What do you think?
Rate this book
Mirage
A Halloween murder mystery novel by Emma Smith, perfect for fans of Cynthia Murphy and Kathryn Foxfield.
Ravensfarne, an idyllic paradise, off the beaten track...
Georgia has lived on a tiny island off the coast of Northumberland all her life. So when cousin Cindy from Connecticut comes to stay for Halloween, she's not expecting anything out of the ordinary to happen... until her friends start dying, one by one.
A push from the castle ruins; an accident; and murder, cold-blooded murder. Trapped in a storm with the killer still on the loose, there's no way to escape. It's down to the cousins to figure out what's going on, and to track down the murderer...
Because if they don't, it looks like they might be next.
A young adult mystery set off the coast of England, exploring themes of first love, friendship and loyalty.
Ravensfarne, an idyllic paradise, off the beaten track...
Georgia has lived on a tiny island off the coast of Northumberland all her life. So when cousin Cindy from Connecticut comes to stay for Halloween, she's not expecting anything out of the ordinary to happen... until her friends start dying, one by one.
A push from the castle ruins; an accident; and murder, cold-blooded murder. Trapped in a storm with the killer still on the loose, there's no way to escape. It's down to the cousins to figure out what's going on, and to track down the murderer...
Because if they don't, it looks like they might be next.
A young adult mystery set off the coast of England, exploring themes of first love, friendship and loyalty.
304 pages, Paperback
Published August 30, 2024
35 people are currently reading
1300 people want to read
About the author
Emma Smith
14 books562 followersEmma Smith is a young adult and children's author from Yorkshire. She wrote and illustrated her first “book” when she was seven years old and hasn’t stopped writing since. When she’s not walking on the beach or drinking an iced coffee with a crumpet and some chocolate, you’ll probably find her reading something dark and mysterious… and most certainly YA.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews
July 1, 2024
Before you read this book, I command the sky to cloud over and a hot chocolate to appear in your hand, a blanket at your feet, ginger cat curled round your neck. Ravensfarne is waiting.
August 3, 2024
This book was given on behalf of an ARC read, in return for a review
Mirage by Emma Smith
A young girl who has moved from Connecticut, USA to a small local town called Ravensfarne to start a whole new life but who was to know what would happen next?
My initial reaction was oh my god, I love the way the characters were displayed how jealousy filled Georgia but yet how she put her differences aside with her cousin who came to visit. As well as this I love how the plot keeps you in suspense one second someone is alive and next you’re thinking who will be gone so soon after. The pace of the plot was good I liked how it flowed so effortlessly, with Georgia being able to show each stage of the event.
I liked how Georgia had her comfort and how they started with a big life in America to a small deli in Northumberland, as well as this the final exposure to what happened at the end brought me to another level how quickly the scenarios changed and how it was presented was amazing, although one thing I didn’t like about it was how quickly Georgia judged Cindy not knowing the events that had happened and I often found her jealous over small things but I felt that Brough a difference to the story as it showed her true emotions about how different the pair are. I feel this is written 100% for the age group that it was aimed at, and I believe it will be enjoyable for whom it’s intended.
Overall I would 100% recommend this book for the release on the 30th of August, especially for those who are a massive fan of horror and Halloween themes similar to A Good Girls Guide to murder, Mirage brought me a thrill like never before and showed me a genre that caught me from the beginning. My rating for this book is 5/5 stars.
Mirage by Emma Smith
A young girl who has moved from Connecticut, USA to a small local town called Ravensfarne to start a whole new life but who was to know what would happen next?
My initial reaction was oh my god, I love the way the characters were displayed how jealousy filled Georgia but yet how she put her differences aside with her cousin who came to visit. As well as this I love how the plot keeps you in suspense one second someone is alive and next you’re thinking who will be gone so soon after. The pace of the plot was good I liked how it flowed so effortlessly, with Georgia being able to show each stage of the event.
I liked how Georgia had her comfort and how they started with a big life in America to a small deli in Northumberland, as well as this the final exposure to what happened at the end brought me to another level how quickly the scenarios changed and how it was presented was amazing, although one thing I didn’t like about it was how quickly Georgia judged Cindy not knowing the events that had happened and I often found her jealous over small things but I felt that Brough a difference to the story as it showed her true emotions about how different the pair are. I feel this is written 100% for the age group that it was aimed at, and I believe it will be enjoyable for whom it’s intended.
Overall I would 100% recommend this book for the release on the 30th of August, especially for those who are a massive fan of horror and Halloween themes similar to A Good Girls Guide to murder, Mirage brought me a thrill like never before and showed me a genre that caught me from the beginning. My rating for this book is 5/5 stars.
March 24, 2025
oh. my. god. started this book the same day i finished it and couldnt put it down. a mix between gilmore girls and halloween and a twisty murder mystery. so many twists and turns and this book was SO EXCITING. my new favorite from emma smith and one of the best books ive read this year. i highly recommend this book if you like pumpkin spice lattes and murder mystery books 🎃🔪⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
August 16, 2024
Are you overly obsessed with Gimore Girls? Do you like autumnal books with pumpkin spice lattes and halloween celebrations? And do you like being scared to your wit's end trying to figure out what on earth is going on!!?
Mirage is the perfect blend of cosy and terrifying. The depth that was given to EVERY SINGLE CHARACTER is so thoughtful to the extent where it's very easy to want to hear their story too. But Georgia? Our protagonist? I love how flawed she is, bringing a hint of coming-of-age into the midst of all the horror. This book isn't just about murder; it has a lot of really important topics and realism.
