Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Emerald Shawl

Rate this book
1864, Bristol, England

The seamstress is found in the darkened docks, floating, silenced. Those who found her are sure it must be a tragic accident, probably the result of too many drinks in a nearby public house. But journalist Nelly Brooks recognises the dead woman immediately – Nelly has her emerald shawl in her bag.

Because they had met just one day before, when the seamstress had begged Nelly to investigate the death of the woman who’d given her that same shawl – a wealthy man’s wife. Nelly had tried to insist that her job at the newspaper is only meant to be writing about the best ways to darn a sock or to decorate a drawing room. She’s not meant to actually investigate anything. That’s a job for a man.

But the seamstress trusted her, and Nelly knows she must find out the truth. Even though her investigation will bring her up against the great and the good of the city; with connections that go as high as the crown. And she will have nothing but her wits to ensure she does not become a murderous man’s next victim…

Bestselling author Louise Douglas returns with darkly gothic historical novel of love, murder, madness and secrets, perfect for fans of Fiona Valpy, Lucinda Riley and Jane Eyre.

370 pages, Kindle Edition

Published July 31, 2025

1366 people are currently reading
267 people want to read

About the author

Louise Douglas

29 books852 followers
Hello and thank you for visiting my profile page. I write contemporary Gothic novels which are usually inspired by places close to where I live in the Mendips, close to Bristol in the UK, or by places I've visited, especially Italy and Sicily. The House by the Sea won the Jackie Collins Romantic Suspense Award in 2021. The Love of My Life, my first book, was longlisted for the Romantic Novel of the Year Award. My second book, Missing You, won the RNA Readers' Choice Award, and my third, The Secrets Between Us was a 2012 Richard and Judy Summer Read.

The next book, The Room in the Attic is due to be published in October 2021 and is a ghost story set in a Victorian asylum-turned-boarding school on Dartmoor.

If you'd like to connect, you'll find me on Facebook Louise Amy Douglas or Twitter: @LouiseDouglas3.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
796 (44%)
4 stars
703 (39%)
3 stars
237 (13%)
2 stars
26 (1%)
1 star
9 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 99 reviews
1,753 reviews112 followers
July 16, 2025
A different type of book from Louise but, nevertheless very enjoyable. It had me hooked quickly and I was desperate to find out who committed the murder. Set in days gone by this was very atmospheric. My thanks to netgalley and the publisher's for giving me the opportunity to read this book in return for an honest review.
1,168 reviews
January 3, 2026
3.5 easy to read not memorable.
Profile Image for Helen.
641 reviews134 followers
July 30, 2025
I’d forgotten how much I love reading Louise Douglas! I’ve read four of her books and particularly enjoyed the du Maurier-inspired The Secrets Between Us, but then I seemed to lose track and missed all of her more recent ones. The Emerald Shawl turned out to be the perfect choice for my return to her work.

The novel opens in Bristol in 1864, with journalist Nelly Brooks meeting a woman in a green shawl by the docks. Nelly’s ‘journalism’ amounts to writing a women’s column for the Courier, giving advice on cooking, cleaning and decorating, which is all her editor will allow her to do. She hasn’t given up on her dream of becoming a serious news reporter like her male colleagues, however, and when Eliza Morgan, the woman in the shawl, tells her of the murder of the wife and newborn child of an important man, Nelly is sure she’s found the story she’s been hoping for. When Eliza herself is found floating lifeless in the river the next day, Nelly doesn’t believe the verdict that it was an accidental drowning. She’s convinced that Eliza was murdered and that she is the only person who may be able to find out who killed her.

The mystery is the main focus of the book, but Nelly’s personal life is also interesting. Having become pregnant at the age of fifteen, she spent several years in an asylum, sent there by her parents who found it preferable to admitting that she’d had an illegitimate child. Nelly has had no contact with her daughter – or her parents – since the baby was removed from her after the birth, but she has now discovered that twelve-year-old Hannah is attending a school near Nelly’s place of work. As well as investigating Eliza’s death, Nelly also sets out to find a way to bring Hannah back into her life.

