Alice Arden, idealistic and wealthy beauty, burnt at the stake for killing her husband, the former mayor of Faversham in Kent. But was she really the one responsible for the most scandalous murder of the sixteenth century?
William Shakespeare, England’s greatest playwright, born thirteen years after Alice’s execution. Why does his first-ever play, written about this murder, not bear his name?
This is a story of two people – one reviled, one revered – whose fates become linked in a tale of corruption, collusion and conspiracy. Based on historical documents and recently published academic research, Arden unveils shocking new evidence about the murder of Thomas Arden and reveals, for the first time, a remarkable new theory about Shakespeare’s early years.
I normally avoid Shakespearean fiction, more so when it purports to tell "the history behind . . ." or "the true story of . . ." after bad runs with a few (I especially detest the Romeo & Juliet and Macbeth retellings). But I've made an exception for this one because: a) 'Tis not a retelling but a true and documented story being novelised, b) I like this author.
In normal circumstances, I take subheaders and blurb claims that scream "astonishing!" at you as mere hyperbole, a publicity trick by the publishing world, but in this case, it is true. The story of Alice Arden is so astonishing and incredible that there were scenes I truly doubted were real and had to have the author explain to me that, yes, this and that had really happened and was well documented. Not that I suspected Harper of making stuff up, I had fallen victim to the Life Surpasses Fiction Syndrome and figured it had to be made up.
The story of beautiful and idealistic Alice Arden, married off to a grasping social climber of a husband who neglects her for reasons, and who is so hungry for love and intimacy she takes up a lover wouldn't be anything out of the ordinary if you look only at the first half of the apple, how many women in this situation have opted for infidelity in this situation? Probably millions throughout history. But it takes a surprisingly unusual and dark turn when you take in the second half. Yeah, plotting with the lover to kill the pesky husband isn't something uncommon either; legions of wives must've got rid of their spouses discreetly or indiscreetly throughout history too, and either got away with it or got caught.
So what makes Alice's story stand out is the cruel way she was punished for her crime. By the laws of that time, she deserved execution, indeed, and by the laws of this time, she would've got at a minimum life imprisonment. But she got more, way more than she deserved, a savagery that shocked me and I had to ask the author whether it was true or creative licence. I won't spoil what is done to Alice here, the blurb is spoilery enough but there's more to it than is said.
Originally, on my first read of an earlier draft of this novel, I said that I had enjoyed Will Shakespeare's story more than Alice's. Now that I have a finished and published copy, I can say the turns have tabled. I like the murderess more than the playwright. How did that happen? Magic, thinking on it all some more, and a half pint of ale.
Yes, seriously, I do like Alice Arden's storyline way more than William Shakespeare's often bumbling nerdy self. Oh, it isn't because Alice is a sympathetic character, no. In fact, she is hard to like, almost impossible to empathise with, a tad too much of a whiner for my tastes, and sometimes behaves like a lovesick bimbo, if bimbos can be redheaded. Why, then? Because of the tragedy of her life. Tragedy in the Greek sense of the word, when you bring down your own doom on yourself but the gods see fit to heap an extra helping of pfft you on top just for the hoots and giggles.
She didn't deserve that extra. Nobody does. And that is what puts things in perspective. As a woman, you finally empathise, you finally understand. The final piece falls in place, you get the whole picture, see the horror in its unsparing completeness, and you can't help but feel for Alice.
That's what a great writer does: gets you to sympathise with those you wouldn't otherwise.
G. D. Harper has done extensive research about both Shakespeare and Alice Arden, I think she even got Tudor history experts of the kind that would know you've described the wrong colour of bricks for the period, which was amusing as well as educative to hear about. You can be sure what she depicts here is historically accurate, I certainly do because in my experience not every writer of historical fiction is this thorough or involves experts and historical societies/reenactment societies in their work. Her plot premise, that Shakespeare based his first (and never self-credited or self-acknowledged) play, "Arden of Faversham," on the case of Alice Arden isn't a theory every Shakespearean expert out there will enthusiastically support (they all have their own theories about old Will), but it's definitely convincingly argued, even the blood ties between the Shakespeares and Ardens is convincingly argued. So well argued that it's difficult to remember it's Harper's theory and not the recorded and accepted fact set in stone.
I like that, I like it when a fictionalisation is so realistic you can easily mistake it for the actual documented recordings. That's the hallmark of quality historical fiction, to me.
I received a complimentary copy from the author with no obligation to rate or review it. I do so of my own will. Thank you!
The story here should be fascinating, and the author does a laudable job of trying to be honest to history, as much as it can be known. However, I think I'd rather read a scholarly article on this topic than a book-length work of fiction.
The novel has two narrators—Will Shakespere [as the author notes this is how the Bard most often spelled his own name] and a female forbear— neither of which ever became well-rounded and specific in the way I'd hoped they would.
I received a free electronic review copy of this title from the publisher via NetGalley; the opinions are my own.
