difference in their lives. Ida has also befriended Qui Shau, a Chinese woman who keeps house for her family, but friendships between the whites and Chinese are taboo in Eureka. Ida tries to keep secret her forbidden compassion, but someone is watching and will use it against her.
When Blaine Prescott meets Ida at a church picnic, his parents warn him away from any relationship with the young lady who has been seen on Second Street in the company of a Chinese woman. But how could such a kindhearted, lovely young woman be anything but good? But when riots break out in Chinatown and Ida disappears, Blaine will do anything to find out where and why she has gone.
My Review:
I really liked Ida's story and how it went in deep to the struggles of that time. Im sure there were many people in that era with the same convictions and heart as Ida. Many suffered with it in silence and many did as Ida did. Went there and tried to help others as the Bible instructs us to do. I dont think the author writing on such a taboo topic of the time was wrong or forced. I actually believe quite the opposite.
I love the story and I love Blaine's part in this whole ordeal and Im glad he was waiting in the wings to in turn help Ida. I like the story and the two rich in detail characters served it well. Too bad we can hear a little more from the two of them.
Great summer beach read!
**Disclosure**This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
June 13, 2025
The Angel of Second Street is a wonderful historical fiction novel with some mystery and some romance thrown in as well. You’re going to love this book. Good news, the second book in the series, as well as the third, are on their way! Book two comes out in August, so don’t miss it.
In this book, we meet Ida. Ida has a heart for people. She doesn’t really care about social status or what class someone is or even what they do for a living. She just cares about them as people. It’s admirable, but not acceptable for her time. And it could get her into a lot of trouble.
When people of standing start to notice that Ida is frequenting areas of the city that they deem unacceptable, life begins to be difficult. When Blaine meets Ida at a church picnic, he wants to know more. But his parents are telling him she’s not an acceptable choice for a match. Will he listen to them? Or will he pursue her?
And what happens when Ida disappears in the wake of riots in the Chinese area? Can Blaine find her?
I highly enjoyed this book and will be for sure reading the rest of the series!
Some things of note. I would not let my younger teens read this book. While it is not bad, there are things chatted about and mentioned that I personally would not be comfortable with them reading. That said, I would label this an adult book. There is talk of prostitutes and babies born out of wedlock. There are mentions of the clothing and what would be revealed. But to counter that, there are scriptures and a strong Bible and God presence in the book.
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, which I received from Celebrate Lit. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review, nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.
In this book, we meet Ida. Ida has a heart for people. She doesn’t really care about social status or what class someone is or even what they do for a living. She just cares about them as people. It’s admirable, but not acceptable for her time. And it could get her into a lot of trouble.
When people of standing start to notice that Ida is frequenting areas of the city that they deem unacceptable, life begins to be difficult. When Blaine meets Ida at a church picnic, he wants to know more. But his parents are telling him she’s not an acceptable choice for a match. Will he listen to them? Or will he pursue her?
And what happens when Ida disappears in the wake of riots in the Chinese area? Can Blaine find her?
I highly enjoyed this book and will be for sure reading the rest of the series!
Some things of note. I would not let my younger teens read this book. While it is not bad, there are things chatted about and mentioned that I personally would not be comfortable with them reading. That said, I would label this an adult book. There is talk of prostitutes and babies born out of wedlock. There are mentions of the clothing and what would be revealed. But to counter that, there are scriptures and a strong Bible and God presence in the book.
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, which I received from Celebrate Lit. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review, nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.
June 3, 2025
The Angel on Second Street by Barbara Tifft Blakey is a Christian Fiction/Romance/Historical Fiction novel. Ida Dempsey grew up in relative luxury with her aunt, uncle, and cousin. Now at seventeen she longs to honor God and serve Him by telling people about His love, grace, and mercy. But doing so in Eureka proves to be challenging since she finds herself forbidden to interact with the Chinese.
Blaine Prescott meets Ida Dempsey at a church picnic and finds himself enchanted by her. However, his parents warn him away from her. They take offense at her being seen on Second Street in Chinatown in the company of a Chinese woman. They even go as far as to send him away from Eureka in the hopes of him making a match with a proper lady.
The author builds a book filled with God, faith, family, compassion, grace, friendship, and more. I loved getting to know Ida and Blaine and to see how they love God and seek to serve Him. The twists and turns this book takes you through including Ida’s friendship with Qui Shau, a Chinese woman who serves the Dempsey family, and her desire to improve Qui Shau’s life drew me into the story.