The characters in the book range from the very wealthy, such as the politician Sir Edward Fairfield and his wife, for whom Eliza Morgan worked as a seamstress, to the working class Skinners, who are drawn into the mystery when their daughter’s body is stolen from the morgue. Although both families live in Bristol, they may as well be in different worlds and Nelly has to navigate between the two.

I found it interesting to learn after finishing the book that Douglas based Nelly’s character on the American journalist Nellie Bly, who went undercover to report on conditions inside a mental institution. The fictional Nelly’s own experience of mental institutions allows Douglas to explore issues around mental health and how ‘insanity’ could be used as a convenient way of dealing with people seen as problematic. I also loved the Victorian Bristol setting, which made a nice change from the usual Victorian London settings! The building of the Clifton Suspension Bridge is completed during the course of the novel, an important event in Bristol’s history which helps set the story in a wider historical context.

I hope Louise Douglas will return to Nelly Brooks in a future book as I think there’s a lot of scope to do more with the character. If not, I still have plenty of her earlier novels to enjoy!
Profile Image for Courtney Pityer.
770 reviews45 followers
June 9, 2025
Words cannot describe what I felt for this work of art that this novel is. The Emerald Shawl is a brilliant Victorian Era mystery that has a female reporter who dabbles in detective work and has some of the mannerisms of the famous reporter Nellie Bly. I will admit I was on the edge of my seat many times because I was worried that someone else would end up getting killed or even our heroine herself would meet her end. Thankfully it never came to that situation and everything turned out okay in the end.
Our main character is Nelly Brooks who is the first female reporter for her town newspaper. Now Nellie has had a very difficult life what with her parents putting her an asylum as a teenager. Thankfully her aunt managed to get her out. One day she is approached by a woman who has information that the wife of an aristocrat was actually murdered and didn't die in childbirth.
However, shortly after this conversation the woman is found dead. Nelly wants to investigate some more but is discouraged to do so because they don't allow female reporters to investigate murders. Although she does manage to get some help from another reporter named Will to investigate.
Nelly also finds the opportunity to sneak into the manor house undetected. Although does come close to getting caught but manages to sneak out with some very important evidence. As they come across more details they start to wonder what truly happened and eventually the truth to everything does come to light.
I received an arc copy from Netgalley and all opinions are of my own.
Profile Image for Karen.
1,017 reviews583 followers
August 13, 2025
I always enjoy Louise’s books and this is a super historical mystery with an engaging and sympathetic character at its heart. Nelly has such a sad backstory, being placed in an asylum for the ‘crime’ of having a child at 15. Despite this awful start she starts to rebuild her life and when her job as a reporter on a local paper leads her to a suspicious death and murder, she has to investigate, putting herself in danger. I loved the characters of Nelly, her colleague Will and her landladies who showed her nothing but kindness.

The descriptions of Bristol in the 1800’s gave the story an atmospheric feel and it was easy to visualise the slums and the dirt with the stench pervading everything. A fantastic evocative story which also showed a different side to Nelly when dealing with difficult family matters. I was totally invested in Nelly’s life and rooting for her all the way. I would love to see a follow up story featuring Nelly.
Profile Image for tinalouisereadsbooks.
1,065 reviews14 followers
December 29, 2025
1864, Bristol. Nelly Brooks is a female reporter for The Courier, in a very male romantic world. She is approached by a young woman Eliza who has information about a murder. Eliza then herself ends up dead.

I quite enjoyed this book more than what I thought I was going to. The story follows Nelly as she tries to uncover the truth of the claims made by Eliza. On top of that there is also a body mistakenly claimed from a morgue. All these separate little threads do come together.

I didn't guess where the story was going, especially the body in the morgue but then I was watching the news and there was a report about a morgue and it clicked what was going to happen in the book. This made a nice little twist.

