What do you think?
Rate this book
Cal Lovett Files #3
Unsound
He left for university… and never came back Arran went missing in Edinburgh twenty years ago. The last time his parents saw him he was withdrawn and on edge where he’d once been happy and carefree. Still searching for their son, they turn to their last hope, true crime podcaster Cal Lovett.
Cal begins looking for answers, but is distracted by his sister’s murder trial. He’s so close to getting the justice Margot deserves. Can he finally leave the past – and Margot – behind?
As Cal unearths disturbing evidence about Arran’s fate, he suspects the young man’s close-knit group of university friends are keeping secrets to protect each other. It seems old loyalties don’t die easily. But they can’t all stay silent forever…
An unputdownable crime thriller perfect for fans of Jane Casey, Cara Hunter and Neil Lancaster.
Cal begins looking for answers, but is distracted by his sister’s murder trial. He’s so close to getting the justice Margot deserves. Can he finally leave the past – and Margot – behind?
As Cal unearths disturbing evidence about Arran’s fate, he suspects the young man’s close-knit group of university friends are keeping secrets to protect each other. It seems old loyalties don’t die easily. But they can’t all stay silent forever…
An unputdownable crime thriller perfect for fans of Jane Casey, Cara Hunter and Neil Lancaster.
338 pages, Paperback
Published September 5, 2024
27 people are currently reading
229 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 57 reviews
January 20, 2025
4.5 stars
A very well written book. My favourite out of the three in the series! Lots of guessing and thinking back due to certain clues throughout the book. Hard reading what happened to arran - lots of emotion stirred from his experience. Some might think it’s more complicated, but I have zero sympathy for his university friends. All evil disgusting people who deserve to rot :)
A very well written book. My favourite out of the three in the series! Lots of guessing and thinking back due to certain clues throughout the book. Hard reading what happened to arran - lots of emotion stirred from his experience. Some might think it’s more complicated, but I have zero sympathy for his university friends. All evil disgusting people who deserve to rot :)
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 23, 2024
I requested this book from Netgalley not knowing that it was the third book in a series. Not one to read a book out of series, where possible, I went back and read the first two before devouring this one.
Anyone who is in a similar position, I would encourage them to do the same. Not that it couldn't be read as a standalone, I just feel that you would be missing too much of the backstory to jump in at book three and fully appreciate the main character and what makes him tick.
In essence, Critchlow has a formula which works and one she sticks to firmly. If you have read the first two books in this series, then this review will be quick. If you enjoyed them, you will enjoy this one. There is little that deviates from the previous novels in terms of writing, structure etc.
If you are new to the series, these novels focus on Cal Lovett, true crime podcaster (yeah, I know, are there any characters left who aren't?) which focuses on missing people. Cal's own sister went missing over 30 years ago, when he was a child, and this motivates him to work hard for other families looking to bring closure and answers where possible.
Each novel focuses on Cal working a specific case but with the overarching story of his missing sister playing across all three novels so far - this is why, for me, you need to start at the beginning with this one.
The stories are told over dual timelines, Cal's current investigation but also from the perspective of the missing person leading up to their disappearance. At the end of the novel, the two timelines combine to provide a conclusion which works really well.
I have really enjoyed reading these three novels back to back and look forward to the next one. Other broadly similar series (I am thinking of Tim Weaver's David Raker series) have managed to continue and develop over a number of novels and I am hoping this will be the same.
Thanks to Netgalley and Canelo for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Anyone who is in a similar position, I would encourage them to do the same. Not that it couldn't be read as a standalone, I just feel that you would be missing too much of the backstory to jump in at book three and fully appreciate the main character and what makes him tick.
In essence, Critchlow has a formula which works and one she sticks to firmly. If you have read the first two books in this series, then this review will be quick. If you enjoyed them, you will enjoy this one. There is little that deviates from the previous novels in terms of writing, structure etc.
If you are new to the series, these novels focus on Cal Lovett, true crime podcaster (yeah, I know, are there any characters left who aren't?) which focuses on missing people. Cal's own sister went missing over 30 years ago, when he was a child, and this motivates him to work hard for other families looking to bring closure and answers where possible.
Each novel focuses on Cal working a specific case but with the overarching story of his missing sister playing across all three novels so far - this is why, for me, you need to start at the beginning with this one.
The stories are told over dual timelines, Cal's current investigation but also from the perspective of the missing person leading up to their disappearance. At the end of the novel, the two timelines combine to provide a conclusion which works really well.
I have really enjoyed reading these three novels back to back and look forward to the next one. Other broadly similar series (I am thinking of Tim Weaver's David Raker series) have managed to continue and develop over a number of novels and I am hoping this will be the same.
Thanks to Netgalley and Canelo for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
July 8, 2025
4.25 stars
This is the third book in the Cal Lovett series. It has a dual timeline with Cal looking into a cold case of the disappearance of a college student for his podcast in the present and the events leading up to his disappearance in the past. This case stands alone from cases in the prior book, but the ongoing storyline of Cal's sister continues and builds with each book.
This book is very engaging and often hard to put down. However, there are some intense scenes with hazing/bullying/assault that are hard to read. There aren't a lot of happy endings in this story, but there are some touching moments between some of the characters. I'm so glad I recently discovered this series and am looking forward to the next book which is coming out soon.
This is the third book in the Cal Lovett series. It has a dual timeline with Cal looking into a cold case of the disappearance of a college student for his podcast in the present and the events leading up to his disappearance in the past. This case stands alone from cases in the prior book, but the ongoing storyline of Cal's sister continues and builds with each book.