Emma's writing style is so easy to fall in love with and every adventure into the ELU is an amazing experience. I cannot recommend her books enough: you will love them.
Mirage is the perfect blend of cosy and terrifying. The depth that was given to EVERY SINGLE CHARACTER is so thoughtful to the extent where it's very easy to want to hear their story too. But Georgia? Our protagonist? I love how flawed she is, bringing a hint of coming-of-age into the midst of all the horror. This book isn't just about murder; it has a lot of really important topics and realism.
Emma's writing style is so easy to fall in love with and every adventure into the ELU is an amazing experience. I cannot recommend her books enough: you will love them.
August 12, 2025
just went through every emotion in the english dictionary. anyway everyone read mirage by emma smith thanks for coming to my ted talk
August 2, 2024
you need to read this book immediately with a blanket and a hot drink and a cosy lamp and an 80s slasher spotify playlist on and get lost in the mystery!!! perfect summerween to autumn transition i had a blast
August 20, 2024
‘Ravensfarne is a tiny place. It only has about three-hundred-and-fifty inhabitants.’
‘Untouched beauty. That was the appeal of Ravensfarne. It wasn’t trying to be something great, something special. It just was.’
In a tale of halloween mystery, self-growth, and discovering what is important to you, is the setting of Ravensfarne. Perfectly autumnal and cosy, there are references to Gilmore Girls that make it feel relatable while still being timeless, and Ravensfarne is the best backdrop for this. The descriptions of the castle, the storm and the characters create a spooky atmosphere which makes you question everyone’s intentions. Meanwhile you rely on Georgia’s description of her beloved home and experience her self-development and honest admittance of her insecurities as she sees the island from the view of an outsider, her cousin Cindy, for the first time.
Cindy is introduced as an all-American it girl - the polar opposite to Georgia’s loveable and humble, while still from perfect, group of friends (honourable mention of Annie - the best character in the entire book!). As the group gets closer you grow to love them all despite their faults, and, when the losses start and the betrayal sets in, the claustrophobia of Ravensfarne’s small and tight-knit community grows.
All in all, Mirage is something new to add to Emma Smith’s growing universe (side note: I loved the Dead Fine mention - we love an author who links all her books together!). It is the perfect read for cosy and stormy nights, and as a die-hard fan I cannot wait to see what she comes out with next :).
‘Untouched beauty. That was the appeal of Ravensfarne. It wasn’t trying to be something great, something special. It just was.’
In a tale of halloween mystery, self-growth, and discovering what is important to you, is the setting of Ravensfarne. Perfectly autumnal and cosy, there are references to Gilmore Girls that make it feel relatable while still being timeless, and Ravensfarne is the best backdrop for this. The descriptions of the castle, the storm and the characters create a spooky atmosphere which makes you question everyone’s intentions. Meanwhile you rely on Georgia’s description of her beloved home and experience her self-development and honest admittance of her insecurities as she sees the island from the view of an outsider, her cousin Cindy, for the first time.
Cindy is introduced as an all-American it girl - the polar opposite to Georgia’s loveable and humble, while still from perfect, group of friends (honourable mention of Annie - the best character in the entire book!). As the group gets closer you grow to love them all despite their faults, and, when the losses start and the betrayal sets in, the claustrophobia of Ravensfarne’s small and tight-knit community grows.
All in all, Mirage is something new to add to Emma Smith’s growing universe (side note: I loved the Dead Fine mention - we love an author who links all her books together!). It is the perfect read for cosy and stormy nights, and as a die-hard fan I cannot wait to see what she comes out with next :).
August 30, 2024
4.5
This book was so atmospheric and mysterious, I loved every second reading it!!
The vibes of the setting were amazing it made me really want rainy weather and to just cozy up in a blanket with a cup of hot chocolate or tea.
The story follows Georgia, who lives on a small island called Ravensfarne. Her cousin comes to visit her during her October break, but suddenly her friends are dying.
I did figure out who the murderer was, however I still really enjoyed reading it. It was still very mysterious and intriguing, and additionally I started to really care for the characters, especially Ben!!!
I even cried multiple times hahaha, I will definitely miss the characters and the town.
Also, once again, I absolutely loved the atmosphere of the book and now really want to visit Northumberland hahaha
I’m definitely looking forward to reading more of the authors works!!
This book was so atmospheric and mysterious, I loved every second reading it!!
The vibes of the setting were amazing it made me really want rainy weather and to just cozy up in a blanket with a cup of hot chocolate or tea.
The story follows Georgia, who lives on a small island called Ravensfarne. Her cousin comes to visit her during her October break, but suddenly her friends are dying.
I did figure out who the murderer was, however I still really enjoyed reading it. It was still very mysterious and intriguing, and additionally I started to really care for the characters, especially Ben!!!
I even cried multiple times hahaha, I will definitely miss the characters and the town.
Also, once again, I absolutely loved the atmosphere of the book and now really want to visit Northumberland hahaha
I’m definitely looking forward to reading more of the authors works!!