Following dual timelines this explores a young Shakespeare on the run, learning new skills with a travelling acting troupe, and trying to pursue his aspirations to become an actor and writer, and Alice Arden a young woman who dreams of love but finds herself trapped in a disappointing marriage, and longing after her first love. When Will needs inspiration to help launch his writing career he uses the local infamous murder of Thomas Arden, and begins a dive into history and rumour to uncover the truth of the crime. It explores his early life in supporting his family, growing into his abilities, his failures and fears, and making contacts that could see his rise to success. Meanwhile Alice is conflicted with her duties and role in society, and her need to be seen and loved. She embarks on a salacious bargain that ultimately leads to devastating tragedy. With two tales spanning 30 years apart, it's a gripping dive into compelling journeys of naivety, determination and dreams of a better life. It navigates between the two timelines to show the scandalous events of a murder most foul unfolding, and Shakespeare investigation some 30 years later. This is a fascinating interpretation of history and provides a compelling tale of forbidden love, conspiracy, infidelity, tragedy and scandal. This brings to life the tone, events and imagery of the 16th century it explores, and beautifully crafts a story of passion with plenty of twists.
This was a fine piece of fiction based on real historical events. But what really put this over the top was all the historical documents that went into the making of this tale. There were photos of the actual books (hundreds of years old) and the explanations of how things tied together. Read this for a book club. There were plenty of topics for conversations. Folks that no past Shakespeare familiarity as well others with much more background throughly enjoyed. Highly recommend.
I really enjoyed this book, even though it was quite different from what I expected it to be. The story captivated me as it has everything I love in a good book; beautiful story telling, well developed characters, shocking twists, romance, betrayal and much more. It was a fascinating and lovely read. And I recommend lovers of historical fiction. Well to be honest I recommend to all lovers of a good book.
I was beyond excited to get my hands on an advanced reader’s copy of GD Harper’s, “Arden: The Astonishing Untold Story of Shakespeare’s First Play”, and it did not disappoint. This captivating historical fiction mystery follows two storylines decades apart.
One is of Alice Arden, a beautiful, love-struck girl manipulated by powerful men unbeknownst to her. We are deeply involved in their day-to-day life as Alice and her husband’s world and social status begin to crumble. Her husband is murdered, and Alice is ultimately burned at the stake before a raging and joyous crowd in Faversham.
The other storyline is about Will Shakespeare. It was fascinating to be a part of his humble beginnings, his inner world with his wife and children, his dread of working as a glover for his father, and his desire for more. Attracted to Alice's story due to Arden being the family name of his mother (Mary Arden), he researched firsthand accounts of Alice’s story and wrote his first play, Arden of Faversham. There is debate whether this was, in fact, Shakespeare’s first play, as he does not give himself credit for it. Harper’s storyline and reasoning to help debate this are brilliantly based on historical evidence and are very thought-provoking.
Harper’s skillful weaving of the two storylines, the intricate plotting, and the introduction of devastating new evidence about Alice and the murder of Thomas Arden make this book a must-read for fans of the genre and Shakespeare alike.
Thank you, #NetGalley, #GDHarper, #BooksGoSocial, and #GingerCat, for the ARC in exchange for my honest review of #Arden.
I knew I would most likely enjoy Arden because I had previously read and reviewed another of GD Harper's books, The Maids of Biddenden, and thoroughly enjoyed it. I read the whole of Arden within a few days, and was hooked from the first page. Harper brings to life the time period he is writing about.
Told by both Alice and Shakespeare in dual timelines, Harper weaves historical fact and fiction beautifully. We first meet Alice Arden at the beginning of the story, as she is brutally burned at the stake; we then follow the story of how she got there, with Harper using new evidence about Alice and the murder of her husband, Thomas Arden, to add twists and turns to the story.
Shakespeare was born thirteen years after Alice’s death, and we first encounter him as a young, poverty-stricken glover; with a wife and children. After getting into trouble, and needing to leave home for a while, he tours with an acting troupe and discovers his talent and passion for acting and writing plays. We learn of his connection to Alice Arden, and the reason why he had to remain anonymous for his first-ever play, written about the murder of Alice's husband.
Arden is a fascinating story dripping with scandal, corruption, and conspiracy. The conclusion of Alice’s story is utterly tragic. Harper uses historical documents and recently published academic research, which reveals shocking new evidence about the murder of Thomas Arden and a remarkable new theory about Shakespeare’s early years. The book also includes image plates, which make a brilliant addition to the book!
* I received this book in exchange for an honest review.
The writing was engaging and I looked forward to picking it back up at each reading session. I enjoyed the dual timeline and found it interesting as to how the timelines neatly ran alongside one another. They didn't ever overlap with one another, but the parallel technique worked well and added texture and a well rounded feel to the overall story.
The chapters weren't overly long, but some of them were split. Each chapter was clearly headed with the name of the person that you were reading about and the time period that they were in. There was enough information given in each chapter to give you a feel for that time period, and at the same time, keeping it to a good length to keep you moving through the story. There was a good pace to the book and I found it easy to sit and read large chunks of it at a time. I found both timelines strong and intriguing so I wasn't too disheartened when I was taken from one to the other. There was a good flow between each chapter, despite jumping back and forth in time.
The characters were well written and it was actually the inclusion of Shakespeare that initially drew me towards the book. I love how the story was based on real people and events and that at the end there was a timeline of when everything really happened.
I really felt for a lot of the characters and was saddened at how it all ended. Even though I knew how it was going to end, I was still taken in and was interested to see how it got to that point. The pressures of society and how you had to be careful what you said and did was interesting to read about through the eyes of the characters.