This book is very engaging and often hard to put down. However, there are some intense scenes with hazing/bullying/assault that are hard to read. There aren't a lot of happy endings in this story, but there are some touching moments between some of the characters. I'm so glad I recently discovered this series and am looking forward to the next book which is coming out soon.
April 13, 2025
Slow to start with but a good read, Cal does a podcast about cold cases & is asked to investigate a disappearance of a young lad at uni by his partner’s friend. Though he’s drawn into the case he got his mind firmly fixed on the trial about his own sister’s disappearance. A sad & emotional read set in past & present.
December 30, 2025
This book had me hooked. Didn’t realise it was the third in a series and now want to read the other two. It was a sad tale all round but a good read.
February 8, 2025
how stunning, was slightly slow moving but still enjoyable
September 1, 2024
Unsound by Heather Critchlow is a very highly recommended mystery and the third book in the Cal Lovett series.
Cal, a true crime podcaster, has a life in transition. He is in the midst of the trial to convict his sister's killer. His daughter Chrissie is leaving home for the university in Edinburgh. He is the only one to keep track of his elderly mother and Shona, his girlfriend, wants them to live together. When unforeseen circumstances delay the trial, Shona brings a new case to his attention. A friend of hers had her nineteen-year-old son, Arran, disappear from college and seemingly from the face of the earth. Nothing was ever discovered by the police. His parents have been looking for closure for years. Cal heads to Edinburgh to look for clues about what happened to Arran.
The narrative alternates between the past and the present. Cal in the present day investigation is looking into Arran's disappearance. Alternate chapters follow Arran's story in the past when he arrives at the university and makes three close friends. Both time periods are equally interesting and compelling. The novel is well paced and the plot moves forward quickly with some surprising twists along the way. The final denouement was unpredictable. I thought I had figured it out but I was
Unsound is a well-written, compelling mystery and the third book in a series. The first two are Unsolved and Unburied. Admittedly, I started with Unsound and haven't read the first two - yet. Although it was still easy to extrapolate much of what happened in the two previous books, this novel was enjoyable enough that I'd recommend reading the whole series, if possible, before starting Unsound. I have a feeling that it would have made this third novel even more enjoyable.
In any event, Unsound is an excellent fast-paced mystery. Thanks to Canelo Crime for providing me with an advance reader's copy via NetGalley. My review is voluntary and expresses my honest opinion.
http://www.shetreadssoftly.com/2024/0...
Cal, a true crime podcaster, has a life in transition. He is in the midst of the trial to convict his sister's killer. His daughter Chrissie is leaving home for the university in Edinburgh. He is the only one to keep track of his elderly mother and Shona, his girlfriend, wants them to live together. When unforeseen circumstances delay the trial, Shona brings a new case to his attention. A friend of hers had her nineteen-year-old son, Arran, disappear from college and seemingly from the face of the earth. Nothing was ever discovered by the police. His parents have been looking for closure for years. Cal heads to Edinburgh to look for clues about what happened to Arran.
The narrative alternates between the past and the present. Cal in the present day investigation is looking into Arran's disappearance. Alternate chapters follow Arran's story in the past when he arrives at the university and makes three close friends. Both time periods are equally interesting and compelling. The novel is well paced and the plot moves forward quickly with some surprising twists along the way. The final denouement was unpredictable. I thought I had figured it out but I was
Unsound is a well-written, compelling mystery and the third book in a series. The first two are Unsolved and Unburied. Admittedly, I started with Unsound and haven't read the first two - yet. Although it was still easy to extrapolate much of what happened in the two previous books, this novel was enjoyable enough that I'd recommend reading the whole series, if possible, before starting Unsound. I have a feeling that it would have made this third novel even more enjoyable.
In any event, Unsound is an excellent fast-paced mystery. Thanks to Canelo Crime for providing me with an advance reader's copy via NetGalley. My review is voluntary and expresses my honest opinion.
http://www.shetreadssoftly.com/2024/0...
September 26, 2024
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this eARC.
Heather Critchlow’s “Unsound” is a riveting addition to the Cal Lovett series, blending atmospheric tension with a deeply human story of loss and redemption. This third installment in the series continues to showcase Critchlow’s talent for crafting intricate mysteries set against the hauntingly beautiful backdrop of Scotland.
This novel follows Cal Lovett, a true crime podcaster, navigating a tumultuous period in his life. As he prepares for the trial to convict his sister’s killer, Cal is drawn into a new mystery when his girlfriend, Shona, asks him to investigate the disappearance of her friend’s son, Arran. Arran vanished from his university in Edinburgh fourteen years ago, and his parents have been searching for closure ever since. Cal’s investigation uncovers a tangled web of secrets among Arran’s group of friends.
Critchlow excels in developing complex, relatable characters. Cal Lovett is portrayed with a depth that makes his struggles and triumphs feel authentic. His relationship with his daughter, Chrissie, who is leaving for university, adds an emotional layer to the narrative. The supporting characters, including Shona and the friends from Arran’s past, are well-created and add dimension to the story.
The writing in “Unsound” is evocative and precise. Critchlow’s descriptions of the Scottish landscape are vivid, creating a strong sense of place that enhances the novel’s atmospheric quality.
“Unsound” explores themes of grief, justice, and the enduring impact of unresolved trauma. Critchlow delves into the psychological complexities of her characters, examining how past events shape their present actions.