August 24, 2024
i am soooo happy that i got to read this book as an ARC reader for the first time ever.
throughout the book, i felt nervous, i laughed, i screamed… and i felt a connection with the main character, Georgia, in many occasions. if you are looking for a YA/ mystery book, i highly recommend reading this one. also the plot twists??? so good!!!
thanks Emma for giving me the opportunity to read your book. it’s going to be amazing!!! 🩷
throughout the book, i felt nervous, i laughed, i screamed… and i felt a connection with the main character, Georgia, in many occasions. if you are looking for a YA/ mystery book, i highly recommend reading this one. also the plot twists??? so good!!!
thanks Emma for giving me the opportunity to read your book. it’s going to be amazing!!! 🩷
August 2, 2024
4.5 ⭐️
4.5⭐️
I was sent this arc by the author in exchange for an honest review and wow it was amazing! Georgia the protagonist has spent her whole life living on a tiny island in Northumberland where her mum owns a deli. It’s a small, cosy community that has been described beautifully. When Georgia’s cousin Cindy visits from Connecticut, Georgia’s first emotion is jealousy. But the girls have to put their differences aside when they witness a local girl’s murder on Halloween night. Cut off from the mainland, Georgia, Cindy and their friends have to race against the murderer in order to survive…
I will admit I wasn’t the biggest fan of the protagonist (I found her to be unnecessarily jealous and a bit annoying at times) but I found that didn’t affect my enjoyment of the book at all. I still loved it and read it in a day as I couldn’t put it down.
The writing style was excellent: the characters were so human and the duality between the cosiness of the island and the creepiness of the crimes taking place was so perfect. I’d recommend to any fans of crime and lovers of Halloween!
4.5⭐️
I was sent this arc by the author in exchange for an honest review and wow it was amazing! Georgia the protagonist has spent her whole life living on a tiny island in Northumberland where her mum owns a deli. It’s a small, cosy community that has been described beautifully. When Georgia’s cousin Cindy visits from Connecticut, Georgia’s first emotion is jealousy. But the girls have to put their differences aside when they witness a local girl’s murder on Halloween night. Cut off from the mainland, Georgia, Cindy and their friends have to race against the murderer in order to survive…
I will admit I wasn’t the biggest fan of the protagonist (I found her to be unnecessarily jealous and a bit annoying at times) but I found that didn’t affect my enjoyment of the book at all. I still loved it and read it in a day as I couldn’t put it down.
The writing style was excellent: the characters were so human and the duality between the cosiness of the island and the creepiness of the crimes taking place was so perfect. I’d recommend to any fans of crime and lovers of Halloween!
August 12, 2024
I was given the chance to read this as an ARC reader.
This is a really cute autumnal YA mystery, it made me want to curl up with a blanket and listen to the rain whilst I read - unfortunately it was 29 degrees instead. The story and the characters kept me entertained and the twists and turns just kept coming. I finished the book in less than 24hrs as I didn’t want to put it down.
This is a really cute autumnal YA mystery, it made me want to curl up with a blanket and listen to the rain whilst I read - unfortunately it was 29 degrees instead. The story and the characters kept me entertained and the twists and turns just kept coming. I finished the book in less than 24hrs as I didn’t want to put it down.
August 4, 2024
The perfect YA novel…
If you loved Good Girls Guide to murder you will love this book even more. I did.
The scenery had me wanting to get in bed with a blanked and a hot chocolate I ate this book up.
The mystery hooked me and I loved the island setting it just felt so cozy and homely. Then the mystery kicks in and you’re on your seat wanting to know who is the traitor. One minuite I’m loving the characters relationship development the next I’m trying to be a detective and solve the mystery.
The ending was not at all what I was expecting honestly you will not see it coming which is rare for books these days. This book really had an eerie feeling that kept me hooked all the way through
Emma has written a great YA mystery and I wish I could re read it again without knowing the ending it was fabulous🙂
If you loved Good Girls Guide to murder you will love this book even more. I did.
The scenery had me wanting to get in bed with a blanked and a hot chocolate I ate this book up.
The mystery hooked me and I loved the island setting it just felt so cozy and homely. Then the mystery kicks in and you’re on your seat wanting to know who is the traitor. One minuite I’m loving the characters relationship development the next I’m trying to be a detective and solve the mystery.
The ending was not at all what I was expecting honestly you will not see it coming which is rare for books these days. This book really had an eerie feeling that kept me hooked all the way through
Emma has written a great YA mystery and I wish I could re read it again without knowing the ending it was fabulous🙂
September 8, 2024
I'm so obsessed!!! The setting in this book is one of my favourites of Emma’s ❤️🍂 Absolutely loved all the descriptions (the attention to detail was so so good) and it really felt like a found family (despite all the murder). It’s made me so excited for Autumn and Halloween 🎃 I suspected almost everyone at one point 🤦🏻♀️🤣 I can’t stop thinking about each character and I’ve already made a Pinterest board for them all! (A true sign of a five star)
August 30, 2024
A deeply twisted, autumnal tale, waxed in pumpkin spice candles, seasonal lattes and rainy halloween nights. Emma wrote this one with so much detail, description and power; it truly was a book worth every moment.
Mirage follows Georgia, a simple teenage girl, living on a small island of the coast of Northern England, and her group of friends on the spooky night of Halloween. Her secretive cousin Cindy, is visiting for the week and it seems that she has bought trouble with her. The tight-knit town is not what is seems when Georgias friends start dying one by one, and the police isn’t there to find the killer. She takes it upon herself to find out the truth, whilst also endangering herself.