Lastly the settings. I loved travelling to and from Stratford, Faversham and London in the 1500s. The places were only lightly described as it was a character focused story, but it gave the story a good grounding and you knew that you weren't in modern times anymore.
Was Alice Arden really the one responsible for the most scandalous murder of the sixteenth century? Why does William Shakespeare’s first-ever play, written about this murder, not bear his name?
Buckle Up! This is the Astonishing Untold Story of Shakespeare’s First Play….
I thought this book was so well written and researched. You will feel like you are in the 16th century England with these characters. While on the surface this appears to be more about Shakespeare, Alice was the one I couldn’t stop thinking about. No spoilers here…but did she really get the punishment she deserved?
I really liked the use of dual timelines and dual POVs to tell this story. It opens with Alice being executed and burnt at the stake. The story goes back and forth in time as we find out what happened and why Alice was executed that day.
The author does a great job weaving a tale of corruption and scandals and conspiracies. If you enjoy historical fiction and mysteries, I would highly recommend this book!
✨What To Expect: 🏰Historical Fiction 📜16th Century Setting 🎭William Shakespeare ✌️Dual Timelines 🔪True Crime Vibes 🔍Murder Mystery 😵Scandals and Corruption 🔥Based On A True Story
I'm not one for Shakespeare, but I do like reading G.D. Harper's books, so thought we not give it a go and I'm glad I did. I love how the story is told in two timeline. We begins with Alice Arden being burnt at the stake, then we start to learn more about Alice and how she ended up being burnt. Next we read about Shakespeare's story, 13 years after Alice's death. This is a story that is filled with scandal, conspiracy, corruption, told by an great author G.D. Harper. Harper has brought historical documents and recently published academic research together and gave us the information that tells a different story of 'Arden.' This is a book that you need to read yourself to understand just how two people born so far apart, yet come together in one book
This is a very well researched and thorough historical novel told through the characters of Alice Arden and William Shakespeare in their respective timelines. It was an absorbing read even if you aren’t a Shakespeare fan. The author gave a vivid view into life during the Tudor era. The book opens with Alice’s demise but seeing how she got to that point and if she was responsible for it kept my attention throughout. Watching Shakespeare struggle with his decisions on how to write what may have been his first play and the effects it would have short & long term was interesting. The true historical notes at the end of the book supporting the novel were fascinating. Seeing that some of the events in the novel were backed by facts was disturbing on some level. You almost wished they were made up.
I received a complimentary copy of the book from the author via Voracious Readers Only
Arden appears to be a fascinating historical investigation that intertwines true crime with literary mystery. The book’s premise—re-examining the infamous 16th-century murder of Thomas Arden and its potential connection to Shakespeare’s first play—feels like a blend of Hamlet-esque intrigue and Macbeth-like ambition.
Alice Arden’s execution for her husband’s murder has long been accepted as historical fact, but Arden challenges this narrative, raising questions about justice, power, and gender. Was Alice truly guilty, or was she a scapegoat in a larger web of corruption and conspiracy? The book suggests that her story, much like the tragedies Shakespeare would later write, was shaped by forces beyond her control. As the Prince of Denmark himself says, “Foul deeds will rise, though all the earth o’erwhelm them, to men’s eyes.” If new evidence indeed comes to light, it may force us to reconsider the truth behind one of England’s earliest infamous crimes.
The link between Alice’s story and Arden of Faversham is perhaps the most tantalizing aspect of the book. If Shakespeare had a hand in writing this play, why did he not claim it? The possibility that his earliest known work is tied to an actual murder case adds an eerie, almost prophetic quality to his later masterpieces. “Though this be madness, yet there is method in’t,” one might say of the historical and literary threads Arden seeks to weave together.
If the book delivers on its promise of uncovering hidden truths, it could reshape both literary and historical scholarship. For those who love historical true crime, Shakespearean intrigue, and revisionist history, Arden might prove to be an enthralling and thought-provoking read.
I absolutely loved reading this one! The author has done such a lot of research into the life of Shakespeare and Alice Arden, and I thoroughly enjoyed his interpretation of Shakespeare’s involvement in the play Arden of Faversham which is believed by some to be his first.
It tells the story of Alice Arden (1519-1551) alongside that of Shakespeare’s from 1586 to 1605. It’s written as a dual POV with chapters alternating between the two. It’s a story of love, indifference, betrayal, greed and also the cost of chasing one’s dream.
I found it so interesting to read about Shakespeare’s slow rise to fame, and the men who helped him along the way, alongside that of Alice Arden who was involved in the murder of her husband. It’s all based on written sources from that time: eye-witness accounts and parish records. The author has done a brilliant job with this book, making it a credible and authentic read!
This book was gifted to me by the author in exchange for my honest review of it.
To be honest, I was more fascinated by the historical murder behind the alleged first play from the Bard than the story of how the Bard came to write it. Anyway, after plodding along and seemingly taking forever to get to the juicy bits AND nearly skipping through all the "Will" narrative, the book does finally pick up. Glad I persevered till the end, and really appreciated and enjoyed the author's notes at the end (also well worth the read).
There's a new scandal in town and it's dripping with intrigue, murder, and a touch of Bardic mystery.
Arden: The Astonishing Untold Story of Shakespeare's First Play by G.D. Harper is a tantalising blend of historical fiction and detective work, shining a spotlight on a forgotten murder and the murky beginnings of England's greatest playwright.