“Unsound” is a compelling and emotionally resonant mystery that will captivate fans of the genre. Heather Critchlow’s ability to weave a suspenseful plot with rich character development makes this book a standout in the Cal Lovett series. Whether you’re a longtime follower of Cal’s journey or new to the series, “Unsound” is a gripping and satisfying read.
Heather Critchlow’s “Unsound” is a riveting addition to the Cal Lovett series, blending atmospheric tension with a deeply human story of loss and redemption. This third installment in the series continues to showcase Critchlow’s talent for crafting intricate mysteries set against the hauntingly beautiful backdrop of Scotland.
This novel follows Cal Lovett, a true crime podcaster, navigating a tumultuous period in his life. As he prepares for the trial to convict his sister’s killer, Cal is drawn into a new mystery when his girlfriend, Shona, asks him to investigate the disappearance of her friend’s son, Arran. Arran vanished from his university in Edinburgh fourteen years ago, and his parents have been searching for closure ever since. Cal’s investigation uncovers a tangled web of secrets among Arran’s group of friends.
Critchlow excels in developing complex, relatable characters. Cal Lovett is portrayed with a depth that makes his struggles and triumphs feel authentic. His relationship with his daughter, Chrissie, who is leaving for university, adds an emotional layer to the narrative. The supporting characters, including Shona and the friends from Arran’s past, are well-created and add dimension to the story.
The writing in “Unsound” is evocative and precise. Critchlow’s descriptions of the Scottish landscape are vivid, creating a strong sense of place that enhances the novel’s atmospheric quality.
“Unsound” explores themes of grief, justice, and the enduring impact of unresolved trauma. Critchlow delves into the psychological complexities of her characters, examining how past events shape their present actions.
“Unsound” is a compelling and emotionally resonant mystery that will captivate fans of the genre. Heather Critchlow’s ability to weave a suspenseful plot with rich character development makes this book a standout in the Cal Lovett series. Whether you’re a longtime follower of Cal’s journey or new to the series, “Unsound” is a gripping and satisfying read.
August 14, 2024
Twenty years ago, Arran was in university but in his first year there he disappears. He has always lived on a farm with his parents and two sisters, and the plan was for Arran to take over the farm management which is why he enrolled in this course to complete studies. On his last visit home before his disappearance his family felt Aaron was not alright, he seemed withdrawn and not in a great state of mind, but he would not discuss any issues with them.
Arran finds university to be a whole new world, he is quite shy and has anxiety regarding how he will fit in with his fellow students. But on his first day he meets Jono, a young man with wealthy parents, full of confidence and charisma. People are just drawn to Jono, and he and Aaron become good friends, Arran also develops friendships with two girls and the four of them become inseparable.
Cal Lovett is a podcaster who focuses on missing persons, his sister Margot disappeared many years ago so when he is asked if he can help Arran’s family find some answers he agrees to do so. Cal feels the three other friends may know more about what happened to Arron but are keeping quiet.
The story is told moving back and forward regarding both Cal and Arran’s past lives and as it progresses, we fed more information that leads to a book that is gripping and very enjoyable. Clever twists along the journey will keep you turning the pages, and I found this book very hard to put down reading it is a few hours.
Thank you to Netgalley the author and publisher for an ARC, all opinions are my own.
Arran finds university to be a whole new world, he is quite shy and has anxiety regarding how he will fit in with his fellow students. But on his first day he meets Jono, a young man with wealthy parents, full of confidence and charisma. People are just drawn to Jono, and he and Aaron become good friends, Arran also develops friendships with two girls and the four of them become inseparable.
Cal Lovett is a podcaster who focuses on missing persons, his sister Margot disappeared many years ago so when he is asked if he can help Arran’s family find some answers he agrees to do so. Cal feels the three other friends may know more about what happened to Arron but are keeping quiet.
The story is told moving back and forward regarding both Cal and Arran’s past lives and as it progresses, we fed more information that leads to a book that is gripping and very enjoyable. Clever twists along the journey will keep you turning the pages, and I found this book very hard to put down reading it is a few hours.
Thank you to Netgalley the author and publisher for an ARC, all opinions are my own.
September 18, 2024
Cal Lovett is a journalist with his own podcast, Finding Justice. He lives in the West Midlands but finds himself in Edinburgh investigating yet another case.
This time, he’s looking into the disappearance of Arran McDonald, who vanished without a trace in 2010.
Arran was from a farming family in Moray, Scotland. His future was all laid for him: he would inherit and run the family farm.
His mother, Angela, tells Cal that Arran left for Edinburgh university, all excited, but when he returned for the Christmas break, he was a changed boy. He became quiet and withdrawn and wouldn’t say what was bothering him. He fell out with his family, and they never saw him again.
Cal digs deeper by talking to people who were close to Arran at that time. He soon discovers that they are all hiding something…
On a personal level, Cal lost his sister, Margot, when he was just nine years old. 36 years later and her body was found in a scrapyard and the killer apprehended. Can Cal’s family, after all these years, finally get justice?
This is the third book in the Cal Lovett series, and I am a great fan.
I am so glad that he has found happiness again, but he’s quite a damaged character, and it’s almost as if he has to jeopardise it. I do get a feeling that he reckons he will never be happy because of what happened to Margot.
As always, he is investigating quite an interesting case, which explores the issues of hazing and exclusive drinking societies (which I thought were a thing of the past, but when I googled it, they apparently still exist!).
I definitely recommend this book.