I simply could not have figured out this book, I had to sit and read it mostly in one sitting, as it was too gripping and had to find out who was behind the monstrosity. Mirage keeps you guessing, thinking you had it all figured out, until you hadn’t. It’s also a story of youth, friendship, teenage love and difficult relationships.
I really enjoyed reading it, the setting was grimy and dark, perfect for the upcoming seasons, the characters were intricate and interesting, I wanted to know more about them. The writing style was clear and well organised, there was no plot holes and everything made sense in the end.
For the fans of Gilmore girls, pumpkin spice lattes, halloween movies and dressing up- this book is for you: so read it❤️
Mirage follows Georgia, a simple teenage girl, living on a small island of the coast of Northern England, and her group of friends on the spooky night of Halloween. Her secretive cousin Cindy, is visiting for the week and it seems that she has bought trouble with her. The tight-knit town is not what is seems when Georgias friends start dying one by one, and the police isn’t there to find the killer. She takes it upon herself to find out the truth, whilst also endangering herself.
I simply could not have figured out this book, I had to sit and read it mostly in one sitting, as it was too gripping and had to find out who was behind the monstrosity. Mirage keeps you guessing, thinking you had it all figured out, until you hadn’t. It’s also a story of youth, friendship, teenage love and difficult relationships.
I really enjoyed reading it, the setting was grimy and dark, perfect for the upcoming seasons, the characters were intricate and interesting, I wanted to know more about them. The writing style was clear and well organised, there was no plot holes and everything made sense in the end.
For the fans of Gilmore girls, pumpkin spice lattes, halloween movies and dressing up- this book is for you: so read it❤️
September 10, 2024
Before I even started Mirage I knew I'd love it from everything Emma had shared about it - and I was totally right. The perfect Autumn/Halloween read, Mirage is a fairly fast paced mystery set on a tiny island in the north of England. I absolutely adored the setting and thought it was really brought to life, and the mystery itself was terrifying and engrossing - I couldn't stop reading. As always, I loved the characters, they were very realistic and I loved Georgia as a protagonist. The story also deals with some really important issues very well, and I liked the side characters and their places within the island's community and the mystery itself. I would 100% recommend this for a September or October read, it really got me in a Halloween mood!!
August 28, 2024
This book was wonderful,felt like a hug on a plate with a sinister tone (yes im weird that i find murder mysteries comforting), and as someone who has always felt inferior to their cousins, it felt very close to home,the plot was enthralling and dragged me out of my worst adhd based reading slump I've ever had.
August 30, 2025
I loved this book! First of all, the vibes.. omg stunning! Two, I loved the plot, it was intriguing and kept me thinking.
I loved how this book was a bit different from the books I have read by Emma but it still kept the same Emma Smith charms that I love. I think my favourite thing about Emma's books for each of them is the way she can make me feel cosy in places I've never been, also under represented places in both UKYA and literature as a whole!
I loved how this book was a bit different from the books I have read by Emma but it still kept the same Emma Smith charms that I love. I think my favourite thing about Emma's books for each of them is the way she can make me feel cosy in places I've never been, also under represented places in both UKYA and literature as a whole!
August 30, 2024
This was a cosy spooky read. You didn’t know who to trust or believe and was suspicious of some of the nicest characters. I did however guess who it would be but I read a lot of crime mysteries and for a YA this was great and think many people will love it for its Gilmore Girls/ Halloween vibe.
I really enjoyed how in depth each character was and I found that some of them added to how good this book was! Everyone had their own personality so it was easy to follow and made for fun reading. I also liked the reclusiveness of the place, it’s what added to the Gilmore vibe and it kind of made me want to live there (besides all the murder and stuff 🫢)
100% you have to cosy up with a hot drink, a candle and blanket to get in the proper mood to read this story!
I really enjoyed how in depth each character was and I found that some of them added to how good this book was! Everyone had their own personality so it was easy to follow and made for fun reading. I also liked the reclusiveness of the place, it’s what added to the Gilmore vibe and it kind of made me want to live there (besides all the murder and stuff 🫢)
100% you have to cosy up with a hot drink, a candle and blanket to get in the proper mood to read this story!
September 22, 2024
*Thank you to the author for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.*
Looking for the perfect book for spooky season? Look no further than Mirage!! Emma Smith does an AMAZING job of creating such an atmospheric setting with Ravensfarne that you can easily picture in your mind. It’s the perfect place for a mystery to occur. I also think this book is full of realistic characters. A lot of the time when reading books I feel that teenage characters don’t really act their age, but the main friend group written in the book each face issues many teenagers face and act appropriately. One tiny issue I had was that I felt some scenes could have been used to show rather than tell us about different characters, but that’s no reason to skip this book. I’d say if you want a fun and spooky mystery mixed with Gilmore Girls to check this out on August 30th!!
Looking for the perfect book for spooky season? Look no further than Mirage!! Emma Smith does an AMAZING job of creating such an atmospheric setting with Ravensfarne that you can easily picture in your mind. It’s the perfect place for a mystery to occur. I also think this book is full of realistic characters. A lot of the time when reading books I feel that teenage characters don’t really act their age, but the main friend group written in the book each face issues many teenagers face and act appropriately. One tiny issue I had was that I felt some scenes could have been used to show rather than tell us about different characters, but that’s no reason to skip this book. I’d say if you want a fun and spooky mystery mixed with Gilmore Girls to check this out on August 30th!!