I did think the story was a little bit sugary at times. I did however enjoy the plot of the story. I haven't read anything by this author before but would probably read more in the future.

Thank you to the publisher via Netgalley for the book to review.
344 reviews2 followers
January 18, 2026
Not my favorite by this author, but it was good enough. Her descriptions of places are excellent, sometimes I felt like I needed a change of clothes and a bath after being ‘in the streets’ with Nelly. What bugged me was the constant I KNOW I SHOULDN’T BUT I MUST. It wore on my patience. It’s a mystery though, and I have to follow it to the end.
Profile Image for Helen H.
177 reviews10 followers
August 1, 2025
Set in Victorian Bristol, The Emerald Shawl is a superb novel full of mystery, suspense and investigative charm.

The author has so accurately depicted the world in which women lived in this era. Women didn’t have choices; their paths were directed by men (their fathers and husbands) and by societal expectations.
I was rooting for Nelly throughout the entire book. She is such an endearing character, who has suffered injustices of her own, yet she has a determined spirit, a strong sense of independence and a desire to help others.

The author’s writing is so atmospheric. I was able to feel a vivid sense of time and place in the darkness of Bristol’s docks, the eerie silence of Arnos Vale cemetery, and the old corridors of Mordaunt Hall.

The plot is so cleverly crafted and I was as keen as Nelly to uncover the truth.
The Emerald Shawl is a real page-turner and I loved it!

Thank you to Boldwood Books for a digital copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Profmarianne.
168 reviews3 followers
June 17, 2025
This story ticked all the boxes for me; 1860s England, a mystery with great characters, easy to follow, and a great wrap-up. Not only was this an enjoyable read, it explored the hardships for women during their childbearing years and how women were at the mercy of the men around them. I highly recommend it!

Thank you, Boldwood Books and Netgalley for this ARC.
Profile Image for Kerrie Kelly.
392 reviews10 followers
September 18, 2025
Nelly Brooks is a reporter for the Bristol Herald, she’s usually tasked with writing the female columns, writing simple articles about decorating your home, darning, etc. However she’s desperate to be allowed to investigate and write a proper story, when Seamstress Eliza contacts her and asks her to meet, she tells her about a wealthy woman who has been killed by her husband and begs her to investigate and bring him to justice. She doesn’t give away too many details promising to meet her the next day to share the diary the wife has written detailing everything the husband has put her through. She hurries away, leaving behind an Emerald Shawl she claimed the Wife had given her . Unfortunately the 2nd meeting doesn’t take place as Eliza is found drowned the very next day.

Nelly’s interest is peaked and she cannot get this awful feeling that Elsie was telling the truth and has also been murdered out of her mind. She begins to investigate and soon gets the feeling she is being followed. When she believes she has discovered the identity of the wife, she then comes face to face with her husband Edward Fairfield,ma prominent politician. He makes some veiled threats and Nelly is even more convinced he has done harm to his wife, who supposedly died in Childbirth

I’ve enjoyed many of Louise’s books and this one was no different. Her descriptions of each character brought them all to life, the detailed description of Bristol made the setting perfect.

I loved the character Nelly and her colleagues and was totally invested in this story and how things developed. I would absolutely love a follow up to this story as I felt several characters had more to tell and I would love to know how things turned out for them all


Thanks to Netgalley for the opportunity to read this title
Profile Image for Gosia.
174 reviews4 followers
July 31, 2025
1864 in Bristol, England

Nelly was a reporter, but she was given the column to write about women, not exciting stories of everyday life.

When she received news of the murder, she knew it was the story of a lifetime. A story that could change everything in her life. She might even get her daughter, Harriet, back.

Nelly met with Eliza, who told her that the wife and baby of a prominent man had been murdered. When Eliza's body was found in the river the next day, Nelly knew she had to investigate both cases.

Little did she know, however, that she would put herself in danger and even lose her daughter before she could get her back.