This time, he’s looking into the disappearance of Arran McDonald, who vanished without a trace in 2010.
Arran was from a farming family in Moray, Scotland. His future was all laid for him: he would inherit and run the family farm.
His mother, Angela, tells Cal that Arran left for Edinburgh university, all excited, but when he returned for the Christmas break, he was a changed boy. He became quiet and withdrawn and wouldn’t say what was bothering him. He fell out with his family, and they never saw him again.
Cal digs deeper by talking to people who were close to Arran at that time. He soon discovers that they are all hiding something…
On a personal level, Cal lost his sister, Margot, when he was just nine years old. 36 years later and her body was found in a scrapyard and the killer apprehended. Can Cal’s family, after all these years, finally get justice?
This is the third book in the Cal Lovett series, and I am a great fan.
I am so glad that he has found happiness again, but he’s quite a damaged character, and it’s almost as if he has to jeopardise it. I do get a feeling that he reckons he will never be happy because of what happened to Margot.
As always, he is investigating quite an interesting case, which explores the issues of hazing and exclusive drinking societies (which I thought were a thing of the past, but when I googled it, they apparently still exist!).
I definitely recommend this book.
July 30, 2024
I am a big fan of the Cal Lovett files series and it just keeps getting better and better!
We rejoin podcaster Cal as he is in the midst of his sister’s killer’s trial. Tensions are high, his daughter is moving away to university, his relationship with girlfriend Shona is currently rocky, and he’s worried about his relationship with his Mum whose health is rapidly deteriorating. It’s definitely not the best time for Cal to take on a new unsolved case, but he does so as a favour to Shona.
Arran went missing in Edinburgh fourteen years ago during his first year of uni. The police were quick to dismiss it as suicide, given Arran’s recent change in personality, but Arran’s family do not believe this. With Cal’s help, the truth about Arran’s disappearance slowly begins to unravel, and it is truly shocking.
The book alternates between Arran’s past and Cal’s present. I love this format and I was really invested in Arran’s story. The twists were clever, I didn’t see any of it coming! I love it when a book completely blindsides you, the final revelations shocked me!! Tense, dark and gritty…this book completely captivated me and I read it in one day. I love Cal and I can’t wait to see what case he takes on next. There’s definitely unfinished business with his sister’s killer too, so I hope there are many more books planned in the series 🤞🏻
Unsound is released on 5th September so plenty of time to read the first two in the series if you haven’t already 🤩
We rejoin podcaster Cal as he is in the midst of his sister’s killer’s trial. Tensions are high, his daughter is moving away to university, his relationship with girlfriend Shona is currently rocky, and he’s worried about his relationship with his Mum whose health is rapidly deteriorating. It’s definitely not the best time for Cal to take on a new unsolved case, but he does so as a favour to Shona.
Arran went missing in Edinburgh fourteen years ago during his first year of uni. The police were quick to dismiss it as suicide, given Arran’s recent change in personality, but Arran’s family do not believe this. With Cal’s help, the truth about Arran’s disappearance slowly begins to unravel, and it is truly shocking.
The book alternates between Arran’s past and Cal’s present. I love this format and I was really invested in Arran’s story. The twists were clever, I didn’t see any of it coming! I love it when a book completely blindsides you, the final revelations shocked me!! Tense, dark and gritty…this book completely captivated me and I read it in one day. I love Cal and I can’t wait to see what case he takes on next. There’s definitely unfinished business with his sister’s killer too, so I hope there are many more books planned in the series 🤞🏻
Unsound is released on 5th September so plenty of time to read the first two in the series if you haven’t already 🤩
September 9, 2024
ARC Review 🌟 Unsound by Heather Critchlow
Pub Date Sep 05 2024
🌟He left for university… and never came back
🌟Absolutely gripping crime thriller. This book is the third installment in the Cal Lovett series. Cal is a true crime podcaster. I haven't read the first two, Unsolved and Unburied, but I can deduce a lot about them after reading this one, but I would love to read the whole series.
Sharp and clever writing with two timelines. One is past, 20 years ago, from the 19 years old, Arran's point of view, his start at the university, the problems, the struggles he faced, the cruelty of privileged kids and second is Cal's view point in present, his daughter starting the university, the trial of his sister's killer, caring for her aging mother, and moving in with new partner, Shona.
As Cal unravels the truth about Arran's dissapeance, he finds so many ugly truths and shocking revelations that came out in the open. It's truly heartbreaking to read about Arran, the way an innocent boy suffered and all the culprits walk free and his parents, who were still finding answers for the last twenty years.
Fast-paced and suspenseful, twists on every end, and the climax is just horrifying and gritty. It is an excellent thriller, highly recommended.
Thanks to @Netgalley and @canelo_co and the author for the eARC.
Pub Date Sep 05 2024
🌟He left for university… and never came back
🌟Absolutely gripping crime thriller. This book is the third installment in the Cal Lovett series. Cal is a true crime podcaster. I haven't read the first two, Unsolved and Unburied, but I can deduce a lot about them after reading this one, but I would love to read the whole series.
Sharp and clever writing with two timelines. One is past, 20 years ago, from the 19 years old, Arran's point of view, his start at the university, the problems, the struggles he faced, the cruelty of privileged kids and second is Cal's view point in present, his daughter starting the university, the trial of his sister's killer, caring for her aging mother, and moving in with new partner, Shona.