September 5, 2024
The perfect read for the autumn, this book came just in time for cosy vibes and warm drinks by the fire!! For a Gilmore Girls and halloween loving fanatic I think this is the perfect book. I cannot wait to read more by this author💗
January 2, 2025
This was bit of a frustrating read to me. I really wanted to love it, and I did like it in the begging, the whole premise of it all, but then it just went a bit… downhill?
a) Why there was so much time spent on the characteristics of the other three friends, when they were barely important to the story and only one of them showed up again at the very end of the book?
b) Why didn’t any of them make an appearance at least in the village hall, when all of the island residents were there?
c) How could have Mr. Evans been with the Petersons when Lolly died, as we later find out? Because after Lolly dies, the mum goes to his house and sends him to the Petersons to tell them their daughter has died - so that doesn’t make a whole lot of sense to me.
d) Almost all of the story building is based on conversations - it’s all tell and almost no show. I feel like there could have been more clues throughout the book about who the killer is, not just a summary of all that happened at the end of the book. The revelation that Paul was suspecting Cindy the whole time also felt a bit random, since there were no suble hints about it before - again.
e) If the mom had such a bad feeling about Cindy and knew she had a history of lying, why would she let her daughter run around the island with her while all the murders were happening? Instead we got the ominous “don’t trust anyone”, but it doesn’t make any sense to me why she wouldn’t just tell Georgia to keep her distance and why.
f) And even if she had no problem with Cindy, why would she let them run around the island with all that was hapenning still? My parents would probably lock me up in a basement.
g) Why would Georgia jump to the conclusion that Mr. and Mrs. Evans were the murderers basically just because he followed them into the house?
h) The overuse of the word “loo”.
i) If Cindy tripped Annie while they were all looking down, why did she fall backwards? At least that’s what I’ve gathered from the description.
All in all, I feel like this writer and her ideas have a lot of potential, but the execution wasn’t quite there yet imo. On the other hand, the whole book is very atmospheric, I loved it’s setting and if Ravensfarne was a real place, I would love to go there.
a) Why there was so much time spent on the characteristics of the other three friends, when they were barely important to the story and only one of them showed up again at the very end of the book?
b) Why didn’t any of them make an appearance at least in the village hall, when all of the island residents were there?
c) How could have Mr. Evans been with the Petersons when Lolly died, as we later find out? Because after Lolly dies, the mum goes to his house and sends him to the Petersons to tell them their daughter has died - so that doesn’t make a whole lot of sense to me.
d) Almost all of the story building is based on conversations - it’s all tell and almost no show. I feel like there could have been more clues throughout the book about who the killer is, not just a summary of all that happened at the end of the book. The revelation that Paul was suspecting Cindy the whole time also felt a bit random, since there were no suble hints about it before - again.
e) If the mom had such a bad feeling about Cindy and knew she had a history of lying, why would she let her daughter run around the island with her while all the murders were happening? Instead we got the ominous “don’t trust anyone”, but it doesn’t make any sense to me why she wouldn’t just tell Georgia to keep her distance and why.
f) And even if she had no problem with Cindy, why would she let them run around the island with all that was hapenning still? My parents would probably lock me up in a basement.
g) Why would Georgia jump to the conclusion that Mr. and Mrs. Evans were the murderers basically just because he followed them into the house?
h) The overuse of the word “loo”.
i) If Cindy tripped Annie while they were all looking down, why did she fall backwards? At least that’s what I’ve gathered from the description.
All in all, I feel like this writer and her ideas have a lot of potential, but the execution wasn’t quite there yet imo. On the other hand, the whole book is very atmospheric, I loved it’s setting and if Ravensfarne was a real place, I would love to go there.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 16, 2024
this book was good, i guess?
i quite liked the beginning, the description of the island and the atmosphere. the prose was also fine. a couple of errors but i can excuse that, since the book’s self-published.
i was excited for this book; a mystery thriller, set on a small island in england, promising agggtm & gilmore girls vibes? sign me up. needless to say, i was a bit disappointed. i wouldn’t say it’s anything like agggtm. or gilmore girls, for that matter. the potential was there, sure, but it wasn’t explored nearly enough for me to consider it a fair comparison.
regarding the plot, it’s… okay. it definitely has potential, again, but i’d say after the halfway mark, it goes downhill. there are no real suspects, at least according to the main character, because every time someone *is* suspected (because they had either motive, a chance to yk… ~do the killing~ or both) she just *looks* them in the eye or *sees* their face and she just… *knows*. trust her, she’s known these people for *so* long and they’ve *always* been kind, they wouldn’t hurt a fly… even though they have secrets that are just now coming to light… she *knows* they’re telling the truth. really. no doubt. unless, of course, they’re lying… that was so annoying, ugh.
i would say most of the plot is quite predictable, i think i correctly guessed all the murders except for one and part of the ending as well. (more on that below)
i will say that the characters were well written, although some of them were uselessly described in detail, even though they don’t appear for the rest of the book. they didn’t feel flat, interesting themes and feelings were explored and i could picture them being real people. however… gushing (for *years*) about a guy you barely seem to know? even though he’s supposedly one of your best friends? WHILE YOUR FRIENDS ARE DYING???? girl, stand up.
now, for the ending. i so wanted it to not be the classic cliche, which is why i was so disappointed and angry at the revelation that the murderer was, in fact, the most obvious and cliche suspect EVER. sorry not sorry, i didn’t like that ending, at all. the explanation of everything felt rushed, boring and… quite bizarre if i may say so.