Nelly was persistent, ambitious, and dreamed of reclaiming her daughter, who had been taken from her shortly after birth. She was only fifteen when her family took Harriet away and sent Nellie to a mental institution.

This was the story of a woman who fought for her daughter, for her dreams, for justice, and for the truth.

It was an interesting and quick read. This book captivated me enough that I couldn't put it down. I was expecting a more gothic atmosphere and some kind of suspenseful twist that would have added a bit more depth to the story.
Would I recommend this book to others? Yes. If you like mysteries, you'll definitely enjoy it.
1,058 reviews10 followers
January 3, 2026
3 stars for mediocre readability
Profile Image for Stormi Ellis.
355 reviews9 followers
August 10, 2025
The Emerald Shawl
By: Louise Douglas

5 Stars

Nelly knows her fair share of pain. She was in an asylum for 10 years for having a child at a young age. Now, she is out, thanks to an aunt. She has a home and a job at the paper. She becomes embroiled in a mystery when a woman comes in spouting a crazy tale, then ends up dead. Soon, Nelly is onto the story of her life following a prominent man and the death of his young wife and child. This story leads Nelly and everyone she is close to on a journey steeped in danger.

This was such a complex story. It was about Nelly and her child, while also being about Nelly and the time she spent in the asylum. Then, It was also a great murder mystery that is steeped in danger, drama, and mysticism. This was a story that was descriptive and intriguing. It captivates from the beginning. It was filled with so much history, and It had so much emotion. This was a great book that really had all my favorite things. Emotions, history, drama, romance, danger, I mean, what more can a reader ask for in a good book? I have learned that this author always delivers a moving story. I have become quite the fan.


*I want to thank Netgalley and the author for this book in return for my honest review*

Stormi Ellis
Boundless Book Reviews
9 reviews
January 11, 2026
I wanted to love this book. It had all of the bones of a fantastic story - a Victorian era mystery with the female lead having to overcome adversity and misogyny to solve the murder and become a successful reporter. The ending was fantastic but I found the first 3/4 of the book quite slow and hard to get in to. Hence the 3 stars!
81 reviews1 follower
October 7, 2025
An intriguing read

I enjoyed this book however I felt it was rather slow to start.An interesting story involving the treatment and attitudes, towards women in this era,by men .
Profile Image for Grace J Reviewerlady.
2,135 reviews105 followers
July 31, 2025
An absolutely terrific read - exactly what I would expect from this author.

In the second half of the nineteenth century, Nelly is breaking stereotypes by getting a job at the local paper. Although she is kept firmly in her place writing for the women's pages, she is contacted by a young woman with a story for her. When the same person turns up floating in the docks the next day, Nelly finds that she can't let it go - not even when she knows it's not the kind of story the paper will let her write . . .

I'm a firm fan of all of this author's novels. At the start of each one, I know I'm in for a treat and this one did not disappoint. I read on long after I should have been in the land of nod and couldn't wait to continue the next day. A beautiful read, well written with a great cast of characters and a firm storyline. Highly recommended and most definitely meriting all five glowing stars.
Profile Image for Annette.
2,833 reviews50 followers
July 31, 2025
This was a good mystery full of surprises. I liked Nelly and her determination to get to the bottom of things. The story did seem to be a little too long and dragged at times. I did still enjoy the story and want to know what happens to Nelly and her life.
Profile Image for Jessicabookworm.
98 reviews1 follower
August 25, 2025
Overall, I thought The Emerald Shawl by Louise Douglas* was a light easy read, with a quick paced mystery of murder, abuse, betrayal, and secrets; which wraps up this case neatly by the end, but also leaves the door open for possible future investigations.
My Rating: Good ❤️❤️

My full review: https://thebookwormchronicles.wordpre...