As Cal unravels the truth about Arran's dissapeance, he finds so many ugly truths and shocking revelations that came out in the open. It's truly heartbreaking to read about Arran, the way an innocent boy suffered and all the culprits walk free and his parents, who were still finding answers for the last twenty years.
Fast-paced and suspenseful, twists on every end, and the climax is just horrifying and gritty. It is an excellent thriller, highly recommended.
Thanks to @Netgalley and @canelo_co and the author for the eARC.
August 10, 2024
True crime podcaster Cal Lovett is back for the third installation of this series. In this book, Cal has been enlisted to determine what happened to a university student named Arran who went missing fourteen years ago in Edinburgh.
For Arran’s family, it is a chance to have closure; for Cal, it is a distraction from the trial of his sister’s murderer. However, as Cal begins to uncover what happened to Arran, he finds himself becoming more invested than he anticipated.
As mentioned, this is the third book of a series, but I haven’t read the other two and found this one works as a standalone. However, I enjoyed it enough I would read the earlier works, and it probably would help to enhance this story.
Cal’s struggle with personal issues rings true; he is not overly stoic and is just the right amount of self-destructive where he is sympathetic but not infuriating.
Regarding Arran, there are flashbacks to give the reader insight into his story. These flashbacks help move the story forward while also making the reader feel invested in Arran; however, near the end of the book, it all starts to feel a bit rushed, and the ending feels somewhat anticlimactic.
Overall, this was an enjoyable read and a good selection for someone looking for a new, well-written mystery series.
For Arran’s family, it is a chance to have closure; for Cal, it is a distraction from the trial of his sister’s murderer. However, as Cal begins to uncover what happened to Arran, he finds himself becoming more invested than he anticipated.
As mentioned, this is the third book of a series, but I haven’t read the other two and found this one works as a standalone. However, I enjoyed it enough I would read the earlier works, and it probably would help to enhance this story.
Cal’s struggle with personal issues rings true; he is not overly stoic and is just the right amount of self-destructive where he is sympathetic but not infuriating.
Regarding Arran, there are flashbacks to give the reader insight into his story. These flashbacks help move the story forward while also making the reader feel invested in Arran; however, near the end of the book, it all starts to feel a bit rushed, and the ending feels somewhat anticlimactic.
Overall, this was an enjoyable read and a good selection for someone looking for a new, well-written mystery series.
November 4, 2024
Heather Critchlow is one of the best crime writers out there at the moment; this is the third in the Cal Lovett series and they get better and better. Cal is a crime podcaster; in the first two books we know that he has been investigating the tragic murder of his older sister 30 years previously and the case has moved forward in book 3.
Cal has also been asked to look into the case of missing Edinburgh student Arran - he went missing 13 years ago just after he started university and has never been seen or heard from ever since. He became close with three new friends when he started uni, but they dont have any insights into what might have happened.
Cal's investigation of Arran's case is also wrapped up in his own daughter going to university and all of the feelings and emotions that stirs up for him and his daughter.
The chapters move between Cal's present day investigation and Arran's movements 13 years ago. As Arran's story unfolded and I started to realise what has happened, it sent shivers down my spine, it s absolutely chilling. I listened to the story on audio, and found myself going for longer and longer walks to find out how the plot developed.
I can't wait for Book 4 -so many more cases for Cal to uncover!
Cal has also been asked to look into the case of missing Edinburgh student Arran - he went missing 13 years ago just after he started university and has never been seen or heard from ever since. He became close with three new friends when he started uni, but they dont have any insights into what might have happened.
Cal's investigation of Arran's case is also wrapped up in his own daughter going to university and all of the feelings and emotions that stirs up for him and his daughter.
The chapters move between Cal's present day investigation and Arran's movements 13 years ago. As Arran's story unfolded and I started to realise what has happened, it sent shivers down my spine, it s absolutely chilling. I listened to the story on audio, and found myself going for longer and longer walks to find out how the plot developed.
I can't wait for Book 4 -so many more cases for Cal to uncover!
January 4, 2025
Just under a year from reading book 1 and 2 back to back I finally got to dive back into Cal’s world and join him on a new podcast adventure and journey through his own personal issues as well.
I liked that the case in this book was set in Edinburgh city centre and I could really envision the characters and the places they visited. I must say, Cal seemed really low in this book and struggled with all of his relationships and I felt myself wanting to check in with him and just make sure that he was ok.
This book explores the case of a 19 year old university student who just vanished one night and no one spoke up about any of the events in the lead up to his disappearance, there was no evidence or any reason to investigate further and it was deemed as most likely to be suicide… until Cal picks up the cold case and looks into all the smaller details which had been missed.
I would say this one was a little bit more predictable than the other books in the series and I did predict most of the twists. However, I still found it really enjoyable to read how it all played out.
I absolutely love the podcast chapters that are woven throughout the books.
Another really enjoyable instalment to the series - I will never stop recommending these books!
I liked that the case in this book was set in Edinburgh city centre and I could really envision the characters and the places they visited. I must say, Cal seemed really low in this book and struggled with all of his relationships and I felt myself wanting to check in with him and just make sure that he was ok.
This book explores the case of a 19 year old university student who just vanished one night and no one spoke up about any of the events in the lead up to his disappearance, there was no evidence or any reason to investigate further and it was deemed as most likely to be suicide… until Cal picks up the cold case and looks into all the smaller details which had been missed.
I would say this one was a little bit more predictable than the other books in the series and I did predict most of the twists. However, I still found it really enjoyable to read how it all played out.