Other characters in the book surprised me in how their storylines developed. I would love to get to read the story of Ida’s cousin, Abigail – Blaine’s best friend’s sister, and how the relationship develops between Ida and another woman in the story. I have to say I loved reading this book and getting to know these characters.
So if you want a novel that combines Christian Fiction, Romance. and Historical Fiction, check out The Angel on Second Street by Barbara Tifft Blakey.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
Blaine Prescott meets Ida Dempsey at a church picnic and finds himself enchanted by her. However, his parents warn him away from her. They take offense at her being seen on Second Street in Chinatown in the company of a Chinese woman. They even go as far as to send him away from Eureka in the hopes of him making a match with a proper lady.
The author builds a book filled with God, faith, family, compassion, grace, friendship, and more. I loved getting to know Ida and Blaine and to see how they love God and seek to serve Him. The twists and turns this book takes you through including Ida’s friendship with Qui Shau, a Chinese woman who serves the Dempsey family, and her desire to improve Qui Shau’s life drew me into the story.
Other characters in the book surprised me in how their storylines developed. I would love to get to read the story of Ida’s cousin, Abigail – Blaine’s best friend’s sister, and how the relationship develops between Ida and another woman in the story. I have to say I loved reading this book and getting to know these characters.
So if you want a novel that combines Christian Fiction, Romance. and Historical Fiction, check out The Angel on Second Street by Barbara Tifft Blakey.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
June 9, 2025
I have read and enjoyed several stories lately with women in unconventional roles, such as young Ida Dempsy in The Angel of Second Street. I enjoyed this character and her unique story. I appreciate how the author doesn’t shy away from the seedier things in life, or the prejudice of believers and unbelievers alike, yet offers a strong Christian message.
Ida is a genuine and sweet-natured young lady with a strong desire to serve God. I admire her compassion for others and how she allows her heart and faith to guide her rather than following the accepted social “rules” and norms of her family and community. Because of her wholesomeness, fortunate upbringing, and youthful inexperience, she puts herself in dangerous situations (which makes me want to shake her at times) that reveals her unwavering desire and determination to witness to others.
Blaine is a sincere man who is easy to connect with and his passion to witness to others is also evident. I appreciate how he wants a godly woman and relies on his prayers and strong faith in God to deliver her to him. He is more mature than Ida and slightly balances out her (sometimes off-putting) immaturity.
This is a fresh story that doesn’t mask the ugliness of sin, yet reveals it through a lens of faith, hope, love, and grace. Though I didn’t connect with Ida like I’d hoped, I did enjoy this unique and quick read and will seek out new books in this series.
First Line: Ida Dempsy pinned her bonnet on and skipped down the staircase, eager to enjoy the church picnic among the redwoods.
Series: Enduring Hope, book 1
Genre: Christian Historical Romance
Author: Barbara Tifft Blakey
Page Count: 256
Content: Prostitution, prejudice
#CoverLoverBookReview received a review copy of this book. Opinions are 100% my own.
Ida is a genuine and sweet-natured young lady with a strong desire to serve God. I admire her compassion for others and how she allows her heart and faith to guide her rather than following the accepted social “rules” and norms of her family and community. Because of her wholesomeness, fortunate upbringing, and youthful inexperience, she puts herself in dangerous situations (which makes me want to shake her at times) that reveals her unwavering desire and determination to witness to others.
Blaine is a sincere man who is easy to connect with and his passion to witness to others is also evident. I appreciate how he wants a godly woman and relies on his prayers and strong faith in God to deliver her to him. He is more mature than Ida and slightly balances out her (sometimes off-putting) immaturity.
This is a fresh story that doesn’t mask the ugliness of sin, yet reveals it through a lens of faith, hope, love, and grace. Though I didn’t connect with Ida like I’d hoped, I did enjoy this unique and quick read and will seek out new books in this series.
First Line: Ida Dempsy pinned her bonnet on and skipped down the staircase, eager to enjoy the church picnic among the redwoods.
Series: Enduring Hope, book 1
Genre: Christian Historical Romance
Author: Barbara Tifft Blakey
Page Count: 256
Content: Prostitution, prejudice
#CoverLoverBookReview received a review copy of this book. Opinions are 100% my own.
