What do you think?
Rate this book
The Marian Apparitions at Zeitoun: An Evidential Inquiry
Religious experiences are usually private though occasionally they are intersubjective, involving multiple individuals at the same time. These group experiences carry extra evidential weight. But what of mass religious experiences, in which hundreds or even thousands of people apparently experience the same supernatural occurrence at the same time? Such events are rare historically, but of great interest in evidential terms, since they are more difficult to explain scientifically. The largest mass religious experiences in recorded history (outside Scripture) occurred over the course of several years in Zeitoun, Egypt. Beginning in 1968, the Virgin Mary began to appear above a Coptic Orthodox Church. These apparitions soon attracted massive crowds and sparked official inquiries by both the Egyptian government and the Coptic hierarchy. This book explores the history of these fascinating events and critically examines every scientific explanation thus far put forward in an attempt to account for them in naturalistic terms. The author argues that, so far, these attempts have failed, and thus the Marian apparitions at Zeitoun constitute powerful evidence for the reality of the supernatural.
312 pages, Paperback
Published September 2, 2024
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews
Read
June 9, 2026The Marian Apparitions at Zeitoun: An Evidential Inquiry by Travis Dumsday
I find Marian apparitions to be absolutely fascinating. As someone raised firmly within the realm of Protestantism, the veneration of Mary as a whole feels a bit foreign to me, and the notion that she periodically shows up to chosen individuals for various reasons is intriguing to me, even as I find it far-fetched.
This particular apparition is particularly interesting to me. A Catholic church less than a mile away from me is named for Bernadette of Lourdes, famed for a 19th century apparition experience. Apparitions at Fatima and Guadalupe are widely known, and both names have experienced periods of popularity in some places due to the association with the apparition.
But Zeitoun? I had no knowledge of it until I went through a period of heavy reading on modern-day saints. Mary? Showing up before many thousands? On top of a church? Within my parents' living memory? The entire idea seemed fanciful. Naturally I wanted to learn more.
So, I'm thrilled this book exists.
I did find myself only interested to a point. The first few chapters give the basic groundwork for the apparition: the geopolitical context of Egypt in the 1960s and 1970s, the relationship between Coptic Orthodoxy and the Virgin Mary, some eyewitness testimony. The author is very forward about his own limitations, which I appreciate - he doesn't speak or read Arabic, and the majority of firsthand texts about the apparitions are untranslated from their Arabic originals. Ergo, he only provides some limited firsthand content.
What is present is definitely worth a read, but I did find myself wishing Dumsday had co-authored the book with an Arabic speaker who would've given some insight into those other testimonies.
The second half of the book gets more frustrating: Dumsday's goal moves from describing the event itself and into a critique of the published rebuttals to the idea. I have to be honest, as someone not particularly familiar with some of the psychology described, much of this went over my head. Moreover, even coming from someone deeply skeptical that the Virgin Mary actually chilled on top of a church in Cairo for a period of years fiftyish years ago, the naturalistic explanations feel nearly as farfetched, based on Dumsday's descriptions. For that reason, I find myself wondering if Dumsday is reliable as a conduit for these explanations. He's upfront about his biases, but as to whether those color his explanations meaningfully, I can't tell.
On the whole, this is a worthwhile book and I'm glad it was published, but it seems to me that this is perhaps a first attempt in English at describing these events.
I am also glad the audiobook exists, but I must admit that this was a case where I wish a different narrator had read the book. The audio quality strikes me as something recorded by the author on his own laptop - which is to say more "good enough" than "good" - and his vocal tone doesn't give the content the heft that a quality narrator can provide. (There's also some inconsistency with the footnotes: the published book is probably a quarter footnotes, which is great, except that they're sometimes included in the audio and sometimes not.)
It's hard to know where to draw lines with events like this, but there is part of me that wishes the scope had grown a bit. There were, after all, further apparitions, also on top of a church, in in Egypt in 2000 and 2001 - and there's video footage of those apparitions. It's hard not to see something like that as linked to these earlier events, but I'm hardly equipped to make such commentary
Reading history:
Normally I keep this in my private notes section, but I'm moving it. Yay!
Reading history was not added on Goodreads, but was instead kept on a small piece of paper with the book.