so yeah, a bit of a let down, but still okay. just… average — hence the three stars.
i quite liked the beginning, the description of the island and the atmosphere. the prose was also fine. a couple of errors but i can excuse that, since the book’s self-published.
i was excited for this book; a mystery thriller, set on a small island in england, promising agggtm & gilmore girls vibes? sign me up. needless to say, i was a bit disappointed. i wouldn’t say it’s anything like agggtm. or gilmore girls, for that matter. the potential was there, sure, but it wasn’t explored nearly enough for me to consider it a fair comparison.
regarding the plot, it’s… okay. it definitely has potential, again, but i’d say after the halfway mark, it goes downhill. there are no real suspects, at least according to the main character, because every time someone *is* suspected (because they had either motive, a chance to yk… ~do the killing~ or both) she just *looks* them in the eye or *sees* their face and she just… *knows*. trust her, she’s known these people for *so* long and they’ve *always* been kind, they wouldn’t hurt a fly… even though they have secrets that are just now coming to light… she *knows* they’re telling the truth. really. no doubt. unless, of course, they’re lying… that was so annoying, ugh.
i would say most of the plot is quite predictable, i think i correctly guessed all the murders except for one and part of the ending as well. (more on that below)
i will say that the characters were well written, although some of them were uselessly described in detail, even though they don’t appear for the rest of the book. they didn’t feel flat, interesting themes and feelings were explored and i could picture them being real people. however… gushing (for *years*) about a guy you barely seem to know? even though he’s supposedly one of your best friends? WHILE YOUR FRIENDS ARE DYING???? girl, stand up.
now, for the ending. i so wanted it to not be the classic cliche, which is why i was so disappointed and angry at the revelation that the murderer was, in fact, the most obvious and cliche suspect EVER. sorry not sorry, i didn’t like that ending, at all. the explanation of everything felt rushed, boring and… quite bizarre if i may say so.
so yeah, a bit of a let down, but still okay. just… average — hence the three stars.
January 2, 2025
WOAH!!! Kept me hooked. Was a bit slow at the beginning and took awhile to get to the main plot but I can guarantee that if you stick it out, it’s SO worth it.
August 19, 2024
Mirage' is definitely one of my highlights this year and a perfect read for september/october, the cozy island feeling, reminding me of Gilmore Girls somehow, paired with the murder mystery gives of the perfect autumn/halloween read, so don't hesitate to get yourself a copy, especially if you like crime shows and thrillers!!
The characters were so well described, each and every one had a lot of dimension, even the smaller characters (for example Graham). This made the story to me even more better since Emma managed to make me feel like I was a part of this Island and knew the people that lived there, just as well as Georgia knows them.
The story NEVER got boring, when I thought that there would come some "slower" chapters now, something new, that made the plot complete, happened and gave me new thoughts about what was happening on the island and who could be responsible for that...
Speaking of that... not once while I was reading the book was I able to figure out who was responsible for the murders. I had some different suspects but still got surprised in the end!
This book was so great but I have to say that I would have wished for a biiiit longer ending honestly, but I think that is just MY preference, in no means this made the book bad, but for me a little longer ending (1-2 more short chapters) would have made the book a 10 out of 10 for me, now I would say it's like a 9.5. (still wishing good reads would offer more rating options)
Probably this one is my favorite out of Emmas books now, since I'm such a lover of thrillers.
She managed to keep me on the hook the entire time, and make me like and also feel with every single one of the characters, I'm repeating myself but I have to say it again, this was definitely one of my highlights this year, I think it could be yours too if you give it a chance :)
The characters were so well described, each and every one had a lot of dimension, even the smaller characters (for example Graham). This made the story to me even more better since Emma managed to make me feel like I was a part of this Island and knew the people that lived there, just as well as Georgia knows them.
The story NEVER got boring, when I thought that there would come some "slower" chapters now, something new, that made the plot complete, happened and gave me new thoughts about what was happening on the island and who could be responsible for that...
Speaking of that... not once while I was reading the book was I able to figure out who was responsible for the murders. I had some different suspects but still got surprised in the end!
This book was so great but I have to say that I would have wished for a biiiit longer ending honestly, but I think that is just MY preference, in no means this made the book bad, but for me a little longer ending (1-2 more short chapters) would have made the book a 10 out of 10 for me, now I would say it's like a 9.5. (still wishing good reads would offer more rating options)
Probably this one is my favorite out of Emmas books now, since I'm such a lover of thrillers.
She managed to keep me on the hook the entire time, and make me like and also feel with every single one of the characters, I'm repeating myself but I have to say it again, this was definitely one of my highlights this year, I think it could be yours too if you give it a chance :)
August 29, 2024
I was given an early access copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
If you were an avid fan of Jaqueline Wilson or Cathy Cassidy in your childhood, or maybe you still are, this book will be right up your street. Not to mention, with Halloween coming up, it's a perfect read.
Although a murder mystery, this book has super cosy and autumnal vibes.
I really enjoyed reading this story through Georgia’s point-of-view and think Emma Smith did a fantastic job at delving into the emotional impact that the events – both big and small – had on Georgia, her thoughts and her actions.
We see the balance between the classic struggles of being a teenage girl alongside the difficult circumstances that Georgia has no choice but to face head on. The key side characters, although portrayed through Georgia’s perspective, were just as interesting. There are numerous side characters (and suspects) on the island all with their own motivations. Nobody is not suspicious!