June 2, 2025
Oh my is Ida a sweet young lady. There is talk swirling all around about finding a husband for her. I loved when she said , “I want to serve God. I want to share Jesus and talk about Him.” Her heart is filled with her love for God. It will take a special man to capture her heart. Her faith is deep rooted and she continues to pray for God to send her the right man.
Blaine is a good character who wants to marry but she needs to be special. He prays for the right one and then he meets Ida. The chemistry is definitely there as they begin a blossoming friendship. He knows that Ida wants to reach others and share about God, but will he be willing to go with her.
I remember sitting in church today and hearing a message about going out and reaching others. Do we know our neighbors? What about down the road where there may be people who are struggling? Ida inspires me to get out of my comfort zone and be His hands and feet.
I appreciate how the author shows readers how Chinese immigrants were treated. It breaks my heart to know that there are those who shame others. Ida sees past the cruel words spoken to these women and knows that God loves them unconditionally. Ida is determined to reach these women and is not afraid of her reputation being ruined.
A beautiful story of faith, prejudice and unconditional love await readers in this unforgettable illustration of following God. Ida is an inspiration to everyone who seeks God for their calling. Blaine is a man who stands up for what he believes. The ending was so impressive and I can’t wait to read more from this gifted author.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
Blaine is a good character who wants to marry but she needs to be special. He prays for the right one and then he meets Ida. The chemistry is definitely there as they begin a blossoming friendship. He knows that Ida wants to reach others and share about God, but will he be willing to go with her.
I remember sitting in church today and hearing a message about going out and reaching others. Do we know our neighbors? What about down the road where there may be people who are struggling? Ida inspires me to get out of my comfort zone and be His hands and feet.
I appreciate how the author shows readers how Chinese immigrants were treated. It breaks my heart to know that there are those who shame others. Ida sees past the cruel words spoken to these women and knows that God loves them unconditionally. Ida is determined to reach these women and is not afraid of her reputation being ruined.
A beautiful story of faith, prejudice and unconditional love await readers in this unforgettable illustration of following God. Ida is an inspiration to everyone who seeks God for their calling. Blaine is a man who stands up for what he believes. The ending was so impressive and I can’t wait to read more from this gifted author.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
June 6, 2025
There was much about this book that I enjoyed. Ida is an incredibly sweet character and her heart to serve the Lord is admirable. She just wants others to know about Jesus–what’s wrong with that? And the fact that Blaine prayed for a woman just like her, supports her in her endeavors, and deeply cares about her–well, that’s just swoon-worthy.
I also thoroughly enjoyed the historical background. My knowledge of the history of Chinese immigrants is extremely limited, if not nonexistent, so I really loved the incorporation of that in the novel. It broke my heart to read about how they were treated and how people looked down on them and wanted to get rid of them.
That being said, there were aspects of this book that I struggled with. Ida, while incredibly sweet, was also naive. Perhaps that could be accredited to her young age, however, it was something that I could not get past. She constantly defied her aunt and uncle, ignored warnings from others, and jumped into her plan headfirst without considering the consequences or heeding any sort of advice. I, of course, encourage those to listen to God’s calling for them, however, I do also believe in constant prayer and Godly advice and leadership–the latter of which Ida did not pursue.
There was also an incredible lack of communication in the book which just ended up frustrating me. The ending was also abrupt with lots of loose ends still needing to be tied up.
Overall, even though it was not my cup of tea, if you like Christian historical fiction, I would recommend this book.
I had received a copy of the book as part of the Celebrate Lit Blogging Team and was required to give an honest review.
I also thoroughly enjoyed the historical background. My knowledge of the history of Chinese immigrants is extremely limited, if not nonexistent, so I really loved the incorporation of that in the novel. It broke my heart to read about how they were treated and how people looked down on them and wanted to get rid of them.
That being said, there were aspects of this book that I struggled with. Ida, while incredibly sweet, was also naive. Perhaps that could be accredited to her young age, however, it was something that I could not get past. She constantly defied her aunt and uncle, ignored warnings from others, and jumped into her plan headfirst without considering the consequences or heeding any sort of advice. I, of course, encourage those to listen to God’s calling for them, however, I do also believe in constant prayer and Godly advice and leadership–the latter of which Ida did not pursue.