Alice Arden, a femme fatale for the ages. Accused of orchestrating the murder of her husband, Thomas Arden, the former mayor of Faversham, Alice’s story is one of love, betrayal, and a fiery end..literally.
Harper does a fabulous job of painting Alice not just as a villain but as a complex, possibly misunderstood woman navigating the treacherous waters of 16th-century societal norms. Was she truly the mastermind behind the crime, or a scapegoat in a larger conspiracy? Harper lets you decide, offering a fresh, nuanced take on this centuries-old mystery.
But wait, what does William Shakespeare have to do with this 16th-century scandal? More than you might think! Harper connects the dots between the infamous Arden murder and Shakespeare’s enigmatic early years, suggesting that the Bard’s very first play, Arden of Faversham, was inspired by this juicy real-life drama. Yet, curiously, this play was never officially credited to Shakespeare. Harper dives into this literary whodunit, teasing out a plausible and utterly fascinating theory that Shakespeare’s anonymity in this work was no accident.
Harper’s Arden reads like a historical thriller, but with the rich, atmospheric detail that history buffs crave. Every page feels like peeling back layers of Elizabethan England, from its shadowy backrooms of political intrigue to the bustling, muddy streets of Faversham. The meticulous research shines through, but Harper’s real skill is in making it all feel alive, like you’re eavesdropping on whispered secrets from the past.
This isn’t just a book about a murder or a mysterious playwright, it’s about the power of stories themselves. How legends are crafted, how reputations are made or marred, and how the truth can be obscured by those who write history. Harper deftly shows how Alice and Shakespeare, despite their vastly different fates, are both victims of the narratives imposed upon them.
Harper’s writing is sharp and witty, injecting a modern flair into the historical narrative that makes it both accessible and engaging. There’s a sly humour in the way he juxtaposes the seriousness of the crime with the theatricality of Elizabethan England. It’s as if Harper is winking at the reader, inviting us to enjoy the absurdity of it all while never losing sight of the gravitas of Alice’s plight and Shakespeare’s genius.
Arden is a must-read for history lovers, Shakespeare enthusiasts, and anyone who enjoys a good old-fashioned murder mystery. Harper’s ability to weave historical facts with speculative fiction results in a story that feels both educational and thrilling. You’ll walk away not only questioning what you thought you knew about Shakespeare’s origins but also reconsidering the fate of Alice Arden, the woman who might have been much more than the villain history painted her to be.
Grab your quill and parchment or, more realistically, your favourite reading nook and prepare to be astonished by this untold story of scandal, murder, and the making of a legend.
In Arden, by GD Harper, we follow Alice Arden, the frustrated young wife of avaricious Faversham bigwig Thomas Arden, from 1536 to 1551, when she’s burned at the stake for her part in her husband’s death.
Her narrative alternates with that of Will Shakspere – a young man working all hours at the theatres just outside London’s walls while trying to write his first play – starting in 1586. When he discovers information that casts Alice’s actions in a new light, Will knows he has his story.
However, before the authorities will allow the play to be staged (and therefore make Will money to support his young family back in Stratford-upon-Avon), he’s required to tone down his criticisms of certain prominent characters. Will the play still feel like “his” once he’s made the revisions? And how culpable was Alice for Thomas’ murder, really?
I very much enjoyed Arden. The dual timeline was an inspired choice on the author’s part which kept me highly engaged as I went through the two principal characters’ frequent – and very different – trials and tribulations alongside them.
As an upper-class woman in the early modern period, Alice lives in a gilded cage. She’s well aware Thomas married her primarily for the patronage of her influential stepfather, and he isn’t even interested in consummating their union. Her material and social fortunes are irrevocably tied to his, and while a passionate affair with tailor Tom Mosby (which her husband grudgingly tolerates) gives her the love she craves, it also increases her vulnerability to manipulation and ruin.
Will, meanwhile, struggles to muster enthusiasm for making gloves like his father, much preferring to entertain the alehouse with his clever political rhymes. When one gets him into hot water with a local landowner, he seizes the chance to act with a travelling troupe while waiting for things to blow over. This experience leads him to the realisation that he wants to be a playwright, and from there, a challenging, penny-pinching few years away from his family as he gets involved with the theatrical world in whatever way he can.
While both accounts are necessarily fictional – Alice’s own voice hasn’t survived, and little is known of Shakespeare’s early years – Harper’s extensive historical knowledge and research, and ability to put himself in the shoes of his characters, make them feel convincing and authentic.
It’s also very meta, sometimes, as we watch Will face the challenges of using limited surviving evidence to create a fully fleshed-out story about the murder of Thomas Arden. I did feel, though, that his last few chapters, which summarise his more well-known subsequent highs and lows, with an emphasis on Faversham and themes that recur in his later plays, felt a bit rushed and might have worked better as a historical note.
As with his previous book, The Maids of Biddenden, the author takes care to vividly convey the full sensory and social experience of England at the time the novel is set, as well as the far-reaching real-world impact of contemporary events such as the dissolution of the monasteries, and the plague. Ideas about gender and class intersect to make things especially difficult for Alice, much as they did for Biddenden’s conjoined twins, but with a far worse outcome.