*I received an Advanced Readers Copy of this book from Boldwood Books, via NetGalley, in exchange for my honest opinion.
312 reviews2 followers
December 27, 2025
This one was a bit harder to read. It was the story of a woman in the 1800s who is a journalist and is very upset that all she gets to write is women related stories that she has no interest in. She wants to be a real reporter, but only men can do that. There is this woman and baby who apparently die and she is the wife of some important man in the city. This woman journalist is convinced that they were murdered and she goes about trying to prove that this happened. this woman author was approached by a woman who told her the story about the death of the mom and baby, and then she dies the next day, and the woman assumes that she was also murdered. The main character of the story also had a baby when she was 15 years old and her parents took the baby away put her in asylum and she’s not been able to see or contact her daughter. it just makes me think of how horrible it would’ve been to be a woman at that time. The story ends when you find out what really happened and this woman journalist is going to write some articles that’s going to hopefully damage the reputation of the powerful man.
81 reviews
January 2, 2026
An ok historical novel set in Bristol. I struggled to get into it but then enjoyed the story of a woman who escaped the asylum where her parents placed her for having a child out of wedlock and follows her story of investigative journalism in a time when women were not expected to do such things.
Profile Image for Juli Morneweck.
111 reviews
August 17, 2025
solid story with good writing but a little heavy with the current viewpoints on situations in the late 1800s, especially the treatment of women and the lower classes.

Although I certainly don't agree with those 1800s viewpoints, that doesn't mean I want a historical novel to alter itself to fit our current POV. This novel comes close to doing that. Although there is definitely the essence of discrimination on the outskirts of the story, all of the main characters (minus the villain) have modern viewpoints.

Otherwise, a well written story with a mystery to solve with minimal upsetting descriptions.
Profile Image for C.R.  Comacchio.
319 reviews15 followers
July 25, 2025
Many thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for an advance copy of this novel.

The emerald shawl of the title is the principal key to the mystery that young reporter Nelly Brooks, hired by the Bristol Courier to report on domestic issues, sets out to solve. It was gifted to seamstress Eliza Morgan, who sewed for the beautiful young wife of a nasty member of the House of Lords. Pregnant with the child that the much older Earl desperately wanted—in hopes that the baby would be his sole male heir after the death of his first wife—she died suddenly in childbirth. The baby boy was stillborn. This was in no way unusual in Victorian Britain, especially in filthy industrial towns like Bristol. Nelly agreed to meet Eliza at a dockside tavern, where, while drinking heavily, she related her suspicions that both wives and the baby were murdered.

Abject poverty had made Eliza shrewd and quick to demand a fair price. Known to have a drinking problem, she had several gins on Nelly’s bill during their meeting, but revealed only a few select details. The bait was a promise to turn over the deceased woman’s diary for a price far higher than Nelly could afford. But a story like this one, if the promised evidence was in hand, could elevate Nelly’s career. She could finally put aside the stultifying writing of trite household advice to entice middle-class women to read their husbands’ newspaper.

They agreed to meet again when Nelly had found a way to meet the price. Eliza departed for another appointment, forgetting the shawl. Nelly took it home, thinking to return it quickly. The next morning, Elizabeth was identified as the drowned, probably drunk, woman who had fallen into the dirty waters of the dock only steps from the tavern. This story also made perfect sense. But not for Nelly. Did someone go after Eliza to shut her up about the earl’s dead wife and child? Perhaps about both dead wives? What role did the earl’s adult stepdaughter, inherited from his first marriage, have in all this? Was Nelly now also in danger?

By making her one of Britain’s first female journalists, the author is modelling her Nelly Brooks on the famous historical character Nellie Bly. Bly was an intrepid reporter, women’s rights supporter, and champion of better treatment of the poor, especially mothers and children. Like Nelly Brooks, she was also ruthless in her pursuit and exposure of the truth.

It is this dogged determination that propels Nelly. She had suffered her own loss of a child, born to her at the age of 15, to be raised by her well-off parents as their own. When she told her parents of her plan to support herself and take back her baby, they spirited the child to a hidden location and cut off all contact with her. Finding her daughter, almost ten by the time Nelly has settled in Bristol, becomes another of the mysteries that she is driven to unravel.