This leads me on to Cindy, who we as the readers would only see through Georgia’s bias. This conflict between the two cousins is present right off the bat and creates a perfect amount of tension to set up the book’s following events. We watch as both characters battle their differences (including one-sided jealousy) whilst having no choice but to work together regardless.
Although at times there was some repetition, I really enjoyed this book and felt on numerous occasions that I just HAD to read the next chapter to find out what would happen next. There was a number of moments which made my jaw drop – but no spoilers here.
This truly is a cosy story about teenage-hood, grief, friendship and learning about who you can really trust.
As for the killer? You’ll just have to wait and see…
If you were an avid fan of Jaqueline Wilson or Cathy Cassidy in your childhood, or maybe you still are, this book will be right up your street. Not to mention, with Halloween coming up, it's a perfect read.
Although a murder mystery, this book has super cosy and autumnal vibes.
I really enjoyed reading this story through Georgia’s point-of-view and think Emma Smith did a fantastic job at delving into the emotional impact that the events – both big and small – had on Georgia, her thoughts and her actions.
We see the balance between the classic struggles of being a teenage girl alongside the difficult circumstances that Georgia has no choice but to face head on. The key side characters, although portrayed through Georgia’s perspective, were just as interesting. There are numerous side characters (and suspects) on the island all with their own motivations. Nobody is not suspicious!
This leads me on to Cindy, who we as the readers would only see through Georgia’s bias. This conflict between the two cousins is present right off the bat and creates a perfect amount of tension to set up the book’s following events. We watch as both characters battle their differences (including one-sided jealousy) whilst having no choice but to work together regardless.
Although at times there was some repetition, I really enjoyed this book and felt on numerous occasions that I just HAD to read the next chapter to find out what would happen next. There was a number of moments which made my jaw drop – but no spoilers here.
This truly is a cosy story about teenage-hood, grief, friendship and learning about who you can really trust.
As for the killer? You’ll just have to wait and see…
August 26, 2024
4.75
I really loved this book. I am obsessed with the vibes it gave and it was so cozy to read it. I knew I was gonna like this as it was being marketed as a mix between Gilmore girls and agggtm and it really was, the relationship between Georgia and her mom was really comforting to read. As for the mystery part it was really well written, I did not except Annie to die and certainly not so soon also I didnt see Pauls death coming. I was really shocked at the deaths and cried a little. In the beginning the pace was a bit slow but as the first murder came it was picking up pretty quick. I loved the themes in this book: grief but also manipulation and there was alot of character development especially from Georgia. I liked that it had a plot twist but not a big one, like not that some character who we never heard of did it. There were alot of secrets on the island that Georgia also discovered and that was fun to read about. I also liked that it was sort of realistic, that there was a good reason why there wasnt police and she had to do it herself. I really loved the add of holly who 'fled from her husband' who abused her, I feel like thats an important part as it probably happens alot. This book has alot of potential for other books as someone from Vibbington came to visit (and there was a little mention from dead fine which was really fun to read about) and a friend from Georgia who does girl guiding which I feel could really make a fun book.
This book made me stay up all night to read so thats a really good sign. I think this is my favorite Emma Smith book!
-Iris
I really loved this book. I am obsessed with the vibes it gave and it was so cozy to read it. I knew I was gonna like this as it was being marketed as a mix between Gilmore girls and agggtm and it really was, the relationship between Georgia and her mom was really comforting to read. As for the mystery part it was really well written, I did not except Annie to die and certainly not so soon also I didnt see Pauls death coming. I was really shocked at the deaths and cried a little. In the beginning the pace was a bit slow but as the first murder came it was picking up pretty quick. I loved the themes in this book: grief but also manipulation and there was alot of character development especially from Georgia. I liked that it had a plot twist but not a big one, like not that some character who we never heard of did it. There were alot of secrets on the island that Georgia also discovered and that was fun to read about. I also liked that it was sort of realistic, that there was a good reason why there wasnt police and she had to do it herself. I really loved the add of holly who 'fled from her husband' who abused her, I feel like thats an important part as it probably happens alot. This book has alot of potential for other books as someone from Vibbington came to visit (and there was a little mention from dead fine which was really fun to read about) and a friend from Georgia who does girl guiding which I feel could really make a fun book.
This book made me stay up all night to read so thats a really good sign. I think this is my favorite Emma Smith book!
-Iris
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 29, 2024
Get your pumpkin spice latte, snuggle under a blanket and DEVOUR this book!!
I absolutely adored this!! It's just so fun and spooky and easy to read with so many twists and turns!
The overall atmosphere of this was everything. It had the cosy pumpkin spice latte, Gilmore Girls vibes of autumn yet also a series of murders on Halloween on a cut off island in a storm! This is THE autumn book and as always, the descriptions were incredible making it feel all the more real. I also need Georgia's coffee set up in my bedroom 😅
I was completely hooked when reading this! The murder mystery is so wild and fun and creepy. I was literally guessing everyone and just when I thought I had it, another twist would be thrown in.
The characters were so well developed and easy to distinguish. As is always the case with Emma's YA books, they were realistic, flawed teenagers which I love!! There's themes of first love, friendship, loyalty, judgment. It sums up the British teenage experience (excluding the murders hopefully!).
I also loved the relationships in this book - romantic, family, friend, community. It was all there! It's interesting to see how these relationships grow and change and develop, for the better or for the worse..