Her accomplices include not only her lover, but also a freed man whom Thomas had cheated out of a piece of crucial farming land; an artist who supplements his income by selling poisonous substances; and a fearsome itinerant assassin-for-hire, yet it’s Alice who faces the most opprobrium and worst punishments.
This is because, at this time, a wife killing her husband was directly equated with killing the King or God. The notion of woman committing a murder was also shocking because it was so antithetical to her “natural” role of bringing and nurturing life (arguably, an idea that still has influence today!).
At the same time, any suggestion that a gentleman of similar social standing to Thomas might be involved is shut down as unthinkable and disrespectful, hence Alice took the fall for something that may have been part of a grander conspiracy, and Will didn’t get to write the play he wanted.
Arden is an inspired, convincing, and entertaining historical novel.
My personal rating: 4.5 Arden leads with strong premises about an infamous murder and Shakespeare's early career. Once it got to the murder, it captivated me.
Harper brings the time and the places to life in his detailed narrative. I found the characters and the strange relationships and rivalries fascinating. There are moments when honor, courage, and love shine through.
This is the most comprehensive account I've read of Shakespeare's life and his development as an actor and playwright. Harper brings a great deal of insight and skill to his portrayal of the tensions of the time.
The young playwright faces challenges of earning a living, caring for his family, dealing with censorship, plagues, and enemies.
In an earlier timeline, we follow Alice Arden and the events that led to her involvement in a notorious murder. This case exposes a great deal about the uses of power, the law, the extremes of punishment–and its uses in this place and time.
It's notable that Harper had access to discoveries from recent years and did a great deal of research with original source materials. Although Arden is fiction, he took great care with historical accuracy and included excellent notes. The photos and illustrations were an unexpected bonus.For me, the early chapters felt slow. Once the story gained momentum, I became enthralled. The many parts of the tale came together in a satisfying climax and conclusion. The core issues felt timeless. There's scandal, striving to please parents and people of influence, desire, resentment, compromises made for social standing, greed, arrogance, corruption, grudges, betrayal, and vindictiveness. Little has changed in hundreds of years.
****Possible mild spoilers****
A love triangle and a possible homosexual relationship play a part in the story, and a disturbing event during Alice's imprisonment is treated with sensitivity. The awareness of the social, legal, economic, and familial restrictions on women in this era make this a particularly valuable book. These factors intensify the novel's emotional impact as a long-hidden truth comes to light.
Bravo.
Highly recommended for readers of Historical Fiction, fans of Shakespeare, and patient aficionados of true-crime-based mysteries.
My thanks to Books Go Social and the author for the ebook review copy via NetGalley for consideration. These are my unbiased opinions.
This is a confusing book on several counts. It is essentially two separate stories rolled into one.and inextricably intertwined. Whether or not the author is successful depends on your point of view.
The first part is a fictionalized account of the early life of Willian Shakespeare in Stratford-upon-Avon, his marriage and his ability to upset powerful noblemen in his area. William flees to London to seek his fortune as a jobbing actor and eventually a playwright leaving his three children behind with their mother.
The second part concerns the life of Alice Arden, an unfortunate lady who got herself mixed up in a plot to kill her husband and was burned at the stake for her pains. Regrettably, the author decides to tell the reader that Alice is executed halfway through her story thereby rendering the rest of her narrative irrelevant. In addition, the opening chapter of the book, the prologue, contains an account of her death, but the reader does not know this until the end of the story!!!
The two stories are written consecutively. I found the story of Alice Arden not as interesting as that of William Shakespeare. In fact, I was somewhat irritated by this device the end.
The book is about how Shakespeare wrote his first play, which in this fictionalized account of what is now known as Alice of Arden. There is no evidence that this is the case. The play does exist and it is possible the Shakespeare had a hand in writing part of it.
The author spends so much time on the account of how this play was written that the great works like Romeo and Juliet, King Lear and Hamlet are glossed over with barely a mention.
However, the book overall is interesting. It kept me looking forward to reading the next chapter. The author has clearly spent a huge amount of time researching the material for this book. As a writer of historical fiction myself, I greatly appreciated this. Well done!
A brief account of the unfortunate Alice Arden would have been sufficient in that it was the source of inspiration for the play. Developing this theme and writing a story developing Shakespeare's character, his adventures in plague ridden London might have been better.
A fascinating, meticulously-researched story starring both William Shakespeare, and a real-life sixteenth-century convicted murderess, Alice Arden.
Told in alternating first-person voices of each of the main protagonists, the story oscillates between the timeline leading up to Alice’s involvement in the historical murder, which took place in 1551, and Shakespeare’s ascent into play-writing, forty years later, with the publication of an unacknowledged work concerning these same events.
Self-proclaimed as both a historical work, and one with which some fictional license has been taken, the author does a terrific job of linking the two, taking the reader on a mesmerizing journey surrounding young poverty-stricken Will, his hopes and dreams, and his somewhat tentative foray into the work that will eventually make him famous.
At the same time, Alice makes for an excellent and intriguing foil; a red-headed beauty who is trapped by the expectations of her times, and her gender, into a loveless sham of a marriage. Exactly how Alice’s life plays out between these pages is a journey that, for this reader, invoked both compassion and horror, as the Middle Ages are screechingly brought to life, with all their associated political, religious, and social upheavals, underlaid by an incredible mysogyny, several episodes of horrific bubonic plague, poverty, and a series of oppressive ruling classes, each of which are redolent with corruption.