There was also an incredible lack of communication in the book which just ended up frustrating me. The ending was also abrupt with lots of loose ends still needing to be tied up.
Overall, even though it was not my cup of tea, if you like Christian historical fiction, I would recommend this book.
I had received a copy of the book as part of the Celebrate Lit Blogging Team and was required to give an honest review.
May 1, 2025
Barbara Tifft Blakey transports readers to 1880s Eureka, California, when anti-Chinese racism was rampant. Ida Dempsey makes it her mission to teach the soiled doves of the town about Jesus.
Seventeen-year-old Ida, with boundless enthusiasm, little tact, and even less sense, visits the notorious Second Street to deliver the Good Word to the fallen women. With that approach, what could possibly go wrong? Perhaps my amusement at Ida's first misguided attempt is unfair, yet I found the scandalously-clad heroine and her genuine confusion to be diverting. Eventually she turns her attention to meaningful service, with fulfilling results.
Love interest Blaine Prescott is devout, as well. His mother is a condescending snob and his father a domineering businessman, and neither displays any faith, so it's a wonder Blaine is religious at all. Compatibility of faith is essential to a couple, but Blaine determines that is the only criteria needed for a successful union; therefore, he chooses Ida after a brief encounter. While most of the characters are appealing, they're not finely developed.
Blakey imparts many interesting facts of the time, and several historical characters are featured. The author's prose is pleasing and easy to read. However, there's a side plot that doesn't get the attention it deserves. There are some references to the health concerns of the prostitutes. Other than that, this novel has a YA feel.
Thanks to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for an ARC of this tale.
Seventeen-year-old Ida, with boundless enthusiasm, little tact, and even less sense, visits the notorious Second Street to deliver the Good Word to the fallen women. With that approach, what could possibly go wrong? Perhaps my amusement at Ida's first misguided attempt is unfair, yet I found the scandalously-clad heroine and her genuine confusion to be diverting. Eventually she turns her attention to meaningful service, with fulfilling results.
Love interest Blaine Prescott is devout, as well. His mother is a condescending snob and his father a domineering businessman, and neither displays any faith, so it's a wonder Blaine is religious at all. Compatibility of faith is essential to a couple, but Blaine determines that is the only criteria needed for a successful union; therefore, he chooses Ida after a brief encounter. While most of the characters are appealing, they're not finely developed.
Blakey imparts many interesting facts of the time, and several historical characters are featured. The author's prose is pleasing and easy to read. However, there's a side plot that doesn't get the attention it deserves. There are some references to the health concerns of the prostitutes. Other than that, this novel has a YA feel.
Thanks to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for an ARC of this tale.
May 15, 2025
5 stars, Impetuous Miss
THE ANGEL OF SECOND STREET (ENDURING HOPE BOOK 1)
BY Barbara Tifft Blakey
Ida lives with her aunt and uncle in Eureka, California in 1884. Ida wants to minister to the Ladies of Second Street that live in the brothels there. She would also like to share her faith with her Chinese cook and other immigrants in Chinatown. Ida doesn't believe that those areas aren't safe for young misses. She daringly takes chances that could have poor outcomes for her, with no caring for her own personal safety.
Blaine lives with his overbearing parents and looks forward to helping his father run the family business.
Ida gets into all sorts of mischief while trying to minister to the downtrodden of her town. She doesn't understand why no one wants to help the unfortunate souls.
Blaine's parents want him to marry well to beautiful powder puff, with no brains or personality. Blaine wants more.
Ida reminds me a little of Lucille Ball. How Lucy was always getting into messes.
I liked Blaine, he was a determined young man who knew what he wanted from life and had no problems going after it. His life would never be dull, with Ida around.
The author used historical facts surrounding the Chinese during this time period.
I received a complimentary copy of #TheAngelOfSecondStreet #EnduringHopeSeries from #BarbourFiction #BarbourPublishing #BarbaraTifftBlakey #NetGalley I was not obligated to post a review.
#historicalfiction #EurekaCalifornia #ChristianFiction #inspirational #sweetromance
THE ANGEL OF SECOND STREET (ENDURING HOPE BOOK 1)
BY Barbara Tifft Blakey
Ida lives with her aunt and uncle in Eureka, California in 1884. Ida wants to minister to the Ladies of Second Street that live in the brothels there. She would also like to share her faith with her Chinese cook and other immigrants in Chinatown. Ida doesn't believe that those areas aren't safe for young misses. She daringly takes chances that could have poor outcomes for her, with no caring for her own personal safety.