And then there is the handsome young reporter who shows her great kindness in the office and would like to be her friend as well as her colleague. She likes him but, not surprisingly, doesn’t want romantic involvement. She also wonders whether his offers of help in finding out whether the suspected murders were connected and why, and whether the earl was behind one or both, are just his attempts to ‘scoop’ her story in the highly competitive press environment.

These interwoven strands make the book suspenseful and compelling but they are also somewhat confusing for a short novel. In particular, the heartbreaking story about the search for her daughter takes the reader away from the main story. But the character of Nellie Brooks, as well as the setting of the misogynistic press and the larger society, are so finely drawn that I can highly recommend this excellent historical mystery.
Profile Image for Pam Baddeley.
Author 2 books64 followers
February 12, 2026
A departure for this novelist, the book is set in the 1860s in Bristol. The main character is Nelly (Helen) Brooks, unusual for the time in eking out a living by being a newspaper journalist, although the male proprietor is adamant that she shouldn't report anything challenging and should just write fluffy articles for the 'ladies'.

Nelly is approached by a seamstress with concerns about the wife of a prominent man, whom she doesn't name. She says the woman and her baby were murdered by the husband shortly after the woman gave birth, with the murders being covered up by a death-in-childbirth story. She wants money to name him and will leave Bristol as soon as she gets it as she feels endangered. The next day Nelly, walking to the newspaper offices via the docks, comes across a crowd gathering around a body: the seamstress has been pulled out of the water, drowned. Soon after, Nelly, pursuing the investigation, is menaced herself, even more so when she finds out exactly which important man the seamstress suspected.

There is quite a lot of material on the second-class citizenship of women at the time. Nelly herself made the mistake of falling for a boy when she was a teenager and becoming pregnant. The boy was packed off to the colonies and, to avoid scandal, immediately after her daughter was born, Nelly was sent to a lunatic asylum. She spent the next ten years locked up, and was only freed when her aunt returned from abroad, learned of her plight, and managed to get custody of her. Consequently, Nelly's freedom is precarious and there is always the threat of being recommitted. One thing I found a bit 'off' is that, towards the end of the book, a character who is otherwise kind and supportive points out to her that her parents were only doing what was best for the family - and she agrees. I thought this was gaslighting to the nth degree.

One subplot which eventually joins up with the main story is the disappearance of a body from the morgue. When the body is relocated, it was immediately apparent to me what the role of two other characters had been and their motive, so the failure of Nelly and the friend who joins in the investigation with her, to also comprehend this made them come across as a bit 'thick'. It was necessary to read on quite a way before they finally caught on. This meant that what was obviously meant to be the big reveal/twist was rather a damp squib for me personally.

For these slight weaknesses, I would rate the story as an enjoyable but 3-star read.
Profile Image for Bookfan36.
441 reviews
July 25, 2025
Brief synopsis from the book cover:

1864, Bristol, England

The seamstress is found in the darkened docks, floating, silenced. Those who found her are sure it must be a tragic accident, probably the result of too many drinks in a nearby public house. But journalist Nelly Brooks recognises the dead woman immediately – Nelly has her emerald shawl in her bag.

Because they had met just one day before, when the seamstress had begged Nelly to investigate the death of the woman who’d given her that same shawl – a wealthy man’s wife. Nelly had tried to insist that her job at the newspaper is only meant to be writing about the best ways to darn a sock or to decorate a drawing room. She’s not meant to actually investigate anything. That’s a job for a man.