A book that is hard to put down, this is a story that will keep you reading, as much for the plot revelations surrounding both protagonists, as for the hold achieved by the incredibly immersive setting.
Highly recommended for lovers of historical fiction; anyone interested in young Will and his struggles (both real and imagined), and a first-rate, heart-wrenching murder mystery — all packaged in one abundantly readable volume.
A great big thank you to the author for an ARC of this book. All thoughts presented are my own.
Arden The Astonishing Untold Story of Shakespeare’s First Play GD Harper 10/03/2024 (This is available on KU now.)
Harper's masterful interweaving of dual storylines, the meticulous plotting, and the shocking revelation of new evidence surrounding Alice and the murder of Thomas Arden make this book a must-read for both fans of the genre and Shakespeare enthusiasts. This book is an essential read for both history enthusiasts and lovers of historical fiction, offering a captivating journey into the secrets of scandal and the enduring impact of legacy. It is also the kind of read that you want to take your time with, go down rabbit holes, ponder and then read some more!
I will admit, until I was grown as far as I knew Shakespeare was something you had to read in school and Romeo and Juliet were dead. Period. That was it. I mean I could probably throw out one or two lines from other plays, but they had no depth or meaning to me. Now it is really a huge part of history and something that should be learned and loved.
This book has opened another piece of the history puzzle for me and has made me want to take a more in depth look into Shakespeare and so many other things. Also, even though I read it digitally, I had to order a keep on my shelves copy too!
BLURB
Alice Arden, idealistic and wealthy beauty, burnt at the stake for killing her husband, the former mayor of Faversham in Kent. But was she really the one responsible for the most scandalous murder of the sixteenth century?
William Shakespeare, England’s greatest playwright, born thirteen years after Alice’s execution. Why does his first-ever play, written about this murder, not bear his name?
This is a story of two people – one reviled, one revered – whose fates become linked in a tale of corruption, collusion and conspiracy. Based on historical documents and recently published academic research, Arden unveils shocking new evidence about the murder of Thomas Arden and reveals, for the first time, a remarkable new theory about Shakespeare’s early years.
This novel re-examines the infamous 16th-century murder of Thomas Arden and the execution of his wife, Alice. Weaving together historical documents and new research, the book explores a compelling theory linking the crime to Shakespeare’s early life and the mystery surrounding his first play.
This book is an interesting and entertaining historical mystery with a strong plot. The characters are a bit underdeveloped. Alice’s evolution from a naive young woman to an adulterer and murderer doesn’t show any real character transformation. Rather than being a person with agency, she’s portrayed as a victim and pawn of the men around her. I can believe that she was manipulated, but she certainly wasn’t innocent.
The portrayal of Shakespeare as a young man was interesting and plausible, though not at all the way I would have imagined him. Shakespeare’s grammar school education would have included the classics, such as Ovid’s Metamorphosis. The idea that Shakespeare didn’t have the creativity to devise his own stories doesn’t quite ring true to me. As the book itself points out, plays were subject to censorship, so sticking to new treatments of familiar subjects was the safe route. The Shakespeare of this book lacks the genius I would expect. Still, it’s impossible to write a portrayal of Shakespeare that resonates with all readers, or even most of them. We all have an idea in our heads of what Shakespeare was like, with very few facts to support that impression.
The book does a good job of explaining why, if ARDEN OF FAVERSHAM was Shakespeare’s first play, he wouldn’t have wanted his name associated with it. This is where the book shines. It’s pretty convincing in this area, especially when combined with current scholarship. Fans of Shakespeare and Tudor history will find much to enjoy in this novel.
Thanks, NetGalley, for the ARC I received. This is my honest and voluntary review.
Having read and really enjoyed the author's previous book, The Maids of Biddenden, I cannot express how excited I was to learn of this novel.
The sights, the sounds, the smells, what people were wearing, the foods they ate, the culture, politics and social norms of the time. I can only begin to imagine the amount of time and research that must go into any work of historical fiction. That this book is based on actual historical documents and academic research, all kudos to the author who does it soooo incredibly well.
Following a duel timeline, that of Alice Arden and Shakespeare. Again, not something every author can pull off but GD Harper does with a wonderful self-confidence, his seemingly effortless ability to put himself into not only his characters' shoes but also the times they lived in making for an authentic read despite the fact that Arden's voice has not survived the annuls of time and so little is actually known of Shakespeare's early years.
The tale of a love-struck young woman, manipulated by powerful men, who goes on to pay the ultimate price ... and then some, such is the savagery of her punishment. As much as I enjoyed the part Shakespeare was to play in the book, it was Alice's story that, saddening me as deeply as it did, grasped me from beginning to end.
Enlightening, entertaining, intricate plotting, chock-a-block full of wonderfully rich, historical detail and an engaging narrative, Arden has it all when it comes to quality historical fiction and has left me super excited to see what the author comes up with next.
Copyright ... Felicity Grace Terry @ Pen and Paper Disclaimer ... One of several bloggers participating in the Publication Day Push of this book, agree or disagree with me, all opinions are my own; no financial compensation was asked for nor given; threats of violence towards my favourite teddy bear went unheeded as did promises of chocolate.