Blaine lives with his overbearing parents and looks forward to helping his father run the family business.
Ida gets into all sorts of mischief while trying to minister to the downtrodden of her town. She doesn't understand why no one wants to help the unfortunate souls.
Blaine's parents want him to marry well to beautiful powder puff, with no brains or personality. Blaine wants more.
Ida reminds me a little of Lucille Ball. How Lucy was always getting into messes.
I liked Blaine, he was a determined young man who knew what he wanted from life and had no problems going after it. His life would never be dull, with Ida around.
The author used historical facts surrounding the Chinese during this time period.
I received a complimentary copy of #TheAngelOfSecondStreet #EnduringHopeSeries from #BarbourFiction #BarbourPublishing #BarbaraTifftBlakey #NetGalley I was not obligated to post a review.
#historicalfiction #EurekaCalifornia #ChristianFiction #inspirational #sweetromance
May 2, 2025
This story started just a little bit slow for me. My mind tended to wander during the beginning, but soon picked up and I was intrigued at the idea of this young lady, Ida, who was so bold and determined to share her faith and belief with the downtrodden. However, I don’t believe her story to be believable, especially without being harmed in anyway, so even though this is a story of fiction, I like to read fiction that at least can be plausible. The fact that her betrothed was attacked is proof of that.
The family dynamics and social classes made for interesting reading, including the matchmaking mommas, disinheritance of family business, and secrets of parenthood to name a few.
The sweet romance and faith in Jesus Christ was uplifting and inspiring.
This story also portrays the injustice and cruel treatment of the Chinese people in and around Eureka, California. I have read other stories that reiterate this in other parts of the country as well. It’s unfortunate that people cannot treat each other as their equal, be it from the past or in the present.
I did think the ending was too abrupt. It would’ve been nice to have at least had an epilogue.
So while I enjoyed much of the story, there were a few parts I struggled with, which is what led me to my 3.5 rating rounded up to 4.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
The family dynamics and social classes made for interesting reading, including the matchmaking mommas, disinheritance of family business, and secrets of parenthood to name a few.
The sweet romance and faith in Jesus Christ was uplifting and inspiring.
This story also portrays the injustice and cruel treatment of the Chinese people in and around Eureka, California. I have read other stories that reiterate this in other parts of the country as well. It’s unfortunate that people cannot treat each other as their equal, be it from the past or in the present.
I did think the ending was too abrupt. It would’ve been nice to have at least had an epilogue.
So while I enjoyed much of the story, there were a few parts I struggled with, which is what led me to my 3.5 rating rounded up to 4.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
May 3, 2025
This story is set in 1884 California, largely in the city of Eureka. The female protagonist is a young woman who is determined to share Jesus with two of the city's marginalized populations. The male protagonist is a slightly older man who is determined to follow the path God wants for his life, but must learn to accept that may not be what he had always thought it was. While these two seem perfect for one another, life seems set on keeping them apart. That causes the reader much angst as they can see what's coming next when the characters can't. Isn't that the way it is sometimes in our own lives, those around us can often see where our path is leading even when we can't? That is when we, too, must truly surrender our plans to God.
Blakey has written a story that includes a sweet romance as well as lots of family drama that revolves around opposing priorities and allegiances. We understand how her characters think and feel, but we don't know a lot about what life events brought most of them to being the person they have become. The dialogue flows smoothly. The mental images the author creates are visually and emotionally vivid. The story comes to a satisfactory ending even though not everything is tied up neatly with a bow. I am grateful to have received a complimentary copy of The Angel of Second Street from Barbour Publishing via NetGalley without obligation. All opinions expressed here are my own.
Blakey has written a story that includes a sweet romance as well as lots of family drama that revolves around opposing priorities and allegiances. We understand how her characters think and feel, but we don't know a lot about what life events brought most of them to being the person they have become. The dialogue flows smoothly. The mental images the author creates are visually and emotionally vivid. The story comes to a satisfactory ending even though not everything is tied up neatly with a bow. I am grateful to have received a complimentary copy of The Angel of Second Street from Barbour Publishing via NetGalley without obligation. All opinions expressed here are my own.