I absolutely love the podcast chapters that are woven throughout the books.
Another really enjoyable instalment to the series - I will never stop recommending these books!
September 4, 2024
Cal, our intrepid podcaster is back in action. He's dealing with the trial of sister's killer, his daughter leaving for Uni, dealing with his difficult and ageing mother and Shona, his new partner wants them to live together. Mora than enough problems for one man to handle simultaneously.
A friend of Shona hands Cal a case of her missing son, 19yr old Arran. Is it fate that Cassie is going to University in the very same city? He can maybe grab another couple of moments with his daughter whilst helping another family learn the whereabouts of their missing child.
I really enjoy the overlapping time periods - we get to see Arran going to Uni, making friends, seeing the problems he faces. We then see Cal in the present trying to untangle the story and find fresh leads. I struggled with identifying the "baddie" - I usually have some kind of an idea but I was completely stumped this time! Since I work in the world of law and order, I'm keeping that quiet from my colleagues!
I'm thoroughly enjoying this series. It's based in enough real world fact and procedures that you can easily immerse yourself in Cal's world. Well paced and twisty enough to keep you guessing!
A friend of Shona hands Cal a case of her missing son, 19yr old Arran. Is it fate that Cassie is going to University in the very same city? He can maybe grab another couple of moments with his daughter whilst helping another family learn the whereabouts of their missing child.
I really enjoy the overlapping time periods - we get to see Arran going to Uni, making friends, seeing the problems he faces. We then see Cal in the present trying to untangle the story and find fresh leads. I struggled with identifying the "baddie" - I usually have some kind of an idea but I was completely stumped this time! Since I work in the world of law and order, I'm keeping that quiet from my colleagues!
I'm thoroughly enjoying this series. It's based in enough real world fact and procedures that you can easily immerse yourself in Cal's world. Well paced and twisty enough to keep you guessing!
October 3, 2024
Book 3 of true crime podcaster Cal Lovett series. I loved the other two books so when book 3 was on Nergalley, I immediately requested it. Luckily for me, I've received a copy from Canelo via Netgalley.
Again, we follow the main protagonist, true crime podcaster Cal Lovett. He investigates the missing case of Arran, a university student. Meanwhile, Cal is tormented personally by his sister’s murder trial. He’s so close to getting the justice Margot deserves. Hopefully, he can leave the past behind. While Cal finds information about Arran, he is aware that the university friends are keeping secrets to protect each other. Will he be able to get to the truth?
After three books, the main protagonist is well worked out, and you really get to know him and his personal struggles quite well. This book is the personal culmination of what the other two books wete leading to. The struggles with his past demons finally getting what they deserve play a big part in this book. The case Cal is trying to solve in the meantime is also brilliantly written. Loved every bit of it.
Hopefully, there'll be a book 4!
5/5⭐️
Again, we follow the main protagonist, true crime podcaster Cal Lovett. He investigates the missing case of Arran, a university student. Meanwhile, Cal is tormented personally by his sister’s murder trial. He’s so close to getting the justice Margot deserves. Hopefully, he can leave the past behind. While Cal finds information about Arran, he is aware that the university friends are keeping secrets to protect each other. Will he be able to get to the truth?
After three books, the main protagonist is well worked out, and you really get to know him and his personal struggles quite well. This book is the personal culmination of what the other two books wete leading to. The struggles with his past demons finally getting what they deserve play a big part in this book. The case Cal is trying to solve in the meantime is also brilliantly written. Loved every bit of it.
Hopefully, there'll be a book 4!
5/5⭐️
September 1, 2024
Told over 2 timeperiods, this book is about Cal, a crime podcaster who tries to bring closure for cold cases. In this book, Arran, the son of a highland farmer leaves for university . At the beginning of the second term he disappears. Cal has his own family problems and these are also dealt with along with his investigation into Arran's disappearance. The third in the series, I would advise reading all the books, more because you understand Cal's personal situation as well as the way he works, though regarding the main investigation, the book reads fine as a stand alone. It took me a couple of chapters to get into this book but once the investigation in Edinburgh got going, I could not put the book down The descriptions of emotions and of student life are well done and Cal's reactions in the investigation are considered and believable. He does have his own troubles as well and I like the ongoing personal factors as well as the completed investigation as it gives the book an extra dimension.
A great read, thanks to Net Galley for the ARC
A great read, thanks to Net Galley for the ARC
November 19, 2025
Unsound by Heather Critchlow is the third book in the Cal Lovett Files. Read it under 48 hours, that’s how hooked I was - saying it was gripping is an understatement 🙌🏽
I have one more to finish this series and boy am going to miss all the characters 😢
This particular story centers on Arran, who went missing in Edinburgh 14 years ago.
His parents, still desperate for answers, reach out to Cal Lovett, a true-crime podcaster, hoping he can help. By the way am obsessed with Cal! 🙊
Meanwhile, Cal is emotionally torn his sister Margot is on trial for murder, and he’s deeply invested in that as well. Trying not to think too much of his current partners wishes and his daughter starting university !
As Cal digs into Arran’s disappearance, he suspects that Arran’s old group of university friends were hiding something secrets, loyalty, and possibly betrayal come strongly into play.
Themes of betrayal, family, friendship, loyalty are explored.
Short chapters are always an extra bonus!
Rating: 5/5 💫💫💫
I have one more to finish this series and boy am going to miss all the characters 😢
This particular story centers on Arran, who went missing in Edinburgh 14 years ago.