I originally was lucky enough to read The Maids of Biddenden as part of a book tour. I will admit going into that book I knew very little about the historical figures that inspired the story but my interest was piqued and I was literally blown away by how Harper manages to present historical facts and fill in gaps as it were with such a beautiful narrative. Needless to say he quickly became a favourite historical author. Now when I was contacted with a chance to review his newest novel I was ready to say yes but when I saw the blurb I jumped at the chance. I am a Shakespeare geek and studied renaissance studies focusing on him and his contemporaries as well for my MA. This paired with what I already knew of Harper’s research and writing I was overjoyed. I can honestly say I was not disappointed in the slightest.
Arden explores the lives of two people, Alice Arden and William Shakespeare and how their lives get intertwined together despite never meeting in person. Now obviously I loved the story but the thing that really made me geek out was the historical accuracy. From the use of language to daily life I got exactly what I expected too from this novel. In a short attention to detail. Of course this is a novel, it’s fiction at it's core, but a lot of the events and happenings are based on historical facts. I adored seeing a younger Shakespeare and his life. I adored learning more about the Arden’s, particularly Alice and generally loved the whole thing.
By following a new theory about Shakespeare and indeed Arden we are gifted something brilliant. A bridge between fiction and fact. While as I said I’m a bit of a Shakespeare geek this still had the same captivating effect of The Maids of Biddenden that after reading I wanted to know even more. A perfect novel for historical fiction fans.
As always thank you to the GD Harper for the advanced copy to review, my reviews are always honest and freely given.
Fascinating book about Alice Arden and the murder of her husband and how this tale inspires William Shakespeare to write his first play. It is told in parallel timelines of both Alice and Shakespeare. Poor Alice is living in a time in England where women had zero rights. A time when her beautiful red hair was seen as a curse. She was expected to marry well and that was that. She made the mistake of falling for a traveling tailor and naive enough to believe he loved her. She than had the misfortune to be married to a cold man obsessed with money (who I think was gay since he never slept with her and spurned her advances). The way her life is described after marriage, it is so depressing. I can't believe she had any urge to live. Her sadness continues when the cad tailor reappears in her life. Alas, Alice is not street smart enough to realize this man is using her and it leads to her downfall. We also follow Shakespeare, as the author supposes what happened to him during those lost years. He became part of a traveling acting troupe, get some lucky breaks, worked a ton to make ends meet and finally became the super famous playwright we know today. The book starts out really interesting and I would have given more stars but because we already know exactly what happens to Alice and the murder (it is told right at the start of the book) the middle of the book drags a bit, till it ramps up again to the end, trial and what happens to Alice (tragic). It was a good read to distract me from all the sad news in the world and also for someone who likes all things British, fascinating. It is not the time period that I usually read about but still interesting. The dialogue could have been better, seemed like the author cribbed from Shakespeare himself. Yet, not a bad book all in all. I'd recommend for someone looking for historical fiction that isn't set in the usual troupes (WWII, Europe between the wars, post civil war America).
Having read the authors previous book, again based on fact, I was very keen to read this. It is the fictionalised story of Alice Arden and how she was the catalyst for William ‘Will’ Shakespeare first play. The prologue takes place on 14th March 1551 in Faversham where a crowd has gathered for a public execution. We then move to 1586 where Will is working in his father’s business making leather gloves and worrying about the future for his family. Told in duel timelines and from the POV’s of Alice and Will this is a fascinating story and clearly the author has done an incredible job of research.
Briefly, Will becomes interested in the story of Alice Arden and her husband Thomas as Arden was his mother’s maiden name and he was looking for a family connection. Alice didn’t have a good life. She was a beautiful woman but her husband wasn’t that interested in her so she took a lover, and decided her only way to future happiness was for her husband to die! Will uses Alice’s story in his first play, Arden of Faversham, although for reasons noted in this book he never put his name to the play.
Don’t let the Shakespeare theme put you off this, I’m not a fan of Shakespeare but I found this book riveting and a compelling read. Alongside the fictional story the author has included a lot of interesting information, maps and photographs which backed up some of the research. Alice wasn’t a terribly likeable woman but Will’s research (and that of the author) tells a tale of scandal, infidelity and corruption and a woman manipulated by the men in her life. Will’s life was interesting and his reasons for not owning the play made a lot of sense. An interesting and entertaining read.
As a lover of Shakespeare and a historical fiction fan I was delighted to be offered a spot on this book tour for Arden.
This fabulous tale is told using a dual timeline. The story of Alice Arden begins in 1536 and follows her story as she leaves her parent’s home to embark on married life and the subsequent events which eventually lead to the murder of her husband. The tale of William Shakespeare’s ambition to become a playwright begins in 1586 and his pursuit of that dream leads him to explore the story of the Arden murder some years before. The two timelines are interesting and weave together seamlessly with the writing style being perfectly suited to the time period and subject matter.
I felt the author described life in 16th century England factually and I could imagine the constraints of living in that period. I really felt for poor Alice. She was involved in a terrible wrong but her life was quite sad and I didn’t feel she deserved her horrendous fate.
I had some prior knowledge of Shakespeare’s rise to success as a playwright but I was unfamiliar with the theories about his involvement in writing the Arden of Faversham play. It was intriguing to read about the beginnings of his career in greater depth.