May 18, 2025
Ida and Blaine’s story is for those who enjoy insta-love, strong faith themes, and family disagreements. Ida and Blaine had lots of things to get in the way of their relationship - a jealous and overzealous friend, family members that feel they don’t belong, distance, and even some miscommunication. I like how they just went to God and trusted He knew what was best for them.
I admired Ida’s desire to share the gospel, especially with those who led a different lifestyle. I think at times she was extremely naive about it, but we can still glean something from her willingness to do whatever it takes. She was willing to take risks. Go against the norm. And that’s something I found commendable, even though I think she was way in over her head.
The other thing I admired was Blaine’s ability to not let his family dissuade him from Ida. He wasn’t afraid to admit she was whom he desired, and he wouldn’t go along with their attempts to pair him with other girls. In fact he was rather bold about it - something we don’t see often from historical heroes.
I would have liked to see a little more growth and connection to the characters - but this is just me personally. Overall I think historical fiction fans that want a strong faith themes will enjoy the story.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I admired Ida’s desire to share the gospel, especially with those who led a different lifestyle. I think at times she was extremely naive about it, but we can still glean something from her willingness to do whatever it takes. She was willing to take risks. Go against the norm. And that’s something I found commendable, even though I think she was way in over her head.
The other thing I admired was Blaine’s ability to not let his family dissuade him from Ida. He wasn’t afraid to admit she was whom he desired, and he wouldn’t go along with their attempts to pair him with other girls. In fact he was rather bold about it - something we don’t see often from historical heroes.
I would have liked to see a little more growth and connection to the characters - but this is just me personally. Overall I think historical fiction fans that want a strong faith themes will enjoy the story.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
May 2, 2025
Set in the 1800s, this book tells the love story of Ida and Blaine as they navigate through society's expectations and dislike from Blaine's parents who dissapprove of his choice of Ida as his bride.
In the midst of their love journey, Ida is shown as a strong courageous woman although sometimes impulsive but determined to serve God and to bring God's love to others especially the less fortunate women who had to do less than honorable job to survive. The way Blaine supported her is admirable even though he had misgivings at times of some certain steps she took. Standing up to his parents and making the choice of Ida reveals a man of character which grew as their love grew.
Angel of second street is a tale of love, perseverance, hope even in the midst of hardship and society's expectations. The effect of prejudice and how it influences decisions with lasting consequences can be seen even as the Chinese are forced to immigrate from Eureka, a town in California. Filled with different characters who make their choices, Angel of Second Street is fiction woven around history; the pain and struggles as well as the desire to spread the gospel to all.
At some point, I felt the story rushed along some parts but overall it was a good read, one that shows faith, love, hope and growth.
I received an advanced copy from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
In the midst of their love journey, Ida is shown as a strong courageous woman although sometimes impulsive but determined to serve God and to bring God's love to others especially the less fortunate women who had to do less than honorable job to survive. The way Blaine supported her is admirable even though he had misgivings at times of some certain steps she took. Standing up to his parents and making the choice of Ida reveals a man of character which grew as their love grew.
Angel of second street is a tale of love, perseverance, hope even in the midst of hardship and society's expectations. The effect of prejudice and how it influences decisions with lasting consequences can be seen even as the Chinese are forced to immigrate from Eureka, a town in California. Filled with different characters who make their choices, Angel of Second Street is fiction woven around history; the pain and struggles as well as the desire to spread the gospel to all.
At some point, I felt the story rushed along some parts but overall it was a good read, one that shows faith, love, hope and growth.
I received an advanced copy from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
May 5, 2025
This was my 1st book by Barbara Blakey and I found the Christian fiction and interesting on.
It is set in 1884 with the main characters of 17 year old Ida, her family and friend and Blaine, her romantic interest.
What was done well was the way their faith was written, with prayer, scripture and wanting to truly follow a Christian walk, not just religious attendance.. It was also very interesting to read about the discrimination against the Chinese, not just in business and work, but even in the church. The prostitution was written a bit differently with empathy from Ida and even their medical care was realistically described.. The challenges to their relationship by Blaine's parents gave the book was an engaging subplot.
Areas of opportunity are with Ida's character,, who while just 17, her immaturity with the various situations became a bit exasperating and difficult to understand. The end was also somewhat abrupt, with so much that still needed to be explained a too neatly resolved for such a big secret revealed.