His parents, still desperate for answers, reach out to Cal Lovett, a true-crime podcaster, hoping he can help. By the way am obsessed with Cal! 🙊
Meanwhile, Cal is emotionally torn his sister Margot is on trial for murder, and he’s deeply invested in that as well. Trying not to think too much of his current partners wishes and his daughter starting university !
As Cal digs into Arran’s disappearance, he suspects that Arran’s old group of university friends were hiding something secrets, loyalty, and possibly betrayal come strongly into play.
Themes of betrayal, family, friendship, loyalty are explored.
Short chapters are always an extra bonus!
Rating: 5/5 💫💫💫
July 24, 2024
Thank you to NetGalley and Canelo.
While awaiting the verdict in the trial for his sister's murder, Cal decides to help a friend of Shona's whose son disappeared fourteen years earlier.
It's the third book in the series and if something works why change it? With the usual scheme alternating past and present we see how Arran struggles to adapt to his new life at college, friends, environment and challenges. He disappeared one day and has not been heard from since. Now Cal Lovett tries to find out what happened while trying to distract himself from the trial and the issues that concern him, such as his mother's health or his daughter's college life.
A novel with a good story both in the investigation and the personal side and as always with some interesting twists. After the closing of the case, we are left with the expectation of knowing more about the murder of Cal's sister and her killer.
If you have read the previous ones, you can't miss this one.
While awaiting the verdict in the trial for his sister's murder, Cal decides to help a friend of Shona's whose son disappeared fourteen years earlier.
It's the third book in the series and if something works why change it? With the usual scheme alternating past and present we see how Arran struggles to adapt to his new life at college, friends, environment and challenges. He disappeared one day and has not been heard from since. Now Cal Lovett tries to find out what happened while trying to distract himself from the trial and the issues that concern him, such as his mother's health or his daughter's college life.
A novel with a good story both in the investigation and the personal side and as always with some interesting twists. After the closing of the case, we are left with the expectation of knowing more about the murder of Cal's sister and her killer.
If you have read the previous ones, you can't miss this one.
August 31, 2024
This, third book in the Cal Lovett Files, was every bit as gripping as the first two!
It opens with Cal dealing with the trial of the man he believes responsible for the death of his sister where he might finally gain some closure and relief from this event from his childhood which has influenced so much of his life. We also see him coping with Chrissie moving away from the Midlands and starting her own journey in life at university in Edinburgh.
Cal is having a tough time in life right now and that’s even before we mention Shona and his mother, let alone get into what he’s doing with his podcast! But at least with that Shona has some information for him that leads him on a new journey of discovery in trying to find out what has happened to Arran.
This is another interesting case with Cal following the clues but will he find all the answers this time? You’re just going to have to read it and find out!
It opens with Cal dealing with the trial of the man he believes responsible for the death of his sister where he might finally gain some closure and relief from this event from his childhood which has influenced so much of his life. We also see him coping with Chrissie moving away from the Midlands and starting her own journey in life at university in Edinburgh.
Cal is having a tough time in life right now and that’s even before we mention Shona and his mother, let alone get into what he’s doing with his podcast! But at least with that Shona has some information for him that leads him on a new journey of discovery in trying to find out what has happened to Arran.
This is another interesting case with Cal following the clues but will he find all the answers this time? You’re just going to have to read it and find out!
September 9, 2024
The crime podcaster trope has been overdone to an alarming extent in recent years, but Heather
Critchlow's character Cal Lovett is the real deal. I really enjoyed the first two books in the series and this third one is a good addition.
In this story, we discover Cal investigating the puzzling disappearance of a young man in Edinburgh, who went missing over a decade ago. His parents insist their son, Arran, went from being a happy and well-adjusted boy to someone who was clearly troubled.
In the course of his investigations, Cal becomes increasingly convinced that Arran's university friends - who must surely have witnessed the changes in his personality that his parents described - are hiding something.
But why would they lie? And what are they lying about?
This one is definitely worth a read, especially if you liked the earlier books, as I did.
I received a free copy of this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
Critchlow's character Cal Lovett is the real deal. I really enjoyed the first two books in the series and this third one is a good addition.
In this story, we discover Cal investigating the puzzling disappearance of a young man in Edinburgh, who went missing over a decade ago. His parents insist their son, Arran, went from being a happy and well-adjusted boy to someone who was clearly troubled.
In the course of his investigations, Cal becomes increasingly convinced that Arran's university friends - who must surely have witnessed the changes in his personality that his parents described - are hiding something.
But why would they lie? And what are they lying about?
This one is definitely worth a read, especially if you liked the earlier books, as I did.
I received a free copy of this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
February 14, 2025
This is the third in the Cal Lovett series and my favourite so far. Perhaps I’m biased because I go to Edinburgh every year and know it so well so I found it easy to picture and imagine. I found this book hooked me in right from the beginning and I liked Arran’s character and the circumstances behind his disappearance which seemed to play out well. I read this one straight after the second in the series, Unburied , and I think that definitely helped too. Although it is set a few years after the events in Unburied it features the trial of Margot’s suspected killer but this didn’t overshadow the cold case Cal is investigating which I preferred. The story moves at a fair pace and, like the previous books, the chapters alternated between Cal in the present and Arran in 2009. The final chapter ends on a cliffhanger and sets the tone for the next in the series so I don’t think this is the final outing for Cal Lovett.
August 15, 2024
I have read the others in this series so was familiar with Cal’s back story. In this book, he is dealing with personal issues regarding the trial of the man responsible for his sister’s death and his daughter is leaving for university.