But the seamstress trusted her, and Nelly knows she must find out the truth. Even though her investigation will bring her up against the great and the good of the city; with connections that go as high as the crown. And she will have nothing but her wits to ensure she does not become a murderous man’s next victim…

My rating:

Plot: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Writing: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Character development: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Overall: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Recommended for readers of:

Historical Fiction
Mystery and Suspense


Review:

This book takes you back to the Edwardian England a very different time where women still had few rights. The main character Nelly Brooks is a strong woman who is determent to forge a life for herself despite the restrictions and limits set by society or her job.. As one of the few female reporters of the time with a strong sense of justice, she is determent to investigate when a source tells her about a possible murder cover up, Things turn more serious when the source is found dead the next day.

The book is well written, atmospheric and full of intrigue. The story flows well and has the right amount of mystery and suspense that makes it hard to put the book down. The characters are well developed; their personalities were explained with enough detail so that they felt realistic.

Overall:

This is an interesting story that captures you from the beginning, with realistic characters and the right amount of mystery and suspense.

Review copy provided through Netgalley at no cost to me.

Profile Image for Ashley Cohoon.
298 reviews20 followers
July 31, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (4 out of 5 stars)

The Emerald Shawl is a rich, atmospheric historical mystery with a strong, determined heroine you can’t help but root for. Set in 1864 Bristol, this book follows Nelly Brooks, a young reporter stuck writing a women’s column- until a mysterious woman in a green shawl brings her a story too big to ignore: a supposed childbirth death that may actually be murder. When that same woman is found dead the next day, Nelly refuses to let it go, even if it means putting her own life, and her hopes of reuniting with her estranged daughter, at risk.

What makes this story shine isn’t just the twisty murder plot (though that kept me turning the pages), but Nelly herself. She’s a mix of grit, vulnerability, and relentless drive. Her past, being institutionalized as a teen for getting pregnant, losing her daughter, and being constantly dismissed in a man’s world, adds real emotional weight to the story. Her journey to find the truth and reclaim her own life is as compelling as the mystery she’s trying to solve.

I also loved the setting, Victorian Bristol is beautifully drawn, and it’s refreshing to get a break from the usual London backdrop. There’s a great balance of social commentary, suspense, and character-driven storytelling. While the pacing lagged just slightly in the middle and I wouldn’t have minded a touch more gothic atmosphere, it was still a satisfying, immersive read.

Highly recommend this one if you like historical fiction with smart, resilient female leads, a bit of danger, and a mystery that unfolds at just the right pace. I’d definitely read more Nelly Brooks if this turns into a series, she’s a character with more stories to tell.

A big thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Kate.
68 reviews1 follower
June 22, 2025
The Emerald Shawl is a novel set in Victorian England. Nelly, an aspiring journalist, acquires the shawl, when its owner leaves it behind, after telling Nelly that she has heard that a high ranking gentleman had murdered his wife and new born baby. The very next day Nelly witnesses the woman's lifeless body being pulled out of the docks. Nelly is determined to investigate, despite the consequences being potentially devastating for Nelly herself as she has been rescued by her aunt from an asylum, after her parents at fifteen for giving brith to an illegitimate child. The child is in potential peril also, as her parents have sent her to a reform school, which by coincidence, is in the same town where Nelly is working.

I enjoyed this novel. I am not a great fan of historical novels, but this piqued my interest. The way in which women were at the mercy of their parents and their husbands in times gone past is eye opening and disturbing, with the options open to them being narrow and challenging, and then only if they went against societal norms. However, the mystery at the heart of this novel is well written too and drew me in. I was sorry about some aspects of the endings, but my preferred ending is probably too saccharine and sentimental and not true to the period! Definitely recommended.
130 reviews5 followers
June 25, 2025
Thanks to Louise and NetGalley for allowing me to read The Emerald Shawl before the publication date.

The setting for this book is Bristol in 1864, with bustling docks , dirty cobbles, dark narrow alleys and families crowded into insanitary accommodation. Money talks and corruption is rife.

It explores the culture of the era, particularly women’s rights, or rather the lack thereof.

The characters are many and varied, some with colourful backstories, others with very sad lives.