If you love
- Gilmore girls
- Murder mysteries
- Pumpkin spice lattes
- Castle ruins
- Autumn
Then this is a must-read!!
I absolutely adored this!! It's just so fun and spooky and easy to read with so many twists and turns!
The overall atmosphere of this was everything. It had the cosy pumpkin spice latte, Gilmore Girls vibes of autumn yet also a series of murders on Halloween on a cut off island in a storm! This is THE autumn book and as always, the descriptions were incredible making it feel all the more real. I also need Georgia's coffee set up in my bedroom 😅
I was completely hooked when reading this! The murder mystery is so wild and fun and creepy. I was literally guessing everyone and just when I thought I had it, another twist would be thrown in.
The characters were so well developed and easy to distinguish. As is always the case with Emma's YA books, they were realistic, flawed teenagers which I love!! There's themes of first love, friendship, loyalty, judgment. It sums up the British teenage experience (excluding the murders hopefully!).
I also loved the relationships in this book - romantic, family, friend, community. It was all there! It's interesting to see how these relationships grow and change and develop, for the better or for the worse..
If you love
- Gilmore girls
- Murder mysteries
- Pumpkin spice lattes
- Castle ruins
- Autumn
Then this is a must-read!!
August 15, 2024
What an engaging and beautifully written story with an amazing murder mystery element. If you’re a fan of Halloween and Autumn like me, this is the book for you! Reading this made me even more excited for the season than I already was! I’m not usually a fan of mystery thrillers, but I’ve loved every one of Emma’s entries into the genre, especially this one. The character dynamics were extremely accurate to the late teen age group and I can see people disliking some of them, but I found that especially Georgia was so real and human. Many female leads these days have no flaws or personality, so her character was a breath of fresh air to me.
I adore the setting of Ravensfarne island and how the small community come together during the storm, while also creating an isolating atmosphere where anything could happen. It’s an extremely captivating read throughout and I couldn’t recommend this book more! August 30th can’t come any quicker for everyone to get their hands on this! Congratulations again Emma and I wish you every success! x
I adore the setting of Ravensfarne island and how the small community come together during the storm, while also creating an isolating atmosphere where anything could happen. It’s an extremely captivating read throughout and I couldn’t recommend this book more! August 30th can’t come any quicker for everyone to get their hands on this! Congratulations again Emma and I wish you every success! x
September 7, 2024
This 😭 book 😭 oh 😭 my 😭 god 😭
Emma you have done it again! This book was so fun to read, and had me in all the feels 🫶 I can’t describe how relaxing it was to come home from school each evening this past week or so, and curl up on my bed with a coffee and my kindle reading this book!
I was theorising and guessing throughout the entire book (and was also very wrong, I formally apologise to the characters I wrongly accused in my kindle highlights). I read the last 150 pages or so at work and oh my god?? I had to hold back tears at my desk and I couldn’t hide my jaw DROPPING.
This book now has me in a chokehold, and the quotes are SO memorable. I loved the little shoutout to Lilz and Owen! And now I NEED to try every sort of item on the seasonal menus at Lianne’s 🫶
“Until you find your thing, you might as well just… enjoy your teenage years. Enjoy your friends, your favourite singers and shows, enjoy boys, crushes, little things, excitement.”
Emma you have done it again! This book was so fun to read, and had me in all the feels 🫶 I can’t describe how relaxing it was to come home from school each evening this past week or so, and curl up on my bed with a coffee and my kindle reading this book!
I was theorising and guessing throughout the entire book (and was also very wrong, I formally apologise to the characters I wrongly accused in my kindle highlights). I read the last 150 pages or so at work and oh my god?? I had to hold back tears at my desk and I couldn’t hide my jaw DROPPING.
This book now has me in a chokehold, and the quotes are SO memorable. I loved the little shoutout to Lilz and Owen! And now I NEED to try every sort of item on the seasonal menus at Lianne’s 🫶
“Until you find your thing, you might as well just… enjoy your teenage years. Enjoy your friends, your favourite singers and shows, enjoy boys, crushes, little things, excitement.”
August 24, 2024
A Chilling Halloween Must-Read!
Mirage is a perfect read for fans of Halloween-themed murder mysteries! Set on a remote island off the coast of Northumberland, this novel masterfully weaves together suspense, atmosphere, and emotion.
The books vivid descriptions bring the book to life, enabling you to be fully immersed into the plotline. The plot is well-paced, with enough twists and turns to keep you on the edge of your seat until the very last page.
What sets this novel apart is its exploration of deeper themes like first love, friendship, and loyalty, which adds emotional depth to the gripping mystery. Mirage is the perfect blend of thrills, chills, and autumn feels, making it a standout in the young adult mystery genre. Highly recommend!
Thank you to Emma Smith for selecting me as an ARC reader!
Mirage is a perfect read for fans of Halloween-themed murder mysteries! Set on a remote island off the coast of Northumberland, this novel masterfully weaves together suspense, atmosphere, and emotion.
The books vivid descriptions bring the book to life, enabling you to be fully immersed into the plotline. The plot is well-paced, with enough twists and turns to keep you on the edge of your seat until the very last page.
What sets this novel apart is its exploration of deeper themes like first love, friendship, and loyalty, which adds emotional depth to the gripping mystery. Mirage is the perfect blend of thrills, chills, and autumn feels, making it a standout in the young adult mystery genre. Highly recommend!
Thank you to Emma Smith for selecting me as an ARC reader!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews