This started as a "let's see if this will be a good Christmas gift for my dad" and turned into "whoops I read the whole book." Melissa Fitzgerald (CJ's assistant Carol, the "one L in Tel Aviv" Carol) and Mary McCormack (Kate Harper) trace the history of the show, do a deep dive on a few special episodes, and reflect on the crew and cast. While I enjoy The West Wing I am not a podcast listener, superfan, et c., so a lot of the information was new to me; however, based on their source attribution, a lot of the information comes from DVD commentary and the podcast. The authors did lots of original research, including around 100 interviews.
A significant chunk of the book is simply the tale of how The West Wing began, with (a little too much) detail about pitching, casting, the pilot, and so forth. It covers the exits of Aaron Sorkin (writer), Tommy Schlamme (director), and Rob Lowe (actor) from the show. There's also a lot of material honoring John Spencer (Leo McGarry) who died during production, and Martin Sheen (President Bartlet) who had a significant impact on the culture of the show. I enjoy learning about trivia, and it was nice knowing how great everyone thinks these folks are/were, but at the end of the day...I don't know them, and it's like reading a stranger's birthday card.
The nature of the show propelled its cast into activism, which the authors detour to cover throughout the book. This was a mixed bag for me. Some of the cast, like Martin Sheen, are dedicated activists (he's been arrested for protesting over 60 times, and is active in the Catholic Worker Movement). Others repeat the same journey of "What can little ole me do?" to "Oh yeah, I'm famous and rich so I can do publicity and donate." That's kind of a sour take on it--it was neat to hear everyone talk about nonprofits close to their hearts--but it just got so repetitive. Near the end of the book is a chapter with interviews of non-affiliated folks who were inspired by The West Wing to go into public service, including a senator who took the DVDs with her to Iraq to watch after flying Blackhawks all day, Lin-Manuel Miranda cataloguing all the intentional and unintentional references in Hamilton, and a politician realizing life imitates art (probably more than once as this book went to print before September 2024, S1E7).
Some fun facts: at least one scene was filmed on the Gilmore Girls set; an inside scoop on Gail's goldfish bowl décor; the full list of considerations for the role of President Bartlet (Johnny Carson, Sidney Poitier (who turned it down), Stockard Channing (who made it onscreen anyway); and John Spencer introducing Emily Procter (Ainsley Hayes) to the walk-and-talk.
Overall, fun for fans, though probably not the most informative resource if you follow the podcast or watch the DVD commentaries.