I loved the descriptions of Chrissie in the present day tackling university life and Arran in the past dealing with the same issues. It brought back my own memories of leaving home near Glasgow and moving to Edinburgh to study. The story also deals with ‘class’ issues - where does privilege get you in the world? Echoes of Eton and Oxford and their secret societies- and what they get up to! I felt quite sorry for Cal , he’s overwhelmed and won’t ask for help. A cracking story with some unsavoury revelations near the end. Can’t wait for the next one!
I loved the descriptions of Chrissie in the present day tackling university life and Arran in the past dealing with the same issues. It brought back my own memories of leaving home near Glasgow and moving to Edinburgh to study. The story also deals with ‘class’ issues - where does privilege get you in the world? Echoes of Eton and Oxford and their secret societies- and what they get up to! I felt quite sorry for Cal , he’s overwhelmed and won’t ask for help. A cracking story with some unsavoury revelations near the end. Can’t wait for the next one!
September 5, 2024
This is Book 3 of The Cal Lovett Files. Cal is asked by Angela and Bill McDonald to investigate the mystery surrounding their 19 year old son, Arran about 14 years ago in Edinburgh, where he was a first year student studying. Meanwhile, Cal is anxious as his sister's (Margot) murder trial is taking place around the same time. Cal is a true crime podcaster - Finding Justice so the investigation into Arran's disappearance is the reason for Angela and Bill to ask him for his help. The story is told over time periods using different POVs and we learn things are not what they seem. The sub plots come together with a dramatic twist. I found the book to be well written with plenty of plot twists that I could not put this book down till I reached the ending. I highly recommend this book.
February 21, 2025
**SPOILERS**
I think this is slowly becoming one of my favourite book series.
The way the author makes you feel the emotions of every single character, and yet makes you feel lost with what is happening throughout.
The podcast storyline this time was incredibly sad and out of everybody this one was the hardest to read as you always knew what was coming. It was very well done though and even though justice isn't exactly served it was a good outcome.
The Shona and Cal storyline was good to see - for Cal to get some clarity in his own mind for a change.
The ending leaves the door open for so many possibilities going forward - excited for the next installment!
I think this is slowly becoming one of my favourite book series.
The way the author makes you feel the emotions of every single character, and yet makes you feel lost with what is happening throughout.
The podcast storyline this time was incredibly sad and out of everybody this one was the hardest to read as you always knew what was coming. It was very well done though and even though justice isn't exactly served it was a good outcome.
The Shona and Cal storyline was good to see - for Cal to get some clarity in his own mind for a change.
The ending leaves the door open for so many possibilities going forward - excited for the next installment!
August 12, 2025
Another enjoyable book in this series.
I enjoyed the multiple perspectives, Cal's, Arran's via flashbacks and the podcast episode clips.
This was an interesting mystery, the disappearance of Arran during his first year at Edinburgh University 10+years before. The sub-plots of Cal struggling with his relationship with Shona, daughter Chrissie's move to Edinburgh University and the trial of Barr for Cal's sister Margot's murder meant that there was a lot going on in this book.
I look forward to seeing Cal continue in his quest for justice for Margot in the next book whilst his personal life hopefully settles down.
I enjoyed the multiple perspectives, Cal's, Arran's via flashbacks and the podcast episode clips.
This was an interesting mystery, the disappearance of Arran during his first year at Edinburgh University 10+years before. The sub-plots of Cal struggling with his relationship with Shona, daughter Chrissie's move to Edinburgh University and the trial of Barr for Cal's sister Margot's murder meant that there was a lot going on in this book.
I look forward to seeing Cal continue in his quest for justice for Margot in the next book whilst his personal life hopefully settles down.
October 11, 2024
Excellent addition to this series
Podcaster Cal Lovett is reluctant to take on a new case as he waits for the end of the trial of his sister’s killer. But because his partner asks him to look into the 13 yr disappearance of her best friend’s son, he takes it on.
In the course of him unraveling the trail of the missing young man, Cal will be forced to confront his own fears. The story he unearths is shocking and horrific.
Tightly plotted, filled with emotion, you will race to the end of this satisfyingly well-crafted read.
Podcaster Cal Lovett is reluctant to take on a new case as he waits for the end of the trial of his sister’s killer. But because his partner asks him to look into the 13 yr disappearance of her best friend’s son, he takes it on.
In the course of him unraveling the trail of the missing young man, Cal will be forced to confront his own fears. The story he unearths is shocking and horrific.
Tightly plotted, filled with emotion, you will race to the end of this satisfyingly well-crafted read.
March 2, 2025
It's dark and very sad in places however makes an highly interesting read. Mainly set in Edinburgh across now and the 2009/2010 period with parrels to now at every turn of the page. I started at book 3 in the series. Yes there are things that would be explained more in the first two if you read them first but it did not spoil my read in the slightest. I was just to keen to read about the darker side of Edinburgh in this fictional creation. Poor Arran in all of this. Cal is an excellent lead character. I want to read the others now.
September 15, 2024
A captivating story unfolds with two intriguing mysteries intertwined as Cal embarks on a quest to unravel the truth behind Aaron’s disappearance. Amidst this pursuit, he grapples with the emotional aftermath of his sister’s murder trial, which has yielded no justice. The author’s masterful storytelling keeps the reader enthralled throughout the book, ensuring a thoroughly engaging and immersive reading experience.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 57 reviews