The author presents a fascinating storyline with theories based on well researched historical evidence. There are extensive historical notes at the end of the book which are well worth reading.
I very much enjoyed this book and I would recommend it to anyone but especially fans of historical fiction. I look forward to reading more from GD Harper in future.
Thank you to @lovebookstours, Ginger Cat Publishing and @gdharperauthor for sending me a personally signed copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
William Shakespeare is trying to establish himself in the theatrical world and stumbles across an astonishing story. 40 years earlier a woman was burned to death following a trial for the murder of her husband. It sparks his creative energy and he sets to work on his first ever play... Arden is an historical depiction of a new theory about a Tudor play and the legal case that inspired it. Will is in trouble in his local area and feels unfulfilled helping in the family glove-making business. He joins a band of actors and finds a talent for amending plays, inspiring him to write his own. The story of Alice Arden captivates his interest. She shares the same surname as his mother and he is fascinated to unpick the truth behind the crime. The book is written in two timelines to show Will's experience in the 1580s and Alice's life in the 1540s as she faces life's struggles which unltimately lead to a murder and her own execution. Both characters are trying to negotiate their way through a dangerous world. Alice has the extra difficulty of being a woman, constrained by the gender conventions of the era. Politics and class affect both their lives too. I felt that both timelines were equally well developed and I was immersed in the Tudor world. It is wonderful to get an insight into the potential truth of the mystery years of Shakespeare before he became famous. The new research that the the author has undertaken was extensive in my opinion and I thought that the fictional write up was very effective. I enjoyed the exploration of the murder and motves with the personal dimension of Alice's story from the primary sources. Arden is an engaging and enjoyable historical novel.
Arden is a masterfully crafted historical narrative that immerses readers into the heart of one of the most sensational crimes of the sixteenth century. At its center is Alice Arden, a captivating and questionable figure: wealthy, idealistic, and executed at the stake for the murder of her husband, Thomas Arden, the former mayor of Faversham. But was she truly guilty? Or was she a pawn in a far more tangled web of duplicity and betrayal?
What makes this story even more intriguing is the unforeseen link to William Shakespeare, born thirteen years after Alice’s grim fate. Why does his earliest known play, centered around this notorious murder, remain anonymous? With meticulous research, the book intertwines two seemingly distant lives—Alice Arden, demonized in history, and Shakespeare, celebrated across centuries—revealing hidden connections and long-buried truths.
Drawing on newly uncovered historical documents and the latest academic research, Arden doesn’t just retell an old crime; it reshapes it, exposing corruption, conspiracy, and artistic intrigue. The result is a captivating blend of true crime and literary detective work, presenting an innovative theory about Shakespeare’s enigmatic early career.
Beautifully written and impeccably researched, Arden offers readers a riveting and thought-provoking exploration of justice, power, and legacy. This is a must-read for lovers of historical fiction, Shakespeare enthusiasts, and anyone drawn to the magnetism of untold stories.
Thank you NetGalley and BooksGoSocial for this eCopy to review
"Arden" by GD Harper, is a fascinating journey into the life of William Shakespeare and the infamous murder of Thomas Arden by his wife, Alice Arden.
The book delves into the early years of Shakespeare, exploring how he transitioned from glovemaker, to a theatre worker, to an actor, to a playwright. The central plot revolves around the murder of Thomas Arden by his wife Alice and her lover, Tom Mosby. Harper weaves a compelling narrative that connects Shakespeare’s first play, "Arden of Faversham," to this real-life crime. The historical backdrop is richly detailed, making the story come alive.
Shakespeare is portrayed as a young, ambitious man, eager to make his mark in the world of theatre. Alice Arden is depicted as a complex character, driven by frustration and desperation. The supporting characters, including Thomas Arden and Tom Mosby, are well-drawn, adding depth to the narrative.
The novel explores themes of ambition, justice, and the power of storytelling. Harper’s exploration of these themes is thought-provoking, and the historical context adds a rich layer of authenticity to the story. The idea of Shakespeare drawing inspiration from real-life events is intriguing, and the tension between fact and fiction is well-handled.
"Arden" is a unique blend of historical fiction and literary intrigue, with a compelling premise and well-developed characters. It’s sure to appeal to fans of historical fiction and those interested in the early life of Shakespeare.
Straight off, one of my favourite books of 2024! The mix of historical facts with fiction worked so wonderfully, and has had me doing my own extra research since wanting to know even more of the times and goings on!
The story runs over 2 timelines - we're introduced to Alice Arden in the 16th century as she meets a very brutal end and we soon learn how her life, and the men in it, led to her demise. And then we also get to see the timeline of Will Shakespere, born 13 years after the death of Alice Arden and seeing how their lives play out - no pun intended!
The story of Alice was the main pull for me and watching her story unfold was fascinating. Seemingly having it all thanks to wealth and beauty, but mostly used by those men in her life and her quest to find real love leads her to her doom.
And the storyline of Will was equally fascinating, as we see his quieter start to life, not happy following in his fathers' footsteps in business but with a passion for acting and plays, which takes him away from his family for lengthy spells. And how his connection with the story of Alice came to be, and why his first play remained anonymous.
The historical detail was brilliantly crafted by the author and he effortlessly transports you back in time to the intrigue and conspiracies. Definitely one of those books that sticks with you thanks to the characters and storyline and one I can highly recommend!