The central character is Nelly Brooks, the first woman reporter at the Courier, albeit that her role is to write articles which will appeal to the women readers (heaven forbid that she should even consider writing about something serious or might upset the sensibilities of the women readers, although I doubt that anyone actually asked the readers for their opinion).
Nelly has a disturbing history before arriving at the Courier and that will impact on her decisions. Her saving grace is her aunt Angela, aka Angel, who, with her wisdom and kind heart, will always be there for Nelly.

Louise has introduced a tiny bit of humour in what is a very sad story by using names for a couple of the characters which reflect their responsibilities ( i.e. Mr Snitch, the timekeeper and Mr Cuddy, the coachman).

I hope that this might be the start of a series.
Profile Image for Lily.
1,519 reviews13 followers
August 22, 2025
In this fun new Victorian historical mystery novel, readers follow journalist Nelly Brooks as she tries to uncover the reason behind the murder of a local seamstress whose emerald shawl Nelly has in her possession. Having met the day before, the seamstress asked Nelly to investigate another woman’s (the original owner of the shawl) death, but Nelly technically isn’t supposed to investigate anything. Defying her boss and braving the risks of this unknown killer, Nelly decides to find the truth no matter who she has to confront or investigate. Packed with details, fascinating, and absolutely entertaining, readers will love the depth to this new mystery novel and its historical setting. The characters are well-written, detailed, and fascinating, and readers will really enjoy solving the mystery alongside Nelly. The mystery itself is fascinating and interesting, and the historical setting and added drama of the class and gender conflicts at play will intrigue readers. The attention to detail and the intricacy of the different storylines and threads of the mystery will keep readers on their toes throughout the book, and Louise Douglas has brought a fascinating side of 1864 Bristol to life in this new, immersive, intense, and high-stakes historical mystery novel.

Thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the advance copy.
Profile Image for Anne Williams.
2,214 reviews
August 5, 2025
Oh my goodness, what a read – such a well-drawn historical setting, an intrepid and very sympathetic heroine in Nelly, a whole cast of characters I so enjoyed, and a real gothic chill throughout. And such a gripping story, wonderfully told – I honestly loved every moment.

Nelly had a difficult start in life – with experiences that still haunt her – spending time in an asylum until her caring aunt was able to secure her freedom. She now works on a Bristol newspaper, frustrated that her writing is confined to the women’s page. But an opportunity crosses her path when she’s approached by seamstress Eliza who tells her a horrifying story about the murder of a mother and child, convinced that her aristocratic husband was responsible. Eliza herself ends up dead – found floating in the dock – and that only increases Nelly’s appetite to uncover the truth, however dangerous that might prove to be.

She finds a friend and ally in crime reporter Will – one of the few who takes her ambitions seriously, involving her in another investigation into a missing young woman. And he’s by her side when things become even darker – she’s aware that her movements are being watched, and that she might have some powerful enemies, but she remains undeterred. And not only undeterred – she takes the most immense risks in her pursuit of the full story, endangering both her job and her life, with a range of risky actions that sometimes made me want to look away (but, of course, I didn’t – the narrative was far too gripping!).

I was firmly in Nelly’s corner throughout, with her passion to do the right thing while following her own dream – and the issues of her past, and the way they resonate throughout the story, only made me love her more. She’s very much a woman of her time, fighting against constraints and expectations – and the backdrop of 1800s Bristol, every mirky back street, the shadows hiding who-knows-what, set against the insights into others’ privileged lives, is superbly done. Although things can get a bit disturbing at times – graveyards at night tend to be that way, and perhaps more wisely avoided – the whole story manages to be tremendous fun too, the pace never easing with every new discovery. And I really loved the plotting, the way the different threads of the story were slowly pulled together by its unexpected end – storytelling at its very best.

So, something a little different this time, but still everything I love about the author’s writing. If historical and gothic are something that whet your appetite, with a substantial slice of excitement and danger, this is a book you’re going to love – and its emotional touches are equally perfectly handled. Very much recommended – and most definitely one of my books of the year.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 99 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.