If you enjoy a sweet, clean Christian romance read that has some interesting historical facts about the time and culture of 1884, with more of a younger reader feel, this would be for you.
A big thank you to Barbour Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC, I' m always grateful for the opportunity. All opinions expressed are my own.
It is set in 1884 with the main characters of 17 year old Ida, her family and friend and Blaine, her romantic interest.
What was done well was the way their faith was written, with prayer, scripture and wanting to truly follow a Christian walk, not just religious attendance.. It was also very interesting to read about the discrimination against the Chinese, not just in business and work, but even in the church. The prostitution was written a bit differently with empathy from Ida and even their medical care was realistically described.. The challenges to their relationship by Blaine's parents gave the book was an engaging subplot.
Areas of opportunity are with Ida's character,, who while just 17, her immaturity with the various situations became a bit exasperating and difficult to understand. The end was also somewhat abrupt, with so much that still needed to be explained a too neatly resolved for such a big secret revealed.
If you enjoy a sweet, clean Christian romance read that has some interesting historical facts about the time and culture of 1884, with more of a younger reader feel, this would be for you.
A big thank you to Barbour Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC, I' m always grateful for the opportunity. All opinions expressed are my own.
May 6, 2025
PLEASE READ THIS REVIEW ON MY BLOG: https://bookreadingtic.com/2025/05/05... AND PLEASE FOLLOW ME, THANK YOU!
Poking the Bear!
Ida is a naive young woman who loves Jesus, and wants to tell the world about Him. She wants to convert the women of the red-light district, along with the members of Chinatown. But the way she goes about it, opens a hornet's nest.
The time is 1884 California, and she has grown up knowing there are certain ways to stay in good standing in society. Despite that, she innocently does things that could ruin her position.
Blaine is home from college, and ready to take his place in his father's business. His parents push him to find a girl, and get married. When he picks Ida, his family does everything possible to break them up.
When they follow their hearts, both Ida and Blaine face criticism from those they love.
This is a great story that will clue you in on what life was like at that time. Both Ida and Blaine have a strong faith, and that directs their decisions.
This is a five-star book, but it ended suddenly with a cliff hanger, leaving unanswered questions. Since this is a new series, answers should be found in upcoming installments.
Thank you, Barbour Books, for providing Tickmenot with a book to review. Opinions are my own.
Poking the Bear!
Ida is a naive young woman who loves Jesus, and wants to tell the world about Him. She wants to convert the women of the red-light district, along with the members of Chinatown. But the way she goes about it, opens a hornet's nest.
The time is 1884 California, and she has grown up knowing there are certain ways to stay in good standing in society. Despite that, she innocently does things that could ruin her position.
Blaine is home from college, and ready to take his place in his father's business. His parents push him to find a girl, and get married. When he picks Ida, his family does everything possible to break them up.
When they follow their hearts, both Ida and Blaine face criticism from those they love.
This is a great story that will clue you in on what life was like at that time. Both Ida and Blaine have a strong faith, and that directs their decisions.
This is a five-star book, but it ended suddenly with a cliff hanger, leaving unanswered questions. Since this is a new series, answers should be found in upcoming installments.
Thank you, Barbour Books, for providing Tickmenot with a book to review. Opinions are my own.
May 11, 2025
I enjoyed this christian historical novel, partially based on true events in California. Ida is always looking to help others, so when she sees a woman who is in need she is determined to find her out and help her. Although Ida is a little naive in understanding that those women who do need help, also live dangerous lives and in a dangerous area. She decides to enlist the help of her friend and the two end up in some trouble. She reaches out to her pastor who offers to help where he can but also warns her of the dangers Chinatown. Meanwhile her romance with Blaine is budding, but her good works is calling her reputation into question. Also wanting to better understand the Chinese she tries to engage with their cook, Qui but her mother has made it clear she should not infer their religion and beliefs onto them, however Qui is eager to learn but knows the danger of this. As Ida continues to try to help, she only seems to be met with failure after failure until Blaine helps her come up with a plan. Will this one finally work or will she again feel she is not able to succeed in doing the Lord's work? I enjoyed this storyline and the history that was woven throughout. Thank you to the author and Barbour Publishing for the complementary novel. This review is of my own opinion and accord.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 88 reviews