Started June 2nd, 2026.
Finished June 8th, 2026.
June 2nd, 2026: listened to intro + chapter 1 (pp. 1-85) via Audible with physical copy nearby.
June 3rd, 2026: listened to chapter 3 (pp. 86-145) via Audible with physical copy nearby.
June 6th, 2026: listened to chapter 4 (pp. 146-186) via Audible with physical copy nearby.
June 7th, 2026: listened to chapter 5-conclusion (pp. 187-280 via Audible with physical copy nearby.
June 8th, 2026: read through all footnotes in physical copy.
I find Marian apparitions to be absolutely fascinating. As someone raised firmly within the realm of Protestantism, the veneration of Mary as a whole feels a bit foreign to me, and the notion that she periodically shows up to chosen individuals for various reasons is intriguing to me, even as I find it far-fetched.
This particular apparition is particularly interesting to me. A Catholic church less than a mile away from me is named for Bernadette of Lourdes, famed for a 19th century apparition experience. Apparitions at Fatima and Guadalupe are widely known, and both names have experienced periods of popularity in some places due to the association with the apparition.
But Zeitoun? I had no knowledge of it until I went through a period of heavy reading on modern-day saints. Mary? Showing up before many thousands? On top of a church? Within my parents' living memory? The entire idea seemed fanciful. Naturally I wanted to learn more.
So, I'm thrilled this book exists.
I did find myself only interested to a point. The first few chapters give the basic groundwork for the apparition: the geopolitical context of Egypt in the 1960s and 1970s, the relationship between Coptic Orthodoxy and the Virgin Mary, some eyewitness testimony. The author is very forward about his own limitations, which I appreciate - he doesn't speak or read Arabic, and the majority of firsthand texts about the apparitions are untranslated from their Arabic originals. Ergo, he only provides some limited firsthand content.
What is present is definitely worth a read, but I did find myself wishing Dumsday had co-authored the book with an Arabic speaker who would've given some insight into those other testimonies.
The second half of the book gets more frustrating: Dumsday's goal moves from describing the event itself and into a critique of the published rebuttals to the idea. I have to be honest, as someone not particularly familiar with some of the psychology described, much of this went over my head. Moreover, even coming from someone deeply skeptical that the Virgin Mary actually chilled on top of a church in Cairo for a period of years fiftyish years ago, the naturalistic explanations feel nearly as farfetched, based on Dumsday's descriptions. For that reason, I find myself wondering if Dumsday is reliable as a conduit for these explanations. He's upfront about his biases, but as to whether those color his explanations meaningfully, I can't tell.
On the whole, this is a worthwhile book and I'm glad it was published, but it seems to me that this is perhaps a first attempt in English at describing these events.
I am also glad the audiobook exists, but I must admit that this was a case where I wish a different narrator had read the book. The audio quality strikes me as something recorded by the author on his own laptop - which is to say more "good enough" than "good" - and his vocal tone doesn't give the content the heft that a quality narrator can provide. (There's also some inconsistency with the footnotes: the published book is probably a quarter footnotes, which is great, except that they're sometimes included in the audio and sometimes not.)
It's hard to know where to draw lines with events like this, but there is part of me that wishes the scope had grown a bit. There were, after all, further apparitions, also on top of a church, in in Egypt in 2000 and 2001 - and there's video footage of those apparitions. It's hard not to see something like that as linked to these earlier events, but I'm hardly equipped to make such commentary
Reading history:
Normally I keep this in my private notes section, but I'm moving it. Yay!
Reading history was not added on Goodreads, but was instead kept on a small piece of paper with the book.
Started June 2nd, 2026.
Finished June 8th, 2026.
June 2nd, 2026: listened to intro + chapter 1 (pp. 1-85) via Audible with physical copy nearby.
June 3rd, 2026: listened to chapter 3 (pp. 86-145) via Audible with physical copy nearby.
June 6th, 2026: listened to chapter 4 (pp. 146-186) via Audible with physical copy nearby.
June 7th, 2026: listened to chapter 5-conclusion (pp. 187-280 via Audible with physical copy nearby.
June 8th, 2026: read through all footnotes in physical copy.
Read
March 17, 2026I don’t think I read this book…
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews